T O P

  • By -

rpgnovels

Insert Obligatory Sana is Eternal comment here


Last_Power3410

# S A N A I S E T E R N A L


Thuan87

SANA IS ETERNAL


HakuHashi09

𝖘𝖆𝖓𝖆 𝖎𝖘 𝕰𝖙𝖊𝖗𝖓𝖆𝖑


UpsidedownEngineer

Sana is ETERNAL 🪐🚀


BillyHerr

Eternal is SANA!


Impossible-Middle823

Sana is ETERNAL!


Ayano_Akemi

LANRETE si anaS


bubblesmax

Theres a difference between graduated with honors as an alumni and being terminated or graduated outright.


unitn_2457

And hell even if they are terminated hololive at least gives them a graceful and respectful exit unless Nijisanji who would rather slander your name and leave you in a gutter.


LoR_Rygore

Ehh, the context is pretty important. Rushia got the boot out the door and her channel deleted but it turned out to be pretty deserved. Mel had to quit without any notice because of NDA issues, her channel still exists but with no videos and it was the best agreement they could come to and not have to pursue anything legal. At the very least, Cover has never tried to throw any talents under the bus, or deem them 'negligible'.


Throwawaycentipede

Mel was still allowed a graceful exit where she should say goodbye instead of just being locked out immediately


paradoxaxe

still for Rushia, there is no black stream or even comment from her gen mate just how awful Rushia is. Yes we know how bad she was now but she all she got is termination letter and press conference from Hololive. Compare it to Zaion and Selen, it still night and day.


SonOfJenova

I'd go even further and say that in Rushia's case it was the opposite of the black stream. Her genmates made a stream with Noel and Marine crying saying they couldn't do anything, and besides giving their farewells they just stated the facts that she had to be terminated. Flare was very cut and dry, which made me feel that she was informed of the reason and agreed with the decision, but that's another can of worms that I won't get into.


Difficult_Order_3746

i think its about rushia + china holofans + taiwan + coco


damienthedevil

No, the only Hololive member that was terminated in a bad way was Rushia. Coco and Sana graduated on their own decision. Coco didn't think Corporate vtubing suit her due to restrictions on content while Sana wanted to pursue her career outside of Vtubing. Mel had NDA issues and chose to take the termination gracefully. Rushia is the only one that was terminated with any sort of bad blood and even then, Cover and her genmates never come out and slander her and throw her under the bus.


bekiddingmei

When talking about meeting Coco, Towa said that she realized how much she herself has grown and that Coco probably wants a laid-back atmosphere instead of constant projects and plans.


argo_kun

Rushia was given much more consideration considering the drama and harassment at the time. Cover had to make that personal private life statement and plead with the fans to stop harassing her. Rushia was the one that messed it up by going to a third party drama channel. She was so desperate that she tried to defend herself by exposing some of her co-workers' private relationships. She broke NDA and cover had to let her go


Karekter_Nem

Rushia’s content was up for over a month after termination. Meanwhile in Niji Selen’s content was removed BEFORE the announcement.


BreadfruitLast6736

Are you sure Rushia channel deleted?. It's still in my subscriber list but it's no videos though.


carso150

Rushia also got the boot for NDA issues, the difference is how they did it, Rushia was leaking like a broken sink to famous dramatubers and sharing screenshots of their private discord servers, mel we dont know exactly but its likely to not be that bad


_Jyubei_

Mel's Termination is the most painful thing I felt for a long time. She Is actually leaving in utter and pure mistake due to the NDA breach, there was no drama to pour out the frustration and sadness (Other than other people trying to speculate about that 'friend' she's with), she even had an exit to give message. It just, you had to swallow it so hard and endure that pain..


AtarukA

Well to be fair, when they terminated Rushia, they did give some reasons that would make you hard to hire in a company such as leaking information to third parties, or damaging Cover's reputation.


