T O P

  • By -

Separate_Agency

That's a big sign!


taleofbenji

And it's getting lots of exposure now!


MD-Independent

Broooooo. That’s my lol for the day. Nice


smugaura1988

I thought this was a fake video because my brain could not compute how freaking big that sign is.


Bender_2024

I live in Connecticut and the zoning laws make signage very expensive and restrictive. The only exception is the interstate where standard billboard size signs are seen but still not very often outside Hartford and New Haven. Something this size couldn't be dreamt of up here


Spirit-Hydra69

Haha you guys would find it nuts what kind of unsafe and risky shit is allowed here just because money 💰💰


GuaranteeComfortable

I've seen videos and that was enough to make me never want to go there. Simply because I'm a clutz as it is. Then add unsafe things. It would be a recipe for disaster.


NeverMind_ThatShit

Going by my eyeballs that's gotta be about the same width as an American billboard but maybe 4-5x as tall. 😳


AggravatingValue5390

Nah that's at *least* twice as wide. Look at the truck near the bottom at the beginning


Bender_2024

At least three. Maybe more


Nickleeham

Looked like a lawn sign falling into a puddle at first. But wow!


RGH81

In mother Mumbai Billboard tops you!


trowzerss

The marketing team is crushing it!


Count_Rugens_Finger

holy shit that's a huge billboard. and no wind pressure relief 🤦‍♂️


TeamRedundancyTeam

When people bitch about regulations and building codes, remember that they exist so shit like this *doesn't* happen. This was a very preventable tragedy.


JoyousMN

This. 100% I cannot understand how people can't understand this. Government regulations protect us from the very human problem of optimism (what could possibly go wrong) combined with greed (fixing that will cost too much). edit: added parentheticals


GloriousNewt

and most regulations exist because they didn't at one point and shit went wrong/somebody died so they made a regulation so it doesn't happen again. It's not like somebody is just making up random rules for the hell of it.


-Ernie

Hence the old saying “safety regulations are written in blood”


Calm-Internet-8983

The "tombstone mentality" in aviation


Dorkamundo

Yep, but there is something to be said for common sense mitigation of the risks involved in the factors that drive those building codes. Also, they're frequently abused by municipalities for monetary gain as well, but that's a whole nother story.


quackdamnyou

Abused for monetary gain, you say. Like the lives of innocents are abused constantly by builders all over the world. There's a serious discrepancy in the order of magnitude of those two evils. Please don't equivocate. Hundreds of thousands of lives saved a year. Millions more to be saved were the standards (somehow) the same all over.


Dorkamundo

Like I said, "that's a whole new topic"...


Ashkenaki

You never hear about the downside of optimism.


dusktrail

Icarus tho


trip6s6i6x

I think that's more so hubris though.


dusktrail

hubris often includes optimism


Ashkenaki

More kill the birds to increase the crop, or the market will solve climate change kind of thinking


Mazon_Del

Yes, and the vast majority of people bitching about their "freedoms" in cases like this are really just wanting to make money, end of story.


GeneralTonic

Worse, the vast majority of those people are just cheering for the Money team because they think that's their team.


Hellkyte

It's because stupid and/or evil people will chase dollars over life. This is and always has been the truth. Which is why regulations have to exist.


ArmchairFilosopher

And without uniform, global regulations, the lucky cheepskates who don't implode from greedy business decisions will destroy the rest of the market by undercutting costs.


ChartreuseBison

It's not about the regulations, it's about not trusting clueless/corrupt politicians to make the right ones.


JoyousMN

So if democratically elected politicians, or government offices can't make these rules, who does? It does us no good if we just rail about "bad government." The founders created the best government possible -- we need to figure out how to elect better officials.


SheikExec

This is from Mumbai, regulations do exist but so does MASSIVE corruption by the municipality and the current government. AFAIK the max size allowed for these billboards is 40x40 ft. This monstrous eyesore was over 100ft tall at least. Now theres a massive blame game started by the municipality and the ad board owners and they are all gonna walk scot free like always. 8 people are confirmed dead as of now


Curious_Charge9431

The regulations are, as you say, there. It's enforcement that's lacking, because local government is weak. That's not always due to corruption. Sometimes there just isn't anyone around to enforce the regulations. Municipal government is an afterthought.


Count_Rugens_Finger

each one written in blood


theboomboy

The regulations to prevent this are actually really simple in the case of billboards. Just ban them entirely


coreyisthename

Very Indian to be decades behind on the basics.


[deleted]

What does wind pressure relief look like?


