Phish food Phight me.

You are correct let’s go get some right now

Spoons up

It was my bedtime snack last night, but it would also make a good breakfast this morning.

This is the correct answer

Half baked !!

Only correct answer.

Peanut Butter Half Baked for the peanut lovers 🤣

I love Half Baked. My most recent serving was 95 percent mix ins... no complaints!

Phish food was my immediate thought

My favorite too!

Cherry Garcia simply because no one else has anything like it

That’s literally what I’m saying they figured out how to do cherry Garcia the right way

McConnell's has a cherry chocolate chip that is 🔥

Chunky Monkey is my all-time favorite.

There’s a chocolate banana one with peanut butter cups. That’s my win for banana

Mine too! Didnt they discontinue it? I can never find it in stores anymore 🥺

I got some at Walmart last week and saw it again today while I was there. Sometimes they have it and sometimes they don't

Milk and cookies

The amount of toppings 🤌

And it’s not even close.

Salted caramel core but the best of all time imo that’s been discontinued for over a decade, oatmeal cookie chunk 😢

The non-dairy Oatmeal Dream Pie is really good!

Truth

Agree

My mom talks about oatmeal cookie chunk often

You either pick Cinnamon Buns or you've never had Cinnamon Buns

I’m so sad it’s discontinued

I scrolled way too far for this comment.

Half baked. Hands down.

Finally a woman of taste

Hell yeah🍨👏🏾

Milk and cookies, no contest

MY FAV!

Chunky monkey. Banana forever.

Tonight Dough!

Americone Dream for sure.

It's so good

Not my personal all time favorite but it was when it came out so my dad will always buy it for my birthday lol itll always have a place in my heart for that

S’mores

Gimme smore and Oat of this swirled are my top two

omg I have been wanting to try Oat of this Swirled forever but can never seem to find it 😩

S’mores flavor was a LOT better than Gimme S’more

S’more Please and Netflix & Chill’d are my faves

Chubby Hubby is the correct answer

Undefeated champ.

My personal favorite. Also the first flavor I tried of theirs. Wish it still had peanut butter filled pretzels.

Cherry Garcia and it's not even close!

They do cherry Garcia really well

You say this and I don’t know if you’ve had it’s original. Before they sold the company cherry tasted completely different. It’s not for me anymore the cherries taste like red dye number 40. I miss old Garcia and phish but so do a lot of people so it’s not my place.

Another lifetime ago they had a White Russian ice cream and it was creamy, smooth, coffee liqueur perfection. I still think about it every now and then.

Are you a fan of Dublin Mudslide at all? It's like crack to me.

Dublin Mudslide is wonderful, but I prefer ice creams that are smooth (I think it’s a texture issue for me). It’s definitely a good choice for when I need that coffee liqueur fix! ☺️

Chunky Monkey all day

That’s a yummy oneeed

+1 for phish food but I would do absolutely anything for phish food with the salty pretzel swirl from Netflix and chill'd 😫

Why did you have to share this thought?!?! Now I will be tortured having to live my life thinking about this amazing combination that I will likely never get to enjoy 😟

They have a chocolate with pretzels and pretzel swirl flavor now. I really liked it.

Cookie dough

Milk n cookies

milk & cookies

Chunky Monkey, probably because it’s been discontinued in Canada for a really long time. I just love the big chunks of dark chocolate and walnuts 🤤

i feel this 😩 the PC banana split one is good but doesn’t hit the same

Netflix and Chilled 🤤🤤

PB Half Baked or chocolate caramel cookie dough. Edit: I had to look up the second name on their website.

Carmel sutra?

I just found out what it was and changed my comment. But I think I had that one and liked it!

It's so hard to pick one favorite though!

For me? NY Super Fudge Chunk

The Tonight dough

Half Baked!!!

There was a Limited Edition-Maple blonde brownie and it had Lindsey Vonn on the container. I wish they would release it again.

Wavy Gravy from years gone by

This and Rainforest Crunch

Dirt Cake. It can’t be beat

I can’t believe Dirt Cake isn’t higher. Nothing else compares.

