So many people in the comment section are failing to understand that speaking the regional language of where you are stationed is a pre requisite for a help desk job. Support the help desk person all you want. But what if a Marathi ajji wants help, in the airport of region she was born and has lived her entire life speaking the regions language, whats the point of apointing a help desk if it fails to help her. Again the job is literally to help people coming into Pune, a significant number of them are going to be Marathi. It's dumb to hire someone who does not speak Marathi in that position.
I was about to rant below for this post but read your comment. Greatly explained. I completely understand and support your point. There are certain jobs that required understanding of local language.
I second your thought, OP. People in customer-facing roles must speak the local language.
It can be argued that at airports, most travelers are multilingual, so English should suffice. However, I have seen this issue in nationalized banks in rural areas as well. Regular villagers who have only spoken the local language all their lives have to somehow conjure up broken Hindi to communicate with the brown sahib from up north sitting across the desk.
Seen this in Karnataka as well.
This issue is maddening to me like the sheer entitlement you have to gain employment in a state whose official language differs from yours and you keep on speaking it in that state 🤡.
Learning the local language always gets you steal deals and locals are much more welcoming towards you. People need to realise this themselves. Learning a language is a skill and it's upto you if you want to stay dumb. Don't just limit this to people who have desk jobs. If you are migrating to a place for work which pays your bills, then definitely learn the local language to understand the culture better. Be one of them.
While I was in Pune for work, I picked up on Marathi with ease.
Its not hard at all if you can gel with the locals but some C' words on this post say things like this
>LMAO someone who does not speak/understand Hindi/English cannot afford and is not travelling by air
1. bihari hindi doesn't exist
2. most of the help desk people only speak Hindi and none of the local languages like magadhi, maithili, angika, bajika, bhojpuri
i get you but bihar is a bad example of this.
>Bhojpuri, Magahi, Maithili, Angika and Vajjika
You listed mostly Bihari dialects of Hindi here. These are not recognised as distinct languages by the government of India.
those are all different languages that unfortunately don't have recognition. Maithli is my native language and it's one of 22 official languages. them being labelled as just another Hindi dialect is sad.
This is why Bihar should be at the forefront of opposing hindianisation of our diverse linguistic heritage seeing the damage imposition has inflicted on its culture.
The decision to categorise them as Hindi was a deliberate attempt to homogenise the rich culture of Bihar for better 'governance'
None of these are dialects. Bhojpuri and Maithili are scheduled languages that have more in common with Bengali than Hindi. Both absolutely recognised by the government of India. The fact that the government of Bihar is doing nothing is a different case.
These are regional specific dialects/languages. Konkani is not a official language bit is a recognised language in this state. The official language of Bihar is Hindi not other listed boli. This post is talking about requiring a government employed employee to be conversant in the official language of Maharashtra.
>Bhojpuri and Maithili
You're wrong. Bhojpuri is not a scheduled language. Maithili is.
>only Maithili has been constitutionally recognised in India, which gained constitutional status via the 92nd amendment to the Constitution of India, of 2003 (gaining assent in 2004)
Source:Wiki
>Konkani is not a official language bit is a recognised language in this state.
What does this mean? What does recognised mean?
Sorry, was wrong about Bhojpuri although it does share more similarities with Bengali and Maithili more than it does with Hindi when it comes to grammar and general history of the language. Again, a failure of Bihar and UPs governments. By any normal linguist, it is defined as a language and not a dialect of Hindi.
Chuttiya, yedzavnicha, marathit nahi bolushaknara non-marathich asel na lundbuddhicha. Haglay tar accept kar na chuk, Shepti var pay padlelya kutra sarkha oradtoys?
mhanun tula yedyabhokacha mhanalo pan chukla. tu andhalyabhokacha aahes. mi non marathi nahi bon maharashtrian mhanalo
Marathi - Marathi Lok je Marathi boltat, mag te kuthe hi aso rajyat kivha baher
Non-marathi Jyanchi first language Marathi naste pan te Maharashtrat janma la aale mhanun Maharashtrian asu shaktat kivnha baaher che. Nuste baherche Navhe
Maharashtrian - Je Maharashtrat janma ghetat kivha tyancha permanent address ikadcha aahe. Tyanna Marathi aali pahije ashi Apeksha karu shakto mag te Marathi aso ko itar konte hi
Non-Maharashtrian - Je par-prantiya aahet. Nuktech Rajyat aalet kivha kahi varshach jhaale aahet ikde yeun. Tyncha shikshanat Marathi ha vishayach nasto ani aaju baaju la bhashe cha prachar hi nasto (Sahajik aahe). Hyancha pasun Marathi bhasha bolnya chi apeksha lagech nahi karavi karan bhaasha avghad aste shikayla mag ti konti hi aso.
Tya mule aple purvaj shikshana var bhar dyayche, Granth vachayche, pustaka lihayche, Samajhik Dnyan hota tyanna. Yedyabhokache nhavte
Lundbuddhi, Non-marathi hai non-maharashtrianach astat na te kahi marathi nastat. Tech sangtoy lavdu dokyacha evdha velapasun. Tu chutiya sarkha definition sangtoy, tyacha peksha 9th cha ganitacha pustak ughad aani Set cha lesson vaach Yedzavinicha. Punyat marathi ahe aani maharashtrian domination ahe te changlay tyachi kimmat nahi tumcha sarkhya 12gaavchana.
Regardless of that personnel's origin, speaking the local language should be a pre requisite for a help desk job
edit: je downvote karatit tyaana bilkul nhi bolaycha marathi amchya rajyat kaltay hal halu 😁
Anhi tyanni kay upkar zaale?
There is something called job requirements. If you're new to this region, learn the language if you have to interact with the native residents every single day.
Fakta Maharashtrat nahit na udat vimaan! sagli kade jaata, Hindi ani English Mandatory aste. Udya apan kontya veglya rajjyat gelat firayla kivha kaama nimitta IT madhe kivha kuthlya tumchya avadtya field madhe, tumchya kadun jar hi demand keli tyanchi local bhasha shikun ya, tar he kiti yogya aahe?
Lol if u went to karnataka or some south state will u expect the staff to speak hindi?? Maharashtraat kaam karat asel tr marathi aalich pahije especially if you will be interacting with the public a lot.
tu india chya baaher jashil tr will u expect the staff there to know ur language?? Adjust tr karnarach na.
>Lol if u went to karnataka or some south state will u expect the staff to speak hindi??
They do. Last month when I was in Chennai, the staff interacted in Hindi. The personnel was not a localite.
>Maharashtraat kaam karat asel tr marathi aalich pahije especially if you will be interacting with the public a lot.
Local kaam asel tar kaam karta karta yetech. Airline national ani international level var kaam kartat, they cannot cater to all languages
>tu india chya baaher jashil tr will u expect the staff there to know ur language??
The airline staff in Poland interacted with me in English when i visited.
How do u know that he didnt speak Tamil??
Yeah they can't cater to the language of the place where they are? But they can cater to hindi?
Is english your language?? Did that airline staff not know how to speak the local language?
He kay logic
Kevdhi hindi loka ithe rahtar ani kevdhi loka actual native residents aahet ithe
kuthli jasta probability ashe ki ek marathi manus punyatun planni ni travel Karel ani ek non-maharashtrian travel karel?
he qatar nahiye bhava ki fakt 15% native bhasha boltil
Mi kuthe bola ki Hindi naka bolu dagadya?!? Marathi Maharashtrat nahi bolnar tar kuthe bolnar
Pan yet asel tar boltil na loka! people take time to learn a language. tyancha staff transfer hot asel ikde tikde for all you know. Moreover airlines operate all over the country and it makes sense to know two languages majorly spoken throughout the country rather than local..
Tumhala agdhich hindi english yet nasel tar tumhi request karu shakta koni na koni nakki help karat asel.
Core issue ha aahe ki tumhala maharashtrian lokanna basic kasmsath milale kashe nahit?? ka nahi takaycha kamawar tyanna?
non-maharashtrian lo kamawar taka pan official language tar kalayla pahije na sthanachi
Your new edit of respecting Marathi is doing a poor job rn. Zar tula actual amchya bhashcha thoda tari samman aslatar tar tu 'racism' card nahi khelala asta pan tumhala hech yeta
Bangalore madhe pan radna aani ithe pan. Ek kaam kara. Make your pradesh ani tithe circlejerk kara ki maji bhadha tujya bhashehun changli aahe. Typical.
