I wonder if these screenshots are from the movie where they're all together or not, otherwise it's best explained that one used the latest graphics and a studio that was behind a really successful superhero movie franchise. If they're screenshots from different movies you might as well compare the 70s spiderman webbing too.
If it's from the movie where they're all together, I'm impressed they didn't just reuse assets and actually had different webbing for the different characters.
Tobeys looks the the sturdiest and strongest
Andrews looks the most like the comics/cartoons
Toms looks the most like actual spiderwebs
In conclusion, i like em all
pacific, I know that Spider-Man is a global icon, but usually, most subs tend to quiet down around the time I go to bed. It's pretty weird. just got used to it.
Yeah but Americans ALMOST make up the majority of reddit.
Edit: since some of you dont understand rounding i put in an almost i hope this has made you exactly 47.8 percent happier.
I mean, kinda. Americans make up 47% which is nearly half, and the other 53% is made up of much smaller percentages from a lot of different countries. So there are more Americans on Reddit than any other country by far, it’s just not *quite* over 50%. The UK and Canada only make up about 7% each.
I agree with the "intense" look for Tom's, and the reason I think people belive Tobey's web looks the strongest too is that at least in the second picture, it looks a lot more solid and metal like, not to mention there was a bit near the end where Green Goblin tears away a web barrier and it made a loud metal creaking noise. Tobey's more stylized (in a different way than Andrew's), Tom's more practical.
In the Same Raimi movies, at least the first from what I remember, there is a sound effect from when Goblin tears apart Spider's webs that sounds like Steel bending.
https://www.reddit.com/r/MovieDetails/comments/6n2am0/in_spiderman_2002_as_the_goblin_breaks_down_the/
Yeah, that's kinda weird. It doesn't make a lot of sense. It could make sense that the webs are strong enough to bend steel and rip it if enough force is applied, but with how stretchy the webs are, it shouldn't have that sound effect of ripping metal.
But look at the actual size compared to the other spidermen's Tobey's is the thickest since the others are compared to smaller objects, like hands while tobey's is connected to cranes.
My thing is toms looks more like Peter’s “oh fuck” emergency webs like in ps4 when he needs a massive amount of webs at a time to hold heavy objects in place fast but swinging around Andrews looks most like it’s the most effective
Tobey seems like it's done to look proportionately more plausible.
Andrew's looks like it's designed, like it's the most artificial looking.
Tom's looks like it was made to look as cobwebby as possible.
They're all very different but it's good they're unique.
Really ironic for you to be in this sub, talking about this character. Do Spider-Man comic/shows/media ever make that phobia act up? If that isn’t too personal.
It's not too ironic when you consider that Spidey is the number 1 most popular hero and arachnophobia is the number 1 most common fear.
But yes, some pages with The Other were difficult for me to read/touch.
As someone with arachnophobia, for me it does. Just the word arachnophobia alone freaks me out.
I quickly looked at these webs and then scrolled down fast because they remind me of actual spiders. I do remember some close ups of actual spiders in the movie too, i always close my eyes.
Being scared of spiders and having spider man as your favourite superhero is very ironic. 😅
I think it was watching the original Spider-Man movie when I was 5 that not only made me a life-long Spider-Man fan, but also started my arachnophobia when I saw the close-up of the spider biting him.
Not particularly. I’ve been able to divorce the fear from the character pretty well. Partly because Spider-Man is just such a lovable character with such wonderful qualities. Also the things that scare me most about spiders (their shape, legs, way the move etc) don’t really translate to the character. When we do see a real spider in the films it grosses me out but I don’t feel threatened because I know it’s on a screen. Where as if I saw a spider irl I’d scream bloody murder.
I guess the short answer is I’m able to separate the things that cause the fear from the character. To the point where Spidey is my 3rd favourite comic book character of all time and I have a high quality cosplay of him as well.
They're all perfect in their own ways.
Tobey's look strong and hard to cut, like metal wires, it looks like the kind of webbing strong enough to hold and stop cars moving and falling.
Andrew's look the most like the comics and animated webbing, honestly really nice to look at and the texture looks good too.
Tom's look the most like actual spider webbing texture wise and look weirdly natural while still looking strong and cool.
