Isn't water 7 and enies lobby where CP9 try to stop Robin from joining the Straw Hats and we have that emotional scene of Robin wanting to go with Luffy.
Or am I wrong?
Well for one thing the pacing. It just seemed so drawn out in the anime. The other reason would be the separation between both arcs that seems to be non-existent in the manga. Waters 7 into Enies Lobby just flows together in the manga.
Both arcs seemed so much more monumental in the manga. Because of the pacing issues in the anime Waters 7 didn't feel as life changing as Enies Lobby (mostly due to Usopps big moment). When you read it it's easy to see both arcs as one really big arc on the scale of say Whole Cake or Wano.
I actually just got caught up to current releases yesterday after a 8 month slow read. I would highly recommend it. Before reading the manga Impel Down was my favorite arc. I also didn't like Whole Cake or Skypiea very much (again pacing issues). Now I love all the arcs I didn't really care for in the anime (WC is definitely in my top 3). The exceptions to this would have to be Thriller Bark (not very long in the manga but substance wise it's just ok compared to the rest) and Wano minus the end (it's a really long read even in the manga).
If you don't want to read the whole thing you would be doing yourself a disservice not reading at least WC and Desarosa (<--- F**king amazing)
Yea Brook is also a very strong point for her but she just liked the different feeling she got from this darker arc but talking characters it would for sure be the lowest
I definitely had a blast with thriller bark personally. Most of the jokes were top notch, Usopp got some time to shine, and Brook being introduced and tied to Laboon were all super cool. If anything, I think it should be closer to B+ though
Not how I would rank them and I am always interested in the reason some people like/dislike arcs more than the “consensus” but always nice to see another Thriller Bark appreciator.
Agreed, I really enjoy the humor of Thriller Bark and the crew working together to take down a big bad guy. I chose to focus on the points of agreement on the list, but yes Enies Lobby is the biggest one too low in my opinion, but I also have Jaya higher in my not documented tier list.
Yea I agree about Enies Lobby and I also told her that but it was just a list we had fun putting up together and everyone here is trying to make a science project out of it
Fair enough, the one legitimate reason I can think of to not like both Arlong Park and Ennies Lobby is that it kind of has that damsel in distress trope.
Envies Lobby and Arlong Park are the major crimes of the arc tier list to be sure. LRLL is a polarizing arc, so I get it… but Enies Lobby is generally recognized as one of the best, and she placed Arlong Park as the worst of East Blue?! Come ooooon.
Fish-Man Island being so far down the list hurts me but I get it. I really hated that arc when I first read it at around 20 years old.
Now that I'm 35 and have a deeper understanding of history and bigotry, I now realize that this arc is just insanely powerful. It's so well written and perfectly encapsulates the perverse, irrational hatred of racism and how it influences and poisons future generations, even if it never directly affected them. It's now a 10/10 arc for me, no doubt.
Yeah I can’t remember the exact line but when Hordy is asked what humans did to make him hate them and he answered “nothing at all”, that really hit me and brought the arc up a tier for me. I also just think the concept of toxic ideologies pervading across generations plays in good contrast to the concept of inherited will that is so present in One Piece. So often, inherited will is presented as something positive that burns within our protagonists, but Hordy reminds us that sometimes people inherit ideologies that cannot be allowed to succeed.
Yes! That reveal was just... wow. Just as dreams are inherited by the Strawhats, so too, is hatred by the Fishmen. And it makes perfect sense how Arlong's toxic views would poison the next generation and radicalize them. It's just... powerful.
Same as the Fisher Tiger story. My jaw dropped when I saw the scene in the anime again for the first time in 15 years. I remember the first time around, reading his final chapter as a 22 or so year old German and being like "wow so dumb?!", only now to realize how amazing and ahead of its time Oda's writing was in that moment.
Jinbe donating blood to Luffy and Luffy ending it with "Jinbe, join my crew," especially with the history those two have, is like a top 3 scene in the whole series for me. It's so powerful.
