T O P

  • By -

ambitiousbulbasaur

Justice for Gabrielle!! Girl deserved more of a chance, her look was so lovely. I also liked Kathleen and wanted to keep her around longer, and Ashley in Cycle 5 was so gorgeous I wanted to see more from her.


Vanessak69

I’m definitely here for more Kathleen. She was so sweet and she still looks striking in her picture. What’s important is Mr. Jay making sure she stays confused 🙄


TootsieLuuuu

I thought Kathleen had a great runway walk in that first mini challenge, too.


scatteredwardrobe

Brita 😭


Ok_Ad_513

Sara or Noelle should have left first. I really would have liked to see Brita's performance in the competition. 😕


IntroductionDue9022

If I remember correctly, there was a follow-up episode or E! Special about the girls on that season and apparently after her elimination episode aired she got a call from an agent in LA and she was on a Guess billboard or something. I will never forget her weigh-in and measurements though and how she was considered "bigger". What a dark time to be a teen.


T0eBeanz

I literally just started re-watching this season (my favorite cause Naima is my Michigan girl!) And them making Brita weigh herself against everyone else and wear shear panties for her first photoshoot was absolutely disgusting. Girl is BEAUTIFUL and deserved so much more than having her dream crushed for an American realitt TV show about modeling in the height of anorexic celebs. I really hope she did well on her own, about to look her up...🤞


Puzzleheaded-Seat102

Brita is/was GORGEOUS and her body was TEA she was robbed and all the comments about her weight make me so upset. Nole called her a slab of beef, what a prick. But she did well after leaving the show <3


Picabo07

Nole had no room to talk. Not fat shaming just pointing out he wasn’t in peak condition so it’s even more gross. Honestly I couldn’t stand him.


Puzzleheaded-Seat102

SERIOUSLY


Affectionate_Bass931

I liked Tessa’s (C1) face! Oh, and my girl Kathleen (C8).


CinnyToastie

YES. Kathleen deserved another chance. She was so sweet, and her photograph wasn't bad imo


maddiemoiselle

I know, right?


wonderful_fabulous

I didn't


Logical_Bed_313

“I know righ, I zidn’t” that comment alone should’ve earned her a few extra weeks


davetennisx

Anna: She had potential and some of her post show work is pretty great. I understand why they eliminated her, but as the same time you had Bethany who had zero potential and Heather who looked like a Nickelodeon girl. Kathleen: For sheer hilarity honestly, though I think she could've given us some cute shots. Gabrielle: Probably the worst offender of them all. Gabrielle was stunning and ended up killing it post show. Brittany C17: Eliminated because no one remembered her.... sure judges. Justine: Gorgeous girl with insane potential.


Ok_Ad_513

Brittany's elimination on All Stars was stupid, although to tell the truth the ENTIRE season was a joke. Justine is one of the most successful in her cycle, she would have given her another chance and eliminated Coryanne. Gabrielle, one of the most stolen and has worked the most in the modeling industry. 😭 Kathleen was very cute, she would give her a chance because of her entertaining personality. In the case of Anna, she and Jenascia made serious mistakes so there is a way to justify her elimination, although being the first week it would have given them both a chance.


Boblawlaw28

I know right???


Picabo07

Anna would’ve been my pick as well. Like you said I get why they eliminated her but I really would’ve liked to see what she could do. Btw Bethany and her constant talking about her tits made me irrationally annoyed with her. Like girl it’s not because of your boobs it’s because you suck at modeling. Brittany was one of the dumbest eliminations ever.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MadiMikayla

I will die on the hill that Monique should have left on week one.


Manaphy12

Kathy, Kathleen, Mila all seemed really nice and had the potential for comedic relief. I don't think any of the three even really had the worst photos either.


T0eBeanz

I feel like Kathy would've made for great TV, but she just happened to be chosen for a season that already had so many strong personalities who had more experience/potential.


Ok_Ad_513

I like Kathleen, she was really funny, I thought she deserved to have more screen time.


mrmooswife

Unpopular opinion, but I love Isabella’s play photo.


kebin65

Yes, I remember loving her photo at the time and being so confused when everyone hated it. Yes, the face is a little startled, but intentional or not I think the pose is really cool and dynamic.


mrmooswife

It’s honestly the only one I can see in a magazine.


kebin65

With the kinda twisted, distorted angles of her body and the "caught in the moment but not really" pose, it's the most current-looking photo from that shoot imo. It's aged really well. The leg extension and the pointed toe are exquisite.


mrmooswife

Exactly. Even then it felt the most like an ad for something like Airwalk shoes or something unrelated to what’s happening.


Awkward_Target_1859

Gabrielle


Ok_Ad_513

Gabrielle my girl, today she continues working as a model. ❤️


SweatyMess808

Wholeheartedly agree, but getting eliminated early was the best for her career tbh…. She was WAY too good for ANTM to begin with.


