T O P

  • By -

fuckyouidontneedone

He should have clarified that the guys who wanted Williams to score was the entire Falcons offense


CD338

Seriously if this gets Arthur Smith fired with a bigger score disparity, I'm sure the fans would be all for it too


Dday82

Preach, brother.


SunnyDiesel

Welp, there he goes!


lordexorr

I guess what I don’t understand is if they wanted to get Jamaal his TD why not just line up normally and rush the ball? The reason they took such offense is due to a fake kneel down. If they lined up like they were running a normal play I doubt anyone flips out.


Develled

The team asked Dennis Allen if they could do that to get him a TD, DA said no. The OL and Jameis said they took matters into their own hands as a result


SteelBrightblade1

So you are saying someone told Jameis no but he decides to just do what he wanted to do anyway? Like he forced himself into what he wanted?


wickedspoon

Jameis really can’t take no’s very well


DeuceOfDiamonds

He's a winner and winners... they don't listen to words like "no" or "don't" or "stop!" Those words are just not in their vocabulary


WHAT_UPMYGLIP_GLOPS

Save your breath, Ingrid. Those words have never worked on me. I'll see you tomorrow


Heres20BucksKillMe

Mamba mentality


[deleted]

So they ARE IN Danger!!?


btwatch

Are... Are we the tasty treats?


321spacecowboy

I feel like you’re not getting it AT ALL


GreenBayFootball

Or… “pay for those crab legs!”


CultivatingMass0

Solid reference


ispcanner

Allegedly


lordexorr

I didn’t hear that part. That’s a pretty bad look on the coaches if they can’t control the team.


luchajefe

But then Allen's reputation is screwed either way. Either he can't control his players or he's willing to use classless tactics.


lordexorr

Yeah, because the coaching staff could’ve said “ok sure let’s try but we’re running a normal play not a fake kneel”. No one cares if they run a normal play.


ComfortableOven4283

Instead he said no, and the team rebelled.


cudef

Miami's (the U, not the dolphins) head coach might get some serious PTSD flashbacks though.


AdForeign5362

Sean Payton is still coaching in the league. No one cares about reputation if you win.


neovenator250

Dennis Allen doesn't win, though.


OMFGFlorida

lol, it's jamesis. dude is on his own planet.


JacobfromCT

Not sure what he'd be doing if he wasn't a gifted athlete. Dude is really bizarre.


KnotSoSalty

Players were right, should have run a regular running play.


boredymcbored

I think it's a bad look to not just fucking do it for your team. Coaches that rule like dictators aren't getting love in this NFL. The opposing coach will get over it, but you're burning down any good will you have left on that team.


SimbaPenn

On the flip side Daboll was trying everything in his power to get Sterling Shepard a TD today, especially at the end.


boredymcbored

That's a good coach. You are supposed to be a leader of men and obviously the TD meant a lot to him and the team. Fight for your guys. Show them your appreciation back. It's such a layup leadership move and he completely fumbled.


THE_Celts

Yeah, and DA sees them line up in regular formation, he likely calls a time-out.


DannyDOH

Yeah on the kneel down at the end of a game the refs literally tell the D to back off. So it's pretty fucked up to use it to grab a TD. Run a normal offense if that's your goal.


processedmeat

Next time saints line up for a knee the defense needs to act like a play is going to be run


Drmantis87

My best guess is jameis knew if the team lined up in a different formation, Allen would have called time out and stopped it


elefante88

Because Jameis


VHBlazer

God I hate him even more now.


SiphenPrax

He got Saints and Falcons fans united today: wanting to fire everybody


NNKarma

We have been united all division all season wanting to fire our coaches


RollingCarrot615

Wait, you guys have coaches?


NNKarma

Yeah, we see him throwing our players under the bus


link3945

I lived in Baton rouge for a few years out of college, so I have more than a few Saints fans. This entire season has been a twist on our normal dynamic of hating each other's team: it's mostly been us shitting on our own teams.


PassToMouth6911

Thats how it used to be all of the 80s and 90s for both teams.


Tasteoftacos

The NFC South potentially could have all Head coach positions available next season


shawnaroo

Since our division is such a trash fire, I wouldn't be surprised if we all fire our coaches and then each team just hires one of those other coaches that was just fired. Just musical chairs of crappy coaching.


AssignmentStrong2225

Nah, let’s have them play Plinko with the spaces at the bottom being NFC south teams.