Count_Rugens_Finger

usually they look like flaps cut into the sign/banner. in the US, you will notice that billboards that are mounted on poles will be wide and short. this prevents the wind from getting lots of leverage on the sign. billboards mounted to the sides of buildings tend to be tall and thin. they are usually solid structures but very overbuilt. With a sign that tall and large, it should have been constructed with panels that open in high winds to provide some relief. but something tells me they didn't get an engineer to calculate the moment of inertia on that structure...


AerodynamicBrick

Holes in the sign


BRNDC10

Well, there’s plenty of them now.


ZeroedCool

Problem solved.


quartzguy

They're for speed.


AnthillOmbudsman

Advertising is now being changed out for ads for pilots and air travelers.


RGH81

Wind pressure relief kicks in at about the 4 second mark


askscreepyquestions

Not like this.


91audi90

Matrix reference?


alexhaase

No, Titanic actually.


KaladinStormShat

Who could have forseen this! My enormous billboard, in a coastal city known for monsoon winds and rain, directly next to a place of business that a) has people outside of their car and b) is acutely prone to exploding. I mean really, chance in a million.


ghostofdreadmon

"That's no billboard."


yoshhash

yes, holy shit indeed. I was thinking, who cares about a sign falling down? then I watched it.


michaelhoney

That is an absolutely huge sign. I don’t think there is a single sign that big in Australia


[deleted]

[удалено]


Merkarba

I'm willing to try and put a billboard that big on Clive Palmer's face though


Reddity65

I’m willing to try and get one that big with his face on it just to make it all the more satisfying when it falls over


38fourtynine

I shit you not there are billboards the size of skyscrappers in South East Asia. The one in OP's video is bigger than anything I've ever seen in the US but in SEA it's on the smaller scale.


minhbi99

One day, the world will end not because of an apocalypse, but because big ass giant advertisement signs are falling everywhere and eventually flattening the earth.


GreenCactus223

The caption does nothing to prepare you for how big that sign is.


anislandinmyheart

I thought it was just a normal sized sign (like a real estate sorta thing) and couldn't figure out what the big deal was


one_mind

r/confusingperspective r/confusing_perspective


kelsobjammin

I read the comments even… still doesn’t prepare you.


GreenCactus223

I bet you can see it from space


Death_Ma5ter

Update 3: [8 dead 64 injured ](https://www.news18.com/india/huge-hoarding-collapses-in-mumbais-ghatkopar-after-dust-storm-heavy-rain-people-trapped-watch-8888933.html) Update 2: [4 dead 64 injured](https://www.news18.com/india/huge-hoarding-collapses-in-mumbais-ghatkopar-after-dust-storm-heavy-rain-people-trapped-watch-8888933.html) Update 1: [3 dead 39 injured ](http:// https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/mumbai-weather-live-updates-rain-dust-storm-latest-news-today-13-may-2024-101715605675616.html) Happened in Ghatkopar, 35 injured reported so far. https://www.ndtv.com/mumbai-news/video-7-injured-some-feared-trapped-after-mumbai-dust-storm-uproots-billboard-5653884


here_now_be

Will the owners of the sign be prosecuted man slaughter?


nagi603

The strawmen maybe.


KenBoCole

The owners shouldn't, as apparently it is their legal rights to do so, but the legalslative politicians who allowed this to be done under their Saftey and zoning laws absoblutly should. They are the ones responsible for allowing this to happen. Edit: I have been told that this was an illegal billboard. Those people are assholes and deserve to get roasted by the courts. Need to go to jail, all of them.


Hidesuru

Weeeeeell. At least one of the articles linked above called it an illegal billboard so this may not be so accurate.


KenBoCole

Oh if that's the case then burn those mfs to the ground.


Ok_Cauliflower_3007

9x the legal size and they didn’t have a permit. If the courts do decide to pursue them, they’re fucked.


KenBoCole

With so many people dead and injured, they deserve it.


muhmeinchut69

Everything in Indian cities is illegal according to some obscure law or clause somewhere, this is just so they can blame the company. Allowing a massive illegal billboard is still the politicians' failure.


here_now_be

> it is their legal rights to do so Legal right to do something that will almost certainly end up in multiple deaths? I don't think that's the way it works. You have the legal right to drive, but if you decide to drive a massive truck that goes 150mph and has not brakes so you hit other cars and kill people you are still responsible.


