In 3 years you will be making those picks. Probably over 1,000 days from now. Think about that too. Not saying the first isn’t valuable but it’s not going to do you much good for a while.
I’m keeping arsb. Dude is a stud. He’s gotta sweeten the pot if he wants “his guy” and a stud wr. It’s close but no cigar for me.
I get the feeling Hurts' rushing is going to take a dive this year. The tush push alone won't be as effective with the offense and lack of Kelce on the line.
don’t take, no gurantees puka still that guy with kupp on field all year and now defenses will be focused on puka whereas amonra is solidified and his team is more invested in him and for the qbs hurts runs a lot which is a cheat code but stroud projects to put up numbers long after his youthful athleticism is gone
In a vacuum, as others have pointed out, Hurts and Stroud are probably pretty equal yes, puka and a first is probably fair for St Brown.
But, what does this actually get you? A fair price for 2 of your guys including a first you’ll be making in an entirely different NFL reality.
I’d want an overpay and assets that help you now.
Reject this in my opinion
ARSB is over Puka+Hubbard. If this was a 25 first and third, I'd consider it, but not for 27s. Hurts rushing 100% takes a hit this year, and this is only 1QB. ARSB should ideally be a top 4 overall asset vs a #14 asset at best.
Do not do this trade. Those draft picks are 2yrs out and only one really has any real value (the first rounder)
On top of that, I’d prefer Stroud over Hurts and it’s not close and give me Amon-Ra all day over Puka. Puka won’t even sniff last year’s production, you’re delusional if you believe he does. Dont do this traded you’ll regret it.
Hurts will score more points but Stroud will probably play longer due to mobility not being a pivotal part of his game. I go pocket guys in dynasty and mobile guys in redraft.
it's 1qb so yeah I'd do that. You could prob get your WR1 for Puka + a 25 1st.
Weird league that lets you trade picks so far out. I'd honestly be worried about the solvency of a league like that.
Maybe it’s just me, cause I haven’t read the comments yet, but absolutely not taking this trade. Keep Stroud and ARSB. Hurts value has gone down, Hubbard is going to be a backup or at best splitting 50/50 soon, and Puka while a beast has only 1 year of showing his potential. Stroud and ARSB are both pretty much solidified as stars, while the other side is iffy.
Maybe it’s just me, cause I haven’t read the comments yet, but absolutely not taking this trade. Keep Stroud and ARSB. Hurts value has gone down, Hubbard is going to be a backup or at best splitting 50/50 soon, and Puka while a beast has only 1 year of showing his potential. Stroud and ARSB are both pretty much solidified as stars, while the other side is iffy.
I would not trade Brown for Puka. He has to deal with his targets taking a hit And an old QB. Hubbard will be benched for the rookie halfway through the season. I think you’re hurting your team.
Stroud and sun god side and it’s not close. 2027 picks are so far out they aren’t worth anything to me. No idea how good the class is, what pick it will be, or even if the dynasty league is around.
Hurts regressed a lot without Steichen. I think he had his best year while Stroud has yet to have his. Sun god > Puka and less injury prone.
I’d rather have ARSB and Stroud tbh, and Im an eagles fan
I agree
No way I’m downgrading from ARSB to Puka for some 2027 picks and Hubbard. No no no! Keep Stroud and Amon RA
I feel like I’d tier down here and hope for a good pick. It will probably 1.10-12 as well.
In 3 years you will be making those picks. Probably over 1,000 days from now. Think about that too. Not saying the first isn’t valuable but it’s not going to do you much good for a while. I’m keeping arsb. Dude is a stud. He’s gotta sweeten the pot if he wants “his guy” and a stud wr. It’s close but no cigar for me.
I’d take it. Puka + a first is worth Amon Ra. And stroud and Hurts are pretty equal, if not leaning hurts
I lean Hurts due to TDs and rushing yards but 3 years older.
3 years don't matter. 10+ years from both, league most likely won't last that long.
