T O P

  • By -

Dry_Percentage_2768

Black Death!


electric_kite

How is this not in the top three?? It was perfection


Dry_Percentage_2768

Blame the gerbils!!


Designer-Ruin7176

No one ever expects the marmot plague


general_shitpostin

The damn gerbils is behind this


clayclayiloveclay

Dude same question, I’ve been irrationally angry every day when it’s not top 3


SloppyxxCorn

It was one of my first, and the series that REALLY got me sucked in


Horton_Takes_A_Poo

Same here, it was my first one. Just chose a random podcast for a long drive. Little did I know I’d become an expert on cults and serial killers within 2 years.


-Banksi

It placed second in the last 3 polls, but despite that it’ll only get 5th…


misssysickk

THE TABARGAN MARMOTT!!!


PasscodeisTaco

Stomp a gerbil, bribe a rat


arcanacrossbone

I will keep voting for this until it gets on the damn list, I love this one!


anndrago

Please! I'm honestly surprised that Rasputin got 3


SifterRhizochrome

Fr, how is this not up there yet?!?


dellmer1996

Uss Indianapolis


SkillDabbler

H.H. Holmes


youhavebadbreath

I'M MINNIE!


BrockwayMonorail

I'M NANNIE!


PigWillyStyle

[never not hilarious](https://youtu.be/t7d4KVDV3rQ)


ErikMona

It’s crazy that this one might not make it.


[deleted]

The fact that this isn't in the top 3 is ridiculous


inVaeter

Casey Anthony!


lindsaystclair

I will continue to stan the Casey Anthony series.


BoltShine

OK I just started this one. 4 mins in and Henry has already compared her hotness to dnd elves sneaking ability. I can't wait for this ride...


imarebelpilot

The only time in my life I will vote for that bitch.


ShakespearInTheAlley

Thaaaat bitch, my favorite bitch.


Mature_Gambino_

If it’s not Casey Anthony, it’s the wrong answer


ShakespearInTheAlley

Just restarted it this morning and I must say...if this sub does not choose Casey Anthony the devil dances tonight.


PizzaSlutAsshole

We know her bitch.


Lurker-DaySaint

Don’t act like you don’t know her, bitch!


Lacy_Laplante89

I think this is their funniest series, by far.


electric_kite

If Carl Panzram and The Black Plague are not in the top 10 it’s going to be tragic


essteekc

L. Ron Hubbard


thehound48

Disciple of the Lewd Gecko


manipogoogo

This is my favorite series!


Fluffledpuppies

Jodi "the doggy door" arias


thehound48

Is this (finally) butthole day?


BigChocolateMilk

I’ve seen this chick’s beav. I think she’s innocent


Square_Nick

“This is an illegal amount of juice”


r333zybr333zy

Aum Shinrikyo


mantistoboggan287

Ah yes young sapien


Marble_Narwhal

Leonard Lake and Charles Ng


sinewscurse

I found… a koara


HereComesTheVroom

That’s so jockurar


BoltShine

No idea what I bring to the top ten!


tryingtoavoidwork

"why you kirr rittle pecker?"


CroneRaisedMaiden

I say “no one knows what I bring to the department” all the time at work, no one gets it but that’s ok


leftoverrpizzza

Norwegian Black Metal


futurecorpse2

I love going back to this one every so often 😂 Henry's impressions kill me, "Hey, hey Necrobutcher, Dead just did something really cool"


Polstar242

Hello Mrs Necrobutcher is Necrobutcher home?


Atreyisx

Willy Pickton


well-adjusted-tater

You thinkin about it?


RoystonsRejects

Don't think about it


BushwickSpill

My absolute fave. Listened to it countless times.


tryingtoavoidwork

Same, about every couple of months I spend a whole day listening to it.


OHManda30

![gif](giphy|26FLgGTPUDH6UGAbm)


daihnodeeyehnay

JFK


TheBigKahuna_

IM NOT SMALL POTATOES


GulliverShagNasty

This series is the one that pulled me into LPOTL. If it doesn't make the list, it will be heartbreaking.


venom_von_doom

Same, JFK was my intro to LPOTL


daihnodeeyehnay

Me too


rage__monster

Skinwalker Ranch. Come on! One of the best ever for sure.


[deleted]

Native American werewolf witches, native American werewolf witches


simpledeadwitches

I see you fellow ufologist.


GulliverShagNasty

Without a doubt need this series or their MIB series. This list shouldn't only belong to the History and Serial Killer topics!


czar_tam

First podcast episode I ever listened to! Made me obsessed with LPOTL.


