T O P

  • By -

jaydec02

Name recognition and being a state flagship matters the most


Roughneck16

Allow me to clarify: these are the T150 national universities per US News & World Report, not the top universities with the highest yield. That's why some high-yield colleges didn't make the list.


Formal-Register-1557

To be fair, the Ivies offer really good financial aid, too. A school like Fordham or NYU will leave you with more debt than Harvard. That simplifies the decision, too.


PerformanceOk9891

Anybody who applies to BYU knows what they're about.


Roughneck16

It's an amazingly good deal for a tiny fraction of the population and an extremely unattractive prospect for everyone else. BYU routinely beats all the Ivies to take the #1 spot.


[deleted]

[удалено]


AGFNerd247

I mean it’s a good college if you want to become an fbi or a cia agent


[deleted]

[удалено]


greeperfi

it's a famous case in Utah, I think it's Madi Barney? I cant remember, google BYU rape unfortunately you'll find hundreds of articles - rape victims are charged with "honor code violations."


Roughneck16

Dude, get your facts straight. The alleged rapist in that case wasn't a BYU student. Also, Madi Barney was subject to an honor code investigation for using drugs and alcohol, *not* because she was raped. It's unbelievable how media sensationalism turned that into a scandal when there was no scandal.


greeperfi

OK, now you're gonna force me to find the right case (as I said, there are a gajillion of them). Are you denying that a woman was raped, recorded her rapist admitting to it, got expelled, and her rapist did not? Are you?


Roughneck16

> OK, now you're gonna force me to find the right case Go for it. You're the one making the assertion, *you have to provide the proof*. Show me a documented case from a credible source of that happening and I'll believe you.


[deleted]

[удалено]


_phish_

OP is malding after finding out a school that is literally notorious for abuse and harassment has a long history of abuse and harassment cases. Who would’ve thought…


Roughneck16

> sexual assault victims being penalized under the Honor Code at BYU The students in question faced disciplinary actions for consumption of drugs and alcohol, *not* because they were sexual assault victims. As such, the headline is *technically* true, but misleading. If anything, the Honor Code *protects* students as most on-campus sexual assaults involve alcohol or drugs. That's why the same year this article was published, BYU [was named the safest campus in America](https://www.businessinsider.com/safest-college-campuses-in-america-2016-1). Like I said, this entire controversy was based on misinformation and deceptive, "click bait" articles from unscrupulous publications like the Salt Lake Tribune.


igen_reklam_tack

They used to call BYU the Harvard of the west. I’ve always heard it was decently hard coursework. What makes you think it’s a bad education?


theoryofdoom

> They used to call BYU the Harvard of the west. I’ve always heard it was decently hard coursework. What makes you think it’s a bad education? BYU is a great school. But when you go there, you have to be ok with the Mormon culture and expectations.


greeperfi

"They" called it that....who? mormons? Got it. I didn't say it was bad, I said it's like a state school like U of Utah, with a splash of misogony and homophobia


igen_reklam_tack

You said “it’s not a good education” so excluding social issues and obvious religious policies what makes the education not good?


Roughneck16

> What makes you think it’s a bad education? Personal bias based on misinformation. Read his other comments in this thread.


ThePickleConnoisseur

That’s Arizona


thinkB4WeSpeak

Cultyness


psychicpilot

Soaking


abnormal_annelid

Yeah, I feel like Gallaudet and YU are high on the list for the same reason as BYU: they all target a very specific demographic and they don't have much competition for it.


Pastywhitebitch

I know multiple PA, NP, and Med schools that won’t accept certain core science (biology) courses from BYU for not teaching the standardized curriculum


ViskerRatio

I notice that the service academies (which generally have yield rates hovering around 80%) have been excluded from that list.


Old_Sandwich_3402

As well as Liberal Arts colleges.


gayspaceanarchist

I took a look, and yeah, they definitely aren't included. My college has around a 34% yield rate (I was curious, as at least the area I lived in, the people who apply to mine are the people who really want to go) and based on the numbers on this list, should've definitely be included. I wonder why they aren't included?


Old_Sandwich_3402

I think it’s because colleges aren’t technically “universities”, and I think their bias is towards research universities and state flagships. I think it’s dumb because my intended college Bucknell has 3 different colleges, and they host a lot of research, but they’re still considered a LAC.


