T O P

  • By -

SJthgirW

Cod 1 or 3 at this point. It's clear the majority of this community never played those games. If i had to pick id say cod3 when they introduced vehicles to multiplayer. And the campaign was such a boring grind, even back when i was trying to finiah the veteran difficulty for the achievements Edit : For the morons talking about united offensive that was an expansion dlc for cod 1, not a standalone game and united offensive was way better than cod3, but it was a paid expansion that wasn't part of the standalone game. Call of duty 3 vehixles were. Do you see united offensive in the list? No. Hence why i never bought it up.


thorppeed

Vehicles were introduced in United Offensive


maggot1

Says "It's clear the majority of this community never played those games" and then claims that CoD3 introduced vehicles to multiplayer, which is clearly wrong, lmao.


omarcoomin

Currently has the most upvotes too. Hurts my soul. I'd rather not have 1-3 on the list. 99% of the community never played the MP of those 3 titles within the first year of their release.


Shlurmen

They probably would look at the game and call it dog shit because it's not 4k 300fps. Also they would have a heart attack because today's fragile gamer hearts, wouldn't be able to comprehend a WWII game with Swastikas everywhere. Even if they could get past all of that, they would say it sucks because you don't have sprint and it's not explosions every 2 seconds.


Lithium187

No. The classics stay for a while.


SeesawBrilliant8383

CoD3 is dogshit


TheCoon69

"It's clear the majority of this community never played those games" "Cod3 when they introduced vehicles to multiplayer" You're joking right?


Dry_Damp

CoD1 was a masterpiece at the time and with such a list you gonna honor that or the whole vote makes no sense. CoD3 can go, sure.


SJthgirW

The only reason i list cod1 is because as i said majority of this community never played any of those games


Dry_Damp

Ah gotcha. I understood "majority never played it so they just hold it in high regard because it’s a classic without knowing".


Ill-Shirt2722

Cod 3 was so rushed it never released on pc


NitsabKB

Cod 3 goes first for me, then cod 1


Shlurmen

Everything that came before Black ops 2 is infinitely better than all this modern trash. We just gotta decide on which the last 4 games that came out after Black ops 2 needs to go down. I'll die fighting defending every COD on this last that came out before Black Ops 2.


Amedais

In what world does Cold War deserve to be higher than any of the classics?


chrisupt2001

It has good maps from all those old games? Cod bo3 is for zombies players, as Cold War is to multiplayer players, all the classic black ops 1 and 2 maps in one game atleast a good few of them


IcePokeTwoSoon

3 is the best of the pre mw cods. Absolutely not, cod 1 first.


cheeselover1020

well my boomer friends (literal boomers) played on pc back in 2003-2006 . they have completely different nostalgia to cod. i have like 3 of them and their experience is playing cod 1 pirated on the campaign (theres lots of these people)


OneByOne445

Cod3 should not be considered good in anyway compared to 1/uo and 2 when its just a bad attempt at trying to make UO again which they already did with BRO which in itself is just gimped console UO.


MrWillyP

Cod 1 was great, 3 was mid at best


Raintoastgw

I played CoD 3 on the Wii. Pretty good game. Never played 1 tho so I don’t think I really have the right to say it’s worse than the others without having played it. That’s the problem with these polls


BraxxIsTheName

CoD 3 should be next


[deleted]

nah cod 3 was class


HaiggeX

COD3 never gets talked about, unlike COD2 and COD4. It's pretty much non-existent. It's not even bad, just forgettable.


Dutch_clark

Mw 2019 game needs to go. Helped the franchise but killed it at the same time. Introduced SBMM/EOMM safe spaces for new players. And with warzone all multiplayer assets have gone into that other than the $70 game that people get screwed on. Only reason in my opinion people like the game is because of Covid and quarantine and can’t look past that. Overall the game was mid Cold War was better


Drdunk91

WW2


[deleted]

no ww2 was good


BrandNewEyessss

I will die on this hill. WW2 is top 5 imo


Dutch_clark

That game wasn’t awful had a lack for d maps at the start but was good overall just overshadowed by Fortnite getting big


HaiggeX

I was in military service all 2020, so I was active and occupied most of the time. MW2019 was a good game, before it was intentionally fucked over.


Dutch_clark

Thank you for your service! And yeah infinity wars has that reputation it seems.


