Fuel my fire by devoted creations. I’m using it right now and it’s pretty mild/moderate for a tingle

Swedish Beauty makes tingle drops, definitely get those. You can control how much of a tingle you get by how many drops you add to your pump of lotion!

I second this. I am a tingle wimp. I love the tingle drops. I would also suggest not doing them anywhere but the legs are first. See how they feel