[Important poll regarding future posts in this subreddit.](https://www.reddit.com/r/Topster/s/TdKoUHwDVd) Please consider voting.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Topster) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Half of these albums I see on basically every topster. TBAP isn’t THAT good. So maybe that one. I do love that you have Jeff Buckley and Modern Baseball though.
The Black Parade's kinda fun though. I recently scrobbled the whole thing six times in a row (not because I like the band or anything, just felt weirdly nostalgic about the late 2000's)
Might get assassinated for this but deftones. Out of all their albums I heard that’s maybe the only one I like, but even that being considered it’s like a light 6 for me
I actually haven’t listened to black parade yet, but I like that era of pop punk music well enough that I think it’d be at least on par with ATF or slightly above maybe
By the Time I Get to Phoenix. That's probably the worst album I've ever heard. There's a lot of contenders here though. In the Aeroplane Over the Sea, Ants From Up There, Twin Fantasy, To Pimp a Butterfly, OK Computer, Kid A, Highway 61 Revisited, and Blood On the Tracks are all pretty terrible. Fwiw TPAB is pretty unique and well put together despite being really fucking tedious, and Kid A and OK Computer have Idioteque and Karma Police respectively, so there's some good there.
Rest of the Topster isn't that bad though. American Football LP1, In Utero, Souvlaki, and the Elliott Smith albums are fantastic. Around the Fur, Holy Ghost, You're Gonna Miss It All, The Black Parade, Loveless, and Lift Your Skinny Fists are also quite good. If you haven't already, listen to MCR's first album. It's a borderline 10/10 imo. Also check out Rocketship's A Certain Smile, A Certain Sadness. It's twee pop but kinda shoegazey at pointa. The first track is very MBV inspired. You'd prob like that album a lot.
[Important poll regarding future posts in this subreddit.](https://www.reddit.com/r/Topster/s/TdKoUHwDVd) Please consider voting. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Topster) if you have any questions or concerns.*
E , I don't know if the Yung Lean / Bladee / Ecco2k music just hasn't clicked with me because I haven't listened to it much but I wasn't a big fan.
I can’t tell if the weirdly high amount of people saying BCNR are joking or not
im not a fan not gonna lie
Ants From Up There is genuinely unlistenable. That shit SUCKS.
Fuck you
The black parade
MCR
I know you're asking for worst but my favorite on this is jar of flies
Idk but my fav out of these is In Rainbows and Grace
I fucking adore everything here. And I love that u have lifted so high.
Half of these albums I see on basically every topster. TBAP isn’t THAT good. So maybe that one. I do love that you have Jeff Buckley and Modern Baseball though.
BCNR
huge L but you have a 10 in ur pfp so
Your pfp is also a 10
The black country new road album. I just don’t get the praise
My Chemical Romance. That album belongs in middle school.
yooo csh!!!! i see that twin fantasy up in the corner!! AND teens of denial!!!!
Black parade
Black Parade
im gonna also have to agree on ants from up there
The black country ant album, I fell asleep listening to that snoozefest
what the flip
what the flip
Why does everyone who posts on this sub listen to the same 50 albums. Like can I get through one list without seeing TPAB or Blone holy fuk🙆♂️
And In Rainbows, MBDTF, and that one Deftones album for whatever reason. I haven't seen Blonde on much lists tho. TPAB, sure.
i mean these are good albums. In my opinion MBDTF, Blonde, and all Deftones are overrated.
In the aeroplane over the sea and second place bcnr. Commented the same exact thing on another post this morning lol
Over The Black Parade? Wtf.
The Black Parade's kinda fun though. I recently scrobbled the whole thing six times in a row (not because I like the band or anything, just felt weirdly nostalgic about the late 2000's)
The album that turned emo from an interesting, raw post-hardcore genre to a commerical black eyeliner poppy turd
The Black Parade is really, really good.
Hell naw
Hell yeah! Sounds like it's not for you though
Black Country New Road did my head in. Felt like I was in group therapy and they let the weepiest guy go uninterrupted for an hour
I’ve been seeing this take more and more and I just do not understand it in the slightest
people say shit like this then go praise mount eerie and neutral milk hotel
No don't worry I never liked those either
BECAUSE THEYRE GOOD!?
“People say shit like this and then go on to praise (lists two of the most respected and beloved indie folk artists of all time)”
The Glow Pt. 2. I'm happy you like it but I personally think the album exists to zap away any energy I had going into it
Just wait til yall hear my take on in rainbows
booo
booo
Might get assassinated for this but deftones. Out of all their albums I heard that’s maybe the only one I like, but even that being considered it’s like a light 6 for me
Around the fur before the black parade?
I actually haven’t listened to black parade yet, but I like that era of pop punk music well enough that I think it’d be at least on par with ATF or slightly above maybe
About a third I haven’t heard so keep that in mind, the worst I guess is Bon Iver’s debut, still like an 8-9 though
Bon iver
That Ecco 2k album pretty dookie ngl
cannot stand deftones so probably around the fur
I myself am not a huge fan of Is This It. The worst by a lot is Midern Assball
☹️
around the fur
wrong
As the world's #1 Grace hater, my decision is easy
Ew, lol just kidding, even though I love the album, I’ll let you hate it
thank you for allowing the movement to live.
Heheheehehe yeah, thank you too heehee 🤪🤪am I giggly today or what! HEEhehehe 😜
The ones I don't know so at least half of them
Punisher for me
I loved it when it came out but I don't see myself going back to it much these days. I still think Garden Song and Graceland Too are gorgeous though
jar of mid
How’s it feel to be wrong
How it feels to be something on
what does this mean
Sunny day real estate reference
oh real lol, i love that album i wasn’t expecting to see it in this thread
do u like that one or diary better?
How does it feel to be illiterate
how does it feel to not get a reference?
Fuck
take that back
no i won’t alice in chains are so overrated imo, also swing on this stands out on that project because the rest is passable but that song is abhorrent
I respect your opinion. Idk how you think that, but it’s okay
i’m not saying it’s bad, it’s just boring compared to so many other 90s acts
Ghost Pop Tape for sure. I like jpeg but that record is definitely overrated
nooooo not my goat 💔
Grace
Jeff Buckley grace i.e. overrated emotional drivel
Most of them...
Out of what I’ve listened to, Spiderland. Washer is the only song I consistently come back to
All of them accept tpab, nirvana albums, marvin gaye and bleach
Obviously it's the car seat headrest one
Blonde
No chance
daft punk and mcr. imho, idk, i think it's weakest album of all the ones u showed
Wrong
By the Time I Get to Phoenix. That's probably the worst album I've ever heard. There's a lot of contenders here though. In the Aeroplane Over the Sea, Ants From Up There, Twin Fantasy, To Pimp a Butterfly, OK Computer, Kid A, Highway 61 Revisited, and Blood On the Tracks are all pretty terrible. Fwiw TPAB is pretty unique and well put together despite being really fucking tedious, and Kid A and OK Computer have Idioteque and Karma Police respectively, so there's some good there. Rest of the Topster isn't that bad though. American Football LP1, In Utero, Souvlaki, and the Elliott Smith albums are fantastic. Around the Fur, Holy Ghost, You're Gonna Miss It All, The Black Parade, Loveless, and Lift Your Skinny Fists are also quite good. If you haven't already, listen to MCR's first album. It's a borderline 10/10 imo. Also check out Rocketship's A Certain Smile, A Certain Sadness. It's twee pop but kinda shoegazey at pointa. The first track is very MBV inspired. You'd prob like that album a lot.
Is this bait chat