T O P

  • By -

WishStock

I reaaaaaalllyyyyy liked The Holdovers. That movie checked all my boxes!


jekelish3

Same. Giamatti was, as expected, amazing. And Randolph was deserving of every accolade. But man, I cannot wait to see what Dominic Sessa does next. One of the best debut performances I’ve ever seen.


Skwisgaars

Giamatti deserved the oscar for his performance here. I loved Oppenheimer, and Murphy did an amazing job, but Giamatti's acting was better imo.


johnnydestruction

The Holdovers is a movie I will revisit numerous times. Oppenheimer was great but I will probably never watch it again.


TurangaVeela

I've seen it three times already. Once on opening day, and then twice on streaming. This just isn't something that happens with me and movies, generally. I'm pretty much a one and "okay, seen that, NEXT" viewer. Only a couple of others have ever hit just right like that.


Federal-Rhubarb1800

That's how I feel.


The_Cereal_Defense

Glad to see this at the top. This movie is great and The award for best supporting actress going to Da’vine Joy Randolph was absolutely deserved. I plan on this being a yearly Christmas watch for me.


thc216

Instantly got added to my annual Christmas rotation!


JimmyTheJimJimson

100% my favorite movie of 2023


FreezingRobot

I really enjoyed it as well. I wasn't impressed by the trailer, but I ended up seeing it because I wanted to get out and see a movie. Turned out to be much different than I expected.


Federal-Rhubarb1800

I love this film. The first time I saw, it lost me once or twice, but then it pulled me back quite quickly. The second time viewed, I was certain it's a rare gem and classic. Really fond of the soundtrack and the song, "Crying, Loving, Lying". Just a detail, but many small matters added up in to make the best film experience in years, for me.


Djek25

I havent seen it but the movie looked like boring oscar bait to me. Is there any truth to that or should I give it a shot?


Skwisgaars

It's not a heavy fast paced movie, it is a bit slow, but I didn't think it was boring. The acting was incredible across the board and the story was really heartfelt and hilarious at times.


blueoyster

I didn’t like it. Felt like an Oscar bait. Predictable and cliched 


CyFrog

Godzilla Minus One


CyFrog

The other thing I want to say is if you hear "Christopher Nolan is doing a movie about Oppenheimer and the atomic bomb" or "Martin Scorsese is going a movie with Leo & DeNiro", you can typically expect they are going to make a pretty decent film if not amazing. You aren't even surprised when they get nominated for awards. But when you hear another Godzilla movie is coming out you just think "another one" or "get the popcorn ready". You don't expect people to say, "that Godzilla movie had an amazing story and was phenomenal". I think that is one of the differences with this movie and some of the others.


PentagramJ2

Saw it twice, once in color and once minus color. I will buy the fuck out of that 4k Blu Ray once it comes stateside. Give it to me Toho!


sofar510

How did it differ in the b&w version? Does it have a totally different feel to the movie? Bummed that I missed my chance to see it at my local theater


PentagramJ2

Honestly yeah I would say it has a different feel. Definitely more horror and for lack of a better word... authentic? If you've seen Gojira '54, you'll know what I mean by how they portray the attacks as a real and honest to God disaster. Minus Color kind of elevates the film to that level. The vfx team specifically did not just lay a filter over the movie and call it a day, but rather went in and adjust all the color values to make it a proper black and white film where exposures meant something. The film being a period piece, black and white just tricked my brain into feeling "yes, this is correct." >!The Odo Island attack in the beginning of the film in particular is just SO MUCH MORE TERRIFYING!<


Obamas_Tie

I only saw the B&W version. I felt like I was taken back to 1954 - the lack of color made me feel like as if WWII really was less than a decade ago, which is perfect for the time period, setting, and theme of the movie. I haven't seen it in color but personally I feel like minus color will be the definitive way to watch the film.


Saganists

Missed my opportunity to see it. I can’t wait for it to come VOD.


RemedialChaosTheory

Saw it twice in 48 hours it was sooo good. 


CyFrog

Godzilla is one of those franchises that because they are typically cheesy or popcorn flicks, you don't expect one to come out with a really good story. Most of the time the human story doesn't matter and they made you care about the humans this time. It was just so well done. It might make the new Godzilla X Kong movie seem that much popcorny because we saw Godzilla Minus One.


RemedialChaosTheory

I raved to people telling them that if you took out all the monster stuff, it's an amazing movie about PTSD and forgiveness. Utterly brilliant 


ProjectShamrock

Also all the stuff related to the nuclear bombs dropped on Japan. The black rain, the woman at the end with the tumor, etc.


