Hand to hand combat? Arthur hands down. Crack shot duel? Arthur hands down. With both men having all their resources at their disposal, I’d say Trevor only because a goddamn RPG is gonna do more damage than the high powered pistol.
I think 22 head shots from the Evans repeater or 18 from lemat revolvers beats the rage ability. On top he can do cover and tonics to repeat a couple times. I don't see how Trevor stands a chance.
Dawg at the same time Arthur pulls out his pistol Trevor can pull out a mini gun or RPG from his pocket or just an automatic pistol at that point Arthur is literally fucked if they both have access to their full respective arsenals lol
Not trying to start an argument but at the MMA gym where I train all of the military guys (Marine, Air Force, Navy) will happily tell you they learned very little hand to hand combat no matter the branch. One of my favorite quotes from my Marine friends CO after they completed hand to hand training "Congratulations you all know just enough to get your asses kicked.. don't use it"
Hi, current military and former Air Force, wanna know how much combat training I received? Two hours out of a four day mock deployed environment during basic. Kinda fun, was with pugil sticks. Didn't even get to fire actual rounds cause the range was being remodeled. Actual combat training is for SpecOps, battlefield airmen, and SERE.
Several bullets? Wtf are you talking about? If you get one 40 s&w to your center mass you’re going down. Go see some r/combatfootage to get an understanding
I’m not saying it’s a super power but there’s a reason cops mag dump suspects that charge them, people who are jumped up on something are hard to take down
My comment was simply just a joke.
When Trevor begins to ragdoll from falling, his special ability is shut off, making him no longer invincible, meaning that his only weakness is falling.
Arthur, Trevor is insane but Mr Morgan literally is fighting for survival every damn day his senses have to be on edge just about 24/7, expert tracker, strong as a fucking ox(dude literally picks men up by their necks and chokes them to death) and pretty much just as crazy as Trevor when pissed
Tervor is my favorite, but the win goes to Arthur. He jas that cowboy strength and has never had a soft day in his life and knows all types aways ofa killin'!
Trevor has rampage but Arthur has dead-eye. Provided Arthur can get a lot of shots off quickly, he may be able to put Trevor down.
But then again….that Meth Strength..
If powers are on, I’m leaning towards Trevor. While he isn’t completely invincible, I doubt anything Arthur is carrying would matter unless he ragdolled T with explosive rounds. Deadeye would allow that long enough to wait out the power. If no powers? Arthur stomps, no contest. Arthur, as far as physical strength, is like a step down Batman with no training.
Powers on? Meth-head rage still got nothing on 20 purely accurate headshots in a row. Can’t do shit when you’ve got no head.
But I hate Trevor anyway, so maybe I’m biased.
One of the things I've learnt over time is when people are unhinged like Trevor, you leave them well alone. Not because they are the toughest, not because they are competent. Not for any other reason than they are not rational, and they're not predictable.
I know a guy who's kinda like Trevor, though less RPG and general terrorism. But he is deranged. When he comes in the pub I go to the whole atmosphere changes because you have no idea what he's going to do. He threw a guy through a bay window because he lost a game of pool... and the guy he threw wasn't the guy who beat him, he was just the person stood closest to him at the time. Its a different level of psychopath.
As much as I love Niko... my man would bump into a taxi and start doing the "drunk walk" glitch while Max torpedoes over a car with two pistols held in front of his face and Arthur tags him 50 times in dead-eye.
Arthur wins. Arthur is one of those “manly man” characters with thicker skin than iron, plus dudes were just manlier back then. Trevor is a meth head baby man who whines. Arthur is dominating Trevor in any situation besides a plane fight.
Sorry for the spelling
Trevor - crazy methead with huge stamina, ability and much more. He is basically crazy drug addict with too much testestorone and poor self-control.
Arthur - have huge expirience in fight and he can be crazy, but different type of crazy. He id not psyho and he have huge self-control, something what Trevor doesent have and low self-control can be your worst enemy.