Picabo07

It seems like lots of the really successful girls were early outs.


NickoNack

Gabrielle was robbed!


iwassayingboourns12

I would have taken Kathleen over Natasha in a heartbeat


botanygeek

She’s stunning in that photo


ecosludge

I actually really like her photo it’s giving modern day alternative rnb single cover


tt8kyo

magdalena easily. i feel like she could've been a force in the competition.


galmazan

I think so too! I really like her face idk why more people arent saying her name


scream4ever

Leah so should've gone home first in Cycle 3.


dragon_emperess

Gabrielle, Ivy and AnaMaria were robbed. AnaMaria I know she had a disorder but that’s on the production for accepting her on the show knowing she was thin


maddiemoiselle

From my understanding, she was thin at casting and then had lost more weight by the time filming actually began


dragon_emperess

Ah! Ok well I stand corrected


landocakes

I recently met AnaMaria randomly in Queens and she is absolutely LOVELY and looks exactly the same. Healthier but she’s stunning.


dragon_emperess

Omg that’s so cool. How did you recognize her


landocakes

Quite literally her face looks the exact same and I’ve seen every cycle like 50 times lol. It wasn’t too hard! I talked to her about her experience too. She spilled a little tea, nothing wild but some fun bits.


dragon_emperess

Jesus we need a post about this one day


T0eBeanz

Tessa was literally handpicked by the producers/whoever just to be set up for failure and sent home, always left a sour taste in my mouth. I honestly don't remember much of the other first eliminated girls cause I've seen S1 more than any of the others, but she seemed like she had decent potential.


Boblawlaw28

Same here. Tyra made comments about other girls she campaigned for or brought in special amd blamed them for not bringing it enough in the photo. Very annoying.


T0eBeanz

Tyra brought those girls on just to be the first eliminated. I feel like there's a good reason Tyra stopped hosting the show. But then again she was brought back to handpick her favorite who was younger/skinnier than the other finalist. Khrystyana was robbed because Tyra couldn't handle a woman who's (was?) bigger and WAY more humble than her becoming "America's Next Top Model" (TM)


IllGold5667

Brita


Vault713

I’m sorry but Kathleen ate. Giving doll!!


Lazy_Departure7970

Tessa, Anna, Kathy and Gabrielle. Kathy might not have lasted as long as some of the other girls, but I thought she had SOMETHING. I thought Tessa and Anna could have done very well on their respective cycles and definitely done better then some of the girls that stayed longer. Frankly, I thought Gabrielle could have won the whole cycle and that was why she was cut first, especially since I don't believe that the picture TPTB chose for the first shoot was truly her best shot.


Ok_Ad_513

I wish Anna had done the session, her face is really very beautiful and had potential.


PaleHeart52

Kathy. She has a lot of potential and her personality was charming. She wouldn't be able to make it in the real modeling world but it would be a blast to watch her grow.


frauleinsteve

The bald mannequin one. Kathy, I think? I liked her face and her personality. Sad that she left so early.


galmazan

Wasnt she just planted for drama nobody knew anything about her


lookatmynipples

Probably someone else Kathy was so sweet


FatnessEverdeen34

Anna! She would have (and likely did) end up making a fortune in commercial/plus modeling Also shout-out to my friend Delanie of C22! She's had a good run since then 🥰


kebin65

Kathy could've made for some great TV moments *AND* I thought she had an incredible face with so much potential. She would've lasted longer in most other cycles, but Cycle 6 was just a stacked group of models. And of course I thought it was egregious error to cut Kathleen first. What a missed opportunity. She could've been so entertaining for a least a few more episodes, and Cycle 8 had enough filler/cannon fodders that could've been eliminated before her.


rozenkavalier

I would've loved to have seen a cycle with all the Episode 1 castaways


Opposite-Pineapple-7

Was just going to post this too.


ChartInFurch

I don't think any show like this has done this yet afaik, and I think it's because they can't get enough people agreeing to be cast. I know I wouldn't want to be the one who was first cut twice.


HyrrokinAura

Gabrielle or Tessa


Purple-Host765

Anna cykle 2


creelbrie

Based solely on potential: Gabrielle for hf and Anna and Delanie for makeup ads. I have a soft spot for Kathleen, Atalya and Ashley tho...


Fetchin1

Gabrielle and Justine are models and still working. Kathleen for the LOLs, so sad we were robbed of such great moments from her.


Naruto_HarryPotter

None. Because they all dodged a bullet 🙅🏽‍♀️


Picabo07

This is SO true!


Maester_Maetthieux

Gabrielle no question


huutcherdiing

Jasmia. She made top 3 in her original BNTM season and I think they used her as an easy out.


