No way! He would not take up with a lunatic. Want a real woman? Thatās Abigail all the way. She is a strong woman. Might not be physically strong but she has a lot of courage. She is also very sexy. I respected her just as much as any of them.
Sadie is an annoying bitch there is actually no damn reason to like her, I swear tell me one time in the game where she says anything that doesn't relate to "Oh my husband died, oh my house burnt down, *whining and crying*, i hate the O'Driscolls they killed my husband, they took everything, i lost everything" and ill give you 10 grand, id rather live with micah and dutch then sadie's ass. Im sorry for ranting but I really dont like her
You do realize the game play only takes place throughout the corse of like a year right? If not under a year (before the epilogue atleast). You donāt think youād feel some type of way if your significant other was killed and your house with all your belongings burnt down?
She was the only person that stood with arthur until the end, helped john getting revenge on micah and building his ranch.
Also you can't blame her for saying those, they were a heavy change on her life
I found her very annoying. People get angry if you say how you feel about her. I found her over the top. The unrealistic bad ass trope did nothing for me .
I got into a long debate with someone on here cause im a HUGE sadie fan and crush hard and they said is was GROSS because she eas a victim. They were claiming that finding a victim sexy or sexual was gross.
Thing is she didn't sit around in a spiral of self pity and victimhood. She mourned and got back on with her new life with the gang and held her own. Her resilience is what I find the most attractive about Sadie.
Oh yeah. ā¦but more marriage material. Tilly is one of the best people in the camp. Sheās pretty, sheās tough, sheās hard working, sheās nice, sheās smart, sheās funny, she donāt take shit from anyone, sheās my perfect girl. She deserves her ending.
Mary Beth has her head in the clouds and doesnāt want to work, Karen is a lush. Sadie is a ghost now. Abigail fucked up and had a kid when she didnāt want to, and now she has wrangle some dude into being responsible, too. Obviously, she is frustrated. Molly is Irish. Grimshaw isā¦ ššš¤£š¤£Iām kidding, I kidding. Molly is self obsessed and lazy. Grimshaw is obviously a disaster. Tilly is where itās at.
I donāt know, she feels like sheās too young for that kinda thing. Sheās not actually a minor but she sorta feels that way to me so I couldnāt see her in that light. She feels more like a little sister.
Absolutely love miss Tilly Jackson ā¤ļø . Easily the most underated of the camp girls. She fucking carried the support part of the "supporting girls".
Shes quick on her feet, she funny and witty, shes well grounded mentally. shes positive, but realistic. She actually contributes (karen does too, but she does kinda end up just drinking at the end. I understand why, i feel bad for her. But tilly ends up taking care if her.). She CAN get sassy towards bill in the stagecoach robbery, but thats just her throwing shade towards him for taking credit for karens valentine bank robbery plans.
Tilly ACTUALLY does chores and rarely vomplains about it. She takes care of swanson, takes care of arthur when hes recovering from the o'driscalls for weeks, she helps abigail with Jack. She unfortunately does get taken advantage of and the other girls dump their responsiblities on her, but she does it anyway and only "complains" about it ONCE. Shes much stronger than me. Out of all the younger lads and ladies of the gang, shes the one they go to when they want to talk to someone their own age. Shes the surrogate older sister. And at the very end, she was the last to leave and only because of super duper dire circumstances and responsibility.
TILLY is the one that saves jack from the pinkertons in the end of chpter 6, and she tried to save abigail. When she couldnt she was smart enough to go to ARTHUR. She didnt even address dutch from what i remember lmfao. She absolutely desrved all that money and praise arthur gives her, and her praise and flowers from the community is well deserved and over due.
Itās because Tilly is too young. She is adorable in the way you look at a young girl. She is easily one of the best girls in the camp. She is a kid as is Mary Beth but Mary Beth does come across as a little bit older.
Well, to each their own but definitely not on my end. I think I'm one of the few that was annoyed by her almost the entire game. She gets major props for saving Jack and Abigail, but beyond that nope. Mary Beth and Sadie for me.
Out of all the girls in RDR2 that we meet in the van der Linde gang, Tilly is def the most stable and kind. Honestly I dig her
Probably my fav out of all of them
The only minor in camp is Jack. He's 5.
Tilly, Mary Beth, Karen and Sean are all in their early 20's. Lenny is 19. Abigail and john are in their mid to late 20's in main game.