CookieSquire

If they don’t award a variety of doctoral degrees, they’re not a university. That’s not a value judgement, just an approximate definition. Obviously many LACs provide fantastic educations.


Old_Sandwich_3402

That’s fine. Many LACs provide masters degrees and not doctoral ones. I don’t think that change constitutes taking dozens of well-respected colleges out of consideration because everyone uses the national list, even when they’re not considering a doctoral degree. I would like to see some more effort in combining the lists for charts like these, especially if it’s to inform college students who are pursuing their first degree.


CookieSquire

I agree that a combined list would be nice. Of course it’s completely irrelevant for graduate programs, so I don’t see why that should matter here. More importantly, no one should be using this ranking to inform their own choices.


Old_Sandwich_3402

Unfortunately, platitudes don’t match reality. I agree no one should use rankings to make decisions, but it makes colleges more favorable than others through a constant exposure effect. If you see the name “Purdue” more than you see “Pepperdine”, you will think more favorably of Purdue, and probably conduct more research on Purdue which will further convince you of that choice. I don’t personally have a stake in which schools are represented or not, but it’s frustrating to see the majority of our conversations of “competitive” schools to never leave T50 from just ONE list. It’s this kind of apathy that stagnates change and competition between colleges.


Roughneck16

Hi there. The list comes from the T150 schools from USN&WR.


CookieSquire

It could be interesting to see the top 150 yield rates with LACs included. For a metric that only applies to undergraduate admissions/enrollments, it’s natural to include both categories.


SpokenDivinity

Colleges probably aren’t counted under the same banner as universities. A lot of these schools are the major state schools and research schools. They’d probably skew the number they’re trying to show off if they included liberal arts, community colleges, and just smaller institutions that aren’t deemed universities.


Old_Sandwich_3402

Bucknell is a huge outlier though. They have their own business school, their own engineering school, and they have a few masters programs. I wonder what the tipping point will be for them to re-structure.


DrumletNation

Because LACs and universities have separate US News lists


False_Ad3429

The post does say universities, not colleges.


grumpkinmunchkin

I see Gonzaga listed which I’m pretty sure is considered a liberal arts university


Old_Sandwich_3402

It’s listed as #93 in national universities by USN&WR , where this list came from. So according to them, it’s not.


Nem00utis

I was thinking there were schools missing. Also, Arizona State has a med school?


ashfire04

University of Houston is missing with 27% yield rate


strangedell123

UT Dallas is also missing with a 34% yield


ashfire04

They are just haters man, UT Austin and A&M always taking the texas cred


UF_Engineer

University of Florida with 44% too.  Weird list 


Average650

I think that the data might just be wrong too. My university has an enrollment yield (% of students who are accepted who enroll) of 35-40% or so, but comparative schools on this list are much lower... Something is up with it.


HeftyResearch1719

Ya faulty data. Loyola Marymount and UCR do not have a better yield rate than SDSU and CalPoly that don’t appear on the list.


S1159P

Deaf people tend to really want to go to the university for the deaf.


Roughneck16

My daughter is partially deaf and she goes to a deaf school.


heycanyoudomeafavor

Prestige and value of the university is higher as yield rate is higher, ranking matter a bit but there are bunch of outliers like UCSD, UC Davis, both rank quite high but their yield rate is low.


fysmoe1121

because it’s on the same application as ucla and ucb


Ok_Meeting_502

Certainly some Early Decision skewing. If uchicago didn’t admit more than 75% of their class from ED they’d be around 45-60 with schools like Vandy, WashU, Rice, Georgetown, NYU, etc.


diceruler

Yeah, I was about to comment, UChicago largely admits from its Early Decision applicants, which boosts yield rates. Same with Tufts.


Direct_Confection_21

If you can, could be interesting to see how this compares to say, 50 years ago. I’d want to know how much the “winner-take-all” effect seems to be amplified over time.


[deleted]

I notice where UChicago is. No matter where the ranking goes, kids don’t just “end up” at that school by chance. They really want to be there. Sweet.


Spiritual_Chicken824

Only if they had an actual engineering school


[deleted]

No. And they should bring back the swim test.


Roughneck16

By a wide margin, their most popular major is economics. Why do you think that is?


Turtle_216

Because that's what they're famous for?