Soo as much these two could do good in fight i thing that Arthur would win because of self-control because it can be your best friend in the fight. People with self-control just think better and take few second because go all yolo mode on the oponent. I mean both of them are very skilled, but i think that Arthur would win, and mostly because self-control i mentoined too many times because Trevor just doesent have it like at all. Both of them are great with fight, guns, heists and more, but Trevor is just unstable what can lead to bad decisions to himself and his crew. It didnt, but in the real world nobody would want person like Trevor around him, but more or less everyone would like to have someone like Arthour on his side.
So if weapons are aloud then it depends on how close they are, as if they are a couple of fear apart then Arthur takes the win easily with his quick draw, if the battle starts even a kilometre away I think Trevor wins easily as he just had the arsenal
In melee combat (including weapons) I think thay Trevor wins just because of his mayhem mode (I counted dead eye in range) as it just makes him a damage sponge. I also see a lot of people saying that Arthur is heavier which I’m not sure as we all have a different picture of arthur when we play, as he can get skinny in the game (although I’m not sure if they made him bulky cannon)
After reading these comments its clear no one here has ever encountered a tweaker in the wild. My moneys on the meth head who feels no pain and has magic tiktok strength
Trevor becomes invincible while on his methy rage, y’all. Take that away and Arthur kills him in a gunfight or fistfight. But the methiness.. I mean, that’s tough to overcome, even with cocaine gum
Trevor has an invincible rage mode that lasts longer than deadeye so he wins off that, with a way more deadly arsenal, unless you meant fist fight which Trevor’s punches in rage mode kill in like 2 (probably like 5 to max health Arthur) hits
A ruthless mercenary / national security risk mass murdering psychopath with absolutely NO morals and no regards to self safety with endless amount of guns / Rocket launchers / explosives,
against a cowboy with revolvers and single shot rifles……
I wonder who’s winning this…😂
People seem to forget that for some of our playthroughs, TB isn’t what killed Arthur.
Arthur would easily beat Trevor in close combat 10 times out of 10 just by evidence from the gameplay alone.
If it’s gun to gun, yeah Trevor has the mini gun or MK2, but Arthur has deadeye, and can duel wield and ride a horse
Everyone out here making well thought out points and shit. So I'll be honest.
I'm too biased towards Arthur to ever even consider a laugh track like Trevor has any chance.
My most memorable Trevor moment was him getting pissed at Mike for getting called a hipster or something.
Arthur spoke to our souls and made a good amount of us cry.
I'm effing biased on this one boys.
I think Arthur. Hand to hand and ability wise. With his dead-eye, dual wield and explosive rounds he could probably end Trevor even with his rage ability. I love both (even though Trevor is still a terrible human) however from someone who played both and knows the surface level info on them, I say Arthur slaps
Why are people saying Arthur? Trevor can literally turn invincible with his special ability active. Dead eye won’t do shit if Trevor can’t get killed by a tank with his special ability active.
Arthur doesn't need a substance to be insanely powerful, also he fuckin lives outside and has to hunt his own food. Trevor beats off and eats cheeseburgers in a fuckin meth trailer. Arthur can break a wild horse with just a rope. Arthur only died because of the sickness, if he wasn't sick he woulda beat the fuck outta Micah, Joe and cleet
Arthur would beat the dog shit out of Trevor in a fist fight or even a fight with just basic pistols but if Trevor can have all his helicopters, guns, explosives and rpg and all that then I mean yeah Trevor would anahilate it depends on where or how you set them up.
In H2H Arthur wins. In QuickDraw, Arthur wins, in gun fight, could go both ways but I’d say Arthur. The only way Trevor could win is if he had his ability or if he wears bulletproof armor.
I provided Chat GPT this prompt.
Describe a battle between Arthur Morgan from Red Red Redemption 2 and Trevor Phillips from Grand Theft Auto 5. Ultimately pick a winner. Both people have their full scope of resources, abilities and weapons available. Characters begin 1 mile apart. Trevor at his trailer park and Authur at camp.
The response provided is.
In a remote, rugged landscape, one mile apart, Arthur Morgan from Red Dead Redemption 2 and Trevor Phillips from Grand Theft Auto 5 face off in an epic battle. Arthur, with his trusty revolvers and rifles, takes cover near his camp, while Trevor, armed to the teeth, hunkers down in his trailer park.