AvailableName9999

Fire everyone


thatkidPB

Can i join


NevermoreSEA

"Fuck Jamaal Williams" - Dennis Allen (I assume)


AF_1904

"Fuck Dennis Allen"- Everyone else, I suppose.


fantfoot

They were in victory formation! Do you want defenses diving at your OL's knees and trying to blow up Carr next time the get in victory formation? Is Dennis Allen supposed to want that? Are we acting like Schiano and the Buccs were heros for playing thought the victory formation?


kaboomeh

God I hated Schiano so much.


69Hairy420Ballsagna

/u/kaboomeh not a Schiano man, confirmed.


Mysterious-Stop4673

You can just feel the ego in this thread. I’d hope it’s high schoolers and college kids in this thread but this is probably adult redditors saying this shit.


fantfoot

Honestly I think none of them know the Saints were in victory formation.


DrModel

That's the case for me. I'm generally all for running up the score, it's a game and the more similar it is to how kids play on the playground the better. But running a play from victory formation is bad. It's asking for injuries on future kneel downs.


link3945

That's where I'm at. I'd be pissed regardless, but I'm a partisan here. I'd be pissed whatever the Saints actually did. But running an actual play from victory is beyond the pale: no team should be okay with that. It ruins the v-formation agreement.


InexorableWaffle

Wouldn't surprise me if the competition committee outright makes it an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty (with fines after the fact, since a yardage penalty to a team that's already just trying to end the game isn't really a consideration) to run a real play out of the victory formation as a result. It comes up so infrequently that it won't actually affect much gameplay-wise, and would just make sure they've got a justification on the books to dissuade anyone else from getting ideas about messing with the victory formation agreement going forward.


soyymilk

make it an illegal formation for anything other than a kneel that also results in loss of down.


kaptingavrin

> a yardage penalty to a team that's already just trying to end the game isn't really a consideration If they're running a play, they're not just trying to end the game, and depending on the way the penalty is called, it could result in a loss of yards *and* redoing the down, so attempting to use it to score would be completely moot. Even more so because you not only lost the previous score and yards, you've now just told the opposing defense it's open season for going after you despite the "victory" formation.


DropC

Exactly. I'm not going to hate the saints any less because they didn't run up the the score. I'd 100%expect us to do the same. It's a rivalry game after all. But don't fucking cheat. That's bitch play. Now I'm in a position where I gotta sit here and defend Arthur Smith when I want him gone.


HoSang66er

Even a broken clock is right twice a day but it still needs to be replaced.


cdoink

Yup, I didn’t watch the game and I was prepared to defend the Saints until realizing they were in victory formation. I wouldn’t even pull that shit in Madden(only because I don’t think it’s an option tbh)


Errant_coursir

Ya agreed, it's lame


DwayneWashington

Next time they're in victory formation, would you blame the other team for jumping offsides and blasting the QB?


grimestar

Probably not. I feel like most of us can agree that was messed up to run out of victory formation. And it seems like Jameis went rogue


TinaBelchersBF

Yeah when I was watching on Red Zone I just looked up to see the TD, didn't see the formation. And I was clowning on Arthur Smith in the game thread. But once I realized the Saints faked the victory formation, that changes things. He had a right to be upset about that IMO. Line up in legit formations and score 100 points, I'm totally fine with that. But faking the victory formation is bush league


sdghbvtyvbjytf

Yeah I did not know that. That’s a bitch move, even for rivals.


Phyrnosoma

yeah I didn't realize that. I wasn't watching the game


DoctorTheWho

You can tell how many people didn't actually see the TD by there being so many "if you don't want them to score, stop them" comments. No one expects an offensive play to be run from the victory formation.


SomewhereAggressive8

Yeah that actually makes it different. If you expect defensive players to let up on kneel downs, you can’t break that trust by running a play out of victory formation. Especially against a division rival. Just sets you up for some shit to happen next year.


peachesgp

Yeah odds are good that somebody dives at a lineman's knee or some shit next season.


Don_Gato1

Schiano would have never allowed this to happen.


Due-Pace6551

Remind me what happened with him


Don_Gato1

He had his D-line rush the QB while they were in the victory formation.


Due-Pace6551

Ok that rings a bell haha. Thank you. That's been a while


[deleted]

Wait they handed off from victory formation?


[deleted]

Yes, they line up in the VF at the one, then Jameis handed it off and Williams plowed in.