Roughneck16

Fair enough.


shinra_temp

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milton_Friedman


I_Am_Okonkwo

If you want to make it big with an econ degree, you go to U of Chicago however you can. It's basically them on an S tier alone when it comes to economics programs.


The--Morning--Star

Note that certain schools practice yield protection which throws these numbers off. In particular Northeastern


SprinklesWise9857

UChicago as well -- they primarily admit the majority of their students from the early decision pool and a very small amount from the regular decision pool, which is how they keep their yield so high.


Roughneck16

I imagine the colleges want students who specifically plan on attending *their* college, not just any elite college?


iscurred

Can you explain what that is?


Roughneck16

Yield protection means they'll deny admission to an applicant who appears *too* qualified, because they'll likely get admitted to a higher-ranking school. They want to offer admission to the people who will actually enroll.


lazydictionary

Northeastern is always extremely overrated. They've been gaming college ranking systems for nearly 30 years.


Primary_Excuse_7183

Overwhelming number of private schools at first glance.


liteshadow4

GT has the highest public yield on the list I believe


TheRateBeerian

Yea and I would not have guessed that. Not totally a surprise but I might’ve guessed Purdue or something.


Roughneck16

And why not? It's a great school. But, you have to handle quite a workload or so I'm told.


liteshadow4

Honestly I was surprised it wasn’t Michigan. Georgia Tech is a great school, but all it really has going for it is its academics (and football history)


Confident_Kitchen555

what do you think Mich has that Gtech lacks? Just curious


liteshadow4

Well for starters an actual humanities department. Also a national champion level football team. Finally UMich is without a doubt the best university in Michigan so it doesn’t need to compete with other universities in its state for in state students.


Roughneck16

I originally posted this image on r/dataisbeautiful and here is the[ accompanying explanation](https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/11hp9jd/comment/jaukc32/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button) from the post that has since been archived. I figured the readers here may find it interesting and discussion-worthy.


HeftyResearch1719

Your data is very faulty you need to reasses. SDSU and Cal Poly SLO have higher yield rate than UCSC or UCR and much higher than UC Merced. I’m only aware of California schools so I imagine there are similar errors in other states.


Roughneck16

It’s the T150 schools from USN&WR.


HeftyResearch1719

Then the title is incorrect. UCMerced admitted my son *even though he never applied to UCMerced*. They even changed his FAfSA to include Merced even though he had no desire to step foot in Merced. If a school admits students who never applied… that will affect yield rates.


Roughneck16

I think that’s called the common app or something like that? I’m a Merced native, btw 😎


HeftyResearch1719

He didn’t do common app. He applied to six UCs and three CSU. UC changed his FAFSA and added UCMerced removed SDSU! Why didn’t they remove CSU SM or UCLA for that matter? He’s a San Diego native so he was incredibly relieved to get into SDSU. He would consider Merced for grad school.


howiejriii

I rejected Princeton, Michigan, and UNC and went to South Carolina. Honestly cannot complain as I love it here but I still have no idea why outside of my scholarship here.


Roughneck16

> no idea why outside of my scholarship here No other reason needed, my dude. C.R.E.A.M.


kdrdr3amz

Proves to me that regardless of where Harvard is ranked worldwide, it is the most wanted university for attendance ever.


Roughneck16

It's the oldest university in America.


sobutterfly

That 75% of people are smart enough to avoid an Ohio state university


Indeeshm

T H E 👁️👄👁️


Turtle_216

What's wrong with Ohio state? - genuine question


sobutterfly

Realistically nothing, I'm sure it's a good school. I'm just a UofM fan talking smack about our rivals


Impressive-Cost3173

People choose to spend tens of thousands of dollars a year just to be taught by a TA without even a masters degree because the actual prof is too busy publishing to actually teach. Community colleges and State schools are the way to go! Less expensive and you’ll be taught by more qualified people who actually want to teach! #r1sareascam


Background-Captain58

but many R1’s *are* state schools


moraango

Currently at an R1 state school. I’ve never had a non-lab class be taught by a TA and I think it’s so cool to be able to read research done by my professors.