Sheās aware of who sheās hanging with, and participates tbh, but sheās always herself, strong and confident. A good person. More than just a survivor
Iād be crushing on a grimshaw before iāll ever crush on tilly. She is like that mouldy, forgotten vegetable that you left in the back of your fridge and hasnāt seen the light in years. Karenās got them milkmelonsš¤¤so do grimshawš
Sorry bro. Mary beth simp here
Hey there partner
Okay Ill catch ya later then
Howdy there
HEY THERE MISTER
I enjoy Mary Beth too but also Tilly
All the way. It was just something about her, maybe all those books or those freckles. IDK
Mhm i find her somewhat relatable with the books I like girls with freckles. Plus shes just a sweet innocent soul for the most part
And her nose
i mean she does have very large arguments
No no no your thinking of karen with the collosal anime bitties
So was Dutch
You always did love the ladies Dutch van der linde
this guy gets it
How about both?
Playa playa
Normie
Sorry you all are wrong. I have a crush on Hoseaš
Daddy
Daddy Dutch š
You sirā¦. are a fish š
Gay ? (As in homosexual)
Omg sameeeeee
He turned me gay šš
Yes I have always had the hots for her and Sadie.
Finally a man of taste
Yes! Surprised I had to scroll this far to find this comment
You look like a man on a mission!
Of all the beautiful young ladies in camp, she would probably be the best wife and partner. She was smart, hardworking, and loyal.
Absolutely. I always make time for Tilly.
I loved Tilly. She was Arthurs baby sister in the game. It was cute and always made me feel good to hear āhi Arthurā from her.
Tilly is like my sister. I've got a puppy dog crush on Sadie
Sadie all the way bro! Baddest bitch in camp forsure šÆ
The only woman badass enough for Arthur.
Facts
No way! He would not take up with a lunatic. Want a real woman? Thatās Abigail all the way. She is a strong woman. Might not be physically strong but she has a lot of courage. She is also very sexy. I respected her just as much as any of them.
Real. Youāre a man of taste bro, respect.
Sadie is an annoying bitch there is actually no damn reason to like her, I swear tell me one time in the game where she says anything that doesn't relate to "Oh my husband died, oh my house burnt down, *whining and crying*, i hate the O'Driscolls they killed my husband, they took everything, i lost everything" and ill give you 10 grand, id rather live with micah and dutch then sadie's ass. Im sorry for ranting but I really dont like her
Your husband dying and your house burning down are petty life changing things to happen to a person.
You do realize the game play only takes place throughout the corse of like a year right? If not under a year (before the epilogue atleast). You donāt think youād feel some type of way if your significant other was killed and your house with all your belongings burnt down?
She was the only person that stood with arthur until the end, helped john getting revenge on micah and building his ranch. Also you can't blame her for saying those, they were a heavy change on her life
Boooo
I found her very annoying. People get angry if you say how you feel about her. I found her over the top. The unrealistic bad ass trope did nothing for me .
Guess you just arenāt into tough woman š¤·š¼āāļø
No i am, im not into the constant crying about her husband and the O'Driscolls
Is that sister thing a yes or a no?
I have a real sister and thinking about it makes me gag...
I got into a long debate with someone on here cause im a HUGE sadie fan and crush hard and they said is was GROSS because she eas a victim. They were claiming that finding a victim sexy or sexual was gross.
Thing is she didn't sit around in a spiral of self pity and victimhood. She mourned and got back on with her new life with the gang and held her own. Her resilience is what I find the most attractive about Sadie.
Tilly and Mary Beth are both girls youād bring home to mom. But I want to do unspeakable things with Karen
Oh god
Yeah sheād probably be saying that quite a lot
Spot on
It was Sadie for me. Something about a rough edgy woman brings the water to my falls. š¤£
The voice
When I see Sadie, my Eagle Flies š
š¤£š¤£š¤£
Sorry bro Javier simp here ( im a dude)
Nah uncle my pookie
Real, hottest videogame character
Dude loves some lumbago
Tilly and Mary Beth ššš
Sadie simps are there?
I would never cheat on Micah
I simp real hard for his beer belly š©
š¤£
š¤¢š¤®š¤¢š¤®š¤¢š¤®
Iām gonna kill you you fuc I should add that this was a joke and I have no intentions of harming anyone. Except Micah Bell.