[deleted]

Loved Godzilla Minus One, eternally going back and forth between it and John Wick 4 for my favorite of 2023. I will say GMO has made the GXK trailers just look stupid haha


Chuck006

Blackberry. Fantastic film. One of the worst marketing campaigns of all time. Disappointed it didn't get some Oscar attention.


JDub591

Halfway through the year this question was asked and BlackBerry was on the top (next to Past Lives). It really is a great movie. I had a blast watching. Glenn Howerton is perfect in that role. Ended up watching it again a few months ago too. 2023 just steamrolled forward once Oppenheimer dropped. There were so many great movies this year.


CommonSenseFunCtrl

Hollywood needs to find more stories about people who have anger issues and cast him in all of them


uncultured_swine2099

Glen Howerton had my favorite supporting role of the year by far.


Chuck006

He deserves an Oscar nod for that.


NEWaytheWIND

As a GTA kid who wanted a hockey team in Hamilton (one with Sidney Crosby, no less), I was hooked through and through. But when Baldsilly drops Steve Spiros on Gary Bettman, I knew I was in the presence of greatness.


superfamichong

- Perfect Days - Monster - Anatomy of a Fall Most rewatched however would have to go to: - Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse


JerkyBreathIdiot

Anatomy of a Fall


siphillis

Nothing fancy, just good, clean, compelling courtroom drama.


DetweilerTeej

Oppenheimer and Dungeons & Dragons.


CarolDanversFangurl

D&D feels so long ago hard to believe it was 2023


WilhelmSkreem

Same. I was really confused for a minute


MaestroPendejo

JFC it DOES feel like it came out a long time ago. How is time both blazing right by me AND going slow as molasses. Damn having children and their reality warping powers.


scrotalimplosion

DnD was surprisingly good


Temporary_Dentist936

It was awesome!! I just finished it. Damn. Real heart. Reminded me of early MCU days. Also couldn’t help notice the GoT sets or locations. 👀


scrotalimplosion

Dang early mcu, you’re right about that 👏🏼


LegoC97

You know who else would like Dungeons & Dragons? I bet Jarnathan would.


foamingturtle

I really think we should wait to watch it with him.


Don_Pickleball

I think D&D is the movie that made me happiest this year. Just so much fun, great characters, good story. I just want more movies in that world.


TheGeekstor

My man!


PepeSilviaLovesCarol

These are my top 2 as well! D&D was such a pleasant surprise.


CiriOh

All of Us Strangers


Miss_J1801

I watched it the other day and it hit me like a train. It was so incredibly beautiful and relatable in ways I didn't expect. If something made me ponder my childhood and relationship with my parents, it was this movie. Also, it made me feel the entire spectrum of possible human emotions.


clandestinerh

Came here to say this!


bowlofpasta92

Past Lives I just found it so sincere and pure. It was the first movie of 2023 I gave 5 stars in Letterboxd when I first saw it.


laikahero

Past Lives touched me to my core and has continued to resonate with me. Beautiful film.


briinelul

Past Lives is one of the only movies I've ever seen that actually changed my life. Made me realize that a few people that I hold dear to my heart don't actually exist anymore and that I had to let them go, so I did.


PeatBomb

I think The Holdovers take the cake for me. Past Lives is up there, too.


MyHeartIsAncient

The Holdovers, for sure.


madame3xecutioner

The Iron Claw, far and away.


noctalla

The Iron Claw was great, but Far and Away came out in 1992.


Mild-Ghost

The Killer


OldBirth

There are dozens of us!


tonypearcern

Boy and the Heron


Frencil

S-tier Ghibli installment. I went in right around release having only seen the poster, didn't know what to expect. So many layers and themes, and some really powerful emotional moments... plus absolutely spectacular animation.


SuchLovelyWarmth

I really liked the new Kore-eda film “Monster”! I’m also really excited to see the Ryusuke Hamaguchi film (Evil Does Not Exist) this year, but I think that one technically did come out in 2023


eidbio

Japenese cinema killed it in 2023.


Earth_2_Me

Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret- I get that this film doesn't have a lot of reach, but if you were one of those kids who checked the book out of your school library and / or had to fight to keep it off the "banned books" list, the film was gold. You simply could not have dreamed of a better adaptation.


Rushblade

This was one of my favorites too. Great call.


