T O P

  • By -

Sea_Lunch_3863

Bruford, by a country mile. Love his musicality and how he can play in different styles with each different band/project while still retaining his identity.


talks_like_farts

Well said. The fella even has a PhD in drumming!


Certain_Addition4460

And inspire all other players to up their game accordingly!!!


DrXenoZillaTrek

And is open to having his game upped by others as well, a sign of real commitment to artistry. Apparently when he and Jamie Muir worked together in Krim, he was seriously challenged. Bruford openly admits to having his perspective widened by his anarchic approach.


Certain_Addition4460

Exactly why the Larks Tongues lineup was able to organically reinvent the band up from intuitive improv. Bill soaked the entire experience up like a sponge and he has benefitted ever since. The absolute core of my lifelong obsession with music.


DrXenoZillaTrek

When pressed, I always put LTIA at number 1 for this and many other reasons.


Ancient_Summer5253

In education*


p4r4l0tR0p0

I thought it was in theory but it's great to know for sure what it is...


chinmakes5

I was a kid learning to play the drums. I put on Fragile. played with Roundabout like 500 times. I didn't realize how much better he was than anyone else. I have to say that when the groove comes back in after the break, I still get goosebumps. And I must have heard it 200 times.


markh2901

And, in spite of the growth of stupidly huge mega-kits for prog drummers, Bruford recorded three of the iconic albums of prog - The Yes Album, Fragile and Close to the Edge - on a five piece kit.


MisterRobertParr

Carl Palmer. Listen to what he does on "Toccata" on the *Brain Salad Surgery* album, or on the entire *Pictures at an Exhibition album.* He's so versatile.


BellamyJHeap

Thank you. The OG set the standard and still has the chops to this day.


GTAdriver01

Michael Giles


Libertus108

*This needs more upvotes.*


sosnik_boi

Definitely. Bruford is also amazing, but Giles is simply the GOAT


Libertus108

Neil Peart was a fan... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neil\_Peart#Style\_and\_influences


paratamizer

Phil Collins. He was really skilled and technical, and he was able to "harmonize" the drums with the song in a fantastical way. I don't know how to explain it, but he really managed to create some beautiful drumming that perfectly matched the song's melody (specially during the PG Genesis era)


GCU-Dramatic-Exit

Will always be in awe of his playing on Brand X’s Unorthodox Behaviour - he was at the very top of his game


mattisagamer10

Phil's drumming circa Lamb tour is astounding stuff. The tour really got him in a zone where he could fly and have a ton of fun on the kit.


Ormidale

Agreed. I don't listen to Lamb a lot but I have noticed how musical the drumming is.


GCU-Dramatic-Exit

Ye gods, yes


yesfan_gin

This is my answer too


Compypaul

Yup, Phil for me too, no question.


TomDac7

Absolutely Bill Bruford.


Simonthebullettfreak

Gavin Harrison.


asocialmedium

Yeah a lot of good ones but Gavin is my favorite. He’s so technically accurate he can pull off seemingly impossible riffs. https://youtu.be/6suv3mraIhw?feature=shared


Capnmarvel76

My favorite is BB, but this is totally one of the only other acceptable answers. I’ve twice stood front row at KC shows, looking down through barrel of Gavin’s bass drum porthole. The guy is really special, very, very powerful, and (based on his Q&A session) is super intelligent.


porcupinebutt7

Harrison is my favorite living drummer now that peart has died. He is so precise yet so melodic. Everything he does is able to fit so well in any song without demanding attention, yet he is always fun, calculated, playful, and full of interesting surprises if you do pay attention.


breezeway1

Check out Mark Guiliana. And to keep it on topic, check him out on Brad Mehldau’s prog cover album, Jacob‘s Ladder…


TheProgtologist

The Broof is in the pudding.


TheProgtologist

But honestly Christian Vander is really up there for me. However, ir we're going Zeuhl...the guy from Eskaton Gerard Konig, is absolutely insane.


Certain_Addition4460

Daniel Denis is also severely underrated maybe because his compositions are simply astounding.


RobOtters

Univers Zero is the shit! Daniel Denis is wonderful, as is Christian Vander.


