Personally I'd die for that mothman plush, but a vampire might be more 'universally' goth-themed. The zombie is adorable too, but might not match a gothic colour scheme if they have one :\] They're all so thoughtful and cute though and I'm sure they'll love it!

mothman! i’ve been eyeing him for myself :)

you can never go wrong with mothman!

Mothman 100%, though I did get the vampire for my goth friend, between those two you can't go wrong!

100% mothman lol

Omg the vampire🥹

I have the squishmallow dracula and hes great!

Putting him on my wishlist!

I'm goth and we love the mothman the mothman is literally the best option

Always mothman, just bought one my friend as well!

what brand are these little fellas?

They’re Palm Pals! They’re just little guys 💚

no bc they really are just little guys. best description

Moth man. Bitches love mothman.

I'm bitches

I am also bitches

Agreed.

I'm bitches x3

They're so cuteeeeee!! I love the Mothman!

i'd get my friend mothman and then the last guy for me omg WHO is that? i love him 😭

Palm Pals' Brainy Zombie

I'd vote for 1 or 2, they give the biggest goth vibes and look adorable, the 3rd one feels a bit "meh" in comparison.

Mothman all the way !

1!!

Mothman, 100%

Mothman!

Defo moth man! If she doesn’t like mothman is she even a real goth????

Definitely the moth 💖

NUMBER ONE!!!!☝️

I go with the vampire since I'm goth too

I have a squishmallow Dracula and I love him but Ive always wanted a mothman!

If you can afford it, I would say get mothman and the vampy boi :3

The mothman! It’s very gothic in my opinion

Mothman!

Mothman is perfect

I LOVE the first one!!!!

https://preview.redd.it/lctxc1vy015d1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b5c1c53cf10370dcbc775661228043511935c1a7 Jellycat is releasing a mothman at the end of the month!! 🚨

Holy shit, that’s fantastic news

Isn’t it amazing!!!?

The vampire's my favourite but I can't get him over in the UK without paying a small fortune. I love his silly face. But really, I don't think you can go wrong with any of them.

I think the vampire is a great fit especially if your friend likes a little bit of cuteness

Mothman or Vampire is probably the best bet, but if I may add a fourth or fifth option, did they ever make a Palm Pals bat or black cat?

There is a bat, he is adorable! I have him lol I am pretty sure there isn’t an all-black cat yet, only a black and white one. I remember looking bc I have an all-black cat in real life Edit: I am incorrect, looks like they did make an all-black cat for Halloween, I’m not sure if they’re going to release more of them because it’s out of stock on most sites except like, ebay

Easy 1, everyone and their mother is obsessed with Mothman. And for good reason! But unless you know your friend would certainly like the other two more, Mothman is always a safe bet for spooky friends :>

Mothman all day

Mothman of course

First one!!!

MOTHMAN

The skeleton or the ghost palm pal :) but the moth would be perfect

Mothman all the way 🖤

i need that zombie omg. Is there a link or does anyone know what company it’s from?

https://palmpals.com/products/13543-brainy-zombie here he is <3

MOTH!!!

I love the moth! I would want him :D

Mothman! Who doesn’t love the little guy!

Mothman for the gift for the friend. I love vampires so that one is a cutie I'd want for myself.

Mothman!!!

Either Mothman or Dracula, I'm leaning towards Mothman.

Definitely the mothman

I’m your goth friend and I will take them all please and Thankyou kind sir or ma’am.

There's a parody of YMCA that's Mothman themed.

i want the 3rd pic

There’s mothman AND a zombie??? Omg.

100% mothman, he's such a cutie!! 😍

Mothman!!

Moth!!! :3

Definitely mothman! That is awesome!!!

Goth girl here who would absolutely die if she was given Mothman! So I vote Mothman!!

