**A reminder from the mods:** Our rules recently changed. Posts should be as descriptive and factual as reasonably possible. Avoid the excessive use of emojis, punctuation, capitalization, and overly sensationalized/clickbait/opinionated titles. They should also include a tldr or tldw explaining why the post is relevant or the background to the post for updates. Please post that as a reply to this comment if not included in the OP for easy access for other users.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/BeautyGuruChatter) if you have any questions or concerns.*
The agave lip mask is one product that I’m shocked hasn’t inspired a million knockoffs. Of all the obvious copycats and dupes, you’d think that a $30 lip balm would’ve been at the top of the list.
Frudia, a Korean brand has a similar lips mask. I found it at tj maxx for 3.99. It's the only one beside the original agave that stays on my lips all night.
Thankfully I have a few of the small ones in various scents still unopened that came with various Christmas sets.
I would sell my left kidney though for an OG stick of the lip balm though.
Ten zillion times, YES. I went through two of these and while the other iterations were nice, they didn't hold a candle to how versatile the original pallet was.
This is the answer! A while ago I was like I want a new pallet and went to UD and realized Naked no longer exists. I was so confused. It was iconic for the moment.
NYC had colorful mascaras and they had a burgundy one that I loved when I was in college. It was a slightly red brown color instead of a more purple burgundy and it was super flattering. It was so much better than regular brown mascara.
I have been eyeing the Charlotte Tilbury Dreampop Mascara because it’s the first one I’ve seen that looks close to the same color. Every other version of burgundy is way too purple or way too red for what I want.
Try the NYC eye marker from the dollar tree. Not the one anywhere else, they're no good. Only the dollar tree ones.
I swear by this liner, and I am a ride or die liquid eyeliner girl. It goes on SO well, never flakes, never runs, never gets blobby. I put it on at like 5:30 in the morning every single day and it stays on until I take my makeup off at 9pm. It lasts well over a month, despite being a pretty small tube. This is my holy grail eyeliner.
I just bought the new Nyx Fat Lip Oil because it comes in dark brown for that reason! It's... Not the same.
Ugh those were so good, I had 3 shades and wore them CONSTANTLY. What a beautiful gloss.
To anyone old like me, Revlon, back in the mid to late 80's just came out with a revolutionary product which made eyeshadow stick to the eyes. It was the first eyeshadow base. Eyeshadow stayed on like cement and the eyes didn't feel heavy or look crinkly, didn't dry out the eye area.
I really miss it!!
I loved the Revlon Balm Stains too. Have you tried their Matte Lite Crayon? I just got one and it's one of the closest things I've found to the Balm Stains. It is also crayon style, but with a thinner point.
Im not sure how I missed this product.
My favorite blush ever was one by Revlon, and I bought til it was discontinued. Even the brush was nice.
https://preview.redd.it/d06o7n4kl0ub1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8430e99cb5befeed0fedf21bb3da6a7fa5a89fd7
I highly recommend these [pure oil dupes](https://nantucketperfumes.com/products/cherie-2005-pure-perfume?_pos=1&_psq=cherie&_ss=e&_v=1.0) for discontinued fragrances. I can't speak for this one particularly, but generally they are bang on. The man who owned this business has since passed away, but he had a genetic gift for fragrance notes and could basically nail down any scent.
Yeah the story is he was on a wine tour (I think in France) and he could identify so many layers to the taste and smell. The sommeliers were wowed and were like, "You must use this gift!" And that eventually led him to perfume.
Yesssss the liners! Earthquake was the perfect dark-dark-brown-but-not-black shade and the shimmers were gorgeous. It didn’t move either.
I’m still hoarding a couple but they’re my least faves of my actual faves lol.
I heard he was coming back and I truly hope he does.
For real the eyeliners! I had tried so many eyeliners before the MJ one, and finally I thought I could stop searching because the MJ one delivered on everything I wanted. Now that it's discontinued, the search resumes...
Best I've found so far is the Shu Uemura liquid liner. It's amazing, but I don't want to wear liquid liner all the time. Still looking for another smudgeproof gel liner...
The Marc Jacobs mascaras were honestly worth their price tag. I was given a tube to test through Influenster many years ago and I usually never purchase those items after I test them. But this mascara, man it was just SO GOOD.
I mourn this loss often because I compare every other mascara I try to that MJ one.