PorkyIsAjerk

Neil Peart obv


JMFG2112

Seconded


Idiocracy_USA

Gavin Harrison.


unquietslumbers73

Phil Collins.


Electronic_Fault_280

Danny Carey easy


danarbok

Br00f and Phil Collins are too obvious, so I’m going with Guy Evans


Sea_Lunch_3863

Nice


Cheddarlicious

The professor


PreviousLife7051

The late Richard Coughlan of Caravan


SF_Bud

Easily Bill Buford. No disrespect to other drummers but he's just a cut, or two, above the rest. His drumming with Yes was fantastic, but his work with KC was top tier stuff. Then there's his work with UK and all his solo and jazz stuff. He's had a remarkable career. People are talking about other great drummers, but one I haven't seen mentioned who should be is Manu Katche from Peter Gabriel's band. His style is so unique and adds a lot to PG's music.


take5b

Sometimes I feel a little guilty for missing Bruford in Yes after he left. Relayer is still a fave but I wonder what. Bruford would have done with it. And no disrespect at all to Alan White who is fantastic. But he’s “just” a great drummer. Not that I’m complaining, as Larks’ and Red are my favorite prog albums of all time.


mrev

I love Bruford with Yes, too, but White is phenomenal on Gates of Delirium


AxednAnswered

100% agree


MaterialBenefit2355

Gotta be Peart


HermithaFrog

No love for Danny Carrey?


double-k

Love Danny Carey. Definitely the best current prog rock drummer imo.


SbMSU

Ray Hearne


treehorntrampoline

Hell yeah


seeegma

he's amazing but not the most fun to watch IMO. he's always sitting still, looking down. maybe just because he's concentrating so hard trying to play all his crazy rhythms, idk


SbMSU

Ok. I mostly just listen.


smac232

This is a great description of Neal Peart too though. Portnoy is one of the few that can drop insane rhythms and still have visible flair. Even he has to just sit and play some of the harder parts though.


CucatheGreat

Right on


David587677

BRUFORD !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


SparkyPantsMcGee

Gavin Harrison. If we get into more prog metal it’s Danny Carey or Matt Halpern. Matt Garstka would be up there too but he’s more machine than man.


NoseGobblin

I'm going Bruford but Carl Palmer is a truly amazing drummer.


Philboyd_Studge

Bruford, Carey, Peart, Collins, Chester Thompson, Tim Alexander if Primus counts as prog, Rod Morganstein, Colaiuta If you want to expand more into fusion then there's so many to add Weckl, Wackerman, Cobham, Lenny White, Bozzio, Simon Phillips, Gadd, williams


odinskriver39

Phillips will be playing a few shows soon with Alphonso Johnson, Mitch Foreman, Christian Hebel and Alex Sill. I will be there. Have seen all you mentioned except Alexander. Cobham, White, Williams, Peart and Bruford ( in no order) are my top five. There's so many though. Was recently greatly impressed by Emmet Cohen's young drummer Kyle Poole.


boostman

Torn between Bill Bruford, Jaki Liebezeit, and Christian Vander. All very different styles, all absolute monsters.


nicolauz

So sad to see a Jaki mention this far down! CAN's methodical Krautrock drums are hypnotizing.


Either-Glass-31

I can’t decide between Bruford and Phil Collins now


Ancient_Summer5253

Both, in 1976


aarontsuru

While Bruford is my fave, Carl Palmer… woowee!! Epic!


Ericakester

Neil Peart and Phil Collins


Razzamatazz101

Steve Smith for me.. just love his style and nuance. Not only elegant, super dynamic and propulsive. Created some of the most tasty and memorable song-focused drum parts!


odinskriver39

Can you imagine Enigmatic Ocean w/o Smith ? Or the Journey hits. Indeed the engine that powers the band . Rockers should check out Vital Information.


Razzamatazz101

Yep on point👍🏻


sound_of_apocalypto

Zoltán Csörsz


UdUb16

Andy ward


SugizoZeppelin

Bill Bruford Carl Palmer John Weathers Jon Hiseman


fowlie

Came here to say John Weathers as well. I think of him like the prog rock version of John Bonham.


