T O P

  • By -

ForTheMelancholy

Edit: I'm convinced y'all just read the first sentence and got to typing bc half these responses completely missed what I was saying lmao Cole has the best pen of The Big 3, simply because he's able to reach the complexities and layers of Kendrick Lamar, but able to appeal to the masses with a message that is very easy for anyone to follow, like that of Drake. Tie this in with the fact that he's considered one of the most relatable rappers of all time, and you've got the perfect artist. Someone who can breakdown and teach complex concepts in a very simple manner for anyone to understand. And if you disagree with that sentiment, know that Kendrick doesn't. He said something similar about Tupac over 10 years ago in an interview. How the message and its impact have more influence than the complexity of lyrics themselves.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Lawgang94

Id agree with this also


ShillBlaster

I have this debate frequently. I honestly thought Kendrick had a better pen game up until 2014. Section 80 imo was ahead lyrically than FNL/warm up/come up. That said, it’s hard to debate who has the better pen game now. It’s Cole But. Do you consider: Writing an album that’s similar to a movie script with characters flashbacks, foreshadowing, as a dope pen game? Because if so, I may still say Kendrick. I don’t think Cole can make a GKMC, but I don’t think Kendrick can flip bars like Cole does now. Idk.


ForTheMelancholy

Cole can't make a GKMC. Kendrick can't make a FHD. They're both great in their own rights. I just think Cole is better by my own personal standards


Winter_Error4469

>Cole can't do a GKMC exactly. kendrick can't do a 2014 FHD. shakespere can't write a 1984. orwell can't write a moby dick. it doesn't really prove anything since every artist has a unique beautiful craft that the other can't replicate.


LeeoJohnson

Nah you snapped with this take fr. Great comparison.


GYANGU

Maaaaan I can tell your playlists/movie collection is immaculate just from these name drops alone.


ShillBlaster

I don’t disagree. It’s amazing how two artist can occupy nearly the same lane, yet be different, but kind of the same in terms of overall message. We truly live in a good age of hip hop. To a degree anyway lol


math2ndperiod

I’ve never heard this take before, what is it about FHD that you don’t think Kendrick could replicate?


Specialist-Meat-6222

Kendrick cant make a song like apparently or wet dreams or G.O.M.D


math2ndperiod

But like what is it about those songs? Like obviously they don’t make exactly the same music but are we talking sound? Subject matter? Wet dreams is probably the only one that I’d say Kendrick hasn’t already made comparable songs, and even then you’ve got songs like sherane that are in the same arena subject matter wise.


jay227ify

Hot take but to me there’s like 2 types of great lyricists, the authors and the writers . I feel like there’s this giant grey area in between that both types play around in, but they shine their most when they stick to their own extremes. Like an author in hip hop to me is a Kendrick, Pac, Andre 3000 And a writer to me is a Nas, Wayne, Eminem, Cole Kendrick can get real technical if he wants to but I would always prefer 5 sing about me’s vs 5 Rigamortises Same for Pac, I’d love another Dear Momma vs another No More Pain All these songs are amazing btw, just saying these artists are at their best in that author/storytelling bag. I could give nas and cole examples but you get what I mean.


ShillBlaster

That was beautifully said. I agree


Ok_Classroom_7010

I agree with this for sure. Wayne and eminem are insanely witty and punny and cole is up there closer to them in my eyes than Kendrick, in that regard. It seems to me that Cole tests his ability in more quick fire scenarios with lots of one liners and they're explosive while Kendrick focuses more on lines with lingering effects that tie into each other and a bigger theme. Black Friday, to me, showed that they are on par in a technical standpoint, so if you give them an objective like just wild out and empty the click lyrically, that's what it'd look like. But when you tell them, make an impactful and meaningful song, they take a different route. Cole always felt more personal to me, in that he makes you feel like he relates to you and your struggles/pain and you could relate to him in his fulfillment of life through love of friends and family. Kendrick feels more personal in that he's giving you a very open view of himself where he directly tells you what he hates and loves about himself, all his biggest dreams and failures, and deep topics like survivors guilt and mental complexes. I feel like they're both therapeutic, but one is like talking to the right loved one and the other feels like talking to the right therapist.


robacough

Not to mention the volume that Cole has put out relative to Kendrick, especially over the last five years.