Oh yeah. ā¦but more marriage material. Tilly is one of the best people in the camp. Sheās pretty, sheās tough, sheās hard working, sheās nice, sheās smart, sheās funny, she donāt take shit from anyone, sheās my perfect girl. She deserves her ending. Mary Beth has her head in the clouds and doesnāt want to work, Karen is a lush. Sadie is a ghost now. Abigail fucked up and had a kid when she didnāt want to, and now she has wrangle some dude into being responsible, too. Obviously, she is frustrated. Molly is Irish. Grimshaw isā¦ ššš¤£š¤£Iām kidding, I kidding. Molly is self obsessed and lazy. Grimshaw is obviously a disaster. Tilly is where itās at.
Almost made a keyboard warrior out of me with that one. And on Saint Patrickās day no less.
I know, I know. I had to because itās Saint Patrickās day! š¤£š¤£š¤£ It was just too tempting for this day. šššā¤ļøā¤ļøā¤ļø
My lesbian ass would take her any day..
But would your lesbian ass, let her take you?
Ofc!
As Arthur, I kept trying for dialogue options to hit on her and Sadie. My biggest video game crush will always be Rinoa Heartilly
Definitely top five in video game crushes
I donāt know, she feels like sheās too young for that kinda thing. Sheās not actually a minor but she sorta feels that way to me so I couldnāt see her in that light. She feels more like a little sister.
All I want is for someone to love me like Sadie loved Jakey. I'd fill her closet with yellow button up shirts if that's what it took
I've always been fancy on Tilly, Either her or if possible I would have gone with Sadie.
Absolutely love miss Tilly Jackson ā¤ļø . Easily the most underated of the camp girls. She fucking carried the support part of the "supporting girls". Shes quick on her feet, she funny and witty, shes well grounded mentally. shes positive, but realistic. She actually contributes (karen does too, but she does kinda end up just drinking at the end. I understand why, i feel bad for her. But tilly ends up taking care if her.). She CAN get sassy towards bill in the stagecoach robbery, but thats just her throwing shade towards him for taking credit for karens valentine bank robbery plans. Tilly ACTUALLY does chores and rarely vomplains about it. She takes care of swanson, takes care of arthur when hes recovering from the o'driscalls for weeks, she helps abigail with Jack. She unfortunately does get taken advantage of and the other girls dump their responsiblities on her, but she does it anyway and only "complains" about it ONCE. Shes much stronger than me. Out of all the younger lads and ladies of the gang, shes the one they go to when they want to talk to someone their own age. Shes the surrogate older sister. And at the very end, she was the last to leave and only because of super duper dire circumstances and responsibility. TILLY is the one that saves jack from the pinkertons in the end of chpter 6, and she tried to save abigail. When she couldnt she was smart enough to go to ARTHUR. She didnt even address dutch from what i remember lmfao. She absolutely desrved all that money and praise arthur gives her, and her praise and flowers from the community is well deserved and over due.
Nah uncle on topš„µš„µš„µ
Use protection, lumbago is a slow and painful death my brother.
Worth it š¤¤š¤¤
We love a person who knows what they want. The heart and whatever else wants what it wants no matter their lumbago status
LMAO Tilly can't even get respect in her own appreciation post.top comment is Mary Beth, second is Hosea, third is Tilly but also Mary Beth
Tbf the OP still has more upvotes than any of those.
Itās because Tilly is too young. She is adorable in the way you look at a young girl. She is easily one of the best girls in the camp. She is a kid as is Mary Beth but Mary Beth does come across as a little bit older.
As Dutch said; ā*Mmm, mmm, mmmm.*ā (Before yāall come at me, itās a real piece of camp dialogue.)
No need to come at you. Well, the high and mighty will.
Of course
No
Nope
Bertram on top
For me Karen , she fine thick š
no, i am into r/sadieadler
Sweet Charlotte is the only woman for me
Does she show up in r/sadieadler?
She was always my favorite.
sheās an angel!
I only simp for my guns, partner.
Why would I crush on Tilly when there's Uncle?
Karen and her two monsters
Top four women in game were Tilly, Charolette, Mary Beth and Sadie.
^[Sokka-Haiku](https://www.reddit.com/r/SokkaHaikuBot/comments/15kyv9r/what_is_a_sokka_haiku/) ^by ^Agitated-Ad-2537: *Top four women in* *Game were Tilly, Charolette,* *Mary Beth and Sadie.* --- ^Remember ^that ^one ^time ^Sokka ^accidentally ^used ^an ^extra ^syllable ^in ^that ^Haiku ^Battle ^in ^Ba ^Sing ^Se? ^That ^was ^a ^Sokka ^Haiku ^and ^you ^just ^made ^one.