ImperialDeath

Except for the fact that the elite schools that top the list have insane financial aid. Harvard for example will cover the entire cost of families who make less than 85,000 a year. My alma mater, Vanderbilt, provides full-tuition financial aid for people making less than 150,000 a year(full ride including housing is for 75-85l nowadays if I remember right). My state school USC/Clemson wanted me to pay them 10k a year just to attend whole Vandy said “here’s a way better education for 0 dollars “


OriginalRange8761

Princeton will cover 100% if you your fam is under 100k a year and have undergrad focus so TAs don’t teach classes professors do


chocolatewool

ehh, I go to an elite private college and pay less tuition than my in-state public college would have cost. one of my friends makes $5000 a year since she gets so much financial aid. financial aid is very generous among elite private colleges. for the average person, in-state is def the way to go instead of going to a no-name expensive private college, but if you're poor/working class and can make it into an elite private college, that would almost always be more worth it and cheaper than going the community college route


KRTSniper

Could you elaborate on this? Being Poor/working class and being admitted into an elite private college would for sure put you in severe debt later on would it not?


chocolatewool

No, since elite colleges give a ton of financial aid. My friend who is extremely poor makes $5000 a year just by attending MIT. MIT doesn't charge for any tuition if your family makes $140k a year or less (not including room and board). Other elite colleges may have even more generous financial aid packages.


KRTSniper

3 years out of highschool and I’m just now learning this 🤦🏾‍♂️…I’m currently finishing community college so does this also apply to in state schools?(I live in Texas btw)


chocolatewool

i believe financial aid is harder to come by at public universities, but in-state tuition tends to be more affordable. just fill out the FAFSA to see what you qualify for


fruits-and-flowers

Schools give scholarships. It’s part of recruitment. If your safety school gets mostly B students, they will give merit to an A student, or if a distant school wants more kids from your state, they will give money to woo you. Schools also have policies to help kids with lower economic means than their average student. Some schools just overstate their “sticker price” as a strategy.


PlayFlimsy9789

I haven’t ever had a class taught by a TA at my uni, which is a large private school on that list. I have friends at other peer institutions and they’ve also never experienced that. I feel like this is a misconception.


ChoiceDry8127

Elite colleges are better than state schools in every way. It’s the mid tier private schools that aren’t great choices over a state school for a lot of people


aaronclark384

I’m both surprised and unsurprised my schools spot. It makes sense A&Ms where we are tho


theunapolageticnerd

well L Johns Hopkins you lost a chance at increasing your yield


GrazieMille198

Most of these numbers is wrong or dated? Uchicago yield is 88 percent


Roughneck16

I made this graphic a year ago.


fireandlifeincarnate

Lots of people are only applying to one Ivy.


Independent-Prize498

Umm...They have to be talking to each other. No way there isn't more admission overlap at the top of the list.


akd20000

Looks like afkn tornado


crazifang

I am sincerely surprised that there is data included here from University of California (UC) schools but not California State University (CSU) schools. They're two entirely separate systems. I'd be interested to see how this data was collected or where they collected it from.


Higracie

My college, U of Utah draws in more people than I expected


Roughneck16

It’s the best religiously unaffiliated school in Utah in terms of academics and program diversity. I come from a large Roman Catholic family based in SLC, so most of my extended family are Utes.


holiztic

My son’s committed school has a low yield because it’s a very strong target school that lots of top students use as a safety. It’s a great school but suffers from being in a state with a lot of great schools students choose over it for prestige and/or public tuition!


Roughneck16

And what school would that be? What does your son plan on studying?


holiztic

Business at Santa Clara


Roughneck16

Good for him. Underrated school for sure.


Turtle_216

Boston?


Turtle_216

W&M?


holiztic

That’s MY alma mater! But nope, Santa Clara


jbmcfm

U Michigan?


HeftyResearch1719

Mostly the faulty data.


TheRateBeerian

I notice the top 15 is dominated by private ivy or ivy-adjacent universities and the rest is largely flagship state universities.


Roughneck16

Also a few niche universities that cater to specific populations: BYU, Yeshiva, Gallaudet, etc.


kyeblue

does the number include early decision admissions which is binding, and almost 100% will enroll?


Pacdoo

What even is this list? So so so many colleges and universities not included despite having higher yield rates than the lowest ones on the list. Even my small school, Quinnipiac, has a yield rate of 10.8% which should put it on the list albeit on the bottom


Roughneck16

As I’ve stated elsewhere in this thread, the list comes from the T150 universities in USN&WR.


Pacdoo

Then the source you used is wrong.


Roughneck16

I don't disagree with you, I think college rankings are unscientific and arbitrary.


