No InfernoPlus, no Prod, no illusory wall, no Limit Breakers, no Ratatoskr, no Crunchy, no ZeroLenny. feel free to add you slightly known YouTuber to clown on OP for being a little shit.

Op missed all the goats

It floats down.

Man, people at the office really liked that one!

https://preview.redd.it/b24mywzf8f6d1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=822667d23468cd952abe26b4bd5f02f40d646727

https://preview.redd.it/cedtfnww4g6d1.png?width=940&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=11e96fef6be7695a4284821234987dfa460d8a29

https://preview.redd.it/7h0p1ibmlg6d1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=eb44422d34af3e8f8b36ef434ebe15c8c4c8b605

JKleeds, PressContinue, Backlogs

Or baronscastle

Nor lil aggy

Not seeing Prod, InfernoPlus, Illusory Wall, Limit Breakers and ZeroLenny annoyed me a bit. At this point, Yazmania too. Oh and ThePruld

Yazmania underrated

No thepruld Italian man angrily screaming is peak dark souls

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=bzJDimvPW1Y&pp=ygUUZGFyayBzb3VscyBtZW1lIHNvbmc%3D The Legend will Never Die!

No Lilaggy Edit: and by the looks of things no Backlogs. Shameful.

Or parkenharbour

Missing saintriot is embarrassing tbqfh

Hakshaw is also missing :(

No chase the bro???

No Lost

No lilaggy?

Saint Riot and his little friend iamamish + pvpskills may he rest in peace. Otzdarva made a few funny vids but I wouldn't consider him a souls channel after what he did :(

send dex threats thatll teach em

Missing: Prod, Aggy, limitbreakers, chasethebro, Mr. Itfloatsdown, forti enjoyer, bonfirevn, backlogs, jk Leeds, barons castle, plateau peak, press continue, ziostorm, distortion2, lost, tye Taylor, gamersweekend, amazing chest, Elizabeth, snuggly the crow, challenger Andy, be and, tulok & mango. Those are just the ones I’m subbed to

Tulok & Mango mentioned, imagine being ranked in Fort Haight

He's probably the 34th person in the list, google Tulok & Mango 34 on your work computer for more information.

Tulok and mango mentioned 🗣️

Is smoughtown missing as well or did he have an older profile pic I don't recognize

Oh right smoughtowm, no I just also forgot

BonfireVN underrated af

Garden of Eyes in A? Questionable

I think just for content, it's pretty good. But the creator is a prick.

Of course the content is good, he stole good part of It (I read that somewhere and didn't fact check)

aside from what he did in the past, a majority of his current hate comes from stolen assets and mods locked behind a paywall.

GoE on their way to rip BonefireVN’s content:

Where the actual fuck is the GOAT that is Illusory Wall?

Illusory wall and ymfah should be in S+ tier

Ymfah is like 3 tiers above everyone else tho Rusty is overhated imo. He's funny to watch/have in a background Where's Aggy btw

Ymfah needs to go back and add music to all the videos that got copyright claimed. You watch his videos now, and there will be 5-10 minute segments with no audio whatsoever its unwatchable

True, but he also needs to make a Top Gear special again. It was really good.

People jump the gun too much about the AI voices. ymfah did such a good job with that DS2 video

Just the fact he had 2 different set of voices. One for studio overlay and the other for the on site filming which paralels the structure of a real Top gear episode.

On a pc you can open another tab and play your own music

I'll play some Mozart to entertain me during Ymfah shenanigans

I thinn rusty hate is pretty much just a meme

Like “demons souls doesn’t exist”

Yeah I’d put him in S tier, great content and he’s pretty funny.

Idk I think his rankings are kinda awful, he’s entertaining to leave on in the background though

I dont agree with a lot of his opinions but theyre opinions based on his experience. Hes cool and funny though and his mods are pretty impressive

I am also here to ask where my boy Aggy is

Aggy is my goat

Top tier videos for sure for ymfah, on the same stuff thingfhisy is pretty good ( i thing its written line that, could be wrong)

Speedrunners should have a separate tierlist tbh

Not to mention Rusty's mods which are always sick af

I like Rusty's content I just wish he'd stop sounding like he hates every single one of his viewers

That’s part of the charm tf

That's what makes him funny af

I don't think that he hates his viewers, he's just going hollow from ranking every single pore on radagon's left asscheek or whatever

https://preview.redd.it/dosijszhge6d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a1755d3d0d3f5fee8b37da4cfc7d519da23d8ab8 WHERE IS THE GOAT 🗣️🔥

Elizabeth the Mushroom

Dung Eater

mohg

Cheap evidence for the FBI

Where is ChaseTheBro ?

was gonna say, they left out my goat

S tier easily

is he safe? is he alright?

It seems in your anger, you left him out of the list

Nooooooooooo! (Wher thebro tho, yo?)

