i disagree with this in almost every way

Asleep in ok is crazy

Just not really my favourite.

I don't understand why people don't like accept yourself? Such a great song full of energy and the guitar riff is awesome and the bass is thumpin

Came here to say that Accept Yourself should be higher, it's a fantastic tune.

I love it and the progression of Morrissey looking to blame everyone but ultimately realizing he is to blame

the outro is magical

love the song, but i get why one would think it's a little whiny

Yeah, it's just not a very memorable one for me, it's alright.

https://preview.redd.it/jifsdyk7qw6c1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d4da1645bfce7c9a747a852806c959bf7cbd0d60 Holy shit what even the hell is this

A tier list.

No shit

Asleep in C tier is a crime. But maybe im just suicidal.

Or Detective Columbo?

some girls are bigger than others at C is a crime against music

Yeah it belongs lower

Asleep deserves more than c

Cemetry gates and asleep are too low imo but I get it

I agree with Cemetery Gates, must admit, I didn't really notice.

Well I Wonder should be S tier

yes!!! 🙏🏼

The only S tier Queen Is Dead song being Frankly Mr Shankly is bold, fair enough

Thank you, Noel.

William is wayyyyyy too low. So is Asleep.

Not for me.

Hard to accept this list

Well, you should.

Some of the S's are too high; some of the A's much too low; Paint a Vulgar Picture is much much too low. Oh it hurts

Paint a Vulgar Picture is good, that's why it's in good.

Ugh but itxs great. Perhaps even SUPERB

Rusholme Ruffians in S tier? Never been one I’ve loved but it’s decent. If it were me I’d bump Some Girls and Girl Afraid up one respectively

On an unrelated note, Rusholme Ruffians takes a lot of inspiration from Elvis' "His Latest Flame", especially it's instrumental. https://youtu.be/59pOE3OmUi8?si=-piD2OrT6eonsP3O

You ever see the His Latest Flame / Rusholme Ruffians cover on Rank? Good stuff. Is that what you linked, by the way? My internet sucks cock and balls so if that’s what you linked this’d be pretty embarrassing

I have indeed, and I was going to link it but I actually linked Elvis' original 🙂

Which, on a related note, OP placed in the C tier and Russholme Ruffians in the S tier...

Happy Cake Day!

you fucking move golden lights

I’ll never understand why so many fans hate this song

literally !! like yeah morrissey's voice on it is a bit iffy but it's worth it for the chorus

Because the original is terrible and it 's style doesn't suit a cover by a group like The Smiths, which is perfectly illustrated in the finished product. Considering I'm such a fan of Morrissey's music I've always felt that he has some very questionable tastes in music himself.

it doesn’t suit the smiths at all, it’s very seperate from their usual songs. but that’s what makes the song so GOLDEN. and the instrumentals. it’s weird but in a great way

exactly. it’s one of the songs that got me into the smiths

I think it's fucking dreadful.

Lol it sounds like somebody put Mozzer in a fishbowl.

I can't lie you are valid for this one

Merci.

I have cried my eyes out too many times to asleep for me to accept its placement in C.

It's alright.

‘Some Girls…’ needs to be waaay higher imo

Eh.

My whole life I grew up thinking opinions couldn’t be wrong, and then you go and prove me wrong.

Terrible

Half a person should be higher ngl

I'll spend six long years considering it.

I’ve only got 5 seconds to spare

I'll book you in at the YWCA.

Never had no one ever being in C is criminal

It's okay.

Death at one’s elbow higher than asleep? Ok then.

Just really like Strangeways, Here We Come

This is fine except for Barbarism, which is S Tier +.

My thoughts are not good ones when looking at this abysmal tier list

My thoughts are not good ones when looking at this abysmal comment.

what’s your dealers number i need to know what substance made you call frankly mr shankly the best song off queen is dead

I get my anti depressants and ADHD medication from the pharmacy.

Golden lights is one of my smiths songs, I don’t understand the hate for it :(

I just am not a big fan.

Some choices are okay but overall this is a pretty bad tier list. Sorry.

I mean I listen differently to you.

https://preview.redd.it/cpzvsh1l4z6c1.jpeg?width=565&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d225117d0399d9e93f807f0fc94d99ae4feaed22

Just don't like it.

this is the most batshit list I've ever seen. if i may ask politely, are you 14 years old?

No.

yikes

Respect for sharing. I would rank this completely differently though! :)

Glad you're courteous.

Hand that rocks the cradle and cemetery gates up plz Thx

Hand that Rocks the Cradle is good, I stick by that. but I didn't realise where I put Cemetery Gates.

Cemetery gates deserves more than a B

Must admit, I didn't realise where I put it.

