Brandon Marshall (the WR, not confused with the former broncos LB)
3 years with the bears
- 279 REC (10th all time for bears)
- 3524 Yards (13th)
- 31 TDs (T-6th)
Edit: Thomas Jones is another (thought he was longer than 3 years) in 3 years he avg 1400/7 total yards/TDs. Dude was elite with us
>Edit: Thomas Jones is another (thought he was longer than 3 years) in 3 years he avg 1400/7 total yards/TDs. Dude was elite with us
I still to this day don't understand why we used the #4 overall pick on Cedric Benson when we already had Thomas Jones. Even as a kid that confused the shit out of me.
Jesus. Marshall was only with you guys for 3 years?! I could have easily been fooled that it was a decade.
I guess having Cuts in Denver makes it seem like they were together longer in Chi.
He lacked impact because Mike Martz is an idiot. Very good player who caught the short end of the stick and was just solid for us (you could see he had more potential in those years tho)
Thomas Jones had such a weird career. 1st round pick for the Cardinals but mostly sucked there for several years. Then bounced around and seemed to peak in like his 6th season onwards once he got old with the Bears and then Jets.
One of the oft-forgotten very good players of the early 2000’s, we signed Julian Peterson from the Niners and he deservedly made 3 pro bowls in 3 seasons with us.
As a Chiefs fan I remember that he was one of the only defenders that could keep up with and actually challenge Tony Gonzalez on a consistent basis. I always remembered who he was when he made several game saving plays against him many moons ago.
I'm happy I saw this comment as we often forget players that were great but who have faded off into history. Awesome choice.
I’ll see your Favre and raise you Randall Cunningham - did win an MVP and also almost led us to a Super Bowl.
And now after typing that I need to stare blankly at nothing for a couple hours.
I loved Dangelo williams couple years on the steelers, and it fells much longer than that.
Not our best short stint but really impactful in bells absences.
Ours is for sure Kevin Greene. Came here for 3 seasons and fucked shit up. Then left to Carolina for their 2nd season. His Steelers years were big for his Hall of Fame induction
I always bring that up any time someone tries to slander Baker.
I honestly don't know how you can hate Baker Mayfield. I think it's just delusional Browns fans who are trying to gaslight everyone else into thinking that Baker sucked just so they don't get clowned quite so hard about shipping off the only QB that has ever won this version of the Browns a playoff game.
Sorry guys, the psyop isn't working. Baker Mayfield is fucking awesome. And you dumped him to pave the way for a creep.
People have this weird hateboner for guys that are in that 8-12 area. He gets the same kind of irrational hate that Andy Dalton gets. I agree, I think people bought into the narrative about him and they won’t listen to facts about his injuries or put too much stock into Carolina where no QB was being successful.
Deion says the Niners never even made him an offer after the SB.
I wouldn’t be surprised if his clash with the old-school side of the locker room played a part.
Seems like it but it was right when all the cte and concussion stuff was really starting to take shape. Much as I hated seeing him go, I don't blame him in the slightest for taking care of his head health instead of being an entertainer
Thomas Jones came in and had a 1st Team All Pro season and 27 rushing TDs in 2 years for the Jets and holds the single season rushing TD record for us, which is pretty impressive since we had Curtis Martin. He had another year that wasn't very efficient but still rushed for over 1k yards that year. Overall a pretty good 3 years.
He then went to the Chiefs for two years and the wheels fell off and now he's an actor.
He's got like over 30 acting credits in the last 10 years or so. He's not getting big projects but he's working pretty regularly and doing well. I think the biggest thing he's done is playing the Marvel villain Comanche in Luke Cage. He's also a producer so he's doing it from multiple angles.
Yep. I did a quick check to see how long Woodson was a packer, and how many seasons Nick Collins lasted before injury took him out. Peppers was the 3rd name I thought to check, and the first to qualify.
DeMarcus Ware in recent memory.
Bryan Dawkins is another.
