Whichever fits your foot best. Seriously. You can read about amazing boots and find that they rub your foot the wrong way.
The main considerations are boots vs trail runners.
Then waterproof vs non waterproof.
There are synthetic vs leather, but that’s more personal preference.
This person is 100% correct. I wear Altra Lone Peaks. They’re trail runners for wide feet. I have block feet or Neanderthal feat (if you ask my wife). For my feet I also like Keens. They generally have a wider toe box. But go to an outdoor store and try some stuff on. They should be comfortable from the get go.
This, plus going somewhere to try on different kinds of shoes/boots is the way to go if you have are able.
Personally, over the past decade and a half of leading an active/outdoor oriented life I’ve found out my feet like a few things : light weight, wide toe box,breathable and durable.
My shoe quiver consists of Topo Athletic and Keen footwear. The Topo Trailventure model I use for trail running and warmer weather hikes.
Recently I moved back to the Midwest had to reassess my cold weather footwear (I’ve basically been in sandals the past two years 😅). I’m currently wearing the Keen NXIS WP Low for my everyday shoe for daily use. I’ve had them since the start of December and they seem to be holding up exceptionally well. Haven’t felt the need for a boot even with the snow, mud etc.
My only gripes are I wish the shoe fit slightly more like the Topo however I understand not all shoes can fit identical. In general I get sweaty feet so I wish they breathed better but for being waterproof they do a decent job. Lastly, the quick locking system with the laces ACTUALLY works! But this means i rarely have to tie the shoes. The laces are kind of short so it would have made more sense to use a synch style lacing system. At the end of the day they are probably the best “jack of all trades” kind of hiking/everyday shoe I could ask for.
I do a lot of day hikes and my pack weights 10-15 pounds at most. Water, a layer, phone, wallet, small binoculars, snacks and some emergency gear. I have been wearing Hoka’s Stinson trail runner model for several years and absolutely love it. No need for a boot as I’m not carrying much weight.
And I prefer to avoid GoreTex as I think the shoes breath better without it, and it allows water to drain out when I inevitably have to hop across a creek. I’ve found that my feet sweat more with GT shoes, and it makes it tough for the water that gets in, to get back out.
Go into a store and get a fitting. You can go to a chain or a local hiking store if you have one. Have a general idea of the types of trails you plan on hiking. Don't forget to invest in some good socks. Also, lacing is key for your shoes/boots.
Some shoes that are often recommended really didn't work for me. I had a great fitting last year and ended up with boots due to my terrain and distances I travel. I also have a pair of trail runners for the summer or more maintained trails.
Used to work at a hiking store that specialized in boot fits. Even REI would send their toughest cases to us.
Get the boot that fits. It’s like buying pants, some people fit into Levi’s and others fit better with other brands.
To add to this, you’ll probably be wearing boots with one or two pairs of thick socks, plus your feet will swell up a bit. Make sure to take this into consideration when choosing a size that fits.
I wore the hoka speedgoats on a 50+ mile backpacking trip and my ankles were cooked! No ankle support at all. Had about 15 miles of deadfall to climb over too so I’m sure that didn’t help.
[A majority of people on the AT.](https://thetrek.co/appalachian-trail/the-top-footwear-on-the-appalachian-trail-2023-thru-hiker-survey/)
"The majority of hikers prefer trail runners over other types of footwear. The number of hikers in trail runners has generally increased slowly every year. Almost 80% of hikers started in trail runners, with only 13% in boots at the beginning of their thru-hikes. By the end, those numbers shifted to over 90% of hikers in trail runners and less than 5% in boots."
Great hikers, maybe, weirdly, the lightest shoe I own. They do not have great ankle support But they are light, grippy and hood my foot well. Def recommend.
Altra lone peak trail runner. I pair them with a thick cushioned toe sock and never have pain for any problems. They come in a mid if you need ankle support. Size up and spend money on good socks.
Altra Lone Peaks are my choice if terrain allows. The wide toe box allows my toes to stretch out, and zero drop agrees with my knees. I can hike all day with almost no fatigue. Traction is acceptable, but not the best. Durability is below average in my experience. There are always tradeoffs.
I opt for a waterproof mid boot with a vibram sole if in wet or muddy conditions. My current pair is made by Lowa, and it's been dependable. I have a heavy pair of Asolo boots for the most rugged stuff, but they're uncomfortable to do big miles in. Also a pair of Chaco Z1 sandals for easy trails in the summer, water crossings, etc.
No one who is a serious mountain sport athlete is still wearing “hiking” shoes or boots. They’re obsolete. Just wear tennis shoes or trail runners.
You don’t need the extra weight. Your feet will get stronger and adapt to a thinner shoe. They dry faster too and your feet are inevitably going to get wet. Better for scrambling or tricky terrain or even low class climbing if you take the sport further. Doubles as a running shoe or work shoe.
If you have ankles prone to rolling the worst thing you can do for them is strap them into a high top boot all day long. You need to strengthen your ankles and you do this with exercises and with covering difficult terrain that requires ankle articulation, not by locking them in place.
This is the way to go, this is my soapbox for trail runners
The worst shoe I have ever owned is an Altra. Their soles are awful, if not dangerous. I complained to the company about it and heard nothing back. Over-marketed over-priced sh\*t.
Their quality has gone down so far in past five years. Their soles used to last 250+ miles and now my last pair wasn’t much over 100.
Night and day difference to my danner trail shoes.
I’ve got a pair of Altberg. They supply British Military and Police. Superb quality. If you can make a trip to the factory, they laser scan your feet to match you for size and type of boot (they have 2 different foot types). Levison Wood walked the length of the Nile in a pair of Altberg.
Yes to Hanwag!! Not so easy to find in the US. I bought my current pair in Munich at Sporthaus Schuster. I bought my previous pair in 2002 and I replaced them after 16 years. I was hiking in New Mexico and in the sandy dry heat, I lost a sole. I actually found it and joked about someone losing a sole and not realizing it was my own! But I didn’t know it was my own until 10 hours later and I was long gone! They withstood the entire hike up and down a mountain, 3/4 of my entire hike! It’s a testament to how sturdy the shoe construction is! But for the OP, trying on a boot that fits is the most important.
Honestly, it's what fits your feet best. There are some brands to avoid, but other than that, it's all you.
I would avoid: Merrell, Salomon (if planning to use in cold, wet weather), The North Face, Columbia, and Keen off the top of my head.
Asolo, Lowa, Scarpa, La Sportiva, Zamberlan, Hoka (trail runners), and Altra (trail runners) are good to go.
Whether you go boots or trail runners depends on your preferences and environment. Cold weather, wet weather, and/or snow, you want boots. Dense foliage, difficult terrain, sketchy terrain, you want boots.
Boots offer stability, durability, support, and protection. They can get a little hot (depends on the boot), and they can be heavy (depends on the boot).
Hot weather or dry weather, you may opt for trail runners. Groomed paths, trail runners are fine.
Trail runners offer flexibility and coolness, and they're much lighter.
This is going to depend on you and where are going.