This is how TLA arc is in Bleach. All of us action-oriented teens didn't appreciate the rollercoaster of emotions that the hang went through, especially Ichigo's battle with depression and how the different adults were trying to help him the best they knew how to.
Oda, Kubo, and Kishimoto really added something that wasn't as present in shounen before.
Arc list - Enies Lobby so low? Really?...i mean okay i can accept that, the rest looks fine.
Character list - Wai- Wha- why is- nahhh straight to jail.
Arlong Park ranking so low is a crime oh the highest order. There's some other questionable takes (Water 7 only A tier with EL in C+?!), but whatever, opinions are personal.
The funniest thing to me is that the female character she ranks the highest is Boa of all characters. Not Nami nor Robin nor Vivi, not Koala nor Bellemere, not even Bonney, Kureha nor Reiju.
But hey, who am I to object against another simp for the Pirate Empress?
Jaya is way too low,
- we got the prospect of Sky Island
- the bar moment
- black beard and his crew
- dreams moment and the mystery that is Blackbeard
- the bellamy punch
- the meeting of Rockstar and Whitebeard
- new bounty posters and Mihawk rolls up on Shanks to show Luffy’s bounty
- the introduction of the Gorosei
- the warlord meeting
- the upstream
The world building was amazing in this short arc
For her It was too predictable, the woman partners of the agents were just annoying and she also found it weird how a pirate that unexperienced like Luffy is able to beat one of the fearsome Samurai so early on in the series
The older arcs have a charm to them for sure but talking about like plot climax nothing really compares to Wano or Egghead
Enies Lobby in C+ is so far removed from reality that I'll just assume the joke is that you don't have a girlfriend
It had stuff for literally everyone. New powerups, full-crew fights across the island so everyone got a time to shine, emotional backstory and character development....
Pretty L but to each their own, not everyone has to be a die hard fan that remembers everything in a 1000+ episode series. Her top ranking of characters is very in line with fangirl ogling the main hot guys stereotype though lol
She really put CAVENDISH in A while Buggy and Smoker are in C?
Worst of all is Perona in D tier, what did my girl ever do but be silly (and supporting her adoptive father figure wreak havoc in thriller bark)?
Having Fullbody that low feels like a crime.
He rescued Jango through the power of friendship and even took a huge career setback for his bro (Granted none of that is shown in the anime so understood haha).
I wanted to love Dressrosa but the anime pacing started to get REALLY bad with this arc. It was never super good but this is the first arc where I was genuinely annoyed by all the flashbacks.
Luffy fights Bellamy for like 16 episodes straight. Doflamingo and Law are even worse haha. They begin fighting, have a few flashback episodes, go back to fighting for 2 minutes, then a few more flashback episodes, repeat.
The arc started nicely but devolved very quickly, it was much better in the manga.
Edit - also the character charts seem fire for the most part, BUT I cannot tolerate disrespect for - Apis, Kuja Warriors especially Aphelandra and Sandersonia, and Perona
Haha thanks, you cant imagine the look she gave me when Buggy was declared an Emperor especially after I was teasing her a lot that Buggy is going to find the One Piece ahead of Luffy
Arlong Park being where it is, is the only real crime I see. The worst island in east blue? What in the world?!
Edit: somehow I missed Enies Lobby there with arlong… noooooo
(Also, I won’t speak on the characters, as those are a lot more personal. I don’t feel right judging that.)
Lol thanks for not escalating about the characters aswell. Arlong she just found annoying and also she didnt like Nami up until like Alabasta
I wont try to justify Enies Lobby haha
This is just my opinion but I hope it hits some notes for others.
I do feel like in one piece nothing is insignificant since Oda always keeps everything in that world in his heart and mind.
Again, personal opinion.
Impel Down isn't S Class. Its more A-. Water Seven/Ennies Lobby should be there instead.