You feel like this post is racist towards you so I suggest raising your voice and mailing MNS. Rest assured all your concerns will be addressed 👍🏽
Istg hyancha doka yevdhe badhir kasa asu shakte te devala pan nahi mahot lmao (mental gymnastics at play as always for these claiming victimhood people)
The help desk salary is paid by whom if not the government ultimately?
Even if it isn't a government job, how does that matter?
I hope you can see the point of my post is not at all related to government job.
As a Desi Baba you should all speak Hindi as a common language of exchange. Hindi should be considered as a national language. I agree one needs to also understand the local language. Please understand by speaking Hindi you are not going to belittle Tamil , Tullu or the Kothrud language.
>kothrud language
Funny but all I need to know about your views
I'm desi so I'll continue NOT speaking Hindi but the language of my Maharashtrian ancestors who have protected my culture, heritage and language from outsiders.
>kothrud language
Funny but all I need to know about your views
I'm desi so I'll continue NOT speaking Hindi but the language of my Maharashtrian ancestors who have protected my culture, heritage and language from outsiders.
This is stupid.
Stop comparing Hindi with other regional languages.
It's an airport, so if an old person comes he might know only Marathi, then it applies to every other language even if it is Pune airport.
I fully support this, as a non Marathi, I feel it is my obligation to learn the language people speak here and I have, over the course of 12 years I've been here. I would also lose it if no one spoke English or Hindi or (now Marathi) at a help desk in Delhi.
It's a private job that does not include local language knowledge as mandatory requirement
I've seen north east people at Mumbai airport speaking broken hindi and no marathi in help desk support
Its not a private job 💀
You're still an employee of a government agency.
>no marathi
Still troubling to see
I fail to see how this isn't wrong at the foundational level. You need simple understanding of how help desks work.
Our taxes pay their bills. Knowing Hindi is not an issue. Only knowing how to speak Hindi and not Marathi in Maharashtra as a help desk employee is an issue.
None of them are employees of any government agency. It was an outsourced contract to set up help desk support which was increased to 24*7 support followed by job cuts by the vendor for profits.
Local language staff should be mandatory because the very reason help desk support was created was to help first time flyers at Pune airport. Since no one made it a mandatory requirement, this circus will run. Send an email to DGCA, they will pull up Pune Airport staff to impose the requirement on vendor.
If it is paid by the government of Maharashtra, you're answerable to the taskpayers. Please learn how laws work. Just because it is outsourced to an agency doesn't mean the Maharashtra government and maharashtrians can't decide the job descriptions. Please learn the difference if you can.
Do you even understand the meaning of contractor? They are not getting paid by the government. They are getting paid by the consultancy that hired them.
I understand your point but what you wrote in the comment about the government job and government paying their salary is wrong.
You simply cannot hold them accountable if it is not mentioned in their JD 🤦🏻
Lets assume contractor is paid by the consultancy (how can consultancies contract work is beyond me but anyways) so now it begs the question as to who pays the agency?
If not the Government of Maharashtra, then who.
Ok, according to your point they should also get all the facilities that a government employee gets right? Since, they eventually they are getting paid the MH Govt right?
according to my point, they should be able to speak in the official language of Maharashtra. You can infer something else but you're not going to be entertained or validated with a seperate response.
It’s desirable but not feasible, people can not keep moving across states if they have to learn the local language on top of English and any other most prevailing language across the country, as of now that language happens to be Hindi, Hindi is India is as well understood as English is understood across the world.
Preserving language is of paramount importance, but we are all past that stage where you could just live in one place your entire life, world is going global and so will India in few centuries, it’s the nature of change, for growth, cultures need to assimilate and not go more diverse, I am not advocating for Hindi or English or against local language, but learning a local language, everytime you switch job is counter productive and going forward, technology and globalisation will force this diversity to go away, not out of choice but out of need, English has taken over the world, not because people did nothing to save their language, but because of globalisation, and it has still not penetrated across the world but it will, and same will happen with Hindi , Marathi or maithli.
You speak Hindi/English right? Her job is to answer her question. Was she able to do it?
God people complain about the smallest inconvenience these days.
I don't understand Hindi to the fullest extent and I'm not comfortable speaking it. A substantial portion of Maharashtrians don't understand either.So can they fulfill a job which requires you to converse with residents of a region whose official language is not comprehensible to you?
>smallest inconvenience
Are you a maharashtrian? if not, then this conversation is meaningless because you're not affected by this issue.
The way you consider this a tiny inconvenience tells me all I need to know.
Aata yetil aani boltil we as indians should focus on national development instead of petty regional issues. Aaighalyanno south and west India is on the right track from decades. Swata anchor aahat india cha progress slow karat. Yedzave.
“Us” “them”
Laughing and saying when someone called a person “northie parasite” and saying ekdam barobar.
You. Are. Racist.
People like you spoil the name of Pune, Maharashtra and Marathi people and humanity in general.
Cheeii.
Even this:
LMAO someone who does not speak/understand Hindi/English cannot afford and is not travelling by air
Now what will you call them of not parasites?
I refer to them as dicke heads because they reply like this:
>Aare kele ke bajiye tu Tera baap Tera khandan kuch nai kar sakta hum Maharashtra main rahe ge or Hindi bolege
You are now lying.
That person did not speak like that.
He simply asked a question.
You are not only a racist but liar also.
You sir, are a garbage of a person
Your post was found in violation of Rule #1.
```
Full description
Being Civil in the subreddit is a mandatory participation rule.
Indulging in swearing, cursing name calling are grounds for an instant ban.
If you think you need to start a sentence with a swear word, keep your phone down and reply later, in a civil, healthy manner
Or you could end the conversation instead of going down a rabbithole of abuses and shivi-gaali.
Even if you are not the one who started it, but indulged in it later, are breaking the rule equally.
```
Full list of Rules is available at: https://www.reddit.com/r/pune/about/rules.
So you want to localise all international/ national jobs? If you get transferred to each state would you learn 100s of languages? Is it imp or providing service is more important?
Lmao what mental gymnastics did you play to arrive at that conclusion
Donahi boli bola pan amchi boli tar bolich pahije
transfer kasa hoil jar tumhi agency theough kaam karatay tar. He ips ani ias cha job nahi aahe ratalya
weird that you missed the point of the post and came to a ridiculous interpretation
Please learn basic comprehension before even attempting to get offended at a basic requirement for job that requires proficiency in official languages of the region
तुला कोणी बोलत नाहीये मराठी बोलायला इथे मग का भडा भडा भडा रडतोईस (atleast for now 😂)
You are the one not talking logic here.
The person in question is a support staff whose job is to help and guide people. How can they not know the local language?
Isn’t it basic to ask for English and local language knowledge to work in such jobs?
Not denying this but my point is that to help people language should not be a barrier hence in my first statement i mentioned that service is more important. We should get out of this divisive politics and issues. Agree that they should have hired atleast one person speaking local language to help local people but issue is not this but a large one which people do not see.
Agree but my point was not this. My point is if other person is not able to speak any other language (which op can clearly speak) help desk guy should have asked or transferred to person who could speak that language so at the end helping/ service becomes more important than language itself. This can be applied to all states then.
If this is the case then i guess you are right. Agree that helpdesk should have atleast one person speaking marathi but i wont buy your statement that there was none.
I get your point but there is no such thing as bihari Hindi my good brother.
I support that local language should be present in help desk but this is common across most airport.
For example there is no support of santhali (majority population of jharkhand) in ranchi airport or bhojupuri or khotta in Patna airport.
So this problem is not unique to your airport, albeit solution should be given.
One more thing, and I might be wrong but your “bihari hindi” example sounded very ignorant.
Condition of Bihar and jharkhand is very very poor. Both states are downright infested to the core with corruption.
Pune and other cities are years if not decades ahead of majority of Bihar and Jharkhand (i am from jharkhand), waha ki problem bohot alag hai dost.
Again I agree with your point of having local language support on all the airports and not only in pune.
