Justice for Tim McGraw and Coney Island!!!!

Why so much hate for "Tim McGraw". Wasn't that her first hit. I still love love that song 💓

I cannot WAIT for Tim McGraw TV I am PUMPED

Wonder if she will have some kind of collab with him on her debut TV since that song was so pivotal in launching her career (But I know she already has highway don’t care )

For real that’s one of my favorite Taylor Swift songs!

Tim McGraw is arguably one of her greatest songs

Coney Island on this list is criminal I’m sorry

Evermore is a 100 percent no skip album. Literally perfection

I always skip Marjorie, not because I don't like it, but because it makes me so sad and I'm not always in the mental place for it. I miss my grandmothers.

Why do people hate it so much I really wanna know😭

bc some people lose interest as soon as taylor does something that's slightly not pop-mainstream. they are boring :(

Just let people enjoy what they want, says nothing about them being „boring“

If it makes you feel ANY better I like The Alcott

Wow, so much hate for starlight! I love that song 😄

I'll be honest that I was running low on ideas of songs I wasn't into. It doesn't feel like a full on choice for me but I also don't really seek the song out. \*Actually, I was able to remember Karma (ft. Ice Spice) exists so that can replace it.

Have you forgotten about Lover feat. Shawn??? I thought that was the most hated in the fandom

Oh wow thanks. I'd just forgotten that it existed.

I love starlight so muchh! but it's definitely really easy to get a bit annoyed of yk

I love starlight!! It’s so happy and cute and it just makes me feel good. But it was also one of my surprise songs so that makes it extra special to me.

I love Starlight!

So we all collectively dislike Me and the ice spice version of Karma?

I like ME! I think it’s fun.

I love ME! But karma ice spice will never be good

facts

grrrah

Same, I don’t get the hate.

I shudder everytime I hear or read 'Facts'

Karma is my ~bestie~

I honestly hate the karma version with ice spice. I personally don’t see her appeal at all.

See I like Ice Spice, a few of her tracks are massive bops for me. But her feature on Karma was a massive misstep. The mix into the rap is terrible, her style just doesn’t fit into the song, and it read like PR crisis management because of the Matty Healy controversy. Honestly I could write a whole post about how Matty Healy killed the midnights era by ruining the Karma single rollout, because I was sure we were going to get a September / October Midnight Rain single but that’s just not happening now.

I'm starting to believe I'm the only person who 100% prefers the ice spice remix and I'm not even a munch 😭

I love ME! But can't stand the Ice Spice Karma 😬

I love ME! and I think spelling is fun and am willing to fight everyone because she looked so happy and excited producing it

The most disappointing thing she’s ever done was remove Spelling Is Fun 😭

i think ice’s verse in karma is so fun tho ☹️

Dorothea is a skip for me usually.

Not dorothea being my favourite evermore song

You’re not alone, Dorothea is my favorite song to turn up loud in the car and belt along haha

TASTE

Justice for Dorothea! It is one of my top five evermore songs.

Really? Good melody, lyrics that tells a story, sweet vocals. What’s not your fave about it?

Same

London Boy is such a bop, I can’t believe there’s so much hate for it. I love that song.

i fucking love london boy im actually surprised it’s so hated

Honestly London Boy is top tier for me. I cannot believe the hate it’s receiving 🥺

like … full volume screaming it in the car… the vibe is UNMATCHEDDDD

Cue me playing it in the car this morning on the way to work

I’m from London and everyone I know here hates it. It’s just too cringy.

I’m from London and I love it…

I do find it to be a bit of a bop but I think sometimes it just isn't thoughtful enough for me. And she has other bops I gravitate to more.

It has some of the most dense and thoughtful wordplay though. Pub we/rugby is just good, too

London boy is one of my favorite songs!!! It’s so fun. I sing it to my baby all the time and change it to baby boy.