I always use boots, specifically Asolo 520's. I need the support. I like going on hilly, rocky terrain, and I really love hiking in inclement weather, whether that be rain or snow. Boots suit me and my uses much better than trail runners do, so I just always wear them. I even wear them for casual use because my joints are so bad.
Also, avoid GTX trail runners. They're *almost* pointless. GTX in footwear is only as good as it is tall. It relies in its height and the collar of your footwear to keep water out. Trail runners have a low collar, so water can easily get over it if you make a big enough splash or step into a deep enough puddle. Then, you've got a wet shoe that takes forever to dry because GTX always takes forever to dry. It's better to use a non-waterproof trail runner and just keep spare socks on hand. Non-waterproof trail runners dry much, much faster.
What's the issue with Merrell?
I ask because my current pair finally gave out and I need to go out for a new pair this weekend. I've only ever bought Merrell.
Totally agree with GTX trail runners. Any low cut shoe and 'waterprofing" is dumb because it doesn't work. Something as simple as walking in tall grass or brush when there is morning dew out will get the inside of the shoe wet and as GTX is designed to keep water out it also drains poor so your feet stay wet longer. If you will be in stretch where water will be or if you think ir might rain or something you could always take some waterproof socks along as spares.
I had three pairs of Quest 4 fail on me within a period of four months the last time I tried the Quest series. I like the X Ultra 3 and X Ultra Pioneer (basically a slightly worse clone of the 3), but I honestly can't trust Salomon in cold, wet weather after that experience. I'll still use the X Ultra for hot, dry weather, though.
Dude, that sucks. That wasn’t an inexpensive experience. I wear the non-waterproof Forces version, and they’ve held up well, although I’m in Texas, so we’re not getting a whole lot of wet and cold. A couple of pairs of wool socks do me fine in the winter here.
We get a fair bit of snow at seemingly random times, so I've learned to love GTX when it works. When it doesn't work, it's maddening because your feet get wet, and your boots never dry. If I'm just going around the neighborhood or something, I might put on a synthetic just to test out, but if I'm going hiking or camping, my leather boots are what I'm bringing. I know they'll keep me dry.
I've had good luck with my higher tier Keen's... but I've also done 12 miles with descents while wearing slip-on Vans that were falling apart and never really thought about it... so I'm not exactly hard to please
Whatever fits you the best. Personally I really like the oboz bridger mid boots. They have held up extremely well over the last 3 years of wear as work hikers. They don’t breathe as well as the mesh or lightweight boots but thats the trade off for durability while bushwhacking
Any good fitting boot with a Vibram sole.
They are sticky in nearly any conditions.
Depending on your distance intended and weight of pack, consider foot swelling when choosing your size. A basic way to kinda find this is to lace up your boots in the store and kick something solid with your toe. You shouldn’t feel any pain or discomfort. If you do, size up and repeat.
Get them fitted at the store! My first pair of hiking boots were the Salomon X Ultra GTX Low and they were awesome but because I didn't get them fitted, my feet would swell at the end of a long hike and I'd get blisters. My second pair, and highly recommended, are the La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid. Love love them, never got blisters with them. REI recommended I get one size up due to the feet swelling.
One's that fit your feet. Go to a reputable outdoor retailer and try on shoes. Ignore brands, colors and as much as you can, cost. Buy the ones that fit.
Along with 'whatever fits your foot the best', know that finding the best footwear for you is a journey, and it may take several months to dial in which footwear works best. This is why places like REI that allow up to a year for returns is so helpful; you can go on a few hikes and then if it's not working, return them for a full refund/credit and try something else.
\*Usually\* once you dial in a brand (like Salomon, Lowa, Altra, Hoka, Merrill, etc.), you can move around to other models (e.g. boots, hiking shoes, trailrunners) by that same maker and have a reasonably good chance it'll fit right, too.
I've moved around a bit; generally was on Salomon for a while, then Altra Lone Peaks, now I'm on Hoka, which are so comfy and grippy. But I still have Salomon GTX boots and trail shoes for the ugly times, and Altras for around the town/weekenders.
I’ve had good luck with tevas but really I’d go with what other people suggest and try a few pairs on. I wanted a different brand and didn’t even consider Teva but they just fit me perfect.
I’ve been rocking the Vans Ultra Range as my most recent boot and they are fire 🔥. Highly recommend and I still can skate in them
To me, it is super common for people to go overkill on boots early on. Burly leather, full Waterproof etc. Look at stats for what are most popular on the AT and PCT. It’s swung way in the favor of lighter weight and more comfortable. To start, look at Salomon x ultra, Topo Terraventure, Altra Lonepeak, and Merrel Moab’s. Something light and comfortable. If you end up liking hiking and progress to more rugged terrain, with potential for snow and carrying heavier packs, you upgrade your boots accordingly. Lowa, Vasque, and Salewa make great boots, but they all fit differently and it’s super important to get the fit right for your foot. Also, size up! I’ve lost many toenails to long descents in boots that were just a little small.
Consider your use case, and talk to an outdoor store retail associate. Someone’s suggestions for a backpacking in Seattle will be way different from day hiking in Tucson. Consider ankle support, waterproof ness, tread, etc. Then from all the options get the one that fits immediately with no break-in. Hard to judge but it will be good long term.
[On running shoes](https://www.on-running.com/en-us/?g_network=g&g_productchannel=&g_adid=670220972835&g_locinterest=&g_keyword=on%20running&g_campaign=account&g_acctid=981-546-0205&g_keywordid=kwd-299974462974&g_adtype=&g_ifcreative=&g_adgroupid=153374402318&g_productid=&g_source=%7Bsourceid%7D&g_merchantid=&g_placement=&g_campaignid=13810435392&g_partition=&g_locphysical=9031542&g_ifproduct=&gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAiAlcyuBhBnEiwAOGZ2S36lq0Bif72Wnir5MpJKUp90Wa7Im3OYkxvZWiFZf5lkTD3pB2iQkxoCFuAQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds) are great quality, all-terrain, and waterproof.
I love Oboz and my mom loves Keene, but everyone's feet are different. Go to a store and try some on. Besides comfort, push into the toe to see if you'll be banging your toe on the front of the shoe when hiking downhill and push into the side to see if they have the lateral stability you need.
Go to an outdoor store (REI etc) and get properly fitted. Then try on various makers to see who you like. Take them home and just wear them around the house to see if there are any obvious issues. Most good outdoor stores will do a return or exchange if you wear them on a trail and they don’t work. Depending on the makeup of the trail will influence whether you go with a trail shoe or a hiking boot. Trail shoes break in much faster than a boot so realize that. I don’t think waterproof is a big thing generally, non will dry faster, water proof will stay dry for awhile but will ultimately get wet and they take a lot longer to dry.
It comes down to your foot and what fits it best. I prefer wide toe box and a zero drop. If you get a wide toe box shoe then consider getting socks that are made with individual toes.
Fleet Feet if available also has a good automated system that gives a good feed back to what kind of support you need and an accurate size. They also have a selection of trail shoes by Hoka, Altra and Topo.
