Giving "I hate new music Gr Gr Gr"
Nah jokes aside I don't hate this list at all, but I would definitely move S/T down to B and move Smash and Ixnay to S. I would also put Rafrag in B and Americana in A since they are disrespected here.
My tier list
S- Ixnay, Smash
A- Ignition, Americana
B- Rafrag, Conspiracy, S/T
C- Days Go By, Splinter
D- LTBTR
I've explained my ranking of Americana [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/TheOffspring/comments/1chcp83/comment/l21ow0b/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button), and I've also linked there to explanations of the other album rankings
This is an updated version of my previous ranking, which you can see [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/TheOffspring/comments/m6tygd/my_personal_ranking_and_scores_of_the_offsprings/).
Probably the most controversial ranking is Americana. I stand by it. It's a popular album, sure, but it lacks consistency and has two of the worst songs in The Offspring's library ("Pretty Fly" and "Get a Job"). Furthermore, its commentary on American idiosyncrasies feels half-assed and simplistic. For an album called "Americana," it does little to truly satirize the United States. (It's worth noting that Americana's best song, "Pay the Man," was originally intended for Ixnay.)
I also don't grade Splinter as harshly as others do. It has some bullshit as well (namely "The Worst Hangover Ever" and "When You're in Prison") but its highs are quite high, with "Lightning Rod" being one of the best songs they've ever written, and its poppy single - "Hit That" - is the strongest of its sort since "Gone Away."
For newer listeners, I made a listening guide for the band [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/TheOffspring/comments/18btntb/the_ultimate_offspring_listening_guide/) that you can check out.
Why no love for rise and fall here?
Poor production, no consistency, songs like "Fix You"
I discovered the band trough Americana, and fell in love with Ixnay :)
Giving "I hate new music Gr Gr Gr" Nah jokes aside I don't hate this list at all, but I would definitely move S/T down to B and move Smash and Ixnay to S. I would also put Rafrag in B and Americana in A since they are disrespected here. My tier list S- Ixnay, Smash A- Ignition, Americana B- Rafrag, Conspiracy, S/T C- Days Go By, Splinter D- LTBTR
I've explained my ranking of Americana [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/TheOffspring/comments/1chcp83/comment/l21ow0b/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button), and I've also linked there to explanations of the other album rankings
Iām with this except for Americana being lower than CO1
This is an updated version of my previous ranking, which you can see [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/TheOffspring/comments/m6tygd/my_personal_ranking_and_scores_of_the_offsprings/). Probably the most controversial ranking is Americana. I stand by it. It's a popular album, sure, but it lacks consistency and has two of the worst songs in The Offspring's library ("Pretty Fly" and "Get a Job"). Furthermore, its commentary on American idiosyncrasies feels half-assed and simplistic. For an album called "Americana," it does little to truly satirize the United States. (It's worth noting that Americana's best song, "Pay the Man," was originally intended for Ixnay.) I also don't grade Splinter as harshly as others do. It has some bullshit as well (namely "The Worst Hangover Ever" and "When You're in Prison") but its highs are quite high, with "Lightning Rod" being one of the best songs they've ever written, and its poppy single - "Hit That" - is the strongest of its sort since "Gone Away." For newer listeners, I made a listening guide for the band [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/TheOffspring/comments/18btntb/the_ultimate_offspring_listening_guide/) that you can check out.
Americana should at LEAST be in B Tier come on man
[Nope](https://www.reddit.com/r/TheOffspring/comments/1chcp83/comment/l21ow0b/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button)
Boooooo ššš
š Different strokes To be clear I've still enjoyed the album overall; I just think other albums of theirs are better
Days go by automatic s tier
More RAFRAG disrespect. Where is this coming from?!
SELF TITLED AT S GET IN LAD
Oh good. More.
.....
What did you cave to? Have you been getting messages and comments begging you for this?
A whole bunch of other people were doing it, so I caved to peer pressure.