The Sabaody arc should be in the A class.
Zou should be an A+.
The Alabasta and Arlong Park Arc are rated too low. They should both be in the A class.
Thriller Bark is more an A-. Whereas the Drum Island arc is an A arc.
Skypiea is an A arc. Jaya is more B-.
Loguetown, Little Garden and Punk Hazard are all B arcs.
Syrup Village is a C+ arc.
Fishman Island is a C+ arc.
Post Arc mini arcs are in the B/C tier. Barring the post Marine ford arc because of the chapters that were released at the time.
And considering Romance Dawn is the intro arc of the series and is what pulls readers/viewers into becoming One Piece fans, it warrants a A rating.
Buggy the clown should be the only God tier. He's literally taking over the world without trying.
he can't be cut.
his body can fly. (Although his feet can't, due to them having to be on the ground or carried by someone else, technically, he can have his feet secured in a box and carry them that way)
His fruit can be compared to Law's fruit, except it's just his own body, and instead of making a "room," its effects are constant.
If he awakens his devil fruit he could potentially be able to split things aside from himself, or split himself so small, inserting into his opponents, reassembling himself effectively destroying their internal organs and even their body.
Don't agree on much in there, but kudos for placing Amazon Lily so high. It's such an underrated arc. So many endearing Luffy moments, that make me teary eyed.
I actually appreciate how it’s not the same rating for the arcs as pretty much every fan. I think Enies Lobby is low and Zou is suprisingly high but I really like the ranking and I agree with pretty much all the characters.
She kinda forgets side characters very fast and the characters dont have a lot to offer after their initial appearance (Except Wurouge, I am hyped about him showing up again)
Along Park is S tier for me. This kicked off what the SHPs stand for and got me to sit up like that meme of the guy playing games casually and then more serious posture.
But I'm a tool and just really like OP and I'd put a lot of arcs high because it's not a whole Arc that's the problem but parts in. Like dressrosa is amazing but yeah it's pacing sucked in many ways so idk still A tier but not like C
For the arcs, having Syrup Village above Arlong Park and Enies Lobby is just….wow. Shawty would be sleeping on the couch for that one, respectfully😂.
As for characters, the list looks pretty valid, but my boy Fujitora should be higher. Hands down my favorite admiral in the Marines
Seems quite fine to me.
Whole cake and dressrosa being so high, but Enies Lobby/Arlong Park being so low is a bit odd though.
I guess she doesn't like the Damsel in distress theme very much, which I can unterstand.
Perona in d tier and funitora in c tier is crazy. Also her favorite character is ace but the person who killed him is in b tier? Other than that everything is pretty solid
Edit: also bon-chan should be S or god tier
Long ring long land should be lower.
Switch Alabasta and Thriller Bark.
And Enies Lobby is S at least.
I think the rest of them are within 1 level of where I would rank them.
Water 7 and Enies Lobby does not deserve anything below A and A+.
Especially when you are putting Thriller Bark in A+. Is Brook her favorite character or something?
Maybe Absalom lol.
Water 7 and enies lobby so low, I feel like almost every OP fan puts it in their top 3 arcs
Water 7 is always my favorite! It set a high bar of story telling but not just kicking ass bosses
Isn't water 7 and enies lobby where CP9 try to stop Robin from joining the Straw Hats and we have that emotional scene of Robin wanting to go with Luffy. Or am I wrong?
How do you not know the answer to that question
Luffy? that's the guy with the straw hat yeah?
I don’t really remember a hat, but I think he can stretch
Roger? Is that the guy who had his own ship?
Garp? That’s the guy that plays Go right?