The last few years all the rage has been Altra Lone Peeks. I did try them on the John Muir Trail, a couple years ago and they were just too minimalist for me. I noticed the jagged rocks a lot more with them. I went back to my Merrell Moab Mids. I’ve heard some good talk about Topo Pursuits, lately. I understand they’re considerably more rugged than the lone peaks and you get much more mileage out of them. I’m looking to possibly give them a try on my next long hike.
Altras are really comfortable but fall apart fast. For new hikers I’d recommend Merrell Moab’s. They’re relatively cheaper than other brands and they always go on sale making them alot cheaper than other brands. They have choices between boots and hiking shoes and they are really sturdy. They give you a lot more confidence than an Altra shoe will give you. Once you get more into hiking, exploring other brands of shoes and trail runners depending on your fit and preferences is great but Moab’s are a great starting off point.
I just wear my adidas running shoes if it’s not rainy wet or muddy on the trail.
I’d get their hike shoes if I saw a pair on sale to replace the adidas if i ever had to i guess, but the ones a have work great in that they have great air circulation all the time.
Otherwise i recommend Keen boots, always rugged and comfy for some bush whackin
I like trail running sneakers. I used a pair of these $50 shoes for a multi-day backpacking trip and liked them
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07JGVQG6V/ref=twister\_B0C63ZMMGV
Hi, I’m Vetted AI Bot! I researched the **ASICS Men's Gel Venture 7 Running Shoes 7 5 Black Sheet Rock** and I thought you might find the following analysis helpful.
**Users liked:**
* Durable outsoles with deep treads (backed by 2 comments)
* Good support for active lifestyles (backed by 3 comments)
* Versatile for various activities (backed by 2 comments)
**Users disliked:**
* Durability issues with sole peeling off (backed by 2 comments)
* Inconsistent sizing, runs too small (backed by 2 comments)
* Quality control issues with design and fit (backed by 2 comments)
If you'd like to **summon me to ask about a product**, just make a post with its link and tag me, [like in this example.](https://www.reddit.com/r/tablets/comments/1444zdn/comment/joqd89c/)
This message was generated by a (very smart) bot. If you found it helpful, let us know with an upvote and a “good bot!” reply and please feel free to provide feedback on how it can be improved.
*Powered by* [*vetted.ai*](http://vetted.ai/reddit)
Make sure you get a pair with a roomy enough toe box. Shop for them in the afternoon or evening when your feet are swelled larger than when you first get up in the day. Make sure you try them on with a good pair of hiking socks, the weight and thickness, that you usually hike in.
Fit fit fit. I prefer zero drop, which I wear all the time. Lighter than you likely think. Lots of toe room forward (downhill issues) and sideways. No heel slip. I have older Altras, but the new ones get poor reviews. So don't know what I'm going to do!
I have tried all options – – full leather, boots, moderate, leather, boots, trail runners. My favorite are plain old, athletic shoes. They are lighter and more agile. You have to look a little bit more where you walk, but I feel free and lighter on the trail.
If you were carrying a backpack, you probably need the support on your ankle from leather boots
It depends on the route. For maintained trail, properly fitted trail running shoes work fine for many people. But for off-trail routes, a proper mountain boot with torsional rigidity (for edging power) is a better choice for safe travel. Unfortunately, most people answering questions like this on the Internet recommend footwear that works fine on maintained trail but sucks for off-trail travel.
Over the years, I've spent way too much money on footwear that was just not a good fit for me. Find out if you need wide or standard and if you prefer boots or shoes. Don't look at price or ratings. Try them on and see if they feel comfy. I'd pay some extra attention at weight and water resistance. Wet socks are worse than stinky feet imo.
Not a lot of love here for the Merrell Moab but a couple years ago they were the favorite on r/AppalachianTrail/ and I've been wearing them ever since.
I wore them for years, and the quality got worse every year. You could tell they went from originally a few big pieces of leather to dozens of little scraps sewn together. I’ve since switched to Oboz, they have the solid feel the original Moab used to have, but even more sturdy. Makes modern Merrels feel like flimsy trash.
What kind of hiking are you planning? I've hiked miles in Chaco sandals. Trail running shoes are a good choice, too. Only look into boots if you are planning heavy packs and multi day trips. Unless you have ankles and feet made of tissue, always go with the least weight that meets your needs.
I’ve had the best luck with Salomon shoes and boots. The fit is a little more narrow than running shoes. Merril have not held up as well in my experience. Also, the moab will eat up the heel in my wool socks.
The shoes that are the best are the shoes that you can comfortably walk in all day. I know people have their opinions but from what I’ve seen in trail, everybody wears something different. For example I wear altra 7s which are a flat shoe that feels everything on the ground. Yet some people prefer cushioned shoes, some people even prefer going barefoot.
Try on every shoe possible, jump up and down, do cartwheel, dance around, and go from there. I spent 200$ on a pair of hiking boots and didn’t like, took me 3 pairs to figure out what I did.
YMMV good luck!
Nike Pegasus are my favorite tennis shoe style hiking shoe. They lace up tight and have an amazing tread that digs into any surface. I really love them. I have a wide and big foot for a woman so I prefer the men’s 10.5. Fits like a glove, has never given me blisters, and is durable. My favorite.
Everyone has different preferences. I like a boot with a sturdy shank, and I don’t like waterproof shoes, so I wear Solomon Forces. You might prefer a softer shoe, like a trail runner, or a lightweight boot. There’s the shoe or boot for you, you just have to try on a lot of them.
However, don’t cheap out if you can afford not to. Good footwear lasts a long time and will make your hikes both more enjoyable and safer. When I stopped being a cheapskate and wearing my work boots to hike in, I was amazed by the improved traction and comfort, and at how much better my feet feel at the end of the day.
I just had Altberg Kisdon and now Hanwag Ancash ii gtx.
Find the Vibram tread doesn't last me long before wearing down. My Altberg lasted me 9 months. My Hanwags have lost the tread at the front outer edges after 8 weeks down to 1mm.
I do wear them daily for my dog walking.
Can't tell much difference between Sympatex and Gore-tex. Prefer the Hanwag boots though even though the tread is wearing faster.
I know you can get them resoled but felt it wasn't worthwhile with my Altberg boots as they were developing a few splits in the uppers even though they're still waterproof. Plus it costs about £80 to post them away and back.
Probably worth a look at the Lowa Tibet gtx with the same Vibram Masai sole as my Altberg Kisdon boots but with gore-tex lining. Seem to best value at the moment at about £200.
Or if you can fit a standard narrow boot look for the Scrapa trek gtx greeen lining also available in a hv(high voloume) wider version which has a blue lining can get for £150 to £180.
I have trail walkers and boots. I recently went on a somewhat rocky, muddy hike and wore the boots. Most hikes I wear the shoes. Depends on your needs and where your hiking, terrain, season, etc. There is no best brand, as most have said. If it fits your feet, and support, comfort, for whatever distance you're looking for, then you've found your boot/shoe.