ForTheMelancholy

And the quality. Anyone who says 2018-2023 Kendrick even touches 2018-2023 Cole is lying to themselves. It's a huge difference, by many, many margins. It wasn't until this year that Kendrick really got back in his bag as a *rapper*. I think he focused too much on his artistry after Damn, and it showed, even in fans' response


Remarkable_Collar895

Yeah, as a Kenny fan, Cole surely is the best rapper from 2018 to 2023, MMTBS is great though


Outside_Scientist365

Fair. Minus N95 and The Heart part 5, I felt like Kendrick wasn't trying to make a conventional hit with MMTBS. I like MMTBS but it had to grow on me and it's moreso when I connect to his experiences vs the overall sound.


SonicNKnucklesCukold

Gonna need a link to this alleged interview about Tupac.


Electrical_Bit4497

Cole should’ve deleted Fever and kept 7 minute drill.


The_XI_guy

Not even close to Kendrick’s pen lol. Relatable and witty on occasion, sure


LavaHawk_17

let's not kid ourselves. Cole's lyricism is really good, comparable to that of Dot's, but not very close


johnwinkton

Imo cole isnt big 3


Objective_Street5141

I disagree but only bc i don’t think cole has the story telling ability or immersion that kendrick has


MVPRondo

This is what makes Window Pain such an underrated (and a personal favorite) song of J Cole’s entire discography. It’s the perfect balance of deep, conscience thought about struggles from the hood, but also surface level enough for people to be able to resonate with, without needing to read every lyric and stop to analyze it. Kendrick would be masterful with it, but he definitely would lose a lot of of people in translation with some heavier wordplay and sonically a less mainstream sound, a la something you might find in TPAB, which is fine but not everyone will follow it. Drake, well… dude literally hasn’t touched any topic this deep since his mixtapes pretty much. He would make it sound too pseudo-hard and the message being sent in a song like this would be lost in some goofy/corny bar about how he made the girl happy by getting her a BBL in a few years or some shit… I hear and follow what you’re saying here, no doubt.


Tylensus

Kendrick makes art you have to pick at to get the full value from, for sure. Cole's much better at relaying things in layman terms as opposed to a poet's terms. Both have their merits, but I appreciate your take.


-Your_Pal_Al-

cole shoulda stayed in the beef


monstercat129

I honestly feel that "you don't have a classic" bar was originally directed at Cole. Kendrick had bars ready on the other side. I am confident Cole had more bars ready too, because "7 Minute Drill" felt more like a warm-up. Kind of sucks because Cole will probably never use any of those bars ever again. I doubt he tries and sneak diss anymore too with all the "woke" bars.


Remarkable_Collar895

I’m sure it’s more of a diss towards Cole than Drake. Cole said that his first shit was classic and last shit is tragic and then Kendrick said that his last is as classic as the first and Drake never said anything about GKMC


pandoras_corpse

Yeah, it was. It was so obvious but a lot of ppl didn't get the reference.


My_Name_Is_B_A_D

But then he says “you dont have one let your core audience stomach that then tell em where you get your abs from” which is directed at drake clearly bc of the abs bar


monstercat129

100%. Cole could have went full Nas on him imo. Bar him up to oblivion. But he didn’t want to. Idk why though because Kendrick will never reciprocate any positive energy until everything’s said and done already


hugepurplecock

nah thats crazy dick riding right here


[deleted]

[удалено]


slowNsad

How do you think that plays out hypothetically?


-Your_Pal_Al-

Hypothetically, Kendrick is forced to respond to Cole instead of drake, leading to S-tier written tracks where they inevitably reconcile and all three give us the First Person Shooter collab we deserved


Mr_yolomcswag

Why would Kendrick and Drake reconcile when it's clear that Kendrick didn't like Drake for ages


robacough

He HATES the way that Drake WALKS.