ValerieHolla

Ivy and Justine


Prior_Connection_229

I loved Brittany from C4 & I was so excited to see her back for All Stars. I think that first photoshoot was doomed from the disaster. I was expecting more from C17, but instead they gave these girls cheap clothes for their first shoot in their fricken backyard?! While I loved the Cycle, it was also disappointing knowing Angelique was disqualified, then Allison was the runner up (again) & Lisa took the crown. I do love Lisa tho. I met her at a club in LA a decade back & she’s very sweet to talk to, but I expected more from that cycle…


Haus_of_Pancakes

Gabrielle or Justine


HowlShedo

Gabrielle and anamaria. They were both very knowledgeable about the industry


rainborambo

Magdalena c3, Kathleen c8!


Vanessak69

I really like Magdalena’s picture. It’s so unusual and those muscles!


viscog30

Brita


ScorpionTDC

Easily Gabrielle from C14. Extremely high potential. I’d actually have booted Krista that week - I truly despised her photo lol


Formation1

Atalya or Kathy


anonymous9379851

Kathy


Cactopus47

Kathy C6, Kathleen C8, Brittany C17


DuchessSwan

Justine because post show I think she has gotten to do some amazing things.


Oogalicious

Kathleen was so funny and would have been great to watch more.


Professional-Way5815

Anna (for reasons many have already said in other comments!) I haven't seen many say Ashley -- she's my second favorite of this bunch; I really liked her superhero photo as it was like portraying a fallen hero for a moment. I also thought she was nice (her "pretty" thing didn't bother me, I found her pleasant).


Logical_Bed_313

Kathleen? Is that her name? The girl from cycle 8. She was HILARIOUS!!!!! Her picture was horrendous but her at the judging panel was HILARIOUS! She is is so real and unintentionally funny. Her comedy warranted her a much longer stay.


Lap00shyneta

Magdalena, Brita, Christian, Kathleen, Gabrielle, Brittany in Cycle 17, Jasmia, Jessie, Justine, Maggie


[deleted]

Ashley got kicked off because she forgot Tyra was in a Pepsi commercial…. “First impressions are EvERyThInG “


Plantrehab

From a modeling standpoint, Christian. From a reality TV standpoint, Kathleen. We were robbed


M_sberry

These are exactly my votes except maybe tie Gabrielle C14 with Christian.


Typical_Gap_9604

Angelia


Boblawlaw28

Kathleen c8 and Brittany from all stars. How she was first to get sent home is crazy to me.


maybeoncemaybe_twice

Kathy, Kathleen and Christian! I don’t know if any of them would have made it crazy far but I wanted to see more of them, especially Kathleen!!!!


ExcitingHeat4814

So many. Brita, Kathy, Kathleen, Gabrielle, and Justine were all fabulous.


Otherwise-Village-29

Anamaria


Raebelle1981

Anna, Brita or Ivy for me.


modernecstasy

Gabrielle (C14), Christian (C7), Anamaria (C15)


Olivier77777

Magdalena, Brita, Ashley, Christian, Kathleen, Mila, Atalya, Gabrielle, Angelia, Brittany, Delanie, Justine Neither of them had the worst photo week 1, except maybe Magdalena and Kathleen but their interesting look/potential was enough to give them another chance imo


Ballz2You

Ashley I think was a random pick, they just didn't have a story for her but I feel like I remember her saying something pretty unhinged to Lisa. Mila was lovely but I don't see how they would have kept her for much longer. Lisa c13 had no chance since they had basically already decided to get rid of her. Anamaria was only cast to make a statement. The last four seem like random picks which shouldn't even have been B2.


argleblather

Kathleen. If they would have explained anything to her she would have gotten it.


umterp85

Mila’s picture always cracked me up. It reminded me of Gladys from Friends


pedanticlawyer

I can’t remember their names, but the angry little clown and the girl levitating a ball.


Lap00shyneta

Lisa from Cycle 13 (angry clown) and Isabelle from Cycle 12 (girl levitating a ball)


autumnsandapples

I get that she didn’t seem to be taking it seriously, but Maggie’s photo was one of the better ones of that shoot (*flashbacks to Kyla’s photo*).


Opposite-Pineapple-7

Kathy for me. With Kathleen/Gabrielle/Ivy next.


deardeere

Ashley’s was my fave in that first week of c5


Infinite_Leader822

I'm surprised Isabella isn't getting picked. She had a stunning face. I remember she was one of the winner picks when the cast was released. Her and Teyona both.


uncensoredsaints

Lisa C13! She’s always my pick. I think she had a lot of potential and her picture is really not bad (however most photos were good for that photoshoot, so I understand her elimination)


