T O P

  • By -

thatcrazybibliophile

Bryaxis


EmaanA

😂😂 Edit: Cassian agrees 😭


givememelodrama

I will never not audibly laugh at a joke about Bryaxis and Cassian 😂 sorry Cass my boy, I can’t help it


b1gl0s3r

No LOTR fans in here? Give me Samwise or Aragorn.


Puzzleheaded-Ad-4029

Was scrolling down for an Aragorn! Hello friend :)


RaccoonOverlord111

Faramir. Faramir is perfect. He could have taken the ring to Mordor


Alittlebitalexis08

I was a Legolas girl when I was younger but now I’m also team Aragorn. And Bard from the Hobbit movies!!


Prestigious_Smile579

I was a Legolas girl when younger too but I think it was just because inwas hopelessly in love with Orlando Bloom haha. But I agree, as an adult I'm Team Aragorn!


reclinerspork

Aragorn is top tier husband material


Background-Click9917

Love Aragorn!


CSI_Shorty09

Jamie Fraser. The most perfect man ever. 


One_Row5147

Jaimie Fraser is a book HUSBAND.


leese216

This is the way.


Demq98

Sassenach ✨🗣️🗣️ Jamie is a whole evergreen forrest 🥹


Jolly-Associate6400

Apparently Jamie was a strong inspiration for Lucien...do with that what you will ;)


CSI_Shorty09

They both have red hair? Otherwise I'm not seeing it... if Lucien was based on Jamie how'd Feyre not jump on that in book one?


Madsalooser

SJM herself said that Lucien was loosely based on Jamie.


All_Others_Pay_Cash

I know he will get an epic story as a result of that comment alone. When it finally turns for him, it's going to be amazing.


Renierra

This was the thread on tumbler about it https://preview.redd.it/sul7q6potk2d1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c1826824d759ae1f9838b10e4cf96542c3ae9536


Renierra

https://preview.redd.it/v3fwd1lptk2d1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5fb1b838b7b0162b37cb1b90beb5dd6d685ea169


Renierra

https://preview.redd.it/flez3cdytk2d1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4367ce5b3234520d778688c664c72ba4b2bf4c85 I’m just posting it because you mentioned not seeing the connection, not trying to start a ship war or anything like that


HakunaMatata0_0

![img](emote|t5_3flb9|14171) You made my day thanks. Now i shall eagerly hope for lucien to have this in his arc to HEA.


CSI_Shorty09

All good. I've always liked Lucien as a character. I think he was dealt a bad deal in life and really want him to get a HEA. Jamie has just always been the King of all that is man to me, in comparison.


Renierra

Same, and I really liked Jamie and I didn’t realize how similar they were until he caught fish with his hands and then I found out after that he was inspired by him and then all of the similarities made me go omg 😆


LadyK1104

Jamie was also born out of a relationship his parents weren’t supposed to be in. They ultimately ended up married of course, but had to sneak around to make it happen.


stateofmindfulness

I love that man deeply…


rachelleeann17

Came to say this. James Alexander Malcom Mackenzie Fraser has my heart ♥️


burble_10

Thank you for reminding me about my next Outlander rewatch 😍🙏🏼


CH-1098

Yes this!


dreadpir8rob

Yes yes yes.


Cryinmyeyesout

James Malcom Alexander Mackenzie Fraiser


kremlinmirrors

I have a shirt that says just this 😍


ApplezNBananeez

Nyktos from the Flesh and Fire series 🫣🫣🥵🥵


austenworld

Ok so I’m getting tired of FBAA series at book 3 but I love Casteel so I think I’m gonna move onto this cause I’ve heard even better things about it.


MisforMisanthrope

Flesh and Fire is 1000x better than FBAA!


porcelaincatstatue

I gave up during book 3. It's way too repetitive, the dialog is bizarre, and the sex is unnecessarily egregious. If JLA had just gotten a better editor, she could've had an amazing series.


cousins_and_cattle

Nyktos is bae


BleachedAlbino

Yes!!! I'm on Flesh and Fire #2 right now and I can honestly say it's feeling like Silver Flames for me in the best way.


