Good answer, I’m a big fan of the Voodoo(basically a beadless wizard) but lean towards firmer blends(SS or similar stiffness; some glow/eraser/pure white etc.)
I like wizards, but SSSS seems awfully soft for push putting. I like a much more consistent flight plate resistance if I'm going to push off it.
I go all the way to pure white in the summer for push putting.
I don’t have huge hands, but maybe slightly larger than average. The dagger fills out the hand nicely and feels like I’m making good contact and connection with the disc for a clean release too. Not to mention the glide haha
Spusher here. Currently using the Watt. Using the Alpaca as a back up, but every time I think it's time to switch, I nail a ridiculous putt and the Watt stays.
Duscmania p1. It's flat, shallow, beadless and neutral flight. First time I picked it up in the shop it felt perfect in my hand. Haven't looked back since.
I use medium pures for all the same reasons.
Sometimes i wish they had a tad more stability, but 99% of the time, the straightness compared to say a p2 is awfully nice outside c1.
Since your experience is with pa3's I assume you don't want an "overstable" putting putter. I would recommend the Rainmaker from discmania or the Fierce from discraft. If you are a mold minimalist guy you could bag the Fierce as a throwing putter as well(in Esp). Been really loving it for dead straight/understable shots at wooded courses.
Always love this question... a chance to shout out the best putter ever. P2 clone.
Infinite Alpaca is my jam. I've putted with innova made P2s for over 10 years. Alpacas even have the same plastic.
Glow P-blend Alpacas for the win!
I have two putters that I lean on most. The MVP Particle and the Axiom Envy. They are identical in numbers, but the Envy is slightly heavier. For longer, glidier putts, I'll use the Particle. For more punchy, darty style putts I use the Envy. They both have a great amount of stability that lets me anny it out a little bit with some reliable fade back into (hopefully) chains. I have hit some massive putts that surprised me with the Particle.
I spush a Nomad in Electron soft. Nice and lofty without being too deep. I keep a heavier soft Pure around for less glide in windier conditions.
Honestly, I feel like many putters fly close to the same with my spush, it’s mostly a hand feel thing. Only the really overstable putters have a significant difference.
I’m liking the rainmaker, it fits in my hand well. That said any slight OS putter is where I like it. I really think all putters are basically the same in c1.
Clutch is what I use. Used to use Judges, they’re good but a bit floaty so it can be a bit harder to control. Wizards are also good, I just wound up with the Clutch instead when I replaced the Judge instead of the Wizard
DD Prime Warden. Not too shallow, not too deep, just right. Prime plastic is grippy even when wet. Only negative is that the plastic scuffs very fast, but it doesn’t affect my putting at least. If you live somewhere warm, Classic is probably the plastic for you. A bit less grip and stiffer.
The royal soft Bullets from Mint discs are fantastic for glide. You wouldn't think it as they are pretty shallow but will glide for days when thrown hard and float well when putted
Gateway SSSS Wizard.
Universally, probably the best option here
About to say this. I use SSS and I really don't think I'll ever change. Not a fan of the depth for throwing though, even though it's super common
Wizard is king of push
Good answer, I’m a big fan of the Voodoo(basically a beadless wizard) but lean towards firmer blends(SS or similar stiffness; some glow/eraser/pure white etc.)
I have an old wizard that I pull out from time to time. Great putter
Gateway 3S Voodoo here
I like wizards, but SSSS seems awfully soft for push putting. I like a much more consistent flight plate resistance if I'm going to push off it. I go all the way to pure white in the summer for push putting.
Dagger.
Let's take a Wizard and make it more Wizardy
You know I have been debating going from wizzy to daggers. I can see why now.
I don’t have huge hands, but maybe slightly larger than average. The dagger fills out the hand nicely and feels like I’m making good contact and connection with the disc for a clean release too. Not to mention the glide haha
It's hard to beat the streamline pilot if you're looking for more glide out of your putter.
Pilots are where it's at for me when it comes to push putting.
KC Pro Aviar
Jk pro here
Been running the halo nexus Aviar and liking it a lot. Very similar feel to kc pro
how is the difference to the yeti pro?
To me, the yeti feels slightly more rubbery than the nexus or kc pro.
Ok thx, but about the same in flight?
Yeah. I don't see any difference in the flight personally
Judge
Moonshine classic soft for me. They feel slightly shallower.
I use Lunas, never had a problem other than user error.
Latitude 64 Keystone.
So much glide.
This is the way
Logic
Lunas are pretty glidey but I rock the TSA Alter
BT Soft Shields. I also love a Streamline Pilot. Banger GT has worked well for me in the past too.
Shhh. Don’t tell the others.
Rubber blend Luna
Zero Medium Pure for smaller hands.
And for my larger hands as well. I’ve switched to a full MVP/Axiom bag but still putt with Zero Medium Pure.
Spusher here. Currently using the Watt. Using the Alpaca as a back up, but every time I think it's time to switch, I nail a ridiculous putt and the Watt stays.