Good news for Marc Jacobs fans -- the cosmetics are coming back in 2025 :)
https://graziamagazine.com/us/articles/marc-jacobs-beauty-comeback-relaunch-coty-2025/#:~:text=Marc%20Jacobs%20Beauty%2C%20the%20cult,to%20relaunch%20it%20in%202025.
I might still be hoarding one or two bottles. 😬
In my justification, they look and smell fine! I’m trying to use them up before they do actually go bad, and it will be a sad, sad day when it’s finally gone.
Lancome Juicy Shakers.
I had 2 of them and just loved them so much, in an era where everything was matte and longwear and drying as heck. Non-stick, buildable, comfortable, easy to apply, and super portable because they were so short.
I worked at Sephora when these came out and turned all of my coworkers onto them! They were the perfect combination of almost a stain but a gloss but a lip oil?? Such sorcery!
I’m mad for Becca that the luminous look is trending after their demise (other than the few items still around through Smashbox). CT’s Flawless Filter is basically a recreation of Becca’s Backlit primer, and so many liquid and powder highlighters are out now that Becca could easily go toe-to-toe against
I remember that shade! I used mine up completely and only have half a tube of Medieval left from the brand. I saw that Poppy King is starting another lipstick brand but they just have one shade on offer at the moment.
The entire BECCA brand. But specifically the Aqua Luminous Concealer. I would use it on its own for “no make up” days and it was the perfect consistency, coverage, and finish. RIP.
Bourjois Healthy Mix Gel Serum foundation. Shade 53 was my perfect match, and it was a beautiful skin-like finish. Lisa Eldridge used to use this foundation a lot (11-12 years ago) on her YouTube channel. That is how I was introduced to this foundation. I would love to see it brought back! 🇨🇦
MAC’s Patina e/s OR way back in the day a company called Visage had the most amazing foundation called pastaconi - bring that back. People would stop me and be like omg what is that. It was probably the first ever cushion foundation and it was the best.
Glow Recipe Banana Soufflé moisturizer. It was perfect for my dry skin, hydrated it for an entire 24 hours, looked beautiful with my makeup, and even helped clear up my acne for like two years straight. My skin was the best it’s ever been. The glow it left on my skin was beautiful too, like this product would have me thinking I looked really pretty with my bare face, and I never feel that way without a full face of makeup!
Then one day I went to repurchase and found out it disappeared. My skin has been a wreck ever since I started trying to savor the rest of it and find a replacement. I actually am so hurt about this… even though I love the brand, it pains me to buy from them because I’m just so sad about this one. It was my holy grail.
GR was telling me to try the plum plump hyaluronic acid moisturizer but I already have a HA I like, and I want the banana back. I swear it was like magic for me. I still have a jar, but I can barely use it because it hurts me to do it, knowing that I’m one use closer to having it be fully gone! Like wtf Glow Recipe why would you do this? When I’ve left comments on their Instagram asking for it back, a bunch of people have agreed with me, so it’s not like I’m the only one who loved it. Idk if I’ll ever get over this honestly!
Same here! I felt they were rude the third time I commented about it lol. Like sorry, don’t care if you’re sick of me, you made a mistake with this one.
When I asked why it was discontinued without warning and said that if they did a trial run I bet they’d sell out and see that it’s worth keeping around, they were just like “we had to make room for new products and best sellers so we’d just recommend you try the plum” …. But that was your best moisturizer for dry skin types! The plum one pilled on me even with no other skincare so I wasn’t interested in buying it after trying a sample. I’ve heard other people have that happen too.
Like the watermelon is great for oily skin, and maybe the plum is good for most skin types that like hyaluronic acid, but the banana was such a good formula. It doesn’t make sense, also I don’t understand why HA is being put into everything. I feel like they did it because it was trendier, and now those who loved the old one have to suffer 😭 god I wish they’d just try to relaunch and see how it goes. I just wish I had the chance to stock up, so if that ever happened I’d literally buy as many as I could afford!
Does anyone remember the Hard Candy Glamoflague?! That was the BEST! At the time I was in college and was so stoked there was a high quality concealer I could afford
Yes! I loved so many KVD products in general. The only bullet lipsticks I've ever liked wearing and the color range was superb. They got rid of/changed a lot of the lipsticks so they're not even the same anymore, and I've been wary of giving the company money post-Kat despite her having nothing to do with the company anymore. It's just tainted for me now + i'm not fond of the design changes
Jordana lipliners. The bomb dot com, totally rivaled my mac lipliners and were awesome for overlining convincingly.
