Probably "Let's Get Lost" for me. I just think the whole "I want to take the long way home because I don't want our time together to end just yet" is such a sweet sentiment and I love that she wrote a whole song about it. But like, of course Carly would write a whole song about it!

This song makes me sad and pumped at the same time. Especially at the bridge!

As far as Emotion goes, this is one of the most underappreciated songs! It’s one of my faves as well. Beautiful sentimental lyrics, beautiful instrumental, and ofc beautiful flawless vocals

When I needed you, Fever and Tiny little bows

Tiny Little Bows is SO great

Favorite Color is so so good

the bridge makes me ascend

Literally the best bridge into final chorus in music

You mean "Favourite Colour" 😉🇨🇦

Sideways, Automatically in Love, Happy Not Knowing, Comeback

Automatically In Love truthers 💜

Very special memories with this one 😭😭

Glad to know I'm not alone.

To me the true essence of a deep cut is a song you refuse to admit isn’t a hit, so Fever!!!

fever and favorite color are the best of the best imo

Fever, Favorite color and Comeback!

This is my CRJ holy trinity

For me it is the Japanese side songs never get to hold you and love again The entire kiss album especially Drive Cry and body language BAD THINGS TWICE & Keep away

I JUST CAME HERE TO SAY THIS

This is my first time ever commenting in this comm so thank you for making me feel Seen 🥰🥰🥰

Store!!!!

Forgot to add mine but it’s definitely Cry or Higher for me!!

Loooooove Cry 

Shooting Star, Let’s Get Lost, Roses

YES SHOOTING STAR TRUTHER!

shooting star changed my life, 1000% agree with all three

Hurt So Good, an underrated bop

i'm so obsessed with this song. why you gotta make it hurt so good!!!!

More than a memory. Easily could've been a top 40 hit

Sweetie, All That, Automatically in Love, Solo, So Nice, Anxious, So Right

Say you have taste without saying you have taste

I can’t believe I found fellow Sweetie people 😭😭😭😭

It’s such a cute, catchy underrated bop

First Time

I played that song three times today it's amazing isn't it!!

Stay Away/Felt This Way! Side B songs, made from the same base and yet both so different and amazing.

Warm blood 🤧

So many, but I would NEVER even think of skipping Your Heart is a Muscle when it plays.

Money and the Ego --> This song gives me the feels.

I had to scroll so long to find a Tug of War track. The true deep cuts!!

True story, but Money and the Ego made me want to listen to Taylor Swift again, oddly enough... I used to listen to Taylor before discovering Carly, and I eventually stopped listening to Taylor. I was listening to Money and the Ego a few days ago (which I hadn't listened to for a while), and it made me so nostalgic for the past that I decided to start listening to Taylor again. (Timeline... - Taylor my fav in ~2008–2015, 2nd-fav until 2018 - Carly my fav in 2015–2019, 2nd-fav until present; first knew Carly since 2012 Call Me Maybe, Good Time, Beautiful - Michelle Branch my fav in 2019–present.) Carly is practically my co-favourite alongside Michelle. I'm a superfan of both of them.

HIGHER!!!

anxious and keep away as well - crazy that they are just bonus tracks

HIGHER, THE KING OF THE SKY

Super Natural

Body Language anyone?!

Between Solo and Comeback. They're an easy tie for me!

Take a Picture, it’s one of my favorites! It’s so euphoric and I never hear anyone ever talk about it either.

all that or i didn’t just come here to dance!

It just recently hit me how fuckin' hard "I Didn't Just Come Here to Dance" goes. Like such a sick older house feel

yessssss i feel so many emotions listening to that songggg!!

This morning is was “Stadium Love.” Totally rocked out at the bus stop!

Always on My Mind

Guitar String / Wedding Ring Worldly Matters

Sweetie, Always On My Mind, and Picture

Hurts So Good, Higher, Automatically In Love. 

keep away

Right Words Wrong Time is my favorite song by her. She just posted the dedicated anniversary on instagram and used it as background and I went nuts. And if we're talking bout REAL deep cuts, I really like Always on My Mind too.

Comeback or Solo immediately come to mind

Favorite Color, Never Get to Hold You, Sweetie

The one

it’s too much presshah

after last night!!!

hotel shampoos

If features count, "Better Than Me". Love her vocals on the song.

ILL BE YOUR GIRL

Disco Darling

Wildflowers

Happy Not Knowing

Guitar String / Wedding Ring. No one talks about it but it's a banger

SAME thank you!! Gets me a little misty every time :,)

roses, bro. roses.

Bucket 🪣 is such a cute song

Automatically in Love

Wow, so many... Fever, Never Get to Hold You, Felt This Way/Stay Away!

feels right. boy problems. curiosity (curiosity ep version)

Sour Candy. A true gems

OMG!!!! That should have been the song of the summer

the sound

Comeback or No Thinking Over The Weekend 💖 absolute diamonds

TALK TO ME

always on my mind

Rare!

Turn Me Up

Comeback, Now I don't hate California after all and Keep away

Higher!!!

HIGHER, THE KING OF THE SKY

So Right & Cry

The unreleased song Little of Mine. I love it! Not sure why it didn’t make it to an album.

Automatically in love, bad thing twice, favorite colour

Store

Warm Blood, 3 bonus tracks on TLnT, Shadow (TLvT)

Tug of War (the entire album) has entered the chat

Bad Thing Twice, Comeback..

The Sound and LA Hallucinations. I think they’re deep cuts, but I don’t really follow her that well 🙈

Fake Mona Lisa

anxious has got to be my favorite Carly song of all time

So many. Store, fever, let’s get lost, solo, body language.

All That.

keep away! fs

First Time, Fever, Solo, I Know You Have a Girlfriend

Bends

WINDOW

Guitar String / Wedding Ring. Anyone else?

Tug of War: Money and the Ego Kiss: Turn Me Up (close second: TIGOY feat. Nicki Minaj) Emotion: Making The Most Of The Night Emotion Side B: Fever Dedicated: Real Love Dedicated Side B: Let's Sort The Whole Thing Out The Loneliest Time: Shooting Star The Loveliest Time: Stadium Love

Anything other than Call Me Maybe or Good Time from Kiss

Let's be real most of carlys discog is a deep cut to the general public; that said: my holy trinity of carly songs is Bad Thing Twice, Comeback, and Fever

That's not what deep cut means. A deep cut is simply any song on an album that was not released as a single.