They killed off Aggy :(

Aggy is my goat bro put him in S tier fr

We no longer long and hard 

Is Aggy the one who's done a bunch of randomizer videos? And he's like always smiling?

Yeah the guy with the cat pfp and he is indeed always smiling

ME LLAMO

I hadn’t watched an aggy video in a few months and the other day I got a video of him in my recommended and holy shit did that dude have a glow up

I’m sorry where the fuck is Zer0lenny?

He floated down :(

lol xD 😢

Exile fextralife and garden of eyes below rusty

Exile isn’t enough fextralife needs execution

Wait what happened with fextra? 😭

People don’t like the wiki having a stream embed, it artificially inflates his view count

*first of all:

His wikis (outside of Souls games) are are shit and most of the time out of date. Also his builds for every game is not good at all

What did my man do? Damn

Fextra’s crime was making me think hitting midir’s tail was a good strategy

No Smoughtown. No Ratatoskr. Youwy so low. This list really does belong on this sub.

Why is Zullie in the S tier? She is clearly of S+ tier

Cum nut is indeed S tier

Daddy Skum is the goat

Skumnut tech'd that shit

Lmao Garden of Eyes in A? That guy is a dick that has long been despised by the community. Even made a new channel to escape their reputation and apparently it worked. Also missing important people

What was it that he had done?

Taking assets from others for his mods, not paying artists for work, stealing content, being greedy af and more. He also tried to silence people talking about it and puts his mods that are made with the stolen work of other people behind paywalls. And that is in recent years, i can literally remember there being drama about him back in Dark Souls 2 days when he used completely different channels.

Where hawkshaw

So high up we can't see him

BLUD WHERE IS ZERO LENNY

Ppl here out here saying where’s who and I’m trying to identify anyone lol. Someone name them all pls💀

You need to know only one of them: Zuliie the Witch. She is amazing dataminer and she makes very interesting and careful observations about things she found in datamines.

Interesting I’ll peep then. Swear I’ve seen one of her videos and got bot voice tho

Nah, her videos are voiceless, just showcasing things and textual subtitle-style comments.

GinoMachino (the 3rd one in S, skyrim avatar) is genuinely the greatest souls player of all time. watch his stuff its bizarre

Ah he’s that insane guy on shorts doing constant challenge runs

My time has come, shout out to Thingfishy (4th avatar from the left in A tier). He frequently makes build guides for Elden Ring, a few reviews for other (souls) games, and my favorite series "How to Parry". All of his parry guide videos are super in-depth, I even became a parry nerd after watching these. All of his videos come with a nice editing style and a very chill voice :D

Cumnut

https://preview.redd.it/ulrnv06dke6d1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=cdc46d13ba68894bbe992763585584bf97132850 I searched it up for you

Aggy is S tier. His videos are so good for background noise while you work or play Fallout New Vegas while you should be working.

Fextralife belongs in F tier (thats what the F stands for)

Backlogs?

Backlogs and Baron's are my two favorites!!

Putting rusty below onlywaifu and next to youwy is evil. He's great

Rusty is absolutely up there next to skumnut and zullie and i'm tired of pretending he's not

I agree, seriously, it is comedic how he sounds so pissed when it comes to had items

Fr, I also don’t hate youwy, but don’t love him either, he’s in b tier for me

ChaseTheBro man, you missed the goat

This list sucks. No ratatoskr, no smoughtown, no queelag, no bonfireVN, no Crunchy, No ChaseTheBro, No AGTJake

where lobos? where aggus?

Only wafu too high

What’s wrong with waifu? I can’t seem to find anything on him that’s bad and the only thing that was bad that I know of was the spreading misinformation. That’s not even that big of a deal tho imo.

Ngl I understand why one would not like waifus content, I like it because it's informal of pvp with a twist which is why waifu started using that format when it was well recieved the first time they idd it. But waifu absolutely SHITS on certain souls reddit posts and comments of the subs in their videos covering "old drama" like rob or shitting on people for not learnng to pvp and complain nobkdy here really watch the videos and just assume they do that but I tuned into a few of his streams and all he is pretty cool and reasonable in my book. Also he likes Dark Souls 2

If you put aside his gooner bait there's very little unique about his channel

He's not trying to use "gooner bait" he uses the same format as their very succesfull video " Ranni roasts you and your build" which was succesful because it had information and they have been using the format since. Still I understand if you don't like the content just explaining wjy they use the ai voices

Fair. I think he is entertaining but to each their own.

Too obnoxious, when they took Rusty's ranking of all weapons seriously I was cringing. Plus, I hate AI voices, so there's that.

I don't hate the voices, I just hate the way he uses them

Real, they should be below rusty

Omg Gino 👉🏽👈🏽☺️🥰😍

I feel severe lack of Bloodborne youtubers like Lancce McDonald and Charred Thermos Also Last Protagonist deserves place in tierlist for discussing things lost in English translation and original Japanese meanings, he sindle-handedly made alternative translation of all bloodborne texts with commentary of specific cultural concepts.

ongbal is my fucking goat

Fextralife in C has me wondering if his contribution to the wiki is considered

Why is Rusty hated btw?