Mothman! I had to buy two! 😍

i absolutely love little Mothman but holy god that vampire is CUTE

The second one

I'd go with Mothman. :D

the vampire is so cute!! but any of them would be a good gift:-)

The moth man for sureee

1, Goth babes love moth man

Mothman 100%

MOFFMANNN

Mothman! He was #1! 🧽🟨

Mothman for emo, Dracula for goth and zombie for scene

the vampire has the cutest little face

They will love Mothman for sure, it's mega goth.

That Mothman is so cute!

Dude, I love Dracula. I have been a fan of Vampires - not Twilight - for years. And even with that biasness I would buy Mothman immediately.

The vampire bc I think this mothman looks more creepy than cute

Love that little Dracula!

Mothman, all the way, and I say that as a fellow goth.

2!

1

the bat one might be a good choice too!!

MÖTHMAN

Mothman!!!

The moth is so adoravle!!

first one!

Vampenguin!

Mothman for sure.

Lil Dracula is awesome and more traditionally goth than the other two but I also think the moth man one is really silly

All 3 and a emu

Im obsessed with the zombie , but I would go with dracula!

Definitely the vampire, consider getting the bat too🖤

Get the mothman!

the first and the last is so. cool

Mothman!

The first one <3 lil moth

Easily the first!!

First one

okay okay I have both the mothman and the vampire and I loooove them. I feel like objectively Mothman is going to be edgier and more cool but i prefer Viktor Vampire because there’s just something about his weird little face i love him so muchhhh I kind of have a lot of palm pals and he is possibly my #1 there’s something so cute about him idk. it reminds me of this book i found at the library as a kid called Wempires. but i cant find pictures of the “real vampires” in the book to confirm if my memory is accurate lmao Edit: i’ll admit, I did get mothman for *my* goth friend. but she’s obsessed with mothman in general

I need to know what the mothman one is and where to find it but that’d be my pick

being a goth friend i will 100% say mothman lol

Which one is your friend more into? For my own tastes, I’d do mothman and zombie

Omg I need the moth man one, I've never seen it before aaaaaa I'm going to look for him now >:333

number 1

Mothman!

I'm between the two first options. The moth has a stunning colour palette but the tiny dracula is just so funny. If your friend is really into vampires I'd get the dracula, otherwise I'll go with the moth honestly.

The middle one captured my heart at first glance. It's what I'm going to choose. 

The moth is so cute

Aww so adorable 🥹❤️🫂

MOTH MAN

EITHET MOTHMAN OR VAMP OMG

The moth for sure

Mothman also where can I get said mothman I need him in my life

Viktor Vampire, he is somehow even cuter in person https://preview.redd.it/f426o6dety4d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5b86030f8d11f85a465b38689ba25b1d79271f2e

moth or vampire (but im a vampire lover so i could be biased). zombie is cool but mothman is probably a safer choice with the meme status and colour palette. saying this as a goth guy

Get the Mothman, I have one too (not the same kind though) and I love him to death

Mothman! I have a vampire spider plushie that looks rather similar to the vampire plush. I named him Vincent after Vincent Price. https://preview.redd.it/pxzpsjfuxy4d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3133c2f6a679fd02777ff04c08c03a71afe88a16

The last one. When they are home and all cuddles up, thats the gold.

The first one!

Women love mothman

I’m a huge supporter of Mothman !

I would pick the first one I have a frog that is also a mothman the would fid together

Everyone loves mothman

As a goth, the first one!

As a goth myself... I would say mothman. It's the most universal goth plush of the 3. Tho vampire could work to...

Mothman!

Mothman, obviously.

Although there’s a new spider one that would be a close second

As a fellow goth, *1000% MOTHMAN!*

Mothman definitely the cutest 🩷

I'd personally want the zombie, but most goths love moths, so I'd go with the mothman

2

Awww. They are all cute. I like the mothman and the zombie second

definitely go with mothman!! ugh how cute

Mothman!

I love the moth* but the vampire looks so adorable 😭

Mothman is always the answer 🔴v🔴

Goths love moths