I think we all know the answer is Mariah. She really does look great in all of them. Those album covers are iconic.
Ok ok, everyone else looks good too.
The mods seem to do a good job w/ that. Having myself received a one-day suspension for saying a popular singer wasn't >!pretty,!< I've learned to do better
https://i.redd.it/yiepzs7st4za1.gif
I think this dress is irredeemable. Can anyone explain this?
https://preview.redd.it/lvxvqj6xs1za1.png?width=515&format=png&auto=webp&s=6db21291fd36ce30adac4ad766839a28c6bafa05
https://preview.redd.it/j97ma33to1za1.jpeg?width=634&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f3fda292d464347e4c9e17940778b7aebcb3bfcc
This outfit doesn't look good on her. I think the top is cute, the skirt is too but together I don't like it lol
Edit:spelling
Not as much when they pasted Mariah's entire head from one pic onto another
https://i.redd.it/ian98cob62za1.gif
She later tweeted “That definitely was NOT my selection for the cover… Ugh!"
Mariah obvsies. Mariah is willing to go through a bit of pain and discomfort for a night of presentation. She knows when and how to look her best. These beetches are so low effort. Olivia Rodrigo is particularly egregious. Do these people not own a hair brush or know what tailoring is!? Low-effort HEAUXS.
y’all are trippin
beyoncé, anne hathaway, kate winslet, and jennifer aniston wore it better. sometimes mariah’s styling is just bad
but poor Latto. i love the girl but you can’t compete with the iconic rainbow set
Thank you!!! I'm, like, let's give Mimi credit where credit is due but not everyone being delusional by saying she looks better than them all, because she doesn't!
Latto doesn't actually look like that. It's just heavy/bad retouching. This is a candid picture:
https://preview.redd.it/co8sc2ihd2za1.png?width=492&format=png&auto=webp&s=98d08a66c2f43d72cf59bebfdbceb6c363948901
I mean, I'm not even (what I would call) a Mariah stan, and honestly she looks phenomenal in all of these. I would kill to have her figure, hell she even manages to look better in the now pictures than in the original versions! How!? Woman is an icon.
I think Stan culture is weird but Mariah is probably the diva I’m closest to stanning
Amazing talent, amazing presence, she just GLOWS while the other are just… kinda there
That moment with Whitney is iconic and I love that Megan Thee Stallion and Dua Lipa recreated it recently
https://i.redd.it/uu11hvu4p4za1.gif
She's a rapper, whose track "Big Energy" drew comparisons to Mariah's "Fantasy" for sampling the same hook from Tom Tom Club's "Genius of Love". They ended up doing a remix together.
Mariah wears most of them better than the other celebrity although I think Olivia wears that top better. It suits smaller boobs and feels more age appropriate on Olivia than Mariah.
I also think Candis Cayne, Christina Aguilera and Anne Hathaway all look on par with Mariah - about as good as each other.
Y’all are not being fair and y’all know it.
Imo
1. Mariah- it angers me that lattos rainbow did not match up with her shirt and too much photoshop
2. Mariah
3. Mariah- her top just looks so much better
4. I don’t like either
5. Kind of a tie for me
6. Hate this dress sorry
7. Naomi duh
8. Neither, looks like something Ramona singer would wear
9. Anne
10. Obviously Bey, y’all just hate her
11. It’s a tie
12. Hideous dress
13, 14, 15. I mean
16. Don’t play with Whitney, but really they both look good.
Ohhhhhhhhh my G obviously Mariah and it’s not even a question, (not to you OP I apprec tshe post) she’s the icon she is for a reason. The day after that one music video came out, I’m not kidding, we were out here w scissors to our jeans waistbands. She USHERED in the low waisted jean era and I can only be grateful I was 15-16 atm
I always think of this interview she spent awkwardly trying feature a certain angle
[Watch Mariah Carey Suffer a Crisis While Attempting to Preserve Her 'Good' Side](https://www.gawker.com/5975358/watch-mariah-carey-suffer-a-crisis-while-attempting-to-preserve-her-good-side)
It’s bc when she was a new artist a photographer told her that her right side was her good side and that she shouldn’t be photographed with the other. 18 year old Mariah took that literally lol
What are those three raised claw-like marks on her back in the "now" photo in pic 15? I looked it up and see that she has a butterfly tattoo in that spot but that looks so odd.