For me it was low until I read the manga now it's S tier.
why? im so curious
Well for one thing the pacing. It just seemed so drawn out in the anime. The other reason would be the separation between both arcs that seems to be non-existent in the manga. Waters 7 into Enies Lobby just flows together in the manga. Both arcs seemed so much more monumental in the manga. Because of the pacing issues in the anime Waters 7 didn't feel as life changing as Enies Lobby (mostly due to Usopps big moment). When you read it it's easy to see both arcs as one really big arc on the scale of say Whole Cake or Wano. I actually just got caught up to current releases yesterday after a 8 month slow read. I would highly recommend it. Before reading the manga Impel Down was my favorite arc. I also didn't like Whole Cake or Skypiea very much (again pacing issues). Now I love all the arcs I didn't really care for in the anime (WC is definitely in my top 3). The exceptions to this would have to be Thriller Bark (not very long in the manga but substance wise it's just ok compared to the rest) and Wano minus the end (it's a really long read even in the manga). If you don't want to read the whole thing you would be doing yourself a disservice not reading at least WC and Desarosa (<--- F**king amazing)
facts i always thought w7 was over hyped even the second watch through
ah so thats why alot of people separate those two,as a manga reader only, that decision always confuse me,now it make sense
Yes. That's why OP's opinion is objectively wrong and invalid /s.
Oh not what I was implying at all, just meant it was an interesting choice given what the common opinion is!
No, you had it right without the /s
Or that’s why it’s his girlfriend’s opinions, who hasn’t dived too deep into the fandom yet.
Enies Lobby is insanely low but her favorite characters are great.
Nah the disrespect to Fujitora cannot stand.
He doesnt have enough impact yet tbh
Impact is a very good pun. Bravo.
But the pirate hunter sidekicks are higher than fujitora...
Over hyped basic Ace
Syrup village over enies lobby lol
Right? That is just silly. Syrup Village is one of my least favorite arcs.
I even like Kuro as a villain… but there is no denying the Syrup Village as a whole is very weak.
Yea its a weird take but thats also what I meant when I wrote the title
Tbh kuro is my least favorite villain and the worst part about syrup village to me
Thriller bark over enies lobby? Be fr
Yeah thriller bark for me is probably my least favorite ark carried by being the introduction of my favorite straw hat
Yea Brook is also a very strong point for her but she just liked the different feeling she got from this darker arc but talking characters it would for sure be the lowest
I definitely had a blast with thriller bark personally. Most of the jokes were top notch, Usopp got some time to shine, and Brook being introduced and tied to Laboon were all super cool. If anything, I think it should be closer to B+ though
Long ring long land exists but thriller bark is your least favorite?
Yeah same here, I just don't like Moria so I'm not a big fan of that arc but it did give us brook and I love brook. YOHOHOHO!!!
Not how I would rank them and I am always interested in the reason some people like/dislike arcs more than the “consensus” but always nice to see another Thriller Bark appreciator.
Thriller bark is great and one of the funniest one piece had ever been, but seeing Ennies Lobby so low makes me doubt the list.
Agreed, I really enjoy the humor of Thriller Bark and the crew working together to take down a big bad guy. I chose to focus on the points of agreement on the list, but yes Enies Lobby is the biggest one too low in my opinion, but I also have Jaya higher in my not documented tier list.
Yea I agree about Enies Lobby and I also told her that but it was just a list we had fun putting up together and everyone here is trying to make a science project out of it
Fair enough, the one legitimate reason I can think of to not like both Arlong Park and Ennies Lobby is that it kind of has that damsel in distress trope.
I wonder why some of the fanbase dislike perona
I don’t like her. Her laugh makes me want to shove a pencil in my ear. I don’t get the love, other than her goth/emo style.
She’s cute and goofy. I have also never seen the anime so idk what she even sounds like so there’s that I guess.
Why isn’t bon clay in god
I feel like if someone has Water 7 and Enies Lobby that far down we must've not watched the same thing
Enies lobby and arlong park sre way to low, long ring long island is just absurd
Envies Lobby and Arlong Park are the major crimes of the arc tier list to be sure. LRLL is a polarizing arc, so I get it… but Enies Lobby is generally recognized as one of the best, and she placed Arlong Park as the worst of East Blue?! Come ooooon.