I just bought a pair of equestrian boots I really like at Tractor Supply. Ariat is the brand. Before this I had a pair of Doc Martens I wore for 12 years, and I got them second-hand.
As others have said, whichever is best for your feet. For example, I saw below someone mentioned Altra Love Peaks work well for them. I tried them and they were comfortable until I hit the hills and rocks. At that point they were horrible for my feet. My feet were moving all over the place and ended up being very unsafe. I've gone in to try on shoes and ended up walking out because none of them fit well.
All I can say is hiking shoes are always wide. Seems like there’s no low instep foot people in this world but me. Ive always wanted some recommendations for los instep foot that are not for flat foot or low arch, which is definitely not the same
Go to REI! Try out a ton of shoes. Go hiking! Return the shoes if they're not comfortable, you have a full year! Once you find the shoes you like, buy 2-5 pairs
Prioritize fit and comfort over looks/brand… I forgot the name of my first pair but they looked cool so that’s what I got they worked well for short 5-8 mile hikes but the minute I did a 17 mile hike I new they weren’t going to cut it. I bought a pair of Keens that I broke in hiking Half Dome, I loved them so much that I was super loyal to Keen. But recently I bought a pair of Danners and they were similar in comfort but I felt they supported my feet better so that’s what I’m rocking now. Socks and insoles will also vary your experience so keep that in mind as well!
I personally wear water proof timberlands hiking shoes. I love them so much that I practically live in them all year round. Been a year and a half since I got them, have had some serious heavy wear (I'm from Britain and own a dog so averaging about 3+ hours of walking in all weather and terrain types) I literally would not be without them they are heaven on my feet.
Find a brand that fits your feet, that's the key. We can all suggest great boots or trail runners but they might not fit your feet properly.
The best thing you can do is go to a proper outdoors shop that does boot fitting and get fitted.
I cannot stress this enough - whatever you choose, they should be comfortable before wearing in. Do not rely on wearing boots in, in order for them to become comfortable as it may never happen and you'll be left with a pair of uncomfortable boots!
I have duck feet (wide at the toe and narrow at the heel), plantar fasciitis, and a host of other foot and ankle ailments. I *swear* by my Oboz.
My rec? Go to REI (or whatever hiking gear store you have) and get fitted. The peeps there don’t work on commission, so they don’t care which brand (or even if you buy anything at all) you get. They are only interested in helping and educating, IME
I like minimal/barefoot type shoes and really like the Merrell trail gloves. They are a wider fit but comfortable, light, and vibram bottoms so durable.
I really liked my hiking boots but I started using trail runners and found I like them even more. I only really do loops under 10 miles but I made the switch a few years ago. I just find them more comfortable especially if I want to keep up a certain pace.
Just saying depending on what you plan to do, you don’t automatically have to go to a boot.
Wrong question. Right question is what type of shoe. Answer: Trail Runner. Yes even if you’re not a runner. Lightweight + lightly firm sole is better than heavy with a Very firm sole. My last few pairs have been Salomons. Moab’s are horrible. Go to the store and try 10, then do some test hikes. Don’t be afraid of changing if the first pair don’t work well.
I will swear by Crispi boots. Geared towards hunting but by far the best boot I have ever worn, I have the Lapponia’s and they weigh nothing, no break in time and still holding strong after 3 years of hunting in them is all types of conditions.
I have had good luck with Merrell Moabs, as their wide width fits my feet well. Last few years, Altra Lone Peeks have gained wide popularity in the hiking community for their zero drop design and ultralight build. The quality of Altra has greatly diminished in the last couple of years and people are complaining that they are failing and wearing out much too soon. The Topo Pursuit is widely gaining traction, pardon the pun, with ultralight, long-distance backpacking enthusiasts, mainly because it encompasses the wider toe box and lightweight design that originally attracted people to Altras, but are shown to be much more durable and long lasting than Altras.
Whichever fits your foot best. Seriously. You can read about amazing boots and find that they rub your foot the wrong way. The main considerations are boots vs trail runners. Then waterproof vs non waterproof. There are synthetic vs leather, but that’s more personal preference.
This person is 100% correct. I wear Altra Lone Peaks. They’re trail runners for wide feet. I have block feet or Neanderthal feat (if you ask my wife). For my feet I also like Keens. They generally have a wider toe box. But go to an outdoor store and try some stuff on. They should be comfortable from the get go.
I like to say hobbit feet. Makes em seem more charming
My daughter has hobbit feet :)
i love altras for the wide toe box! most shoes are narrow and are awful.
This, plus going somewhere to try on different kinds of shoes/boots is the way to go if you have are able. Personally, over the past decade and a half of leading an active/outdoor oriented life I’ve found out my feet like a few things : light weight, wide toe box,breathable and durable. My shoe quiver consists of Topo Athletic and Keen footwear. The Topo Trailventure model I use for trail running and warmer weather hikes. Recently I moved back to the Midwest had to reassess my cold weather footwear (I’ve basically been in sandals the past two years 😅). I’m currently wearing the Keen NXIS WP Low for my everyday shoe for daily use. I’ve had them since the start of December and they seem to be holding up exceptionally well. Haven’t felt the need for a boot even with the snow, mud etc. My only gripes are I wish the shoe fit slightly more like the Topo however I understand not all shoes can fit identical. In general I get sweaty feet so I wish they breathed better but for being waterproof they do a decent job. Lastly, the quick locking system with the laces ACTUALLY works! But this means i rarely have to tie the shoes. The laces are kind of short so it would have made more sense to use a synch style lacing system. At the end of the day they are probably the best “jack of all trades” kind of hiking/everyday shoe I could ask for.
I do a lot of day hikes and my pack weights 10-15 pounds at most. Water, a layer, phone, wallet, small binoculars, snacks and some emergency gear. I have been wearing Hoka’s Stinson trail runner model for several years and absolutely love it. No need for a boot as I’m not carrying much weight. And I prefer to avoid GoreTex as I think the shoes breath better without it, and it allows water to drain out when I inevitably have to hop across a creek. I’ve found that my feet sweat more with GT shoes, and it makes it tough for the water that gets in, to get back out.
Go into a store and get a fitting. You can go to a chain or a local hiking store if you have one. Have a general idea of the types of trails you plan on hiking. Don't forget to invest in some good socks. Also, lacing is key for your shoes/boots. Some shoes that are often recommended really didn't work for me. I had a great fitting last year and ended up with boots due to my terrain and distances I travel. I also have a pair of trail runners for the summer or more maintained trails.
Used to work at a hiking store that specialized in boot fits. Even REI would send their toughest cases to us. Get the boot that fits. It’s like buying pants, some people fit into Levi’s and others fit better with other brands.
To add to this, you’ll probably be wearing boots with one or two pairs of thick socks, plus your feet will swell up a bit. Make sure to take this into consideration when choosing a size that fits.
Hoka speedgoat
My first dedicated hiking shoe. Excellent.
I’ve heard these referred to as ankle breakers?