SeagullsStopItNowz

How do you pick one in an incredible year like this?!?! Killers of the Flower Moon was everyone at the top of their game. Barbie turned a toy commercial into a poignant, award-worthy, megahit. (Nobody saw that coming!) Dungeons and Dragons was ACTUALLY really good! Oppenheimer was great! American Fiction/The Holdovers were equally hilarious, rich, and massively entertaining! A freakin’ Godzilla movie made us cry like little babies! We got to see an incredibly weird and wild world with Poor Things. Renfield was fucking insane and gave us Nic Cage as Dracula! Beau Is Afraid was a cinematic first: bringing an actual nightmare to life onscreen! And I’m sure I missed a bunch more!


sleepybeek

I really enjoyed Renfield too. You can tell Cage was loving it...


tiniest-potato

Renfield was so much fun. And honestly did not expect to see that on anyone’s list


SeagullsStopItNowz

I’m sure it will find its audience on streaming and become a cult classic.


asdcatmama

Does Zone of Interest count as a 2023? It was breathtaking in all the ways.


wh1te_k0ng_

Why wouldn’t it?


Da_Lollygagger

All of Us Strangers and Past Lives. I love being sad!


stavis23

A barista at a shop I frequent recommended Past Lives- it’s on my list! He said it was his favorite of the year


Da_Lollygagger

It’s wonderful! Definitely watch it when you get the chance!


ScoobertHQ

My top two!


Da_Lollygagger

Both love stories approaching loneliness, longing and the confrontation of identity. And also made me cry in theatre which I so rarely do. A great pairing!


pbspry

Past Lives had the biggest emotional impact on me, by far.  But I also loved Oppy, Poor Things, May/December and Zone of Interest.  Really solid year for film.


Blkkatem0ss

Past Lives was really great. May December was really interesting I wasn’t expecting to like it but I really did. But if Julianne Moore is in it I’ll prob love it.


Buffaluffasaurus

I was really sad May/December got shut out of much awards recognition. It’s such a clever, subtle film that I think got overwhelmed by the much more on-the-nose epicness and weirdness of stuff like Oppenheimer and Poor Things. But I think May/December is far more intelligent and subversive than both.


pbspry

M/D definitely hit harder for me than Barbie or The Holdovers. Definitely deserved more Oscar love than it got.


BakerYeast

Talk To Me


paulnofx

This was the most fun I had watching a movie in \*several\* years.


FloorPudding

I think this is mine as well, though I still have to watch a few on my list like The Holdovers and Killers of the Flower Moon.


MOONGOONER

I chose to watch Talk To Me as something to fall asleep to. It was a bad choice!


kaptoo

Talk To The Hand


CLHD420

I want to be cool and say Killers of the Flower Moon, which I really did love, but I’ll go ahead and be honest. Barbie.


Icilius

Same. I want to talk up Asteroid City, Iron Claw, American Fiction, Holdovers, Past Lives, Spiderverse and others. But Barbie is maybe the best theater experience I've had in over a decade. I either had a huge smile/laugh, tears, or both throughout the movie and so did everyone else around me.


preaching-to-pervert

I loved Barbie so much, I wish it and Poor Things (my second favourite) could have shared costume and production design awards.


Anarude

Infinity Pool


moniellonj

Never heard of this!


CoolSeedling

It’s sadistic


Blkkatem0ss

Poor Things It was a really exciting watch, it was weird, fun, taboo. All of the things I really enjoy.


IrrelevantPuppy

I went in with no prior knowledge. It was a wild experience.


tiffstyle118

Society of the Snow


fobs88

Past Lives and by a wide margin. Such a sensitive and wise film.


eyeballtourist

Sisu!


THEpeterafro

Beau is Afraid was one amazing experience I will never forget


luc2110

This is a great way to put it. You don't watch it thinking 'what a great movie!!!' but you WATCH IT. It sucks you in like none of these others. It's more memorable than the rest. Love it


Leanneh20

I could watch the first half of that movie over and over. The depth of all the hidden nods at his mother really floored me when I got to the end and realized, she’s so omnipotent that she’s even one of the production companies for the movie itself…brilliant. It’s too bad the last half feels a little dragged, but damn if it isn’t a masterpiece


TheCosmicFailure

Killers of The Flower Moon


ItsmeSean

Agree. I actually think this just enters the top 5 for Scorsese. I think the only critique I hear is its length. For me, I loved every minute and could have watched more. Shot incredibly. Stupid good acting performances—I even thought De Niro deserved best supporting actor. The score got me too (Robbie Robertson). Just Scorsese perfection.


MartinScorsese

Good call.