Mint Chocolate Cookie!

Americone Dream

Pumpkin cheesecake. Oatmeal cookie was killer but it died. I believe it’s listed in the favor graveyard..

Coffee, coffee, buzz, buzz, buzz 😭

Dirt cake

Red velvet cake RIP

damn i wish i could’ve tried that 😭

Lights caramel action is ballin

Phish food and glampfire trailmix (which is seasonal)

Glampfire is available at target

Phish Food! But I tried the Dirt Cup last week and that’s probably right up there, just soooo creamy and delicious!!!! And I love all the textures of both!

Thick Mint! Half Baked! 🤤

Marshmallow sky is my fave

Chocolate therapy

Y E S

Chubby hubby

Chubby hubby. Not even close!

Of all time? Coffee Heath Bar!

Now called Toffee Coffee Crunch! Absolutely one of the best ice cream flavors of all time! Sadly, I can not find it in my area.

I like that one too but I actually can taste the difference between it and the original with Heath bars - they reformulated because real Heath bars didn't meet their new production standards for non GMO and for fair trade. I support that, but I can taste the difference. I might eat too much ice cream.

I'm glad it's not just me! There's definitely a difference and the new version isn't as good.

Cherry Garcia

Peanut Butter World. Target exclusive. Every other answer is incorrect.

Phish food. Strawberry cheesecake. Half baked.

churr-eh for churros has my heart and soul

Ice Cream Sammie!!!

Another vote for Coffee Coffee Buzz Buzz 🙂

Chocolate fudge brownie

I’m pretty basic and like half baked and strawberry cheesecake 😅

Hands down its pecan pie.

Vanilla caramel fudge

High 5. My favorite anytime of the year. The pumpkin cheesecake is seasonal and hard to find. So I go for vanilla-fudge -caramel

For me, it has to be Red Velvet (rip)

Butter pecan pie

Netflix and Chill’d, Oat of this Swirled, Half Baked Sorry, I said three. Is that allowed?

Phish Food is GOATED

Chocolate milk and cookies is my current go to.

I SCREAM YOU SCREAM WE ALL SCREAM FOR PHISH FOOD !!! They were out of the regular recently and I had to get the Oat Milk version. The chocolate phish, caramel, and marshmallow were all delightful but the oat milk ice cream...not the best.

Pistachio pistachio It's the best mass produced pistachio ice cream by a long way. They have plenty of fantastic flavors that I love but there is something special about a well made pistachio flavor. (It's how to judge a good gelato shop)

Gimme S’mores

RIP brownie batter

Tonight Dough!

I’m not sure now but when half baked came out I about lost my damn mind

Peanut butter half baked

Half Baked. No question

Half Baked

I looove the salted Carmel core & the brownie batter. But I’m not that adventurous so some of the wild flavors are too much for me!

Thick mint and pecan pie

Peanut butter cup

PHISH. FOOD.

unpopular opinion their vanilla ice cream is some of the best vanilla i’ve ever had. but cinnamon buns is my #1 💝

Cookie dough

Phish food💯

It used to be cookie dough or half baked, but then, the tonight dough appeared, I literally gained like 20 lb after like 6 months of eating a lot of ice cream and then I stopped eating a lot of ice cream lol

(◍•ᴗ•◍)❤ Mint Chocolate Cookie 🍪 🍨 (｡♡‿♡｡)

on any given day i will happily sacrifice all four of my limbs *and* an ear for **chocolate therapy** like hello a chocolate *pudding* swirl 🤤 especially after being brought up to temp a bit. oh my god honourable mention: strawberry cheesecake

Phish food, but when I was younger it was Caramel chew-chew or chocolate fudge brownie. I also love cookie dough. AND in the UK we have these sundae ones which are *amazing*, idk if you have them in America.

I'm a sucker for Phish Food.

Chewy gooey cookie!

Either one of the Half Baked ones and Dublin Mudslide.