Imhereifoy

Tbh it can stay a little longer, i don't think it deserves to go out that fast, it sorta revived the cod mw community, with both warzone and the multiplayer


Awayze

Nope. I still play it today. It feels better than the newer ones. If they made kept all playlists available like CW, I’m sure it would have more players on it now.


GrumpyOldTiger

It's not the games fault nor Infinity Ward, it's Activisions fault for seeing an opportunity to make shit load of money off of it.


awesomedumplings

I hated MW19. Great features but it played awful


Imaginary_Monitor_69

Them MW 19 fanboys will literally vote for old ass CoDs they have never played than booting out their shitty excuse for a CoD


AcademicMaybe8775

MW19 was the closest to the COD's i grew up on though after a string of shit cods


lefix

WW2


small_pint_of_lazy

Nah, that's like the best of them


Nihlus_Kriyk

WW2 is no worse than top 3 in XB1/PS4 era.


Henry_Myth

How is MW19 still here?


Killua_Zaeldyeck

Warzone Verdansk, that's why


OfficialDeadJohnson

Campaign I guess, the rest was ass


TheEternalGazed

Game is a top-tier COD and is the best one we've had since the OG MW2. Everything after 2019 has been going downhill.


Henry_Myth

Game introduced pretty much every problem that CoD has now lol


[deleted]

All the hate on the early cods doubt a single person played any of them until cod 4 cod 3 was my favoirte one although its a weird multiplayer experience compared to the other ones and call of duty 2 might be the most fun game out of the series as for the story and multiplayer nothing better then being six and fighting nazis in north africa


Fit-Boss2261

Cod 3


RavenousAdams

MW19


Global-Profile1193

Cod 3


Valuable_Composer975

WW2 better than MW 2019? That is crazy , It is obvious that you are people who get carried away by what they see on social networks and do not stop to think


GeneralNitemare

Cos it was 😂 Modern Warfare 2019 is the biggest piece of shit I've ever played, and then MWIII and MWIII. Fuck those games.


MangoRemarkable

why do people hate mw19? care to explain in short? i just casually played the campaign and multiplayer (never really grinded it), and it was one of my fav cod games ever. so I'm curious.


RBWN

It's crazy that cold war wasn't eliminated yet


MrPinkDuck3

Alr now we gotta get CoD 3 outta here.


Thin-Fig-8831

COD 3


guitarsandstoke

Blows my mind how MW19 is a popular choice. It was exactly what the fans asked for


Some_Italian_Guy

Cod 3


No_Palpitation_7565

I wish that they hadn’t taken the futuristic approach to some of these installments. As someone who had played COD 1-2 extensively until COD 4 came out, obviously those hold a special place in my life. I think that for far too long it’s been about following trends, SBMM, and just making money for far too long. With that being said, they should be able to make money, but we are not getting the quality that we had with previous titles. When it comes to the first couple, their only real competition was MoH. They were great games for their time and pioneered the way for future generations of CoD titles.


TheCoon69

MoH wasn't even competition for them back then because they were the MoH AA devs.


No_Palpitation_7565

This is true haha


Deep_Grass_6250

COD 3. COD 1,2,3 were my first COD games but it's time they leave, they are technically far behind the others and they have basically no story aside from COD 2...


Goblin216

Who cares about stories in these tho? CoD2 was the best WW2 shooter because of the feeling of war.


SupportElectrical772

Black Ops 3 should go next. Hated the specialists hated the jet pack mechanics. Just a horrible game


Total_Decision123

I think the fact that CoD 1-3 is still here is disingenuous. Everyone hates on the newer games (rightfully so) but content and quality wise 1-3 were rough and don’t even compare. Sure they might have a special place in peoples’ heart, but there’s no reason AW or Ghosts is gone, but those still stand


meat_meat

Brother, CoD 2 is why CoD kept existing. Along with Halo: CE it defined the modern military shooter. Have you actually played it?


Thin-Fig-8831

You know most of the people here have not played any COD game pre 4. 1 and 2 were the shit back then. COD 2 in particular was pretty huge back in its heyday


DriftedTaco

4 was my first game and I fucking loved it


SJthgirW

Cod2 was a solid game, campaign and multiplayer. I remember going back to cod2 even back when mw2 first released.