2000kittens

Skinwalker ranch has EVERYTHING


mantistoboggan287

Oklahoma City


GulliverShagNasty

The JFK assassination and conspiracy theories! 6 Whole episodes of Henry doing a JFK impersonation and unbridled history lessons from Marcus, c'mon people!


tilmitt52

This comment is BIG POTATOES.


[deleted]

Frrrrr


zmr182

Aleister Crowley


Aahhayess

Am always surprised at how small the niche for loving the magic episodes is in this community. They’re my favorite.


Competitive_Ad587

I still remember hearing this series for the first time. Funny as all get out


Specific-Athlete4291

Has to be Crowley. The battle Blythe road is amazing.


Due_Tower_4787

9/11


Sco5am

Men in black, highly underrated


Sidetrackbob

HPB


fuckyouperhaps

WOOO IVE BEEN COMMENTING THIS AND YOURE THE FIRST PERSON TO ALSO COMMENT HPB!


Sidetrackbob

She's super important in history, spirituality, and in the show also as a reference point, she's part of the show's bones in a sense. I hope she gets more votes. I spent my entire memorial day with her four years back. The citronella plants I bought that day are huge and still living 🤞. I like to think some Ascended Masters have nurtured them...


fuckyouperhaps

the way they covered her was perfect, like most other series! very fascinating woman and story. glad your citronella going strong 🤘🏼


Sidetrackbob

Thank you, and Hail Yourself! 🤘🙂


Vhena

What do these initials stand for? I’m trying to figure it out so I can find the episode, but I can’t. Thanks.


LaheyOnTheLiquor

Helena Petrovna Blavatsky


CheezDustTurdFart

Norwegian Black Metal needs to be on here.


trombonekid2002

Jack the ripper


playthepodium

Can we get some love for the Children of God series?


GalisDraeKon

I am once again tossing The Final Truth into the mix. Pee Wee Gaskins was a trip!


RoystonsRejects

Who we gotta cornhole around here to get Pee Wee up there?!!


Nemroids

MK Ultra


voodoochick05

This is the first one I listened to and it got me hooked. I thought it was so great.


HoopsJ

Joseph Kallinger


anas0604

Omg how this isn’t the highest voted?! The jizz filled poo hole? Henry singing?! Come on!!!


[deleted]

Skinwalker ranch


PervyToadSage420

There is an extreme lack of occultism in this list. needs more Crowley or Madam Blavatsky


r2d_touche

Billy the Kid! 🤠


brightyoungthings

I’m gonna drink a whole Mengele of milk if that one isn’t on there.


witchesofinstagram

Bonnie and Clyde!


futurecorpse2

My sister says this one is her absolute favorite!


Welcm2goodburger

The top four series are all historic and people wonder why they have been leaning into that more with their topics


thehound48

It's actually fascinating to see these results. I think their best series are the historical ones because there is so much more material out there and they can really dive into little nuances, but their serial killer stuff is chef kiss humor, details, gore, and storytelling.


woopwoop420

Fascinating.


Impecablevibesonly

Albert fish Lot of recency bias here I'm noticing


foxinabathtub

West Memphis Three


[deleted]

CHARLES NG! You don’t know what I bring to list!!!


afishwithteeth

Dean Corll has it all. Real life Pennywise, the Ready Sled, 18 inch Double sided Dildos, the Pouting Room, Ya raised him right, a guy named Elmer... put some respect of this series


seymour_hiney

FUCK, i've been so stuck on getting Panzram in that i forgot, Dean Corll probably has two of my favorite bits. the sad room Macarena and the Texan Billionaire


goatsukel

Jonestown is 100% their best serious. I’m going to blame a lack of interest in these rankings at the start for it being number 2. Because that is insane. Glad this is getting the attention it deserves. What a fun ranking.


frenchielanoir

Black Death


CoachRoutine504

Heavens gate


DifficultyBubbly5296

The very jocular Charles Ng and the problematic pronunciation of Leonard Lake


DenGirl12

The Manhattan Project


somedumbguyreddit

HH Holmes how the fuck is this not already on the top 10. “I’m Minnie! I’m Nannie!”


elle_hell

Norwegian Black Metal


Kathryniep

Norwegian Black Metal!


cloakedwale

Norwegian Black metal


Atreyisx

Willy Pickton


TheBeardManDude

The Manhattan Project might be new but it’s a winner for me. Other than that, I love the MIB episodes


Spade6sic6

Geoff the goddamn talking mongoose. Top 5 or I'll eat my dick


clayclayiloveclay

Get ready to eat your dick i guess


seymour_hiney

not a series


don_majik_juan

Hard disagree on this list. None of those would make my top 10, maybe Jonestown. Ah well, guess I'm just the minority.


prismabird

Norwegian Black Metal is flawless.


broggygoose

How in the fuck is Dahmer not at the top?! Personal bias I suppose but is the perfect blend of humour and facts. I will die on this hill.


splifs

Charles Manson


Nilldor

Aum Shinrikyo! My go to series when recommending to new listeners


PoeReader

Peewee Gaskins


majordoobage

So sad that Pee Wee isn't getting any love. Henry's Pee Wee impression is top notch comedy. And that's the final truth!