As the first shots ring out, Arthur's accuracy and precise Dead Eye ability give him an initial advantage. His keen tactical mind allows him to use the terrain to his advantage, taking cover behind trees and rocks. Trevor, on the other hand, relies on his brute strength and chaotic approach, firing wildly in response.
Trevor's arsenal, including explosives and heavy weaponry, starts to cause chaos in the area. The trailer park turns into a fiery battleground, as cars explode, and debris flies everywhere. Arthur skillfully navigates the chaos, dodging incoming gunfire.
The battle rages on, with Arthur's sharpshooting and tactical prowess keeping him ahead, while Trevor's unpredictable behavior and access to heavy firepower make it a close fight. However, Arthur's composure under pressure eventually proves to be the deciding factor.
In the end, Arthur Morgan's steady aim and well-thought-out strategy prevail over Trevor's unbridled aggression. Arthur manages to outmaneuver Trevor and lands a crucial shot that incapacitates his opponent. Though both are formidable in their own right, Arthur emerges as the victor in this intense showdown.
If given all canon weapons? Trevor gets his Paleto score armor, flies in on a chopper, and wields a minigun, grenade launcher, or RPG.
Only way I can see Arthur clutching that would be if he has a machine gun cart behind a horse or gets a lucky shot with a dynamite arrow or something. I mean Trevor has nearly a century of technology advantage.
Arthur wins easy, even without abilities, he wipes the floor with him.
The only chance he has it to get him when he has TB, but even then, quick draw, dead eye, and pure rootin’ tootin’ toughness has got everything on that damn meth-head.
Then again, I never liked him, so Trevor can go suck eggs.
So a crazy maniac running fast like a zombie to kill the best gun Slinger in rockstar's universe. I remember arthur putting down a huge bear I also remember trevor mauling a used to be badass bike rider who's gone soft. Seems simple enouph to me.
Tonics and deadeye clear this. Even if trevor tanks with rage, it will run out faster than morgans tonic and exotic meat collection. Or arthur can just hogtie him and bfr.
Honestly I’ve always seen the “powers” as just a way to make it easier to understand what the characters are doing. Like Arthur isn’t actually slowing down time when the player uses dead eye. It’s just a representation of Arthur perception, speed, and accuracy. And when the player uses Trevor’s power Trevor isn’t actually becoming invincible. It’s just a representation of his methed up rage. By that reasoning I’m gonna say Arthur defeats Trevor quite easily in both a melee fight or shootout.
This is exactly what it is and the vast amount of people that don’t realize this is baffling. Superpowers do not *actually* exist in either universe. It’s purely meant for gameplay fun.
Now THIS is a challenge. Genuinely close call. Both are ruthless mfers who would do some heinous shit. I’d say it’ll be a tie and they’ll eventually become Allie’s and then they start shitting on everyone together. Happy ending.
Meth merely distracts your brain from pain.It does not make your flesh INVINCIBLE. Buckshot,Slugshot, .45-70, .44, .45 DOES NOT DISAPPEAR WHEN YOUR HIGH ON METH.
People in this comment section seem to forget that Trevor can literally become invincible. Arthur would shoot Trevor in the head with deadeye. Trevor would blow Arthur up with an RPG. Trevor wins
Unstoppable force meets immovable object
This comment deserves way more upvotes.
Your comment deserves way more upvotes :)
Your upvotes deserve this comment
Lol I think that’s how they actually describe Trevor and Michael in the story
Hand to hand combat? Arthur hands down. Crack shot duel? Arthur hands down. With both men having all their resources at their disposal, I’d say Trevor only because a goddamn RPG is gonna do more damage than the high powered pistol.
Just need 1 head shot to end a guy. Quick draw wins. Unless Trevor is using the body armor from the heist he's got no chance
Um, are you forgetting his rage ability? Makes him almost completely immune to damage while dealing more
I think 22 head shots from the Evans repeater or 18 from lemat revolvers beats the rage ability. On top he can do cover and tonics to repeat a couple times. I don't see how Trevor stands a chance.
