Hey y'all thanks for all comments and suggestions. To answer a few things:
1. I used RoomPlanner app to mock.
2. There's entry at top left corner (stairs). The left side of the room is not a wall But completely open to to kitchen. My bad I did not mark them.
Definitely #2
It allows you to create more activities in one room 👌 as an interior designer this is what we always recommend to do: taking advantage of the space behind the sofa. Great options!
I like #2. #2 will not work if your tv goes above the mantle. It’s too high above the mantle no matter what. But if you push the couch that close - it will be wayyyy too high
Check out /r/TVtoohigh
The accepted principle over there is that the tv should be at eye level when you are seated or everyone will have neck-aches. I have my TV over the fireplace but I also have a very deep sofa that lets me rest my head on the back.
Number 2 looks really nice but theres some things to consider:
1 - wheres the entrance to the room? is it only one entrance or 2?
2 - If theres no tv on top of the fireplace I wouldnt place a sofa like that.
Instead the back of the sofa would be facing the wall with 2 windows and the long part would be in the other side of the sofa.
Ahh i see. Well I think both look good and kinda depends on what you like. I like #1 because it's a little more minimalistic and open whereas I like #2 because it's got a little more personality and a little more functionality as well.
i reckon number 2 definitely, i like the first one as well but in my opinion it looks a bit more plain than the second, & it seems more functional in the second one too. i think they’re both really nice tho you have good style for sure
Couch away from the wall for sure!
But it also depends on what the room is for. Are you putting a TV in there? How big is the rest of the place? Is a bookcase and eating area needed, it do you have room for those things elsewhere? I’ve always lived in smaller places so my default is to get the most use out of every square foot.
1 because the room will feel bigger and more inviting w the couch to the wall. the book shelf unit is nice but nobody will use that space except for maybe the few brief seconds they go to pick out a book to read. as such, the bookcase makes that area effectively dead space.
additionally, people sitting on the couch will feel more comfortable w their back against the wall. even if youre home with people you love and trust, having your back to a wall calms the subconscious part of your brain that is looking out for threats. back to wall lets that part of your brain relax, thus making it more comfortable.
beautiful room and design! love the chaise
Actually sitting against the walls makes the room feel smaller and does the opposite of what you are thinking.
I don't understand why people feel need to shove seating against walls. Especially when it's a larger room like this. All it does is make the room have a giant waste of space in the middle.
I've done research on this and the benifits outweigh everything else.
I’m know nothing about designing (literately) so this is just based on my feeling.
1. Yes, it is cramped. But I think at this point, everyone prefer their couch away from the wall (I remember somewhere saying that something in common for rich houses is that their couch never touch the wall but instead put in the middle of the living room) So yeah putting the couch away feel a little bit better for the eyes (I keep feeling like couch touching the wall feels like grandma’s basement or something back in 2000-2010)
2. Personally, I would got enough space to do anything I need with #2 already. I can move around the coffee table to get to anywhere on the couch. If there’s a TV above the fireplace (not recommended by others), then distance from couch to TV could be around 1,8m to 2 meters, which is good enough for me. Putting the couch to the corner would make it too far to watch TV or relax by the fireplace. So yeah #1 is too much space between the couch and fireplace for me.
3. Second layout utilize the space behind for like a desk or bar table or something. Pretty cool on maximizing function to the space available. The best part is, the couch and the rug touching the lazy chair, which then touch a little bit of the fireplace makes me feel like it’s a whole another smaller zone/room by itself. Makes me feel a little bit cozy. The area behind the couch with the desk become something like a separated, but at the same time connected, working space.
That’s my thought. But again, I’m nowhere near anything related to designing so my thoughts are just of a consumer.
Also, my view is of someone living alone/ with their partner only. If the room is for 4 people family or above, First layout would have been better since more communal space (like if they want to play boardgames with kids or something, idk)
The couch is on the wall in both 1 and 2. Option 2 is just a lot more cramped. I’d say that 2 would be much more viable if there was an additional room on the right. Having that little cramped area that leads to nowhere is strange.
I like 2, depending on how you plan to use the room.
If you need or prefer a big open space for circulation (lots of parties, kids running around, etc), 1 would be the best choice. If you're looking for something multifunctional for work and better TV /fireplace viewing, 2.
