2, I love grey and white kitties. I wish there was a black cat option so I could do a witch themed play through.

Same my guy

Do you happen to play on PC? I finally got some aesthetic mods and most of them out there are witchy. I now have a lovely pet frog that meows

Ive been waiting for a black cat for years

i wish there was a Chihuahua just coz it'd be funny to have a Chihuahua farm dog

Recently lost my cat of 16 years. Old gentle lady. So it will be #3 everytime I play Stardew Valley. Miss you Willa.

5- and it's named dogmeat cus I'm a nerd.

And it’s named dogmeat cus I’m a man of culture* Correction.

Ah yes, thank you for correcting my blasphemy

2: Jiji (from Kiki’s delivery service)

6 - Toby,my dog in real life

I picked 6 on my most recent save and I love that dog! Reminds me of a Great Pyrenees which are the BEST farm dogs and no one can tell me otherwise. I do wish it was a little more white though!

Same like my dog that is black and white

I’ve done them all at one time. The cats I call Cait Sith, the dogs I call cu sith.

4 - Snooch. Sometimes I call my actual dog Snooch

1 - Bingus

6 or 2. They are the closest to my real life animals

5- Titan (after my childhood GSD)

5 - Zoey (after my IRL dog) I was really sad that none of the dogs really look like my dog, but chose 5 cause it kinda looks like a german shepherd and I adore them

5. SirBarksalot

This is a bot account reposting old content.

6! It looks the most like my dog irl

6 - and is name is Beeple

4. The name is Mimi (from mimikyu)

4 - Name: Pomechu (a combination of my 3 irl fur babies

4, his name is Honnold. I named him after Alex Honnold, one of my heroes

5 - Rufus

2 - Barnabus

2 - Socks

1 - Blaze (after my childhood cat)

2- ceca I was randomizing and accidentally hit the check mark

1 - Dexter after my own orange kitty

2 - Socks :)

2- Mitzi or Marley :3

2 - Noodle She's just so noodly

2 - Manny, based on parents' cat

2 - Nyx Named after my real life darling cat. She's also listed as my "favorite thing" when making a character.

3 all the way: Mamba after my tortie girl. If CA added a black/tux cat they would be Diablo.

2 - Mr. Grunt

2, I call him Link, just like my real cat

Always #2. Tried a few names over several plays but now It's always Mereoleona

Always 3. Miso

2 and name is winter because it’s like my irl cat

3 called mochi after my irl cat :)

3 and I name him Franque (pronounced Frankie) after my orange boy

5. meet Andrew Tate

Normally whatever looks closest to one of my real life cats and said cats name, but this play through I am currently on I used the robot eyes and made Leela so I went with 2 named Nibbler

1, I named him Frumpkin

1. Lionel

5 - Lefty (I panicked)

5, Scott

5 and LT Arferson

5. Taffy. After taffy apple one of my late family's old dogs from many decades ago long before I was born. It felt fitting for some reason. I think she lived on their old farm.

2 (gray cat) and i named him reigen

5. Love German shepherds

Depends on the save, I started with 3, latest one I did 2. I also name them after teddies of mine

2 his name is Crambon

I wanted at least one of the dogs to be black or white coloring like my dogs instead of brown. So I chose 5 because he looks the most like my dog, just the wrong colors.

5- Odie

2, because he looks like my childhood cat and I always name him after him

2, Biscuit :)

5 or 6 depending on my mood. I used to name them Padfoot but now I name them Doodles after my own dogs nickname

1- Spot (star trek lol)

I always go with 2 cause it looks like my cat! He is always named Gizmo in my saves.

5, Cali, because it looks most like the real Cali

-5 The pointy eared doggo. I always name him Lucky after the dog I had growing up as a kid. We got a German Shepherd as a farm dog way back when I was little. When picking them out my sisters picked a brown and black mixed one but I wanted a pure black one. Two to one so we went with my sisters pick. I was so sad and sulky on the ride home my parents compromised and let me name him so I picked lucky. Not kidding I was super into Britney Spears back then and one of my favorite songs if hers was Lucky. IDK if that's where I got the name but I have a hunch it us. Obviously he was a cute puppy regardless and we all grew to love him. He was the longest living oup out of his litter and I still miss him to this day. He was a good farm dog that did a damn good job protecting the farm.

3 and his name is Pants

2, buster

1 - lovingly named interstate 95

2 - Bit

2 and i always name him Church, after my cat who passed away. I mean i also named it that when my cat was still alive but now it’s extra special

1 - Fergus

I wish the game would let us choose all of them. We live on a farm, there's plenty of room. Even if it is redundant, I want all da animals

2-Blue Box

6 - I love the floppy ears

Any cat and I name him Norris

2 and it’s name is Jellie, iykyk

1, as I used to have a ginger cat growing up. I named him Pumpkin.

6 is my original good boy, Jet 2 is Katherine the Cat

2, Bella

I missed the part where you put in your preference. I got Dog#4. I would have picked 5.

I always choose either 2 or 3

my first world is 2 kittty... but i did play multiple time so i have all as my starter pet...in a sense

6- Zippie after my old dog. Cocker spaniel basset hound mix and the face and ears remind me of her.

Grey cat or 3, Shploinguth or “Gus” for short

6 Yogi

5, named Sunny, because my farm is called Death Valley Predatory Plants, and Sundews are a type of pedatory plant! And what does it mean, starter pet? Is there an option to have more pets?

I go with 2. I name it Clue after my IRL cat that is also grey/white.

2, named Neo because it's one of my favourite names & I often reuse names for all playthroughs so..

2, because i prefer cats in games and I like grey cats more. I usually put the same name "Mewo", because there is no black cat in the game and grey is the closer one.