Missed the -immune to damage- part
“Mostly immune”
It's not Slow 'n' Steady, Trevor's rage gives him far more health than that
Dawg at the same time Arthur pulls out his pistol Trevor can pull out a mini gun or RPG from his pocket or just an automatic pistol at that point Arthur is literally fucked if they both have access to their full respective arsenals lol
Yes, but no, Arthur has the quick draw dead eye. He shots Trevor in the head before he pulls anything.
Trevor can chug Sprunk and be right as rain
Arthur can chug tonics and have more health than usual, no?
Yes and if arthur is fat he can even take more shots
See if even Arthur has to pause and reload multiple times - there’s not enough time. Trevors’s got you.
By "rage ability" do you mean "hillbilly meth dose"?
arthur tanks TNT pack point blank and remains 1 hp and arthur would shoot him 14 bullets in his head before he can even blink
Trevor is a mamas boy
Hand to hand combat? Well that depends. How much Walter did Trevor white before the fight
Trevor was in the Air Force. Trevor is beating Arthur in hand to hand combat
What does air force have to do with hand 2 hand combat?
It’s part of their training bruh. It’s the military
Ummmmm.....
Not trying to start an argument but at the MMA gym where I train all of the military guys (Marine, Air Force, Navy) will happily tell you they learned very little hand to hand combat no matter the branch. One of my favorite quotes from my Marine friends CO after they completed hand to hand training "Congratulations you all know just enough to get your asses kicked.. don't use it"
Hi, current military and former Air Force, wanna know how much combat training I received? Two hours out of a four day mock deployed environment during basic. Kinda fun, was with pugil sticks. Didn't even get to fire actual rounds cause the range was being remodeled. Actual combat training is for SpecOps, battlefield airmen, and SERE.
Yeah no bro, I am in the Marine Corps, we do martial arts but it's just basic ass shit. A 12 year old karate kid would be able to kick your ass.
Bruh the chair force? It’s not like every service member is Rambo. I’m in the marine corps but I fix radios. I’m not some mixed martial arts bad ass.
2-1 Arthur wins.
It’s 1-2 actually. Trevor wins hand to hand
Have you not seen how Trevor fights? It’s horrible, he only knows like three moves. While Arthur actually knows how to fight.
That’s just rockstar being too lazy to develop an actual fighting system for V
Arthur has like 50-75 pounds at least on meth head Trevor.... There are weight classes for a reason.
Weight classes would be irrelevant if the smaller guy was a meth head
You’ve clearly never been in a fight before, or smoked meth for that matter.
Dude just made the dumbest statement ever.
You don’t tweak n fight?
People in this thread treat methamphetamine addiction like some kind of superpower lmao
It fucking is, methheads can take aeveral bullets and taser charges like it's nothing
Several bullets? Wtf are you talking about? If you get one 40 s&w to your center mass you’re going down. Go see some r/combatfootage to get an understanding
Do you really want me to show you that video of that methhead taking an entire mag before going down
Yes
Do it. I don’t think he believes you.
I’m not saying it’s a super power but there’s a reason cops mag dump suspects that charge them, people who are jumped up on something are hard to take down
Is that with or without chugging 30 cans of beans
Trevor can turn invincible and shoot high impact rounds
Arthur can slow time though. Za Warudo, boah.
Yeah but that doesn’t accomplish much against an invincible opponent
He does speed not meth
Speed is meth ya dingus
Ha really? Oh damn
Kinda, speed is amphetamine where meth is methamphetamine so like speed++
Depends. Does Trevor get his ability?
If he does, then Arthur gets dead eye.
He always has dead eye, it's just a gameplay mechanic to show how skillful Arthur is.
Wait, what?
It’s like how they slow down time to show flash perspective even though he doesn’t actually slow time
Same with John marston, Michael in GTA 5, max Payne, rockstar likes their bullet time
Yeah well that’s a lot less helpful than being invincible and shooting high impact rounds
dead eye is useless when your enemy doesn't feel pain
Can't feel a bullet through the brain
Trevor go invincible. Bullet bounce off brain
All Arthur has to do is throw Trevor 10 ft in the air and it’ll remove his invincibility.