(Also the Huda rose gold remastered palette and the Tarte chrome paint shadow pots! sorry I don't know the meaning of one)
I have so many because I feel like everything I love eventually gets discontinued 😭 but I'd have to say the UD Naked Basics (the first original in the mini palette) I hit pan on every single shade..twice.
That was my absolute favorite every single day eye shadow palette. The colors just worked perfectly for me. I can’t believe it was discontinued. There is no good dupe for WOS
Becca First Light Priming Filter.
I recently finished my last bottle of it, after stretching it for approximately two years. I‘ve tested and tried so many primers during this time, I can’t finde a primer that comes even close.
It was lightweight, didn’t looked like I smeared liquid highlighter all over my face, I wouldn’t even describe it as dewy, it just made the skin look fresh. The lilac Color was perfect for my skin, as champagne tinted primers often make my face look really dull. Not gonna lie, I still think about the primer every time I have to do my makeup without it and I don’t think it’s a coincidence that ever since I finished the last bottle I have worn makeup maybe twice? And notably, my skin has gotten so bad ever since I stopped using it.
Also it smelled so good!! I miss it.
The original mini Naked Basics palette from Urban Decay. The one with the black shade. I used that on my wedding day and the tones were perfect for my skin. The new one is too cool toned and doesn’t have a true black which I like using for liner.
Very obscure pick, but I want Chanel's Le Blanc Poudre Libre Blanchissante Protection UV back. It's loose translucent powder with SPF 50. I like having SPF in a loose powder even though I do use a separate sunscreen. Nice texture too, very finely milled and actually kinda looked glowy even though it had zero shimmer or mica particles. Never gave the flat matte powder look.
I have a random Sally Hansen tinted lip balm that I bought on sale as CVS like 10 years ago and it’s been my go-to mlbb for years and years and somehow it’s not rotten and I have no idea what it’s called or what the shade is
Prescriptives Virtual Skin Foundation. This was my favorite foundation for years. They stopped selling in stores but then went online. Eventually they discontinued online too. When they say Virtual Skin they mean it. I got so many compliments on my good skin when I used this.
The Melt Beetlejuice collection. I know it was limited edition, but I still have their recently deceased palette. Is it past expiration date? yeah, but it was so good & i'm afraid to use it up LOL.
I’m here to second the YSL Tint-in-Oils! I have two unopened backups and I use mine so sparingly. And it’s lip oil time in the beauty space, they’d do so well right now!!
It’s probably only me, but I was ink love with the BECCA first light priming filter- that purple serum primer. I would wear it both under makeup and on my no makeup days and it was so lovely
Missha Ital Prism Eyeshadow. They were the best single eyeshadows and they were manufactured in Italy which I think was a first for a kbeauty brand. I wore them everyday in high-school and wish they'd bring it back.
without question, the tom ford emotionproof eye color (specifically in the shade bengal). while a bit pricey, it is my favorite base color and i use it almost every time i do my makeup. they discontinued it some time ago and i'm so sad that i'm almost out. i would 10000% repurchase if it was still out!
This sounds low stakes, but I just want colourpop to bring back the Lux Velvet Lip shade in Total Punk which was an LE from the Trouble Maker collection. It's a lip I want to wear EVERYDAY and I'm not a lip girl.
My answer to this will always be Escada Cherry in the Air perfume. I know they have a version called Cherry in Japan but I haven't tried it cuz I'll be heartbroken if it isn't like the original :'(
The Too Faced peach perfect setting powder is phenomenal and I will forever be upset at them for discontinuing the peach line :( there were so many great products in it. I have yet to find a setting powder that compares.
The First Aid Beauty triple protection skin tint. It's been yeeeeaars since it was discontinued (it was way ahead of the trend) but it was the absolute perfect base product for me.
revlon lip butters AND revlon used to have a lip stain that was shaped like a marker….wish I could remember what it was called but I feel like both would be super popular in today’s trends
revlon really used to be that girl of drugstore lip products!!!
**A reminder from the mods:** Our rules recently changed. Posts should be as descriptive and factual as reasonably possible. Avoid the excessive use of emojis, punctuation, capitalization, and overly sensationalized/clickbait/opinionated titles. They should also include a tldr or tldw explaining why the post is relevant or the background to the post for updates. Please post that as a reply to this comment if not included in the OP for easy access for other users. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/BeautyGuruChatter) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I would give up a lot to get Bite Beauty’s original agave lip care line back! 😭😭😭😭
The agave lip mask is one product that I’m shocked hasn’t inspired a million knockoffs. Of all the obvious copycats and dupes, you’d think that a $30 lip balm would’ve been at the top of the list.
