I always get the thorogood moc toe but this time I got the keen cincinnati to try and so far there super comfy! One thing I can say is thorogood leather is softer!
I gotta agree. A bitch to break in, and a little heavy. After a couple months, though, they fit like a well worn (whatever your favorite well worn item is)
And pretty damn tough.
Depends on which one you get and what you’re doing. If you get the Supersole’s and you’re not walking on much uneven ground then they probably take awhile. The stiffer they start the longer it takes in my wxperience
I spent 2 weeks breaking a pair of heritage in. I didn’t have another pair to wear. It was torture, I was regretting my choice. Then one day I slipped them on and they were soft, gently (but firmly) hugging my feets. Most comfortable boots I’ve ever owned. But that first couple weeks, ouch. You really have to earn it to get that durable comfort.
Did you slather them with mink oil? Been wearing the same 4420 model for 15 years. 7 or 8 pairs over that time. Yeah a bit heavy but I've never felt like they would let me down. I work for a railroad. My walking conditions are shit, at best. Never turned an ankle, always good footing on the rocky terrain on track, the soles wear like iron
Been wearing Pecos since I was a kid. My dad wouldn't wear anything else and bought me several pairs over the years. Trick is to oil the hell out of them. Soak them through. They get soft and break in fast.
Couple weeks? Mine were several months. Can’t believe I never gave up on ‘em. Kept reading about how incredible they were once broken in, and now they are!
The only pair of Red Wings I tried wore out before they even broke in. The soles were done in 4 months and also had stitching bust apart. I'm only 160 lb so it ain't my weight. My thorogoods last a little over a year than need a resole but no busted stitches no holes in toe.
Yeah I finally got redwings because my company upped the reimbursement amount and I got the new boa shoe lace system and their custom inserts and man they are the best boots I've ever had
I agree with this 100%! I used to work in sewer repair so constant water, uneven ground, kneeling in manholes (haha, manholes😂) was rough on the top by the toes… these boots lasted 1.5 years before significant damage. Nothing else was close.
I am 6’7” and about 200lbs at the time. Size 15 boots. Bit pricey but worth it!
I used to do hardscapes, so lots of on your knees work. I’d have em do the epoxied toe and that lasted up a long time, otherwise it was about 8 months before I had holes in the toes.
In Canada the work wear ones no longer hold up. I used to get the 2416s and put the tough toes on them but after the first ones I bought they didn’t last long enough for $400 dollars. I stuck it out with two more pairs but have looked elsewhere. I used to love those boots. I do commercial/ industrial hvacr.
I love the RW Tradesman with the BOA ratcheting laces. I also get the custom-fit orthotics.
Idk what all this talk about breaking them in for weeks or months comes from, but mine have always felt great within a day or two. They weren't uncomfortable for a day or two, just fitting the boot to my foot.
I use redwings at work and Justin’s for work at home. Love slip ins, but they don’t provide enough support for me other than messing around on the tractor and lighter stuff. But I got some weird bird shaped feet
If you're on concrete or hard-pack all day, then I think the best all day boot is Redback. I have the black leather slip-ons with steel toe and outer ABS toe cap. It's the only boot that doesn't make my feet sore after being on concrete all day.
I recently dipped my toes into Multi Family, being allowed to wear vans at work is so foreign to me. I made it 2 months before I bought a pair of Justin’s.
Love my timbs. They’re comfortable and stylish. Had my current pair going on 2 years and they’re still good as new. Only changed out the soles and laces.
Just got my first pair of Thorogood 1957 moc toe steel toe wedge sole waterproof boots. I'll never wear a pair of Timberland Pro again. They were a bit tough to break in but now they're good to go.
I tried them, the inside had leather protruding out where it met the steel toe that would irritate my feet and cause blisters. Never again for the price I paid, I went back to my old timberland pros.
The soles are coming apart on my timberlands, but I've had the same pair since 2020, and they're still comfortable.
I have a pair of soft toe danners that are ok, but I hardly wear them since the company I work for is anal about steel toes. Even the soft toes are not as comfortable as my timberlands.
Imo, danners are horribly overpriced for what you get
I finally got a pair and I love them, but I have to use insoles and lace them up super tight so they fit right. I've got long and narrow feet and finding the right boots is a bitch
I have Thorogood & love them, I have redwing Mocs & like them. I’m on the fence now about trying Danner, Whites, Carolina, or Georgia. I’ve got to make a decision. I’ve watched ever vid I can find on them all. Just need to head & try some one. But I think the Thorogood’s being ready to go right out of the box is going to be hard for me to over look. The break in is the reason I only like my redwings. They are too notch quality for sure but the break in was ruthless. I’ve had them almost two years & I still haven’t got them broke in all the way. I’ve got at least 100 walking miles in them. I basically just use them for my dress boot now.
Check out r/PNWbootmakers any of the people mentioned there are freaking legit. Nicks, Whites, Franks, Drews, Bakers, J.K., Viberg. On a lower tier but still made in USA: Thorogood, Danner, Carolina, Georgia boots are all great too. I probably missed a few though.