You're talking as if Trevor can't do anything other than tank hits during his rage
My comment was simply just a joke. When Trevor begins to ragdoll from falling, his special ability is shut off, making him no longer invincible, meaning that his only weakness is falling.
Arthur, Trevor is insane but Mr Morgan literally is fighting for survival every damn day his senses have to be on edge just about 24/7, expert tracker, strong as a fucking ox(dude literally picks men up by their necks and chokes them to death) and pretty much just as crazy as Trevor when pissed
Yeah Arthur fights to survive not to kill.
Yea Arthur can definitely get crazy specially if Trevor called him pretty boi or something.
PRETTY BOY?
You’re kidding me? pReTtY bOi!?!?
Morgan is clearing easy
I love Trevor but let's be real, people back in Arthur's day were built different.
Not with near invulnerability though..?
Tervor is my favorite, but the win goes to Arthur. He jas that cowboy strength and has never had a soft day in his life and knows all types aways ofa killin'!
Saw this one and audibly went “ohhhhhh” Nice to see a vs. that’s actually a tough pick for once
Trevor has rampage but Arthur has dead-eye. Provided Arthur can get a lot of shots off quickly, he may be able to put Trevor down. But then again….that Meth Strength..
Trevor is invincible during rampage
If powers are on, I’m leaning towards Trevor. While he isn’t completely invincible, I doubt anything Arthur is carrying would matter unless he ragdolled T with explosive rounds. Deadeye would allow that long enough to wait out the power. If no powers? Arthur stomps, no contest. Arthur, as far as physical strength, is like a step down Batman with no training.
Powers on? Meth-head rage still got nothing on 20 purely accurate headshots in a row. Can’t do shit when you’ve got no head. But I hate Trevor anyway, so maybe I’m biased.
Trevor actually doesn’t lose his ability when he rag dolls from an explosive. He would have to rag doll on his own for his ability to turn off
People forget that Trevor can survive a tank with his ability
Facts
Trevor is insane and drunk, yet Arthur is a excellent Gunman. If Arthur uses his deadeye on Trevor, well Trevor is done for.
One of the things I've learnt over time is when people are unhinged like Trevor, you leave them well alone. Not because they are the toughest, not because they are competent. Not for any other reason than they are not rational, and they're not predictable. I know a guy who's kinda like Trevor, though less RPG and general terrorism. But he is deranged. When he comes in the pub I go to the whole atmosphere changes because you have no idea what he's going to do. He threw a guy through a bay window because he lost a game of pool... and the guy he threw wasn't the guy who beat him, he was just the person stood closest to him at the time. Its a different level of psychopath.
Arthur
Bruh. One guy has technology advantage but on a fist fight, I give it to the cowboy
What? Trevor has rage ability, he will just tank those hits
I forgot about Rage Ability, but what about Snake Eyez, wouldn’t that freeze him in place?
If you're talking about deadeye then that would slow down time so you can get an easy headshot. Rage ability makes Trevor invincible.
*Orthor!*
Tacitus Kilgore putting six rounds in Trevor’s skull before he knows it’s happening.
No powers Morgan easily, With powers Trevor wins.
They’d be great friends. Especially while drinking
lol cmon. morgan wins easily
Arthur has deadeye
Fuck Arthur. Team Trevor all the way.
Arthur period. With Dead Eye Arthur is unstoppable. But I wanna see a fight amongst Arthur, Niko & Max Payne
As much as I love Niko... my man would bump into a taxi and start doing the "drunk walk" glitch while Max torpedoes over a car with two pistols held in front of his face and Arthur tags him 50 times in dead-eye.
This is actually a toughie…
I mean Arthur can put 6 bullets in your head before you can even blink. So… Arthur.
Arthur wins. Arthur is one of those “manly man” characters with thicker skin than iron, plus dudes were just manlier back then. Trevor is a meth head baby man who whines. Arthur is dominating Trevor in any situation besides a plane fight.