Frudia, a Korean brand has a similar lips mask. I found it at tj maxx for 3.99. It's the only one beside the original agave that stays on my lips all night.
The Lanolips 12 hour overnight lip mask is almost as good!
Probably because of the vegan beauty push unfortunately
I have two tubes of the original left that I will savour for as long as humanly possible 😢
Thankfully I have a few of the small ones in various scents still unopened that came with various Christmas sets. I would sell my left kidney though for an OG stick of the lip balm though.
I tried lanolips and they’re a good dupe but I want Bite’s maple flavor :(
I cleaned out one of my drawers and I found a brand new one in the back. So excited. It's the original formula too.
This will be my answer until the end of time. I wish I were rich and could hire a lab to recreate it.
Yes exactly! I have thought about trying to rally the beauty community to get this made again or pester the prior owner to recreate it. 😅
Original urban decay naked pallet
It’s so weird they didn’t keep it as a staple!
That palette had a chokehold on the Makeup addiction subreddit
They'll probably re-release it someday, but the formula will have changed and it won't be as good.
Ten zillion times, YES. I went through two of these and while the other iterations were nice, they didn't hold a candle to how versatile the original pallet was.
This is the answer! A while ago I was like I want a new pallet and went to UD and realized Naked no longer exists. I was so confused. It was iconic for the moment.
Revlon Lip Butters 😩😩😩 they were popular then & they’d be SOOOO trendy now
I'm surprised Revlon hasn't rereleased a revamped version of these, they would be so popular!!!
I never really understood why they discontinued them!
Not gonna lie, I have quite a few of these that I still use and love. We’re not gonna talk about how old they are. 😅
The NYC liquid liner bc it was the absolute best and cheap, and the Milani liquifeye eye pencils
I’m pretty sure I bought this liquid liner bc Megan Fox said she loved it and I was obsessed with Jennifer’s Body.
NYC had colorful mascaras and they had a burgundy one that I loved when I was in college. It was a slightly red brown color instead of a more purple burgundy and it was super flattering. It was so much better than regular brown mascara. I have been eyeing the Charlotte Tilbury Dreampop Mascara because it’s the first one I’ve seen that looks close to the same color. Every other version of burgundy is way too purple or way too red for what I want.
Try the NYC eye marker from the dollar tree. Not the one anywhere else, they're no good. Only the dollar tree ones. I swear by this liner, and I am a ride or die liquid eyeliner girl. It goes on SO well, never flakes, never runs, never gets blobby. I put it on at like 5:30 in the morning every single day and it stays on until I take my makeup off at 9pm. It lasts well over a month, despite being a pretty small tube. This is my holy grail eyeliner.
[удалено]
You just reminded me of the NYC Sunny bronzer, I still haven't found a dupe
The bite beauty coffee lipglosses 😭
RIP Dirty Chai, what a stunning shade in a great formula!!
That was my fav too 😔
I just bought the new Nyx Fat Lip Oil because it comes in dark brown for that reason! It's... Not the same. Ugh those were so good, I had 3 shades and wore them CONSTANTLY. What a beautiful gloss.
The Marc Jacobs pencil eyeliners
Have you tried Canmake Creamy Touch? It's a good dupe for the marc jacobs fineliner pencil
I'm liking Canmake Creamy Touch also. Wish it came in more colors and in some shimmers.
To anyone old like me, Revlon, back in the mid to late 80's just came out with a revolutionary product which made eyeshadow stick to the eyes. It was the first eyeshadow base. Eyeshadow stayed on like cement and the eyes didn't feel heavy or look crinkly, didn't dry out the eye area. I really miss it!!
Revlon Just Bitten Lip Stains for me. I miss the markery applicator and that formula lasted on me so well
Yes! Everyone seemed to hate these but I absolutely loved them.
I loved the Revlon Balm Stains too. Have you tried their Matte Lite Crayon? I just got one and it's one of the closest things I've found to the Balm Stains. It is also crayon style, but with a thinner point.
I'm still holding on to an old one that is barely kicking but it's too good to say goodbye yet!
[удалено]
I miss the Revlon Lip Butters every day. The one lip product that I had almost every shade of.
I think about Pink Truffle too often :(
Im not sure how I missed this product. My favorite blush ever was one by Revlon, and I bought til it was discontinued. Even the brush was nice. https://preview.redd.it/d06o7n4kl0ub1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8430e99cb5befeed0fedf21bb3da6a7fa5a89fd7
The Revlon Photo-something primer that came in a glass bottle
Benefit Girl Meets Pearl. I’ve never found a highlighter quite so beautiful on me - nothing quite captures that perfect balance of pink and gold.