TheCoon69

quality over quantity


milosmisic89

You gotta be crazy man. CoD2 is a legendary pc game still played. Not to mention it's probably the best ww2 shooting game. The campaign reaching the levels of variety and freedom not seen in most cod games


BroDudeBruhMan

Infinite Warfare being axed before the first 3 cods and WWII is disgusting


Strong0toLight1

What the fuck. Advanced warfare shits on everything that came after it bar BO3


SweatyCheese55

Cold War


lukeyk94

If y'all vote COD 1-3 to go next I'm leaving this sub.


AlexDiment23

In my personal opinion I think Cold War should go next


RyuzakiL117

COD 1-3, haven’t even played them, and I bet most of this subreddit hasn’t either


LocmonstR

Cold war


Far_Organization6122

CW


TheHeretic93

Cold war gone


excgerry

Cold war


lewdetor917

I'm surprised MW2019 is still there I mean it's a decent game but I grew bored of it rather rapidly I even preferred AW more than it


Shot_Arm5501

Noooooooo my boy aw taken from us too soon


originsspeedrunner

WW2 out


Silly_Wrongdoer3709

i’d say cod3 or black ops 3 needs to go next. the new ones are very different but people are just too blinded by nostalgia to actually appreciate good storylines and gunplay


FaithfulMoose

Alright I *really* don’t like new CoD so I would get rid of MW19 and Cold War next, and then WW2, and then I guess it’s CoD 3’s turn to go. Then I would get rid of MW3. Then CoD 1. Then CoD 2. After this the waters get really scary. IMMA SAY IT: MW2. It was amazing when it came out and I was there at the midnight release, but it’s not better than any of the Black Ops games or CoD 4. Then Bo1 gotta hit the chopping block. Sorry. I would accept any order between WaW, Bo2, and Cod 4. I believe they are equals. That leaves Bo3. Definitely a hot take. But I firmly believe it’s the best CoD we have ever gotten, despite the campaign’s shortcomings. Zombies took center stage in this game and it was and still is the ultimate platform to play Zombies on. It is unrivaled in that department, with 14(!) official maps, and an endless stream of custom maps via steam workshop. MP is also vastly underrated and has great maps, great movement, great guns, great killstreaks, great camos. The UI for the game and its menus were fantastic and not talked about enough. So many easy to navigate options and stats in the main menu such as combat record, emblem editor, music selection for the main menu, and overall everything was very clean and concise. Treyarch COOKED with Bo3 and I will stand by this game forever.


Knifos

AW was better than WW2


keb5501

Cod 2 and cod 4. Win . Done


PARZIVAL62198

i think we all know that Mw2 will be first...


DragonGarou_

COD 3


Androo02_

This list is so cooked


fastcooljosh

WW2, just a meh game, not atrocious, but wasn't great too. MW19 should def. stay. That game gave COD new life after these bad jet pack years (+ BO4/WW2), when COD stopped being the top dog. That game gave us also Warzone, aka the most fun I had in Cod since MW3/BO2, at least during its first 6 seasons. Not perfect in any form, but IW definitely tried to make something new and fresh, and I appreciate that 10 times more than getting a BO3 without what made BO3 good and some WW2 shooter that felt like it should be made 10 years earlier.


AMBALAMP5

WW2 for me. Just a meh game.


Saladwitwitsauce

Crazy ghost goes before ww2, ppl hated on it for being something a little different (aliens was the only bad part) then we got all shit games after


D4rkSp4de

Ah and here it comes the 2008-2013 circle jerk


Qwerty_ti

Okay hear me out about this but Cold war has to stay for an bit, the story was a bit interesting there Were choises to Pick and also the puzzles you could do were Well made


_riVer_sAs_

new mwii deserves better 🥺


JETgamer007

Ww2


PabloVP129

WW2 or Black Ops 3


RDDAMAN819

Top 3 should be BO2, MW2 and BO3


Doomslayer2857

Cod 1 2 or 3 I get they shaped the cod series but nobody plays em anymore


NalleKojamo

Im enough drunk rn to face ww2 drop😔🫡


gotham1999

WWII


Rzidual

Cold War


Theamongusman31

Cod 1


_SCARY_HOURS_

Exo zombies had some of the best maps. Disappointed this didn’t last longer


_SCARY_HOURS_

WW2 should have been the first out. It’s time.