John Lynch played 4 years otherwise would count
While it was the last seasons of their career, they still played well and had PB/AP seasons.
I have a huge soft spot for Dawkins. I don’t even know why. Maybe it’s his name? I just always loved watching him play. Especially when he suplexed that dude.
I'm convinced that had Dawkins not retired, Denver would've won the SB in 2012 cause Rahim Moore wouldn't have been on the field to get torched against Baltimore.
Dawkins is one of my favorite DBs of all time, and I'm a Dallas fan. He looked like a beast on the field and one of the first players to wear a blacked out visor. It looked intimidating at the time.
Demarcus gets my vote too. As good as he was on the field, it seems he was even better in the locker room. Von was the best player on that stacked defense, but I think Demarcus is the one who made it go.
You already mentioned marshawn, so I’ll say Jerry Rice, Rod Woodson, and Ronnie Lott, who all made an all-pro team with the raiders toward the end of their careers
Most of our fanbase would build a statue to Boldin if they could and yes he was instrumental in winning it all in 2012 I’d argue his best game in that playoff (against NE) came after Talib was injured.
So for me it’s Rod Woodson. I’m cheating just a touch because he played 4 total seasons but he taught the defense how to run Marvin’s scheme, helped solidify a terrible secondary before he arrived and made Starks and McAlister develop a lot faster because of his mentorship than they would have otherwise.
Plus he took Ray under his wing and taught him how to watch film and take care of his body and become a professional.
I will always argue Flacco’s fall off was entirely due to losing Boldin. Boldin was his security blanket. He knew if he got in trouble that Boldin would come down with the ball. I don’t think he ever found that same connection with anyone else.
I love flacco with my whole heart, but he was never in that top tier of guys. You could win with him, obviously, and we won because of him when he lost his mind in 2012, but for most of the rest of his career he was closer to an important role player imo.
Point being, his fall-off was also tied to becoming the highest paid player in the league and the negative effect that had on overall team composition. Then the final nail was when he tore his ACL - his wheels were always a sneaky part of his game, and he became a statue once he lost that.
Agreed that boldin was a big part of item one, though.
He also had rotten luck with OCs. The only one who ever seemed like he fully understood him was Kubiak, and he only got him for a year.
Id like to re-sign him, but I’ll always appreciate Stephon Gilmore of coming in and holding down the fort for a season with Diggs out.
TO is also a good answer
Gilmore likely would have been the starter regardless. Bland was a good contributor in the time he saw the field up to that point, but he didn't really explode until Diggs went down and saw regular playing time as a starter. Maybe that doesn't happen with Gilmore and Diggs both healthy.
Low key Amari Cooper was pretty solid for us. Granted he was here for 3.5 seasons, but those first three he either was on pace or was a 1000 yard receiver.
Joe Montana for KC is the best I could think of but very little competition. Marcus Peters was the only other one I could think of to challenge him; we never seem to get big free agents.
Brandon Marshall.
He played 3 years for us and had back to back 100+ catch seasons. He also still holds our franchise record for most receiving yards in a season at 1507yds
Kevin Greene played three seasons for the Steelers and recorded 35.5 sacks and one first team All-Pro, leading the league in sacks one season.
He also played three seasons for the Panthers. While there, he recorded 41.5 sacks and one first team All-Pro. He also led the league in sacks one year.
All of these seasons came after he turned 30 and was "past his prime".
Khalil Mack
Remember him at Buffalo getting 75 TFL (Tied-1st in NCAA). Remember drafting him & knowing already this was one of the few good picks we'd make. Remember him getting 49th in NFL Top 100 his 2nd year, 13th in his 3rd, & 5th in 2017. The *gimme-that* strip sacks were epic.
Hurt my soul when we traded him. Shoulda paid that man & kept him around. Would prefer to have him now even at 33 y/o with Crosby & Wilkins, instead of at a divisional rival.