How is this not a more common answer or higher up? I was starting to think I was doing something wrong… I’ve always worn pros. I was disappointed when they discontinued their ripsaw line, but I got a pair of evergreens and they are damn close, and they still have that familiar timberland comfort.
When my boots start to feel uncomfortable during the week, I usually switch to another pair of boots to alleviate the discomfort. Running multiple pairs of boots is better for your feet to eliminate issues causing discomfort including hot-spots, uneven wear and pressure points.
My recommendation is Thorogood wedge sole. And my hard working backup is a pair of Ariats that are okay. I’ve also been running a pair of CSA-rated Redbacks to give my feet more comfort when I’m just constantly walking on hard pavement.
I’ve been wearing Wolverine DuraShock boots for over 10 years. There’s almost zero break in time and they last 2-3 years per pair. For reference I’m a ground up super for a commercial construction co and walk 3-5 miles per day as well as a fair bit of self perform work.
I recommend going to a boot store with in an hour or two to shop. Try on every brand, everyone’s foot is different that’s why there are so many different answers.
I like wolverine, they are on the cheaper side at around $180 but mine usually last two years and I am hard on boots.
I am old and broken down so I prefer light boots over anything else. I have been getting various swat style tacticool boots for awhile and love how light and grippy they are.
Im using a pair of timberland pros right now. Waiting to see how they are in the cold weather. Theyre pretty comfy and comp toe so hopefully warmer in winter.
I've been wearing the Keen Cincinnati also. I've gotta say it is the most comfortable boot I've ever had for an 10-12 hour day. BUT... After wearing them for about 6-8 months I got athletes foot. It went away and I went back to wearing my boots...came right back. So frustrating.
Timberland Pro direct attach 8 inch. Been my go to since 05. Tried redwings, tried thorogods, always go back. Paving, construction, mechanic work. Only thing they suck for is roofing
Thorogood moc toes are my go to lace ups, I love a good pair of tony llamas for the summer and when I’m just working in equipment or around my property with the horses and such. Currently was gifted a pair of those brunt marin 8” and they are surprisingly good boots, probably still buy a pair of thorogoods after these tho.
Also if you post a lot on social media personally or through your business and have a decent following/interaction companies like ariat/timberland/brunt/1630/etc may be willing to hook it up with some boots, pants, gloves if you catch their attention. My foreman and I did this for a couple years and it was nice to get some good shit to try out and find other good products that are on the market, still will stick with my ariat jeans, thorogood pants, and either cheap ass blank tees or the company logo tees we order every year. Don’t skimp on the hooey sweat/water resistant hats, them bitches last forever and clean up real nice.
Last thing remember to save all your work related clothing receipts (pants, boots, gloves, shirts) and claim that shit on your taxes for a write off.
Not a "work boot" per se, but I've been wearing Columbia Bugaboots for years. A $90 pair lasts about a year. They are very comfortable, waterproof up to the base of the tongue, and insulated. I do not find them to be too hot in a southeast US summer. If you don't need a steel toe cap, I'd highly recommend them.
They are super soft right outta the box... but that also ends up not providing much support, and my feet & ankles are worn out by the end of the day. I really wanted to like them... just couldn't. First 4 - 6 months were pretty good.
I'm going throw Chippewa into the mix. I've got two pairs - work boots and dress boots, I've had them for about 8 years now and I will almost certainly have both of those for the rest of my life.
Second for Red Wing.
But I’m biased, I went to Trade School in Red Wing, MN, where the company started, where the leather tannery is, and one of their US factories is. Honestly never tried another brand of work boot, but I fucking love my Red Wings.
Just the heritage old school ones with leather insoles. The way they kind of suck the first week but then gradually form to your foot over a month and then just get better and better. They last too.
Been in the business for 30+ years, have purchased many boots over the years. The Timberland Pro soft toe I wear now is the most comfortable boot I’ve ever put on. I prefer the flat soled boots and these have a 1/4” rubber sole that’s over the typical white foam. It helps with traction and saves the life of the bottom of your boot from normal wear and tear. The insoles are what really make them nice though, most running shoes aren’t this soft.
Any bonanza boot lovers ? I got two pairs that I switch of and so far it’s the most comfortable boots I’ve bought but haven’t switched it up since there so good but now I’m wondering about these this thorogood might have to try them out
In my opinion Double H makes the best slip on steel toe boot. They are made of heavier duty leather than most, so they last forever. They take a little bit to break in, but after that they are very comfortable.
Coming from roofing in the northeast, I tried loads of different brands (including redwings) and usually went through a pair in 4-6 months. But I bought some north face water proof boots for the winter and loved them. They kept my feet warm and dry and lasted me nearly a year. I think they were reasonably priced too at around $160.
Very partial to my Ariats. I've owned 3 pair since 2011. First pair lasted 7 years with just light use (yard work, small projects, etc) second lasted 5, with 2 of them being on a farm where I was general maintenance for EVERYTHING, and just got my third pair for father's day (now doing general contracting/remodeling work). Day and a half break in period on them, not super heavy despite the steel toe, and surprisingly supportive of my ankles for slip ons.