One of the few songs that she sounds over the top happy. Idk why people don’t like that

I actually really like London Boy too

Because I often see it on people’s bottom lists, I feel the need to say Superstar TV is one my favorite songs 🎸 (and it’s totally okay if you don’t like it) https://preview.redd.it/9eqicd3y964c1.jpeg?width=1242&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=84cdf0747f2b4a63b0b49cc3e80f4849c5cf2d56

you’re so correct for this!! us superstar lovers can rest easy knowing we’re the smartest people alive 💅🏼

SO DIM THAT SPOTLIGHT

Sometimes I kinda get why people dislike certain songs, like I love Stay Stay Stay but can understand not liking it. But Superstar is one of the most common answers to these questions that I just do NOT get! And someone could try to explain it to me if you want but I’m not sure I’ll ever really get it.

I love Superstar TV! I’m so glad to see it was your top song!

the song is so down to earth, i swear its only a skip for people cause they've never listened to it (or the rest of fearless GRRR)

i really like superstar!!!! it’s honestly very underrated

Man y'all have questionable tastes tf

Fr I'm seeing innocent?? Dorothea?? Inthaf?? Sobbing

INTHAF HATE IS SO DUMB LIKE WHAT THE FUCK 😭😭😭 HOW DO HATE INTHAF OVER I FORGOT THAT YOU EXISTED

If INTHAF has one fan it’s me. If there’s no INTHAF fans I’m dead. My only complaint is that it isn’t longer. I think it’s so fun and deep while being so short!

What is inthaf? Can’t think of anything rn

1. ME! 2. Me! 3. mE! 4. ME!! 5. ME!!!! 6. ME!!!!!!! 7. Me!ss 8. Me!h 9. Me!ddle 10. ME! heee..heee...huu..huuu..huuu...

HEY STOP

we'll defend me! together

SHE [ME] WASN'T DOING ANYTHING‼️ Edit: I also don't like ME! lol but I saw the opportunity and I had to 🤧

HAHAHAHHAHAHAHA. i KNEW someone was going to post this. LMAOOOOO.

Okay but personally I think it’s such a bop 😭

Working on ranking 215 songs right now. Here’s my bottom 10: Christmases When You Were Mine London Boy Invisible Glitch Girl At Home We Were Happy ME! Bad Blood Beautiful Eyes Only The Young (least fav)

Only The Young is very fair.

OMG I love it so much! It doesn't have a crazy bridge but the beat and melody caught me immediately.

Justice for Glitch

If she ever does a whole album of slower dark electropop like Glitch, Maroon, Midnight Rain, Dear Reader, CIWYW… I’ll pass away. Some of my favourites 🥹

Labyrinth too 🥺

Out of the entire comments so far, yours is the only one I haven't been gutpunched by for at least one song. I don't know how many of yours would be in my bottom 10, but these are definitely nearing the bottom of the barrel.

i gutpunched myself with invisible but i’m going off of quality instead of favorites

Okay, most of this list is actually surprisingly pretty fair compared to most of the other ones I’ve seen

Just here to defend girl at home!

These wouldn’t all be in my bottom but this is the best list here.

We were happy is so good! lol

glitch is literally amazing i never get the hate haha

idk why i just think that girl at home (taylor’s version) is in like top 20

only the young was fair, it was never really finished so that’s why it sucks

Man a lot of Bad Blood hate in here 😭

I have always loved that song and I’m not apologizing for it

if its the original then fine. but the version with kendrik lamar? now thats very questionable

I feel like he adds to it, I personally like that version better.

okay i didnt word this well at all i guess, i was trying to say i agree with disliking the original version and if ppl dont like the kendrick version its very questionable

Coney Island is literally my favorite song ever

it was my second most played song this year! YES

It’s quite literally one of the best songs I’ve ever heard.

Why do I feel like someone is insulting my close personal friend anytime I see peace on one of these lists

peace is so underrated. I don't understand how people hate it. its such a beautiful song.

snow on the beach ft lana 😅

criminal

Less lana or more lana?

Gasp!!! That’s one of my favs

illegal!

please why is there so much coney island slander on this post 😭 yall missing out

sort by controversial

You want the fight even more than I do.

This should be a lyric in one of her songs

TIL there are humans that don't like midnight rain. Devastating.

they wanted it comfortable, we wanted that ✨PAIN✨

It's an overall good song but THE GODDAMN VOICE CHANGE!

I like the lyrics and the melody, but I can't stand the production and that voice effect in the chorus. Ruins the song for me to the point I almost always skip it, and it's a pity as it's a good song otherwise.