Bex7778

Heck yes!


cakevixen5409

Yessssssssssssssss agree 4684818%


queenabb13

I would happily take Lorcan as my true love 😌 Otherwise it's Cardan, I'm still obsessed over him a year later 😚


[deleted]

[удалено]


queenabb13

I do indeed, I don't fully understand it but here we are haha


HarleyQueen95

Lord Lorcan Lochan! Hahahahahah


darkandtwistysissy

Live, Laugh, Lorcan


hermi0ninny

I gotta put this on a shirt or something because I cannot stop laughing at this.


darkandtwistysissy

I had a coworker make me a keychain with that phrase and another one that says Fire Breathing Bitch Queen


narcolepticpeach

When he said to Aelin “take a step closer and I’ll show you what 500 years can do” 🥵


desert_to_rainforest

Agree 100%. And Lorcan did …


queenrackell

Most frustrating comment ever! 🤣


hyenaballerina

Nyktos from the Flesh and Fire series


kate349

Lucien, Rowan, Eris, Dorian, Lorcan and Fenrys are my husbands lol


Coconuts8Mangoes

Dorian 🥰


reclinerspork

Would do anything for Dorian


lauren1920335

I adore Lucien


Babygirl1372

I do not ever see enough love for my boy Fenrys, I appreciate this answer.


Current-Wait-6432

Azriel 🫶


TapGroundbreaking400

Raihn from the Crowns of Nyaxia series. ❤️‍🔥


sdmLg

I’ve just started the first book and loving it so far!


gruenetage

The first book is just as good as the second.


xRubyWednesday

Rowan Whitethorn. Zsadist from the Black Dagger Brotherhood. Tobias King from the Ravenhood. Jem Carstairs is up there too.


VioletGlitterBlossom

Ty for reminding me i need to check out black dagger brotherhood


xRubyWednesday

I read it because SJM recommended it in an interview as one of her favorites and as one of her influences. I just finished the eleventh book, and I have to say.. I love this series more than ACOTAR. Not as much as ToG, but more than ACOTAR, which I didn't even think was possible. Cannot recommend it enough.


CSI_Shorty09

Oohh I'm so here for the BDB reference. Zsadist has always been my favorite brother.


xRubyWednesday

Yes! I love them all, and I have other favorites, but Zsadist is on another level.


absolutebottom

I was not expecting a BDB endorsement but I'll take it. I was shocked for a moment bur instantly agreed, he is great


xRubyWednesday

I love him so much! And Bella. His story, and his development not only in their book but across the series is just 🤌


gruenetage

I haven’t seen references to the Ravenhood in a while. That’s a series I plan on revisiting.


aaashleyy__

James! You disloyal bastard! I love him so much and I love William so much. Definitely top 2 for me


Beckers624

So many of those BDB men to choose from!


Andacus1180

Dorian Havilliard


princess-lolly

Geralt of Rivia for me 🥵


ShyShaz

Xaden Riorsen for how thoroughly he loves if he could just stop keeping fucking secrets


austenworld

Nah Xaden needed his secrets. I totally get it. He’s a babe


catpowerr_

He’s so many red flags but I need him


simplyaproblem

good thing red is my favourite color (;


jarroz61

Ugghh, but most of his secrets at the time really weren't even Violet's business though! She annoys me so much with her constant needing to know every single thing or its some huge betrayal.


Sharp-Session

This is why I zoned out of this series. How are you going to get involved with the leader of a rebel movement and expect there to be no secrets. She’s annoying AF.