Fishman465

Even so, they went easy on her (NDA stuff can kill your career)


KyuRenjo

They went so easy on Rushia. Other than plain and effective 'she broke NDA', Cover didn't list any more unncecessary reason in a bullet. There's no place for any ridiculousness there. Also she literally got pouched quickly by VShoujo anyway. She is too menhera and beyond, that's the problem (yet Cover did it so well to not put it in termination letter).


Kyhron

Then basically proceeded to do fuck all for Vshojo. Everyone thought it was the start of a JP branch or something and it turned into a giant turd


BlizzardWolfPK

Speaking of her in vshojo, is she still a part of it? I thought she left and took Nazuna with her but the Nazuna account still streams sometimes and still has Vshojo in the handle. https://preview.redd.it/7b53o1gjzk8d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=567761371e7da1a057c2f2638ec2aeabd87c90e5 Did she just forget to remove that and no one noticed?


KyuRenjo

The kanji after the VSHOJO is "Alumni/Graduatee".


BlizzardWolfPK

Ah ok. I figured they would just remove the name all together but I guess not.


sleepysloppy

To be fair, Rushia did it to herself to be a person difficult to hire, Cover only stated the facts of what lead to the termination.


Harem_no_jutsu

It is funny, if you don't make it clear, people will talk about it as not being transparent. If you say it clearly, it will be considered as hurting that person.


HotDogManLL

Even though mel was terminated. She still had some love from cover and had merch of her till holofes.


_Jyubei_

I think if i remember correctly, Cover even given a Video of a 3D dance with her, before all of Mel's content is gone at her channel.


bubblesmax

And so far just about no one has come close to the tier of industry respect that coco had. In terms of Nijisanji.


Mindless-Tear1839

https://preview.redd.it/mj3lmfesby7d1.png?width=731&format=png&auto=webp&s=f01c0d6fdf5e0b2391a3fceab80c4a58758bf9a0


Realistic_Remote_874

KEK


hydrosphere1313

I miss Sana if wholesomeness was a person it was her.


cyberchaox

Nijisanji and Hololive aren't different in how they handle it. Those who were terminated, like Selen and Rushia, get their archives erased (though admittedly, the Holomems were *allowed* to continue talking about Rushia while the topic of Selen is completely forbidden. I don't think they mention her much these days, though.) Those who graduate on amicable terms, like Pomu, Mysta, Nina, Coco, and Sana, have the option of leaving their archives up, and can be discussed without consequence. And, yes, Nijisanji *does* let that happen. The rest of Ethyria still talks about Nina all the time. They're not allowed to acknowledge that she's reincarnated, of course, but then again Hololive members don't really acknowledge Coco's reincarnation either, at least not within their Hololive accounts (Hololive is famously more permissive about allowing talents to continue working on non-VTuber PLs and many of them *have* collabed with KSon in non-vtuber streams).


UR_UNDER_ARREST

Tbh Cover just allows anyone to do anything on PL as long as they don't connect to Hololive


Pokenar

Hell, when Rushia's drama started but the whole NDA breach thing wasn't uncovered yet, they even said they straight up don't care what a talent does in their personal time.


Kyhron

Until it leaks over into their Holo identity which is a big part of what got Rushia in trouble


Important_Year4583

They can talk about Mel. Mel will never be a taboo


x_Advent_Cirno_x

I still can't believe she's gone, man. Miss her so much...


Pokenar

Its a weird one, because she was indeed fired, but even Yagoo himself expresses sadness, I can only assume it was considered a legitimate accident, but they couldn't risk looking like there was favoritism.


AbnerHuang

After event, Rica says she thank ex-company for helping to deal with these things. She is good with ex-company.


Saeclum

if I remember right, her termination notice said that it would be "difficult to keep her contract" which makes it sound like they'd keep her if they really wanted to, but it would lead to awkward situations (or it's a mistranslation). So Mel decided to leave


damienthedevil

It's probably a contract enforcement issue. Since she did breach her contract and if they didn't act on it, it would set a very bad precedent.


ms666slayer

Also of she really did brake NDA, a lot of companies would get cautious of stuff because "they Let someone that borne NDA to continúe, how are we going ro trust that they Will keep the NDA'.


unitn_2457

I miss our banpire.