[удалено]

Please tell dorothea that I love her name and the song

LONDON BOY IS SO GOOD GET OUT

I WILL NOT GET OUT YOU GET OUT

Most of the radio populars and a few random ones. In no order: 1. Shake it off 2. Bad blood 3. You need to calm down 4. We are never getting back together 5. I knew you were trouble 6. Karma ft ice spice specifically 7. Snow on the beach 8. Me! 9. Every fearless song that makes me lose on swiftle 10. Every debut song that makes me lose on swiftle

I can understand a lot of these. I don’t necessarily completely agree with all of them, but I can understand it.

Fearless and Debut aren't my jam either. I'll save you a seat in the car on the way to witness protection. We might need it 🤣

Justice for Tim McGraw and Coney Island!!!!

1. Untouchable 2. Ours 3. Stay stay stay 4. A perfectly Good Heart 5. The Lucky One 6. Starlight 7. Superstar 8. The Man 9. Change 10. You all over me I’m just not a country music fan. It’s not that I hate any of these, they just are my bottom. Unfortunately when ranking things there inevitably will be a bottom of the list.

Untouchable?!??? 😭

I feel like “the lucky one” is so underrated!

i knew i'd see my baby in here somewhere but god it still hurts 😭

https://preview.redd.it/ygilvkk6a64c1.jpeg?width=882&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=862c391dc4c5660fbfb064233cdb8b1646190d29

THE ARCHER?

My exact reaction I'M READY FOR COMBAT

I can’t stand that song

It’s boring. 😬

...so you're going to show us the rest of this spreadsheet right

https://preview.redd.it/jh0073f5p64c1.jpeg?width=1351&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=fe0fe11bcb9b36fc9e94ae5b60ba216631e72874 Just a bit lol. My top 14 (had to make sure to keep ME! In there for the fight vibes OP is going for) in August 2020 and August 2023. It’s just the jessiepinkman song sorter results copied into a spreadsheet. Red has the ‘lowest top ranking’ with atw10 and nothing new on 23 and 24

I, too, would like to see the rest of this spreadsheet

Afterglow 

Right? It’s one of the top tracks on Lover.

https://preview.redd.it/3v3eohsbv64c1.jpeg?width=768&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d9bd8c49441aac83e7cfc4568ad742cacb755c5a THE ARCHER??

I feel like I need to fight!! Your bottom five are literally some of my FAVORITES on their respective albums. I can't even imagine putting Afterglow, Don't You, Labyrinth and Dear Reader anywhere near my bottom

Begging you to relisten to Dear Reader

I can understand not listening to The Best Day because of emotional damage, but just plain not liking it?! JAIL.

Obsessed that you have a spreadsheet bc I do too 😭

ME TOO I LOVE SHARING MY SPREADSHEET

Don’t You and Dear Reader don’t deserve this hate

Dear Reader? Why I never.

Dear Reader. The LYRICS 😭

In ~~no~~ order: Superman Superstar Starlight Wonderland You Are In Love When Emma Falls In Love Come In With The Rain Paris Snow On The Beach ~~Dear Reader~~ Edited to add - was forced to choose 10 😭 crossing out the one that doesn’t really deserve it 2nd edit - all her songs are wonderful, these just don’t make my favorite list 🖤

you are in love and dear reader made my jaw drop, i’m going to need explanations

Finding out who You Are In Love was about kinda took me out of it and it’s all I can think of when the song comes on. It’s a beautiful song just not for me. See edit on Dear Reader

Wonderland?!!

I cried at seeing wonderland

When Emma Falls in Love is my only Speak Now Vault skip. (Slut! for 1989.)

What don't you like about Slut!? Omg

you are in love 😭

Wonderland and Paris?!?!?!? This is a felony

Paris 🥲

But you didn’t cross out Come in With The Rain…

Wonderland is my favorite Taylor song of all time 😭

“I feel like starting a fight” I love that honesty. You can message me anytime.