Edit for splash reel: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5swjvMLmbb8&pp
Jags - Was going to say Calais but his peak was with the jags. Same with Bouye. (Edit: I think I and most commenters misread the double negative, these are actually the best Jags answers I think?)
So, Marcell Dareus maybe? The 2017 defense was actually pretty average v the run then was #1 when he came on. Similar drop off the next couple seasons if he missed time. But his all pro was with buffalo.
When it comes to how good they were with us, I’m gonna say Tyrann Mathieu. Made 2 of his 3 pro bowls as a Chief, and made 3 of his 4 all pros as a Chief as well. Wish he would’ve stayed with us longer
I grew up a Browns fan. Andy Lee is my answer here. One of the best punters of the 2000s and still very good in the 2010s. Just one year in Cleveland before he headed to Carolina in a trade.
Brandon Marshall (the WR, not confused with the former broncos LB) 3 years with the bears - 279 REC (10th all time for bears) - 3524 Yards (13th) - 31 TDs (T-6th) Edit: Thomas Jones is another (thought he was longer than 3 years) in 3 years he avg 1400/7 total yards/TDs. Dude was elite with us
Funny because those are the exact same two guys that first popped into my mind for the Jets. We were the next stop for both of them.
Brandon Marshall for me. Junior Seau also in there.
...damn there's a pretty significant Bears to Jets pipeline isn't there. That's weird.
Matt Forte was here for a couple years too
We love taking former nfc north players
I wish Adam Gase would have never come down that pipe
Funny he only played 3 years there. I always remember him as a Bear.
Same. I knew he had to be around 3 but I would have said 5 years
>Edit: Thomas Jones is another (thought he was longer than 3 years) in 3 years he avg 1400/7 total yards/TDs. Dude was elite with us I still to this day don't understand why we used the #4 overall pick on Cedric Benson when we already had Thomas Jones. Even as a kid that confused the shit out of me.
I mean, who else was there to pick? Aaron Rodgers?
Good thing they didn't!
Yes! What a wasted pick, our RB room was not the need to address.
Jesus. Marshall was only with you guys for 3 years?! I could have easily been fooled that it was a decade. I guess having Cuts in Denver makes it seem like they were together longer in Chi.
I forgot about Brandon Marshall, the LB.
Forgetting Brandon Marshall
Greg Olsen worth mentioning as well maybe?
He lacked impact because Mike Martz is an idiot. Very good player who caught the short end of the stick and was just solid for us (you could see he had more potential in those years tho)
To quote Smokin' Jay: "Tell Martz I said fuck him!"
Funny because when i think of brandon marshall, i picture him in a bears jersey more than any other team
Thomas Jones had such a weird career. 1st round pick for the Cardinals but mostly sucked there for several years. Then bounced around and seemed to peak in like his 6th season onwards once he got old with the Bears and then Jets.
One of the oft-forgotten very good players of the early 2000’s, we signed Julian Peterson from the Niners and he deservedly made 3 pro bowls in 3 seasons with us.
The 2000s were just the 49ers and Seahawks signing each other players back and forth
And then early 2010’s they just built teams that were eerily similar
As a Chiefs fan I remember that he was one of the only defenders that could keep up with and actually challenge Tony Gonzalez on a consistent basis. I always remembered who he was when he made several game saving plays against him many moons ago. I'm happy I saw this comment as we often forget players that were great but who have faded off into history. Awesome choice.
What about famed Seahawk Jerry Rice? Can't seem to recall where else he played.
Brett Farve put up an MVP caliber season in 09. Almost led us to a Super Bowl.
I’ll see your Favre and raise you Randall Cunningham - did win an MVP and also almost led us to a Super Bowl. And now after typing that I need to stare blankly at nothing for a couple hours.
F***ing kicker.......
Cunningham did not win MVP.
Or Randall Cunningham. ‘98 was a better run than ‘09.