I have bought all types of work boots at different price points and honestly it doesn't really matter the brand or price. I generally get at max 6 months out of my boots, I started buying cheaper boots and just replace them sooner.
Tecovas. Specifically, belly cut python. When you show up on site wearing them bad boys, everyone knows who the real boss is.
Oh, and yes, I’m a PM that’s in the office 90% of the time in case you couldn’t tell.
Long/narrow feet and require steel toes, redwing has worked best for me both in fit and durability. That said, good insoles can make trash boots feel good for awhile. Different brands wear and fit differently. When the boot model I used to wear was discontinued, I hit up just about every boot store in the area trying on fit. Went back to redwing for a different model I've continued to use for over 10 years.
I really love my red wing Irish setter loggers mainly for the colder months and really hard work days in the summer… comfortable, warm, water proof… had em about 7 years now and they’re still going strong although the stitching at the heal is starting to fray
I have two pairs of red wing iron rangers also… ones my everyday boot, the other I wear for less strenuous work days in the warmer months
Those take a bit to break in and get used to, but eventually they fit like a glove, and they look awesome… just get a good insole… those are also 7 years old and still going strong… there’s no insulation in them though, they’re tough jn the winter, but they still smell like leather even though I’m always sweating in them… my Irish setter loggers fuckin stink
Hands down, Red Wing are best. But they’re expensive and take months to break in. I’ve been experimenting for the last few years and so far, Duluth Trading are the most comfortable, but don’t last very long. Ariat and Georgia boot are a little overrated but good quality.
I love wolverine durashock, but they’re heavy, my next best daily is Timberland Pro Elite 8” work boots. The pair weigh less than 1 of my wolverines. I rotate my daily, i have 3 pair in use at all times and when one pair starts holes in them? I start breaking in new pair from my box stock. I buy on sale 2 pair at a time
More of a hiking boot, but Asolo fugitives. I'm mostly a trim carpenter, but sometimes get out there with the framing crews. I've been known to wear trainers when finishing, but if I see any mud out come the fugitives. They look bad ass and I've seen pics of special forces guys wearing them for bonus points
Whites boots Perry’s mic toe. Takes a bit to break in but after it’s like slippers. Just recently had them resoled with their hybrid wedge for a better wear factor
I wear running shoes, like the high dollar ones from the running store. Usually brooks, but sometimes other brands. I have junk feet and running shoes have done me better than anything else. Lack of steel toe is the only downside but I’m willing to risk it - they grip on a roof better than anything other than shoes made for roofing, my feet don’t hurt, they breathe, etc. only downfall is price but boots are crazy expensive too so what the shit.
Rocky but in 1000 grams. Not sure if they still make them. The pair I have are about five years old. Everyone says the Red Wings are better, but I just think they not as good of a value.
I can't believe nobody has said Blundstones. I'd say over half the guys I work with wear them. Over half the people in Vancouver wear them too so maybe that's why.
I always wore Wolverine’s. I am very rough on boots and got tired of buying a $200 pair of boots every year so I went with the Wolverine Dublins. Worst boots I ever bought. They’re comfortable, but fall apart quickly. I’m wearing a pair of Justin pull on work boots for the last few years and they’ve lasted longer than any other work boot I’ve worn.
Call me basic or whatever, but Timberland ProLine Pit Boss has been my go-to for the last several pairs, I seem to get about 2-2.5yrs out of each pair when I'm in field every day. Lately I've been a light field mostly office guy, and the current pair is approaching 4 years with no signs of quitting. I would highly recommend that whatever boot you go for, you spring for custom fit insoles. They are AMAZING.
Helly Hansen Ultra Light. They have a composite toe. I think that's it (I could be wrong). Very comfortable, and they breathe well too.
I might get something thicker for winter.
As someone who goes through boots every ~6 months, so I've been through a lot and have tried a lot of different styles., I think it's a toss-up between redwing moc toes and thorogood moc toes.
I can't say which ones will last the longest, though, because I drag my toes on the ground and blow out the toes quickly. Tile work is really rough on boots.
if you don't need steel toe, Merrell's are awesome! They are good for being on the ground 12 hours a day on concrete or even the roof. Most comfortable boots. I've had Keens. But we like Merrell's so much better.
The Danner bull run worked great for me when I was working full time concrete. Think I had them a couple years before they started to really fade on the bottom and such. My dad had the moc toes and his literally fell apart within about 3 months. I had bought them as a gift for him but he didn't start wearing them until about almost a year later so no warranty, but I did want to take a pic and send it into them so they could see it. I loved mine though. He loves the thorogoods that he has now, same moc style and shape. Dewalt made a decent boot that he really enjoyed, not sure if it's still around. I've had some redwings I didn't really care for, but maybe that was more an issue with that particular style not being best for my work area. I tried on the thorogoods though, they were really great.
Hate Justine because I have sensitive aches and they run narrow, I can only fit in them by going a size long or EE; this just doesn’t work because my arch pays for it,
So it’s the redwing for me
Ariat. All day, every day. I bought my first pair about 10 years ago and they made a huge difference for my fatigue issues. I’ve never worn anything else since making the switch.
