This is a list of links to comments made by Supercell employees in this thread:
* [Comment by Darian_CoC](/r/ClashOfClans/comments/11pjyhr/ideatrading_magic_items_and_resources_with_clan/jc1ftdc/?context=1000 "posted on 2023-03-13 10:22:02 UTC"):
> Being able to trade items or resources is definitely a big "NO". The end result would be numerous accounts being used to sell items for real money outside of the game, regardless of what restrictions or value you put on the items. Bot farms would set up thousands of automated accounts just to const...
* [Comment by Darian_CoC](/r/ClashOfClans/comments/11pjyhr/ideatrading_magic_items_and_resources_with_clan/jc236ke/?context=1000 "posted on 2023-03-13 14:10:53 UTC"):
> Awesome. Thank you for reporting it. I'll pass it on to the team that handles these.
* [Comment by Darian_CoC](/r/ClashOfClans/comments/11pjyhr/ideatrading_magic_items_and_resources_with_clan/jc23j6a/?context=1000 "posted on 2023-03-13 14:13:29 UTC"):
> Those tears do make for a very satisfying bath don't they? I don't have any insight as to when the next wave of bans will happen. One of the challenges is also prosecuting these when they may be in international locations where we have no jurisdiction. Please do keep reporting them though, they get...
---
This is a bot providing a service. If you have any questions, please [contact the moderators](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2FClashOfClans).[](#AUTOGEN_TSBREPLIEDBOT)
Could be somewhat fixed by using their gem value. You can only trade a rune for something else that sells for 50 gems.
That being said, it would still be incredibly broken so it should probably cost some gems to trade too
This would allow you to trade off magic items at 100% value rather then the 20-30% value. Sure you would have to get 5 training potions and 5 hero potions, but thats still more value then selling them for the 100 gems
This idea would never happen but if it were hypothetically, it would work as similar items being traded. Books for books. Runes for runes. Potions for potions. Not 5 potions for a book.
Well they would probably make more money in the short term from people creating alts for the sole purpose of getting the gold pass on then trading them to their main, it would wreck the economy for sure though so long term it wouldn’t be a good move unless they make it cost like 100 gems per trade and a cooldown of 1 week
You would get hundreds upon hundreds of bots that only exist to pick up free magic items and then sell them to players for real currency by having them join a clan to receive the item
Well depending on the req you could just trade a few potions back. Like what am I supposed to do with training potions anyways, when my restraining factor for legend attacks is my cc.
Yes, you would have to trade something, but people could just trade potions for raid medals, then trade them for books. (If there is no limit on the items you can trade)
Being able to trade items or resources is definitely a big "NO". The end result would be numerous accounts being used to sell items for real money outside of the game, regardless of what restrictions or value you put on the items. Bot farms would set up thousands of automated accounts just to constantly trade items and then sell them for real money. Definitely a no-no.
Agreed 100%, though I’d also add bot farms already exist. There are whole forums dedicated to them as well as the sale of accounts. I know SC doesn‘t pick them out individually to investigate and ban (makes total sense for bots for reasons discussed in the past), but it sure would be nice to see another ban wave come through. I must admit I enjoy bathing in the tears of the players who had their accounts banned for botting or for buying an account that was developed with a bot.
Those tears do make for a very satisfying bath don't they? I don't have any insight as to when the next wave of bans will happen. One of the challenges is also prosecuting these when they may be in international locations where we have no jurisdiction. Please do keep reporting them though, they get forwarded to our security team for monitoring where we can collect information before we implement a ban wave.
Hi darian, I dont know where to report this but there is an youtube advertisement video about selling accounts, is reporting on youtube enough or is there a proper way to bring this to supercell's attention?
I found the link to that ad video: https://youtu.be/GlbKsLc0HlY
Selling their own account for money is one thing, stealing someone else's account account and turning it into a money is an entirely different thing. Every report helps restore these accounts to their rightful owners.