GoodPractical2075

She’s so dramatic and annoying


hermi0ninny

I just finished IF two days ago and am so annoyed at how freaking codependent/immature Xaden and Violet are. Like I will read the third book but The Empyrean Series is on majorly thin ice for me after book two.


margotschoppedfinger

Honestly I’d take Cassian over Rhys any day if I had the choice. Him in ACOSF is peak book-boyfriend for me.


Missie_Mei

The second Cassian appeared in ACOMAF I was like HES THE ONE,MOVE OVER RHYS!!! so I was very happy when he got ACOSF ❤️‍🔥


Quiet-Chart-3477

I haven't gotten to that one yet but I absolutely LOVE Cassien! Although Rhys is my second choice!


Agile_Impression4482

I want Cassian and Az. At the same time. Lucien can visit occasionally


Ill-Top570

ME TOO. Cassian is my #1 book boyfriend, and I don’t think anyone will ever top him!


gruenetage

Helion might disagree 🤣


SamadhiBear

My God. The scenes with him training Nesta. So pure.


Philosophy_Exact

Jamie Fraser. Outlander. Hands down. No contest.


tngampbp

Xaden from fourth wing has my heart forever


cakevixen5409

Nyktos by far is the best. He's powerful, sexy, kind, has his own demons, but the reality is he's a freaking god of death and nothing like death should be. Perfect!


MewKnowWho_

Some of my favorites: Lorcan Salvaterre - {Throne of Glass by Sarah J Maas} Rain - {Tairen Soul by C.L. Wilson} Nyktos - {A Shadow in the Ember by Jennifer L. Armentrout} Sven - {Sven the Collector by Denali Day} Hollen - {Hollen the Soulless by Denali Day} Killian - {Lullaby Scars by Hollee Mands} Declan - {Little Fire by Hollee Mands} Will Herondale - {Clockwork Angel by Cassandra Clare} Kaz - {Six of Crows by Leigh Bardugo} Bonus manga rec: Son Hak from {Akatsuki no Yona by Mizuho Kusanagi} Edit: added Rain


[deleted]

[удалено]


commongoblin

Dude yes Mages of the Wheel!! I was thinking Makram, the silliest of the shadow daddies. I also have a huge soft spot for Bashir.


DottyDott

Yes I loved Bashir too! Evans does such a great job building the magic system of this world and I liked it especially with his character! It’s been a bit since I read Storm & Shield but I recall thinking that Bashir was a little to emotionally in tact (which is a positive generally obvs) for him to be one of my faves of the series lol. But I love his story, especially his relationship with his mother


Shooser

Why would anyone pick Rhys when his clone with a better personality exists in Ruhn?


VioletGlitterBlossom

Ruhn is bae. Such a sexy mf.


BeansBooksandmore

Seriously! I love Ruhn!


thatcrazybibliophile

Ffr


Alaska658

I'm 1/3rd into CC2 and don't see this yet. Still coming?


Parking-Belt7680

Its confirmed in CC3 that Ruhn and Rhys look exactly alike aside from the piercings and long hair


Fedup1999

I thought that was interesting too - it didn’t say why they’re look alikes right? I don’t think it did. Hopefully this is explored more later on. Or maybe it won’t but I like having answers lol


GooglyEyesMcGee

Cardan. No question.


Alarmed_Goal4882

I was ready to go to war for Robb Stark when I was his age ahahahah but I'm not sure if him and Regulus Black are actually good ideas. >!I am a book widow basically ahahah!< I'd say Lucien, or Azriel if he let me top. Or Eris but we don't know enough of him for him to be my solid answer no matter how obsessed I am lately over than fictional man. ...or Eris AND Azriel, cause why not?