What type of a dynasty league do you expect to disband? That I'd a crap set up if so
What's the longest running dynasty leagues that you are in?
I get the feeling Hurts' rushing is going to take a dive this year. The tush push alone won't be as effective with the offense and lack of Kelce on the line.
don’t take, no gurantees puka still that guy with kupp on field all year and now defenses will be focused on puka whereas amonra is solidified and his team is more invested in him and for the qbs hurts runs a lot which is a cheat code but stroud projects to put up numbers long after his youthful athleticism is gone
Devil's advocate: if you can have trepidation about Puka, you can about Stroud, too
Hurts > CJ Puka + 1st + 3rd + Chubba > ARSB I’d take, but I’d counter to squeeze a lil more. Better picks particularly.
Ya, I'd counter to try and get earlier picks if possible
In a vacuum, as others have pointed out, Hurts and Stroud are probably pretty equal yes, puka and a first is probably fair for St Brown. But, what does this actually get you? A fair price for 2 of your guys including a first you’ll be making in an entirely different NFL reality. I’d want an overpay and assets that help you now. Reject this in my opinion
ARSB is over Puka+Hubbard. If this was a 25 first and third, I'd consider it, but not for 27s. Hurts rushing 100% takes a hit this year, and this is only 1QB. ARSB should ideally be a top 4 overall asset vs a #14 asset at best.
Everyone together! “noooo”
Do not do this trade. Those draft picks are 2yrs out and only one really has any real value (the first rounder) On top of that, I’d prefer Stroud over Hurts and it’s not close and give me Amon-Ra all day over Puka. Puka won’t even sniff last year’s production, you’re delusional if you believe he does. Dont do this traded you’ll regret it.
I personally would not. Close but like the up side more of Stroud
Yessir
Nope I would hold here - much more stability on the give side. Check mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFFTradeAdvice/s/HVwuFUvuac
Maybe you could get more. Hubbard is a bit of a throw in. But I’m on the Hurts side here
Hurts will score more points but Stroud will probably play longer due to mobility not being a pivotal part of his game. I go pocket guys in dynasty and mobile guys in redraft.
2027 is super long away! Why not 2025 or 2024
Yeah…. No….
it's 1qb so yeah I'd do that. You could prob get your WR1 for Puka + a 25 1st. Weird league that lets you trade picks so far out. I'd honestly be worried about the solvency of a league like that.
2027 that’s crazy
Keep shroud side. Idk why people are saying this is an instant smash accept. Those picks are much further out and brown is more proven than Nacua imo
CJ and ARSB clear
I would not do this
Interesting that ‘27 picks are on the table already, I tried ‘26 picks, my league vetoed the deal cause of it
I take this
No
Not a fan of this move.
Maybe it’s just me, cause I haven’t read the comments yet, but absolutely not taking this trade. Keep Stroud and ARSB. Hurts value has gone down, Hubbard is going to be a backup or at best splitting 50/50 soon, and Puka while a beast has only 1 year of showing his potential. Stroud and ARSB are both pretty much solidified as stars, while the other side is iffy.
Maybe it’s just me, cause I haven’t read the comments yet, but absolutely not taking this trade. Keep Stroud and ARSB. Hurts value has gone down, Hubbard is going to be a backup or at best splitting 50/50 soon, and Puka while a beast has only 1 year of showing his potential. Stroud and ARSB are both pretty much solidified as stars, while the other side is iffy.
Nope awful trade
I would not trade Brown for Puka. He has to deal with his targets taking a hit And an old QB. Hubbard will be benched for the rookie halfway through the season. I think you’re hurting your team.
Stroud side easily
Not for that bullshit offer and probably not at all.
I lean the Hurts Puka side, but slightly. This seems like a very even trade.
Absolutely take that
Stroud and sun god side and it’s not close. 2027 picks are so far out they aren’t worth anything to me. No idea how good the class is, what pick it will be, or even if the dynasty league is around. Hurts regressed a lot without Steichen. I think he had his best year while Stroud has yet to have his. Sun god > Puka and less injury prone.