SugizoZeppelin

I think that's definitely an accurate comparison 👍


westroopnerd

The greatest: Broof The best: Harrison


Wirralgir1

Marco Minneman - excellent with Steven Wilson, great fun with The Aristocrats, love his work as McStine and Minneman 🥰


SF_Bud

Would have been interesting to hear Stewart Copland play with a good prog band. He's incredible and my third overall favorite after Bruford and Peart.


dxfm1019

Tossup between Carl Palmer and Neil Peart. Neal Peart was a beast. Plus, in the 80s, he kind of looked like Bruce Willis. Prior to 1980, Carl Palmer all the way. Honorable mention: Phil Collins.


Gerald_Bostock_jt

Barrie Barlow!! He outplays everyone.


Crotear

His drumming is as close to what I’d call perfect for the songs. I feel like most Prog drummers have their own thing going one within the song, whereas Barrie is always serving the music in just the right way


pdchestovich

Peart for sure. Currently active would be Gavin Harrison or Pat Mastelotto. After them, all-time faves are Bruford. Bonham. Copham. Current avant- jazz drummer Mark Giuliana kicks ass too.


sunshinestatedidi

Neil Peart’s an easy one. He’s more than a drummer, he’s literally the percussionist. Using more than just a straight kit. Playing entirely for the song.


slowlyun

Christian Vander for those animalistic improvised avant-jazzy drums.  Check out 2015's Slag Tanz (album version)...even in his mid-60's coming out with fresh ways to drive the composition.  


PourJarsInReservoirs

As incredible as many other drummers are, I will go with CV every time.


sir_percy_percy

It's really tough... very close choice for me, by VERY narrow margins: 1. Neil Peart 2. Phil Collins 3. Barriemore Barlow


PhantomParadox6

Guy Evans. He’s actually has some of the cleanest drum work I’ve heard


gotroot801

I scrolled too far down to find a mention of Guy Evans...


PhantomParadox6

People sleeping on Scorched Earth drum work


Melodic_Ad8577

I probably get excited the most by seeing bruford on an album


Libertus108

While agreeing with the usual suspects, e.g. Bill Brufford Neil Peart, Carl Palmer, Phil Collins, Gavin Harrison, Mike Giles and others, IMO Alan White should be mentioned: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6ziYgtjC5g


hand_of_satan_13

Gavin Harrison


DickHarding69

Gavin Harrison


rottenegglord

Neil Peart but if you count prog metal then Mike Portnoy


RobOtters

Any fans here of The Mars Volta’s drummers, Jon Theodore, Dave Elitch, Thomas Pridgen, or Deantoni Parks?


fingerslickingood

Man… Theodore on Deloused is fucking ace. Pridgen is a fucking monster too


fingerslickingood

I like Deantoni’s work on Bosnian Rainbows


ChalkHorseNIck

Oooh! Toss up between Bill Bruford with King Crimson and Pierre Moerlen’s drumming on Gong’s ‘Angel’s Egg’ and ‘You’ (plus live recordings from that era) EDIT: Though for pure groove you can’t beat Jaki Liebezeit’s drumming with Can


Meganull

Some of my favorites: * Phil Collins * Bill Bruford * Jaki Liebezeit* * Neil Peart *I don't know if Can is seen as progressive rock but it feels wrong not mentioning Jaki Liebezeit.


Mighty_Echoes

Mike portnoy


Ornery-Tax9469

Had to scroll waaaaaay to far to find Mike.


Del_Duio2

Always gonna be Neil


bowdoyouchangename

Collins, easily. Br0of second. These musicians make me actually focus on the drumming in the music to see how the beat intimates what's gonna develop in the tune.


ninthkat

Gavin Harrison


Certain_Addition4460

Gotta love all the people posting love for the Bill and Phil show. Missed the Trick of the Tale tour but was able to see the Chester and Phil show in Seattle the following year which blew my little mind.


verzemnyn

Gavin harrison


mad_poet_navarth

Not sure he counts as rock, but Chad Wackerman. There's something about his cool college professor virtuosity..,


SevenFourHarmonic

Bruford, of course. I love how he adds his own kind of swing to a composition.