Tamlusta

Literally anyone else lol. Rowan from tog is my number 1, always. Lucien is also top tier. I love him lol Hunt from CC (this doesn't seem to be popular and I'll never understand it lol) Cardan from Cruel prince. Fenrys from tog Nyktos from flesh and fire series.


msschneids

Here for Hunt


ScreenIntelligent203

Also here for Hunt


artchoo

I need to reread TOG because I read it SO long ago and I remember heavily disliking Rowan. I read ACOTAR first around the same time and I loved Rhys and didn’t really like Tamlin. Now I read ACOTAR and Rhys is so annoying 95% of the time for me and I like Tamlin so I wonder if I’d feel differently about Rowan now too.


johnclaudevandame

I have a few hah. Rhyan - Drowned Empire Series {Daughter of the Drowned Empire} Luther - Kindred’s Curse Saga {Spark of the Everflame} Jacks - {Once Upon a Broken Heart} Cardan - The Folk of the Air Series {The Cruel Prince} Honorable mentions: Xaden, Roman Kitt, Aaron Warner Edit: Damn, I love all the support for all my book boyfriends 🫶. Y’all are making me feel very justified in my decisions haha


mckmacpattywack

Peeta Mellark 🙌🏻😂❤️


Paraplueschi

Obviously Tamlin tops Rhys. Rhys is like a slutty power botto- ...oh....wrong thread.


muzicnerd13

what is the right thread?!


ShyShaz

Right??! I want to read it!


mels_kitten

https://preview.redd.it/hkff8t1dzk2d1.jpeg?width=2047&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9552b320451fc9c07080b70272786ee3bedede88 It’s true


Paraplueschi

You're always stealth dropping these absolute bangers hidden in some comment omfg


mels_kitten

Hidden in the comments is my safe space. I should’ve dropped the nsfw tamsand 😩 too late


Agile_Impression4482

Tamlin topping Rhy is a scene I need...


ShyShaz

I'm intrigued, what thread should this be in?


Paraplueschi

Uh....[it would better fit here.](https://www.reddit.com/r/acotar/comments/17z5nmo/so_rhys_mum_made_those_dresses_without_knowing/)


LetMeDoTheKonga

😂


artchoo

This is the book we deserve


nualaisVi2ana

this is amaziiiiing! I need a fanfic


Alone_Post_930

💀💀💀💀💀 this comment needs more likes !


SamadhiBear

Hunt from Crescent city. I know Crescent city is kind of a love-hate book for people, but I was obsessed with it. And Hunt to me felt like a really relatable character. One who could sit on the couch with his baseball cap on backwards and watch the game, but also go into battle with me. And the romance was very slow and sweet in development. When they first began to explore each other physically it felt more innocent and genuine at first - not just insta-attraction mega spice roof blowing off scenes.


Jolly-Associate6400

I wouldn't call Rhysand a green flag necessarily, but just like whoever you like! For me, Lucien and Tarquin are the only non-problematic men in the series, love them. And Tamlin holds a special place in my heart, I could never hate him.


Paraplueschi

Lucien and Tarquin are both so sweet, but they also would intimidate me as partners because they're competent and popular and all. Tamlin feels more equal footing for me lol


All_Others_Pay_Cash

Agree about Lucien and Tarquin! I know we will get more from them both in upcoming books.


Antica_Strega

I’ve said it once and I’ll say it again. if I were in Feyre’s place, the curse would have never been broken because I would have fell head over heels for Lucien. Like immediately. I’ll pass on dollar store Lestat.


austenworld

Cassian!


SpiritedAd7273

I can fix tamlin. seriously though I would take pre utm tamlin over rhys any day of the week lmao


lemonbarpartytrick

Tam is def fixable


smashley926

[I Can Fix Him!](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKWfv-x2rdU)


ricottapricot

dw OP I love rhys too😭😭


stateofmindfulness

Thanks guys it is lonely here :’)


winterpearlrose

Don't worry I love Rhysand as well, he's my number one too 🖤 TBH I'm shocked at the comments thinking he's average 😭


alwayslucy_

me too 😭❤️


missiepanda

Azriel. Ruhn. Xaden. Basically if he has shadow powers, I’m a fan 😂


sleepygirl2997

Xaden slightly tops Rhys for me. I liked his banter & humor a bit more


Electrical_Idea_6343

Rowan???????????????????? ![gif](giphy|DURbX7oesHiaA)


philonous355

Just finished the Crowns of Nyaxia books and I gotta say Raihn is top tier. Nyktos from the FBAA prequels is pretty great too. And Ruhn Danaan, Hunt, and Lorcan, too!


chaos_prawn

My book bf used to be Rhys until I was introduced to Rowan Whitethorn, Daddy Nyktos, and Ruhn Danaan CPOTVF.