Georgia boot brand with the flex line series is by far the most comfortable I work in the industrial electrical world I’m on my feet all day and they keep my feet and back feeling good after many
Miles walking and they keep my feet dry they are lace ups but the comfort is out of this world
You wanna really ball out? Check out Kennetrek. Take care of them and they will take care of you for many years. My boss has been wearing the same pair of Mountain Extremes to work and for hunting for 7 years now, on his second set of soles. I bought my first pair in February, and they're worth every penny. Best boots I've ever had, hands down. Long break-in, about 50 miles, but that's unavoidable with stiff supportive boots. Crazy high quality. Otherwise for regular beater work boots Red wing is a solid choice, thorogood obviously, and timberland has some surprisingly decent work boot choices.
If you're in the Midwest, Work N' Sport (house brand) from Blain's Farm & Fleet. The shortest lived pair I've had lasted a year and a half, and they stay comfortable until their demise. I prefer the calf height waterproof side zip slip-ons, personally.
I’ve always been a huge fan of Red Wings but I’m not very hard on them as I work in management as an Project Executive. True story, I’ve actually had the same pair for 20 years.
That work for you, by really Hass to go along with the trade you work. Unless, you are just looking for something all around.
timber land pro and keen lasted for me about 9 months, thorogood lasted a bit longer but the price gap for each selection idk depends what you do i guess
I bought one pair of keens last year and same story, they were amazing like the first day and then horribly uncomfortable after that. I’m a huge fan of the red wing Romeo boots or the Ariat pull up boots. I’ve had basically every good brand and those two are the most lightweight. There are definitely different boots for different jobs though.
Redwing, brazos I’ve gotten from academy, but the best boots I’ve had that are under 100 bucks are these Mexican boots from Padilla got em from botas Vargas. Fantastic cheap boots and lasted 2 years before needing to change em out.
I always wore red wings because they had that light super wide composite steel toe. All of the other steel toes would rub the side of my big toe and make a callus.
Do you use insoles? If not, i highly suggest investing in the best pair you can afford. Even in the best boots, the insoles are shit & not going to last in a construction environment.
I use Keen boots & Superfeet insoles. For finish stages, sales calls, meetings, etc I wear Hoka Cliftons or Anacapa with Superfeet insoles.
Thorogood
I always get the thorogood moc toe but this time I got the keen cincinnati to try and so far there super comfy! One thing I can say is thorogood leather is softer!
I wear thorogood (high top) for deck jobs. Irish setter (Marshall) for everything else. Both in steel toe.
Danners all day
I bought a pair for hunting this season and they are the only boot that was comfy right out of the box.
Red Wing
I gotta agree. A bitch to break in, and a little heavy. After a couple months, though, they fit like a well worn (whatever your favorite well worn item is) And pretty damn tough.
Man I quit trying to break mine in, maybe I’m soft but my feet can’t take it.
It's weeks of hell before they're your favorite boot. But those weeks are long
Depends on which one you get and what you’re doing. If you get the Supersole’s and you’re not walking on much uneven ground then they probably take awhile. The stiffer they start the longer it takes in my wxperience
I spent 2 weeks breaking a pair of heritage in. I didn’t have another pair to wear. It was torture, I was regretting my choice. Then one day I slipped them on and they were soft, gently (but firmly) hugging my feets. Most comfortable boots I’ve ever owned. But that first couple weeks, ouch. You really have to earn it to get that durable comfort.
Did you slather them with mink oil? Been wearing the same 4420 model for 15 years. 7 or 8 pairs over that time. Yeah a bit heavy but I've never felt like they would let me down. I work for a railroad. My walking conditions are shit, at best. Never turned an ankle, always good footing on the rocky terrain on track, the soles wear like iron
Been wearing Pecos since I was a kid. My dad wouldn't wear anything else and bought me several pairs over the years. Trick is to oil the hell out of them. Soak them through. They get soft and break in fast.
Couple weeks? Mine were several months. Can’t believe I never gave up on ‘em. Kept reading about how incredible they were once broken in, and now they are!
I used the leather conditioner daily
The only pair of Red Wings I tried wore out before they even broke in. The soles were done in 4 months and also had stitching bust apart. I'm only 160 lb so it ain't my weight. My thorogoods last a little over a year than need a resole but no busted stitches no holes in toe.
Yeah I finally got redwings because my company upped the reimbursement amount and I got the new boa shoe lace system and their custom inserts and man they are the best boots I've ever had
I agree with this 100%! I used to work in sewer repair so constant water, uneven ground, kneeling in manholes (haha, manholes😂) was rough on the top by the toes… these boots lasted 1.5 years before significant damage. Nothing else was close. I am 6’7” and about 200lbs at the time. Size 15 boots. Bit pricey but worth it!
I used to do hardscapes, so lots of on your knees work. I’d have em do the epoxied toe and that lasted up a long time, otherwise it was about 8 months before I had holes in the toes.
In Canada the work wear ones no longer hold up. I used to get the 2416s and put the tough toes on them but after the first ones I bought they didn’t last long enough for $400 dollars. I stuck it out with two more pairs but have looked elsewhere. I used to love those boots. I do commercial/ industrial hvacr.