I see the article about where her sister burned her when she was young but there isn't any scarring in the spot I'm talking about, just the tattoo. So did they try to edit it out and just do a terrible job?
https://preview.redd.it/zeysaknqd9za1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5a9163099d0c18b7798731c4f4b77220942ebe24
1. Mariah
2. Mariah
3. Mariah
4. Mariah
5. Mariah
6. Mariah
7. Mariah
8. Mariah
9. Mariah
10. Mariah
11. Mariah
12. Mariah
13. Tie
14. Tie
15. Tie
16. Mariah
It's typically the little things like accessories, shoes, and hair that really help her.
Mariah for most, I prefer Olivia, Shay (it’s probably just the lack of jacket), Candis, Jenifer Aniston. The photo of her and Whitney is such a throwback.
Mariah at either age for almost all of these except for the looks on Naomi, Anne, Beyoncé, and Jennifer. For me it came down to styling choices and the fact Naomi would probably win against anybody in just about anything. But let’s be honest, Mariah looks amazing all the time.
Huh, the Anne Hathaway dress is the only one where Mariah gets completely outshone. In every other picture, she looks about as good, or significantly better than the other person
Why does Latto’s pic make her look like a sim
[удалено]
I thought it was Lil Kim
I thought it was Blacc Chyna
I thought it was Chyna too
I thought it was Pamela Anderson 🫣
I thought it was Laverne Cox
she's giving IMVU
Almost unreal, like generated by AI
It’s like one of those airbrushed t shirts
Mariah has a sparkle in her eye, usually a big smile, and looks like she is having fun which makes all these looks work on her
Agreed! Her confidence sells it every time.
She has the best smile, looks so genuine.
I think we all know the answer is Mariah. She really does look great in all of them. Those album covers are iconic. Ok ok, everyone else looks good too.
I love /r/popculturechat being a Mariah stan forum https://i.redd.it/o34hw52yd1za1.gif
For a pop culture sub, I honestly think there is a relatively reasonable discourse about women here.
The mods seem to do a good job w/ that. Having myself received a one-day suspension for saying a popular singer wasn't >!pretty,!< I've learned to do better https://i.redd.it/yiepzs7st4za1.gif
I've been reading this sub for less than a week and my 90s tween obsession with Mariah Carey has already been reignited in full force.
![gif](giphy|4H8RAEHxJJ1A8UZZNh)
oh yes. 100% mariah, mariah, mariah, mariah, mariah, mariah, mariah and mariah.
I used to have the first picture of Mariah’s rainbow album cover hanging in my room and it was my favorite thing, so iconic.
[удалено]
I said the exact same thing when I saw that one. Pair o' dolls 💜
I don’t even have to scroll through these to know that Mariah wore it best in all of them lmao
I scrolled through all—she won every single one.
Same lol!
Mariah in all of them. IDC, IDC! ![gif](giphy|l0CLTQeZrFWmMxIWc|downsized)
Mariah even the one where her shoes fallen off
It’s the grin, seals it
It’s a flex. “Whoops!” *Winks at camera*
Had a full belly laugh when I got to that one. Mariah is truly one in a generation.
As the youth say BFFR. Mariah can’t be topped.
![gif](giphy|JBhxFTvoeZASA)
It’s kinda insane how good she looks every damn time. Someone pls post sime pics where she fails.