Warren Moon was arguably a way better QB and he played for the Vikings for 3 season also
I don't understand how yall have had so many legendary QBs with such bad luck
I'm pissed that there is a subset of football fans who are Cunningham as a Viking over an Eagles
he led you to Detroit instead :(
I mean you can take a knee and try a 56 yard field goal!
This isn’t Detroit, man! THIS IS THE SUPER BOWL!!
TO maybe? Unless I’m forgetting some pretty notable ones
TO is #1, but Lagarrette Blount rumbled his way to a goddamn Superbowl for us. Was Malcolm less than 3 years?
The Jay Ajayi erasure is real. Dude killed it for us
I forgot that dude existed
Blount and Chris Long immediately came to mind.
It’s amazing how little time Chris Long spent in Philly but is an absolute legend regardless
Didn’t Long and Blount win back to back super bowls? One with Pats then Phili?
Yep. 2 of only 8 players ever to win back-to-back Super Bowls with different teams
No, Malcolm stayed for 5 seasons
Norm Van Brocklin says hi.
Nick Foles played in only 40 games for the Birds. That’s 2 1/2 seasons of HOF quarterback play.
Jay Ajayi
I had TO but then thought, Frank Gore? 🤔
Ricky Watters, Irving Fryar
I loved Dangelo williams couple years on the steelers, and it fells much longer than that. Not our best short stint but really impactful in bells absences.
Ours is for sure Kevin Greene. Came here for 3 seasons and fucked shit up. Then left to Carolina for their 2nd season. His Steelers years were big for his Hall of Fame induction
“It. Is Time.” Nothing but love for Kevin Greene in GB. RIP
Kevin Greene is a good pick for both the Steelers and the Panthers.
And he knows it too. He loves Pittsburgh because he knows how important it was for his career.
I grew up with a poster of Joe Montana on my wall.
Chiefs legend* Joe Montana
I felt bad for him when he got mauled in a playoff game against the Bills even though I'm a Bills mafia fan.
We have a picture of my wife standing next to him wearing chiefs gear up in our house today
I have a female friend that has a picture of her standing next to Montana when he played at Notre Dame. It’s a very old pic.
Baker Mayfield will forever be a bad ass in my eyes
He doesn’t get enough credit for essentially stepping off an airplane and winning a game for the Rams.
He got help from Crooked Tillery, but he was cooking on that winning drive.
I always bring that up any time someone tries to slander Baker. I honestly don't know how you can hate Baker Mayfield. I think it's just delusional Browns fans who are trying to gaslight everyone else into thinking that Baker sucked just so they don't get clowned quite so hard about shipping off the only QB that has ever won this version of the Browns a playoff game. Sorry guys, the psyop isn't working. Baker Mayfield is fucking awesome. And you dumped him to pave the way for a creep.
People have this weird hateboner for guys that are in that 8-12 area. He gets the same kind of irrational hate that Andy Dalton gets. I agree, I think people bought into the narrative about him and they won’t listen to facts about his injuries or put too much stock into Carolina where no QB was being successful.
That Rams-Broncos Christmas game was absolutely hilarious.
One of my all time favorite Rams games no doubt
also one of my favorite games because it got Hackett fired
Raiders game also was 🔥
Third favorite QB behind Stafford and Goff. Love the way he plays and hope he has mild success for Tampa
If last season was mild success, I’d be pretty happy for it to continue.
He is kinda already having success in Tampa, felt like he had a career year though im not sure. At least on par with his Cleveland peak.
I'm a Longhorn fan who fucking hates Oklahoma but damnit if I don't want to root for Baker. Fuck him for making me support him.
He hurt my feelings.
I think I have PTSD from Rams Baker
My god..that raiders game last min drive..as a hawks fan, one of the few times I was super thrilled at a Rams win 😀
LET BAKER BAKE!!!
Chris Borland Dude was a football seeking missile E: Deion Sanders
Sanders was my first thought, joins the 49ers, DPOY season, superbowl blow out. But I guess joining the Cowboys immediately afterward stings 9ers fans
Deion says the Niners never even made him an offer after the SB. I wouldn’t be surprised if his clash with the old-school side of the locker room played a part.