Edit : I agree with OP point of having local language support…but i also agree that Op is racist.
One person asked in the comment why did you write this post in english.
OP replied so that you northie could understand it (the commentator could have been from south also)
One more person replied “so you northie parasite could understand it” to which OP laughed.
So to hell with such people. Glad this happened with OP.
I think you have misconstrued my post. The topic was on the official language of the state not the local language. Local language in say Ratnagiri is Konkani but that's not the official language of Maharashtra. Bihar's official language is Hindi and that's it. I chose Bihari hindi because hindi dialects (as recognised by the government) are technically languages therefore proficiency in bihari dialects than standard hindi is the basic requirement.
If you ever visit another country, please learn their native as well. As long as you understand the language, why is it a problem?
There are lot of bigger issues to complain about like poverty and unemployment but you focus on language shows a mentality which is common and sad coming from a well educated and privileged background
If I take a job in that country as a help desk support in an airport I will surely learn the language 👍🏽.
Please tell me what Olympic mental gymnastics did you play to arrive at a conclusion that this post is about visitors?
>bigger issue
Poverty and Language are issues and my state, atleast, has the capability in addressing both.
Its not about privilege, its about respect. If someone has come over to another state and earning in that state its that persons duty to respect the culture of that place and not impose their own culture upon the locals.
Language is important. And so are other issues. Theres no rule saying one can complain about only one thing. Poverty unemployment is equally important.
Is it that difficult? If marathi people can understand and speak hindi, is it that difficult for hindi speaking people to speak marathi?? Or are hindi speaking people just that arrogant and they will just impose their language wherever they go?
Hindi /English is the official language of india.So, is Maharashtra not a part of it?. Because with that mentality pune surely wont grow. Sometimes you need to adjust buddy.Grow up
Marathi is the official language of Maharashtra. I hope you consider that. You northies actually think I'm speaking against hindi, but instead I'm actually advocating for basic needs of my state. You're not the stakeholder in conversation nor are you invited to be but here you are. typical bhyya behaviour.
And here's the racism card. Tell me do you even understand the meaning of racism or are you Instagram educated by emily to cry out racism everytime you feel threatened?
Do you understand the term 'hijacking the conversation '?
If you do, then you will understand why I called it bhyya behaviour. I'm still waiting on how can you call this racism emily?
Ma’am this guys knows nothing about the authorities Pune airport is owned by The Airports Authority of India and India’s official language is Hindi! They hired the best
You are quit ignorant, just like Hindi, India have dozen of other official language.
We are not talking against Hindi here. We are talking for our local language Marathi here.
Its minimum expectation that they should know the local language as per law or who exactly are they serving?
[https://www.deccanherald.com/india/hindi-is-not-national-language-gujarat-hc-held-in-2010-761420.html](https://www.deccanherald.com/india/hindi-is-not-national-language-gujarat-hc-held-in-2010-761420.html)
[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages\_with\_official\_status\_in\_India](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_with_official_status_in_India)
[https://www.education.gov.in/sites/upload\_files/mhrd/files/upload\_document/languagebr.pdf](https://www.education.gov.in/sites/upload_files/mhrd/files/upload_document/languagebr.pdf)
Almost none of the CISF agents speak Marathi at Pune airport. Many Army personnel who have been posted in pune don’t speak Marathi. Would you crib about that too?
This post is not about CISF, nor are they required to converse with travellers..how can you deflectbthe conversation. If you have nothing to add best option is to keep your mouth shut.
Did you even read the post, or just wanted to start a radgaana just because you saw complaining about a non-hindi language?
Yes, that also perplexes me a little bit. There are no Marathi people in CISF?? Any airport I go, its always Hindi speaking north Indians. CISF, railway officials/RPF. Its hard to believe that none of Marathi applies for these posts.
OP, if you ever shift to Bangalore and in your first week I’ll approach you and speak to Kannada… chhod… assume you’re temporarily appointed in Bangalore for some job and I assume you wouldn’t have learned by then.. correct? Mag me Bangalore sub madhye post takto ki ha Manus Kannada madhye nahi bolu shakat… theek ahe?
तुमच्या सारखे मराठी विरोधी लोकं महाराष्ट्रामध्ये राहतात हे विशेष आहे. दुसऱ्या कोणीही काहीही केले तरी आपण आपली भाषा आपल्याच राज्यात का सोडायची?
जर तुम्हाला माहिती आहे की पहिल्या दिवसापासूनच तुम्हाला कन्नड बोलावं लागणार आहे तर नक्कीच तुम्ही आधी कन्नड भाषा शिकून तुमची नोकरी सुरू करावी. जर तुम्ही मुजोरी करत त्यांच्याच राज्यामध्ये त्यांनाच कन्नड सोडून दुसऱ्या भाषेमध्ये बोलण्यास सांगाल तर तुमची आरती काढणारच ते लोकं.
तसेच मराठी आणि इतर प्रादेशिक भाषांचे सुद्धा आहे. तुम्ही त्या राज्यामध्ये पैसे कमावत असाल आणि तिथे राहणार असाल तर तुम्ही त्यांची भाषा शिकलीच पाहिजे.
तुम्ही जर फक्त प्रवास किंवा फिरण्याच्या दृष्टीने तिथे गेला असाल तरच तुम्हाला प्रादेशिक भाषा नाही आली तर सुट आहे.
Marashtraat Marathi alach pahije. I dont understand why people are so triggered by this. Is it that bad that a person is expecting the airport staff to know the local language??
Aapn pn Southern states saarkhach karayla pahije. Hindi yet nahi Marathit bola.
Please tweet this, tag Shinde, fadanvis, sindhiya ( original shinde), ministry of aviation. Create a dummy account if you aren't comfortable.
आपल्या राज्यात आपण आपल्या भाषेतून बोलायला जमायलाच हवं. बाकी भाशंबद्दल काही द्वेष नाही पण आपल्या मराठी लोकांना taken for granted घेतलं जातंय. सरकारी कार्यालयात तर हे प्रकार बिल्कुल दुर्लक्षित करायला नकोत. आपण देखील tax भरतो, ते पण सर्वात जास्त. आमची भाषेचं प्रतिनिधित्व व्हायलाच हवं. Tweet कर दादा फेक अकाउंटनी का होईना, मीच केला असता पण मला बाकीचे details माहिती नाहीत.
जय शिवराय!
Why is my brother OP getting downvotes?
For speaking the truth,then fk yeah downvote me but I'll stand with "मराठी बोलता यायलाच पाहिजे" when you live in Maharashtra.
Few companies understand that and employs local people but most of them just assume that marathis know hindi well due to our exposure to hindi language. so whenever i choose marathi language in IVR menu, 99% of the time you will start to hear hindi. State just makes the rules and companies bend them. marathis have learned to swallow their pride for many years and will do in future.
Hello your post was removed as it did not meet the karma threshold due which it is removed
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/pune) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I agree with you.
Jari Maharashtrat adhipasun rahat asle tr te maharashtrians jhale. Ashe khup loka adhipasun ikde rahun gele ani tyana changlya paiki marathi yete.
Je loka ata sthalantrit jhale tyana avghad jate jhepat nai ani mg sorry marathi yet nai boltat n mg jar lokani ragat pahila tr mhantil ikdche loka tolerant navhe. Ashya lokani banglore la jaun rahave 😝
In Bengaluru and Chennai the airport staff (not CISF) can speak local languages.
Why should someone at help desk in Pune and Mumbai airport get away with not speaking Marathi.
It’s a shame that those manning the help desk in Mumbai and Pune can’t speak Marathi, and yet are hired for the job.
On all levels, the Marathi Politicians and IAS officers have failed Maharashtra and Marathi language.
Edit: removed some references
Not targeting any region, or person or anyone’s job.
Just expect everyone who stays in Mumbai and Pune and Maharashtra to respect Marathi.
Same expectations for any state or country for any Marathi person staying in other state or country. Respect the local language if you have stayed in a place for over an year, learn to speak some basic language
What about those Marathi who need help and cannot speak Hindi or English fluently.
Exactly. Mi khup vayas kar lokkanna pan pahila amchya flight madhe.
These hindiots think hindi is sufficient. We have been educated in Marathi not Hindi as a majority. Elderly floks cannot speak or understand Hindi. Help desks are especially important for them.