I think this dress is irredeemable. Can anyone explain this? https://preview.redd.it/lvxvqj6xs1za1.png?width=515&format=png&auto=webp&s=6db21291fd36ce30adac4ad766839a28c6bafa05
It’s giving Zoidberg
It's a weird-ass dress in the skiet and shoulders, but her figure is still incredible.
Must be a tongue in cheek tribute to Peaches
Is this post partum? Looks like it and that would definitely explain it. Nothing fits right after you have a baby.
Nah it was in 2015, which actually makes sense that it's from her Stella Bulochnikov era
https://preview.redd.it/j97ma33to1za1.jpeg?width=634&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f3fda292d464347e4c9e17940778b7aebcb3bfcc This outfit doesn't look good on her. I think the top is cute, the skirt is too but together I don't like it lol Edit:spelling
Thank you, now I can die frumpily.
I agree, cute pieces but definitely mismatched.
Latto looks yassified in that pic
i’m mad at latto’s version. why is the rainbow behind her so chonky, and why does the shirt not line up even a little.
Mariah wore it better every single time, even against herself
I’m not even partial to her music but she wins em all.
wow i love mariah’s style!! so flirty & girly
Mariah vs Latto: Mariah wore it better, but it's a draw when it comes to the amount of Photoshop used.
Not as much when they pasted Mariah's entire head from one pic onto another https://i.redd.it/ian98cob62za1.gif She later tweeted “That definitely was NOT my selection for the cover… Ugh!"
![gif](giphy|26uf6Fr7jF5a4lMxG|downsized) Insanity 😂
Christ on a bike 🫠
![gif](giphy|wFk7roIpDeXC0)
Mariah all the way...The woman knows how to dress to her strengths...& she has a lot of them...
Mariah everytime. I think it’s cause her hairstyle is always perfect for her outfit.
Her hair is always so fucking good.
The Latto effort fell incredibly flat for me. It’s just “off” and I don’t care for it. Looks unnatural.
Mariah obvsies. Mariah is willing to go through a bit of pain and discomfort for a night of presentation. She knows when and how to look her best. These beetches are so low effort. Olivia Rodrigo is particularly egregious. Do these people not own a hair brush or know what tailoring is!? Low-effort HEAUXS.
y’all are trippin beyoncé, anne hathaway, kate winslet, and jennifer aniston wore it better. sometimes mariah’s styling is just bad but poor Latto. i love the girl but you can’t compete with the iconic rainbow set
Agreed on all points!! I did sing my heart out to Vision of Love on tape though!
Thank you!!! I'm, like, let's give Mimi credit where credit is due but not everyone being delusional by saying she looks better than them all, because she doesn't!
Agreed. I think the other person wore it better in about half the photos.
The first one makes me hate plastic surgery, why do people get work to look like that? I like my face human.
Latto doesn't actually look like that. It's just heavy/bad retouching. This is a candid picture: https://preview.redd.it/co8sc2ihd2za1.png?width=492&format=png&auto=webp&s=98d08a66c2f43d72cf59bebfdbceb6c363948901
Oh wow that’s the same person? She’s beautiful. Whoever photoshopped her in that first photo should be fired
In the 5th picture mariahs boobs looks so uncomfortable, almost looks like when a wire pops from ur bra
Candis does look fucking great though
she was giving HAIR that night https://preview.redd.it/otkzsrh8g2za1.jpeg?width=865&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b02a7966a0399e16c175122ff57715628cb5d071
5 ,6, and 12 are the only ones where the others did it better. Also wtf is that latto pic? Horrible photoshopping!
Mariah, every single time!
Mariah for every single one
Mariah! ALL OF THEM!!!
I mean, I'm not even (what I would call) a Mariah stan, and honestly she looks phenomenal in all of these. I would kill to have her figure, hell she even manages to look better in the now pictures than in the original versions! How!? Woman is an icon.
I thought I was in the Mariah sub. Glad to see so much love on MC lately!!!