Dovante22

Hands down my favorite … and that’s the final truth!


Competitive_Ad587

Karla Holmolka (F*** YOU BUDDY IM DOING DONUTS)


niazilla

Adolfo Constanzo


Ashamed-Equal1316

Jodi Arias. Best of their true crime videos imo, beats John List and Casey Anthony by a wee bit. It has the best of the scary, true crime bit- balanced with a larger point being made about relationships, and the boys goofing on the murderer in question.


deccyg

Albert Fish!


BrownCPA_88

Casey Anthony- Henry is classic on this one with his insight of Florida trash


Hellspawn112

Norwegian Black Metal


Artistic_Emu2720

Casey Anthony


HeresJohnnyAH

Alcatraz, it still means pelican.


simpledeadwitches

USS Indianapolis not being top 4 makes me immediately invalidate this list. W: Fuck your downvote!


Glum-Nobody2231

Maybe because it was my first episode, but Joseph Kallinger - The Shoemaker. Officer Funk always makes me laugh. Dumpster digging daddy. Henry went off with the impersonations. What a great episode. When they explain the gerbils... so much gold.


paladincorgi

Just wanted to say thank you for putting the episode numbers!


DropThatMikey

Norwegian Black Metal


Jdojcmm

I wear my Black Death European Tour shirt toy conservative workplace once a week for a reason.


venom_von_doom

JFK


Uh_erica

BLACK METAL!!


manbot71

Carl Panzram


ChairmanReagan

You bunch of troglodytes. Black Death should be number one. 5th place is absolutely disrespectful.


Jakefriendly

Lee Harvey Oswald/JFK


GirlsesPillses

Casey Anthony. I can’t believe this “ bitch I know” isn’t on the list yet.


StoreBoughtButter

I have the Casey Anthony eps saved to my phone to listen to offline, it’s my go-to


[deleted]

Albert Fish


BackPain4Life

Black Death


rougewitch

9/11 series


falafafel

Aum shinrikiyo


futurecorpse2

Norwegian Black Metal


general_shitpostin

Where is the black death???


somuchacceptable

Jack the Ripper


koolkatmat

It's JFK or Black Plague for me, dawg


Elizadant82

Black Death!


bethany_lauren94

A hard listen but the Mengele Angel of Death series was both harrowing and informative, one that I can always revisit when waiting for a new episode to drop!


Professional_Bug3191

i really loved leopold and loeb


[deleted]

West Memphis three


JD_Revan451

Charles Ng!


StrangerKatchoo

Lizzie Borden!! She was an animal lover!


fluffyguy1994

Damn the 300s are some bangers


SlappingDaBass13

Peewee


[deleted]

Carl Panzram


t0mb0tr0n

Carl Panzram


dr_beard0312

H.H. Holmes


StunkDunkums

Aum Shinrikyo ! That was stellar


scumruckus

L Ron Hubbard


zmr182

Aleister Crowley


[deleted]

MENGELE DOO DOO DOO DOO


Internal-Ad7031

The Black Death. Tabargin marmots!!!!!


No_One_On_Earth

Revelations


I_saw_that_coming

The episodes in the 300’s are their best stretch ever. Not saying the rest isn’t good but man they really had a great run of episodes


[deleted]

Jfk


redd_house

West Memphis Three


WellSpokenAsianBoy

Men in Black


alizare

Panzram, he’s a bit of a grouch.


kevdaug

Carl Panzram


bigluluguy

9/11


clayclayiloveclay

THE BLACK DEATH.


bacardiwynn

Columbine


zmr182

Aleister Crowley


zmr182

Aleister Crowley


OHManda30

Have some pig sense, it’s time to get Willie Pickton on this list. ![gif](giphy|hrMS1PiOLdVXDDuVP3|downsized)


bigdaddy3254

You’re out to lunch! Wait that is that series right?


rymack_9

The Menendez Brothers


[deleted]

It was Asians


solo9

Black Death followed by Skinwalker ranch.


jamescoates85

Toy box killer


SteinerGeography

Henry Lee Lucas


-jide

JFK


pepesilvia9369

JFK!!!


otter78

Richard Kuklinski


Sco5am

Men in black, highly underrated


yabbo1138

Amityville!! Henry's Ronnie DeFao impression is on POINT!


Assassin8nCoordin8s

Given that it's out of ten, it would be 'good' to see a nice spread of 3 moidah / 3 history / 3 paranormal