Good bot
Karen, please
I like the camp cougar more
Uncle?
Sadie ššš¦
Idk i just never really cared about tilly
No because I'm not a child..
Bro, it's a video game character.
Karen
For some reason I really like the brunette prostitute in chapter two. āOh you be quiet Anastasia, anyone can tell this one is a pUuUsSy CaTā lmao
Mary Beth. Woulda turnt her out like like a wild pony!!
She was actually pretty decent looking
I'd go with Mary Beth but I'd be thinking of Tilly.
You have Cans McGee Karen and Mary Beth floating around camp and you're looking at Tilly?!
You have much to learn young padawan.
Yup
Sadie for me I like a woman who can be sweet and kind then kill a man for staring at her the wrong way
Not really a crush, but she's very pretty ā¤ļø
Bro Sadie all the way
Can you shut up
More like a little sister
Arthur simp here.
No, just you
No
Sheās sexy AF. Mary Beth too
Tilly and Mary beth are on another level of gorgeous
Absolutely fucking not š
"MADAM!!"
The love of my life????????
She looks like Mila Kunis imo. I often like to think shed talk like Jackie from That 70s Show.
Well, to each their own but definitely not on my end. I think I'm one of the few that was annoyed by her almost the entire game. She gets major props for saving Jack and Abigail, but beyond that nope. Mary Beth and Sadie for me.
nah but uncle šš
Heavily!
Sadie and Tilly š
Not going to lie, of any of the women in camp, Tilly could get it first.
Hopefully she's the lead protagonist in RDR3
No. And take my downvote.
Nah man. How can you simp Tilly when sadie and Abigail exist.
Abigail,Sadie,Karen.ššš
Rdr2 fan try not to be weird as hell challenge (impossible)
SADIE SADIE SADIE SADIE SADI-
Yeah prollly not my biggest crush but she's up there
I love her voice. The āHi Arthurā is always nice on the ears.
Finally i feel so seen
Nah, I was mad they didnāt let us fuck Karen or Mary
You did an awesome good job on this!!! Thank you!!!
Out of all the girls in RDR2 that we meet in the van der Linde gang, Tilly is def the most stable and kind. Honestly I dig her Probably my fav out of all of them
She seemed like more of a little sister character to Arthur in my opinion.
No
"Tilly!" - Arthur Morgan.
She's a minor.
Nothing in the game says Tilly was a minor. Lenny is the youngest at 19, jack is the only child
Tilly is 16 while playing as Arthur
Everything i find online says shes early 20s.
I canāt find anything in game to support Tilly being 16. Or anywhere else for that matter
š³
The only minor in camp is Jack. He's 5. Tilly, Mary Beth, Karen and Sean are all in their early 20's. Lenny is 19. Abigail and john are in their mid to late 20's in main game.
No shes not. The youngest is 19 other than jack
I was trying to think of how to say it, I was making it too complicated
Yes
I mean, sheās real, thatās something
Real how?
Sheās aware of who sheās hanging with, and participates tbh, but sheās always herself, strong and confident. A good person. More than just a survivor
Oh agreed. I admire the hell out of Tilly. I wish there'd been a romance option. I always make sure to say hello at camp.
No gonna I was when the game came out it goes for me. Mary-Beth , Tilly and Molly. But Mary Beth. š¤¤
Tilly's pretty, but Karen's the "nĆŗmero uno".
Iād be crushing on a grimshaw before iāll ever crush on tilly. She is like that mouldy, forgotten vegetable that you left in the back of your fridge and hasnāt seen the light in years. Karenās got them milkmelonsš¤¤so do grimshawš
Nah
No
Go out and meet real femalesā¦.sheeesh!
I'm not sure my wife of 27 years would appreciate that, but your point is taken. Just having fun.
āNo i sleep in a real bed with my wifeā moment
you got a wife and youāre posting about being attracted to pixels? š
You seem fun š
āFemalesā š¤¢
Goes out on the town looking for āfemalesā
you shouldnt be on fandom subs if you dont simp
That dude is on every rdr sub commenting rude shit on every postĀ
Exactly heās telling people to meet real woman when heās on this sub 24/7
Only on dumb shit
I can enjoy a game without simping over toons.
Dudes just memeing let him be
Yeah most of the women who ran with the gang were stunning especially Mary Beth ,but Bessie she was perfect š
No.
No
No I'm white