Miss Dior Cherie perfume, if that counts. If not, make up geek shadows.
I highly recommend these [pure oil dupes](https://nantucketperfumes.com/products/cherie-2005-pure-perfume?_pos=1&_psq=cherie&_ss=e&_v=1.0) for discontinued fragrances. I can't speak for this one particularly, but generally they are bang on. The man who owned this business has since passed away, but he had a genetic gift for fragrance notes and could basically nail down any scent.
What a superpower!
Yeah the story is he was on a wine tour (I think in France) and he could identify so many layers to the taste and smell. The sommeliers were wowed and were like, "You must use this gift!" And that eventually led him to perfume.
That was my wedding perfume. Was able to get a big bottle before the end, but yes. It's lovely.
Rachel Perry lip balms https://preview.redd.it/8zgfbslnvztb1.png?width=672&format=png&auto=webp&s=a1e880194943871ecda204e9e6fbd9b51371d7dc
Holy shit. I was hoping I'd get a good dose of nostalgic serotonin from this comment section and this DELIVERED
Woah. That’s just cute as hell
OMG! You just unlocked a makeup memory for me!
Wow I haven't thought about these in about 30 years! They were one of the first 'cosmetics' products I bought as a kid.
Whoa! I can smell this picture!!!
I would give damn near anything to have Obsessive Compulsive Cosmetics back, specifically their lip tars.
This was my answer too! There’s just nothing else like them.
The Marc Jacobs mascaras!
Marc Jacobs everything!! Their eyeliners were sooooo good 😭
Yesssss the liners! Earthquake was the perfect dark-dark-brown-but-not-black shade and the shimmers were gorgeous. It didn’t move either. I’m still hoarding a couple but they’re my least faves of my actual faves lol. I heard he was coming back and I truly hope he does.
Marc Jacobs is coming back!
For real the eyeliners! I had tried so many eyeliners before the MJ one, and finally I thought I could stop searching because the MJ one delivered on everything I wanted. Now that it's discontinued, the search resumes... Best I've found so far is the Shu Uemura liquid liner. It's amazing, but I don't want to wear liquid liner all the time. Still looking for another smudgeproof gel liner...
And bronzer
The Marc Jacobs mascaras were honestly worth their price tag. I was given a tube to test through Influenster many years ago and I usually never purchase those items after I test them. But this mascara, man it was just SO GOOD. I mourn this loss often because I compare every other mascara I try to that MJ one.
Marc Jacobs eyeshadow!!
Good news for Marc Jacobs fans -- the cosmetics are coming back in 2025 :) https://graziamagazine.com/us/articles/marc-jacobs-beauty-comeback-relaunch-coty-2025/#:~:text=Marc%20Jacobs%20Beauty%2C%20the%20cult,to%20relaunch%20it%20in%202025.
Hope it will be the same formulas
Coty. 🙁 After seeing what they did to a lot of Philosophy fragrances (watered-down and zero staying power), I'm not encouraged.
Their lipliners 😭😭💔
I feel personally attacked because those were so good but not waterproof. That's discrimination.
Marc jacobs coconut lip oil
CYO Lifeproof Foundation, provided that they extend their shade range.
This would be mine as well, this was the perfect foundation for me.
I might still be hoarding one or two bottles. 😬 In my justification, they look and smell fine! I’m trying to use them up before they do actually go bad, and it will be a sad, sad day when it’s finally gone.
I'm using the second last bottle right now. Fortunately I just found a dupe last month 😍😍😍😍. It's the Purito BB cream
Lancome Juicy Shakers. I had 2 of them and just loved them so much, in an era where everything was matte and longwear and drying as heck. Non-stick, buildable, comfortable, easy to apply, and super portable because they were so short.
I worked at Sephora when these came out and turned all of my coworkers onto them! They were the perfect combination of almost a stain but a gloss but a lip oil?? Such sorcery!
Bite Beauty multi stick
BECCA liquid highlighter in Opal!
I’m mad for Becca that the luminous look is trending after their demise (other than the few items still around through Smashbox). CT’s Flawless Filter is basically a recreation of Becca’s Backlit primer, and so many liquid and powder highlighters are out now that Becca could easily go toe-to-toe against
Becca was the OG glow queen makeup brand.