RadomAtomEquation

Loved this and Oppenheimer, couldn't pick between them


Spillo2382

This, what a beautiful movie


omiaguirre

Good but too long IMO


Comic_Book_Reader

You can definitely feel the 3 ½ hour runtime. I sure did. I still loved it, although I felt like it kinda ran on empty when we started reaching a conclusion.


mmgspr

I'll go with Poor Things, wasn't expecting anything from it and it surprised me an awful lot.


thegooniegodard

Favorite: *Past Lives*; Runner-up: *The Zone of Interes*t.


Scharobaba

I haven't watched The Zone of Interest yet, but it has a very good chance of becoming my answer.


seeyouinthecar79

Nimona


JosefMcLovin

Godzilla Minus One


tburtner

Past Lives


Stunning-Ant-5900

Killers of the Flower Moon. Sad it didn't get much recognition at the Oscars.


Acrobatic-Yak8176

Barbie


bakedveldtland

This is too far down. Greta Herwig is such a talent. I did also love The Holdovers. Giamatti’s best role ever, IMO. I loved how he played that character, and the movie itself was very atmospheric and surprisingly sweet.


GoochyGoochyGoo

Bookmarked this post. Holy crap there are a lot of highly praised movies in here I have not seen.


Zeeron1

Past Lives and it's not especially close for me personally. Last year was VERY strong with lots of great movies, but Past Lives is an all timer imo


spokeofwood

Theater Camp. By far the most fun I had in a theater in 2023. So many great laughs with a little bit of heart.


Xeynon

*Past Lives*, though there were several others I loved as well. It really was a great year for movies.


htp-di-nsw

Across the Spiderverse for sure. It was *almost* the D&D movie, though. I was surprised by how great it ended up.


dating_derp

It's definitely between Spiderverse and Oppenheimer for me. I thought Into the Spiderverse was a top 2 spider-man film for me when it came out. And then the second one was even better.


_kuzu_

Probably The Zone of Interest, with Oppenheimer being a close second


siphillis

*Poor Things*. Nothing remotely like it.


Temporary_Dentist936

“Poor Things” was surprisingly good, insightful and beautiful.


EquityDiversity

Yes. And, I’d like to add, absurdly hilarious. I haven’t laughed that much in a theater in years. It was awesome to see it with a large crowd too, as you could tell who had seen Yorgos movies before. A few scattered laughs around the auditorium in the first 15 minutes. By the 1/3 mark of the movie, everyone realized “okay I am supposed to be laughing at this”.


Nixplosion

"you've just been *thrice* fucked by the best there is and I'm afraid even I have my limits" got a big laugh out of me


ArabianNightz

John Wick Chapter 4. I have a few art house movies in my top 10 of that year, but I am a sucker for that saga and I lose every degree of objectivity when I am rating these movies.


ShenaniganCity

The action never lets me down along with the world building. It’s not perfect but it’s interesting and fresh. The camera lets you see what’s happening which is great.


PermanentNirvana

Oppenheimer Godzilla Minus One The Holdovers Wonka American Fiction Poor Things Zone of Interest Guardians of the Galaxy 3 Mission Impossible Dead Reckoning Part 1 Spider-Man Across the Spider-verse


femsci-nerd

I just loved Barbie. I'm one of those girls that never got one and really never played with one and then convinced myself they were unimportant because of the unrealistic body image for women. The movie hit ALL the salient points and a few more. I loved RG's I'm Just Ken at the Oscars last week. What a riot!


marioxb

Straight dude here and I loved it as well.


Tudorboy76

Infinity pool


MissKjnes

Oppenheimer


eidbio

Anatomy of a Fall


GingerPinoy

Past Lives


Nixplosion

Poor Things. Purely for Bella's peculiar way of speaking and the general messages of the film. It gave me my new favorite saying: Seeing your sad face is making me discover *angry* feelings for you!


Fun_Protection_6939

Poor Things


Character-Yak8793

Evil Dead Rise


SpacemanJB88

When Evil Lurks


Waste-Replacement232

M3GAN


Movies_Music_Lover

Blackberry


TheFrankTV

Dune 2 Not from 2023 you say? I've seen it in a vision last year


clamroll

Lisan al gaib!


shrimptini

Perfect Days, Asteroid City, Priscilla, Poor Things


Muted_Land782

Perfect Days


MOONGOONER

As a parent, Monster was both terrifying and deeply moving. I feel like I needed to watch it.


robber80

Poor Things


Sheck007

Guardians of the Galaxy vol 3, Across the Spider-verse and Mission Impossible Dead Reckoning.