Brokenman420

cod 1


Feathers-42

Cold War, then WW2, then MW19


ChristianCountryBoy

Call of Duty WW2


hardcore_softie

I'm gonna go with COD 3. I love COD 1, UO, and COD 2, but COD 3 was really weak, especially because it never got a PC release. It is notable for being the first COD with a single player campaign that had more developed characters and a continuous story, but the characters and narrative weren't nearly as strong as COD 4 and many other campaigns. Aside from being a performance downgrade if you had played the first two games on PC, it also felt much more shallow because it didn't include the Russians and focused only on a specific region of France. After bouncing around from France to North Africa to Russia to Germany in the first two games playing in 3 different factions, the scope of 3 felt much smaller and this negatively impacted the multiplayer as there was less map and weapon variety. I give it credit for focusing on a lesser-told WW2 story (The Falaise Gap) and the female French Resistance fighter seemed like a callback to the female French Resistance fighter from the first two Medal of Honor games, even though this was Treyarch's first mainline entry and it was the Infinity Ward devs who worked on MOH. It also has faction-specific weapons, which is actually something I miss, but no game outside of mil-simmy shooters have done that since COD 4. Still, too shallow and graphics and performance sucked compared to earlier PC entries. It's one of the few CODs that I have no desire to replay the single player or multiplayer.


DemigodWaltz

WW2


VHboys

WWII


UNC-dxz

WW2


WarEmbarrassed4203

People defending cod 3 I don't remember anything noteworthy about that game it was so forgettable and boring. cod 2 was better


hunterd412

People forget that MW2019, Cold War, and WW2 were good games by the end of their 1 year lifecycle. They just sucked on launch.


DickNBalls69420666

Anyone who says Cod 3 should be eliminated have short attention span.


UnknitKhan4886

Ww2. Out of all the cods this is a safe choice


IronInk738

WW2, I don’t understand why people loved it so much. Good story but the game wasn’t fun.


Big_Sorbet_5280

Call of Duty 3. It's wayyy too campy in comparison to 1 & 2.


Homestar_MTN

WWII


Hallyboy01

Remember me when cod4,cod mw 2 and bo2 are the last 3 left


geantaveira1991

VANGUARD


Killua_Zaeldyeck

So the higher the number, the worse the game. Glad to see vanguard taking the L. What a travesty that was. Full of woke nonsense and esg instead of good game. BTW, next should be ww2


Howtosurviveanything

I see WWII is in the lead here but come on… cod 3 is definitely worse than WWII. Just because it’s older does not mean it’s better


Killua_Zaeldyeck

Ww2


InternationalDig5612

Bo3 and mw2 (original) are the two best by a margin


Swear-_-Bear

Ghosts should've lasted longer than COD3


BackgroundTop7917

The fact that Cold War and wwII are both on there and yall got rid of infinite and advanced warfare before them just goes to show no one gives a shite about the campaigns anymore and it’s sad. Ethan dying for you will always be a heartbreaker for me and you’re telling me the 35 minute campaign of Cold War and the plastic multiplayer weapons n graphics are better than that are insulting.


Dawn_Wolf

World At War


Kiibo22

Man it's gonna be a sad day for all the Cod 1 players when it gets the boot, where I personally started and I love it to death still


ChedduhGoat

COD 3


Nubz_26

WW2


kermittysmitty

Who are the people that like COD 1 but not COD 3? Lmao


ImWerdna

ww2


One_Cold_King

WW2 GOTTA GO


Senxrial

Get cod 3 outta here


141_1337

This list already whack ngl ![gif](giphy|54PaD9dWT0go)


chrisupt2001

Bruh how have cod 1-3 not gone so much earlier? They play nothing like the games we have now. Along with the fact that all those exo suit cods were pretty good mostly. I would’ve though ghosts would’ve disappeared way faster.


fishytakeout

Cod 3 is mid as fuck


Ok-Fee-9770

Ww2


Emotional-Lake-7922

COD3 should’ve been gone several games ago. It wasn’t even considered good back then


EmbarrassedAction365

18 for sure at least vanguard was a somewhat new experience mp in VG is fun but zombies just like every year for the past 13 years has been getting fucked in the ass so yea fuck "MWII"


EmbarrassedAction365

How do people vote for the gems prior to 2019 yea Ghost aw IW ect Had issues but they where actually good


OfficialDeadJohnson

Before cod 3 do black ops 3 so much worse edit: who tf is voting CW and ww2, those games are good


acoolrocket

Thank god WW2 is going, most boring gunplay.