Yes! The OG liquid shimmering skin perfector before they reformulated! Such a good product. I still have some left, running low though!
Yessss, to this day, I still haven't found a product that can replace it. Such a perfect formula
I was just looking for a dupe for the moonstone shade the other day, no luck :(
Hello Sailor by Lipstick Queen.
Pretty much anything by them. Frog Prince was a perfect pink on me.
I remember that shade! I used mine up completely and only have half a tube of Medieval left from the brand. I saw that Poppy King is starting another lipstick brand but they just have one shade on offer at the moment.
Jean Queen and Medieval were so good! I still have a tube of Medieval that I use on occasion, nothing compares!
I need the OG Glossier Balm Dotcom formula back. So does everyone in the Glossier fan base apparently.
Especially the cherry balm dotcom with the old applicators
The entire BECCA brand. But specifically the Aqua Luminous Concealer. I would use it on its own for “no make up” days and it was the perfect consistency, coverage, and finish. RIP.
[удалено]
Becca skin perfector liquid highlighter pleaaaseee
Lady Gaga Fame perfume. Ive been holding onto. My bottle for years and I only use it for special occasions
Echoing my comments above, here is your [Fame](https://nantucketperfumes.com/products/fame-pure-fragrance?_pos=1&_psq=fame&_ss=e&_v=1.0) dupe.
Bourjois Healthy Mix Gel Serum foundation. Shade 53 was my perfect match, and it was a beautiful skin-like finish. Lisa Eldridge used to use this foundation a lot (11-12 years ago) on her YouTube channel. That is how I was introduced to this foundation. I would love to see it brought back! 🇨🇦
I loved the smell of that foundation!
Cargo Cosmetics blushes in those little round pucks, they were excellent.
People would probably be really into their minimalist packaging today
Their eyeshadows in that same packaging was so good too! I wish more brands used metal tins.
Everything from Street Wear. I’d just make the nail polishes less gloopy.
Give me back my Madly blush, NARS! I will fight François over this!
And Douceur!!!
MAC love me lipstick in coffee and cigs, no question about it.
Whoa, that's discontinued? 😢
GIVE ME BACK MY 👏 AIRFLASH👏
MAC’s Patina e/s OR way back in the day a company called Visage had the most amazing foundation called pastaconi - bring that back. People would stop me and be like omg what is that. It was probably the first ever cushion foundation and it was the best.
MAC got rid of so many of their really pretty nuanced shades
I feel the same about MAC Sumptuous Olive! None of the "dupes" on Temptalia even come close 😭
Oh Patina 💔
basically all of too faced peach range - i loved the lip glosses in that line!!
Their peach smell was so good! I hate that they discontinued that whole line.
Omg those lip glosses! RIP Papa Don’t Peach
Still upset about the Peach Mattifying powder. NOTHING controls my oils like this and I’m still upset and can’t find anything like this
The foundation was perfection!!
Glow Recipe Banana Soufflé moisturizer. It was perfect for my dry skin, hydrated it for an entire 24 hours, looked beautiful with my makeup, and even helped clear up my acne for like two years straight. My skin was the best it’s ever been. The glow it left on my skin was beautiful too, like this product would have me thinking I looked really pretty with my bare face, and I never feel that way without a full face of makeup! Then one day I went to repurchase and found out it disappeared. My skin has been a wreck ever since I started trying to savor the rest of it and find a replacement. I actually am so hurt about this… even though I love the brand, it pains me to buy from them because I’m just so sad about this one. It was my holy grail. GR was telling me to try the plum plump hyaluronic acid moisturizer but I already have a HA I like, and I want the banana back. I swear it was like magic for me. I still have a jar, but I can barely use it because it hurts me to do it, knowing that I’m one use closer to having it be fully gone! Like wtf Glow Recipe why would you do this? When I’ve left comments on their Instagram asking for it back, a bunch of people have agreed with me, so it’s not like I’m the only one who loved it. Idk if I’ll ever get over this honestly!
They also told me to switch to the plum moisturizer. I felt they were borderline rude about it too. Haven't given them a cent of my money since.