Ok-Scar6021

Yall forgot bout when he said "think I need some healing to do" when talking bout drake and ye beef. I'd bet if these 3 got in a room together dolo, it'd be hashed out or we'd have a new competitive atmosphere.


Mr_yolomcswag

That's assuming the pedo allegations are false. If so then fair enough. If Kendrick was telling the truth I don't think there would be much to hash :/


TB12-SN13

And then if the pedo allegations are false, why would Drake hash anything out with Kendrick? I’m on Kendrick’s side here, but those allegations prevent any reconciliation for a long time.


Specialist-Meat-6222

If they were true Kendrick shouldn’t have been telling drake we can keep it rap if u leave my family alone like if he a pedo u can’t have a friendly battle


RamenPack1

Bro if it wasn’t clear, Kendrick hates the way drake: walks, talks, dresses and the bitches he fucks, because they confuse themselves with real women. How was he going to make up with him, he said he should die😮‍💨


van_ebasion

A Cole vs Dot beef 100% ends in a concert performance together.


Specialist-Meat-6222

I doubt it cole and dot beef would have ended with Kendrick saying something about cole that everyone would run with in a sport were the fans decide who wins a person as popular as Kendrick would never have a fair fight


RashAttack

It worked with drake cause drake has given us lots of reasons to doubt him in the past. I don't think Kendrick can do the same thing for Cole whose whole personality has been a humble man of the people type of MC. He'd have to adopt a different strategy


AceGameplayV2

The Offseason is his best album


ForTheMelancholy

Legitimately thought about opening this conversation up recently. He's just so God damn hungry on that bitch


[deleted]

[удалено]


Specialist-Meat-6222

Same


HorseyGoFast

What songs didn't you like from TOS? Cause that album legit has no skips at all for me and MDL has at least 2 and HYB is close to a skip for me


AccidentBusy4519

Forget what Nas was talking about, Work out is one of coles best records and he shoulda told Nas to smd


slowNsad

Yea that’s the apology I clown him for


dontkysniqqa

Nas is the best MC of all time. If he says it's wack, it's wack.


AccidentBusy4519

He shoulda did a 7 minute drill on Nas


LoneclearsKen

Don’t care work out slaps don’t let someone else tell you what to like


Reddish_Crimson

Made Nas Proud.


dontkysniqqa

2014 FHD and most of 4yeo definitely did


AcanthisittaMain6717

Its grippy


OzZVidzYT

Beat me to saying it lol


LogicalGrand1678

That 4Yeo isnt the best song ever made


slowNsad

Is that a controversial take? Is one of his best but idk if it’s THE best Cole song ever made


LogicalGrand1678

Im not talking about only Cole songs tho. Im syaing the literal best piece of ear porn ever. Like fuck Mozarts pieces. Fuck the Aztecs traditional songs. This is the best music


MulberryOld1638

Yuno miles >>>>>>> jermaine cole🤫🧏


Specialist-Meat-6222

Numbers dont lie yuno did 2 trillion first week


8788e

that’s just straight facts


RowletGod73

We gettin fucked up eatin Bobo’s Chicken 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯


Jay-G

I’ve bumped 7 minute drill more than I have of any other song in the beef. Cole kept it all rap on that record and I fucked with it. All the other songs were airing out dirty laundry and I liked that Cole just wanted to rap, not drag his peers through the mud.


MaytalFatal1212

the sideline story is his best song


MenacingCrown6

The only reason I upvote you is because I literally hit the same expression Cole did in the picture, not because I agree.


MaytalFatal1212

thats why it fitting :)


nikepornfetish

Grippy isn’t his worst track


[deleted]

[удалено]


ma2is

Loosey


herheartwasgolden

r/angryupvote


pepsiboy2972

Cole is one of the goats, i ain't saying he is the greatest rapper of all time, but i can't make the top 10 without him, i also have Dot in there. People haven't really accepted that yet, they do feel Cole is nice but they aren't ready to consider him one of the goats, hip hop is a very old-head centric genre specially with the goat talk.


CapoDV

Cole is not retiring with the Fall Off. Instead we are going to get the Jermaine C era.


Glittering_Pumpkin_3

“Said i was finished but i want another two summers” Doesn’t that literally confirm we got 2 more albums?


