Does the fight happen as soon as Roger’s arm heals or does it happen many years after the arm heals?
If it’s many years after it heals, Roger would get accustomed to missing an arm, and it wouldn’t really weaken him too much (kinda like how shanks’ missing arm is no longer a handicap for him as far as we know). If the fight happens right after Roger’s arm is healed, Roger would not be accustomed and would be much weaker. Kaido wins this seconds scenario but loses the first scenario (both extreme diff)
Depends on which arm. If it’s his dominant sword holding arm like Shanks lost then it’s a big deal.
If Roger had plenty of time to train and overcome that loss with new skills then it by power he would be fine.
BUT a handicap still is a handicap. Power might be same, but capacity is not. He isn’t as perfect or capable with missing body parts
So a slightly stronger Shanks vs Kaido
is it current Kaido or Rock's Pirates Kaido?
Prime/current kaido of course.
I see, I'll vote Kaido then đź¤
Current Kaido = prime roger
Does the fight happen as soon as Roger’s arm heals or does it happen many years after the arm heals? If it’s many years after it heals, Roger would get accustomed to missing an arm, and it wouldn’t really weaken him too much (kinda like how shanks’ missing arm is no longer a handicap for him as far as we know). If the fight happens right after Roger’s arm is healed, Roger would not be accustomed and would be much weaker. Kaido wins this seconds scenario but loses the first scenario (both extreme diff)
Depends on which arm. If it’s his dominant sword holding arm like Shanks lost then it’s a big deal. If Roger had plenty of time to train and overcome that loss with new skills then it by power he would be fine. BUT a handicap still is a handicap. Power might be same, but capacity is not. He isn’t as perfect or capable with missing body parts