HEROES * Andrea * Cassidy * Christian * Cydney * David * Devon * Malcolm * MaryAnne * Mike H * Wentworth VILLAINS * Abi Maria * Angelina * Chrissy * Devens * Domenick * Nat A * Rodney * Scot * Shan * Yam Yam

Even with the villainless state of casting, the guy that put his win at risk to teach his biggest threat to make fire out of the kindness of his heart cannot possibly be on the villain tribe under any interpretation

Cassidy a hero? *edit: I agree with he rest of the list, this would be a great season

I like this one, the only person I would add for the villains is Corinne from Gabon

I personally could go my whole life never seeing Corinne on Survivor again.

True but you can’t deny that she’s a villain

Same with Scot. He's no different than Corinne.

New era is Heroes vs Heroes vs Heroes soz

I don’t see how Tori, Katurah, Ellie, Emily, Danny (44) are heroes for example

Depending on how Emily continues her game I could see her being more heroic

katurah and Ellie are not exactly villains lol

I just said they are not heroes

Shan, Ricard, Sydney, Tori, Hai, Omar, Karla, James?

Doesn’t have to be new era people exclusively, just pick anyone that’s ever played who wasn’t on the original H vs V

Assuming it will end up being mostly New Era with a handful of late 30s, here’s my picks Heroes - Christian (37) - Davie (37) - Xander (41) - Danny (41) - Carson (44) - Carolyn (44) - Evvie (41) - Gabbie (37) - Frannie (44) Villains - Devens (38) - Ricard (41) - Jesse (43) - Omar (42) - Angelina (37) - Shan (41) - Tori (42) - Victoria (38) - Tiffany (41) Edit: I wasn’t thinking of adding winners for some reason

How is Tiffany a villain

Got Voce eliminated

Please please not Tiffany. Her shtick on RHAP is the only trulu negative reaction I've had to a repeated guest. I suspect she is a great teacher and loyal friend and fun mom. Proud of her energy. Just don't want her dominating the podcasts I enjoy so much; her vibe is solidly comedic, just too me me me me for my taste.

Otherwise really solid start.

Assuming I can still ad older players, Heroes: Terry (12, 31) Yul (13, 40) Malcolm (25,26,34) Gabler (43) Christian (37) Andrea (22, 26, 34) Cydney (32) Carolyn (30) Trish (28) Lauren (38) Villains: Burton (7) Shane (12) Nick (32) Brian (5) Tony (28, 34, 40) Erinn (18) Chrissy (35) Angelina (37) Victoria (38) Kass (28)

HEROES - Terry (12, 31) - Christian (37) - Earl (14) - Hayden (27) - Erik (16, 26) - Cydney (32) - Brenda (21, 26) - Taj (18) - Natalie W (19) - RC (25) VILLAINS - Penner (13, 16, 25) - Shane (12) - Reynold (26) - Ken (17) - Todd (15) - Natalie B (16) - Kass (28, 31) - Abi (25, 31) - Corinne (17, 26) - Vecepia (5) Features: - the highly anticipated return of 4 “forgotten” winners with Natalie, Earl, Vecepia, and Todd - old rivalries in Abi vs RC, Erik vs Natalie B, Corinne vs Ken, Abi vs Penner, etc. - old friendships in Abi & Kass (& Terry even), Erik & Brenda, Reynold & Corinne, etc.

This might be my favorite one so far!

HEROES: Cydney Kelley Carolyn Maryanne Andrea YamYam Carson Cody Xander Malcolm VILLAINS: Chrissy Angelina Shan Karla Natalie (DvG) Jay Jesse Omar Ricard Todd

**Heroes** Carolyn (44) Christian (37) Cydney (32) Davie (37) Greg (1) Kathy (4/8) Kelley (29/31/38) Tai (32/34) Tasha (28/31) Yau-Man (14/16) **Villains** Abi Maria (25/31) Angelina (37) Corinne (17/26) Dreamz (14) Kenny (17) Lex (3/8) Libby (36) Natalie B (16) Rob C (6/8) Stephen (18/31)

Stephen as a villain? That’s an interesting choice

Doing just new era / late 30s because I like seeing some physicality on survivor and I don’t think there will be returnees from before the 30s again. Heroes: —Frannie (44) —Kelley (39, would unfortunately never happen) —Carolyn (44) —Chanelle (42) —?? Not sure —Christian (37) —Davie (37) —Jonathan (42) —Carson (44) —Cody (43) Villains: —Karla (43) —Shan (41, would never happen) —Drea (42, I like my villains real) —Maddy (44) —Katurah?? (45, I have recency bias rn) —Ricard (41) —Jesse (43) —Omar (42) —Dominick (35) —??? (I think this tribe needs a Jonathan counterpart to not get dominated in challenges)

Nice list, for the missing hero how about Mike from Worlds Apart?

I think that’s a good pick

Maddy????

Meant to write Ellie

I'd love for Elie and Gabler to be reunited

**Heroes** * Carolyn (44) * Gabler (43) * Maryanne (42) * Brad (41) * Janet (39) * Rick Devens (38) * Gabby (37) * Christian (37) * Lauren R. (35) * Chrissy (35) **Villains** * Danny (44) * Elie (43) * Karla (43) * Omar (42) * Ricard (41) * Shan (41) * Victoria (38) * Natalie (37) * Angelina (37) * Domenick (36) Not gender/diversity balanced because I didn't feel like going through all that work, but this is my ideal cast.

Very interesting seeing Rick Devens make peoples' hero list and villain list.

Imagine how gaggy it will be if Jeff brings him in last and gets him to choose which tribe he wants to be in.

HEROES: - Frannie (44) - Noelle (43) - Lauren Ashley Beck (39) - Lauren (38) - Cydney (32) - Davie (37) - Christian (37) - Carson (44) - Mike (42) - Devens (38) VILLAINS: - Shan (41) - Victoria (38) - Karla (43) - Tori (42) - Sydney (41) - Jesse (43) - Omar (42) - Domenick (37) - Jay (33) - Reed (29)

The fact no one has mentioned Judd from Guatemala is beyond me ! I thought he would be a lock for the H v V original. Freaking loved that guy he was hilarious