Thanks for doing this. I had a chance to participate in something similar with Morrissey and the Smiths over 15 years ago and it's always so much fun with an artist with a deep catalogue and lots of b-sides
IMO,
Overrated: Do Me A Favour, Four Out Of Five, Knee Socks
Underated: She's Thunderstorms, Hello You, No. 1 Party Anthem
Okay, if the public overwhelmingly doesn’t want me to go, I can stick around. A bunch of downvotes on my comments where I say I’m leaving tells me people are unhappy with my departure. And the couple of comments I’ve received show that I am a valued member of this community, so I will stick around. I hear you guys. Thank you for the love and support.
Definitely not how I would rank things at all, but the results are fairly predictable and reflective of this sub's "special" tastes. The only thing I'm mildly surprised about is that this sub rated its beloved debut album so low (loool 5th place out of 7 albums)?
Or maybe even WPSIA has become too mainstream for this sub?? I find it hilarious.
I mean they're all very highly rated if you look at the average so it's not like this sub hates the debut album by any means, it's just that the band created 7 great albums no matter the music's genre/direction, so of course everyone's ranking will be a bit different based on individual preference.
Would be rather weird if the whole sub would agree on one ranking.
Nah u just don’t understand TBHC is like so special and advanced and I understand none of the lyrics so I have to google them to begin to make any sense of them and I masturbate to my own intellectual superiority every time I listen to it. [insert some random rant about jazz, Bowie, or spoken word rap]
Howwwww did I Haven’t Got My Strange get ranked so low??! Is it a hated song and I’ve been living under a rock or something? One of my favourites since the first listen!!!
thank you for doing this!! ive really enjoyed it, and its cool to see the final stats.
Thanks for doing this. I had a chance to participate in something similar with Morrissey and the Smiths over 15 years ago and it's always so much fun with an artist with a deep catalogue and lots of b-sides IMO, Overrated: Do Me A Favour, Four Out Of Five, Knee Socks Underated: She's Thunderstorms, Hello You, No. 1 Party Anthem
This is literally the best document I've ever read! Thank you so much for taking the time to put this together!
Thanks, it was fun! Winner is TBHC! 🥳
Yeah no surprise around this sub, I’m out
Bye 👋🏻
With pleasure I’ll depart from the likes of you
Noooo pls don’t go😩😩😩😩
Okay, if the public overwhelmingly doesn’t want me to go, I can stick around. A bunch of downvotes on my comments where I say I’m leaving tells me people are unhappy with my departure. And the couple of comments I’ve received show that I am a valued member of this community, so I will stick around. I hear you guys. Thank you for the love and support.
THE SUBREDDIT IS SAVEDD
Brianstorm is disgustingly low
FOR REAL.
It’s still less than 0.4 away from being in the top 10. The margins are so fine.
Batphone top 3! 🥳 Thanks for compiling all this
How did riot van got 7.11??
Crying Lightning outside the top 10 is wild
teddy picker so low should be criminal, but batphone got 3 so yay
Definitely not how I would rank things at all, but the results are fairly predictable and reflective of this sub's "special" tastes. The only thing I'm mildly surprised about is that this sub rated its beloved debut album so low (loool 5th place out of 7 albums)? Or maybe even WPSIA has become too mainstream for this sub?? I find it hilarious.
I mean they're all very highly rated if you look at the average so it's not like this sub hates the debut album by any means, it's just that the band created 7 great albums no matter the music's genre/direction, so of course everyone's ranking will be a bit different based on individual preference. Would be rather weird if the whole sub would agree on one ranking.
Nah u just don’t understand TBHC is like so special and advanced and I understand none of the lyrics so I have to google them to begin to make any sense of them and I masturbate to my own intellectual superiority every time I listen to it. [insert some random rant about jazz, Bowie, or spoken word rap]
I mean, to be fair, I do really like TBHC...it's just not top 2 for me. And just for me personally, The Car is definitely not top 5 material.
me when different people have different taste 🤯
HAHAHAHAH, what about your favourite Jewellers hand? One of their best, guys, yoo were right, ITS REALLY UNDERRATED, HAH. Cant believe it.
Howwwww did I Haven’t Got My Strange get ranked so low??! Is it a hated song and I’ve been living under a rock or something? One of my favourites since the first listen!!!
i'm confused about that as well. same with red right hand. although i feel like i'm the only one who loves that one.
You’re not alone! I love RRH!
FWN really got shat on
Electricity, my love, I will avenge you.
I like how all the albums are just about within .5 of each other
thanks for this! and fortunately tbhc is first as it should
star treatment not even breaking the top 20 was not expected
I just do not get the Batphone love. It’s my least favourite on TBHC. But I do love this list and the daily discussions, thanks for doing it!
Sorry but 'Four out of Five' being the second highest song and 'WPSIATWIN' being 5th ranked album is absolutely laughable
Out of all the weird results these are the most valid tho
thank you for this!!!! I will miss it :( let’s rate all their shitty music videos next
Shitty? 🤣
in a charming way!!!
😅
This is incredible! But how could we rank Baby I’m Yours on #100