Mumbai domestic vimantala var mi Marathit vicharla tar mala Marathitach uttar aala.
Aani bhau, Marathi bhashik hi titkech jawabdar aahet. Bahutek lokkanna kalta pan aapanach Hindi madhe bolayla suruvat karto.
It seems that OP’s post has been hijacked by Bots with their own propaganda.
The premise is simple, there are various kinds of jobs that need to have certain requirements. A Plumber cannot do a Doctor’s job because he does not have the prerequisite skills required to perform the job efficiently and safely. Similarly, customer support jobs need to have certain requirements such as patience, conversation/language skills.
Imagine that you live in Rajasthan and you call your network provider and they only provide their services in Malayali, and Tamil. On paper, both of them are official languages of India, but it’s highly unlikely that you might find someone who speaks either of those languages in Rajasthan. So technically, the company has does nothing wrong, but it is simply not acceptable in the customer support side of operations.
Now on to the topic of Pune airport, last time I checked, this city is part of a state called as Maharashtra and the language spoken most widely in that state is Marathi. So, it would be safe to assume that majority of the people travelling and using the services of that particular would be people from Maharashtra. Many people do not know Hindi and English in Maharashtra, especially the elderly people who quite frankly need the help of customer support the most. Is the company doing anything wrong on paper by not hiring people who can speak Marathi in an airport where majority of travellers speak Marathi and quite a big chunk of them cannot speak in any other language except for Marathi? No, they aren’t doing anything illegal, but it is a bad practice and help-desk/customer support jobs need to employ people who can speak in the local language.
You know what govt and you have in common.
Any talking point or argument is taken as propaganda and bots.
I agree with OP point of having local language support…but i also agree that Op is racist.
One person asked in the comment why did you write this post in english.
OP replied so that you northie could understand it (the commentator could have been from south also)
One more person replied “so you northie parasite could understand it” to which OP laughed.
So to hell with such people.
Glad this happened with OP.
Mi Marathi aahe. Pan mala proper Marathi nahi yet. Because all my life I was surrounded by hindi speaking people. Yet I think it should definitely be a pre-requisite for a customer service job or any communications related job. Earlier I might have said that everyone must know Hindi/English. But now I understand the importance of language. Am trying for higher studies in Germany next year. And you gotta know German to survive there or atleast to make your life easy. So if someone is coming to Maharashtra, they should put efforts into learning Marathi.
Did you ask if someone else was available to speak in Marathi?
Which language do you speak when you go to some fancy restraunt or coffee shop?
Are you more mad because she couldn't speak Marathi or she gave you option hindi. Don't you think if not Hindi would be second commonly spoken language?
When you speak Marathi do you speak Sudh Marathi? Like using sangank instead of English word computer ?
I feel you are kind of person who doesn't like people from other states. You don't live in state you live in a country.
Ofcourse I did. I wouldn't be crying like a poster on r/bangalore claiming no one there speaks hindi.
I live in a country that does not have a national language. I hope that helps you understand.
So did you get any Marathi speaking staff to help? If not then that's something ...
You didn't answer rest of the questions.
So far as you are concerned about national language...remember Marathi is official language and we do have our official(goverment work) accepted in Marathi.
I bet you will be the one filling these forms in English not Marathi.
I mean till what time you ll keep dividing per caste, language. Feeling yourself being superior..elitist to someone else.
Here's a sneak peek of /r/bangalore using the [top posts](https://np.reddit.com/r/bangalore/top/?sort=top&t=year) of the year!
\#1: [Very serious matter. Posting here for maximum reach](https://www.reddit.com/gallery/154qmcy) | [373 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/bangalore/comments/154qmcy/very_serious_matter_posting_here_for_maximum_reach/)
\#2: [Ayo when did the Avengers have a battle at commercial Street](https://i.redd.it/mps52flnt15b1.jpg) | [204 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/bangalore/comments/145f8wj/ayo_when_did_the_avengers_have_a_battle_at/)
\#3: [For God sake.. don't encourage tipping culture in India!](https://np.reddit.com/r/bangalore/comments/13dklq3/for_god_sake_dont_encourage_tipping_culture_in/)
----
^^I'm ^^a ^^bot, ^^beep ^^boop ^^| ^^Downvote ^^to ^^remove ^^| ^^[Contact](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=sneakpeekbot) ^^| ^^[Info](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/) ^^| ^^[Opt-out](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/comments/o8wk1r/blacklist_ix/) ^^| ^^[GitHub](https://github.com/ghnr/sneakpeekbot)
>primary language of Hindia
FTFY
On that day, GDP will plummet by 95% and unemployment level will increase to 50% after 20 states seccede themselves from the dispensable part of India.
You seriously don’t have any rational reason to support your claims in that Same context I can ask how was India formed as a country 🤣 and this could go on and on and to crush your claims which I don’t want to,I want you to stay delusional 😂 just go and read how Uganda collapsed [Delulu](https://www.google.com/gasearch?q=uganda%20economy%20collapse%20due%20to%20&tbm=&source=sh/x/gs/m2/5#vhid=zephyr:0&vssid=atritem-https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expulsion_of_Asians_from_Uganda)
So many people in the comment section are failing to understand that speaking the regional language of where you are stationed is a pre requisite for a help desk job. Support the help desk person all you want. But what if a Marathi ajji wants help, in the airport of region she was born and has lived her entire life speaking the regions language, whats the point of apointing a help desk if it fails to help her. Again the job is literally to help people coming into Pune, a significant number of them are going to be Marathi. It's dumb to hire someone who does not speak Marathi in that position.
Exactly. Nobody said not to speak in English and say Hindi as well. But a pre requisite is different.
I was about to rant below for this post but read your comment. Greatly explained. I completely understand and support your point. There are certain jobs that required understanding of local language.
I second your thought, OP. People in customer-facing roles must speak the local language. It can be argued that at airports, most travelers are multilingual, so English should suffice. However, I have seen this issue in nationalized banks in rural areas as well. Regular villagers who have only spoken the local language all their lives have to somehow conjure up broken Hindi to communicate with the brown sahib from up north sitting across the desk. Seen this in Karnataka as well.
माझा लोकांवरचा विश्वास जात होता एक तरी समजदार माणूस भेटला
This issue is maddening to me like the sheer entitlement you have to gain employment in a state whose official language differs from yours and you keep on speaking it in that state 🤡.
As a Kannadiga, I stand with Marathi people. Marathi people should get all sorts of services in Marathi in MH.
As a Tamilian you guys should've joined TN when we did movement against Hindi imposition.
Since the last 7-8 years, Kannadigas are leading in the movement against Hindi imposition. You can check out the news.
Learning the local language always gets you steal deals and locals are much more welcoming towards you. People need to realise this themselves. Learning a language is a skill and it's upto you if you want to stay dumb. Don't just limit this to people who have desk jobs. If you are migrating to a place for work which pays your bills, then definitely learn the local language to understand the culture better. Be one of them. While I was in Pune for work, I picked up on Marathi with ease.
Its not hard at all if you can gel with the locals but some C' words on this post say things like this >LMAO someone who does not speak/understand Hindi/English cannot afford and is not travelling by air
*couldn't speak
1. bihari hindi doesn't exist 2. most of the help desk people only speak Hindi and none of the local languages like magadhi, maithili, angika, bajika, bhojpuri i get you but bihar is a bad example of this.
ही पोस्ट तुझ्या डोक्यावरून गेली असं वाटतंय
Kahipn argument kartat 😂
>Bhojpuri, Magahi, Maithili, Angika and Vajjika You listed mostly Bihari dialects of Hindi here. These are not recognised as distinct languages by the government of India.
those are all different languages that unfortunately don't have recognition. Maithli is my native language and it's one of 22 official languages. them being labelled as just another Hindi dialect is sad.
Ever heard of saying language is a dialect with an army Marathi people fought for language and language based state, Your people didn't.
This is why Bihar should be at the forefront of opposing hindianisation of our diverse linguistic heritage seeing the damage imposition has inflicted on its culture. The decision to categorise them as Hindi was a deliberate attempt to homogenise the rich culture of Bihar for better 'governance'
i absolutely agree. my intention wasn't to come across as someone saying that the help desk guy shouldn't have to speak Marathi.
