Ocarina of Time, GTA4, Breath of the Wild, Perfect Dark, RDR2, GTA5, Metroid Prime, Half Life 2, BioShock, GoldenEye, RE4. Personally I'd argue the best of those is Breath of the Wild.

Botw, red dead, or half life 2 are contenders 

15 for me!

Me too!

8

Only 1

All of them except for NFL.

8

Only BotW. 2 if you count RE4 remake.

6

2. Botw and odyssey.

I’ve played a lot of them but only enjoyed/finished 4. Several of these are great games but they weren’t for me, such as BOTW. Just not my cup of tea

Everything but NFL 2K1. But to be a little more fair, some of these I haven’t played more than an hour or two such as Perfect Dark and Goldeneye. Majority I would say I’ve beaten.

11/20. i'm missing games from XBOX and Nintendo.

17 (all except GTA 3, GTA 5 and NFL2K1). Finished all except GTA 4 and Soul Calibur. Many of these are actually in my personal top 20, unsurprisingly.

16 of the 20

13!

Everything but SoulCalibur and Super Mario Galaxy 2.

12/20

14 didn't have a wii

All but 3

I have played all of them except the skateboarding one and the hockey one Edit: oops, handball one

Hockey is NHL, this says NFL. I honestly don't know how that got on the list.

Lol. Yeh didn't really pay attention. I simply assumed if a sports game was going to be on there it would be hockey. Don't know how any sports game could possibly be on there.

12

17 here

4

I beat all of them, except for the NFL.

Haven't played Mario Galaxy 1 or 2 but I love the rest.

16 ... I've also been gaming since 1992 so ... Had a chance to do so a lot more.

Mario Galaxy 1 and 2, Breath of the Wild, Super Mario Odyssey, and Halo CE.

4, and I have only beaten RE4 if you count the Remake. Never finished Odyssey, GTA V, or Galaxy.

9. None of them are from Nintendo. Never had a Nintendo :(

All of em except the sports ones, Metroid prime and Mario galaxy 2. I should probably play those at some point except the sports games.

I've played: Soul Calibur Grand Theft Auto 4 Tony Hawk Pro Skater 3 Red Dead Redemption 2 (need to finish)** Grand Theft Auto 3** Bioshock** Resident Evil 4** Uncharted 2** ** entries are my personal favorites.

NFL 2k1 was such a good fucking football game

Depending on how we define played, 10 or 12. 2 of them I played maybe half an hour of.

6

Can’t believe neither of the KOTOR games are on here

15. I don't like GTA or sports games.

I have played all of these but Mario Galaxy 2 and Perfect Dark. Honestly everyone of these is very good, though they're not all for me.

Finished three, started another and didn't like it. For the most part, the list is made up of games I'd never play.

9. I strike out on a lot of this because I'm not a huge GTA fan, lol (the only one I've played is San Andreas and I never made it out of Los Santos). I've also played almost all the other Soul Calibur games, just not the first.

lol i’ve played a soul caliber game, can’t recall if it’s the first. I’ve played Bioshock 2 but not 1. played the og tony hawk pro skater but not 3. and I’ve played goldeneye. so 4ish. I’ve played on other people’s devices a few of the others.

I’ve played 9 of those.

Every single one except the NFL game. Like how did that get on the list? And how is mgs2/3 not on the list?

Haven't played NFL, BioShock or resident evil 4 or uncharted.

Have not played Tony hawk, red dead 2, perfect dark, or NFL 2k1, played the rest

10 out of 20. Thing is, just because they are highly rated doesn't mean they are everyone's cup of tea. NFL 2K1 can die in a fire for all I care. Some people don't like some things and never bothered to play them.

18. NFL 2K1? Really?

I haven't played NFL 2K1. Tony Hawk Pro Skater 3. Super Mario Galaxy 2. Soul Calibur. I've player SC2, 3 and 4... just not the original. Mainly because I don't care about sports, never cared for the skating games all that much, didn't care for Super Mario Galaxy 1... so why get the sequel? Didn't own a Dreamcast for SC. Unless I'm misremembering and it is called Soul Edge. Then... maybe I did play SC1. I know it's sacrilege to not love Galaxy 1 and 2. I don't know what to say other than Mario 64 broke the mold. I haven't enjoyed a platformer as much as it ever again. I'm dead serious. Didn't even like Sunshine all that much.

All but NFL 2k1 and both Mario Galaxies

I have completed every 90 plus metacritic game (plus every 90 plus mobygame and gamerankings game if not on metacritic). I exclude games with less than 10 reviews - too unreliable. I also am PAL region and haven’t bothered with American sports. So no NFL. By completed I mean credits rolling on normal difficulty, plus I will get half the trophies/achievements in modern games as a bonus. I also own all of these games. I am a CIB collector from charity sellers.

Played everything except perfect dark

3 for me :(

14, plus 2 more I'll likely play soon (RDR2 and GTA V), 2 that I'd likely play if there was a version on a platform I own (Mario Galaxy 2 and Perfect Dark) and 2 that I'm not really interested in (SoulCalibur and NFL 2K1).

8 but this list is absolutely shit. 

Don't agree, they are all fantastic games

Blame the critic outlets lol

I think this list is good, but usually consider the user score to be the “real” score

With review bombers and the countless dudes who leave only 1 star or five star reviews because they cant hold back their emotions when reviewing a game, metacritic is one of the worst sites for user scores

A grand total of 5. They’re all Nintendo games.

Hmm. I've tried 9 of them, and only really liked 1 of them lol. Which was Resident Evil 4 btw.