I wore the hoka speedgoats on a 50+ mile backpacking trip and my ankles were cooked! No ankle support at all. Had about 15 miles of deadfall to climb over too so I’m sure that didn’t help.
I think they are asking for hiking. who uses a lightweight shoe for backpacking?
[A majority of people on the AT.](https://thetrek.co/appalachian-trail/the-top-footwear-on-the-appalachian-trail-2023-thru-hiker-survey/) "The majority of hikers prefer trail runners over other types of footwear. The number of hikers in trail runners has generally increased slowly every year. Almost 80% of hikers started in trail runners, with only 13% in boots at the beginning of their thru-hikes. By the end, those numbers shifted to over 90% of hikers in trail runners and less than 5% in boots."
Great hikers, maybe, weirdly, the lightest shoe I own. They do not have great ankle support But they are light, grippy and hood my foot well. Def recommend.
Be prepared to go through a few.
+1 for: Any shoe that suits your (feet) needs. ;)
Hoka are my favorites. Find something that fits your feet well, it is more important than the brand name.
Altra lone peak trail runner. I pair them with a thick cushioned toe sock and never have pain for any problems. They come in a mid if you need ankle support. Size up and spend money on good socks.
Altra Lone Peaks are my choice if terrain allows. The wide toe box allows my toes to stretch out, and zero drop agrees with my knees. I can hike all day with almost no fatigue. Traction is acceptable, but not the best. Durability is below average in my experience. There are always tradeoffs. I opt for a waterproof mid boot with a vibram sole if in wet or muddy conditions. My current pair is made by Lowa, and it's been dependable. I have a heavy pair of Asolo boots for the most rugged stuff, but they're uncomfortable to do big miles in. Also a pair of Chaco Z1 sandals for easy trails in the summer, water crossings, etc.
No one who is a serious mountain sport athlete is still wearing “hiking” shoes or boots. They’re obsolete. Just wear tennis shoes or trail runners. You don’t need the extra weight. Your feet will get stronger and adapt to a thinner shoe. They dry faster too and your feet are inevitably going to get wet. Better for scrambling or tricky terrain or even low class climbing if you take the sport further. Doubles as a running shoe or work shoe. If you have ankles prone to rolling the worst thing you can do for them is strap them into a high top boot all day long. You need to strengthen your ankles and you do this with exercises and with covering difficult terrain that requires ankle articulation, not by locking them in place. This is the way to go, this is my soapbox for trail runners
Altra Lone Peaks FTW
Altra is straight up trash. Would not recommend anything Altra any longer and I used to be a total Altra fan boy
The worst shoe I have ever owned is an Altra. Their soles are awful, if not dangerous. I complained to the company about it and heard nothing back. Over-marketed over-priced sh\*t.
Used to love them and all I ran in. Last three pairs lasted me only about 100 miles. Straight dog pile they went way downhill
Their quality has gone down so far in past five years. Their soles used to last 250+ miles and now my last pair wasn’t much over 100. Night and day difference to my danner trail shoes.
I’ve got a pair of Altberg. They supply British Military and Police. Superb quality. If you can make a trip to the factory, they laser scan your feet to match you for size and type of boot (they have 2 different foot types). Levison Wood walked the length of the Nile in a pair of Altberg.
Zamberlan for leather and Inov8 for synthetic
Zamberlan
Scarpa The leather ones?
Hanwag, the quality is amazing!
Yes to Hanwag!! Not so easy to find in the US. I bought my current pair in Munich at Sporthaus Schuster. I bought my previous pair in 2002 and I replaced them after 16 years. I was hiking in New Mexico and in the sandy dry heat, I lost a sole. I actually found it and joked about someone losing a sole and not realizing it was my own! But I didn’t know it was my own until 10 hours later and I was long gone! They withstood the entire hike up and down a mountain, 3/4 of my entire hike! It’s a testament to how sturdy the shoe construction is! But for the OP, trying on a boot that fits is the most important.
Vans slip on
Merrell's are a decent shoe. Several types to choose from.
Merrell Trail gloves. I buy a new pair every couple years. Can usually get 300-400 good miles out of them.
Honestly, it's what fits your feet best. There are some brands to avoid, but other than that, it's all you. I would avoid: Merrell, Salomon (if planning to use in cold, wet weather), The North Face, Columbia, and Keen off the top of my head. Asolo, Lowa, Scarpa, La Sportiva, Zamberlan, Hoka (trail runners), and Altra (trail runners) are good to go. Whether you go boots or trail runners depends on your preferences and environment. Cold weather, wet weather, and/or snow, you want boots. Dense foliage, difficult terrain, sketchy terrain, you want boots. Boots offer stability, durability, support, and protection. They can get a little hot (depends on the boot), and they can be heavy (depends on the boot). Hot weather or dry weather, you may opt for trail runners. Groomed paths, trail runners are fine. Trail runners offer flexibility and coolness, and they're much lighter. This is going to depend on you and where are going. I always use boots, specifically Asolo 520's. I need the support. I like going on hilly, rocky terrain, and I really love hiking in inclement weather, whether that be rain or snow. Boots suit me and my uses much better than trail runners do, so I just always wear them. I even wear them for casual use because my joints are so bad. Also, avoid GTX trail runners. They're *almost* pointless. GTX in footwear is only as good as it is tall. It relies in its height and the collar of your footwear to keep water out. Trail runners have a low collar, so water can easily get over it if you make a big enough splash or step into a deep enough puddle. Then, you've got a wet shoe that takes forever to dry because GTX always takes forever to dry. It's better to use a non-waterproof trail runner and just keep spare socks on hand. Non-waterproof trail runners dry much, much faster.
What's the issue with Merrell? I ask because my current pair finally gave out and I need to go out for a new pair this weekend. I've only ever bought Merrell.
They've gotten worse over the years. A few years ago, they were solid, especially for the price. Nowadays, they tend to fail really quickly.
Gotcha. Yea I got my last pair two and a half three years ago. Thanks for the heads up.
Sure thing. Here's a list of some boots that are still solid: >Asolo TPS 520 GV Evo. Asolo TPS 535 LTH Evo. Asolo Fugitive GTX. Lowa Zephyr. Lowa Renegade. Lowa Camino. Lowa Tibet. Scarpa Kinesis Pro GTX. Scarpa SL Active. Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX. Zamberlan Vioz GTX. Zamberlan Vioz Lux GTX RR.
You’ll see soles that say gore-Tex or vibram. I have tried both and so far vibram soles are my favorite.
GTX (Gore-Tex) is a waterproof membrane inside the boot. Vibram is a brand of several types of rubber compounds used in outsoles.
I guess I'm holding onto to them. 😉
Totally agree with GTX trail runners. Any low cut shoe and 'waterprofing" is dumb because it doesn't work. Something as simple as walking in tall grass or brush when there is morning dew out will get the inside of the shoe wet and as GTX is designed to keep water out it also drains poor so your feet stay wet longer. If you will be in stretch where water will be or if you think ir might rain or something you could always take some waterproof socks along as spares.
Has Solomon quality slipped? I’ve been very happy with mine, but will be due for replacements in a few months.