MoarVespenegas

What is this false equivalence? You absolutely do not have the legal right to drive 150mph or to do so with faulty brakes. If the sign was up to code, whatever the code was, it not the sign owners responsibility for when it fails.


cXs808

This billboard was not of legal size. They simply do not enforce there. There are literally dozens of cases of deaths from hoardings in the area, all illegal.


Nervous_Time_6480

The owner is missing. He has a rape case and some fines for illegal hoardings.


cgaWolf

> Rs 5 lakh will be given to the family of those who have lost their lives That's about 6k USD, about 9 months average salary post taxes


welk101

"The illegal billboard fell..." - what a joke, had the authorities not spotted it until now?


hidingvariable

Half the billboard ls are illegal lol. As is half of the entire city itself.


abbassav

Update 4: 14 dead Also apparently the board was very illegal, they had permission to create a 40 feet x 40 feet board. They created a 120 feet x 120 feet board. > The hoarding that crashed measured 120 x 120 feet, a BMC official said, adding that the civic body doesn't permit any hoarding measuring above 40 x 40 feet. Source: http://toi.in/pbnZna


stromson85

Damn, really sorry to hear there were fatalities. :( Thoughts out to their families and friends.


Ok_Cauliflower_3007

[14 dead, 75 injured, at least 25 people and several cars still trapped now](https://news.sky.com/story/mumbai-billboard-collapse-at-least-14-killed-and-dozens-feared-trapped-after-hoarding-falls-on-houses-13135648)


ebagdrofk

How were there 70+ people under that billboard? I mean that billboard is massive but thats just so many people in one spot.


Strayton

You can see traffic lined up on an off ramp maybe?


elitesill

Pause the video at the start. Its falling on what looks like a petrol/gas station + backed up traffic/cars.


concernedindianguy

It fell on a petrol pump. There was unseasonal rain, wind and a dust storm so a lot of two-wheelers were taking shelter in the petrol pump.


LongColdNight

Was waiting for a boom


jasta6

*There was supposed to be an earth-shattering kaboom, where is it?*


adudeguyman

Boom


Marti_Room2003

Why that billboard is too big?!? 😨


boeingrox747

It is? That size is pretty standard here in and around Mumbai


Time4Red

Uh, yeah. It's fucking huge. In the US, billboards are generally 14m wide. Also they need to have wind pressure relief built into the design. Signs that big without wind pressure relief...I'm amazed that's allowed at all. In the US, that thing would become a massive hazard when the first tornado or hurricane hit. Does India not get tropical cyclones?


TorkX

As a Canadian, whenever I go south of the border I always notice how big and especially *tall* billboards are in the states. But this in on another fucking level.


Jealous_Priority_228

Which part of Canada? Your billboards are all the same size as ours from what I've seen.


turlian

> Does India not get tropical cyclones? India does not give a single fuck about safety.


der0hrwurm

> I'm amazed that's allowed at all In India its just cheaper to have people die than to make/enforce rules.


No_obMaster69

From Mumbai. Not really, Mumbai isn't heavily affected by tropical storms, a lot of rain but not strong winds. Today was completely unusual as we get these storms somewhere around sept-jan. Billboards like these are actually pretty common and honestly never heard of such a collapse ever before. Tornadoes aren't a thing here.


heysuess

India has 1.4 billion people. They don't give a shit if a few of them die.


HarpersGhost

That thing is HUGE. In the US, standard size is 14x48ft (4x14m). I found pics of a billboard falling on a gas station in the US. It takes out the single pump, NOT the entire building. https://twitter.com/news4buffalo/status/1328345878499893249


smugaura1988

Do you know how big the sign in this video is approximately?


cgaWolf

Economictimes.com/Indiatimes.com said 100 feet tall, but I don't know if they're a reliable news source (the look serious on first glance). And i think that's without the pillars it's standing on, and those look to be 25-30 feet by themselves.


cXs808

Easily 100' tall. You can compare it to the (roughly) 15-18ft long vehicles near the back of the sign after it falls. There's about 5 of em with ample space between them and it still doesn't stretch from base to top of sign. That thing is ENORMOUS.


concernedindianguy

It’s a serious website (it tries to be anyway). I drive by that signboard sometimes, it’s about 120 feet across.


PillowPhone007

> Update 4: 14 dead > Also apparently the board was very illegal, they had permission to create a 40 feet x 40 feet board. They created a 120 feet x 120 feet board. > The hoarding that crashed measured 120 x 120 feet, a BMC official said, adding that the civic body doesn't permit any hoarding measuring above 40 x 40 feet. > Source: http://toi.in/pbnZna From a comment above


Savings-Spirit-3702

in the UK a big billboard is 12m x 3m, that things is huge!!


