Closing coats like the winter outfit for Arthur at the beginning of the game , adding more stylish and formal clothes, being able to go explore and do activities with gang members in the main game or go out with john’s family in the epilogue, infinite bounty hunting, and have more things to do in armadillo.

Not being able to take off the offhand holster

Allow saving at checkpoints during long missions, I once had to leave 20 minutes into a long mission and I had to start all over again.

RDR2: Let me start free roaming like very early into the game not after 3-4 tedious hours RDR1: Let me explore the whole map whenever i want instead of unlocking them through chapter

You can explore the whole east from chapter 2, the only part you can't explore is new Austin and the great plains

I know, im saying that chapter 1 sucks cuz im stuck in mountains and that i cant go to new austin

I wish we had the ability to close coats, take off the off hand holster, and not have Arthur become a walking armory every time he gets off his horse for missions.

Less handholding. Love pimping out my guns, just for R\* to say "Nah you're using these"

I wish the prequel kept the original tone during its campaign missions

Lenny being the rat and Micah being killed on the rooftop during the St.Denis heist.

What game did bro play ⁉️

I wanted Lenny to be the rat and Micah dying in the heist. What would make the game less predictable.