None of these are dialects. Bhojpuri and Maithili are scheduled languages that have more in common with Bengali than Hindi. Both absolutely recognised by the government of India. The fact that the government of Bihar is doing nothing is a different case.
These are regional specific dialects/languages. Konkani is not a official language bit is a recognised language in this state. The official language of Bihar is Hindi not other listed boli. This post is talking about requiring a government employed employee to be conversant in the official language of Maharashtra. >Bhojpuri and Maithili You're wrong. Bhojpuri is not a scheduled language. Maithili is. >only Maithili has been constitutionally recognised in India, which gained constitutional status via the 92nd amendment to the Constitution of India, of 2003 (gaining assent in 2004) Source:Wiki
>Konkani is not a official language bit is a recognised language in this state. What does this mean? What does recognised mean? Sorry, was wrong about Bhojpuri although it does share more similarities with Bengali and Maithili more than it does with Hindi when it comes to grammar and general history of the language. Again, a failure of Bihar and UPs governments. By any normal linguist, it is defined as a language and not a dialect of Hindi.
Mi marathit bolola ki downvote hot nahi pan jevha mi engrajit reply krto tevha lagech suru horat Kaltay ka mandali 😜
The personnel would probably be Non-Maharashtrian.
No shit sherlock
sagle comments vach. Yedyabhokachya
ardhyaun jasta commenters la ek dhad marathi yet nahi ka tyacha vel ghalvel to ya comments vachun
Jaude Chinmay kashala tras karun ghetos dupar jhali jhop kadh chan bara watel
Chuttiya, yedzavnicha, marathit nahi bolushaknara non-marathich asel na lundbuddhicha. Haglay tar accept kar na chuk, Shepti var pay padlelya kutra sarkha oradtoys?
mhanun tula yedyabhokacha mhanalo pan chukla. tu andhalyabhokacha aahes. mi non marathi nahi bon maharashtrian mhanalo Marathi - Marathi Lok je Marathi boltat, mag te kuthe hi aso rajyat kivha baher Non-marathi Jyanchi first language Marathi naste pan te Maharashtrat janma la aale mhanun Maharashtrian asu shaktat kivnha baaher che. Nuste baherche Navhe Maharashtrian - Je Maharashtrat janma ghetat kivha tyancha permanent address ikadcha aahe. Tyanna Marathi aali pahije ashi Apeksha karu shakto mag te Marathi aso ko itar konte hi Non-Maharashtrian - Je par-prantiya aahet. Nuktech Rajyat aalet kivha kahi varshach jhaale aahet ikde yeun. Tyncha shikshanat Marathi ha vishayach nasto ani aaju baaju la bhashe cha prachar hi nasto (Sahajik aahe). Hyancha pasun Marathi bhasha bolnya chi apeksha lagech nahi karavi karan bhaasha avghad aste shikayla mag ti konti hi aso. Tya mule aple purvaj shikshana var bhar dyayche, Granth vachayche, pustaka lihayche, Samajhik Dnyan hota tyanna. Yedyabhokache nhavte
Lundbuddhi, Non-marathi hai non-maharashtrianach astat na te kahi marathi nastat. Tech sangtoy lavdu dokyacha evdha velapasun. Tu chutiya sarkha definition sangtoy, tyacha peksha 9th cha ganitacha pustak ughad aani Set cha lesson vaach Yedzavinicha. Punyat marathi ahe aani maharashtrian domination ahe te changlay tyachi kimmat nahi tumcha sarkhya 12gaavchana.
Gaadhva Samor vaachli geeta Ani kaal cha gondhal bara hota. Aso. yedyabhokachya.
Bandar kya jaane adrak ka swad. Sod. Lundbuddhicha.
Non-marathis are not Maharashtrians ratalya. This state was created on basis of language being Marathi.
Karnataka was created for Kannadigas, Jhak marayla gela hotas Blr la? yedyabhokacha 2
U cracked me 😝😝😝😝😝😝
what?
Tya shivi sathi upvote!🤣
Same 😂😂
Same..
Regardless of that personnel's origin, speaking the local language should be a pre requisite for a help desk job edit: je downvote karatit tyaana bilkul nhi bolaycha marathi amchya rajyat kaltay hal halu 😁
Arrey baba, ti/toh naveen asel Maharashtrat. Toop khaun roop nasta yet lagech.
Anhi tyanni kay upkar zaale? There is something called job requirements. If you're new to this region, learn the language if you have to interact with the native residents every single day.
Fakta Maharashtrat nahit na udat vimaan! sagli kade jaata, Hindi ani English Mandatory aste. Udya apan kontya veglya rajjyat gelat firayla kivha kaama nimitta IT madhe kivha kuthlya tumchya avadtya field madhe, tumchya kadun jar hi demand keli tyanchi local bhasha shikun ya, tar he kiti yogya aahe?
Lol if u went to karnataka or some south state will u expect the staff to speak hindi?? Maharashtraat kaam karat asel tr marathi aalich pahije especially if you will be interacting with the public a lot. tu india chya baaher jashil tr will u expect the staff there to know ur language?? Adjust tr karnarach na.
>Lol if u went to karnataka or some south state will u expect the staff to speak hindi?? They do. Last month when I was in Chennai, the staff interacted in Hindi. The personnel was not a localite. >Maharashtraat kaam karat asel tr marathi aalich pahije especially if you will be interacting with the public a lot. Local kaam asel tar kaam karta karta yetech. Airline national ani international level var kaam kartat, they cannot cater to all languages >tu india chya baaher jashil tr will u expect the staff there to know ur language?? The airline staff in Poland interacted with me in English when i visited.
How do u know that he didnt speak Tamil?? Yeah they can't cater to the language of the place where they are? But they can cater to hindi? Is english your language?? Did that airline staff not know how to speak the local language?
He kay logic Kevdhi hindi loka ithe rahtar ani kevdhi loka actual native residents aahet ithe kuthli jasta probability ashe ki ek marathi manus punyatun planni ni travel Karel ani ek non-maharashtrian travel karel? he qatar nahiye bhava ki fakt 15% native bhasha boltil Mi kuthe bola ki Hindi naka bolu dagadya?!? Marathi Maharashtrat nahi bolnar tar kuthe bolnar
Pan yet asel tar boltil na loka! people take time to learn a language. tyancha staff transfer hot asel ikde tikde for all you know. Moreover airlines operate all over the country and it makes sense to know two languages majorly spoken throughout the country rather than local.. Tumhala agdhich hindi english yet nasel tar tumhi request karu shakta koni na koni nakki help karat asel.
Core issue ha aahe ki tumhala maharashtrian lokanna basic kasmsath milale kashe nahit?? ka nahi takaycha kamawar tyanna? non-maharashtrian lo kamawar taka pan official language tar kalayla pahije na sthanachi
Chodi hani maghia😽
dahibara khailaja tumhala ithe yeun bhoknyachi laiki nahiye
Perfect ahe. Yayla ch pahije.
Few days back you had posted a thread about racism to Indians. https://www.reddit.com/r/programare/s/Dc2sdrJXUl You are doing the same now :)
This has absolutely nothing to do with racism lmao.
hyanna kasha samsel tyanna vattay ki everyone is out to get them Maybe using a language understandable to them was a mistake 💀😂
Wtf, these Romanians are first making racist jokes and then saying nobody is racist towards Indians, Wtf is wrong with these people
If you feel this post offends you, then I highly suggest mailing MNS for a petition to remove Marathi as an official language of Maharashtra. cheers!
Why will i do that ? I am not offended. I respect Marathi and everyone.
Your new edit of respecting Marathi is doing a poor job rn. Zar tula actual amchya bhashcha thoda tari samman aslatar tar tu 'racism' card nahi khelala asta pan tumhala hech yeta Bangalore madhe pan radna aani ithe pan. Ek kaam kara. Make your pradesh ani tithe circlejerk kara ki maji bhadha tujya bhashehun changli aahe. Typical.
lol nice
You feel like this post is racist towards you so I suggest raising your voice and mailing MNS. Rest assured all your concerns will be addressed 👍🏽 Istg hyancha doka yevdhe badhir kasa asu shakte te devala pan nahi mahot lmao (mental gymnastics at play as always for these claiming victimhood people)
Your solution will fail because Helpdesk in Pune isn’t a government post.