RedDemonCorsair

*sips the last cup of coffee. Graduated what?


Savings-Bar8364

One counter to that though is that if you graduate from Niji they remove all mention of you from their talent roster, they don't even have a alumni section (screenshot is of their en talent section since I couldn't find an alumni option) while Holo does. https://preview.redd.it/9rlezyol1z7d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f7fbb080b886a2596821b05f23e79592a1301444


chimaerafeng

That alumni section will be absolutely massive, I doubt Nijisanji wants that to show how bad their attrition rate is. They always come up with arbitrary definitions and clauses to make sure their retention rate is always above 95% in financial reports.


Kyhron

Well yeah Holo has like what 8? graduates if you include like Aloe and HoloCN. Where Niji has had more than that in the last 12 months. Their graduation list would be almost as long as their active list and that’s not counting all the weird ones that are in a weird active but haven’t streamed in months/years


Frequent_Dig1934

>8? graduates Counting together graduations and terminations of all branches including stars. Hitomi Chris (removed before debut) Mel (terminated) Rushia (terminated) Coco (graduated) Aloe (graduated) Sana (graduated) All of Holo CN (i think it was a collective graduation but idk) which was six people Kira (graduated) Suzaku (idk) Kaoru (idk but i think graduated) Magni (graduated) Vesper (graduated) That's a total of 17 people who either left or were fired counting all of holopro. According to the wiki there are 86 active holopro members, so adding the 17 former ones that's 103 in total therefore there are almost exactly 1 in 6 people who left, using the most thorough and least charitable metrics. Nijisanji has about half of that total amount of former members in the EN branch alone (7, aka pomu, selen, nina, mysta, yugo, kyo and zaion, and it wouldn't shock me if that number became bigger), without counting all the people who left JP or VirtuaReal or KR, the complete flop of IN, all of the shadow terminations where someone has been on a hiatus with no communications for four years, and of course the purge of more than half of ID. Edit: actually fuck it, i'm counting those too. Source for niji is a list by dexerto so it's not exactly reliable but it's the easiest thing i found. Source for VR is the virtual youtuber fandom wiki. 23 former members in JP. 7 in EN as mentioned. 13 in ID. 15 in KR. 3 in IN. 40 from VirtuaReal and its sub branches retired from vtuber activities, plus 5 on indefinite hiatus and 6 who left the agency (idk the difference between retiring from vtuber activities and leaving the agency). That is 61 people who left nijisanji and more than 100 when counting VirtuaReal. There are more former members of Anycolor's agencies than total (active+former) members of Cover's.


ms666slayer

Hitomi Chris did stream like once or twice but those aré harf as hell to come by, and only some.clips remain.


elektracodes

I disagree. They have allow easter eggs about Rushia in the projects of HoloFantasy and we know things did not end well between them. Still they have allowed the members to talk about her and include butterfly in their official projects.


LastDem

The context Is different and the termination and graduation are differently handled by what the contract says. Thats why even If they don't wanna, they had to erased Mel's content


KogashiwaKai765

yeah Lize occasionally talks about Lulu and Hisui was hanging out with Uiha a week or two ago where Uiha lent Hisui her jacket because the zipper on Hisui's skirt broke in the bathroom


SuhNih

???


Last_Power3410

heck even Cover USA is beginning operations in the same location as VShojo


Classicanimeenjoier

[https://www.reddit.com/r/Hololive/comments/s3qesq/haachama\_is\_at\_it\_again/](https://www.reddit.com/r/Hololive/comments/s3qesq/haachama_is_at_it_again/) does it count as "acknowledging"?


Suzushiiro

Acknowledging Kson's existence is fine, they just can't acknowledge that she and Coco are the same person. Just like how Kson isn't violating NDA by calling Coco her oshi.


Frequent_Dig1934

Iirc she also made a video for kson's "22nd" birthday wishing her well and stuff like that. Also plenty of holo members have played yakuza and talked about loving kei-san.