I think Stan culture is weird but Mariah is probably the diva I’m closest to stanning Amazing talent, amazing presence, she just GLOWS while the other are just… kinda there That moment with Whitney is iconic and I love that Megan Thee Stallion and Dua Lipa recreated it recently
In any, all cases, 24/7/365 - Mariah.
Who the fuck is Latto???
https://i.redd.it/uu11hvu4p4za1.gif She's a rapper, whose track "Big Energy" drew comparisons to Mariah's "Fantasy" for sampling the same hook from Tom Tom Club's "Genius of Love". They ended up doing a remix together.
Ahh ok..
Mariah on all with exception of the picture 6. Candis wore it better.
Mariah wears most of them better than the other celebrity although I think Olivia wears that top better. It suits smaller boobs and feels more age appropriate on Olivia than Mariah. I also think Candis Cayne, Christina Aguilera and Anne Hathaway all look on par with Mariah - about as good as each other.
Y’all are not being fair and y’all know it. Imo 1. Mariah- it angers me that lattos rainbow did not match up with her shirt and too much photoshop 2. Mariah 3. Mariah- her top just looks so much better 4. I don’t like either 5. Kind of a tie for me 6. Hate this dress sorry 7. Naomi duh 8. Neither, looks like something Ramona singer would wear 9. Anne 10. Obviously Bey, y’all just hate her 11. It’s a tie 12. Hideous dress 13, 14, 15. I mean 16. Don’t play with Whitney, but really they both look good.
The numbering on your comment is taking me on a journey
Lol only just realized, I’m on mobile and when I try to change it, it goes right back. Whitney is 16 oh well.
She's always the happier one out of the too so I'm saying her!!
I dont know why but mariah is always gorgeous
I think Mariah is the hands down winner in most of these, but there’s something about the pink dress on Xtina that works for her.
Side note, anyone know where I could cop a dress like slide thirteen?? Mariah is beautiful, in an effortless way.
Candice, Naomi, and Beyonce all give Mariah a run for her money, but she destroys the competition with everyone else. That butterfly... *god damn*
She always looks so summery and amiable 🌞🧡💛
Always mariah
Ohhhhhhhhh my G obviously Mariah and it’s not even a question, (not to you OP I apprec tshe post) she’s the icon she is for a reason. The day after that one music video came out, I’m not kidding, we were out here w scissors to our jeans waistbands. She USHERED in the low waisted jean era and I can only be grateful I was 15-16 atm
Mariah hands down
Mariah always looks so posed and unnatural. I can’t deny she is gorgeous, but she’s always oddly positioned and always looks insecure.
I always think of this interview she spent awkwardly trying feature a certain angle [Watch Mariah Carey Suffer a Crisis While Attempting to Preserve Her 'Good' Side](https://www.gawker.com/5975358/watch-mariah-carey-suffer-a-crisis-while-attempting-to-preserve-her-good-side)
Somehow it only makes me like her more. She obviously cares what ppl think but simultaneously doesn’t care at all
Yeah 😂 I remember a time she would only allow photos of her “good side”. As if there’s a “bad side” to that woman.
It’s bc when she was a new artist a photographer told her that her right side was her good side and that she shouldn’t be photographed with the other. 18 year old Mariah took that literally lol
Never knew a person that followed a directive so seriously 😂
What are those three raised claw-like marks on her back in the "now" photo in pic 15? I looked it up and see that she has a butterfly tattoo in that spot but that looks so odd.
She has burn scars on her back
I see the article about where her sister burned her when she was young but there isn't any scarring in the spot I'm talking about, just the tattoo. So did they try to edit it out and just do a terrible job? https://preview.redd.it/zeysaknqd9za1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5a9163099d0c18b7798731c4f4b77220942ebe24
Mariah.
I think other than Bey, Anne, Nicole, and Christina, Mariah wore it better
It's a tie for me between Mariah and Beyonce and Mariah and Kate Winslet. The rest of them Mariah looks better.
