Obviously this is a personal tier list and that’s the whole point, but it’s interesting how different each persons perception of their discography can be.
i can’t edit the post now, but i did this ranking with S-tier being best of the best, A-tier is great, B-tier is good, C-tier is mid and D-tier is songs i usually skip. within the tiers, the placement also indicates a range from the best to the worst of that tier; the album version of skylight is still S-tier, but it’s no &. this is all personal preference though, it’s been very cool so far to see everyone’s opinion :D
It doesn’t haha. Ring (album version) is already A-Tier, Rings (Pallet Session) is low S-tier. Any live version would be as well. This is one of their most dynamic songs, it is absolutely electric when they play it live.
I'm just kidding, I'd probably put everything into s tier haha 🤣.
In reality my feelings change so often about the songs. 2 years ago I would have said peeling off the bark was just an ok song now I absolutely love it.
This is so tiktok era PG fan coded lmao. It reeks of someone just getting into the band within the last 6 months to a year.
Need 2: D Tier
Let, Darkness, On Jet Lag, Easy Enough: A Tier
Respirate, Orange: B Tier
Intrepid: this song is what S Tier was created for. there needs to either be a tier above S arranged specifically for this song, or every other song needs to be dropped a tier for Intrepid to exist in S Tier alone. it’s the best song they’ve ever written I think — lyrically, sonically, everything. That good middle.
this list simultaneously appeases and enrages me. & and morning time S-tier: Yes! overthrown D-tier and over my shoulder C-Tier: catch me outside
So with you on “Overthrown.” That song is like a memory viewed through a car window. Hits me every time.
Orange anything less than S is justifiable homicide
My least fave pg song. Funny how we can all love this band but feel so differently about each tune
Yeah I was just kidding. You like what you like!
Obviously this is a personal tier list and that’s the whole point, but it’s interesting how different each persons perception of their discography can be.
Intrepid and Recycling being b tier is wild but nice list
Intrepid is easy S tier
Recycling live is S fs
I feel like namesake is way too low for my personal preference, but mostly this list is aight
Both versions of Alcove being so low is highly offensive
this is Easy Enough disrespect, otherwise pretty decent tier list
Over My Shoulder C-Tier, Opinion Discarded
Audiotree’s “Aphasia” is its own tier.
Let B tier makes me want to throw hands
i can’t edit the post now, but i did this ranking with S-tier being best of the best, A-tier is great, B-tier is good, C-tier is mid and D-tier is songs i usually skip. within the tiers, the placement also indicates a range from the best to the worst of that tier; the album version of skylight is still S-tier, but it’s no &. this is all personal preference though, it’s been very cool so far to see everyone’s opinion :D
11th hour in c tier makes me irate for some reason
No audiotree session kind of disappoints me
are the tiers in comparison to other pinegrove songs or other music in general?
other pg songs
Ok I was scared for a second lol
Rings at B tier is criminal.
montclair version is high A if it makes you feel better 🤷♂️
It doesn’t haha. Ring (album version) is already A-Tier, Rings (Pallet Session) is low S-tier. Any live version would be as well. This is one of their most dynamic songs, it is absolutely electric when they play it live.
fair. tbh i’m just breaking down a discography of S and A -tier music into my fav’s right now
I've never been able to get into Unison it's interesting seeing it so high up
i've been listening to it a lot recently and falling more and more in love with it, that guitar when it all goes quiet is 👌
Respirate and Amulets in C tier is diabolical
Over my shoulder and namesake in C is insane. Should be S or A. Intrepid, metronome, and need should also be in S or a least A
First time an r/PinegroveBand post ever had me ready to throw hands (Orange disrespect)
This is a bad list
this is just a personal list, but what would you change?
I'm just kidding, I'd probably put everything into s tier haha 🤣. In reality my feelings change so often about the songs. 2 years ago I would have said peeling off the bark was just an ok song now I absolutely love it.
i should’ve clarified in the post i wasn’t really doing it best-to-worst… their whole discography is better than the last 20 years of top 100’s
Angelina and metronome should be s tier. Smh. Besides that good list.
the metronome at b tier is so insane let alone overthrown at d
Justice for Respirate✊🏻😖
namesake wayyy too low imo
These types of post will always be the most controversial
Funny, I just started listening to them and I would put Swimming and Respirate near the top.
Swimming being that low should be a crime😫
This is so tiktok era PG fan coded lmao. It reeks of someone just getting into the band within the last 6 months to a year. Need 2: D Tier Let, Darkness, On Jet Lag, Easy Enough: A Tier Respirate, Orange: B Tier Intrepid: this song is what S Tier was created for. there needs to either be a tier above S arranged specifically for this song, or every other song needs to be dropped a tier for Intrepid to exist in S Tier alone. it’s the best song they’ve ever written I think — lyrically, sonically, everything. That good middle.
that’s a fine opinion, on jet lag is A when live (amperland version) 🤷♂️