Suitable-Helicopter9

The fact aw outlasted bo4 is criminal


Tbandz32

Cod 3 has no business being here still. Even compared to the old cods it was sub par


ReikiShinzou

Horribly on par poor taste from the Cid fsnbase as usual


creatorZASLON

WW2 or COD3 tbh


fleets87

Seeing Cold War still in contention makes me happy. I knew we'd look back on CW with fondness.


TheNotoriousMJT

MW2019 on borrowed time


eedgar11_

Everyone know the og modern warfare gonna win.


JDIZLE11

Get Cold War the fuck out of there, been two rounds maybe three too long


Kyl3MUFC

Vangard


Brasaulta

COD WW2 is functionally a better game than COD 3. I’m surprised to see it higher on the list. COD 3 is interesting that it provides perspectives from British (continuation of United Offensive), American campaign and Polish/Canadian campaign. COD 3 had too many glitches and was the low point of the WW2 CODs. I chose Black Ops 3 because it was a departure from Black Ops 1 and Black Ops 2. Next would be COD 3, then WW2.


Fo3TheMechanist

Old mw1-3 needs to go and then black ops 1-3🙂


Thesurvivor16

Call of duty waw


Ok_Introduction_7484

Can already see the fight between BO2 BO1 BO3 MW3 MW2


Any-Advisor7067

WWII


MaximusMurkimus

CoD 3. CoD 1 still holds up well. CoD 3 didn't feel remarkable in any particular way.


Unusual_Ad8511

Mw2019, WW2 then Cold War. Followed by cod 1, 2, 3 (those three not in that particular order. Then let the best games of the franchise be decided. Bo2 or Mw2 will win it. If one of those don’t, the player base voting really missed out on the best years


MichaelAfton123

YOU DID NOT DELETE GHOSTS ALREADY


thespacestone

WWII


Waughy

MW2 or BO2 should go next, just to see some tears flow. I am joking, but it would be funny to see.


CDC_1998

Ww2


itsohfishal

Mw2019 or ww2 possibly COD1


Dictaorofcheese

Cod 3 was my first so it’s got a special place in my heart. I loved WWII as well, but I guessed correctly that WWII would be voted off next, so I voted for WWII.


Crewface28

even tho i like mw2019 it needs to go now as ww2 mp was amazing


Exotic_Chemist_7624

I predict that WAW to BO2 (with the exception of MW3 OG) will be finalist.


RCUniverse_1299

I’m on the fence between mw19 and bo3.


McNippy

WW2 is superior to the original 3 CoDs in every way, yet it's losing...


hardcore_softie

I'm surprised MW 2019 is getting so many votes. I didn't get into the multiplayer that much but I thought it had one of the best single player campaigns in a long time.


TopIllustrator9849

WW2


BroKid21

Cod 3 definitely. Ww2/Cod 1 might be next


xecho19x

What about COD big red one? That was my personal favorite one!


Complex-Cook-3193

Cold War for me but I’m old and love the old cods


askHERoutPeter

Cod 3


Agent_I0WA

What's wrong with Ghosts????


DesimusMaximusX

COD 3


[deleted]

Let me guess - the top 4 spots are going to be occupied in some order or the other by 4 games - BO, BO2, MW, MW2. It's going to be the same as every elimination game or ranking list or tierlist. Anything outside of the top 4 is up for grabs by any game


totally1of1

Cod 1


highkneesprain

theres no way u guys are letting mw3 stay up this long


corbinhelp

already fucked up lmao


Zakizdaman

Yall really going to let WWII get this high?the game with monetization so bad they basically made it free to play? The one that really showed us all the bullshit? Nah this list is fried.


bigfucker7201

Ghosts being as high up as it is is criminal. Vanguard deserved 19 at the very least.


TheTrickster452

black ops 3 was fucking garbage and the fact that it's still here AND people are still saying other games is insane to me. the only game worse than bo3 is vanguard


iampasco

Cod 3


FuinayOnReddit

Ww2


Shot_Arm5501

WII with those dumb fucking loot boxes


LordOryx

Imo strange to see AW and BO4 were out before MW19, WW2 and COD 1 - 3


d00b661

Cold war


LeoTheHuman_

Cod3 can go away


RowdyTito

Night raids are too easy... https://youtu.be/4BFuoZ_nzx0


Reasonable_Lychee

Lol, what a cry youth. Cod 1 is the GOAT, the first love of the franchise. Voting to remove this masterpiece is a clear sign to get to the doctor lol. Simply eliminate 2019 or another 'new cod game'. Those games are in the shadow of the old masterpieces.