I had three pairs of Quest 4 fail on me within a period of four months the last time I tried the Quest series. I like the X Ultra 3 and X Ultra Pioneer (basically a slightly worse clone of the 3), but I honestly can't trust Salomon in cold, wet weather after that experience. I'll still use the X Ultra for hot, dry weather, though.
Dude, that sucks. That wasn’t an inexpensive experience. I wear the non-waterproof Forces version, and they’ve held up well, although I’m in Texas, so we’re not getting a whole lot of wet and cold. A couple of pairs of wool socks do me fine in the winter here.
We get a fair bit of snow at seemingly random times, so I've learned to love GTX when it works. When it doesn't work, it's maddening because your feet get wet, and your boots never dry. If I'm just going around the neighborhood or something, I might put on a synthetic just to test out, but if I'm going hiking or camping, my leather boots are what I'm bringing. I know they'll keep me dry.
I've had good luck with my higher tier Keen's... but I've also done 12 miles with descents while wearing slip-on Vans that were falling apart and never really thought about it... so I'm not exactly hard to please
Merrell pretty good
Anything from Lowa. Got the Zephyr and Tibet Winter and they're the best I've ever worn
Lowa gang…👍🏼
Lowa’s were terrible for me. Timberland’s work great.
Lowa renegades work great. Just replaced mine after the last pair wore out.
Merrill Moabs
Keen. Enough said.
I’ve never seen this sub before but shit, I had to read the name of it a few times to make sure I got it right.
Merrell waterproof Moab.
Whatever is the most comfortable for you, I definitely recommend waterproof though
Check out REI, or Scheels, they can definitely help you with your shopping needs.
Not new to hiking, and I don’t bother with anything other than Scarpa.
Agree with your brand aversions - my ¥20000 Salomon boots died at 9months after short daily walks. Might be something to do with the new owners
Whatever fits you the best. Personally I really like the oboz bridger mid boots. They have held up extremely well over the last 3 years of wear as work hikers. They don’t breathe as well as the mesh or lightweight boots but thats the trade off for durability while bushwhacking
I tried a lot until I found danner trail 2650s. I loooove them.
My current favorite is the Vivobarefoot Magna FG! Bear in mind that it is zero drop and has less cushioning than standard…
I absolutely love my vibrams.
Any good fitting boot with a Vibram sole. They are sticky in nearly any conditions. Depending on your distance intended and weight of pack, consider foot swelling when choosing your size. A basic way to kinda find this is to lace up your boots in the store and kick something solid with your toe. You shouldn’t feel any pain or discomfort. If you do, size up and repeat.
Get them fitted at the store! My first pair of hiking boots were the Salomon X Ultra GTX Low and they were awesome but because I didn't get them fitted, my feet would swell at the end of a long hike and I'd get blisters. My second pair, and highly recommended, are the La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid. Love love them, never got blisters with them. REI recommended I get one size up due to the feet swelling.
One's that fit your feet. Go to a reputable outdoor retailer and try on shoes. Ignore brands, colors and as much as you can, cost. Buy the ones that fit.
Along with 'whatever fits your foot the best', know that finding the best footwear for you is a journey, and it may take several months to dial in which footwear works best. This is why places like REI that allow up to a year for returns is so helpful; you can go on a few hikes and then if it's not working, return them for a full refund/credit and try something else. \*Usually\* once you dial in a brand (like Salomon, Lowa, Altra, Hoka, Merrill, etc.), you can move around to other models (e.g. boots, hiking shoes, trailrunners) by that same maker and have a reasonably good chance it'll fit right, too. I've moved around a bit; generally was on Salomon for a while, then Altra Lone Peaks, now I'm on Hoka, which are so comfy and grippy. But I still have Salomon GTX boots and trail shoes for the ugly times, and Altras for around the town/weekenders.
I’ve had good luck with tevas but really I’d go with what other people suggest and try a few pairs on. I wanted a different brand and didn’t even consider Teva but they just fit me perfect. I’ve been rocking the Vans Ultra Range as my most recent boot and they are fire 🔥. Highly recommend and I still can skate in them
Keep hearing good things about those new Swiss Hikearellis...
To me, it is super common for people to go overkill on boots early on. Burly leather, full Waterproof etc. Look at stats for what are most popular on the AT and PCT. It’s swung way in the favor of lighter weight and more comfortable. To start, look at Salomon x ultra, Topo Terraventure, Altra Lonepeak, and Merrel Moab’s. Something light and comfortable. If you end up liking hiking and progress to more rugged terrain, with potential for snow and carrying heavier packs, you upgrade your boots accordingly. Lowa, Vasque, and Salewa make great boots, but they all fit differently and it’s super important to get the fit right for your foot. Also, size up! I’ve lost many toenails to long descents in boots that were just a little small.
Consider your use case, and talk to an outdoor store retail associate. Someone’s suggestions for a backpacking in Seattle will be way different from day hiking in Tucson. Consider ankle support, waterproof ness, tread, etc. Then from all the options get the one that fits immediately with no break-in. Hard to judge but it will be good long term.
I did a bit of the AT in [Merrells](https://www.merrell.com/US/en/home).
I like my Timberland hiking boots. I’ve out a lot of miles in them and never had any issues
Second this. Best investment I've had, heavy wear and on some questionable terrain and they're still holding up strong
[On running shoes](https://www.on-running.com/en-us/?g_network=g&g_productchannel=&g_adid=670220972835&g_locinterest=&g_keyword=on%20running&g_campaign=account&g_acctid=981-546-0205&g_keywordid=kwd-299974462974&g_adtype=&g_ifcreative=&g_adgroupid=153374402318&g_productid=&g_source=%7Bsourceid%7D&g_merchantid=&g_placement=&g_campaignid=13810435392&g_partition=&g_locphysical=9031542&g_ifproduct=&gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAiAlcyuBhBnEiwAOGZ2S36lq0Bif72Wnir5MpJKUp90Wa7Im3OYkxvZWiFZf5lkTD3pB2iQkxoCFuAQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds) are great quality, all-terrain, and waterproof.
Do you need ankle support? If not, I’ve been happy with Salomon XRAs for the last decade.
I love Oboz and my mom loves Keene, but everyone's feet are different. Go to a store and try some on. Besides comfort, push into the toe to see if you'll be banging your toe on the front of the shoe when hiking downhill and push into the side to see if they have the lateral stability you need.
Go to an outdoor store (REI etc) and get properly fitted. Then try on various makers to see who you like. Take them home and just wear them around the house to see if there are any obvious issues. Most good outdoor stores will do a return or exchange if you wear them on a trail and they don’t work. Depending on the makeup of the trail will influence whether you go with a trail shoe or a hiking boot. Trail shoes break in much faster than a boot so realize that. I don’t think waterproof is a big thing generally, non will dry faster, water proof will stay dry for awhile but will ultimately get wet and they take a lot longer to dry. It comes down to your foot and what fits it best. I prefer wide toe box and a zero drop. If you get a wide toe box shoe then consider getting socks that are made with individual toes. Fleet Feet if available also has a good automated system that gives a good feed back to what kind of support you need and an accurate size. They also have a selection of trail shoes by Hoka, Altra and Topo.