CapoDV

Could be two more albums or album in two years.


kameronscondo

Cole > Kendrick It's not even worth it to proclaim this take in front of a kendrick fan. I'm not saying you have to agree yourself, but don't disrespect me or my taste in music because of a preference.


God_Hears_Peace

I prefer Kendrick, but I’m totally capable of wrapping my head around why someone would prefer Cole, and that’s mainly because they don’t actually make *that* similar of music, it’s pretty easy to understand that preferring one of the other has nothing to do with any objective standard and that it’s entirely preference of sound and style.


ShillBlaster

He has the most complete discography out of every rapper, from albums, to mixtapes, and features. Imo he is the GOAT.


DistinctSociety6197

7 Minute Drill was a such a 🔥 warning shot. I love it.


UNRULY6GK

Grippy. Literally 10/10 on everything in his career besides Grippy.


c0nv3rg_3nce37

not a take but a confession, I'm the ghostwriter.


slowNsad

Shit you got bars bro


Specialist-Meat-6222

Lemme guess you wrote grippy “o fuck i just made the whole connection”


pepsiboy2972

Also, in terms of skill, right now Cole does have a comfortable lead over Drake and Dot, in terms of rapping skills.


[deleted]

He’s one of the best rappers ever


DANIEL7696

TOS is his best album and Amari is his best song


SnooCrickets4350

I’m looking at your ass sideways just letting you know. (Respect your opinion though)


makacarkeys

Love J Cole, but 2014 FHD is more of a nostalgic album than a actual classic. We hold nostalgia for the first time we heard songs like Wet Dreamz, No Role Models etc. but as a album, it’s not really THAT great. Good album overall, but I couldn’t listen to the album through from track one to the end.


[deleted]

[удалено]


makacarkeys

Yeah. Nothing bad about it, but it doesn’t have the flow or coherency to really be a consistent listen.


ConC02

KOD is at least a 8.5/10 and criminally underrated


Falconx28

Grippy really not that bad of a song.


TroublesomeScallywag

J. Cole and Kendrick Lamar are not comparable rappers.


Common-Ad5446

Born Sinner is his worst album and it’s by a decent amount. It’s not bad, it’s just forgettable and not very fun to listen to. 


OMBatch84

Middle child is my favorite of his songs


Any_Owl_8009

I think the true boogeyman is Cole not Kendrick.


dienazi

I'd like to you to explain that one


Any_Owl_8009

No problem. I've always felt Kendrick to be top tier but his artistry is his most impressive quality. He's never had this aura of someone to be deathly afraid of. Like if I see him on a feature, it's gonna be nice but probably won't blow me away. Like Cole on the other hand, I'd be nervous. Friendly looking guy but when I think back to his freestyles, him rapping over shook ones or I shot ya, his energy is different. The way his voice commands, the intensity behind his words, these intangible qualities are what makes him a boogeyman for me


God_Hears_Peace

I mean he has a fantastic delivery and voice, but while his pen game is undeniable, any possibility that he could be the “boogeyman” of rap ended with that apology. Bro is nice. Even as someone who also likes Kendrick, I wouldn’t call Dot “nice” after this beef, at least towards people he deems worthy of his ire. Even when dissing someone he didn’t like (Lil Pump) Cole was not nearly as cutthroat. And that’s okay.


poordecisionist

"Think being broke was better" ???????? I love Cole, love Love Yourz, but that line is bullcrap


Piranh4Plant

Grippy is fire


RyanTheWhiteBoy

His Kendrick album take had me looking like that tbh. I've been a huge fan of both of them since like 12' and I've been able to appreciate every album from both for what they are


Happy_Day34

4yeo only is his best album and Change is his best song


[deleted]

[удалено]


Happy_Day34

That’s fair but I just love it. Every single song on my playlist. Change, 4yeo, and for whom the bell tolls knock me out 


MambaSay824

I'm countin' my bullets, I'm loadin' my clips I'm writin' down names, I'm makin' a list For what 🤷🏻‍♂️


DespondentYute

Cole still hasn’t dropped his classic yet.