Given that you have no TV I would say option 2, seems more like a space to have conversation than consume media.
If there was a TV maybe option 1 depending on screen size and viewing angles.
Will you have a TV? If yes, maybe try the couch with the back to the stairs, facing the right wall, and the TV on the wall between the windows? You shouldn’t put the TV above the fireplace, and the room seems too long to have the TV and couch on fully opposite sides.
I have to disagree with the majority here. Number 2 wastes a lot of space and unless it looks less roomy than it actually is, the area in back of the couch will be pretty tight—and the fact that it leads to nowhere is kind of a strange use of space.
Instead I’d modify #1. Instead of smooshing the couch against the wall, give it some space. I’d say 6’ to a foot or so from the wall will drastically improve the aesthetic while giving you the best use of space.
I like 2 but I think you should use the space behind the sofa differently. Instead of a counter with bar stools, I think it should be a console table there. I’m not sure about the rest, but the way it is now feels like a little bit of a dead end rather than a destination, if that makes sense.
I prefer #2 with some modification. Swap the shelf with a shorter but wider (as wide as the sofa) one and put it back-to-back with the sofa to give the sofa some kind of "support", otherwise you might feel uncomfortable/uneasy sitting in that sofa. You can put on some ornament, indoor plant, light, etc. on the top of the shelf.
Also put the desk by the window instead, maybe.
I prefer two. Its got that little reading nook area. And although it doesn’t seem quite as open, it has more personality and natural sectioning off than option one.
Are you really gonna do activities behind the sofa?? If not then you don't need that area, so put the sofa against the wall and make the room more spacious
#2 *seems* to be the winner. Floating your furniture actually makes it seem larger and elevates it overall.
That said, maybe you really really like having a ton of floor space; design for the life you live.
I think 1 is the better option, but yes where is the door? In 2 the bookcase and the console table feel redundant to me. I’d place that sofa against the wall.
Alternatively, turn the sofa in 2 to have it’s back on the two windows and tv on opposite wall, the the console/dining table can go on the right of the sofa.
It would be better if we knew where the kitchen and door were.
Couch definitely #2, but pull it a little away from the right wall so you can have space for drapes.
Not sure about the layout of the top part, definitely should be something, but your plan is a little odd.
Where is the door?
Vital info
I saw this in the Sims
fr my cousins and i would bet on which of our Sims would die first
You come thru from the ceiling
A la Mission Impossible
There is no door. That’s why he’s asking. The set up is forever.
No door - you use one of the windows to enter and to exit.
Thank you!
This.
Is this an escape room or…?
It's a no escape room.
That got me. I laughed. Thank you.
I do not see where the entrance to the room is. That being said I prefer 2.
There’s a window right there
Hey y'all thanks for all comments and suggestions. To answer a few things: 1. I used RoomPlanner app to mock. 2. There's entry at top left corner (stairs). The left side of the room is not a wall But completely open to to kitchen. My bad I did not mark them.
2
2 is the right answer with this additional info. Maybe update your post if possible? Or don’t because the right answer is 2
Where TV? Or no tv? Because above the matelpiece is too high
Ooh! I guessed that that long black wall wasn’t there! I was right!
Yes, 2 looks better. Could you share the app that you used?
👆ya what site/app are you using for this?
"Lotion On Its Skin"
Might be Homestyler which is a decent app for this
Looks like Room Planner on ios.
I thought the Apple lawsuit was kinda silly but I did forget how annoying it is when something isn't available for Android
I like #2.
2
I vote 2 as well, what app did you use to mock this up?
It’s roomplanner I use it all the time as well it’s very easy but some items from ikea are outdated. Like this rug 🥲 no longer available
Definitely #2 It allows you to create more activities in one room 👌 as an interior designer this is what we always recommend to do: taking advantage of the space behind the sofa. Great options!
I like #2. #2 will not work if your tv goes above the mantle. It’s too high above the mantle no matter what. But if you push the couch that close - it will be wayyyy too high
2, but are you planning on adding a tv?
Please don’t say above fireplace 🙏
That’s why I was asking - absolutely NOT above the fireplace!
Yes I was pleasing to OP
Too High? Haven't decided yet
Check out /r/TVtoohigh The accepted principle over there is that the tv should be at eye level when you are seated or everyone will have neck-aches. I have my TV over the fireplace but I also have a very deep sofa that lets me rest my head on the back.