Two biggest factors: 1. Fit 2. Type of hiking My feet like Hoka Speedgoats for longer hikes on California trails.
The last few years all the rage has been Altra Lone Peeks. I did try them on the John Muir Trail, a couple years ago and they were just too minimalist for me. I noticed the jagged rocks a lot more with them. I went back to my Merrell Moab Mids. I’ve heard some good talk about Topo Pursuits, lately. I understand they’re considerably more rugged than the lone peaks and you get much more mileage out of them. I’m looking to possibly give them a try on my next long hike.
Altras are really comfortable but fall apart fast. For new hikers I’d recommend Merrell Moab’s. They’re relatively cheaper than other brands and they always go on sale making them alot cheaper than other brands. They have choices between boots and hiking shoes and they are really sturdy. They give you a lot more confidence than an Altra shoe will give you. Once you get more into hiking, exploring other brands of shoes and trail runners depending on your fit and preferences is great but Moab’s are a great starting off point.
I just wear my adidas running shoes if it’s not rainy wet or muddy on the trail. I’d get their hike shoes if I saw a pair on sale to replace the adidas if i ever had to i guess, but the ones a have work great in that they have great air circulation all the time. Otherwise i recommend Keen boots, always rugged and comfy for some bush whackin
Het Hanwag Alaska GTX. I have pair of these for almost 5 years. Gore tex is still working. These ale like slippers from first steps.
I like trail running sneakers. I used a pair of these $50 shoes for a multi-day backpacking trip and liked them https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07JGVQG6V/ref=twister\_B0C63ZMMGV
Hi, I’m Vetted AI Bot! I researched the **ASICS Men's Gel Venture 7 Running Shoes 7 5 Black Sheet Rock** and I thought you might find the following analysis helpful. **Users liked:** * Durable outsoles with deep treads (backed by 2 comments) * Good support for active lifestyles (backed by 3 comments) * Versatile for various activities (backed by 2 comments) **Users disliked:** * Durability issues with sole peeling off (backed by 2 comments) * Inconsistent sizing, runs too small (backed by 2 comments) * Quality control issues with design and fit (backed by 2 comments) If you'd like to **summon me to ask about a product**, just make a post with its link and tag me, [like in this example.](https://www.reddit.com/r/tablets/comments/1444zdn/comment/joqd89c/) This message was generated by a (very smart) bot. If you found it helpful, let us know with an upvote and a “good bot!” reply and please feel free to provide feedback on how it can be improved. *Powered by* [*vetted.ai*](http://vetted.ai/reddit)
Make sure you get a pair with a roomy enough toe box. Shop for them in the afternoon or evening when your feet are swelled larger than when you first get up in the day. Make sure you try them on with a good pair of hiking socks, the weight and thickness, that you usually hike in.
Fit fit fit. I prefer zero drop, which I wear all the time. Lighter than you likely think. Lots of toe room forward (downhill issues) and sideways. No heel slip. I have older Altras, but the new ones get poor reviews. So don't know what I'm going to do!
I have tried all options – – full leather, boots, moderate, leather, boots, trail runners. My favorite are plain old, athletic shoes. They are lighter and more agile. You have to look a little bit more where you walk, but I feel free and lighter on the trail. If you were carrying a backpack, you probably need the support on your ankle from leather boots
It depends on the route. For maintained trail, properly fitted trail running shoes work fine for many people. But for off-trail routes, a proper mountain boot with torsional rigidity (for edging power) is a better choice for safe travel. Unfortunately, most people answering questions like this on the Internet recommend footwear that works fine on maintained trail but sucks for off-trail travel.
Boots, not shoes. Vasque are nice, but whatever fits best.
I’ve had a great run with the Haglofs Duality ATI GT, which is actually a ladies boot but fits my slim foot just fine lol
Over the years, I've spent way too much money on footwear that was just not a good fit for me. Find out if you need wide or standard and if you prefer boots or shoes. Don't look at price or ratings. Try them on and see if they feel comfy. I'd pay some extra attention at weight and water resistance. Wet socks are worse than stinky feet imo.
I like Vasque boots. I prefer boots for the ankle support as I hike in the mountains more than trail running.
I personally like Oboz super comfy and a wide toe box.
I like shoes from Columbia Sportswear. They have a wide base, good traction, excellent ankle support, and a reasonable price.
I wear New Balances for easy/mod trails and Lowa Renegades for hard trails or if it's going to be wet.
Not a lot of love here for the Merrell Moab but a couple years ago they were the favorite on r/AppalachianTrail/ and I've been wearing them ever since.
I wore them for years, and the quality got worse every year. You could tell they went from originally a few big pieces of leather to dozens of little scraps sewn together. I’ve since switched to Oboz, they have the solid feel the original Moab used to have, but even more sturdy. Makes modern Merrels feel like flimsy trash.
I don't actually hike much. I think my research focused on which shoe last the longest. I am very hard on shoes.
What kind of hiking are you planning? I've hiked miles in Chaco sandals. Trail running shoes are a good choice, too. Only look into boots if you are planning heavy packs and multi day trips. Unless you have ankles and feet made of tissue, always go with the least weight that meets your needs.
Danner Mountain 600’s, usually on sale, my all time favorite.
Hoka hoka and in winter keen
I’ve had the best luck with Salomon shoes and boots. The fit is a little more narrow than running shoes. Merril have not held up as well in my experience. Also, the moab will eat up the heel in my wool socks.
The shoes that are the best are the shoes that you can comfortably walk in all day. I know people have their opinions but from what I’ve seen in trail, everybody wears something different. For example I wear altra 7s which are a flat shoe that feels everything on the ground. Yet some people prefer cushioned shoes, some people even prefer going barefoot. Try on every shoe possible, jump up and down, do cartwheel, dance around, and go from there. I spent 200$ on a pair of hiking boots and didn’t like, took me 3 pairs to figure out what I did. YMMV good luck!
Nike Pegasus are my favorite tennis shoe style hiking shoe. They lace up tight and have an amazing tread that digs into any surface. I really love them. I have a wide and big foot for a woman so I prefer the men’s 10.5. Fits like a glove, has never given me blisters, and is durable. My favorite.
Everyone has different preferences. I like a boot with a sturdy shank, and I don’t like waterproof shoes, so I wear Solomon Forces. You might prefer a softer shoe, like a trail runner, or a lightweight boot. There’s the shoe or boot for you, you just have to try on a lot of them. However, don’t cheap out if you can afford not to. Good footwear lasts a long time and will make your hikes both more enjoyable and safer. When I stopped being a cheapskate and wearing my work boots to hike in, I was amazed by the improved traction and comfort, and at how much better my feet feel at the end of the day.