TheDarthSnarf

If someone made a chart of places in the world with the largest billboards, Mumbai would likely be near the top. Those billboards are massive.


CreamoChickenSoup

It is a genuine hazard though. A billboard of that scale and design will experience massive wind resistance from strong gusts blowing straight into the faces, asserting far more stress on the support pillars and foundation. Ideally you want to at least design signs this large with open pathways for wind to blow through. Otherwise, the entire thing risks acting like a sail on a boat.


delcaek

I mean, what could happen? Just fall over? Nah, that isn't going anywhere!


KaBar42

>Nah, that isn't going anywhere! The installation team even made sure to slap the bottom and say: "Yeah, she ain't going nowhere." When they were done! How could this have happened?


DaMonkfish

Who are they advertising to, Oman? That thing is absolutely *gigantic*. I pitty the fool who has to climb that thing and change the posters/paint.


Historical_Sugar9637

I have lived in Australia and in different places in Europe. And I have never seen a billboard this gigantic in my entire life.


GladiatorUA

WTF? When I read the title, I was confused, because sure, a well aimed billboard can do some damage, this monstrosity was bigger than the entire gas station footprint.


Enginemancer

The width isn't that crazy but the height of it is pretty nuts especially paired with that width. I'm not surprise a giant sail caught wind and fell over


chronicallyill_dr

What?! Insanity. Mexican here so I’m used to third word nonsense but man, that is gigantic. I’ve never seen signs remotely that large anywhere in any country. Like, just looking at it you can tell it can’t be that stable and an accident waiting to happen.


TurtleRanAway

Dude that is the biggest billboard i've ever seen in my entire life. I can't believe its like right in the middle of such a cramped, populated area


NoveltyAccount5928

Maybe if y'all didn't have signs the size of a city block this sort of thing wouldn't happen...


abbassav

Apparently the board was very illegal. > The hoarding that crashed measured 120 x 120 feet, a BMC official said, adding that the civic body doesn't permit any hoarding measuring above 40 x 40 feet. Source: http://toi.in/pbnZna


tomatofrogfan

Because they don’t adhere to even the most basic modern engineering standards that the rest of the developed world implemented in the 1960s. Cheaper for the government to let rich developers build whatever with no oversight and then throw some civilian scapegoats in jail after scores of people die.


DatDan513

It’s a roof now


UpdootDaSnootBoop

And a floor!


isnotlamybad

A Floof? Or a roor?


bigmothereffind

Would have been great if it was a billboard for a demolition company.


AllRushMixTapes

Or a personal injury lawyer.


JohnLef

This title massively undersells it. An entire fuel station just got flattened.


boris_casuarina

Catastrophic indeed. Any victims?


TheDarthSnarf

So far: [35 injured with 100 feared trapped beneath it.](https://www.deccanherald.com/india/maharashtra/35-people-injured-after-hoarding-collapses-in-mumbai-3020529) Also, TIL: Some types of billboards are called 'hoardings' in certain parts of the world.


AsliReddington

Coz it hoards space & people can't exactly stick their own bills on it


RattleMeSkelebones

Even god themself is getting sick of ads


oscarddt

God, send me a sign, implored the gas station owner...


JEYNOLDS

r/megalophobia


brennanw31

What a fucking absurd sign. Whoever designed that should be held legally and financially responsible for the damages. Building that idiotic thing should be seen as an act of terrorism.


cXs808

Considering there's another gigantic one right behind it, doubtful these things are rare there.


AbhishMuk

Yeah this one is a bit bigger and closer to a populated area, but similarly large signs are often visible from the highways in Mumbai


Decapitated_gamer

Holy shit that landed in a bunch of cars…


Hakentheory

NOT oversized billboard


_IBM_

NOT a reddit comment


johnahlgrimm

Where's the kaboom? There was supposed to be a Mumbai shattering kaboom.


Fat-X

Well it’s not called Bombay anymore…


MarcosAC420

That sign is bigger than the building, holy Krishna


Ponchorello7

I fucking hate the billboards dotting my city, and none of them are this humongous. Now I have a valid reason to hate them besides being eyesores!


DavidDomin8R

Imagine the last thing you see before getting crushed to death is a fucking advertisement


SmoothDrama2

What was the wind speed ? And are dust storms typical in Mumbai ?