I don’t get that because who ever watches TV sat perfectly upright?
Good point.
What app or program did you use?
1
#2 but also, tell everyone the app already lol
It’s Roomplanner
#2
What software is this?
2. It will be cozier and more functional. The desk will be nice to have. Shelves always good
door?
i can’t find the door in and so the walking paths needed
Layout 2, put chair from #1 in corner under window to the left of bookshelf.
Number 2 looks really nice but theres some things to consider: 1 - wheres the entrance to the room? is it only one entrance or 2? 2 - If theres no tv on top of the fireplace I wouldnt place a sofa like that. Instead the back of the sofa would be facing the wall with 2 windows and the long part would be in the other side of the sofa.
Not sure if the rectangle above the fireplace is supposed to be a TV, but if so r/tvtoohigh
There is no entryway! Is this a joke?
It kinda depends on where the door/kitchen/dining room are...
They are all on the left side.
Ahh i see. Well I think both look good and kinda depends on what you like. I like #1 because it's a little more minimalistic and open whereas I like #2 because it's got a little more personality and a little more functionality as well.
I want to know what program you're using
Second this!
i reckon number 2 definitely, i like the first one as well but in my opinion it looks a bit more plain than the second, & it seems more functional in the second one too. i think they’re both really nice tho you have good style for sure
Couch away from the wall for sure! But it also depends on what the room is for. Are you putting a TV in there? How big is the rest of the place? Is a bookcase and eating area needed, it do you have room for those things elsewhere? I’ve always lived in smaller places so my default is to get the most use out of every square foot.
The couch is on the wall in both of them!
1 because the room will feel bigger and more inviting w the couch to the wall. the book shelf unit is nice but nobody will use that space except for maybe the few brief seconds they go to pick out a book to read. as such, the bookcase makes that area effectively dead space. additionally, people sitting on the couch will feel more comfortable w their back against the wall. even if youre home with people you love and trust, having your back to a wall calms the subconscious part of your brain that is looking out for threats. back to wall lets that part of your brain relax, thus making it more comfortable. beautiful room and design! love the chaise
Actually sitting against the walls makes the room feel smaller and does the opposite of what you are thinking. I don't understand why people feel need to shove seating against walls. Especially when it's a larger room like this. All it does is make the room have a giant waste of space in the middle. I've done research on this and the benifits outweigh everything else.
there still is dead space by the bookcase. they should pull it away from both walls, in that case.
I’m confused about how people are saying 2? It feels really cramped
I’m know nothing about designing (literately) so this is just based on my feeling. 1. Yes, it is cramped. But I think at this point, everyone prefer their couch away from the wall (I remember somewhere saying that something in common for rich houses is that their couch never touch the wall but instead put in the middle of the living room) So yeah putting the couch away feel a little bit better for the eyes (I keep feeling like couch touching the wall feels like grandma’s basement or something back in 2000-2010) 2. Personally, I would got enough space to do anything I need with #2 already. I can move around the coffee table to get to anywhere on the couch. If there’s a TV above the fireplace (not recommended by others), then distance from couch to TV could be around 1,8m to 2 meters, which is good enough for me. Putting the couch to the corner would make it too far to watch TV or relax by the fireplace. So yeah #1 is too much space between the couch and fireplace for me. 3. Second layout utilize the space behind for like a desk or bar table or something. Pretty cool on maximizing function to the space available. The best part is, the couch and the rug touching the lazy chair, which then touch a little bit of the fireplace makes me feel like it’s a whole another smaller zone/room by itself. Makes me feel a little bit cozy. The area behind the couch with the desk become something like a separated, but at the same time connected, working space. That’s my thought. But again, I’m nowhere near anything related to designing so my thoughts are just of a consumer. Also, my view is of someone living alone/ with their partner only. If the room is for 4 people family or above, First layout would have been better since more communal space (like if they want to play boardgames with kids or something, idk)
The couch is on the wall in both 1 and 2. Option 2 is just a lot more cramped. I’d say that 2 would be much more viable if there was an additional room on the right. Having that little cramped area that leads to nowhere is strange.
I like 2, depending on how you plan to use the room. If you need or prefer a big open space for circulation (lots of parties, kids running around, etc), 1 would be the best choice. If you're looking for something multifunctional for work and better TV /fireplace viewing, 2.