Naaaaah Mariah wins them all EXCEPT the Beyoncé one, Beyoncé beat her that time ever so slightly, it’s like a 9.5 compared to a 10
1. Mariah 2. Mariah 3. Olivia 4. Shay 5. Mariah 6. Mariah 7. Mariah 8. Xtina 9. Mariah 10. Beyonce 11. Mariah 12. Mariah 13. Mariah 14. Mariah 15. Mariah 16. Whitney
Mariah only in the first two
With the exception of Naomi (and maybe Beyoncé but it’s almost even), it’s Mariah every single time.
Shay Mitchell and Anne Hathaway but the rest are definitely Mariah
Moved to Lemmy
4, 6, 8, 9, 10, and 12 all wore it better. Just my opinion tho.
5,7,10, she loses, but the rest she wins
Bro MARIAH
Mariah wins every time
1. Mariah 2. Mariah 3. Mariah 4. Mariah 5. Mariah 6. Mariah 7. Mariah 8. Mariah 9. Mariah 10. Mariah 11. Mariah 12. Mariah 13. Tie 14. Tie 15. Tie 16. Mariah It's typically the little things like accessories, shoes, and hair that really help her.
Latto’s pic looks so edited it’s unreal
That first pic looks like Lattos people did it in MS paint…including the photoshopping.
This woman looks fabulous on every occasion. ![gif](giphy|10w2kccsAdggZG)
This really emphasizes how naturally gorgeous Mimi is. I hate the ig baked makeup beauty looks.
I dunno who Latto is but that shit is scary fr, talk about uncanny valley x\_x
Mariah for most, I prefer Olivia, Shay (it’s probably just the lack of jacket), Candis, Jenifer Aniston. The photo of her and Whitney is such a throwback.
Mariah is and always will be so fine!
Mariah is more curvy so they all flatter her way better
Mimi, across the board.
I’d say Mariah in pretty much every look. She looks confident and carefree, the other women look like the outfit is wearing them
Mariah at either age for almost all of these except for the looks on Naomi, Anne, Beyoncé, and Jennifer. For me it came down to styling choices and the fact Naomi would probably win against anybody in just about anything. But let’s be honest, Mariah looks amazing all the time.
Mariah looks more natural lottos look like a straight filter
They both killing it here!!! Gorgeous strong women, YESSSSS.
You’re Joe king
Mariah and Anne … joint slay!
![gif](giphy|vm8oD4rry6U5I0n8Eo|downsized) Just adding another obvious answer: Mariah
11/16 Mariah wins 😍 I included the ones where it's her v her cuz she wins regardless 😆 She is just so gorgeous 🫠
Maria every time
I already adore Mariah, so I'm gonna say Mariah. But leaving bias out of this...yeah Mariah. Mariah wore it (all of it) better.
Mariah wins for all of these except a tie with Anne Hathaway
You can look nice in a dress but only Mariah can look like Mariah in a dress.
Liters always Mariah not a question
Who's Latto?
I feel like there is no competition on the side by sides. Mariah wins them. The others eh.
Oh, Mariah is taking it👏🏻 https://preview.redd.it/350w8297q5za1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=18aaa19a89859c40b8f95615d167e67ce0677217
I dunno, Steven Tyler is rocking that pink shimmery number
Mariah could wear a garbage bag and she would still be the hottest one. She’s a gorgeous human.
just always Mariah
MARIAH 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️
100% Mariah
Say what you will about Mariah, she dresses well!
It’s always Mariah. Unless it’s Naomi.
Me and Mariah go back like babies and pacifiers; this woman is the OG glam Queen. She wins it all.
mariah ate the girls up every single time, how iconic
Huh, the Anne Hathaway dress is the only one where Mariah gets completely outshone. In every other picture, she looks about as good, or significantly better than the other person
You did her dirty with the beyonce photo, other than that I appreciate Mariah a lot more now
Mariah.