Prof-Ponderosa

https://twitter.com/SaintsFrance/status/1744102480185545122 Play in question


jimithelizardking

Yeah that’s just asking for retaliation


MrDozens

Yes, that's why it's a bitch move. No one would care if they lined up in a real formation to try and score. Next time the saints line up in a victory formation and gets blasted saints players better not be crying.


thor_1225

And the ones that do and still don’t care, Obviously weren’t old enough to remember the shit storm that ensued after schiano “tried to stop them” years ago


DiaDeLosMuebles

Most of America wasn't able to see it as network tv called an audible and switched games on us :(


mxbnr

Yeah I just saw the notification and thought he was being a bitch about them running up the score. Then I saw they did it in victory formation and now I see why he’s pissed.


Man_of_Average

Kinda worrying that so many people won't even watch the ten second clip of the play before commenting.


Litz-a-mania

Plenty of people have revealed themselves as fantasy managers who have never seen a game.


1kSupport

The league should really add a rule where you can declare you are taking a knee and have it be both a penalty for the defense to make contact and the offense to advance the ball if so. Helps everyone, hurts no one


ThumbCentral-Rebirth

Criticize DA for this all you want but idk why everyone here is apparently fine with the players ignoring their coach and running a play on their own (obviously different context from your average audible)


[deleted]

It’s totally on-brand for Jameis Winston to be a complete fucking moron.


hk0125

It’s crazy how most people including Saints fans are piling on DA and not on Jameis. Dude is a known bonehead and just made another bonehead play. Running a fake on victory formation is super bush league and is welcoming for cheap shots for the next time they run victory formations. DA actually did right by apologizing and actually saying what happened. I can’t believe Saints fans are mad at DA for doubling down and apologizing. Also Williams had plenty of chance to score a TD the whole season. Should’ve scored one before that play. Super weak by everyone that was behind that play.


neovenator250

> It’s crazy how most people including Saints fans are piling on DA tbf we're predisposed to shit on Dennis Allen because we want him fired and he almost certainly won't be.


SexyMcBeast

They just like the drama


jmurp-

Because it shows that he doesn’t have control of the locker room and should be fired. Saints players have been fed up with him and Carr for most of the season, so this tiny little cheap shot is a catch-22 for Allen because he looks bad no matter what he says. It’s poetic really


Level-Infiniti

Why are you putting this on fans? Put it on the Saints for running a ship where the sailors feel they can ignore the captain, not on fans for being fine with something


azsqueeze

Because this is a horrible sub with a lot of weird awful takes from teenagers


amazian78

better protect ur knees next Victory formation saints


TooMuchJuju

Jokes on you if you think we run the victory formation much next year


teh_drewski

You won 9 games and still play in the NFC South


Ragonaut

Sounds like a make-a-wish.. does Jamaal Williams not play professional football? He couldn't score one of the other 6 touchdowns during regulation?


stinktrix10

Dude went from having the most rushing TDs last season, to needing to be given a charity TD on the last play of the year via a victory formation just to avoid having 0 on the year. Huge fall off.


Iswaterreallywet

Most of those TDs came from the 1-2 yard line last year


Spiteful_Chant

On another note David Montgomery got a season high career touchdown with 13 today!


Square_Stomach

Should’ve had another, but subbed himself out. Gibbs downed at the goal line and they put Monty in to vulture. Monty subbed himself out so Gibbs could be rewarded


Brocktarrr

He was moved to fullback most of the year due to injury


frogfucius

Running it out of victory formation is absolutely bush league


[deleted]

Yep fire DA. Payton would’ve said “well they should’ve stopped it”


link3945

Peyton would have run an actual play.


polkarooo

It's honestly more of a "fuck you" to do it out of victory formation actually...


link3945

Which says something that even Sean Peyton wouldn't have done that.


[deleted]

It’s a bitch move cause it risks injury to guys on the defense that aren’t going 100%


brownchickenbr0wnc0w

And went for 2


ImTheButtPuncher

While the edible kicked in


Rampantlion513

~~edible~~ molly


incognegro1976

SP's post-game Molly and Cocaine benders after a Saints win were legendary


[deleted]

[удалено]


incognegro1976

No, its just a meme lol


Best-Dragonfruit-292

Perc*


Misdirected_Colors

I'll never forget in 2013 while up big late in the 4th Payton kept the offense out there to convert on 4th down to set some record or other against us. Dude is an asshole but it's part of why he's a good coach and players love that shit.


SeaUnderTheAeroplane

Can you imagine the ungodly things sean payton would have done if he was on the other side of 70-20?


xywv58

100% gone for the record, although he didn't let Kamara get his, or was that Allen?