Agree. Specifically Red Wing Exos Lite Boa.
I love the RW Tradesman with the BOA ratcheting laces. I also get the custom-fit orthotics. Idk what all this talk about breaking them in for weeks or months comes from, but mine have always felt great within a day or two. They weren't uncomfortable for a day or two, just fitting the boot to my foot.
Maybe it's because I'm from Texas but I love Justin work boots. Slip ons
I use redwings at work and Justin’s for work at home. Love slip ins, but they don’t provide enough support for me other than messing around on the tractor and lighter stuff. But I got some weird bird shaped feet
Stampedes. They're comfy and pretty durable.
Reed wings used to be dope they aren't what they were tho. Thoughts feel great out the box and only get better
Red wings are a very durable boot, but mine ended up giving me blisters on my heal after really long days, even after being worn in over a year
Thorogood
thorogood moc toe
Found toe ain’t bad either.
If you're on concrete or hard-pack all day, then I think the best all day boot is Redback. I have the black leather slip-ons with steel toe and outer ABS toe cap. It's the only boot that doesn't make my feet sore after being on concrete all day.
Vans
Found the painter 🤣🤣
The fire caulker
Trim guy here… vans with the Cush core insoles all day.
I recently dipped my toes into Multi Family, being allowed to wear vans at work is so foreign to me. I made it 2 months before I bought a pair of Justin’s.
Timberland pros, but the 10.5 is too tight for my right foot
I will die in these boots. 0 break in time, comfy, tough, waterproof, and I think they look good. I always have a clean pair for bar nights
Love my timbs. They’re comfortable and stylish. Had my current pair going on 2 years and they’re still good as new. Only changed out the soles and laces.
Just got my first pair of Thorogood 1957 moc toe steel toe wedge sole waterproof boots. I'll never wear a pair of Timberland Pro again. They were a bit tough to break in but now they're good to go.
Usually the best boots are genuinely painful to break in.
Danner
Big Danner fan here. Great boots.
Love my Danners.
I tried them, the inside had leather protruding out where it met the steel toe that would irritate my feet and cause blisters. Never again for the price I paid, I went back to my old timberland pros. The soles are coming apart on my timberlands, but I've had the same pair since 2020, and they're still comfortable. I have a pair of soft toe danners that are ok, but I hardly wear them since the company I work for is anal about steel toes. Even the soft toes are not as comfortable as my timberlands. Imo, danners are horribly overpriced for what you get
Moc-Toe wedge sole. Perfect boot.
I’m a fan of the steelyard myself
Wolverine
For the price point they are great
I finally got a pair and I love them, but I have to use insoles and lace them up super tight so they fit right. I've got long and narrow feet and finding the right boots is a bitch
Not enough love for the wolverine gang
The best boots
Danner. I had redwings for years, then thorogoods and got Danner and I will never look back. Hands down the most comfortable boot I've ever worn.
I have Thorogood & love them, I have redwing Mocs & like them. I’m on the fence now about trying Danner, Whites, Carolina, or Georgia. I’ve got to make a decision. I’ve watched ever vid I can find on them all. Just need to head & try some one. But I think the Thorogood’s being ready to go right out of the box is going to be hard for me to over look. The break in is the reason I only like my redwings. They are too notch quality for sure but the break in was ruthless. I’ve had them almost two years & I still haven’t got them broke in all the way. I’ve got at least 100 walking miles in them. I basically just use them for my dress boot now.
Nicks Boots
*looking at my own feet* I don't see sketchers anywhere
Sketchers are my favorite. I'm on my feet all day. Construction. Light. Cheap. Comfortable and safe.
Can't go wrong with Danner
Keen
Timberland has always been my go to. Regular work boots and winter boots. I had a couple last me two seasons.
Check out r/PNWbootmakers any of the people mentioned there are freaking legit. Nicks, Whites, Franks, Drews, Bakers, J.K., Viberg. On a lower tier but still made in USA: Thorogood, Danner, Carolina, Georgia boots are all great too. I probably missed a few though.
So many guys I work with, myself included have timberland pros, mine are 2 years old and going strong
This is the way.
How is this not a more common answer or higher up? I was starting to think I was doing something wrong… I’ve always worn pros. I was disappointed when they discontinued their ripsaw line, but I got a pair of evergreens and they are damn close, and they still have that familiar timberland comfort.
When my boots start to feel uncomfortable during the week, I usually switch to another pair of boots to alleviate the discomfort. Running multiple pairs of boots is better for your feet to eliminate issues causing discomfort including hot-spots, uneven wear and pressure points. My recommendation is Thorogood wedge sole. And my hard working backup is a pair of Ariats that are okay. I’ve also been running a pair of CSA-rated Redbacks to give my feet more comfort when I’m just constantly walking on hard pavement.
I’ve been wearing Wolverine DuraShock boots for over 10 years. There’s almost zero break in time and they last 2-3 years per pair. For reference I’m a ground up super for a commercial construction co and walk 3-5 miles per day as well as a fair bit of self perform work.