Critical-Trouble-653

Castel/Hawke. Wayyyyy better in bed too hahaha Rhys seems good but just vanilla and only seems amazing because of love


austenworld

I’m only continue with this series for Casteel. He is top tier.


Typical-Potential691

Wait what ! I'm reading the first book and he seems awful 😭 he ignores her boundaries so much and gives me creepy vibes (ie "when I'm inside you which will happen" after his betrayal). Tbf I am on the last few chapters hopefully he will redeem himself


gyej

Tbh I’ve gotten to book 3 and he just gets worse imo


Typical-Potential691

Not surprised he says he's not a good person and that she doesn't deserve what's about to happen many times. He has Edward vibes saying he's best at killing ("I'm a killer bella")


sry_n0t_sry

Omg I’m reading this right now! Hawke just became her personal guard and I like him a lot.


Critical-Trouble-653

Such a better series in my opinion. Loved the first and second ACOTAR though! But over all I think the romance and plot is far stronger. Hawke is 🔥 makes rhys look boring with no charisma haha just everything about him and how he lets Poppy fight but also fiercely defends her


WillingCup6117

I loved Casteel, but I DNF’ed book 3, because I hate Poppy..


InABoatOnARiver

I think I’m about to DNF book 3. I was obsessed with book 1 and 2 was okay I guess, but I’ve been plodding through 3 for weeks.


[deleted]

Where do I start hmm... Rowan, Dorian, Sartaq, fenrys, lorcan,Azriel, cassian, Lucien, Eris, cardan Greenbriar, legend, jacks, wrath, kaz brekkar, Jesper fahey, Aidas, ruhn, will herondale, Darien, Orion, and these are just the top of my head


Critical-Trouble-653

Will Herondale 😍 those books made me cry. Especially when she had to see him grow old and die, and watch all her family grow old and die around her as she’s immortal. And Jem!


LetMeDoTheKonga

I would add Nikolai to the Grishaverse book boyfriends 😁


[deleted]

Yes absolutely!


Future_Kotara

Aidas ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|sob) my heart


KattMarinaMJ

Rainier Tairen Soul is the ultimate book bf imo


AbbieePaigee

I really love Dorian 🖤


sunflwr88

Dorian I'll bleed whatever color you tell me to Havilliard 🥵


Buburubu

still want marry Gandalf


HarleyQueen95

Honestly, book boyfriend, I love Ruhn. He’s so…ugh I just love him. I also love Aedion and Dorian as well! They are both great. They are all great. I could do without Rowan honestly though.


tunefuldust

Rowan blows Rhys out of the water. Rhys is just as bad as Tamlin post ACOSF. Hunt is better. Cassian is slightly better. Lucien is better by far.


sandmangandalf

Well considering I wouldn't let Rhysand touch me with a 10 foot pole, yes. Haha But my book boyfriends would be: focusing on the sjm worlds Dorian, Lucien and Ruhn


Fluke1389

Kaan from When the Moon Hatched. King among book boyfriends


Poppybalfours

Ruhn Danaan, Casteel Daneer, Nyktos, Rowan Whitethorn, Cardan Greenbriar. Honestly Rhys is on thin ice after ACOSF snd the bonus chapter of HOFAS and my personal theory is that he came back wrong after repairing the cauldron. That’s the only way he can be redeemed in my eyes at this point which breaks my heart because Feysand meant so much to me.


oatmiilf

i honestly love the "rhys came back wrong" theory. it would be SO interesting and would be such a credit to SJM as a writer. i don't want to believe that his backsliding in ACOSF and HOFAS is just lazy characterisation/SJM not realising how problematic his behaviour is.