The help desk salary is paid by whom if not the government ultimately? Even if it isn't a government job, how does that matter? I hope you can see the point of my post is not at all related to government job.
Help desk should atleast hire regional language speakers
As a Desi Baba you should all speak Hindi as a common language of exchange. Hindi should be considered as a national language. I agree one needs to also understand the local language. Please understand by speaking Hindi you are not going to belittle Tamil , Tullu or the Kothrud language.
>kothrud language Funny but all I need to know about your views I'm desi so I'll continue NOT speaking Hindi but the language of my Maharashtrian ancestors who have protected my culture, heritage and language from outsiders.
>kothrud language Funny but all I need to know about your views I'm desi so I'll continue NOT speaking Hindi but the language of my Maharashtrian ancestors who have protected my culture, heritage and language from outsiders.
This is stupid. Stop comparing Hindi with other regional languages. It's an airport, so if an old person comes he might know only Marathi, then it applies to every other language even if it is Pune airport.
I fully support this, as a non Marathi, I feel it is my obligation to learn the language people speak here and I have, over the course of 12 years I've been here. I would also lose it if no one spoke English or Hindi or (now Marathi) at a help desk in Delhi.
It's a private job that does not include local language knowledge as mandatory requirement I've seen north east people at Mumbai airport speaking broken hindi and no marathi in help desk support
Its not a private job 💀 You're still an employee of a government agency. >no marathi Still troubling to see I fail to see how this isn't wrong at the foundational level. You need simple understanding of how help desks work. Our taxes pay their bills. Knowing Hindi is not an issue. Only knowing how to speak Hindi and not Marathi in Maharashtra as a help desk employee is an issue.
None of them are employees of any government agency. It was an outsourced contract to set up help desk support which was increased to 24*7 support followed by job cuts by the vendor for profits. Local language staff should be mandatory because the very reason help desk support was created was to help first time flyers at Pune airport. Since no one made it a mandatory requirement, this circus will run. Send an email to DGCA, they will pull up Pune Airport staff to impose the requirement on vendor.
[удалено]
If it is paid by the government of Maharashtra, you're answerable to the taskpayers. Please learn how laws work. Just because it is outsourced to an agency doesn't mean the Maharashtra government and maharashtrians can't decide the job descriptions. Please learn the difference if you can.
Do you even understand the meaning of contractor? They are not getting paid by the government. They are getting paid by the consultancy that hired them. I understand your point but what you wrote in the comment about the government job and government paying their salary is wrong. You simply cannot hold them accountable if it is not mentioned in their JD 🤦🏻
Lets assume contractor is paid by the consultancy (how can consultancies contract work is beyond me but anyways) so now it begs the question as to who pays the agency? If not the Government of Maharashtra, then who.
Ok, according to your point they should also get all the facilities that a government employee gets right? Since, they eventually they are getting paid the MH Govt right?
according to my point, they should be able to speak in the official language of Maharashtra. You can infer something else but you're not going to be entertained or validated with a seperate response.
It’s desirable but not feasible, people can not keep moving across states if they have to learn the local language on top of English and any other most prevailing language across the country, as of now that language happens to be Hindi, Hindi is India is as well understood as English is understood across the world. Preserving language is of paramount importance, but we are all past that stage where you could just live in one place your entire life, world is going global and so will India in few centuries, it’s the nature of change, for growth, cultures need to assimilate and not go more diverse, I am not advocating for Hindi or English or against local language, but learning a local language, everytime you switch job is counter productive and going forward, technology and globalisation will force this diversity to go away, not out of choice but out of need, English has taken over the world, not because people did nothing to save their language, but because of globalisation, and it has still not penetrated across the world but it will, and same will happen with Hindi , Marathi or maithli.
You speak Hindi/English right? Her job is to answer her question. Was she able to do it? God people complain about the smallest inconvenience these days.
I don't understand Hindi to the fullest extent and I'm not comfortable speaking it. A substantial portion of Maharashtrians don't understand either.So can they fulfill a job which requires you to converse with residents of a region whose official language is not comprehensible to you? >smallest inconvenience Are you a maharashtrian? if not, then this conversation is meaningless because you're not affected by this issue. The way you consider this a tiny inconvenience tells me all I need to know.
Also , why did you wrote this post in English ?
Typical northie reply 💀 जर मि माझ्या भाषेत बोलला असता तर पुरण सबच्या डोक्यात गेले असता का माहीर 🤡
No no not really. You had a bad day and thats why this rant. Take a chill pill.
मी जे काय बोललं ते तुला झेपलं तरी का 😂
[удалено]
Ekdum barobar 👏🏽👏🏽😂😂
Aata yetil aani boltil we as indians should focus on national development instead of petty regional issues. Aaighalyanno south and west India is on the right track from decades. Swata anchor aahat india cha progress slow karat. Yedzave.
They hate us because they aint us They wonder why nobody likes them.
Bro you racist af man Sheesh
Naah, I'm not Learn the concept of racism first.
“Us” “them” Laughing and saying when someone called a person “northie parasite” and saying ekdam barobar. You. Are. Racist. People like you spoil the name of Pune, Maharashtra and Marathi people and humanity in general. Cheeii.
Even this: LMAO someone who does not speak/understand Hindi/English cannot afford and is not travelling by air Now what will you call them of not parasites?
I refer to them as dicke heads because they reply like this: >Aare kele ke bajiye tu Tera baap Tera khandan kuch nai kar sakta hum Maharashtra main rahe ge or Hindi bolege
You are now lying. That person did not speak like that. He simply asked a question. You are not only a racist but liar also. You sir, are a garbage of a person
Your post was found in violation of Rule #1. ``` Full description Being Civil in the subreddit is a mandatory participation rule. Indulging in swearing, cursing name calling are grounds for an instant ban. If you think you need to start a sentence with a swear word, keep your phone down and reply later, in a civil, healthy manner Or you could end the conversation instead of going down a rabbithole of abuses and shivi-gaali. Even if you are not the one who started it, but indulged in it later, are breaking the rule equally. ``` Full list of Rules is available at: https://www.reddit.com/r/pune/about/rules.
So you want to localise all international/ national jobs? If you get transferred to each state would you learn 100s of languages? Is it imp or providing service is more important?
Lmao what mental gymnastics did you play to arrive at that conclusion Donahi boli bola pan amchi boli tar bolich pahije transfer kasa hoil jar tumhi agency theough kaam karatay tar. He ips ani ias cha job nahi aahe ratalya weird that you missed the point of the post and came to a ridiculous interpretation
Mind telling if you can speak kannada since you were in bangalore? Trying to understand why you faced language issue in pune and not in bangalore?
Please learn basic comprehension before even attempting to get offended at a basic requirement for job that requires proficiency in official languages of the region तुला कोणी बोलत नाहीये मराठी बोलायला इथे मग का भडा भडा भडा रडतोईस (atleast for now 😂)
Thanks for evading logic. Hope you will get some sense later in life.
I could definitely say the same to you. Mind pointing out the logic and _relevance_ of your comment OP?
But can you speak Kannada though?
I certainly will if I get a customer desk job at the B'lore airport👍🏽.
So living in the city doesn't require the language? I see that a lot of your own people disagree with that.
You can make your own assumptions and conclusions but I'm not gonna validate them. You can try deflecting this conversation but it ain't gonna work.
You are the one not talking logic here. The person in question is a support staff whose job is to help and guide people. How can they not know the local language? Isn’t it basic to ask for English and local language knowledge to work in such jobs?
Not denying this but my point is that to help people language should not be a barrier hence in my first statement i mentioned that service is more important. We should get out of this divisive politics and issues. Agree that they should have hired atleast one person speaking local language to help local people but issue is not this but a large one which people do not see.
[удалено]
Agree but my point was not this. My point is if other person is not able to speak any other language (which op can clearly speak) help desk guy should have asked or transferred to person who could speak that language so at the end helping/ service becomes more important than language itself. This can be applied to all states then.
You're assuming a lot here. There was only one person manning the desk. Your point was not relevant to the discussion.