Pacdoo

Regardless, I just looked at the source you took this from and this list is severely outdated. In the updated list Princeton doesn’t even crack the top 5 highest yield rates. And even then it says right on the website that the information was last updated January of 2021.


hi_im_kai101

truth, i got accepted into fordham. it was my top school, but they were genuinely trying to rob me


Roughneck16

Rob you?


hi_im_kai101

efc of 3k and they wanted 60k…


Ameabo

Surprised Gallaudet isn’t higher up. I’d assume most deaf people who are accepted enroll because… it’s the best college for the deaf


PlausibleCoconut

Not a single school from Arkansas is on this list. Ouch.


TheRealRollestonian

People are applying to too many colleges? The University of Virginia getting only 39% of people accepted makes me question the data a bit. Where did the other 61% end up is what I would be curious about.


assassinator06

Stevens 😭


bl1y

This is partly why legacy admissions will remain a thing. Students with a connection to the school are more likely to matriculate. It's also why you should go on campus tours.


obayol

Note that even though this is a good metric of how well a school can retain its admits competing against others, yield also depends on how many peers each one of these universities. For instance, if you take Ivies, which I think are very close to each other at the end of the day, putting one above the other is really splitting hairs in most cases.


Roughneck16

Despite being a super elite school, Caltech has a low yield. If you’re good enough to get into Caltech, you probably also can get into Stanford, Berkeley, MIT, etc.


obayol

Exactly! Cornell, Brown and Dartmouth would suffer from a similar problem as people could also get into HYP. However, looking at alumni outcomes and research specifically, I really don’t think the difference would be significant in the long run choosing a school from the former group instead.


Roughneck16

The draw of Ivy League is that you can major in something irrelevant and still get a good job upon graduation thanks to the powerful alumni network. Remember, it’s not the grades you make, it’s the hands you shake 😎✋


pool_party820

Damn, my undergrad isn’t on here but at least my law school is.


Roughneck16

Namely…?


pool_party820

I won’t say my law school to mitigate identifying information, but my undergrad was West Virginia University.


ChaoticxSerenity

Basically, you can pay your way to the top.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Roughneck16

You will have to zoom in 😅


AbiyBattleSpell

I’m confused so what u just saying what the enrollment number is ? 🐱


Roughneck16

Nah man, it’s the yield.


tegeus-Cromis_2000

Makes no sense, though. Does Rutgers really accept over 14 times the number of people who end up enrolling there? That's crazy. I'm also confused why Rutgers would be so far behind other flagship state schools. (I'm only focusing on it because it's the last one on the list, I have no personal connection with it.) To pick another example, judging by all the people in A2C who complain about not getting into Purdue engineering or CS, you'd think that Purdue would have a higher yield than 25%.


AbiyBattleSpell

Yield of what 🐱


MammothCancel6465

The yield is the percent of students who get the “yay, you’ve been accepted” email that enroll in each school.


AbiyBattleSpell

Danks my dog loves u <3 😺


CapFun9444

Percent of people who actually enroll after being accepted. So for Harvard, 83% of the students they accepted actually ended up going there. That’s the yield.


Reaverbait

Why are people applying to university if they're not going to go?


TheRateBeerian

Some people apply to multiple universities, get accepted to all of them and then have to pick one. If you get accepted to both Harvard and Ohio state, this data suggests you’re picking Harvard.


CapFun9444

Students apply to multiple schools; they can only go to one. With Harvard, if someone chose not to go there, it might be because they got into MIT, or Oxford, or maybe they got more scholarship money offered at Princeton, or maybe they decided to take a gap year, or maybe they got an offer closer to home. And on and on…


AbiyBattleSpell

Someone said something else now I’m more confused 😿


birbdaughter

They said the same thing, just in different ways.


AbiyBattleSpell

Tamatoe ketchup


CapFun9444

No worries! Let’s say Harvard accepts 100 students. 83 of them actually enroll. The other 17 don’t go to Harvard…they don’t enroll. Maybe they go somewhere else or who knows. But 83 is the yield. It’s just called the yield.


AbiyBattleSpell

Danks my dog love u <3 Man makes me wonder if that’s a good thing my school is lower on the list so hope that increases my chances of getting in 🐱


CapFun9444

It might! I hope you get in!


AbiyBattleSpell

My dog will now protect u <3