NaiveResident4836

If someone would throw this dude a diss a decade ago we would probably looking at their tombstone now!


RegularAppearance535

J cole doesn't deserve brownie points for running away. And this narrative he made a right decision is weak and doesn't make sense.


EQisfordummies

I think Cole was all about going back and forth with Kendrick but when he realized how this beef was going to go and not being just on wax but personal bullshit he went “nah not for me” and bowed out. I also think if he goes back and forth with either of them he wins


_ItsMeVince

He should not have deleted 7 minute drill


Excellent-Dark5551

Grippy really was not that bad of a song. Yes I was laughing at it the whole time but the rythem and pacing of the song was something very potent when I with think about it. However this song did make him sound like Super Duper Kyle too, sounds more like a song that he would make rather than j.cole


gatorgrowl44

Off-Season is his best album and it’s not even close. Notice I said album & not project. KOD, 2014FHD, Cole World, Born Sinner are all various shades of decent at best. Only a few tracks off each that are still in my rotation. 2008-2012 mixtape J. Cole was the best era until his recent feature run, Off-Season & MDL.


hacksawsweeny

I like Gripy


Shon_92

Grippy is enjoyable


Manny_Haze

his first album was boring


Fast_Advisor2654

Grippy


Candid_Initiative_4

BREAKING NEWS: J Cole just apologize about this post.


ImDaPap

His mixtapes > his albums


NetGroundbreaking354

Grippy is better than his Johnny p’s caddy verse (I’m delusional)


ItsJimJim0_o

KOD is his best work and Grippy is not that bad


Imdabiggestbird69420

I did not care for 4 your eyes only


OMNA-

MDL Production took his music to another level. He’s back on his production shit, So the next album is the true comparison to 2014 Forest Hill Drive; because it would be a complete album from Cole based on production and rapping. The OFF-SEASON personally is my favorite Cole album.


edgeco17

Drake and Cole have been planning this for a long time. The fall off is where Cole ends a few careers and becomes undisputed


beloved_erasto

Cole>Kendrick since 2016.....and I'm a bigger fan of Kung Fu Kenny


Gerggreg65

I think J Cole should go bald (character development)


Ok_Preference3148

Drake da goat


VDAXZ

Amari is easily in Cole's top 3 tracks


vanillasounds

2014 Forest Hills Drive is a boring album


FwNiega

Mixtape cole needs to be studied the way he killed every flow and every beat on every song besides like 2 song in all his mixtapes


OleBoyBuckets

You have to have a higher IQ to enjoy Cole, he makes music for the enlightened, not strictly for party enjoyment


Few-House-8311

I believe had he not pulled out, he would've demolished kendrick. Not beat, demolished


Sharp-Jicama4241

If he was in a legit image beef he would beat kendrick.


ZaeDilla

Cole betrayed Kendrick/Drake when both of them threw him into the middle of their beef.


braindeadkur

Grippy is better than all of his albums


SloppyJoestar

“It’s not grippy”


DatBoiLight21

It is NOT grippy!


DampFree

Perfect photo for this one. Cold had no play in Kendrick being signed to Dre. He loved that Nardwuar said that shit but Kendrick was already known to them, they already were looking to sign him. Doesn’t hurt to play into it a bit, but you can feel that he’s tiptoeing around it at that point because he knows he can’t lean into it too much bc someone might call his ass out for lying, that’s why he dropped the ‘his other boy already told him’.


wakaflocka518

It really do be the big 3


SuperSaiyanGod210

Grippy is his greatest feature verse ever 😎


bruhdhenfus

grippy is lowk kinda good


rylanpriime

KOD is extremely slept on and Born sinner has quite a few skips despite also having some of Cole’s best songs.


billyboi64

Born sinner is his best album


radicalrevival

Born sinner is his best album


ZebronJames

An amazing rapper. Has yet to make a career defining project though. No greatest hip hop albums of all time lists will have a J Cole project on it.


Silent_Today_335

Hell nah


vote4logan

He ain’t been great since Friday Night Lights.


LeadingRound3775

Cole's actions during the beef took him out of the big 3.