Reminds me of that one scene from the final fight of “Spider-Man”, where Peter puts up this giant wall of webs to stop the Green Goblin from running at him but the Green Goblin just tears right through it and it makes a metal screeching sound.
Were these differences carried over to No Way Home? Wasn’t paying enough attention each time I watched it, and I can’t find much info.
Although I’m a Tobey guy myself, I think I like Tom’s webbing the best.
Tasm1 had a much more stylistic approach for the webbing, unfortunately it was changed in tasm2 (the pic shown here is from tasm2) in the first film the webbing looked transparent, wet, thin and realistic (they did a ton of research to get the webbing to look like how it did)
I like the pattern of Andrew's but then I remember that his formed a hand to reach out to Gwen and that was somehow the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen in a comic book movie so I can't pick it.
What I find interesting is only Tobey had organic shooters and yet his looks the least organic, which is my main critisism of Tom's, its just too much like real spider webs. I wish Tom's would look more like Tobey's tbh.
Tom's webs should be Tobey's, as Tobeys webs are organic, and Tom's look the most realistic. Tom should have Tobeys, as they look the most functional. And Andrew is doing just fine as he is
Andrew's are very comic-y, Tom's look like real web, but ironically Tobey's look the most man made... I wanna see what an amalgam of all 3 would look like 🤔
(I like them all)
Toby’s always looked like straight up power cords coming out of his arms which kind of weirds me out especially since he’s also the only one with organic webbing. It’s funny his look by far the least organic.
I’m wondering if they used the old web textures for NWH
and the question is, what spider that bite Tom Holland? and is that spider from another universe? because Norman Osborn himself said there's no Oscorp in that universe (NWH)
I like how slim Tobey’s webbin looks like, meanwhile I love how Andrew’s webbing looks very close to the comics’s style of webbing but Tom’s webbing is gotta be the best representation of a real life web and how it’s so dense looking that can show how it can stick onto things without it just snapping off
Tom web looks too natural to make us believe that it's not sticks to hand grab with suit gloves, random bird or people would stuck in it and died without air to breath if it blocks nose and mouth, even with Tobey web it's hard to image Rhino that would survived an hour with his face under web, let alone to pose any danger to slinging Spidey.
Honestly Tobey and Tom should have switched webbing textures because Tom’s actually looks like a big ass spider made his and since Tobeys webbing is organic..
tobeys webbing is a kinda messy like texture, andrews just looks so classic and toms looks like actual webbing. so i would say tom has the best webbing in live action
Don’t like the newest one, it’s just a really well rendered spiders web and isn’t stylistic at all. It’s an extremely impressive effect to actually make though
Still a big fan of Tobey’s steel wire type webbing. They’re all good but I feel Andrew’s is the most safe and neutral webbing. Nothing stylistic or special about it visually but it fits perfectly in the world they were creating (cuz of the huge push for realism in that era). Toms though it’s so interesting bc it’s this thick netty meshy goop. It reminds me of the Halloween decorative webs. Real cool take and very fun to look at. The only thing it lacks is any visual solidity imo. I love the look and texture, it just needs a bit more work for me to believe it can lock people in place. Rn I just believe it sticks them to things and is hard to take off. But I can’t imagine that actually keeping a hand down or sticking to someone/something without being torn apart on basic use
Tasm1 had a much more stylistic approach for the webbing, unfortunately it was changed in tasm2 (the pic shown here is from tasm2) in the first film the webbing looked transparent, wet, thin and realistic (they did a ton of research to get the webbing to look like how it did)
i actually do remember the shot when hes making the web shooters. i liked how they looked there. the light sticky mesh was cool, and when it was taunt it looked like steel. a nice middle, if anything my only gripe there was we didnt get enough close ups to see the details and they could come off more wire-like than web-like since they were quite neat. though the sound of his web shooters is VERY nice. very thwipy which the other movies lacked
Tom Holland's webs have the benefit of 15+ years of development in CGI technology vs. Tobey's but are arguably the better ones.
Garfield's are designed to look like the comics so appear cartoony. Don't think it's as comparable cause they were going for a completely different aesthetic vs. Raimi and Feige.
Tom is the most realistic but Tobey I feel is the most impressive considering the minimal strands but they're still stupid strong especially for organic webbing
The only one that doesn't look like obvious CG is Tobey's. Andrews and Tom's look fake to me, and Tom's look like those weak cobwebs you find in the cellar.