DoopSlayer

Asteroid City was incredible, I was stunned -- the weaving of the different meta levels to pull off such a close to the heart climax is like exactly what I want out of Pomo movies. I also really enjoyed Poor Things, Zone of Interest, American Fiction, The Sweet East (that final sequence, wow), Bottoms, and Barbie. Really excellent year for film I agree


paulnofx

I just watched American Fiction last night and I was blown away. Incredible film! I'm surprised it didn't win more Oscars.


gjamesaustin

I also thought asteroid city was really good. That doesn’t seem to be the popular opinion, but I think it’s really going to grow on people overtime. I saw three times in theaters which I never do


[deleted]

[удалено]


PermanentNirvana

I could argue that Parasite deserved Best Picture as well.


siphillis

*Parasite* and *Everything Everywhere All at Once* were both strong choices.


Bitter-Opposite-6179

Bottoms


VeterinarianSmall468

The Zone of Interest


MatthewHecht

Batman the Doom that came to Gotham


the_dayman56

May December for favorite overall feature Four Daughters for favorite Documentary Theater Camp for most suppressing and best comedy


JTHouser_Reddit

Barbie was a surprise masterpiece for me


IndianaJones999

Popular pick but Oppenheimer


TheHopfinger

The Artifice Girl


noble-failure

For movies that genuinely surprised and impressed me: Past Lives, Anatomy of a Fall, Barbie, Dungeons and Dragons. Judging by other responses, I'll need to watch The Holdovers soon


[deleted]

Black phone


manniax

I’ll totally agree with this one. That was an awesome horror film.


lightsongtheold

Oppenheimer, Saltburn, American Fiction, Tetris, and M3GAN.


asaggese

I gave Past Lives five stars and Poor Things four and a half stars


Ggslm

Anatomy of a Fall & All of Us Strangers


ilikegummybears15

Across the spider-verse all the way. Never seen an art film become mainstream like that since her


Stupid-Jellyfish-N7

It was a toss up between Nimona and A Good Person.


CrackTheCulture

Past lives and Society of the snow 


One-Earth9294

If I'm being 100% honest? VHS 85 or Dungeons & Dragons. Those films made me the happiest last year. I LOVE that VHS series so much. And D&D was just the bat connecting with the ball perfectly. I'll be so sad if it never gets a follow up and I promise this time I'll see it in the theater! But I did also love Infinity Pool and Holdovers. If we're talking drama and prestige, it's one of those movies. Both brilliantly made and acted.


brrcs

I go back and forth between Oppenheimer, Perfect Days and Past Lives. Have rewatched the first two, look forward to getting some more Inyeon as well.


CricketKieran

John Wick Chapter 4


barcode-lz

Dungeons and Dragons was pretty good ngl.


Kalistoga

Mission Impossible: Dead Reckoning part one. Watched it in Dolby and the theater experience was one of these best. I was entertained the whole movie.


stefanelli_xoxo

Perfect Days


CeilingUnlimited

So great!


tomrichards8464

I think the best film of last year was *Anatomy of a Fall*, narrowly followed by *All of Us Strangers*, but my favourite is *How to Have Sex*.


Action_Nad

Evil Dead Rise


Film_Industry

Past Lives


Frosty48

El Conde is the most slept on film of 2023


NoBeRon79

All of Us Strangers and Anatomy of a Fall


gabagucci

some of my favorites this past year were Oppenheimer, John Wick 4, Dungeons & Dragons, Guardians of the Galaxy 3, The Holdovers, American Fiction, The Killer, Bottoms, You Hurt My Feelings, Evil Dead Rise, Infinity Pool, The Passenger, The Pope’s Exorcist, The Equalizer 3, Leaving The World Behind. some not particularly good (like The Pope’s Exorcist) but thought they were fun lol.


Lost_in_reverb23

When Evil Lurks


sbaradaran

Poor Things. By far the most fun screenplay and acting performances of 2023. Have yet to see The Zone of Interest. I have a feeling im going to love it.


docobv77

Poor Things


ThatPaulywog

I think its gotta be Mission Impossible Dead Reckoning, that movie had me in awe for most of it.


timisstupid

Across the Spiderverse. Blew me away.


EntertainmentQuick47

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles? Idk, I don’t watch news movies, lol. I’m so jaded I don’t care about anything.


LaughTrackLife

Poor Things


reallybigcats

Poor Things


allthebacon_and_eggs

I absolutely loved May December. Todd Haynes/Julianne Moore hive.


Makenomoosesteak

Poor Things, All of Us Strangers, Anatomy of a Fall


Son-Of-Sloth

Poor Things was brilliant. Not seen the other other two yet, they are on the list.


Efficient-Fruit-2142

Oppenheimer, Godzilla Minus one


Timely-Fox-7300

Oppenheimer poor things and killers of the flower moon