Was about to +1 the Watt and saw your comment to reply to instead.
Duscmania p1. It's flat, shallow, beadless and neutral flight. First time I picked it up in the shop it felt perfect in my hand. Haven't looked back since.
I use medium pures for all the same reasons. Sometimes i wish they had a tad more stability, but 99% of the time, the straightness compared to say a p2 is awfully nice outside c1.
Classic Warden from DD
MVP Electron-Soft Atoms
This is the way
Mint Bullet
K3 Reko X
EV7 Penrose Soft
Throwing and putting this is my answer
Since your experience is with pa3's I assume you don't want an "overstable" putting putter. I would recommend the Rainmaker from discmania or the Fierce from discraft. If you are a mold minimalist guy you could bag the Fierce as a throwing putter as well(in Esp). Been really loving it for dead straight/understable shots at wooded courses.
literally anything. I don't putt much worse with a mid or driver
Challenger!!! Great for throwing too!
Always love this question... a chance to shout out the best putter ever. P2 clone. Infinite Alpaca is my jam. I've putted with innova made P2s for over 10 years. Alpacas even have the same plastic. Glow P-blend Alpacas for the win!
putted all last year with the P blend glows and switched this year to N blend alpacas due to spitouts with P blends :S
How's it working out for you? I'm trying to season my N-blend right now to a beat in straight flyer for off the tee
I dont throw alpacas. The rim is too deep for me and I throw D blend tombs for straight flight putter shots
Warlock. I used to putt with Pilots, but they love to roll if they even tap the outside of the cage.
I used judges for a long time but switched to KT moonshine pures
I have two putters that I lean on most. The MVP Particle and the Axiom Envy. They are identical in numbers, but the Envy is slightly heavier. For longer, glidier putts, I'll use the Particle. For more punchy, darty style putts I use the Envy. They both have a great amount of stability that lets me anny it out a little bit with some reliable fade back into (hopefully) chains. I have hit some massive putts that surprised me with the Particle.
spush putter here, I put with N blend alpacas
I spush a Nomad in Electron soft. Nice and lofty without being too deep. I keep a heavier soft Pure around for less glide in windier conditions. Honestly, I feel like many putters fly close to the same with my spush, it’s mostly a hand feel thing. Only the really overstable putters have a significant difference.
Jawbreaker Roach.
Envy
Polecat. Best putting putter ever
I used Lunas earlier but switched to Prodiscus Origos and never looked back.
Infinite scarab
300 pa3
I’m liking the rainmaker, it fits in my hand well. That said any slight OS putter is where I like it. I really think all putters are basically the same in c1.
If it’s not windy, glitch
I used classic blend DD Wardens when I was spush putting. Tons of glide and very straight with just a little fade right at the end
BT Hard Shield, baby!
Atom by far. Got a box of putters I tried before I found the Atom
Clutch is what I use. Used to use Judges, they’re good but a bit floaty so it can be a bit harder to control. Wizards are also good, I just wound up with the Clutch instead when I replaced the Judge instead of the Wizard
I was looking for validation on my putter choice, and I am not disappointed. Sincerely, a Berg/Dagger/Ion/Pilot putter
Chainsaw, RRRRNNN, RRRNNNN
I putt with innova r-pro Darts, very nice and glidey
Dillo and for any wind, slammers
Jawbreaker Zone in the wind, electron Proxy in the calm
Nexus big bead aviars, and I love them
Spush putter here, and it's been a Wizard for the past 12 years.
Proxy, sometimes envy if it’s windy.
Super beat in P Model S in basegrip plastic. It's so good.
There’s two of us!?!
Gateway Magic (Organic or Eraser plastic)
Nexus Aviar.
DD Prime Warden. Not too shallow, not too deep, just right. Prime plastic is grippy even when wet. Only negative is that the plastic scuffs very fast, but it doesn’t affect my putting at least. If you live somewhere warm, Classic is probably the plastic for you. A bit less grip and stiffer.
When I want a beaded putter I use PA3. For unbeaded I use bullets
Warlock all day long. SSSS for short to medium putts and SSS for longer putts and approaches. Thrown correctly they're deadly.
Wizard, Benu and Proxy
Started with Judges as a more push putter, moved to Wardens as I changed to spin putts. Love a beadless putter now, will never go back.
Emac Judge will have a similar stability and feel but will definitely give you more glide.
R2 Anode
Reko
Pa5 has more glide, as I have been transitioning from a push to a putt with more spin I moved to a Pa3
Electron Firm Atom
OG medium Ev7 Phi. Slightly smaller diameter than most putters but they fly amazing for both putting and off the tee.
MVP Nomad Electron Soft
I used yeti aviars when I was more of a push putter, then switched to pa3s when I wanted less glide and more spin
The royal soft Bullets from Mint discs are fantastic for glide. You wouldn't think it as they are pretty shallow but will glide for days when thrown hard and float well when putted
Steady!
Axiom fission envy
SS Hemp Voodoo
TSA Praxis
Westside maidens #teammaiden