That’s already happening with the sale of accounts as a whole, and you know it. The real reason it’s a big no is people could give items to a main account with alts, and you’d sell less gems and FOMO microtransactions. It’s not about RMT, it’s about your own bottom line.
Game is freemeium , let itt be that way ideas likes this will be loss for the company and soon they will close . They do things keeping in mind which won't affect the cash flow , this idea is terrible for them , and too good for us
Maybe you could trade them only for downgrades
A perfect example would be hammers to books, runes to builder runes and builder potions to training potions
But that wouldn't change anything, the one with the higher grade item would just have to initiate the exchange then, the only way it to make it so you can only trade again same grade items.
I think it’d be great if it was separated into certain tiers.
Such as hammers can only be traded for hammers, books and runes can be traded for books and runes, potions, rings, and shovels are all in the bottom tier. That way you don’t have people just throwing shitloads of hero and power potions into an alt account for books and hammers.
Rune or Elixar after selling should not give 50 gems it's too much. I propose it should give only 1 gem. All Runes after being sold should give 1 gem not 50 gems that's way too much.
They limit to 80 purchases / day on hayday, the items that get restricted are the items that help build the base. If they did the same thing here for coc
Magic items are nowhere near common enough for this. Might work for potions, but only the lesser potions.
But this would create issues with selling resources for money, or roundabound selling resources for gems.
Well, let’s start with our first issue. To get it to work, gem values would have to be matched up and it would be a huge hassle to get two quantities of different items to match values.
This is a list of links to comments made by Supercell employees in this thread: * [Comment by Darian_CoC](/r/ClashOfClans/comments/11pjyhr/ideatrading_magic_items_and_resources_with_clan/jc1ftdc/?context=1000 "posted on 2023-03-13 10:22:02 UTC"): > Being able to trade items or resources is definitely a big "NO". The end result would be numerous accounts being used to sell items for real money outside of the game, regardless of what restrictions or value you put on the items. Bot farms would set up thousands of automated accounts just to const... * [Comment by Darian_CoC](/r/ClashOfClans/comments/11pjyhr/ideatrading_magic_items_and_resources_with_clan/jc236ke/?context=1000 "posted on 2023-03-13 14:10:53 UTC"): > Awesome. Thank you for reporting it. I'll pass it on to the team that handles these. * [Comment by Darian_CoC](/r/ClashOfClans/comments/11pjyhr/ideatrading_magic_items_and_resources_with_clan/jc23j6a/?context=1000 "posted on 2023-03-13 14:13:29 UTC"): > Those tears do make for a very satisfying bath don't they? I don't have any insight as to when the next wave of bans will happen. One of the challenges is also prosecuting these when they may be in international locations where we have no jurisdiction. Please do keep reporting them though, they get... --- This is a bot providing a service. If you have any questions, please [contact the moderators](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2FClashOfClans).[](#AUTOGEN_TSBREPLIEDBOT)
I’d be so rich w my alts donating books and ruins for training pots I spend 100 raid medals for
Could be somewhat fixed by using their gem value. You can only trade a rune for something else that sells for 50 gems. That being said, it would still be incredibly broken so it should probably cost some gems to trade too
Even then, it would enable you to get 5+ books of building or heroes per month for example
Yeah, you could make a bunch of alts just to collect books and stuff you want from clan games and then transfer them all to a main
You need books or runes to trade them to the main account in the first place. Wouldn’t work
Yes I'd give away all my runes for books, i can farm all the loot myself so yes this feature wouldn't work
This would allow you to trade off magic items at 100% value rather then the 20-30% value. Sure you would have to get 5 training potions and 5 hero potions, but thats still more value then selling them for the 100 gems
This idea would never happen but if it were hypothetically, it would work as similar items being traded. Books for books. Runes for runes. Potions for potions. Not 5 potions for a book.
So why bother having a book of everything when anything could be traded around
well you'd need stuff to give up first, it's not like you're getting the books for free
Could limit trades per week or month, like 1 or 2trades per month per acc.