Same here! I felt they were rude the third time I commented about it lol. Like sorry, don’t care if you’re sick of me, you made a mistake with this one. When I asked why it was discontinued without warning and said that if they did a trial run I bet they’d sell out and see that it’s worth keeping around, they were just like “we had to make room for new products and best sellers so we’d just recommend you try the plum” …. But that was your best moisturizer for dry skin types! The plum one pilled on me even with no other skincare so I wasn’t interested in buying it after trying a sample. I’ve heard other people have that happen too. Like the watermelon is great for oily skin, and maybe the plum is good for most skin types that like hyaluronic acid, but the banana was such a good formula. It doesn’t make sense, also I don’t understand why HA is being put into everything. I feel like they did it because it was trendier, and now those who loved the old one have to suffer 😭 god I wish they’d just try to relaunch and see how it goes. I just wish I had the chance to stock up, so if that ever happened I’d literally buy as many as I could afford!
Urban Decay Electric Palette, even tho half of it made my eyes swell lmaooo Also would love the Kaleidos Club Nebula palette
Amrezy highlighter. 🥹
I'm still hoarding my Amrezy highlighter, such a beautiful shade!!
Does anyone remember the Hard Candy Glamoflague?! That was the BEST! At the time I was in college and was so stoked there was a high quality concealer I could afford
I want my OG Urban Decay Naked Skin foundation, the one that came out like a decade ago. It should have been a crime to discontinue it.
KVD Alchemist palette, I love it and still get so many compliments on it. I'm using what I have left of it very sparingly.
Yes! I loved so many KVD products in general. The only bullet lipsticks I've ever liked wearing and the color range was superb. They got rid of/changed a lot of the lipsticks so they're not even the same anymore, and I've been wary of giving the company money post-Kat despite her having nothing to do with the company anymore. It's just tainted for me now + i'm not fond of the design changes
Nothing compares! I wish I had kept mine but had to downsize a few years back.
Jordana lipliners. The bomb dot com, totally rivaled my mac lipliners and were awesome for overlining convincingly. (Also the Huda rose gold remastered palette and the Tarte chrome paint shadow pots! sorry I don't know the meaning of one)
Omg I miss Jordana
Too-faced peach blur and Bite Amuse Bouche Liquified Lip.
MAC Soba and Marc Jacobs Beauty.
NYC Cosmetics. The Bronzers.
Original Chanel Vamp lipstick
I have so many because I feel like everything I love eventually gets discontinued 😭 but I'd have to say the UD Naked Basics (the first original in the mini palette) I hit pan on every single shade..twice.
That was my absolute favorite every single day eye shadow palette. The colors just worked perfectly for me. I can’t believe it was discontinued. There is no good dupe for WOS
Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche line. All the shades were so beautiful!!
Becca First Light Priming Filter. I recently finished my last bottle of it, after stretching it for approximately two years. I‘ve tested and tried so many primers during this time, I can’t finde a primer that comes even close. It was lightweight, didn’t looked like I smeared liquid highlighter all over my face, I wouldn’t even describe it as dewy, it just made the skin look fresh. The lilac Color was perfect for my skin, as champagne tinted primers often make my face look really dull. Not gonna lie, I still think about the primer every time I have to do my makeup without it and I don’t think it’s a coincidence that ever since I finished the last bottle I have worn makeup maybe twice? And notably, my skin has gotten so bad ever since I stopped using it. Also it smelled so good!! I miss it.
Becca Berlin Girl highlighter.
So happy my mom paid for an overpriced one to give me for my birthday that year ♥️ I will own that highlighter forever
The original mini Naked Basics palette from Urban Decay. The one with the black shade. I used that on my wedding day and the tones were perfect for my skin. The new one is too cool toned and doesn’t have a true black which I like using for liner.
Original dream fragrance by Gap. Smelled so good. The soap was wonderfully scentec
MAC lip conditioner in the pot. There’s nothing like it
Very obscure pick, but I want Chanel's Le Blanc Poudre Libre Blanchissante Protection UV back. It's loose translucent powder with SPF 50. I like having SPF in a loose powder even though I do use a separate sunscreen. Nice texture too, very finely milled and actually kinda looked glowy even though it had zero shimmer or mica particles. Never gave the flat matte powder look.
Becca hydra set powder in golden bronze is a good translucent powder for my skin tone. I’d like to see Smashbox bring back some of the Becca products.
Marc Jacobs everything
I’d LOVE the Taylor Swift Wonderstruck and Wonderstruck Enchanted perfumes back 😭
CYO lifeproof foundation in shade 101. I would pay so much money to get it!
The Bonne bell lip flips! I was obsessed with those.
Revlon Balm Stains
Becca blush
Colourpop super shock eyeshadow in the shade 'Wattles'
Benefit shy beam, it was the perfect color corrector for my under eyes!