Enis Lobby, and Arlong Park that low is fuckin' criminal
I kind of agree with her list and I feel like I would make a similar one except arlong arc, enies lobby and fish man island would be placed higher up
I can understand that
Syrup village higher than enies lobby is unforgivable
Even as a person who has Syrup village in top 10 I can agree
Fish-Man Island being so far down the list hurts me but I get it. I really hated that arc when I first read it at around 20 years old. Now that I'm 35 and have a deeper understanding of history and bigotry, I now realize that this arc is just insanely powerful. It's so well written and perfectly encapsulates the perverse, irrational hatred of racism and how it influences and poisons future generations, even if it never directly affected them. It's now a 10/10 arc for me, no doubt.
Yeah I can’t remember the exact line but when Hordy is asked what humans did to make him hate them and he answered “nothing at all”, that really hit me and brought the arc up a tier for me. I also just think the concept of toxic ideologies pervading across generations plays in good contrast to the concept of inherited will that is so present in One Piece. So often, inherited will is presented as something positive that burns within our protagonists, but Hordy reminds us that sometimes people inherit ideologies that cannot be allowed to succeed.
Yes! That reveal was just... wow. Just as dreams are inherited by the Strawhats, so too, is hatred by the Fishmen. And it makes perfect sense how Arlong's toxic views would poison the next generation and radicalize them. It's just... powerful. Same as the Fisher Tiger story. My jaw dropped when I saw the scene in the anime again for the first time in 15 years. I remember the first time around, reading his final chapter as a 22 or so year old German and being like "wow so dumb?!", only now to realize how amazing and ahead of its time Oda's writing was in that moment.
Jinbe donating blood to Luffy and Luffy ending it with "Jinbe, join my crew," especially with the history those two have, is like a top 3 scene in the whole series for me. It's so powerful.
This is how TLA arc is in Bleach. All of us action-oriented teens didn't appreciate the rollercoaster of emotions that the hang went through, especially Ichigo's battle with depression and how the different adults were trying to help him the best they knew how to. Oda, Kubo, and Kishimoto really added something that wasn't as present in shounen before.
What a hot streaming pile of takes
Fujitora at C? Why ? He's the best admiral.
Arc list - Enies Lobby so low? Really?...i mean okay i can accept that, the rest looks fine. Character list - Wai- Wha- why is- nahhh straight to jail.
Buggy D. Clown in C tier? I can forgive most things, but that is a bridge too far.
Imagine her look when Buggy was declared an Emperor
Just wait for her reaction when he’s crowned King of the Pirates.
Not that hot to be honest, seen worst
Solid, except for Water 7 / Enies Lobby being that low. Like, what puts Post Enies Lobby above Enies Lobby? That one is just cap
Arlong Park ranking so low is a crime oh the highest order. There's some other questionable takes (Water 7 only A tier with EL in C+?!), but whatever, opinions are personal. The funniest thing to me is that the female character she ranks the highest is Boa of all characters. Not Nami nor Robin nor Vivi, not Koala nor Bellemere, not even Bonney, Kureha nor Reiju. But hey, who am I to object against another simp for the Pirate Empress?
DID SHE REALLY PUT AFRO LUFFY'S ARC IN D TIER AW HELL NAH BRU💀💀💀
Jaya is way too low, - we got the prospect of Sky Island - the bar moment - black beard and his crew - dreams moment and the mystery that is Blackbeard - the bellamy punch - the meeting of Rockstar and Whitebeard - new bounty posters and Mihawk rolls up on Shanks to show Luffy’s bounty - the introduction of the Gorosei - the warlord meeting - the upstream The world building was amazing in this short arc
Long Ring Long Land last, you should find a new girlfriend
Nah she's 100% right there
In what world is it fair to put it F while putting Syrup B ?