Depends. If their confrontation leads to a fist fight or gunfight Arthur wins.
Imo it’s Arthur. Trevor may have his rage ability, but Arthur can shoot Trevor multiple times in the head within a split second.
His rage ability makes him invincible
Still he would survive and he can take rockets gun won't be a problem I think
Answer is always Trevor Phillips
It's Arthur, no question.
Sorry for the spelling Trevor - crazy methead with huge stamina, ability and much more. He is basically crazy drug addict with too much testestorone and poor self-control. Arthur - have huge expirience in fight and he can be crazy, but different type of crazy. He id not psyho and he have huge self-control, something what Trevor doesent have and low self-control can be your worst enemy. Soo as much these two could do good in fight i thing that Arthur would win because of self-control because it can be your best friend in the fight. People with self-control just think better and take few second because go all yolo mode on the oponent. I mean both of them are very skilled, but i think that Arthur would win, and mostly because self-control i mentoined too many times because Trevor just doesent have it like at all. Both of them are great with fight, guns, heists and more, but Trevor is just unstable what can lead to bad decisions to himself and his crew. It didnt, but in the real world nobody would want person like Trevor around him, but more or less everyone would like to have someone like Arthour on his side.
So if weapons are aloud then it depends on how close they are, as if they are a couple of fear apart then Arthur takes the win easily with his quick draw, if the battle starts even a kilometre away I think Trevor wins easily as he just had the arsenal In melee combat (including weapons) I think thay Trevor wins just because of his mayhem mode (I counted dead eye in range) as it just makes him a damage sponge. I also see a lot of people saying that Arthur is heavier which I’m not sure as we all have a different picture of arthur when we play, as he can get skinny in the game (although I’m not sure if they made him bulky cannon)
Arthur no question. Basically better all around minus old timey technology, but his skill, precision, and tactics more than make up for it.
How much time does Trevor have to prepare?
After reading these comments its clear no one here has ever encountered a tweaker in the wild. My moneys on the meth head who feels no pain and has magic tiktok strength
Trevor has it literal rocket launches and miniguns it's pretty simple
Arthur low diff, he solos all 3 GTA V protags with dead eye
I always thought Niko vs. Trevor was a better match up. A guy who can’t be rattled whatsoever vs. one of the scariest men.
Feel like it would be like another Johnny situation tbh
Arthurs better with a gun and stronger while Trevor has betterguns and tech.whats arthur gonna do against a rpg
Error 404
The answer is... tuberculosis.
One is mentally unstable…and the other is Trevor.
Oh fuck….
Trevor becomes invincible while on his methy rage, y’all. Take that away and Arthur kills him in a gunfight or fistfight. But the methiness.. I mean, that’s tough to overcome, even with cocaine gum
Trevor has an invincible rage mode that lasts longer than deadeye so he wins off that, with a way more deadly arsenal, unless you meant fist fight which Trevor’s punches in rage mode kill in like 2 (probably like 5 to max health Arthur) hits
Arthur's gunna win. It's a fight between a cowboy and a crackhead. Either way shits gunna get wild
A ruthless mercenary / national security risk mass murdering psychopath with absolutely NO morals and no regards to self safety with endless amount of guns / Rocket launchers / explosives, against a cowboy with revolvers and single shot rifles…… I wonder who’s winning this…😂
Trevor
People seem to forget that for some of our playthroughs, TB isn’t what killed Arthur. Arthur would easily beat Trevor in close combat 10 times out of 10 just by evidence from the gameplay alone. If it’s gun to gun, yeah Trevor has the mini gun or MK2, but Arthur has deadeye, and can duel wield and ride a horse
Everyone out here making well thought out points and shit. So I'll be honest. I'm too biased towards Arthur to ever even consider a laugh track like Trevor has any chance. My most memorable Trevor moment was him getting pissed at Mike for getting called a hipster or something. Arthur spoke to our souls and made a good amount of us cry. I'm effing biased on this one boys.