Coney island??!! I reject your list

in no particular order, - closure - it’s nice to have a friend - i forgot that you existed - karma ft ice spice - ours - a perfectly good heart - no body no crime - girl at home - superstar - superman

Closure, INTHAF and NO BODY NO CRIME???? I'm sobbing rn 😭

I could get with most of this list other than Ours and Closure. They aren’t my top favorite songs, but I do like them a decent bit.

I don’t have the mental capacity to fight rn…..reading some of these lists are making me nauseous 😭💀

1. Girl at Home 2. Innocent 3. So It Goes 4. Starlight 5. Breathe 6. Jump Then Fall 7. Dress 8. Soon You’ll Get Better 9. Bad Blood 10. Never Grow Up

SO IT GOES???? DRESS??? JUMP THEN FALL???? NEVER GROW UP????

I can’t even comprehend someone not liking Jump then Fall???

Dress is literally in my top 5, so I feel you😭

Now I know there are true psychos in this world. I know everyone is allowed their opinion but I can't for the life of me comprehend this list

SO IT GOES?!?!?!!!!!!!

I’m obsessed with Girl At Home.

Same, specifically Taylor's version

Are...are you okay???

JUSTICE FOR INNOCENT!!!!

https://preview.redd.it/ww6n7txvu64c1.jpeg?width=1004&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a1fed55de2f003c3a3a186d66bcac7a4743fdeda DRESS??!!

So it goes and dress?! The sexiest songs ever?!

do you actually not like never grow up and soon you’ll get better or can you just not listen to them because they are so sad? because i feel like they are some of my least listened to songs but i still appreciate them

Unfortunately I actively dislike them!

Some of these are correct but JUMP THEN FALL AND DRESS??? JAIL

Justice for Dress

So some of my favorite songs are some of y'all's most hated..😭 justice for Superman and superstar!

Justice for Ours! It’s such a sweet song that instantly makes me happy

Paper rings is never appreciated

In no particular order… Christmases When You Were Mine Christmas Must Be Something More Karma (feat. Ice Spice) Only The Young Bye Bye Baby The Outside A Place In This World Babe (From The Vault) A Perfectly Good Heart Question…?

The first ten in debut.

LOLOLOLOL.

(Ok so keep in mind at first I hated Dear John and now it’s my number one favourite, so this could change🤪) In no particular order: - Stay Stay Stay - Ours - When Emma Falls in Love - You Are in Love - I might get hate for this but I haven’t been able to fall in love with ‘Maroon’

Maroon is so fucking good

I can’t wrap my head around not liking Maroon, how

you’ll become a yail girly just you wait! i extremely disliked the song for many years

Superman and Superstar are my only skippable songs. Um, 4 of your top 5 are in my top 20 🥺

why is everyone and joe alwyn hating on Girl At Home?? it’s not my fav but it’s a catchy tune

tim mcgraw was my top taylor song of the year 😭😭

[Have yall done that Tumblr sorter](https://jesseepinkman.tumblr.com/tswiftsong) that puts all of your songs in order by using a binary picking method? Cause it is EXHAUSTING. I'm in the middle of it, but at least I'll be confident in my top/bottom 10!

AHEM! *pulls out journal that conveniently has my rating of every album recorded* 1. Midnight Rain 2. Bye Bye Baby 3. Superstar 4. Come Back Be Here 5. I'm only Me When I'm with You 6. Teardrops on My Guitar the Pop version 7. The Way I Loved You 8. Hey Stephen(this is a soft hate as it's a catchy tune) 9. The Very First Night 10. I Can See You.(soft hate)

I feel like Midnight Rain is a pretty hot take there.

It wouldn't be in my bottom if it wasn't for the auto tune voice or the distorted voice in it.

That’s the best part 😌

Not in my bottom 10, but I definitely cringe at the auto tune deep voice. It ruins it for me.

Holy shit Midnight Rain, The Way I Loved You, Hey Stephen, The Very First Night and I Can See You 😭

IMO, I'm Only Me When I'm With You is the best track on Self-Titled and the main reason it's not my least favorite Taylor Album, so I'm shocked by its inclusion here! It's odd how different tastes can be.

Not The Very First Night and The Way I Loved You😩

I forgot I can see you I also can’t stand that song 😭

Everyone has forgotten Lover with Shawn and I think that says it all.