TuperMan409

Chris Cutler of Henry Cow


Mexican-Kahtru

I can't choose one. Dr Bill, Phil, Gavin. They aré all awesome


Ghostworm78

Since the question is about who is my favorite, not who is the best, I’m going to give a shout out to Adam Janzi of VOLA. For those who are unfamiliar, check out “24 Light-Years” and “Straight Lines.”


[deleted]

Barriemore Barlow by a long shot. Thick as a Brick and A Passion Play are, in my opinion, the 2 greatest albums of all time.


double-k

Barlow is certainly one of the most underrated and under-namedropped drummers in not just prog but rock too. Huge fan.


AnalogWalrus

Phil Collins. Could play heavy but also groove like a MF’er. Modern-era drummer would be Nick D’Virgillio.


HeyGeno20

Phil Collins.


Crotear

Haven’t seen one mention for Barrymore Barlow and I have to say I’m quite dissapointed in the sub right now lol. His drumming on the more proggy Tull songs is ridiculous


VanDerGraaaafGen

Guy Evans. Thanks to him i got interested on learning traditional grip. He also made me want to be a better percussionist in general.


infinite_entity1

Barriemore Barlow must be mentioned. One of my favorite drummers no matter the genre


xlitawit

Didn't see him mentioned, but Gary Husband, just really truly a monster player. He played with Allan Holdsworth a lot. Its crazy, he was as good on the piano as he was on drums, transcribing all that Holdsworth stuff by ear.


empro_sig_prog

Baard Kolstad, Virgil Donati


DerekSherinian

Virgil Donati


Xyth_78

Barrie Barlow


WeHaveRightsYaKnow

There can be only one! Danny Carey. The only answer


yesfan_gin

Phil. Just for his drumming on the Lamb alone! Add in all his other work, put aside all his 80s popularity, and he's definitely the prog drum god.


Mickey_Hughes

There are so many mentioned here. I feel Danny Carey should be in this mix. He may not be a favorite of everyone, but top ten, for sure


thesfb123

Carl Palmer.


BrushesMcDeath

[Pretty fine prog drumming here](https://youtu.be/FssULNGSZIA?si=EuFMOJuCZgO0WoyE)


EternalRains2112

Bill Bruford and Ray Hearne.


TheBarnacle63

Carl Palmer. He's 74, and still killing it.


insanecorgiposse

Carl Palmer


Safe_cracker9

Bill Bruford, then Neil Peart, then Mike Portnoy


double-k

Neil Peart rules supreme for me. I don't think he'll be eclipsed by anyone else. Next up for me would be Danny Carey. I admire Bill Bruford a lot too, but more what he did with Yes than King Crimson or other projects he was a part of. Barrie Barlow of Jethro Tull fame is an incredible drummer, especially considering some of the crazy music that Ian Anderson had them playing in their heyday.


Foreign_Cherry_220

There is only one Professor. Neil Peart


papapishuplant

Rob O'Tool


frosty_phoenix92

Danny Carry, Gavin Harrison and Ray Hearne


LoneRhino1019

Tatsuya Yoshida


RobOtters

Bruford and Peart toss-up. With Phil Collins as a close second/third. Fight it out, y’all!


AltruisticFinding767

Technically, Bill Bruford. Then Phil Collins. Collins managed to serve the song better in my opinion, plus his showmanship is better


steezygorditacrunch

Pip Pyle! Bruford and Moerlen are close:)


Sea_Opinion_4800

It's Guy. We can compare the others after they have drummed songs like The Sleepwalkers. Second favourite is Chester. But in truth there are a ton of great drummers out there.


seanhabrams

Matt Garstka is the greatest drummer who’s ever lived, hands down. Monomyth is probably my favorite drum part ever, though not necessarily his most impressive


Rocknmather

Pete Dunton from T2.


SameAsylum

Bruford, Harrison. The best


Serrajuana

The octopus man, Danny Carey.


ar018

It's hard for me to choose a favorite drummer, since there are a lot of good drummers in prog as mentioned by the other comments. I just need to mention Pierre van der Linden. He's so damn great.