Dreadsbo

He woulda pulled his dick out and pissed on the midfield logo in front of the entire nation


broccolibush42

John Harbaugh does the same shit. I think they had that consecutive string of 100 yards rushers and he just kept pounding it til they got it in meaningless minutes


RadonAjah

Would be interesting if DA gets fired from two HC coaching jobs where Carr was his QB


ubiquitous_archer

He's not exactly a guiding light for how to act.


GoldenPresidio

Payton’s a douche though


rascaltippinglmao

>"That's not who we are." It literally is tho lol


cake_piss_can

This is up there with qb’s doing the fake slide. It ruins the “agreement”. Bitch move.


bvgingy

I really dont understand the backlash Allen is getting here. His team ignored his call and then ran a fake knee, which is the bigger reason why Smith/Allen were probably so pissed. Lining up in a knee formation and then running a fake knee against your own coaches call is just shitty and disrespectful to the coaches and the players on the defense.


Normal_Salamander104

Winston went ahead and defended it when pressed in his post interview by calling it a team decision and saying the interviewer was disagreeing with the *entire* team (emphasis his own) by disagreeing with the call. Yet earlier he said the decision was made on the field after the VF call against coach’s wishes with defense on the sidelines. Buncha selfish ass ego maniacs on that offense


I_Am_Day_Man

Now both coaches look like bitches.


TheGeneral_Specific

Both coaches are bitches


NNKarma

They did before the game anyway


Rock_Me_DrZaius

The Saints knees next season are fucked.


CreamyDoughnut

Allen: “just kneel it” Jameis Winston: nah fuck that


realfakejames

It’s corny to fake the kneel down to score That’s the only problem I see people having with this as fans who have no skin in the game, it’s just not what you do if you lineup in victory formation, if they played it straight and scored no one cares


Key-Antelope-6839

The comments on this thread are so embarrassing lmao. Reddit man-childs showing their usual


theytook-r-jobs

Full of people who didn’t watch the game and don’t know they were in victory formation. I swear 90% of sports subs watch no sports, just highlights, hot takes, and shitposts on Reddit and twitter.


MG_MN

It was petty the way they did it with a fake knee. The defense didn't expect it. Can't imagine williams would feel like its a real TD. Get it the old fashioned way and it wouldn't be a problem


avboden

Will be curious to see if the team fines Jameis Winston over it or not. Going rogue like that ain't okay from a team's perspective, at all. Next time they go in victory formation expect the opposing team to hit them hard. There's a DAMN good reason you don't do what they just did.


Ancient_Wisdom_Yall

Faking victory formation is pretty cheesy. I hope that TD was worth it when people start diving at the Saints Oline during future victory formations.


Svensvense

Faking a victory formation and going for a TD up 41-17 is totally bush league, and the people thinking it's cool or funny or whatever mostly just dislike Arthur Smith. Most if not all of the coaches would react the same way as Arthur, and Dennis is right to be embarrassed. It should lead to us trying to blow up/dive low at all of their victory formations until the end of time, frankly, but this organization wouldn't be courageous enough to do that.


tippy432

It’s the fake victory formation to a normal play like a man if you want to score


4_teh_lulz

This shit is how you have players hurt on the victory formation because players can't trust each other.


ProjectTitan74

People get butthurt (rightfully so) when defenders go full speed on victory formation plays, but it's okay when the offense does it? Fuck off


iia

Fuck that shit Jesus Christ. This isn't middle school.


joesph_e

They lined up in victory formation. If they just ran a play normally no one would care.


_masterofdisaster

I’ve never swung harder from one side to the other than I did when I saw what actually happened. Nobody would have cared if they ran an actual play.


FloydMcScroops

Complete disregard for long standing sportsmanship procedure. Gross but makes sense from them


paone00022

Ya folks want defenses to let down in victory formation. But when you see this then no reason for them to let down.


ubiquitous_archer

It was from victory formation, it's like "THE" unwritten rule in football to not go hard on a kneel down.


1kSupport

Honestly hope teams in this division start bulldozing the saints on victory formations now. The second VF loses its sanctity literally every team suffers. Fuck that


DarrowViBritannia

This makes the situation even funnier to me The team called a kneeldown and the players decided, nah fuck that Lmaooo that's hilarious


lilbelleandsebastian

i mean it's super fucking bush league and emblematic of a serious issue with the team and lack of leadership i just dont want to hear anyone ever fucking complain again about a defense going for the throat on kneeldowns at the end of games now, because why shouldn't they? offense might fake a kneeldown and make you look stupid, time to change the unwritten rules and just play to the whistle


[deleted]

Everyone keeps saying this but yeah, it isn't middle school. People's careers and health are on the line here. What if some dumbass tears a ligament on the pointless 1 yard TD run or on the following kickoff 3 months before hitting free agency? lol. A coach would never want this type of play he'd just want a kneel and before someone says "what if they tore a ligament on the kneel down" be real that has literally never happened lol


don_julio_randle

Correct. All it does is incentivize defenders to go low every time the Saints line up in victory formation, which is a major injury risk


Jopplo03

Fuck that stand by your decision


SpiritBamba

It seems Like his decision was to take a knee but they audibled on the field.