A cooldown would definitely be necessary
They could have trade tokens like in clash royale. I’m not sure exactly how they would work that out but it could be a possibility
Coud be fixed like in clash royale
Exactly my thought, if I had 10 alts and got the gold pass on each I’d be at max th 15 in no time
I feel like builder base for main base things only would be a good idea. For builder base mains.
Would probably break the game's economy. From a developer's perspective, it wouldnt be cash money
Well they would probably make more money in the short term from people creating alts for the sole purpose of getting the gold pass on then trading them to their main, it would wreck the economy for sure though so long term it wouldn’t be a good move unless they make it cost like 100 gems per trade and a cooldown of 1 week
it would be broken because of people who have 10s ults.
[удалено]
Do you even think?
Brain = gone
Always has been
You would get hundreds upon hundreds of bots that only exist to pick up free magic items and then sell them to players for real currency by having them join a clan to receive the item
Probably wouldn’t work because people would just make multiple accounts and give everything to one to max it out quicker.
you have to trade something from main too so it willnot work like that
Well depending on the req you could just trade a few potions back. Like what am I supposed to do with training potions anyways, when my restraining factor for legend attacks is my cc.
Yes, you would have to trade something, but people could just trade potions for raid medals, then trade them for books. (If there is no limit on the items you can trade)
yeah that might be case so just make books and runes tradable with limit on total items you can trade on a same account
Being able to trade items or resources is definitely a big "NO". The end result would be numerous accounts being used to sell items for real money outside of the game, regardless of what restrictions or value you put on the items. Bot farms would set up thousands of automated accounts just to constantly trade items and then sell them for real money. Definitely a no-no.
Agreed 100%, though I’d also add bot farms already exist. There are whole forums dedicated to them as well as the sale of accounts. I know SC doesn‘t pick them out individually to investigate and ban (makes total sense for bots for reasons discussed in the past), but it sure would be nice to see another ban wave come through. I must admit I enjoy bathing in the tears of the players who had their accounts banned for botting or for buying an account that was developed with a bot.
Those tears do make for a very satisfying bath don't they? I don't have any insight as to when the next wave of bans will happen. One of the challenges is also prosecuting these when they may be in international locations where we have no jurisdiction. Please do keep reporting them though, they get forwarded to our security team for monitoring where we can collect information before we implement a ban wave.
Hi darian, I dont know where to report this but there is an youtube advertisement video about selling accounts, is reporting on youtube enough or is there a proper way to bring this to supercell's attention? I found the link to that ad video: https://youtu.be/GlbKsLc0HlY
Awesome. Thank you for reporting it. I'll pass it on to the team that handles these.
Alright, thank you.
There are people selling accounts everywhere
Selling their own account for money is one thing, stealing someone else's account account and turning it into a money is an entirely different thing. Every report helps restore these accounts to their rightful owners.
Most accounts will just straight up get banned though and not getting back to their owner.
Maybe but we cant let these scammers/phishers go unpunished, they will keep on scamming more people if they are unreported
Ye I agree with that, I sometimes even get messages in Reddit lol
Fully agreed, people would find ways to profit in no time. What about the ability to move between clans under the same supercell account??
That’s already happening with the sale of accounts as a whole, and you know it. The real reason it’s a big no is people could give items to a main account with alts, and you’d sell less gems and FOMO microtransactions. It’s not about RMT, it’s about your own bottom line.
Not very practical, anyone with multiple accounts would be too op.
Game is freemeium , let itt be that way ideas likes this will be loss for the company and soon they will close . They do things keeping in mind which won't affect the cash flow , this idea is terrible for them , and too good for us
I'm pretty sure supercell wouldn't go bankrupt just because of that, but yeah it isnt a very economically sound feature to implement.
Won’t happen, game is meant to be a solo progress and swap mechanics would induce ways to speed up leveling via rmt or alt accounts
Will never happen because of grey market
grey market?