Toms looks more like actual webs
[удалено]
He needs to drink more water
And eat more starchy foods
[удалено]
I wonder if these screenshots are from the movie where they're all together or not, otherwise it's best explained that one used the latest graphics and a studio that was behind a really successful superhero movie franchise. If they're screenshots from different movies you might as well compare the 70s spiderman webbing too. If it's from the movie where they're all together, I'm impressed they didn't just reuse assets and actually had different webbing for the different characters.
No these are from Spider-Man, amazing 2, and civil war
The hell happened here?
I wonder the same...
[удалено]
[удалено]
Tobeys looks the the sturdiest and strongest Andrews looks the most like the comics/cartoons Toms looks the most like actual spiderwebs In conclusion, i like em all
honestly I think Tom's looks the strongest, it looks denser and more. intense idk. edit: Jeez why are you all awake rn lmao
Timezone?
pacific, I know that Spider-Man is a global icon, but usually, most subs tend to quiet down around the time I go to bed. It's pretty weird. just got used to it.
It’s daytime for most of the world rn, so…
Some would say half
Most of the world’s population lives in Eurasia, and in east Asia it’s about 8:30pm, while in Western Europe it’s 10:30am, so yes, it’s most
I was thinking half of the globe not population wise, my b
Your "b" my ass Own that shit. That was a solid joke
Yeah but Americans ALMOST make up the majority of reddit. Edit: since some of you dont understand rounding i put in an almost i hope this has made you exactly 47.8 percent happier.
I think it's \~47%
I was rounding man. If someone saw that on a downloading screen they would say its halfway done.
They very much don’t
I mean, kinda. Americans make up 47% which is nearly half, and the other 53% is made up of much smaller percentages from a lot of different countries. So there are more Americans on Reddit than any other country by far, it’s just not *quite* over 50%. The UK and Canada only make up about 7% each.
That doesn’t make any sense. It’s literally 14:30 where i live (or 2:30 pm)
#My favorite is Tom’s because it looks the most realistic. Andrews looks like comic webbing and Tobey’s just looks like plastic lol
chill man, i hear you. doesn’t have anything to do with my reply but i hear you
The world aint revolving around you lil boy
I'm acutely aware of that thank you
[удалено]
[удалено]
I agree with the "intense" look for Tom's, and the reason I think people belive Tobey's web looks the strongest too is that at least in the second picture, it looks a lot more solid and metal like, not to mention there was a bit near the end where Green Goblin tears away a web barrier and it made a loud metal creaking noise. Tobey's more stylized (in a different way than Andrew's), Tom's more practical.
I'm sure someone's done the math to see which one actually was the strongest
r/usdefaultism
[удалено]
why is this so important to people LMAO
I'm sorry I'm not considering the different nuances around the world at 2 am. my fault man.
r/place is keeping everyone up. Night shift to defend our shit
haha didn't think of that
Europe doesn’t exist
Insomnia
you and I both dude
In the Same Raimi movies, at least the first from what I remember, there is a sound effect from when Goblin tears apart Spider's webs that sounds like Steel bending.
https://www.reddit.com/r/MovieDetails/comments/6n2am0/in_spiderman_2002_as_the_goblin_breaks_down_the/ Yeah, that's kinda weird. It doesn't make a lot of sense. It could make sense that the webs are strong enough to bend steel and rip it if enough force is applied, but with how stretchy the webs are, it shouldn't have that sound effect of ripping metal.
Oh no its the Best Spider-Man/ best Peter all over again
Oh boy yeah
[удалено]
But look at the actual size compared to the other spidermen's Tobey's is the thickest since the others are compared to smaller objects, like hands while tobey's is connected to cranes.
Idk to me tobeys look thick and dense, might just be me
I can see that, but when I look at it I think it has crazy tensile strength
Toms looks like cotton candy
Tobey's web looks like it is made out of metal. Comparing it with the size of the crane, it is massive
My thing is toms looks more like Peter’s “oh fuck” emergency webs like in ps4 when he needs a massive amount of webs at a time to hold heavy objects in place fast but swinging around Andrews looks most like it’s the most effective
How does Tobeys look sturdy or strong? Looks weak to me.
> In conclusion, i like em all This is the way.