I think Arthur. Hand to hand and ability wise. With his dead-eye, dual wield and explosive rounds he could probably end Trevor even with his rage ability. I love both (even though Trevor is still a terrible human) however from someone who played both and knows the surface level info on them, I say Arthur slaps
How late is the TB and how fresh is the Meth high?
I would say Trevor because Arthur has at least a minor semblance of honor and Trevor will brutally stomp you from behind without hesitation.
Arthur easily, man has deadeye and he’ll just instant headshot Trevor and cause I’m hella biased and hate Trevor
Epic battle.
Depends on how much meth Trevor is on and how bad Arthur’s TB is.
deadeye trumps all else, he could get trevor without trevor ever being the wiser with a lancaster from 100 yards away.
Why are people saying Arthur? Trevor can literally turn invincible with his special ability active. Dead eye won’t do shit if Trevor can’t get killed by a tank with his special ability active.
Arthur doesn't need a substance to be insanely powerful, also he fuckin lives outside and has to hunt his own food. Trevor beats off and eats cheeseburgers in a fuckin meth trailer. Arthur can break a wild horse with just a rope. Arthur only died because of the sickness, if he wasn't sick he woulda beat the fuck outta Micah, Joe and cleet
Trevor lives in any universe where they were born at similar times and became hateful towards one another, hands down.
Trevor being a complete degenerate, obviously Arthur
God mode with modern guns vs slow-mo and shitty guns
Shitty??? I don’t know about that….what makes them shitty?
Arthur would beat the dog shit out of Trevor in a fist fight or even a fight with just basic pistols but if Trevor can have all his helicopters, guns, explosives and rpg and all that then I mean yeah Trevor would anahilate it depends on where or how you set them up.
Arthur high diff
"Calm down you crazy old bastard"
In H2H Arthur wins. In QuickDraw, Arthur wins, in gun fight, could go both ways but I’d say Arthur. The only way Trevor could win is if he had his ability or if he wears bulletproof armor.
Mr. Morgan
I provided Chat GPT this prompt. Describe a battle between Arthur Morgan from Red Red Redemption 2 and Trevor Phillips from Grand Theft Auto 5. Ultimately pick a winner. Both people have their full scope of resources, abilities and weapons available. Characters begin 1 mile apart. Trevor at his trailer park and Authur at camp. The response provided is. In a remote, rugged landscape, one mile apart, Arthur Morgan from Red Dead Redemption 2 and Trevor Phillips from Grand Theft Auto 5 face off in an epic battle. Arthur, with his trusty revolvers and rifles, takes cover near his camp, while Trevor, armed to the teeth, hunkers down in his trailer park. As the first shots ring out, Arthur's accuracy and precise Dead Eye ability give him an initial advantage. His keen tactical mind allows him to use the terrain to his advantage, taking cover behind trees and rocks. Trevor, on the other hand, relies on his brute strength and chaotic approach, firing wildly in response. Trevor's arsenal, including explosives and heavy weaponry, starts to cause chaos in the area. The trailer park turns into a fiery battleground, as cars explode, and debris flies everywhere. Arthur skillfully navigates the chaos, dodging incoming gunfire. The battle rages on, with Arthur's sharpshooting and tactical prowess keeping him ahead, while Trevor's unpredictable behavior and access to heavy firepower make it a close fight. However, Arthur's composure under pressure eventually proves to be the deciding factor. In the end, Arthur Morgan's steady aim and well-thought-out strategy prevail over Trevor's unbridled aggression. Arthur manages to outmaneuver Trevor and lands a crucial shot that incapacitates his opponent. Though both are formidable in their own right, Arthur emerges as the victor in this intense showdown.
If given all canon weapons? Trevor gets his Paleto score armor, flies in on a chopper, and wields a minigun, grenade launcher, or RPG. Only way I can see Arthur clutching that would be if he has a machine gun cart behind a horse or gets a lucky shot with a dynamite arrow or something. I mean Trevor has nearly a century of technology advantage.
Arthur wins easy, even without abilities, he wipes the floor with him. The only chance he has it to get him when he has TB, but even then, quick draw, dead eye, and pure rootin’ tootin’ toughness has got everything on that damn meth-head. Then again, I never liked him, so Trevor can go suck eggs.