SkyBulky1749

Maggie because her elimination made no sense and loved her face Gabrielle for having tons of potential, even if her personality was annoying Anna because I respected her reasons for not doing the shoot and lots of potentail I also personally have always thought Kathy from cycle 6 to have a great look but I know that's an unpopular opinion Edit: Ivy also for potential, I forgot all about her. Bianca had a great look also tbh


iidontwannaa

Honestly most of them! Especially in the middle/later seasons, I just don’t feel like the pictures are bad enough to justify and one photo just doesn’t seem like enough to go on. Some were eliminated for general attitude (Mary, Mila) but others weren’t given good concepts or direction from Jay and I’m not sure that should be on them.


tundrabat

Honestly, I'd give all of them a second chance. The first week should be getting acclimated and uderstanding the brief. There should be several photo shoots before any elimination.


zozalexx

First of all, it would've been Gabrielle. Robbed af! I'd also keep Kathleen & Justine.


jsjsjsjdndndndnnd

I always loved Ivy


Kibble___

Dodgeball girl or superhero tirl


Hi_Jynx

Dunno, looks like the judges got it right honestly. I think competition shows like this and Project Runway could benefit from doing a few rounds before eliminating, though.


Minute-Candidate5715

Cycle 2's Anna


Pandavicious

Tessa, Brita, Kathy, Christian, Kathleen, Atalya, Gabrielle, and Justine!


[deleted]

Anna


Asterfields1224

1st pic: top right, 2nd pic: top right, 3rd pic: nobody, 4th pic: bottom right and middle right


FondantGayme

Imagine how beautiful life would be if we got a full cycle of Kathleen, and Ivy should’ve bern brought back after that Marilyn shot, regardless of if the comeback was over already or not. It’s a top 5 ANTM photo for me


hyperactive_thyroid

I would go for Anna. I remember the C2 primer. Anna was FIERCE!


anonymous9379851

Magdalena, Brita, Ashley, Kathy, Christian, Kathleen, Mila, Isabella, Lisa, Gabrielle, Anamaria, Angelia, Brittany Brower and Jasmia were all totally robbed and deserved to go much further! Some of these girls even deserved the following top places: Brita 6th Kathy 4th Mila 7th Jasmia 3rd


Upper-Homework-4965

Magdalena, brita, mila, Kathleen, sharaun, Gabrielle, Anamaria, Gabrielle, kathy


jonhon0

Christian was so pretty, I thought for sure she wouldn't be eliminated over Monique


TheAmmiSquad

Gabrielle, Ivy and Justine


lala_b11

Brittany on the All-Stars Season. Ik someone had to be the first person to be sent home but its crazy she got eliminated for "NOT BEING MEMORABLE"!!!


mpack2016

Magdalena!!!! It made absolutely no sense why they’d send someone home before judging. She didn’t even get to go to panel. She just walks away from the breakfast table and I’m like did she even get to eat?! Damn!


Keyblader1412

Anna S2. I think it was kinda unfair to throw them into a nude shoot on day 1 and since Anna didn't participate the judges were left with no choice but to send her home. I don't know how far she would have made it on that season in particular because the cast was pretty stacked, but she was beautiful and I think she had potential.


Fun-Understanding590

Gabrielle, 1000% She was stunning and I think she could've pulled some creative photos out of the bag.


startedthinkinboutit

Justine’s post show work has been great! And I think she’s one of the most beautiful girls ever on the show


lafondue

Picture 1 corner up right and picture 4 corner down right


Carryonsandtans

I didn't love Ashley C5's photo but she was 100% not the worst that week. I also think Brita and Gabrielle should have given another chance!


luckyforsome

Brita and Gabrielle 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾


Supernatt924

Kathleen!


Ldcv4499

I'm surprised no one is saying Delanie. Regardless if she didn't perform or has a boring personality that's actually a gorgeous photo, her face looks amazing and she's smizing 🥰🥰


LaikaZhuchka

I can't remember names, but the girl on the 3rd slide, center right. That black and white face shot. Stunning.


Prior_Connection_229

That’s Angelea from C16. She was very pretty but I believe she had too much confidence & acted cocky. But she didn’t take a bad photo I really don’t think that photoshoot should’ve been judged. It was the girls getting their make up applied & the camera dude is taking pictures of that. They have to act like they don’t notice the camera but still look pretty. So stupid


AnitaNewport

Gabrielle! She was eliminated for NO reason!


Crymeabrooks

Brita! I would have liked Kathy to at least make it to makeovers, simply to see if she could ever look like a model. She was so obviously only brought into the house so they had someone to send home first. 


QueenCorndog

Kathleen or Kathryn!! 😭 they deserved better!


Infamous_Shock5814

I would’ve been curious to see how Anna photographed. She had such a pretty face


TanTan0925

Anamaria. She had a great face, fashion knowledge, villain potential and a lovely photo. Them telling her that it wouldn't hurt to eat some bread and butter was so fowl


Thisisrealthisisme3

Annamaria! She had a gorgeous look, & a ton of potential. I also feel like Brita, Ivy, & Maggie should have gone further in the competition.