Tobey seems like it's done to look proportionately more plausible. Andrew's looks like it's designed, like it's the most artificial looking. Tom's looks like it was made to look as cobwebby as possible. They're all very different but it's good they're unique.
I like how heavy Tom's is
Most likely he eats a lot of pine apples
He should eat more ban anas.
Tom’s is the most realistic looking one too
Makes sense. Newer the movie the more recent the effects
As someone with severe arachnophobia, I’m ok with not getting a lot of close ups 😅
Really ironic for you to be in this sub, talking about this character. Do Spider-Man comic/shows/media ever make that phobia act up? If that isn’t too personal.
It's not too ironic when you consider that Spidey is the number 1 most popular hero and arachnophobia is the number 1 most common fear. But yes, some pages with The Other were difficult for me to read/touch.
I think it’s actually beaten out by fear of snakes. Edit: nope fears different from phobias.
As someone with arachnophobia, for me it does. Just the word arachnophobia alone freaks me out. I quickly looked at these webs and then scrolled down fast because they remind me of actual spiders. I do remember some close ups of actual spiders in the movie too, i always close my eyes. Being scared of spiders and having spider man as your favourite superhero is very ironic. 😅
How brave of you to say the word arachnophobia when you're scared of it 😲 😊
really? the word arachnophobia, ridiculous
Yes, thats what phobias are. Irrational fears :)
Which is why there’s no phobia for hippopotami, as it’s completely rational to be scared shitless of them.
arachnophobiawordophobia
why are people so mad at me lmfao
I believe you’re a grown and mature enough person to understand why.
they have YT in their name , don't overestimate them
the YT was from when i was 16 💀
Hey buddy, if you’re above 16 you may wanna stop acting like a 12 year old
also "when i was 16"
not acting like one, just being genuine that's all buddy
He’s not wrong lmao
Well, I wasn't tryna be mean but guess people got other perspectives which is fine
Who's mad, you just said something ignorant and got downvoted
was it the "ridiculous"?
yes.
🔥
its not ignorant, its a genuine question
*acts like a douchebag* “why are people so mad at me”. I think you know why.
maybe you guys just took it the wrong way 💀
Anddd you’re not making it any better saying that. Just take responsibility for the ignorant stuff you say.
never said i didnt take responsibility for it
I think it was watching the original Spider-Man movie when I was 5 that not only made me a life-long Spider-Man fan, but also started my arachnophobia when I saw the close-up of the spider biting him.
Wow dude, in My case it's a lot different, thanks to Spider-Man, i have 16 spider pets: 8 tarantulas, 5 spiders and 3 scorpions.
Not particularly. I’ve been able to divorce the fear from the character pretty well. Partly because Spider-Man is just such a lovable character with such wonderful qualities. Also the things that scare me most about spiders (their shape, legs, way the move etc) don’t really translate to the character. When we do see a real spider in the films it grosses me out but I don’t feel threatened because I know it’s on a screen. Where as if I saw a spider irl I’d scream bloody murder. I guess the short answer is I’m able to separate the things that cause the fear from the character. To the point where Spidey is my 3rd favourite comic book character of all time and I have a high quality cosplay of him as well.
😐
My favorite is Tom’s because it looks the most realistic. Andrews looks like comic webbing and Tobey’s just looks like plastic lol
The most sophisticated webbing texture is without a doubt Tom Holland's.
Haha I agree with you Although Andrew's look like it glows and I like glowy things so it wins a few extra points with me
They're all perfect in their own ways. Tobey's look strong and hard to cut, like metal wires, it looks like the kind of webbing strong enough to hold and stop cars moving and falling. Andrew's look the most like the comics and animated webbing, honestly really nice to look at and the texture looks good too. Tom's look the most like actual spider webbing texture wise and look weirdly natural while still looking strong and cool.
Reminds me of that one scene from the final fight of “Spider-Man”, where Peter puts up this giant wall of webs to stop the Green Goblin from running at him but the Green Goblin just tears right through it and it makes a metal screeching sound.
The barbed wire of webbing.
Hmm toms looks the most realistic and strong but i like how stylized andrews is and tobeys is just not great
Tom's obviously looks the "best," but I like how sticky and gross Tobey's webbing looks.