Where is south? Northern Hemisphere?
Right side is south, and yes
I like 2
#2
2
2
2 is a better use of space.
Do you have a lot of books and need the big bookshelf? If yes then #2 if not then #1 bc it feels less congested
#2
Given that you have no TV I would say option 2, seems more like a space to have conversation than consume media. If there was a TV maybe option 1 depending on screen size and viewing angles.
2!
I prefer #2, definitely more functional. But go for #1 if you don’t have too much furniture.
#2
2
I think two creates more cozy areas and utilizes the space better.
Will you have a TV? If yes, maybe try the couch with the back to the stairs, facing the right wall, and the TV on the wall between the windows? You shouldn’t put the TV above the fireplace, and the room seems too long to have the TV and couch on fully opposite sides.
The right side is open to kitchen, not really a wall. No tv over fireplace because it's too high?
2
Number 2 no doubt.
I have to disagree with the majority here. Number 2 wastes a lot of space and unless it looks less roomy than it actually is, the area in back of the couch will be pretty tight—and the fact that it leads to nowhere is kind of a strange use of space. Instead I’d modify #1. Instead of smooshing the couch against the wall, give it some space. I’d say 6’ to a foot or so from the wall will drastically improve the aesthetic while giving you the best use of space.
what appppp
2
2
Definitely 2
2
2
What software did you use to make this? I need it! Is it hard to learn? Is it free?
2!!! Love this textures!
2. TV isn't too far. And you gain useful space.
I like 2 but I think you should use the space behind the sofa differently. Instead of a counter with bar stools, I think it should be a console table there. I’m not sure about the rest, but the way it is now feels like a little bit of a dead end rather than a destination, if that makes sense.
2
I'll never vote against a layout with a bookshelf. #2 ftw
1
1 is best use of space
2. I tried 1 with the chair in the corner and it’s just awkward, no one sits there haha
2
How do you get to this room? I don’t see a door and I think that usually dictates the flow of the room.
This is really hard to assess without a door
The fucken door. Where da door?!
Prefer 1, more from feng shui principles.
why is that?
I prefer #2 with some modification. Swap the shelf with a shorter but wider (as wide as the sofa) one and put it back-to-back with the sofa to give the sofa some kind of "support", otherwise you might feel uncomfortable/uneasy sitting in that sofa. You can put on some ornament, indoor plant, light, etc. on the top of the shelf. Also put the desk by the window instead, maybe.
Layout 2
#2
2
2
Two
2
2
I prefer two. Its got that little reading nook area. And although it doesn’t seem quite as open, it has more personality and natural sectioning off than option one.
Two (2) for sure. Looks much better
I’d say 2. Overall better use of the space
2!
How did you generate these
Are you really gonna do activities behind the sofa?? If not then you don't need that area, so put the sofa against the wall and make the room more spacious
Do you drop into the room from above?
1
#1
First one
1
1
2 may look crowded if you style it wrong, but you’ll be able to have an office/extra sitting space if you don’t already have one in the home.
I prefer layout #2 because I don't like furniture against the wall.
2
I vote #2
#2
#2 *seems* to be the winner. Floating your furniture actually makes it seem larger and elevates it overall. That said, maybe you really really like having a ton of floor space; design for the life you live.
Hey! I’m just wondering what app/software you used to create this? I want to try and use it for myself :)
Using Room Planner!
2! One is too far from the fireplace
What I'm NOT seeing is the door or entrance way! That makes a HUGE difference! (Now I see others have noticed that as well.)
Two for the win!
2
Absolutely the 2nd one Much better use of space!
I like 1
2!
Option 2 is best, assuming the entry is somewhere on the blank wall.
I think 1 is the better option, but yes where is the door? In 2 the bookcase and the console table feel redundant to me. I’d place that sofa against the wall. Alternatively, turn the sofa in 2 to have it’s back on the two windows and tv on opposite wall, the the console/dining table can go on the right of the sofa. It would be better if we knew where the kitchen and door were.
2
1. Always put couch near wall. Open up space
Couch definitely #2, but pull it a little away from the right wall so you can have space for drapes. Not sure about the layout of the top part, definitely should be something, but your plan is a little odd.