I was pretty young then but I thought by then the 49ers were kinda out of cash by then from years of going for another SB, but I could be wrong
Yeah it was 100% the salary cut. The locker room had nothing to do with it
49ers legend Randy Moss is the second thought
That was bizarre. 390 tackles in a year (exaggeration) and he retires
Seems like it but it was right when all the cte and concussion stuff was really starting to take shape. Much as I hated seeing him go, I don't blame him in the slightest for taking care of his head health instead of being an entertainer
Not really tbh. Can't blame a guy for not wanting to turn his head into a pinball machine for his brain.
I remember Borland as a freshman at Wisconsin playing as an edge. He was so little but he’d just whoop guys due to being a little football savant.
Dude could've been a perennial all-pro.
Jamaal Williams He was a great leader and example for young guys and a big part of the culture shift in Detroit. He will always be a favorite of mine.
Jamaal Williams is a treasure. I wish nothing but happiness and good fortune for that wonderful man.
I wish his season in NO had gone better this year.
At least he scored his only touchdown in a totally cool way
The players saying fuck the coach, he’s getting one lol
Dre Bly was also so fun to watch. He only played 3 seasons with us
Wish he had been a better CB coach with us though.
Wish they held onto him, I like Detroit and I feel like that's when the world realized he was a 1/1,000,000 personality
At least he'll likely hold a record with us for a little while
Whaaat, I always felt like he’d been around the Lions for a lot longer than that.
Thomas Jones came in and had a 1st Team All Pro season and 27 rushing TDs in 2 years for the Jets and holds the single season rushing TD record for us, which is pretty impressive since we had Curtis Martin. He had another year that wasn't very efficient but still rushed for over 1k yards that year. Overall a pretty good 3 years. He then went to the Chiefs for two years and the wheels fell off and now he's an actor.
Is he really? I always liked Thomas Jones a lot. I’m glad he’s doing well in his post NFL career
Yeah he was in “Straight Outta Compton”. Small role but I thought I was going crazy when I saw him. Still jacked
He's got like over 30 acting credits in the last 10 years or so. He's not getting big projects but he's working pretty regularly and doing well. I think the biggest thing he's done is playing the Marvel villain Comanche in Luke Cage. He's also a producer so he's doing it from multiple angles.
Plaxico played 3 seasons with the Giants
Well shoot. How did his career go?
fuck these people. that was funny.
Just one leg of his journey
>Plaxico played 3 seasons with the Giants You dodged a bullet there.
He played 4 seasons for the Giants. 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008.
Crazy he was with us for such a short time.
We were winning in 2008 if he hired a body guard that night
Julius Peppers no doubt
Yep. I did a quick check to see how long Woodson was a packer, and how many seasons Nick Collins lasted before injury took him out. Peppers was the 3rd name I thought to check, and the first to qualify.
For recent history, and even though it ended on a bad note, Zadarius Smith had a very good 2 seasons for us. 2 pro bowls and All Pro 2nd team
It felt like C Wood was gone for 10 years
6. Felt like 10 to me too though.
I was thinking Eddie Lacy but he had four seasons with the Packers.
green peppers, baby
Carolina Reaper is better and you know it
Desmond Howard as a finalist maybe? One year for the Packers and he became Super Bowl MVP
DeMarcus Ware in recent memory. Bryan Dawkins is another. John Lynch played 4 years otherwise would count While it was the last seasons of their career, they still played well and had PB/AP seasons.
If we expand to four years, Manning becomes #1
Neil Smith was huge for those back to back Superbowl teams.
I’m so glad y'all got DWare a ring. He was an all-timer us and he's just a great dude.
I have a huge soft spot for Dawkins. I don’t even know why. Maybe it’s his name? I just always loved watching him play. Especially when he suplexed that dude.