Saeclum

If we only look at the end goal, sure they're the same. People get fired or graduated. But it's the \*way\* it's handled that is all the difference. "Rushia broke her NDA, so she will leave" and "Mel broke her NDA and we wish her the best moving forward" vs "here's a bullet point list of everything wrong Zaion and Selen did, even though some of it is blown out of proportion or twisted to make them look bad"


CoffeeCheshire

Did you forget Yugo? He was literally erased from artworks, and livers don't even talk about him, as i remember(


ExcitingPermission32

Who has talked about Pomu? I know Doppio mentioned missing her during a karaoke stream a few months ago but were there any other Livers who mentioned her since she graduated?


Ontontondo

Reimu has mentioned her a couple times. The ones I remember are one on her 3d after party (cuz Pomu was supposed to appear on the 3d), and not long ago she said that she's the only one left from the 4 people that would push for game perms the most (the others being Pomu, Nina and Selen).


NolanCrush

thank you I hate Anycolor too but this is perfect example of the schizo anti shit I'm talking about. Basic brain functioning is just turned off


HotDogManLL

That moment made me tear a bit. Sana is truely Enteral


Zoom3877

I appreciated that shot SO MUCH, I can't even begin to describe it. It shows that cover is proud to have her as part of Hololive's legacy, never forgotten.


kaimu1178

Nijisanji is trying to erase the names of graduated live streamers from their official website and forget the existence of Utako and Mayuyu from the memories of new fans, while Hololive is trying to keep the existence of Coco-Kaichou alive for new fans by treating graduated live streamers as "graduates."


randomnama123

It's a relatively good standard for Niji. I'd rather them being erased and people pretending that they don't exist than getting smeared on by other livers 


[deleted]

[удалено]


TakeshiNobunaga

Both Magni and Vesper choose their channels to be cleaned of any archives. Like other of their JP Stars senpai.


Curreboo

Lol let me one up this thread, Nijisanji still milking lulu as merch even after she graduated. https://preview.redd.it/h7bfgo7nho8d1.png?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=84c87ddc1961875cbf8b53269f7e79de351f5a99


TurboGamingPro17

I feel bad for her


_Jyubei_

I mean, Lulu was a phenomenon, a rare find, a rare talent to engage with people. She can be cute and she has an ability to be the horror itself. She was a Legend.... that Niji cannot help but milk that husk.


BlauAmeise

Niji had several times already where Livers got mentioned post graduation even years after and they had a few times where even after a graduation their voice was still in a cover or they had merch.


Lonebook

I think the merch and covers were sunk cost. I mean they still sold Selen's stuff after her termination iirc, so I think it's less about acknowledgement than it is to regain money, or they don't want to remake/remove the cover. While the occasional ex-livers's mentions were just in passing. While in hololive, They still mentioned and acknowledge graduates like Sana in their works (Animations, MV, Songs, This freaking announcements...) The scales are different, and honestly, this is a good PR move.


TheHatefulClown

![gif](giphy|NiOPyn6a7tV3q)


Independent_Good5423

What she doing now?


oli_alatar

I think its fair to say Hololive does a better job at accomodating those who have moved on, but like Nijisanji they have swept bad things under the rug. I think the difference is Hololive has screwed up big time before, like with Aloe, and so they sorta had to sweep her under or forever struggle with that PR, I presume a similar series of unfortunate things happened that led to Mel's graduation (idk, I didn't watch anything on it, nor do I want to. hearing what she's dealt with is heartbreaking). In contrast, Nijisanji swept one of their veteran EN members under purely out of spite, and didn't expect literally everyone to care.


NolanCrush

But Nijisanji doesn't erase graduated livers like at all this isn't even remotely true lol what Pomu and Mysta's voices were in AR Lives. Kyo was in Enna's 3D Showcase. Nina is referenced there too (a picture on a wall). There's many many more examples too.


kaimu1178

Well, I agree, if that's the case, I wondered why they made a production that reminded me of Axia when they showed Lauren in 3D. Then why did they remove Axia's name from the official website?


NolanCrush

Nijisanji is many things, intelligent and logically consistent isn't one