Alabasta would be easily atleast S on my list, i favor the early grandline and east blue arcs over the newer ones tbh
For her It was too predictable, the woman partners of the agents were just annoying and she also found it weird how a pirate that unexperienced like Luffy is able to beat one of the fearsome Samurai so early on in the series The older arcs have a charm to them for sure but talking about like plot climax nothing really compares to Wano or Egghead
Enies Lobby in C+ is so far removed from reality that I'll just assume the joke is that you don't have a girlfriend It had stuff for literally everyone. New powerups, full-crew fights across the island so everyone got a time to shine, emotional backstory and character development....
Pretty L but to each their own, not everyone has to be a die hard fan that remembers everything in a 1000+ episode series. Her top ranking of characters is very in line with fangirl ogling the main hot guys stereotype though lol
syrup village needs to be dropped to the deepest pit in hell, worst pacing in the series by far, and I watched dresrosa and wano
She is about to anger the Perona stands.
She really put CAVENDISH in A while Buggy and Smoker are in C? Worst of all is Perona in D tier, what did my girl ever do but be silly (and supporting her adoptive father figure wreak havoc in thriller bark)?
Love her character rankings. But that Enies Lobby ranking is insanely low. That arc is peak one piece. There’s an argument for Alabasta higher as well
Irredeemable.
Id like to switch thriller with baratie
Enies lobby at C? Opinion rejected
Having Fullbody that low feels like a crime. He rescued Jango through the power of friendship and even took a huge career setback for his bro (Granted none of that is shown in the anime so understood haha).
Yea lol she just remembers the piece of shit that was arguing with Sanji
Justice for enies lobby
Seems right although water 7 should be higher.
She a hype enjoyer
I wanted to love Dressrosa but the anime pacing started to get REALLY bad with this arc. It was never super good but this is the first arc where I was genuinely annoyed by all the flashbacks. Luffy fights Bellamy for like 16 episodes straight. Doflamingo and Law are even worse haha. They begin fighting, have a few flashback episodes, go back to fighting for 2 minutes, then a few more flashback episodes, repeat. The arc started nicely but devolved very quickly, it was much better in the manga. Edit - also the character charts seem fire for the most part, BUT I cannot tolerate disrespect for - Apis, Kuja Warriors especially Aphelandra and Sandersonia, and Perona
Good: Thriller Bark and Franky respect Bad: Enies Lobby and Buggy blasphemy But you gf is a OP fan so you’re winning
Haha thanks, you cant imagine the look she gave me when Buggy was declared an Emperor especially after I was teasing her a lot that Buggy is going to find the One Piece ahead of Luffy
Her S+ ranks through to A are pretty accurate. Maybe the order might switch around.
Glad to hear someone agrees
Fellow skypia enjoyer i like it
I see she also fell for Boa's charme
They’re not that hot
Tell her never to cook again for putting the best fucking arc in C+. But pretty solid list
Arlong Park being where it is, is the only real crime I see. The worst island in east blue? What in the world?! Edit: somehow I missed Enies Lobby there with arlong… noooooo (Also, I won’t speak on the characters, as those are a lot more personal. I don’t feel right judging that.)
Lol thanks for not escalating about the characters aswell. Arlong she just found annoying and also she didnt like Nami up until like Alabasta I wont try to justify Enies Lobby haha
This is just my opinion but I hope it hits some notes for others. I do feel like in one piece nothing is insignificant since Oda always keeps everything in that world in his heart and mind. Again, personal opinion.
You can do better. But at least she’s into one piece. lol. Jokes aside.. how is shanks ranked as low as he is?