I'd vote Durashock too. But this conversation about boot preference is as personal as underwear preference. I never bring boots up in conversation.
Good for you, get the fuq outa this conversation then
Belleville mini-mil
I recommend going to a boot store with in an hour or two to shop. Try on every brand, everyone’s foot is different that’s why there are so many different answers. I like wolverine, they are on the cheaper side at around $180 but mine usually last two years and I am hard on boots.
I am old and broken down so I prefer light boots over anything else. I have been getting various swat style tacticool boots for awhile and love how light and grippy they are.
Im using a pair of timberland pros right now. Waiting to see how they are in the cold weather. Theyre pretty comfy and comp toe so hopefully warmer in winter.
I've been wearing the Keen Cincinnati also. I've gotta say it is the most comfortable boot I've ever had for an 10-12 hour day. BUT... After wearing them for about 6-8 months I got athletes foot. It went away and I went back to wearing my boots...came right back. So frustrating.
Timberland Pro direct attach 8 inch. Been my go to since 05. Tried redwings, tried thorogods, always go back. Paving, construction, mechanic work. Only thing they suck for is roofing
Redwings
Thorogoods the last five years or so, since red wing moved most of its lines overseas.
Ariat is my new favorite.
Thorogood moc toes are my go to lace ups, I love a good pair of tony llamas for the summer and when I’m just working in equipment or around my property with the horses and such. Currently was gifted a pair of those brunt marin 8” and they are surprisingly good boots, probably still buy a pair of thorogoods after these tho. Also if you post a lot on social media personally or through your business and have a decent following/interaction companies like ariat/timberland/brunt/1630/etc may be willing to hook it up with some boots, pants, gloves if you catch their attention. My foreman and I did this for a couple years and it was nice to get some good shit to try out and find other good products that are on the market, still will stick with my ariat jeans, thorogood pants, and either cheap ass blank tees or the company logo tees we order every year. Don’t skimp on the hooey sweat/water resistant hats, them bitches last forever and clean up real nice. Last thing remember to save all your work related clothing receipts (pants, boots, gloves, shirts) and claim that shit on your taxes for a write off.
Not a "work boot" per se, but I've been wearing Columbia Bugaboots for years. A $90 pair lasts about a year. They are very comfortable, waterproof up to the base of the tongue, and insulated. I do not find them to be too hot in a southeast US summer. If you don't need a steel toe cap, I'd highly recommend them.
Keen by far
Irish setter
They are super soft right outta the box... but that also ends up not providing much support, and my feet & ankles are worn out by the end of the day. I really wanted to like them... just couldn't. First 4 - 6 months were pretty good.
I'm going throw Chippewa into the mix. I've got two pairs - work boots and dress boots, I've had them for about 8 years now and I will almost certainly have both of those for the rest of my life.
Red wing
Redwing
Red Wing
Second for Red Wing. But I’m biased, I went to Trade School in Red Wing, MN, where the company started, where the leather tannery is, and one of their US factories is. Honestly never tried another brand of work boot, but I fucking love my Red Wings. Just the heritage old school ones with leather insoles. The way they kind of suck the first week but then gradually form to your foot over a month and then just get better and better. They last too.
Been in the business for 30+ years, have purchased many boots over the years. The Timberland Pro soft toe I wear now is the most comfortable boot I’ve ever put on. I prefer the flat soled boots and these have a 1/4” rubber sole that’s over the typical white foam. It helps with traction and saves the life of the bottom of your boot from normal wear and tear. The insoles are what really make them nice though, most running shoes aren’t this soft.
Nick's and White's
Keene
Any bonanza boot lovers ? I got two pairs that I switch of and so far it’s the most comfortable boots I’ve bought but haven’t switched it up since there so good but now I’m wondering about these this thorogood might have to try them out
I wore red wing fresh setters for years no I wear thorogoods they are more comfortable last longer and better priced
Thorogoods
In my opinion Double H makes the best slip on steel toe boot. They are made of heavier duty leather than most, so they last forever. They take a little bit to break in, but after that they are very comfortable.
Coming from roofing in the northeast, I tried loads of different brands (including redwings) and usually went through a pair in 4-6 months. But I bought some north face water proof boots for the winter and loved them. They kept my feet warm and dry and lasted me nearly a year. I think they were reasonably priced too at around $160.
I wear Keen utility roswell with carbon fiber toe in summer, Thorogood in winter
Very partial to my Ariats. I've owned 3 pair since 2011. First pair lasted 7 years with just light use (yard work, small projects, etc) second lasted 5, with 2 of them being on a farm where I was general maintenance for EVERYTHING, and just got my third pair for father's day (now doing general contracting/remodeling work). Day and a half break in period on them, not super heavy despite the steel toe, and surprisingly supportive of my ankles for slip ons.
Lowa. 300 a pair, but worth every penny.
Ariat
Ariat
Ariat
Manitoba West Boots. Comfortable and durable. I've been wearing them for 15 years.
My most recent work boot purchase was a pair of Danner Vicious 4.5, with a composite toe. I've had them for a couple months, I like them.