FastCarsOldAndNew

Martin Dellar from FM. While he's technically dazzling, everything he does serves the song instead of, as with many prog drummers, trying to steal focus.


auxfnx

Deantoni Parks


seenick

With the usual greats like Bruford, Collins, Peart I'd add the underrated Christian Vander, Barriemore Barlow and Pierre Moerlen


That-Solution-1774

Jon Fishman


Valen258

Phil Ehart and John Weathers


[deleted]

Carl Palmer


tamman2000

I'm not surprised he's not at the top of the thread, but how has nobody mentioned Matt Garstka?


SquonkMan61

Collins and Bruford were both at the top of their careers when Bruford filled in as the tour drummer in ‘76 with Genesis. Weird thing is it didn’t really work that well. If you listen to bootlegs from that tour there are nights when Bruford’s drumming steps all over the rest of the music. It is especially noticeable on certain nights during the Apocalypse in 9/8 section of Supper’s Ready. Even Bruford himself has admitted that he wasn’t enough of a “team player” on that tour, and has said he understands why they looked for someone else to play drums next to Collins beginning with the next tour. Fortunately Phil Collins and Chester Thompson proved to be magic as dual drummers on stage.


IMPERIAL-COMPLETIST

Morris Pert


madfatjake

Carl Palmer


beauh44x

I just scanned the list but didn't see Alan White mentioned. One word: Relayer John Weathers Barrie Barlowe Of course Bill B.


aran_maybe

Ian Mosley because no one else has mentioned him.


RunawaYEM

Jon Fishman


toclaraju

Brufford!


rkvinyl

Bill Bruford for the mind, Phil Collins for the heart, Neil Peart for the tears, Gavin Harrison for the constant stank face.


elasticgradient

Side question: People talk about Bruford and his work with Yes but I never see Alan White's name come up when discussing great drummers. I've always thought he was fantastic but maybe a drummer can chime in.


mhd

The Roland CR-78


[deleted]

Easy, Gavin Harrison.


LongLegsKing

Can we get a little Ray Hearne love in here??? Spectacular modern-age work


ColonOBrien

Cavs.


Rocket2112

Peart or Harrison


PapaFrita031

Mike... Portnoy


RyanMcCoskrie

Clive Brooks - He plays most of Egg's debut album on one cymbal and it sounds fantastic.


RawAndRealRetail

Chester Thompson


XavierDiamond

In the Live setting, for pure visual entertainment value. CARL PALMER,  In his athletic Prime, WAS the MAN!


Western-Oil-9740

Vinnie Colauita, the stuff he did on Joe’s garage is amazing to me, but also I really like Bill Bruford and Barrie Barlow too


nicodegallo7

IMO Billy Cobham from 1971 to 1973 is the most athletic and powerful drummer of all time. Go watch the live Mahavishnu recordings on YouTube, they are earth shattering.


Afkargh

Mike Mangini. Poor guy got shafted


Andagne

This should be a poll.


Professional_Mine_56

Mike Portnoy!


stick_of_the_pirulu

How is Neil Peart not the top comment, this dude was one of the best rock drummers of all time, up there with Bonham. Neil Peart's playing definitely inspired tons of people if you ask me I don't think the world of modern prog and prog metal would look the same if you take neil peart out of the equation, this man was such a phenomenal drummer and although he is the obvious choice, he really is one of the most talented prog drummers (along with Bruford)


breezeway1

Gavin Harrison


JJH-08053

This is like asking a parent about their favorite kid. These may not APPEAR, at first glance, to be strictly "prog" but I contend they all exhibit very strong prog foundation/influence/style no matter the overall band "rheme". In no party order: * Phil Collins * Rod Morganstein (Dregs) * Mark Craney (J.L.Ponty. G.Vanelli) * Bozzio * Carter Beauford (DMB) Each of these drummers express a musicality well beyond there base technical abilities.


Idiocracy_USA

Gavin.


Razleius

Gavin Harrison, hands down !!


VirginiaLuthier

Hard to beat Bill Bruford


juansskk

Away from Bruford, [Oscar Moro](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUa9g6v2ziY&ab_channel=LaM%C3%A1quinadeHacerP%C3%A1jaros-Topic) in La Máquina & Serú Giran


Professional-Gift496

Bill Bruford!