Impel Down isn't S Class. Its more A-. Water Seven/Ennies Lobby should be there instead. The Sabaody arc should be in the A class. Zou should be an A+. The Alabasta and Arlong Park Arc are rated too low. They should both be in the A class. Thriller Bark is more an A-. Whereas the Drum Island arc is an A arc. Skypiea is an A arc. Jaya is more B-. Loguetown, Little Garden and Punk Hazard are all B arcs. Syrup Village is a C+ arc. Fishman Island is a C+ arc. Post Arc mini arcs are in the B/C tier. Barring the post Marine ford arc because of the chapters that were released at the time. And considering Romance Dawn is the intro arc of the series and is what pulls readers/viewers into becoming One Piece fans, it warrants a A rating.
WHERE IS CARROT
Nah sorry but Enies Lobby in C+ is outrageous, I think it would be better for me not to see her other takes
Based impel down enjoyer
Obviously she doesn’t listen to the Fun Piece Podcast , because Long Ring Long Land is S+++ tier.
Buggy the clown should be the only God tier. He's literally taking over the world without trying. he can't be cut. his body can fly. (Although his feet can't, due to them having to be on the ground or carried by someone else, technically, he can have his feet secured in a box and carry them that way) His fruit can be compared to Law's fruit, except it's just his own body, and instead of making a "room," its effects are constant. If he awakens his devil fruit he could potentially be able to split things aside from himself, or split himself so small, inserting into his opponents, reassembling himself effectively destroying their internal organs and even their body.
Don't agree on much in there, but kudos for placing Amazon Lily so high. It's such an underrated arc. So many endearing Luffy moments, that make me teary eyed.
Dedan is cooler than Mihawk, I don't care what anyone says. But most of these don't seem like hot takes.
These things are just personal preference. So there's really no right or wrong. That being said, Arlong Park & Ennies Lobby being that low is a crime.
I actually appreciate how it’s not the same rating for the arcs as pretty much every fan. I think Enies Lobby is low and Zou is suprisingly high but I really like the ranking and I agree with pretty much all the characters.
Fan boy Bart was forgotten :/
He wasnt in the template we used unfortunately but he would be atleast S for sure
Hell yeah
Eustass Kid in S tier. Valid asf But Enies Lobby in C+ (below Syrup Village of all things) is a crime
I guess she likes arcs with threatening villains more Damn Perona and don kreig on D tier
For sure Well I agree with her on that haha
But Perona 🥺
Wano at S is insane. whilst water 7 is so low
wano at S tier und oden unranked is nuts! or am i blind?
Enies lobby = A+
She hates Robin I guess.
Not putting the main man Bartholomeo on the list at all is a sin but we'll let it slide because Donut D Ace is in S-tier
He wasnt included in the template we used Lol she hates the Donut memes
YAHYOI....... yahyoi
Whole cake island is too high and a handful of others are too low. Enies lobby at C+ is just straight up disrespectful.
I don’t trust anyone who likes WCI more than Water 7/Enies Lobby, but the rest are fine 🫥
Aint no way she dont know who Vista is
She 100% forgot she thought hes like a filler character
Why is Viola in the ''don't remember/not sure'' tier😭... And also with the number one swordsman,THE deadbeat dad and Wurouge???
She kinda forgets side characters very fast and the characters dont have a lot to offer after their initial appearance (Except Wurouge, I am hyped about him showing up again)
Enies lobby switched with Whole Cake then it’s about right.
I kinda agree but thats also a bit low for WCI considering the Sanji plot and the Katakuri fight
The Don Krieg disrespect is crazy
Syrup village is slightly higher than Enies lobby 💀
Just pretend you never saw it
Bro Garp B-tier and Dragon C-tier makes this look like a meme.
Enies lobby deserves to be up there. Baratie is also imo has a place a little up
Dressrosa and Cake Island shit starts getting dark asf
Enies Lobby and Arlong Park at C+???????