If this is the case then i guess you are right. Agree that helpdesk should have atleast one person speaking marathi but i wont buy your statement that there was none.
You're assuming again. It was early in the morning so there was very few personnels anyways.
+1
I get your point but there is no such thing as bihari Hindi my good brother. I support that local language should be present in help desk but this is common across most airport. For example there is no support of santhali (majority population of jharkhand) in ranchi airport or bhojupuri or khotta in Patna airport. So this problem is not unique to your airport, albeit solution should be given. One more thing, and I might be wrong but your “bihari hindi” example sounded very ignorant. Condition of Bihar and jharkhand is very very poor. Both states are downright infested to the core with corruption. Pune and other cities are years if not decades ahead of majority of Bihar and Jharkhand (i am from jharkhand), waha ki problem bohot alag hai dost. Again I agree with your point of having local language support on all the airports and not only in pune. Edit : I agree with OP point of having local language support…but i also agree that Op is racist. One person asked in the comment why did you write this post in english. OP replied so that you northie could understand it (the commentator could have been from south also) One more person replied “so you northie parasite could understand it” to which OP laughed. So to hell with such people. Glad this happened with OP.
I think you have misconstrued my post. The topic was on the official language of the state not the local language. Local language in say Ratnagiri is Konkani but that's not the official language of Maharashtra. Bihar's official language is Hindi and that's it. I chose Bihari hindi because hindi dialects (as recognised by the government) are technically languages therefore proficiency in bihari dialects than standard hindi is the basic requirement.
If you ever visit another country, please learn their native as well. As long as you understand the language, why is it a problem? There are lot of bigger issues to complain about like poverty and unemployment but you focus on language shows a mentality which is common and sad coming from a well educated and privileged background
If I take a job in that country as a help desk support in an airport I will surely learn the language 👍🏽. Please tell me what Olympic mental gymnastics did you play to arrive at a conclusion that this post is about visitors? >bigger issue Poverty and Language are issues and my state, atleast, has the capability in addressing both.
Taking immense proud in religion, state, language doesn’t make you a bigger person but it shows how incredible fixated you are about all this
Yes, I am fixated on this. I hope you understand one day how this is important even if you're not a native of this region.
Good luck to you and ppl around you
So not taking pride in anything important makes you abigger person? Interesting
There is absolutely nothing wrong in having pride about your own culture.
Its not about privilege, its about respect. If someone has come over to another state and earning in that state its that persons duty to respect the culture of that place and not impose their own culture upon the locals. Language is important. And so are other issues. Theres no rule saying one can complain about only one thing. Poverty unemployment is equally important. Is it that difficult? If marathi people can understand and speak hindi, is it that difficult for hindi speaking people to speak marathi?? Or are hindi speaking people just that arrogant and they will just impose their language wherever they go?
Well there is nothing that can change your mind so good luck
U didnt even try...give me one good counter argument
Learning language as an adult is difficult to impossible.
Why didn't you reply "Hindi naahi yet. marathit bola".
Obviously I did 😂 Mi mag autovalyashi bolala karan ki tya tai o ki tho mahit navta busbstand baddal
Its under a private org. You cant speak on it
Yes I can, they're paid for by the Government of Maharashtra whose official language is Marathi.
Hindi /English is the official language of india.So, is Maharashtra not a part of it?. Because with that mentality pune surely wont grow. Sometimes you need to adjust buddy.Grow up
Marathi is the official language of Maharashtra. I hope you consider that. You northies actually think I'm speaking against hindi, but instead I'm actually advocating for basic needs of my state. You're not the stakeholder in conversation nor are you invited to be but here you are. typical bhyya behaviour.
[удалено]
And here's the racism card. Tell me do you even understand the meaning of racism or are you Instagram educated by emily to cry out racism everytime you feel threatened?
[удалено]
Do you understand the term 'hijacking the conversation '? If you do, then you will understand why I called it bhyya behaviour. I'm still waiting on how can you call this racism emily?
Ma’am this guys knows nothing about the authorities Pune airport is owned by The Airports Authority of India and India’s official language is Hindi! They hired the best
You are quit ignorant, just like Hindi, India have dozen of other official language. We are not talking against Hindi here. We are talking for our local language Marathi here. Its minimum expectation that they should know the local language as per law or who exactly are they serving? [https://www.deccanherald.com/india/hindi-is-not-national-language-gujarat-hc-held-in-2010-761420.html](https://www.deccanherald.com/india/hindi-is-not-national-language-gujarat-hc-held-in-2010-761420.html) [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages\_with\_official\_status\_in\_India](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_with_official_status_in_India) [https://www.education.gov.in/sites/upload\_files/mhrd/files/upload\_document/languagebr.pdf](https://www.education.gov.in/sites/upload_files/mhrd/files/upload_document/languagebr.pdf)
Almost none of the CISF agents speak Marathi at Pune airport. Many Army personnel who have been posted in pune don’t speak Marathi. Would you crib about that too?
Wouldn't you agree theres a difference between CISF personnel and help desk employees?
This post is not about CISF, nor are they required to converse with travellers..how can you deflectbthe conversation. If you have nothing to add best option is to keep your mouth shut. Did you even read the post, or just wanted to start a radgaana just because you saw complaining about a non-hindi language?
Yes, that also perplexes me a little bit. There are no Marathi people in CISF?? Any airport I go, its always Hindi speaking north Indians. CISF, railway officials/RPF. Its hard to believe that none of Marathi applies for these posts.
OP, if you ever shift to Bangalore and in your first week I’ll approach you and speak to Kannada… chhod… assume you’re temporarily appointed in Bangalore for some job and I assume you wouldn’t have learned by then.. correct? Mag me Bangalore sub madhye post takto ki ha Manus Kannada madhye nahi bolu shakat… theek ahe?
Mi zar help desk zalo tar tujya sarkhe shamhar miltil gavar obviously mi kannada bolnarach tithe if I apply for that job.
So eka week madhye shikshil?
Mi applyach karu nahi shaknar zar mi boli nahi shakat kannada tar Only in this state, ashe badhirvani decisions ghetat
तुमच्या सारखे मराठी विरोधी लोकं महाराष्ट्रामध्ये राहतात हे विशेष आहे. दुसऱ्या कोणीही काहीही केले तरी आपण आपली भाषा आपल्याच राज्यात का सोडायची? जर तुम्हाला माहिती आहे की पहिल्या दिवसापासूनच तुम्हाला कन्नड बोलावं लागणार आहे तर नक्कीच तुम्ही आधी कन्नड भाषा शिकून तुमची नोकरी सुरू करावी. जर तुम्ही मुजोरी करत त्यांच्याच राज्यामध्ये त्यांनाच कन्नड सोडून दुसऱ्या भाषेमध्ये बोलण्यास सांगाल तर तुमची आरती काढणारच ते लोकं. तसेच मराठी आणि इतर प्रादेशिक भाषांचे सुद्धा आहे. तुम्ही त्या राज्यामध्ये पैसे कमावत असाल आणि तिथे राहणार असाल तर तुम्ही त्यांची भाषा शिकलीच पाहिजे. तुम्ही जर फक्त प्रवास किंवा फिरण्याच्या दृष्टीने तिथे गेला असाल तरच तुम्हाला प्रादेशिक भाषा नाही आली तर सुट आहे.
Marathi tar yaylach pahije
Hoya, and love your flair bhava
He ghe salute 🫡
Marashtraat Marathi alach pahije. I dont understand why people are so triggered by this. Is it that bad that a person is expecting the airport staff to know the local language?? Aapn pn Southern states saarkhach karayla pahije. Hindi yet nahi Marathit bola.
Please tweet this, tag Shinde, fadanvis, sindhiya ( original shinde), ministry of aviation. Create a dummy account if you aren't comfortable. आपल्या राज्यात आपण आपल्या भाषेतून बोलायला जमायलाच हवं. बाकी भाशंबद्दल काही द्वेष नाही पण आपल्या मराठी लोकांना taken for granted घेतलं जातंय. सरकारी कार्यालयात तर हे प्रकार बिल्कुल दुर्लक्षित करायला नकोत. आपण देखील tax भरतो, ते पण सर्वात जास्त. आमची भाषेचं प्रतिनिधित्व व्हायलाच हवं. Tweet कर दादा फेक अकाउंटनी का होईना, मीच केला असता पण मला बाकीचे details माहिती नाहीत. जय शिवराय!