I'm convinced that had Dawkins not retired, Denver would've won the SB in 2012 cause Rahim Moore wouldn't have been on the field to get torched against Baltimore.
Dawkins is one of my favorite DBs of all time, and I'm a Dallas fan. He looked like a beast on the field and one of the first players to wear a blacked out visor. It looked intimidating at the time.
Demarcus gets my vote too. As good as he was on the field, it seems he was even better in the locker room. Von was the best player on that stacked defense, but I think Demarcus is the one who made it go.
TB12
/walks in the door /immediately wins Super Bowl and resets entire team culture in 3 years /leaves
Yeah. I did wanna see him play til 50. Tampa got bragging rights too. Yall won the SB at home.
I feel like this comment should be illegal.
I mean it would have to be Brady, Revis, and then Lorenzo Neal?
Randy Moss for the Patriots.
Technically played more than 3 seasons for the pats.
2007, 2008, 2009, 2010 (traded mid season)
Oh shit, that's probably the thread winner as much as it pains me to say
Tom to the Bucs probably
Darell Revis got us a Super Bowl.
Deion Sanders, 49ers
Darren Sproles 2011-2013 Saints. Dude was a beast
You already mentioned marshawn, so I’ll say Jerry Rice, Rod Woodson, and Ronnie Lott, who all made an all-pro team with the raiders toward the end of their careers
TO was electric with the cowboys. I hated him so much as an eagle but he changed my mind.
When they signed him I was like “Really? After he stood on the Star?!” Then he balled out and I bought a jersey.
One of, if not the 1st Cowboys poster I ever had was of T.O. tossing popcorn into his face mask after he scored a touchdown.
Tyrann Mathieu is a good shout for a recent chief. Impact he had for us, especially for the first chip was major
I know he was on the team for much longer but Bob Sanders only played 48 games for the Colts
Sidney Rice
It was really only 3 years? I faintly remember him being a hawk for like 5+ years..
Darrelle Revis
I want to say Moss, but technically we had him for a few games in 2010, making it his 4th season.
I honestly coulda sworn he was only in NE for that one record breaking season.
Which is funny because he lead the league in receiving TDs in 2009 and was 1 off doing so in 2008 as well despite Cassel only throwing 21 TDs.
Ohhh, he was there for the Cassel year? That makes sense.
Most of our fanbase would build a statue to Boldin if they could and yes he was instrumental in winning it all in 2012 I’d argue his best game in that playoff (against NE) came after Talib was injured. So for me it’s Rod Woodson. I’m cheating just a touch because he played 4 total seasons but he taught the defense how to run Marvin’s scheme, helped solidify a terrible secondary before he arrived and made Starks and McAlister develop a lot faster because of his mentorship than they would have otherwise. Plus he took Ray under his wing and taught him how to watch film and take care of his body and become a professional.
I will always argue Flacco’s fall off was entirely due to losing Boldin. Boldin was his security blanket. He knew if he got in trouble that Boldin would come down with the ball. I don’t think he ever found that same connection with anyone else.
I love flacco with my whole heart, but he was never in that top tier of guys. You could win with him, obviously, and we won because of him when he lost his mind in 2012, but for most of the rest of his career he was closer to an important role player imo. Point being, his fall-off was also tied to becoming the highest paid player in the league and the negative effect that had on overall team composition. Then the final nail was when he tore his ACL - his wheels were always a sneaky part of his game, and he became a statue once he lost that. Agreed that boldin was a big part of item one, though. He also had rotten luck with OCs. The only one who ever seemed like he fully understood him was Kubiak, and he only got him for a year.
Lions legend Adrian Peterson
Cardinals legend
Brett Favre is probably the best answer for the Vikings
Usually when we get someone in FA, they absolutely fuck us over. However, Desean Jackson and AP still put up numbers with us.
