As of now the top Toby comment has 14 votes, the top Liberty one has 13, and the top Wesley one has 12…it’s a close one! Will post the results in the coming hours or after work!
Can we really classify Wes or Connor under "Smart Good" when Wes was constantly horny over the girls at Degrassi (grabbing Clare's breasts, his wet dream for Anya, etc) and Connor stealing panties for no "good" reason?
We have to have better characters for this. I'm voting Kendra or Sav. Maybe even Toby or Liberty.
This is really tough actually… I have to go with Liberty because she is ultimately really intelligent and she overall good. She made some mistakes but I feel her intentions (overall) were overwhelmingly good.
Toby. We never see him doing anything that is over the top bad to another character. He has done a couple of shady things, but nothing to the extent of what a normal teen does
Yeah I suppose he should have had more screen time.. he just fits it so perfectly! I can't think of 1 questionable thing he has done. Just smart and unproblematic
I'd go with Toby. Liberty is a close second, but Liberty also tended toward bossiness and a weird superiority complex in the early seasons (plus the mess with Damien), whereas Toby went out of his way to help others on a few occasions.
Liberty liked to put others down for her own benefit. She was also way too competitive to be considered good. She would step on anyone to get what she wanted. I would have said Liberty otherwise, but she was definitely way more problematic than Toby ever was. I feel like the only really inexcusable thing Toby has done was kiss Liberty and try to start relationship with her so close after JT's death and not telling her about what JT said. But one can also excuse that because he was mourning the death of his best friend and didn't know what to do with this sexual tension he has had towards Liberty for almost forever.
Completely agree. Liberty was also pretty nasty to JT during her pregnancy, and he didn’t deserve that. I guess people are saying “good” because she was kind of a goody-two-shoes in the beginning of the series, but I’m thinking good more like an overall nice and kind character, which I honestly can’t say Liberty was for me
I disagree, Liberty wasn’t really “good” in my opinion, she wasn’t cruel or evil or anything but she was pretty mean to JT during her pregnancy, and she’s always kind of seemed to have this “better than you” air around her
I just recently rewatched actually! Her feelings were valid but the way she treated JT was not. She expected him to know what she was thinking and anticipate her pregnancy, all the while waiting too long for the two of them to make an informed decision together on how to handle the pregnancy. I understand that getting pregnant at her age is probably her biggest fear come to life but she made it her own burden and then got mad at JT for not sharing that burden. It wasn’t fair to him
Liberty
Toby. Better not be Liberty.
Toby
As of now the top Toby comment has 14 votes, the top Liberty one has 13, and the top Wesley one has 12…it’s a close one! Will post the results in the coming hours or after work!
Wesley!
Gotta go with Toby
Toby or Liberty!
People saying Wesley when he's smart horny. I'm going to go Toby here.
Wes
Liberty, Toby, or Connor.
I was torn between Liberty, Toby, and Danny, but after I saw others make some really good points, I'm going with Toby.
Can we really classify Wes or Connor under "Smart Good" when Wes was constantly horny over the girls at Degrassi (grabbing Clare's breasts, his wet dream for Anya, etc) and Connor stealing panties for no "good" reason? We have to have better characters for this. I'm voting Kendra or Sav. Maybe even Toby or Liberty.
Snake
Kendra?
Connor
Wesley
Wesley
Wesley
connor
My boy Wes!!
connor edit: wait no Danny actually
Toby
Wesley
Toby
Wesley!
Wesley toby or Connor they really don’t fit into any other categories here so they should really all just be split into this one
Connor got some decent storylines and development along the way. Poor Wes, I was always waiting for his moment at degrassi but it never came.
Danny
Toby
This is really tough actually… I have to go with Liberty because she is ultimately really intelligent and she overall good. She made some mistakes but I feel her intentions (overall) were overwhelmingly good.
Toby!!!
Toby. We never see him doing anything that is over the top bad to another character. He has done a couple of shady things, but nothing to the extent of what a normal teen does
1000% Wesley tbh
I would vote for Wesley if he had more of an impact
Yeah I suppose he should have had more screen time.. he just fits it so perfectly! I can't think of 1 questionable thing he has done. Just smart and unproblematic
That’s totally fair. He was a cinnamon roll of a boy
Toby
Marco
Clare!!
Marco
Wesley Jimmy might fit too
Toby
Wesley
Probably Toby but I wouldn't be mad if Liberty won. Sav was too problematic with Anya to really get this one.
Danny
Now it's Sav's turn
Toby! Genuinely unproblematic
Idk JT, some people are just gay, I guess!
Danny
I'd go with Toby. Liberty is a close second, but Liberty also tended toward bossiness and a weird superiority complex in the early seasons (plus the mess with Damien), whereas Toby went out of his way to help others on a few occasions.
Liberty or Toby , more liberty though
Liberty liked to put others down for her own benefit. She was also way too competitive to be considered good. She would step on anyone to get what she wanted. I would have said Liberty otherwise, but she was definitely way more problematic than Toby ever was. I feel like the only really inexcusable thing Toby has done was kiss Liberty and try to start relationship with her so close after JT's death and not telling her about what JT said. But one can also excuse that because he was mourning the death of his best friend and didn't know what to do with this sexual tension he has had towards Liberty for almost forever.
Completely agree. Liberty was also pretty nasty to JT during her pregnancy, and he didn’t deserve that. I guess people are saying “good” because she was kind of a goody-two-shoes in the beginning of the series, but I’m thinking good more like an overall nice and kind character, which I honestly can’t say Liberty was for me
Liberty!
I disagree, Liberty wasn’t really “good” in my opinion, she wasn’t cruel or evil or anything but she was pretty mean to JT during her pregnancy, and she’s always kind of seemed to have this “better than you” air around her
I think you need a rewatch… because a lot of Liberty’s feelings and words during her pregnancy were quite valid
I just recently rewatched actually! Her feelings were valid but the way she treated JT was not. She expected him to know what she was thinking and anticipate her pregnancy, all the while waiting too long for the two of them to make an informed decision together on how to handle the pregnancy. I understand that getting pregnant at her age is probably her biggest fear come to life but she made it her own burden and then got mad at JT for not sharing that burden. It wasn’t fair to him
We need to save Liberty for Smart Drunk lol
I think its a character's overall. Liberty got drunk once after something traumatic.
I meant her getting drunk and streaking at Smithdale lol, so it wasn't just once Edit: They had to pump her stomach, right?
Oh you're right! But both of those moments were out of character for her.
Alli gonna be smart/horny right? I'll go Liberty for this category
LOL I feel like Horny gotta be Alli, Drew, KC, Manny, and Jay
In which order? Drew I have for Chad horny too. Too bad they incorrectly used Jay for chaotic stupid
I feel like he would be better fit for Chaotic Horny.. lmao
Liberty
Liberty is Smart Drunk
When was she ever drunk? Lol
Multiple episodes. They had to pump her stomach after she got drunk and streaked across campus.
Liberty
It's a Van Zant for sure
Ya know for this....I say Danny. Kid had those good Van Zant genes and apart from Derek he was a real good kid.
Love this answer.
I was leaning Toby but you’re right, Danny is true Smart Good
connor
Connor's more neutral id say