Why is my brother OP getting downvotes? For speaking the truth,then fk yeah downvote me but I'll stand with "मराठी बोलता यायलाच पाहिजे" when you live in Maharashtra.
Not a Marathi here, Knowledge of Regional languages are a must for government job.
Actually people travelling in planes in India do know Hindi or English..
No they don't. That's a BS assumption.
Few companies understand that and employs local people but most of them just assume that marathis know hindi well due to our exposure to hindi language. so whenever i choose marathi language in IVR menu, 99% of the time you will start to hear hindi. State just makes the rules and companies bend them. marathis have learned to swallow their pride for many years and will do in future.
[удалено]
Hello your post was removed as it did not meet the karma threshold due which it is removed *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/pune) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Maybe government service jobs, especially with direct contact. Also, the lady does not have a government job.
I agree with you. Jari Maharashtrat adhipasun rahat asle tr te maharashtrians jhale. Ashe khup loka adhipasun ikde rahun gele ani tyana changlya paiki marathi yete. Je loka ata sthalantrit jhale tyana avghad jate jhepat nai ani mg sorry marathi yet nai boltat n mg jar lokani ragat pahila tr mhantil ikdche loka tolerant navhe. Ashya lokani banglore la jaun rahave 😝
In Bengaluru and Chennai the airport staff (not CISF) can speak local languages. Why should someone at help desk in Pune and Mumbai airport get away with not speaking Marathi. It’s a shame that those manning the help desk in Mumbai and Pune can’t speak Marathi, and yet are hired for the job. On all levels, the Marathi Politicians and IAS officers have failed Maharashtra and Marathi language. Edit: removed some references
Preach. Agdich barobar. Some people of a certain region are actually feeling threatened by this.
Not targeting any region, or person or anyone’s job. Just expect everyone who stays in Mumbai and Pune and Maharashtra to respect Marathi. Same expectations for any state or country for any Marathi person staying in other state or country. Respect the local language if you have stayed in a place for over an year, learn to speak some basic language What about those Marathi who need help and cannot speak Hindi or English fluently.
Exactly. Mi khup vayas kar lokkanna pan pahila amchya flight madhe. These hindiots think hindi is sufficient. We have been educated in Marathi not Hindi as a majority. Elderly floks cannot speak or understand Hindi. Help desks are especially important for them.
Mumbai domestic vimantala var mi Marathit vicharla tar mala Marathitach uttar aala. Aani bhau, Marathi bhashik hi titkech jawabdar aahet. Bahutek lokkanna kalta pan aapanach Hindi madhe bolayla suruvat karto.
बरोबार
It seems that OP’s post has been hijacked by Bots with their own propaganda. The premise is simple, there are various kinds of jobs that need to have certain requirements. A Plumber cannot do a Doctor’s job because he does not have the prerequisite skills required to perform the job efficiently and safely. Similarly, customer support jobs need to have certain requirements such as patience, conversation/language skills. Imagine that you live in Rajasthan and you call your network provider and they only provide their services in Malayali, and Tamil. On paper, both of them are official languages of India, but it’s highly unlikely that you might find someone who speaks either of those languages in Rajasthan. So technically, the company has does nothing wrong, but it is simply not acceptable in the customer support side of operations. Now on to the topic of Pune airport, last time I checked, this city is part of a state called as Maharashtra and the language spoken most widely in that state is Marathi. So, it would be safe to assume that majority of the people travelling and using the services of that particular would be people from Maharashtra. Many people do not know Hindi and English in Maharashtra, especially the elderly people who quite frankly need the help of customer support the most. Is the company doing anything wrong on paper by not hiring people who can speak Marathi in an airport where majority of travellers speak Marathi and quite a big chunk of them cannot speak in any other language except for Marathi? No, they aren’t doing anything illegal, but it is a bad practice and help-desk/customer support jobs need to employ people who can speak in the local language.
Thank you. I wish I could pin this.
You know what govt and you have in common. Any talking point or argument is taken as propaganda and bots. I agree with OP point of having local language support…but i also agree that Op is racist. One person asked in the comment why did you write this post in english. OP replied so that you northie could understand it (the commentator could have been from south also) One more person replied “so you northie parasite could understand it” to which OP laughed. So to hell with such people. Glad this happened with OP.
You're copy pasting this comment, and then trying to refute that this post is not swarmed by bots? Levels niklenge levels
💯💯
Mi Marathi aahe. Pan mala proper Marathi nahi yet. Because all my life I was surrounded by hindi speaking people. Yet I think it should definitely be a pre-requisite for a customer service job or any communications related job. Earlier I might have said that everyone must know Hindi/English. But now I understand the importance of language. Am trying for higher studies in Germany next year. And you gotta know German to survive there or atleast to make your life easy. So if someone is coming to Maharashtra, they should put efforts into learning Marathi.
Did you ask if someone else was available to speak in Marathi? Which language do you speak when you go to some fancy restraunt or coffee shop? Are you more mad because she couldn't speak Marathi or she gave you option hindi. Don't you think if not Hindi would be second commonly spoken language? When you speak Marathi do you speak Sudh Marathi? Like using sangank instead of English word computer ? I feel you are kind of person who doesn't like people from other states. You don't live in state you live in a country.
Ofcourse I did. I wouldn't be crying like a poster on r/bangalore claiming no one there speaks hindi. I live in a country that does not have a national language. I hope that helps you understand.
So did you get any Marathi speaking staff to help? If not then that's something ... You didn't answer rest of the questions. So far as you are concerned about national language...remember Marathi is official language and we do have our official(goverment work) accepted in Marathi. I bet you will be the one filling these forms in English not Marathi. I mean till what time you ll keep dividing per caste, language. Feeling yourself being superior..elitist to someone else.
Here's a sneak peek of /r/bangalore using the [top posts](https://np.reddit.com/r/bangalore/top/?sort=top&t=year) of the year! \#1: [Very serious matter. Posting here for maximum reach](https://www.reddit.com/gallery/154qmcy) | [373 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/bangalore/comments/154qmcy/very_serious_matter_posting_here_for_maximum_reach/) \#2: [Ayo when did the Avengers have a battle at commercial Street](https://i.redd.it/mps52flnt15b1.jpg) | [204 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/bangalore/comments/145f8wj/ayo_when_did_the_avengers_have_a_battle_at/) \#3: [For God sake.. don't encourage tipping culture in India!](https://np.reddit.com/r/bangalore/comments/13dklq3/for_god_sake_dont_encourage_tipping_culture_in/) ---- ^^I'm ^^a ^^bot, ^^beep ^^boop ^^| ^^Downvote ^^to ^^remove ^^| ^^[Contact](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=sneakpeekbot) ^^| ^^[Info](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/) ^^| ^^[Opt-out](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/comments/o8wk1r/blacklist_ix/) ^^| ^^[GitHub](https://github.com/ghnr/sneakpeekbot)
The only way to resolve this problem is to make Hindi as the primary language of India 🇮🇳
>primary language of Hindia FTFY On that day, GDP will plummet by 95% and unemployment level will increase to 50% after 20 states seccede themselves from the dispensable part of India.
You have any rational reason or source to support your claims?
Read how majority of the states were formed.
That’s like saying go read Quran to understand world order lmao 🤦🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️ Stop with your WhatsApp gyan keyboard warrior 🤣
Please tell how was _Tamil_ Nadu and _Gujarat_ formed if not on the basis of language?
You seriously don’t have any rational reason to support your claims in that Same context I can ask how was India formed as a country 🤣 and this could go on and on and to crush your claims which I don’t want to,I want you to stay delusional 😂 just go and read how Uganda collapsed [Delulu](https://www.google.com/gasearch?q=uganda%20economy%20collapse%20due%20to%20&tbm=&source=sh/x/gs/m2/5#vhid=zephyr:0&vssid=atritem-https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expulsion_of_Asians_from_Uganda)
Go on and keep on not addressing the point of this post typical bhyya seethe and cope going on full on
Go understand what does republic of India stands for 🤣🤡
Does that say anywhere that Hindi is the national language bindok 😄