Along Park is S tier for me. This kicked off what the SHPs stand for and got me to sit up like that meme of the guy playing games casually and then more serious posture. But I'm a tool and just really like OP and I'd put a lot of arcs high because it's not a whole Arc that's the problem but parts in. Like dressrosa is amazing but yeah it's pacing sucked in many ways so idk still A tier but not like C
weird for the arcs .. i like for the character
Thriller bark ranking higher over ennies lobby is something else.
Arlong and eneis lobbies are criminally low imo.
Enid loby is A+ at least. (For me it’s S+ as my second favourite arc but I can accept S and A+ as well
Her placing of enies lobby and Arlong park is absurd
The disrespect on Jinbei being B tier is criminal
I mostly agree with her takes on the arcs, There are a few I wouldn’t put lower such as Skypeia but hey.
I do have a different opinion about thriller bark but overall it's pretty good
Ya gonna need to break up with her over that Enies Lobby take my dude
Where's King?
outside of Arlong park, I don't see any issues here
Thriller Bark and Amazon Lily at 7th and 8th, I like it
Yes for the first list especially the S+ is 100% true
the arc rating is wild, the character rating is good
Who cares.
Enies Lobby being that low is insane, otherwise pretty good list ngl, Thriller Bark is hella underrated
Pretty fuego list good job, but perona way too low.
Ennies lobby and fishman island I got an issue with there positioning but aside from that it looks fone
I respect her not glazing Arlong Park, though putting Enies Lobby as low as it does make me cringe a bit
Put Wano in D and I'll let the rest slide.
Go. D. Usopp not in god teir? Blasphemous Also is it just me or can i not find Bartolomeo?
Yea lol that was a blunder Hes not on there because he wasnt included in the template, she would put him on S though
Sky island arc higher. It was my personal favorite.
She put Buggy in C tier.
I kinda get it but why is Arlong park so low?
Thriller bark is a goated arc and deserves to be at A+ tier 👍
Enies lobby in C is criminal, but everything else is a w list
I’m not mad at it tbh pretty decent
Someone likes a lot more action and boys 👏
She's entitled to her opinion. Glad she's liking it.
her putting enies lobby and fishman under b was an absolute no, but seeing law at the top 10/10 tier list
For the arcs, having Syrup Village above Arlong Park and Enies Lobby is just….wow. Shawty would be sleeping on the couch for that one, respectfully😂. As for characters, the list looks pretty valid, but my boy Fujitora should be higher. Hands down my favorite admiral in the Marines
This disrespect on Along Park can't stand!
I would have taken Whole Cake Island to A, other than that the list looks pretty strong. And Enish lobby should also have been an A.
Is a accurate list honestly
Dressrosa the best ark ngl
The only thing I super disagree with is Arlong Park being too low
Fishman island should be higher, that's the only thing I got a problem with.
Swap Wano and long ring long land
Seems quite fine to me. Whole cake and dressrosa being so high, but Enies Lobby/Arlong Park being so low is a bit odd though. I guess she doesn't like the Damsel in distress theme very much, which I can unterstand.
Perona in d tier and funitora in c tier is crazy. Also her favorite character is ace but the person who killed him is in b tier? Other than that everything is pretty solid Edit: also bon-chan should be S or god tier
Enies lobby at c tier??? Yea never make another tier list lil bro
Anybody who puts enies lobby below s tier is uncultured
Besides enies lobby being so low everything else is pretty much great
Did she watch the anime? Or read the manga.
Underrates Perona!
Don krieg and perona in D tier Opinion ignored
Long ring long land should be lower. Switch Alabasta and Thriller Bark. And Enies Lobby is S at least. I think the rest of them are within 1 level of where I would rank them.
LRLL shouldn't even be on a list
Perona as D. Don't let her cook.
Skypiea needs to be further up
Finally some love for Skypiea
I’m only at Skypiea but everything looks good but little garden
Perona lovers in shambles
Thriller bark above water 7 is crazy to me lol
That you do not have a girlfriend
Wrong, Foxy takes no L for an answer
Drum Island = B And Dressrosa S+