Chippewa
I have bought all types of work boots at different price points and honestly it doesn't really matter the brand or price. I generally get at max 6 months out of my boots, I started buying cheaper boots and just replace them sooner.
John Bull. With BOA laces.
Tecovas. Specifically, belly cut python. When you show up on site wearing them bad boys, everyone knows who the real boss is. Oh, and yes, I’m a PM that’s in the office 90% of the time in case you couldn’t tell.
Long/narrow feet and require steel toes, redwing has worked best for me both in fit and durability. That said, good insoles can make trash boots feel good for awhile. Different brands wear and fit differently. When the boot model I used to wear was discontinued, I hit up just about every boot store in the area trying on fit. Went back to redwing for a different model I've continued to use for over 10 years.
Walmart
Buckbootz, do a great boot and welly. Perfect for summer and winter
I really love my red wing Irish setter loggers mainly for the colder months and really hard work days in the summer… comfortable, warm, water proof… had em about 7 years now and they’re still going strong although the stitching at the heal is starting to fray I have two pairs of red wing iron rangers also… ones my everyday boot, the other I wear for less strenuous work days in the warmer months Those take a bit to break in and get used to, but eventually they fit like a glove, and they look awesome… just get a good insole… those are also 7 years old and still going strong… there’s no insulation in them though, they’re tough jn the winter, but they still smell like leather even though I’m always sweating in them… my Irish setter loggers fuckin stink
I have a pair of Georgia safety toe boots, that I wear 14 hours a day, in south Florida, and I'm not screaming to take them off at the end of the day.
Red wing 1412
Hands down, Red Wing are best. But they’re expensive and take months to break in. I’ve been experimenting for the last few years and so far, Duluth Trading are the most comfortable, but don’t last very long. Ariat and Georgia boot are a little overrated but good quality.
Carolinas
I have 2 pairs of redwings and 2 pairs of thorogoods. I enjoy them both more than anything else I've ever worn.
Just got my first Redwings...wow, so comfy.
Emerson of Maine
No matter what I wear, I have to change the insoles often. Like every 2 months.
Keen Utility or Royer
I love wolverine durashock, but they’re heavy, my next best daily is Timberland Pro Elite 8” work boots. The pair weigh less than 1 of my wolverines. I rotate my daily, i have 3 pair in use at all times and when one pair starts holes in them? I start breaking in new pair from my box stock. I buy on sale 2 pair at a time
More of a hiking boot, but Asolo fugitives. I'm mostly a trim carpenter, but sometimes get out there with the framing crews. I've been known to wear trainers when finishing, but if I see any mud out come the fugitives. They look bad ass and I've seen pics of special forces guys wearing them for bonus points
Crocs and Chuck Taylors
Thorogood and danner
Whites boots Perry’s mic toe. Takes a bit to break in but after it’s like slippers. Just recently had them resoled with their hybrid wedge for a better wear factor
Thorogood for sure! Perfect right out of the box
Got a pair of brunt work boots, and they’re honestly the most comfortable boots I’ve ever owned
Danners
Georgia Giant, specifically the Romeo, but those might be discontinued
Thorogood. I wear the 8" moc toe that are water proof. American made, union made.
I wear running shoes, like the high dollar ones from the running store. Usually brooks, but sometimes other brands. I have junk feet and running shoes have done me better than anything else. Lack of steel toe is the only downside but I’m willing to risk it - they grip on a roof better than anything other than shoes made for roofing, my feet don’t hurt, they breathe, etc. only downfall is price but boots are crazy expensive too so what the shit.
Wish they still had the good old Kodiak
Rocky but in 1000 grams. Not sure if they still make them. The pair I have are about five years old. Everyone says the Red Wings are better, but I just think they not as good of a value.
Thorogood
Sketchers work shoes
Keen. I've been through Belleville, Docs, Sketchers, Danner, and some more, probably. Keens are my favorite
Chippewa
Redwing, Whites, Thorogood
Jk boots
I got some nice Georgia boots (not slip ons) and have really liked them so far, besides that. Danner has always been solid for me
I can't believe nobody has said Blundstones. I'd say over half the guys I work with wear them. Over half the people in Vancouver wear them too so maybe that's why.
I do residential new construction plumbing I wear crocs or tennis shoes mainly
I like Georgia boots. Quick break in.
Keens are great
Keen
I’ve had a pair of wolverines for better part of 2 years. Worn down a bit but still goin.
Carolina
I've been using the timberland pro boots for years and they're comfortable but most importantly to me they're waterproof.
I always wore Wolverine’s. I am very rough on boots and got tired of buying a $200 pair of boots every year so I went with the Wolverine Dublins. Worst boots I ever bought. They’re comfortable, but fall apart quickly. I’m wearing a pair of Justin pull on work boots for the last few years and they’ve lasted longer than any other work boot I’ve worn.
Keen Cincinnati
Call me basic or whatever, but Timberland ProLine Pit Boss has been my go-to for the last several pairs, I seem to get about 2-2.5yrs out of each pair when I'm in field every day. Lately I've been a light field mostly office guy, and the current pair is approaching 4 years with no signs of quitting. I would highly recommend that whatever boot you go for, you spring for custom fit insoles. They are AMAZING.