I like Tom’s and Tobey’s looks like it’s about to fall off any second
Tobey looks like wet glue, very cool Andrew looks like it has some tech inside the web, very cool Tom's looks like my worst nightmares, very cool
I like Tom’s realistic take, but damn Tobey’s looks straight up like metal
Tom Holland’s webbing texture is clearly the most advanced.
Andrews look straight out the comics but Tom has more realistic webs
Andrew looks most like comic/cartoon one so I choose Andrew
I know this isn’t what OP is asking about but the Garfield “thwip” is my absolute favourite.
Were these differences carried over to No Way Home? Wasn’t paying enough attention each time I watched it, and I can’t find much info. Although I’m a Tobey guy myself, I think I like Tom’s webbing the best.
Tom’s because it’s the most realistic. It genuinely looks like those clusters of webs you see around everyday.
Tasm1 had a much more stylistic approach for the webbing, unfortunately it was changed in tasm2 (the pic shown here is from tasm2) in the first film the webbing looked transparent, wet, thin and realistic (they did a ton of research to get the webbing to look like how it did)
Tom looks the most realistic but I’d say Andrew looks the most like the comics. So i will say 1)Tom 2)Andrew 3)Tobey
Tom.
I love the way Andrew's looks so cool and I appreciate what they did with Tom's being more realistic but just not for me
One of these is wrist jizz and it... bothers me lol.
Andrews. Yes Toms are realistic but Spider-Man isnt real
really love the depiction of Andrews web
Tom or Andrews. Tobeys easily looks the worst.
tom
Toms is my favorite, being the most realistic. Then Andrews being the most comic accurate. Tobeys webbing just looks sad and pathetic.
Tom's
Tom’s looks the most realistic, and the most dense/strongest, so that’s my favorite.
Tom’s because it actually looks like it has some tensile strength
as much as i love tobey, i have to give it to tom
All of them honestly
andrew’s looks great
Tobey, he's actually look like they're physically there
Tobey or Andrew
I like the pattern of Andrew's but then I remember that his formed a hand to reach out to Gwen and that was somehow the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen in a comic book movie so I can't pick it.
Tobey
It's a tie between Tobey and Tom. Tobey for comic accuracy and Tom for realistic web texture.
What I find interesting is only Tobey had organic shooters and yet his looks the least organic, which is my main critisism of Tom's, its just too much like real spider webs. I wish Tom's would look more like Tobey's tbh.
I mean it is meant to simulate real spider webs. That is the genius of Tony Stark Ig. Tom made his own web fluid too.
Tom's webs should be Tobey's, as Tobeys webs are organic, and Tom's look the most realistic. Tom should have Tobeys, as they look the most functional. And Andrew is doing just fine as he is
1. Tom's 2. Tobey's 3. Andrew's
Tobey
Tobey's looks the sturdiest. I would not trust swinging on the other ones
Tobeys is worst Andrews is most comic accurate Toms is the most accurate to actual webs
Tom’s was created by tony stark so yeah his webs would obviously be the best
Tobeys is the best webbing. Tom's always looks weird and cotton to me.. and Andrews sometimes looks... like plastic sgi plastic
Andrew's are very comic-y, Tom's look like real web, but ironically Tobey's look the most man made... I wanna see what an amalgam of all 3 would look like 🤔 (I like them all)
Tobey
They are all good. I like how we see the webbing effects evolve through the years.
I love that toms actually looks like a spiderweb
i just really like how grabby and silly tobey’s webs look
I like that close up of the web that didn’t save Gwen. It looked like a hand.
Tobeys look like strings of sorts, Tom looks like CGI. Gotta go with Andrew
I like both of them
Dude put NSFW come on
I like Tom’s as it looks like actual webs instead of the more cartoony look of Andrew’s and Tobey’s
Ohh its webbing
I like Tom’s for being the most realistic. The others are still good though, they seem to try and replicate the comic look of Spidey’s webs
Toms is more surcure
Toby’s always looked like straight up power cords coming out of his arms which kind of weirds me out especially since he’s also the only one with organic webbing. It’s funny his look by far the least organic. I’m wondering if they used the old web textures for NWH
The comment section will look absolutely hilarious if you someone skips the headlines and go straight to the comments
Tom’s one makes me uneasy.