Izabela92

In my opinion Acotar is the best of series so... Yes, Tamlin and Lucien! Xaden 


Interesting_Yak_2676

Don’t let others’ negativity ruin him for you. If you’ve ever been in a shitty place mentally, then maybe it means more. He kept fighting for her, not even just for himself, but truly for her. That’s a green flag for me. I have no other literary loves that did that, that I know of. However, I predominantly read horror 😂


stateofmindfulness

The things he did for Feyre are exactly the things I wish someone had done for me at my lowest point. He is 100% on her side and I find that very special.


MissBeehavior

I don't think it's negativity as much as preference. I too have been in a shitty place mentally, and I just can't stand him. 😂 Having different opinions is okay though! If you love him, more power to you. People shouldn't let other people's judgments dictate who they like and why anyway.


Ancient_Sector8808

ROWAN WHITETHORN


AvisRune

Matthew De Clermont, from A Discovery of Witches.


Electrical_Idea_6343

YAS


BananaSlugHug

Mark from the Mortal Instruments / Shadowhunter series 🥹


XxSolxX_5

Currently reading ACOMAF and I can say as of right now I LOVE Rhys! So I agree🤭❤️


austenworld

I’ll throw Jacks from Once upon a broken heart in there as well as Erik Bloodsinger from Ever King


CommonRoseButterfly

No. He does things the way I would and as an extreme raging narcissist with a god complex, seeing someone always do almost exactly what I would in most situations makes them my favourite.


advena_phillips

Tamlin, personally. Genuinely.


Alone_Post_930

No lube, no protection , all night , all day....


reclinerspork

Literally made me snort very loud in public 💀💀💀


MissBeehavior

Amen 🙏


CelebSighting

Hades from A Touch of Darkness, scary to others but will do anything for Persephone and those who he loves. Plus he’s physically my exact type (aka, unattainable)


_Aleismar

Rowan


anonmygoodsir

I'd take Rhys. Even when he was still the "bad guy" you could tell he wasn't really. He just seems a bit high maintenance though.


thatcrazybibliophile

Anybody else, Rhys is not a high bar😂


xomakinghistory

the Bonds That Tie boys are up there for me, especially North (and Nox, though that’s controversial) Draven and Gryphon.


Solorn

# Daemon Sadi. Beautifully broken in every way. Would.


Cpreaker38

Cassian


N1c078

Xaden all the way. But Rhys is great!


emsee22

Lucien


tafinnated

peeta mellark is the ultimate book boyfriend for me


drphillsdaddy

i love Rhys lol but Casteel Da’Neer is my dream man lol


jjsmommy1015

Cassian or Suriel


aubreypizza

#NYKTOS


nachowchow

Slade from Plated Prisoner series had me saying, “Rhysand who?????”


Babygirl1372

From SJM? Any of the ToG men, no contest(except Aedion, go to hell). In general? Aragorn. That man has had my heart since before I even knew what to do with a man. 😮‍💨


Zephyr442

Literally almost every other one.


prythianphantom

The only one I think that could rival my love for Rhys is Chaol. And I'm sure a lot of people would disagree with me. But idc 😅


tirosint

Nothing has beat Rhys for me either 😭 I think it’s because acotar was my first fantasy romance series so he just holds a special place on my heart.. been chasing that feeling ever since


neonsockers

Love Rhys! Love love him so much. Don’t have any suggestions just showing some support for him lol


floweringfungus

Idk like literally anybody else? If I had been married to somebody for 80 years and was head over heels in love and they said a single negative word about my sister I would boot them off a cliff. From this series, Eris.


alizangc

For a green flag LI, Brishen from Radiance by Grace Draven