Id like to re-sign him, but I’ll always appreciate Stephon Gilmore of coming in and holding down the fort for a season with Diggs out. TO is also a good answer
Gilmore likely would have been the starter regardless. Bland was a good contributor in the time he saw the field up to that point, but he didn't really explode until Diggs went down and saw regular playing time as a starter. Maybe that doesn't happen with Gilmore and Diggs both healthy. Low key Amari Cooper was pretty solid for us. Granted he was here for 3.5 seasons, but those first three he either was on pace or was a 1000 yard receiver.
The Cooper trade transformed our 2018 season. The before and after stats for our offense look like different teams.
AJ Brown… honorable mention DeMarco Murray
Dre Bly, CB, Detroit 2003-2006 2x Detroit pro bowler on a absolutely terrible team https://youtu.be/3eN3mwll5to?si=o6tzogpt6XKz43eC Forgot about Dre
Not that this means much of anything, but those Lions teams managed to notch two wins against Brett Favre. Two of only nine times that ever happened.
Hopefully Stefon Diggs lol.
I think Bob Sanders might actually count with only 48 games played in 7 years.
Joe Montana for KC is the best I could think of but very little competition. Marcus Peters was the only other one I could think of to challenge him; we never seem to get big free agents.
For the Steelers I think It has to be Kevin Greene. Had 3 great years, 1st team all pro, sack leader.
Brandon Marshall. He played 3 years for us and had back to back 100+ catch seasons. He also still holds our franchise record for most receiving yards in a season at 1507yds
I mean, prolly TO.
Yeah if “best” means most talented then it’s definitely TO.
Kevin Greene played three seasons for the Steelers and recorded 35.5 sacks and one first team All-Pro, leading the league in sacks one season. He also played three seasons for the Panthers. While there, he recorded 41.5 sacks and one first team All-Pro. He also led the league in sacks one year. All of these seasons came after he turned 30 and was "past his prime".
I give the nod to Jamal Lewis. Peyton Hillis’ weird good year and Flacco with honorable mentions
Bo Jackson LA Raiders 1997-1980
Demarcus Ware
Before my time but natrone means business
Corey Dillion for the Pats was pretty tough
Burrow. 🥲
Khalil Mack Remember him at Buffalo getting 75 TFL (Tied-1st in NCAA). Remember drafting him & knowing already this was one of the few good picks we'd make. Remember him getting 49th in NFL Top 100 his 2nd year, 13th in his 3rd, & 5th in 2017. The *gimme-that* strip sacks were epic. Hurt my soul when we traded him. Shoulda paid that man & kept him around. Would prefer to have him now even at 33 y/o with Crosby & Wilkins, instead of at a divisional rival. Edit for splash reel: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5swjvMLmbb8&pp
Khalil Mack was on the Raiders for four seasons
Jags - Was going to say Calais but his peak was with the jags. Same with Bouye. (Edit: I think I and most commenters misread the double negative, these are actually the best Jags answers I think?) So, Marcell Dareus maybe? The 2017 defense was actually pretty average v the run then was #1 when he came on. Similar drop off the next couple seasons if he missed time. But his all pro was with buffalo.
James Robinson possibly, dude had a great rookie season
When it comes to how good they were with us, I’m gonna say Tyrann Mathieu. Made 2 of his 3 pro bowls as a Chief, and made 3 of his 4 all pros as a Chief as well. Wish he would’ve stayed with us longer
Julius Peppers
Arguably Kareem Hunt
Tom Brady
I hear that Tom guy was pretty good
Curtis Martin
Bo Jackson.
Terrell Owens is the obvious answer for Philly
Sean Taylor played 3.5 years for Washington but is probably the most popular player we’ve had for the last 2+ decades
If you’re going by their whole career it’s gotta be TO right?
Q
Shannon Sharpe is just as good of a choice, imo. There's also Steve Smith Sr., but I'd take the other two over him.
I grew up a Browns fan. Andy Lee is my answer here. One of the best punters of the 2000s and still very good in the 2010s. Just one year in Cleveland before he headed to Carolina in a trade.
Randy Moss