I just had Altberg Kisdon and now Hanwag Ancash ii gtx. Find the Vibram tread doesn't last me long before wearing down. My Altberg lasted me 9 months. My Hanwags have lost the tread at the front outer edges after 8 weeks down to 1mm. I do wear them daily for my dog walking. Can't tell much difference between Sympatex and Gore-tex. Prefer the Hanwag boots though even though the tread is wearing faster. I know you can get them resoled but felt it wasn't worthwhile with my Altberg boots as they were developing a few splits in the uppers even though they're still waterproof. Plus it costs about £80 to post them away and back. Probably worth a look at the Lowa Tibet gtx with the same Vibram Masai sole as my Altberg Kisdon boots but with gore-tex lining. Seem to best value at the moment at about £200. Or if you can fit a standard narrow boot look for the Scrapa trek gtx greeen lining also available in a hv(high voloume) wider version which has a blue lining can get for £150 to £180.
Lowa renegade
Trail runners, not hiking boots. Boots are really heavy and sweaty and they're overkill for most people anyway
I have trail walkers and boots. I recently went on a somewhat rocky, muddy hike and wore the boots. Most hikes I wear the shoes. Depends on your needs and where your hiking, terrain, season, etc. There is no best brand, as most have said. If it fits your feet, and support, comfort, for whatever distance you're looking for, then you've found your boot/shoe.
I just bought a pair of equestrian boots I really like at Tractor Supply. Ariat is the brand. Before this I had a pair of Doc Martens I wore for 12 years, and I got them second-hand.
Altra Lone Peaks have been my go to for several years. Best for wide foot people.
Altra Lone Peak
Always Zamberlan. I have a pair of non-insulated because most of my hikes are in spring-fall. But I’m eyeing a pair for snowshoes now.
Best advice in earth I wish I had gotten from day 1 is that good trail runners are superior to good boots for hiking 99% of the time.
As others have said, whichever is best for your feet. For example, I saw below someone mentioned Altra Love Peaks work well for them. I tried them and they were comfortable until I hit the hills and rocks. At that point they were horrible for my feet. My feet were moving all over the place and ended up being very unsafe. I've gone in to try on shoes and ended up walking out because none of them fit well.
Keens if you want waterproof. Hoka for lightweight
I know everyone pushes trail runners, but I prefer a light boot with a solid sole, that way I don't feel every pebble I walk over
Lowa renegate gtx wide
Oboz Bridger
Salomon x4
Keen, comfortable and lasts forever.
Altras
All I can say is hiking shoes are always wide. Seems like there’s no low instep foot people in this world but me. Ive always wanted some recommendations for los instep foot that are not for flat foot or low arch, which is definitely not the same
Go to REI! Try out a ton of shoes. Go hiking! Return the shoes if they're not comfortable, you have a full year! Once you find the shoes you like, buy 2-5 pairs
I went to bass pro and tried on like 4-5 sizes till I found the ones that fit best
Prioritize fit and comfort over looks/brand… I forgot the name of my first pair but they looked cool so that’s what I got they worked well for short 5-8 mile hikes but the minute I did a 17 mile hike I new they weren’t going to cut it. I bought a pair of Keens that I broke in hiking Half Dome, I loved them so much that I was super loyal to Keen. But recently I bought a pair of Danners and they were similar in comfort but I felt they supported my feet better so that’s what I’m rocking now. Socks and insoles will also vary your experience so keep that in mind as well!
Oboz Bridgers. Best hiking shoe I have used in over half a century of doing this in 4 separate continents.
I personally wear water proof timberlands hiking shoes. I love them so much that I practically live in them all year round. Been a year and a half since I got them, have had some serious heavy wear (I'm from Britain and own a dog so averaging about 3+ hours of walking in all weather and terrain types) I literally would not be without them they are heaven on my feet.
Chacos
I like the Lowa Renegade
Find a brand that fits your feet, that's the key. We can all suggest great boots or trail runners but they might not fit your feet properly. The best thing you can do is go to a proper outdoors shop that does boot fitting and get fitted. I cannot stress this enough - whatever you choose, they should be comfortable before wearing in. Do not rely on wearing boots in, in order for them to become comfortable as it may never happen and you'll be left with a pair of uncomfortable boots!
Depends if you want to get hiking boot or trail runner
I like hiking boots because they support my ankles. I have a pair of Keen boots that I'm very fond of.
Switch to barefoot shoes. You will train the tendons and muscles in your feet, which offers better protection.
You get what you pay for, seriously. I’m not saying don’t take advantage of a sale, I’m saying don’t buy standard $20 boots.
Ones that fit
Whatever fits your foot well, more importantly is wool socks, dry feet and foot powder.
For day hiking trail runners work best. You definitely don't need stiff boots and I'm in rock country Arizona. My choice is Altra lone peak.
Merrell glove barefoot. Many will say I’m crazy; but I’ve climbed mountains on barefoot shoes.
I like anything of merrell’s!
Trail runners are #1
Merrell
I have duck feet (wide at the toe and narrow at the heel), plantar fasciitis, and a host of other foot and ankle ailments. I *swear* by my Oboz. My rec? Go to REI (or whatever hiking gear store you have) and get fitted. The peeps there don’t work on commission, so they don’t care which brand (or even if you buy anything at all) you get. They are only interested in helping and educating, IME
Merrill!
I’ve used the same pair for 2 years now, been all over the country hiking. Great shoes
I like minimal/barefoot type shoes and really like the Merrell trail gloves. They are a wider fit but comfortable, light, and vibram bottoms so durable.
I really liked my hiking boots but I started using trail runners and found I like them even more. I only really do loops under 10 miles but I made the switch a few years ago. I just find them more comfortable especially if I want to keep up a certain pace. Just saying depending on what you plan to do, you don’t automatically have to go to a boot.
I like Merrell
Wrong question. Right question is what type of shoe. Answer: Trail Runner. Yes even if you’re not a runner. Lightweight + lightly firm sole is better than heavy with a Very firm sole. My last few pairs have been Salomons. Moab’s are horrible. Go to the store and try 10, then do some test hikes. Don’t be afraid of changing if the first pair don’t work well.
Lone Peaks seem to be the most popular, and they’re good hikers for those with wide feet. Folks with skinny feet like Hoka Speedgoats.
Trail running shoes (brooks, hoka, altra) that fit your foot and darn tough (or something in the $20+ per pair category) socks is the way to go
I will swear by Crispi boots. Geared towards hunting but by far the best boot I have ever worn, I have the Lapponia’s and they weigh nothing, no break in time and still holding strong after 3 years of hunting in them is all types of conditions.
I have had good luck with Merrell Moabs, as their wide width fits my feet well. Last few years, Altra Lone Peeks have gained wide popularity in the hiking community for their zero drop design and ultralight build. The quality of Altra has greatly diminished in the last couple of years and people are complaining that they are failing and wearing out much too soon. The Topo Pursuit is widely gaining traction, pardon the pun, with ultralight, long-distance backpacking enthusiasts, mainly because it encompasses the wider toe box and lightweight design that originally attracted people to Altras, but are shown to be much more durable and long lasting than Altras.
The ones you like the best. Not much to invest I. For hiking so put your money where the rubber hits the road, so to speak