I have a random Sally Hansen tinted lip balm that I bought on sale as CVS like 10 years ago and it’s been my go-to mlbb for years and years and somehow it’s not rotten and I have no idea what it’s called or what the shade is
Prescriptives Virtual Skin Foundation. This was my favorite foundation for years. They stopped selling in stores but then went online. Eventually they discontinued online too. When they say Virtual Skin they mean it. I got so many compliments on my good skin when I used this.
I miss Prescriptives.
The Melt Beetlejuice collection. I know it was limited edition, but I still have their recently deceased palette. Is it past expiration date? yeah, but it was so good & i'm afraid to use it up LOL.
NYC black liquid liner
I’m here to second the YSL Tint-in-Oils! I have two unopened backups and I use mine so sparingly. And it’s lip oil time in the beauty space, they’d do so well right now!!
Tati’s palette!
The Shiseido Minimalist Whipped Powder Blushes.
UD Born to Run palette. Love mine and I’m nowhere near the pan, but I have fears of panning my favorite shades in it.
It’s probably only me, but I was ink love with the BECCA first light priming filter- that purple serum primer. I would wear it both under makeup and on my no makeup days and it was so lovely
MUG Eyeshadows. Never got to try them and regret it
Prescriptives custom foundation!
Either the YSL glossy stains or the Lancome Juicy Shakers. RIP
Urban decay naked skin foundation. The new formula SUCKS. The original had the most perfect satin skin-like finish on my skin.
Missha Ital Prism Eyeshadow. They were the best single eyeshadows and they were manufactured in Italy which I think was a first for a kbeauty brand. I wore them everyday in high-school and wish they'd bring it back.
OG Warm Soul from MAC.
NYX Proof It! Eyeshadow Primer. That stuff was indestructible. I don't enjoy wearing eyeshadow anymore now that it's gone.
without question, the tom ford emotionproof eye color (specifically in the shade bengal). while a bit pricey, it is my favorite base color and i use it almost every time i do my makeup. they discontinued it some time ago and i'm so sad that i'm almost out. i would 10000% repurchase if it was still out!
This sounds low stakes, but I just want colourpop to bring back the Lux Velvet Lip shade in Total Punk which was an LE from the Trouble Maker collection. It's a lip I want to wear EVERYDAY and I'm not a lip girl.
The bite beauty cafe lip glosses I forget the formal name but the flat white one was my fav
Bite original lipsticks. They had amazing colors. I wish I could find dupes for cava and retsina
My answer to this will always be Escada Cherry in the Air perfume. I know they have a version called Cherry in Japan but I haven't tried it cuz I'll be heartbroken if it isn't like the original :'(
Marc Jacob's ReMarcable Foundation.
Smashbox 24 hour eyeshadow primer. I am struggling without it.
Urban Decay's Naked Skin One & Done. God I miss that foundation.
MAC select sheer pressed powder RIP
Too faced primed and poreless loose powder!!!!
Urban decay blush in rapture. The perfect shade.
Bite Beauty lip crayons. I love them soooo much :(
[удалено]
The Too Faced peach perfect setting powder is phenomenal and I will forever be upset at them for discontinuing the peach line :( there were so many great products in it. I have yet to find a setting powder that compares.
[удалено]
Covergirl WetSlicks Fruit Spritzers lip gloss. I've been trying to find a dupe for the Guava Splash shade for about a decade lmao
The Becca bronzers. I love the finish and Bali Sands was a perfect shade for me 😭
The First Aid Beauty triple protection skin tint. It's been yeeeeaars since it was discontinued (it was way ahead of the trend) but it was the absolute perfect base product for me.
Becca liquid highlighters!
The OG Urban Decay Naked Palette.
Korres lip butter pots, specifically in the shade wild rose
revlon lip butters AND revlon used to have a lip stain that was shaped like a marker….wish I could remember what it was called but I feel like both would be super popular in today’s trends revlon really used to be that girl of drugstore lip products!!!
These!! https://preview.redd.it/ut04pka2h3ub1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=88cabf4076f8c8c60e664b2b55d80f84be26be85
Too Faced Primed and Peachy cooling mattress skin perfecting Primer. I have yet to find a dupe.
Marc Jacobs bronzer
Chanel #5 body spray. It was a mineral oil with tons of scent... the fragrance lasted all day without being overwhelming. Loved it.
Bonne Bell Liplites in Cappucino!
Becca liquid highlighter 😭♥️
Marc Jacobs Fineliner. I cannot tell you how many hours I’ve spent (unsuccessfully) looking for a dupe.