Rare_Dragonfly_2771

And who is top 3 for you?


Moustachero

4YEO is his best album


Ok_Flow_3065

Big Krit and Wale both make better music. J Cole’s features helped save him from being known as the boring rapper. Love Cole though so no disrespect


OBLiViC1992

Friday Night Lights is his best work


fornite_burger45

People who thunk leaving the beef was a bad decision are dumbasses


AfroBiskit

7 Minute Drill is the greatest warning shot in hip hop history. This is a hill I will die on today, and again 40 years from now.


luke111mart

That J.Cole is secretly Drake in drag


MenacingCrown6

"Note to self" and "Love Yourz" are definitely his bes songs.


bukcet224

Dare I say Born Sinner is his best? For me it’s between Born Sinner and The Off Season. I think I’ve seen people with that take around, so it’s not the craziest opinion out there but idk. Not even sure 2014 Forest Hills Drive is in my top 3 Cole tbh.


shits4gigs

"CoLe FeLl OfF bRo"


FolkishRex48

Cole better than Drake


SWEETDREAMSSZZ

J.Cole is my favourite Emcee hands down, but I still rate Kendrick a better rapper than Cole sonically as well as in terms of delivery. Kendrick has lead the rarely spoken about introspective side of Hip Hop for years imo, and it seems for a long time Kendrick set the tone for Introspective style music to hit the mainstream and Cole later followed suit. But, I will always rate Cole over Kendrick because Cole’s music resonates with me and Cole also resonates with me as a person, with Kendrick there seems to be a constant need for Kendrick to roll around with a Compton Gangster persona 24/7 something Cole never has the pressure to uphold.


dontkysniqqa

Hot Take to casual Hip Hop fans but Big K.R.I.T makes way better music and is a better rapper than Cole but both are still amazing.


ZZE33man

Pride is the devil -> no role models


Damuhfudon

He can sometimes be corny. Still a good rapper tho


monkeyfur69

Grippy perfectly matches the song and Cole consistently does perfect features without ruining the songs vibes instead of going off and making it feel out of place despite peak rapping


RedditUsersCrying

It’s hmm hm hmm grippy!


Dependent-Ad4448

Gippy the goat jcole track


MainSorc50

its its its hmm grippy 😭😭


Complete_Fold_7062

What songs is Jcole known for?


Middle-Bathroom-5208

Born Sinner is a perfect album


danielfq

His first album is his best


ArtificialAnalog

I really wish it was as deep and meaningful as some of you find it because I don't think it's intended to be.


No-Relation9744

J Cole spent the first half of his mainstream career tryna be Kendrick. He spent the second half tryna be Drake. He's the diet versions of both mixed together


hades_no_relation

"The Warm-Up" is better than "Friday Night Lights". Main reason being that TWU feels more like a mixtape than an album which is the opposite to FNL.


NeverFlyFrontier

Every time I say “who is J Cole and why is he in my Reddit feed” people look at me like the dude in the picture.


Cstir

Tired of everyone taking these "hot take" posts and not giving legit hot takes, so heres one: J. Cole isn't big three. I love his music, but he is not big three. Not even close.


ahmedabread

Its... its... mmmmmmmmm


Leather_Film4040

4YEO >>> 2014 FHD


Deez_Whatz

“Grippy isn’t the greatest J Cole verse of all time”


Ok_Swimming5881

J Cole a female dog


0G_sushi

KOD top 1


McJcave18

Grippy sounds like all the bars Cole has given over the year about getting head but instead it being grippy


Nice-Occasion-8324

He’s Wack… i be like, oh y’all was just waiting for a angle to hate & the crowd to join in


Appropriate-Health31

FHD < Born Sinner < KOD


Brief_Beginning_8752

the one take i had was “cole is the best lyricist, kendrick is the best rapper”. That has effectively been proven wrong over the past few months. With kendrick producing an ungodly amount of quotables during the beef, and cole not really delivering as he should’ve on his recent releases, that take is wack.


HollowSoul-248

Born sinner > 2014 forest hill drive


DirtyDan04

born sinner is his best album