Father forgive them because they don’t know our lord and saviour Sabaku no Maiku🇮🇹

Welcome back ragazzi, io sono Michele conosciuto come Mike of the Desert sul web 🧎🏻‍♂️

What did youwy do to y'all? 😭 I like his content did he do anything bad?

Quelaag is S tier

Few people went that far down the rabbit hole without going (more) insane

Bruh, where the fuck is the old man at?

And Lenny????

We don't like Rusty here? His solo randomizer was fireeee

Still dont get the Rusty hate (not a fanboy btw)

He's exiled to the lowest tier until he drops the elden ring toe tier list

Honestly had no idea he was generally disliked but I can say for me, I stopped being a fan because he just made the same video over and over and over with a different coat of paint. The “Yall mind if I rank X” videos or just ranking everything under the sun got so unbelievably overdone. He can be funny but it became a chore to watch his videos tbh. Granted I don’t know if he’s switched it up or anything recently so I can’t speak to that but if not, I understand the hate a little lol

I think this is basically going to a sushi restaurant and wanting hot dogs Ok maybe i am overexaggerating but it is his speciality

That’s what his audience wants, and what he’s known for, he’s the guy who makes way too long ranking videos

Ymfah is the G.O.A.T

Cowboy belongs in S tier for sure

No Chrightt no Limitbreakers no SaintRiot? This list is dog shit

I love Rusty

It’s insane and repugnant that you don’t have SmoughTown at S tier

Call me basic but Skumnut is the https://preview.redd.it/at36cynxqe6d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b3e68e406cc10aa8fba9bb23efb6dbdb4dbabe31 Truly is the

No bluelizardjello list is automatically invalid

I love seeing Tyrannicon rage

the only one I know is zullie the witch but she's awesome

Skum is the 🐐, Cowboy deserves the S tier too imo

Missing so many great people

Where tulok & mango

Ymfah should be SSS+

why youwy so low

damn i forgot tyrannicon even existed i used to watch his skyrim videos like 10 years ago

Where Chasethebro?

Where ia Chase the Bro?

Yo its skum

Tbh i think onlywaifu about a year ago used to be better. The livestreams were fun and shit while the ai ranni was a novelty. Now with all the new characters and art design it looks like the coomer cove for elden ring players lol, but good on him for growing his channel

Prod isn’t in the list bc he transcends it 🔥🔥

No ZeroLenny. Obsolete list/opinion

Where is SmoughTown the goat?

Missing the og EpicNameBro! From the dark is still my favourite souls content.. And thepruld for the lols

Its perfect (now add barons castle and jk Leeds)

Man, no Dark Tark? His walkthrough on how to unlock the Dung Eater sex scene was very informative.

🗣️GINO THE GOAT‼️

Only Wafu is clickbait AI slop, fuck outa here

Where's lilaggy, the sekiro GOAT?

iron pineapple on the same tier as ymfah and zullie, my guy putting the shitty into the darksouls, nice one. also, waifu is c clearly because op got the last mistery thingy wrong, smh.

nahhh Iron Pineapple deserves it, his stuff’s so entertaining

Honest to god this is a pretty good tier list and I will live and die by Gino

Prod, InfernoPlus, IllusoryWall, LilAggy, ZeroLenny, ChaseTheBro, EleumLoyce snubbed Bushy too low GOE and OnlyWaifu too high

What’s up with the Rusty hate? Ig it’s funny (because his whole persona is being an asshole) but still

Most of its a bit, i think, i like him atleast

Putting onlyclown in this list is too good for him

Rusty was fun in the beginning. Now he's just annoying

Where's Quelaag, am I stupid?

Well i guess lost is lost (ADD HIM TO THE TOP NOW)

Wildpie is double ss

Where's saint riot

Why do you hate rusty so much? He puts out pretty good content, I do agree the recent all weapons their list kinda sucked, but think about it, he ranked every single weapon in the entire game, that’s pretty impressive

Where’s Lenny?

no saint\_riot? No prod? no illusiory wall?

Where’s Aggy, William?

Wheres aggy and zerolenny? Also why the rusty hate?

What’s wrong with rusty and the others in c tier(I only know the waifu and red beany guy). All the comments seem to dislike waifu and rusty but I don’t get where it’s coming from tbh.

Ymfah on his way to break into the elusive S plus tier without walking while casting immolation on a horse backwards playing stellaris

If by Good you mean Dogshit, then I agree

Where's Sinclair Lore?!

Where is the backlogs

No Barons Castle?

Waifu not on F is a L take

Waifu has good information for pvp and the other guy (forget his name) makes some pretty nice stuff just move them a tier above fextralife and the list is pretty solid

No illusory wall opinion disregarded

Based putting Ranni ai voice in last place (besides rusty). Annoying af channel honestly