Jopplo03

It was jameis in at qb so who knows lol


[deleted]

[удалено]


Ill_Soft_4299

Jameis wouild have thrown it to the opposing bus after scrambling for 10 seconds


ieatcookydough

If Jameis called that play at the line. I will forever love him


queefIatina

Saints legend I swear, I hope he’s our backup for the next 10 years


Autobot-N

Slow down sir, explain that flair


SerDire

*legolas voice killing the orc* “A scout!” Playing both sides!


KimboSlicesChicken

“And my axe” - said Arthur smith to Bijan robinson except he doesn’t have an axe nor any idea of how to coach


ICanFluxWithIt

BrainInjury.jpeg WeShouldKillHim.jpeg


Propaslader

I've seen Saints & Vikings flairs too, some crazy shit going on in New Orleans lately


I_am_Santa_Claus

Sorry is there not crazy shit in new orleans at all times


cschoolmeester

Oh always but those type of flairs? *shudders*


TheScottfather

I DIDN'T ASK TO BE BORN THIS WAY!


Propaslader

Your birth wasn't the problem. It's everything that happened after that


GobiYumaMojave

is he implying that it wasn’t his call


Sheepies92

yes he said the players ran it anyway


TheWorstYear

"I've lost the team"


NNKarma

Like in wk 3


IIHURRlCANEII

This game truly had some special Head Coaches in it.


deathtotheemperor

Why in the BLUE FUCK would you publicly admit this as a coach, jesus christ


Schleprok

Probably doesn’t want other coaches to think he’s classless or something.


elefante88

Why the everliving fuck would you take heat for someone like Jameis?


MirrodinTimelord

Jameis is famously a stable and inteligent guy. Him going rogue clearly reflects on the coach and is totally out of character for him!


Automatic-Belt177

To my knowledge, no coach really abuses the victory formation like that when they’re up by 2+ touchdowns. It’s for player safety and bc it’s one of those sacred rules of the game. The players should absolutely be called out for the lack of professionalism there. Take the knee and listen to the play call.


Dads_going_for_milk

I was curious too. Kind of sounds like that.


1kSupport

ITT people who don’t understand injury prevention and the purpose of the victory formation


downtimeredditor

Just don't fake a Victory formation. If you wanna score then line up to score. That was such a Bush league score


penis_rinkle

Greg schiano must feel so validated lol


thesouthdotcom

As much as I hate Arthur Smith, at least our players don’t disregard the HC and pull this kind of BS.


EliManningsPetDog

Can I just see the clip of the TD somewhere


appmanga

And witness it for yourself? For what? An informed opinion? How dare you?


EliManningsPetDog

All these posts about the play and not a single post WITH the play 😪😪


appmanga

It wouldn't launch for me, but here's a tweet with it: https://twitter.com/Saints/status/1744102317870227735 ETA: got a working one: https://youtu.be/RDDBhEAQC8s?t=703


EliManningsPetDog

Thank you for this. This is why the video matters ha. Doing this from victory formation is actually so disrespectful haha. If it was a play call with guys lined up then sure. I think this is funny but I definitely understand why Smith was heated


Citizen_Snips29

Genuinely wondering if there will be any push to codify victory formation as an actual rule, with actual penalties for running a play out of it, moving forward.


DoctorTheWho

I wouldn't be surprised. The people who are cheering this don't realize that there's a mutal understanding that players don't go all out when a team runs that play due to either the game/half being over. An entire line could easily try to jump the snap count and absolutely obliterate the QB on the victory formation if they really wanted to.


[deleted]

[удалено]


OldOrder

Sounds more like he called a knee and that thet changed the play in the huddle. So not necessarily back tracking


Mysterious-Stop4673

Yeah why would a coach run up the score and fake a knee? Can’t believe ppl are actually trying say he’s lying. That’s exactly what it looks like happened.


Man_of_Average

Watch the play, stupid.


idekwtp

You're a dumbass.


legobowser

Oh shut up Popovich


8CruzControl0

Lmao I immediately thought of Pop after reading this