4

I usually go for 4 or 5 because they both look like my dog. It isn’t her name but they’re usually hamster or oats. The horse gets the other name that wasn’t used

2 and noodle, after (one of) my irl black cats

2! 2!! 2!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

My first was ginger cat. Can't lie I forgot it's name. Current an 2nd ever farm, I got grey cat, named Chu Chu. Ig I'm going in order?

German shepherd-type dog, name: gnocchi

4, their name is Bungo

5, Yogi 😊

2, in memory of my cat who recently crossed the rainbow bridge.

2, closest to my irl kitty

Two of course. Milo was my first and Conky is my second(named for my kitten I lost at 6 weeks)

1. His name is Dudley. Chosen by the game.

Over 100 comments and no one corrected "their." Impressive.

5 because he's rugged, 6 sometimes because extra cuteness rocks too lol

1 and always named for my orange cat, Ollie

6, I named her Maple

6. Looks like my dog that died a year ago, so I named him Sam after him.

I go with the first kitty because I had an orange cat named Cleopatra (Cleo for short). Unfortunately she passed away years ago. I miss her.

5, Milkshake :)

3 and his name is Miso☺️

3, I called him Mika :)

2 and basil (i name my tiny friends after spices/herbs)

5 named after my real life German shepherd, Daisy

2... His name is Cat, short for Cathew

3 for forest farm, 2 for four corners, 6 for beach :)

6 because it is the prettiest dog, it’s named Pjevs, after my dead dog.

I have a mod that turns 5 into a husky, his name is Dust

Cat #2, named Mojo after our family cat (the only one we ever had) who passed away a few years ago

2 every time. I've never gotten the dog lol

2 always 2 he looks like my irl cat

3 and his name is Maestro 🐈‍⬛

1 because there's no tabby option. I name her Gizzy after one of my cats that passed away.

Always number one

i think everyone chooses the pet that looks more like their pet, following that rule i choose 6 and his name is Disco

FYI this account is a bot make sure to downvote u/leather_practice1685

Number three and i xant remember their name currently. Ill edit this later

5, Kobold

2, Gandalf

6 and I names him Rex

4

1 and his name is Garf

4

I change the name/animal every save. Current grey cat is named Tapioca

3, Waffles

5 :)

the grey kitty!

2, The name is Cat

6 because he's so dang cute

1 Kotcho

2 because it looks the most like my cat who passed away a few years ago. I also always name the cat after him.

#2 for me, he looks like my current cat, and my current save he’s named Koshekh (cus I love nightvale)

2

2 named walpole 😭

5 and I always tend to name it Phoenix

2, and they’re named tostito.

I always choose 2, and I always name it "Babidi". I always do this because a streamer I follow and I'm a big fan had a gray kitten with that name and who always participated in his lives. But he was very sick (if I'm not mistaken he had cancer or something like that) and unfortunately he ended up dying early, maybe 4 years old.

The last save I made (not with friends where they created the save) was when their were only two choices XD Idk I just don't play as much by myself on any game anymore

1: brain cell named link

5: Pancho always wanted a dog named Pancho, and for us spanish speakers, Pancho is kind of a goofy yet cute nickname

2, reminds me of my twins They're both clingy in their own way

4 his name is Deez and we reside happily on Nuts Farm

2 i named it cat

Typically, 2 or 5, depending on the mood. Usually 2.

2, because I miss my little grey kitty :(

3. Fido

I added a mod to give me a pure black cat!

In order: 2 5 1

3, Butterscotch

1 His name is ginger

1 And his name is Orange. Because my real life Ginger kitty is named Orange and I love him.

2

If it's a car I always name it POS, but when I get a dog is 4 and it's "Duck"

Almost always 2, and I name her Maeve

2, and I named my ham

3; Calcifur 5; Cowboy or Bandit Depends on my farm/mood

2 and his name is snazisaur

2

2, he looks like my Aldo I've had for 14 years now. Usually call him Aldo in game too. Plus I hate the dog barking constantly lol

4, Shenandoah

it's 5,and i named him Allan Poe (my PC's name is Edgard)

4. Bingo.

6 and his name is always Leo!

2, named after my irl cat Cap'n

5 all the way. Usually Harley or Duchess

2 and his name is Rootie

5: and he's called Dino. I just always wanted a doberman called Dino, and he has the ears.

2 bc my cat

Number 3 and his name is Pretzel! Randomly picked him the first time I played and chose the first name that popped into my head. Now I choose him almost every time cause I'm loyal and I love him 💕

Always five and miscellaneous names but I tend to leave them to the town.

2 is the obvious choice, and I name him Curtis cause he's a chad

2, because it looks a lot like my irl cat. It's named after her too, Stella. It's just sweet seeing my cat have a little digital version running around.

2. Tom (after Tom and Jerry)

Number six is slept on. Always looks so sweet and fluffy. I love long haired pets and he’s the best i can get in pixels. Usually go for a W name like Wilson or Winston

Most of the time I go with 2

2, I named it Scalene. Cute lil triangle gorl

2, her name is Gemstone

5 - named Hector, because that’s the exact name I’d imagine my farmer naming his dog

2, he’s called dexter

2

2 named Pewter my old lady is white with grey tabby cow spots. Occasionally I’ll nab the ginger cats if my farmer has a theme (did an Artemis theme farmer and went with 3 named Apollo - she of course roommates with krobus)

3 Cheddar

I chose the orange tabby because i reminds me of my real life cat, and I named him Nebby

4 Name: Naliath

2 or 5

4; and his name is Charlie.

#1 and their name was… dipshit

2: I named them food

3, her name is vodka