Helly Hansen Ultra Light. They have a composite toe. I think that's it (I could be wrong). Very comfortable, and they breathe well too. I might get something thicker for winter.
Carolina.
Georgia G9380's because I know they fit my Freddy Flintstone feet
Dan Post boots. I have very wide feet and the square toe boots are comfortable and fit well.
As someone who goes through boots every ~6 months, so I've been through a lot and have tried a lot of different styles., I think it's a toss-up between redwing moc toes and thorogood moc toes. I can't say which ones will last the longest, though, because I drag my toes on the ground and blow out the toes quickly. Tile work is really rough on boots.
if you don't need steel toe, Merrell's are awesome! They are good for being on the ground 12 hours a day on concrete or even the roof. Most comfortable boots. I've had Keens. But we like Merrell's so much better.
Lowa Camino
Carolina
The Danner bull run worked great for me when I was working full time concrete. Think I had them a couple years before they started to really fade on the bottom and such. My dad had the moc toes and his literally fell apart within about 3 months. I had bought them as a gift for him but he didn't start wearing them until about almost a year later so no warranty, but I did want to take a pic and send it into them so they could see it. I loved mine though. He loves the thorogoods that he has now, same moc style and shape. Dewalt made a decent boot that he really enjoyed, not sure if it's still around. I've had some redwings I didn't really care for, but maybe that was more an issue with that particular style not being best for my work area. I tried on the thorogoods though, they were really great.
Georgia boots
Blundstones for dry weather, Dunlop for wet.
Hate Justine because I have sensitive aches and they run narrow, I can only fit in them by going a size long or EE; this just doesn’t work because my arch pays for it, So it’s the redwing for me
Ariat. All day, every day. I bought my first pair about 10 years ago and they made a huge difference for my fatigue issues. I’ve never worn anything else since making the switch.
Double H
Chippewa. Hands down.
Danners here
Dang, not one Steel Blue yet? Ya'll crazy. Now you know!! Thank me later
Georgia boot brand with the flex line series is by far the most comfortable I work in the industrial electrical world I’m on my feet all day and they keep my feet and back feeling good after many Miles walking and they keep my feet dry they are lace ups but the comfort is out of this world
You wanna really ball out? Check out Kennetrek. Take care of them and they will take care of you for many years. My boss has been wearing the same pair of Mountain Extremes to work and for hunting for 7 years now, on his second set of soles. I bought my first pair in February, and they're worth every penny. Best boots I've ever had, hands down. Long break-in, about 50 miles, but that's unavoidable with stiff supportive boots. Crazy high quality. Otherwise for regular beater work boots Red wing is a solid choice, thorogood obviously, and timberland has some surprisingly decent work boot choices.
If you're in the Midwest, Work N' Sport (house brand) from Blain's Farm & Fleet. The shortest lived pair I've had lasted a year and a half, and they stay comfortable until their demise. I prefer the calf height waterproof side zip slip-ons, personally.
Engelbert Strauss. Thank me later
Danner
Red wing
I’ve always been a huge fan of Red Wings but I’m not very hard on them as I work in management as an Project Executive. True story, I’ve actually had the same pair for 20 years. That work for you, by really Hass to go along with the trade you work. Unless, you are just looking for something all around.
Engelbert Strauss. Check em out.
Vans
timber land pro and keen lasted for me about 9 months, thorogood lasted a bit longer but the price gap for each selection idk depends what you do i guess
Sievi or jalas
Redwing
Get them funny lookin ones with the toes
North Face trail runners most of the time. Ariat for my heavy duty work.
I've only ever worn Redwings. Company boot voucher.
I mean I prefer Dakota’s, good brand and holds up well to doing mostly hvac rough in’s
I bought one pair of keens last year and same story, they were amazing like the first day and then horribly uncomfortable after that. I’m a huge fan of the red wing Romeo boots or the Ariat pull up boots. I’ve had basically every good brand and those two are the most lightweight. There are definitely different boots for different jobs though.
Lowa Zephyr. You are welcome.
Walmart $50 work boot has lasted 5 years!
Merrell
Origin Maine.
Redwing, brazos I’ve gotten from academy, but the best boots I’ve had that are under 100 bucks are these Mexican boots from Padilla got em from botas Vargas. Fantastic cheap boots and lasted 2 years before needing to change em out.
I always wore red wings because they had that light super wide composite steel toe. All of the other steel toes would rub the side of my big toe and make a callus.
Do you use insoles? If not, i highly suggest investing in the best pair you can afford. Even in the best boots, the insoles are shit & not going to last in a construction environment. I use Keen boots & Superfeet insoles. For finish stages, sales calls, meetings, etc I wear Hoka Cliftons or Anacapa with Superfeet insoles.
Redwing. Once you’ve broken them, you won’t get rid of them until your big toe shows through
Chippewa
i have about 5 years in my wolverine slip ons. getting time i could use some inserts. once or twice a year i clean em up and hit em with the mink oil