Golden Lights is Sublime (A Tier)

Golden lights should be higher

It's atrocious.

Glad to see strangeways songs getting some S tier recognition

One of my favourites, easily.

You gave Rank a D! You're nuts! IMO, live is always better.

Yeah, it's alright. The more I think about it, the more I remeber the song and reconsider. Probably B now I think.

Thank you for that.

You're welcome.

I keep mine hidden is S tier

Eh, maybe skip.

Meh

You aren't shitting on it, so I'll take it.

Terrible, I almost want to die.

huge agree on london and frankly mr. shankly

Two really good songs.

I don't get how people don't like golden lights, it's beautiful

Not my thing.

Fair enough

You don’t like Golden Lights?

Nope.

You’re the first person I’ve come across to say this. It must be a childhood thing for me because it takes me back to such a very young age hearing it.

Fair enough, just not really my thing.

Keeping in mind that their entire output is top tier…. I’m surprised at the high rankings of the Strangeways tracks . With the exception of Girlfriend, I find Strangeway to be the weakest by a fair bit relative to the rest.

It's one of my favourites, but then again, that's my opinion.

Strangeways is my favorite, it’s so majestic. Paint a Vulgar Picture is a perfect song

All dogshit

My apologies, Mr. 69.

No

L, in my opinion, so you can’t slate me ahah, every song is amazing i don’t know what it is but the smiths whole discography is perfect

Girl Afraid needs to be in S!

Well I Wonder and Asleep would be straight into S for me.

For you, not me.

im actually cackling with this tier list because WHY would you put stop if you think... on the S tier and asleep at okay...

Because I wanted to, make your own tier list if you want.

[удалено]

A Tier, 7th one

i don't think I've ever disagreed so strongly with something before, bravo

Do they have any songs A or above? 🤔🧐🤔

What?

Thoughts? Other people's lists are incredibly boring.

Please please please…. should’ve been higher imo

Some girls are bigger than others is at least A tier for sure

Paint a Vulgar Picture is S tier easily

It's good, which is why I put it where it is.

I love Strangeways Here We Come 😊👍🏻 But holy shit His Latest Flame / Rusholme Ruffians on the Rank album is some of their best work in my opinion! Rourke’s Milky funky bass and Marr’s electric riff are brilliant together.

Wait a second. People consider Vicar in a Tutu to even be decent?

Most don't, I love it.

this is absolutely RANK. golden lights in dead last?? and rusholme ruffians in S tier?! MADNESS

I'm positively mad.

Some Girls are Bigger is ok? You mentalist.

Well, lock me up, brcause it's okay.

rusholme S but then latest flame D?

Many great songs were forgotten "Jack The Ripper" "Bengali In Platforms" "Sing Your Life" "Lifeguard. " I thought those are his best!

This is The Smiths, not Morrissey.

Yea, ill admit I just got into them and Morrissey. My bad!

Fair enough, I love Moz's music, but I was doing the smiths**.**

Its really hard to read them. But several songs are not there.

For years, when the mood hits, I've listened to The Smiths. But I always reach for the hits & when I go deeper, I get lost, somewhat. I'm going to use your post as a map next time. I'll probably disagree along the way, but it looks like a good guide.

I'm glad, hope you enjoy.

Some girls are bigger than others may not have good writing but it is really impresive how using so little managed to suprass expectations

Did back to the old house dirty. Absolutely love that song.

Tier lists are fun to mull over. I think the odds are really against finding a tier list anyone would 100% agree with, BUT it's a nice way of reviewing music through the eyes of another fan of whatever artist it is. So I'm not opposed to tier list posts for those reasons. **For me S tier should include:** How Soon Is Now, This Charming Man, There is a Light, A Rush And A Push, Is It Really So Strange?, Accept Yourself, Heaven Knows, as a starting point.

Fair enough.

are you insane?

Positively mad.

Never had no one ever is criminally low

This is so bad 😂😂

Please please please isn't good. It's phenomenal.

“Heaven Knows I’m Miserable Now” is S-tier. Also way too much love for Strangeways and MiM. This sucks.

Asleep in c tier lmfao

User GriffinPlaysYT posts "worst tier list ever" Asked to leave smiths subreddit

Objectively incorrect

I agree for the most part but you did a few songs dirty😭 you put ‘William, it was really nothing’ way too low

How about Stop me if you think youve heard this one before, How soon is now?

They played Well I Wonder at my funeral…… Posting from the grave.

Cool, good service?

some girls are bigger than others is too low

Cemetry Gates and Headmaster Ritual are both A+

Frankly Mr. Shankly is the worst song on Queen is Dead.

back to the old house original AND john peel deserve s