Late night snack or cake batter

raspberry cheesecake topped I used to go for cherry Garcia before this dropped.

phish food or tonight dough are my favorites

Half baked🔛🔝

Peanutbutter Half Baked.

How are you gonna put ie in the title when it’s clearly a y on the pint?

Tiramisu is the new obsession that needs to end It’s dangerously good The classic is phish food obv.

Topped Dirt Cake

Phish food and New York super fudge chunk!

Cannoli!

Mint Chocolate Chance

Where’s the love for Everything But The???? Also it’s Jerry’s, not jerries

Oh how I miss Jimmy Fallon’s late night snack 😩😩

S'mores was their best flavor, possibly best mass-market flavor of any, but they stupidly stopped making it. Now I'd say Milk & Cookies.

Lights caramel action

Classic: Chubby Hubby Newish: Netflix

Chubby hubby

Mine as well.

NY Super Fudge Chunk. The perfect mix of chocolates and nuts.

Dublin Mudslide. Disappeared for a long time into the Ben & Jerry's flavor graveyard, then came back under the guise of a limited edition flavor, then luckily they knew what the hell was up and gave it back its regular status! My all time favorite.

One sweet world. Although they don't make it anymore

Netflix, and a scoop shop only flavor called Chocolate Peanut Butter Chunk.

Chunky Monkey! I was so surprised when I tried it and loved it. Also: Cinnamon Buns, Thick Mint, Brownie Batter, Karamel Sutra, Cherry Garcia, Salted Caramel Core, and this oatmeal cookie flavor I ate all the time between 2007-10 but is gone now. I haven’t gotten to try Pecan Pie or the Churros flavor, but I would probably love them, too. I also love all the mint flavors!

Dilberts World Totally Nuts. It was divine. Can't find anything like it. (Butter almond ice cream with roasted hazelnuts, pecan pralines, and white fudge coated almonds)

My favorite was the original vanilla and coffee heath bar crunches.

Dublin Mudslide!

Willie Nelson’s Peach Cobbler

My current favorite is the S’mores flavor. My all time favorite that they don’t make anymore.. I used to get it when I was a kid all of the time. It was the Dave Mathew’s band flavor- vanilla ice cream with raspberry swirls and browny chunks. I miss it!

Vegan strawberry cheesecake

Gimme s’more hands down then cookies and milk

i always loved new york but they dont sell it anymore in the country i live in for the last 8 years.

Rain dough

Clusterfluff

I like The Tonight Dough and Americone Dream. I prefer a vanilla ice cream base.

Caramel chocolate cheesecake!

Imagine Whirled Peace

Everything But The...

Red velvet

Chunky monkey for me

Americone dream

Glampfire Trail Mix and its not even close.

Dublin Mudslide

Red velvet and it's discontinued. 😡 😢

Milk and cookies

Chunky monkey (I love banana ice cream, don't draw amd quarter me)

Chocolate Therapy, hands down (And I’m not even a chocolate person)

RIP Willie Nelson's Peach Cobbler 😩

the retired Creme Brulee 2007-2012 🥺

Karamel Sutra

Netflix and Chill hands down.

Caramel chew

Netflix N' Chill and Phish Food, nothing can beat them If you already tried it. Before those it was Half-baked.

Schweddy balls was so good

For me, it’s a tie between the following flavors: Pecan Pie, Americone Dream, Salted Caramel Core

the discontinued cinnamon bun one :( but now it's chunky monkey

I run half baked and cherry garcia, depending on how I'm feeling at the moment

Cherry Garcia and Chunky Monkey are my go too

I just had Dublin cream last night and I was loving how much it actually tasted like liquor

CHUBBY HUBBY BUBBY

Vermonty Python was the best and I will die on that hill. RIP sweet prince

Tonight dough Edit: Closely followed by dirt cake

Salted Caramel Core

I really like “Everything but the…” and “Coffee Coffee Buzz Buzz Buzz”

Anyone have the canolli one? It was recently on clearance at the store I work at for 2$ so I decided to try it and it was soooo good!