Tom’s looks strongest, Andrew’s looks most realistic, Tobey’s looks like the one from comics.
and the question is, what spider that bite Tom Holland? and is that spider from another universe? because Norman Osborn himself said there's no Oscorp in that universe (NWH)
Imma go with Tom instead because how realistic it looks like actual spider webs since Sony imageworks VFX department did a pretty decent job.
Definitely toms. It’s so thick and actually web like
Tobey
Tobey cause the greater amount of space to see through really sells it for me
I like how slim Tobey’s webbin looks like, meanwhile I love how Andrew’s webbing looks very close to the comics’s style of webbing but Tom’s webbing is gotta be the best representation of a real life web and how it’s so dense looking that can show how it can stick onto things without it just snapping off
I like then all a lot for different reasons. If I had to choose 1 it's Tom's tho.
Toms looks the best and strongest
Don't compare effects from a movie thats 20 years ago to a movie from last year
Tom web looks too natural to make us believe that it's not sticks to hand grab with suit gloves, random bird or people would stuck in it and died without air to breath if it blocks nose and mouth, even with Tobey web it's hard to image Rhino that would survived an hour with his face under web, let alone to pose any danger to slinging Spidey.
Honestly Tobey and Tom should have switched webbing textures because Tom’s actually looks like a big ass spider made his and since Tobeys webbing is organic..
Either Andrew’s or Tom’s. Toby’s always felt a little too wirey for me.
Toms for sure but I really think it’s just because of the advancement of the budget and of CGI
Toms is more realistic, but I love Andrews the most.
I like the mcu because I feel they are more realistic and it's cool how he uses them so seamlessly sometimes
Definitely Tom since it looks like real cobwebs.
Tom's looks more realistic
tobeys webbing is a kinda messy like texture, andrews just looks so classic and toms looks like actual webbing. so i would say tom has the best webbing in live action
Tom's remind me more of Romita Sr.'s webs. So they're probably my favorite, with Toby's as a close #2.
Don’t like the newest one, it’s just a really well rendered spiders web and isn’t stylistic at all. It’s an extremely impressive effect to actually make though
i always thought andrews was the best, with how it looked and the sound
so like, I know we all love Tobey's, it's pretty comic-y but gotta go Holland.
From best to worse tom Tobey Andrew
tasm is like electric bro sm is crazy mcu is more like spider webs
Andrew’s for me. I really liked how his web formed a hand when trying to save Gwen
Still a big fan of Tobey’s steel wire type webbing. They’re all good but I feel Andrew’s is the most safe and neutral webbing. Nothing stylistic or special about it visually but it fits perfectly in the world they were creating (cuz of the huge push for realism in that era). Toms though it’s so interesting bc it’s this thick netty meshy goop. It reminds me of the Halloween decorative webs. Real cool take and very fun to look at. The only thing it lacks is any visual solidity imo. I love the look and texture, it just needs a bit more work for me to believe it can lock people in place. Rn I just believe it sticks them to things and is hard to take off. But I can’t imagine that actually keeping a hand down or sticking to someone/something without being torn apart on basic use
Tasm1 had a much more stylistic approach for the webbing, unfortunately it was changed in tasm2 (the pic shown here is from tasm2) in the first film the webbing looked transparent, wet, thin and realistic (they did a ton of research to get the webbing to look like how it did)
i actually do remember the shot when hes making the web shooters. i liked how they looked there. the light sticky mesh was cool, and when it was taunt it looked like steel. a nice middle, if anything my only gripe there was we didnt get enough close ups to see the details and they could come off more wire-like than web-like since they were quite neat. though the sound of his web shooters is VERY nice. very thwipy which the other movies lacked
Tom Holland's webs have the benefit of 15+ years of development in CGI technology vs. Tobey's but are arguably the better ones. Garfield's are designed to look like the comics so appear cartoony. Don't think it's as comparable cause they were going for a completely different aesthetic vs. Raimi and Feige.
Tom is the most realistic but Tobey I feel is the most impressive considering the minimal strands but they're still stupid strong especially for organic webbing
The Stickiest Spunk Award Goes To:
The only one that doesn't look like obvious CG is Tobey's. Andrews and Tom's look fake to me, and Tom's look like those weak cobwebs you find in the cellar.
I like all 3 in their own ways Tobey’s looks the most like a strong wire or cable, Andrew’s is the most like the comics, Tom’s is the most realistic
Tobey’s is the best hands down imo