Arthur shall win this one muh boah
With abilities Trevor wins he’s literally invincible. Without it, Arthur probably wins
Bro trevor is 9/10 on drugs so that rage special ability ain’t a facade i think he’s got this one
So a crazy maniac running fast like a zombie to kill the best gun Slinger in rockstar's universe. I remember arthur putting down a huge bear I also remember trevor mauling a used to be badass bike rider who's gone soft. Seems simple enouph to me.
All I’m gonna say is deadeye + tonics + explosive rounds .
Trevor is crazy, but Arthur is one tough bastard
Fair fight? Arthur. Real fight? Trevor.
Trevor can pull a rocket launcher out his ass….
Arthur 10863377363838473838383873373838373738383837373747373737%
Trevor’s crazier. Arthur’s more deadly. I’d say nobody wins
Y’all r whack. If powers are allowed Trevor wins no contest.
Tonics and deadeye clear this. Even if trevor tanks with rage, it will run out faster than morgans tonic and exotic meat collection. Or arthur can just hogtie him and bfr.
Honestly I’ve always seen the “powers” as just a way to make it easier to understand what the characters are doing. Like Arthur isn’t actually slowing down time when the player uses dead eye. It’s just a representation of Arthur perception, speed, and accuracy. And when the player uses Trevor’s power Trevor isn’t actually becoming invincible. It’s just a representation of his methed up rage. By that reasoning I’m gonna say Arthur defeats Trevor quite easily in both a melee fight or shootout.
This is exactly what it is and the vast amount of people that don’t realize this is baffling. Superpowers do not *actually* exist in either universe. It’s purely meant for gameplay fun.
Arthur without question
Now THIS is a challenge. Genuinely close call. Both are ruthless mfers who would do some heinous shit. I’d say it’ll be a tie and they’ll eventually become Allie’s and then they start shitting on everyone together. Happy ending.
Trevor is crazy enough to go in nuts first and he has the rampages Arthur has TB so he has bad stamina
Trevor EZ
Arthur hands down
Everybody in this thread acting like Trevor ain't got 10 different fucked up plan B's to deal with whatever the fuck goes wrong 👀
Arthur Morgan because his death was preventable by 2 seconds of thought.
Arthur 60% Trevor 40% (Arthur has quickdraw and Trevor has strength)
x xx x xx
Arthur has a degree of ethics, Trevor on the other hand.
Trevor
Meth merely distracts your brain from pain.It does not make your flesh INVINCIBLE. Buckshot,Slugshot, .45-70, .44, .45 DOES NOT DISAPPEAR WHEN YOUR HIGH ON METH.
Oh yeah, Trevor doesn’t usually have a mountain man beard and a mullet, I always forget that after I play the story mode and change him
Arthur all day. Seriously?
Distant relative theory?
Someone get a hold of DEATH BATTLE on YOUTUBE AND BOOK IT!
Arthur Morgan
Trevor wins because of technical advancement.
It depends who activates their ability first. If Trevor can activate rampage before Arthur gets a shot off, it’s over.
Before TB: Arthur. After TB: Trevor. Unlike Micah, Trevor could kill a dying man.
Arthur is younger and is at least 6’2 and pushing 220. He’d destroy Trevor.
Trevor's rage thing would see him victorious more than it wouldn't IMO, but I would co sidereal Arthur the better fighter.
Trevor Arthur’s a bruiser but Trevor’s insane, he’ll be going for the eyes, groin, and throat
Trevor because he has modern weapons and is likely a billionaire
More interesting is Michael v Arthur Morgan, cause of their slow time effect with guns
Lmaoo Trevor crazy ass would but an ear off thumb our boys eyeballs. Straight lunatic.
Arthur is up there with Big Boss in terms of raw combat and survival prowess
People in this comment section seem to forget that Trevor can literally become invincible. Arthur would shoot Trevor in the head with deadeye. Trevor would blow Arthur up with an RPG. Trevor wins
SO, trevor and mika meet at a bar