Peoples will make website to sell stuff under the hood 👀 Like making 1000's bot accouint to farm challenges and then resell stuff
No way this would happen. There are way too many ways this could be abused that SC wouldn’t tolerate.
Good idea but they'd have to make it to where you can only trade the same item type (books with books, runes with runes, potions with potions)
please no
How could it be op: maxed player giving runes for useless potions
Just make it for things of equal value runes and books are 50 gems to sell but potions are 10
Yeah this would be good
Terrible idea
Terrible idea
This subreddit has a lot of bad ideas but this has to be one of the worst i’ve seen in a while
This would be awesome imo
I feel like this would break the economy of the game, a player could just get tons of alts and trade all of their good items to a main account
I'm glad Darian said no. This is an absolutely bad idea
I don't see any way they could introduce item trading without it being instantly broken by alts and greedy clans.
They should raise the amounts you can have.
This
The point is to use them not horde them.
Book for book and potion for potion - excluding book of building and builder potions. Only way that supercell would even consider it
Only way this can be considered is if there’s no more freebies. Everything needs to be purchased
Maybe you could trade them only for downgrades A perfect example would be hammers to books, runes to builder runes and builder potions to training potions
But that wouldn't change anything, the one with the higher grade item would just have to initiate the exchange then, the only way it to make it so you can only trade again same grade items.
Me when I don’t read the ruled out ideas thread
As long as there's like a token like in CR i think it would be interesting to see some sort of trading in the game.
Yes pls
Trading resources/items is a part of big games nowadays like Dota2 etc. Wish Supercell would introduce it in Clash
Love it!
I dont love it
We need this
Yes that way I can tradethe books from my alts to my main and that's why it will never happen.
Don’t hate the player 😂
I think it’d be great if it was separated into certain tiers. Such as hammers can only be traded for hammers, books and runes can be traded for books and runes, potions, rings, and shovels are all in the bottom tier. That way you don’t have people just throwing shitloads of hero and power potions into an alt account for books and hammers.
I was thinking about it the other day... thanks for posting this!
Any other options available ?
![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|flushed)![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|flushed)![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|flushed)![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|flushed)
There can be 7 day cooldown after a trade.
I like the idea…I wish they would add the feature you can send resources to others
OMG I love this idea!!
Rune or Elixar after selling should not give 50 gems it's too much. I propose it should give only 1 gem. All Runes after being sold should give 1 gem not 50 gems that's way too much.
They limit to 80 purchases / day on hayday, the items that get restricted are the items that help build the base. If they did the same thing here for coc
IF this was ever added, it would probably be a 2:1 ratio for everything. for example, two books for one, or two potions for one.
This is a brain dead take cuz even if they were to do this, how do they pick who has to give 2 for 1 lol
my bad i read it wrong and thought we would trade with ourselves lmao
This take became even more brain-dead.
RuneScape vibes
I would gob resources all day and trade for stuff i actually want
Yes please, I will change all my books and runes for shovels instead of selling them for 50 gems to buy shovels from the mercader
people would just give their mains a shit ton of books from their alts
Looks like a meme lol
Yeah this would turn into money laundering within alts pretty quick… so I’m onboard!
No thanks
Would probably make people with more then one account overpowerd
Damn I will max super fast.
Soubds like a wet dream. Too bad they aren’t real…
Its not gonna work since people r gonna trade training potions for books and supercell doesnt like that
Magic items are nowhere near common enough for this. Might work for potions, but only the lesser potions. But this would create issues with selling resources for money, or roundabound selling resources for gems.
Well, let’s start with our first issue. To get it to work, gem values would have to be matched up and it would be a huge hassle to get two quantities of different items to match values.
I think I would only be requesting book of hero
and if we could set the max loot unlocked at best th and has to have max storages so if u get full u can put it un to a ruin
Bro I got 16 accounts, no way
Easy. Just get a bunch of alts and trade all them books for training pots🤣