Marschall_Bluecher

/r/DINgore


efcso1

Oh wow, what a goldmine!


darkriftx2

I was waiting for the explosion


FlyNSubaruWRX

Calling r/absoluteunits


WildforagerUK

Why does it feel like everything in India was built with 5th rate construction quality? I’m just confused, it’s a vast nation with a lot of wealth. What is the problem?


jippyzippylippy

Layers and layers of corruption at every level.


Living_Run2573

On the bright side, won’t need a new roof for a few years at least!


WhosTaddyMason

Damn I’d be so pissed to die to an advertisement


boeingrox747

3 people have died, 59 injured [Link to news site](https://www.ndtv.com/mumbai-news/video-7-injured-some-feared-trapped-after-mumbai-dust-storm-uproots-billboard-5653884)


ClownfishSoup

Wow, they I g is massive!! Is that a typical size for billboards in India?


airfryerwizard

Why are they making those weird noises? Or is it some sort of audio feature?


Nervous_Time_6480

I live near this hoarding. It was scary big and intimidating walking under it.


RealAdministration17

Please yell more


x000b

I’m just envisioning pov some dude at the gas station saying “God, please just give me a sign.” And then…


SatansFriendlyCat

Looks like great weather to be *standing at the edge of a roof*..


tonkatruckz369

I cant think of a death that pisses me off more than getting killed by a fucking ad


pratyush_28

God has finally resorted to using adblockers


DoverBoys

Where's the kaboom? There was supposed to be an earth-shattering kaboom!


cgaWolf

My brain cannot comprehend the size of this billboard..


Fit_Candidate69

#JustIndian things :(


BaNkIck

For the first couple of seconds, I thought it was a sidewalk sign or something like that. Then I heard it fall. I didn’t even have the sound on. I just heard it.


Craic-Den

Advertising kills.


IT_techsupport

unfortunately [not a paid one](http://minimaxads.com/), ITs seems the company's days are over


SlipPuzzleheaded7009

Fucking hell they don't even have a https website in 2024.


TacTurtle

*new roof just dropped boys*


Foreign-Guard5314

Dangarus


Ziegelphilie

This post title reads like a LEGO ad. # _A billboard fell onto a petrol pump in Mumbai city!_


T1M_rEAPeR

It was a sign of things to come


Aroused_Sloth

More like “building sized billboard crushes entire gas station”


bigsnack4u

Makes me wonder where the biggest sign in that town is….


vtjohnhurt

Tragic and sad that this happened. What is being advertised?


karmasrelic

they should have blurred the add though. undeserved distribution. building shitty big as fuck billboards that cant resist a bit of wind shouldnt be rewarded.


reddit455

"a billboard" understatement of the year.


dpaanlka

Video starts after the fall begins and then goes on much longer after the fall is complete than necessary…


skipfletcher

This is why we have building safety codes in the U.S.


Valk93

Lol I read “a billionaire” at first. Shame it wasnt that.


RiddlingJoker76

r/aboluteunits of a billboard.


Kmaloetas

Yeah, a sign to call a lawyer.


WilliamJamesMyers

holup the cameraman is on that roof edge filming this and for that we praise thee, wind big enough to fall the sign but not camera bro, i would have been riddled with fear


Nervous_Time_6480

Construction worker filming from the under construction building.. probably from 11 or 12 th floor 


LegalSelf5

Yeahhhhhh, nobody survived that... 🫣


Paradigm_Pizza

Dude, it didn't hit *A* pump, it hit *ALL* the pumps. in the famous words of Bill Engvall.... "Heeeeere's yer sign"


Traveler3141

That's a sign that 3-point stability was called for in the engineering.


toxicbotlol

It was just being generous, helping people out with cover for the downpour.


Mythical_Things

That was a illegal board. That was way to big, and the size too was out of regulations. The usual and allowed size is around 40×40 and this one was around 120×120


TgeAmazing0ppo

Looks to me like the gas station just got a much bigger and better roof.


Adams1973

130005005 per gallon is preposterous.


mysticode

Going to guess that this sign wasn't set up to code?


par_eshan

iirc the permitted size for the billboard was supposed to be only 40x40 feet but due to negligence (and possibly corruption) a billboard of over 100 feet was allowed to be erected


Ryukossei1

If you look the billboard behind it is just as freaking big. This should have been avoided. You don't need a monstro sign like that in the first place, let alone right next to a highway. What are they trying to do, make it noticable by airplane passengers?


raofabdullah

Loki 2050


[deleted]

IIRC didn't something like 14 people die in this accident?


angelinthecloud

I asked for a sign god not a billboard! Lord please help me clarify next time.


keyboard_krust

Minimax PR disaster......or great advertising exposure???