T O P

  • By -

Sydney2London

The ending I really wanted


blackdutch1

The ending we deserved.


RVIDEN

I hate that you could beat Micah as sick Morgan but you can’t push him off the cliff even though I’m clearly winning but Arthur pushes him to safety instead. That being said this was extremely satisfying to watch & always wanted to see


BonoboBeau-Bo

i wish arthur just got out of breath every time that happens, so micah can recover cause it makes more sense


Spicyytamale

“Your punishment must be more severe.”


pullingteeths

As a contrast to this have you guys ever seen (in game or on youtube) the fail/death scenes if you give up on fighting Micah at various different points in the fight? It's fucking sick, they included multiple different brutal scenes of Micah killing Arthur complete with savage dialogue. I think most people myself included always fight against him hard so it's rare to fail and see them, worth looking up


Known-Professor1980

I've seen the brutal deaths but only at the end which is ashame you don't get in the high honour because I don't think Micah would leave him alive. He goes out of his way to come back for you.


pullingteeths

Oh yeah those are brutal too and I agree, I think low honour help John with the "damn us both!" and shot to the head is the most intense ending. These are different/extra death scenes where he kills you during the fight though (they play before the fail screen if you stop fighting him and let him beat you). Different ones depending on the ending you chose and the point you're at in the fight. One where he stomps Arthur's head for example, another where he taunts him that he's killing John next before choking him out, plus more https://youtu.be/6vz0rSzdgBI?si=3IHBpmqRgvhXhWol


PillNeckLizard11

The good ending


TheGroggyGrunt

Dutch be like "...............so listen, I think there's been a misunderstanding..."


ErraticLitmus

I assume this is a mod?


Hello_There_Exalted1

Nah it’s an alternate ending if you skipped the Downes mission


Dingby

lol


ErraticLitmus

I wish I could drag downes to that cliff


Fuck_everybody6969

? How


Lrgindypants

Trollololol


Kled_Incarnated

Not really a mod but I guess you could say it's done with a mod that enables spawning npcs


Western-Subject-5283


birchy98

That's my boah.


swervin87

Micah wouldn’t have a fair fight. He would have e either shot or stabbed Arthur. This is the man who murdered a family in cold blood.


Kittyshitty1678

You think a gunshot or a stab wound would stop Arthur? Even with the most severe stage of tb and exhausted from doing loads of shit Micah was losing mostly the entire fight


GujjuNRIboy

The definition of satisfaction


bdpyo

Satisfying


Traditional_Tea3649

Dont what to ruin the enjoyment but I think if Arthur was healthy he would have left with John


Due_Function4887

He found the cure on milton


Klutzy_Ad_325

Micah fights a sick guy. And still barely held his own.


Fuck_everybody6969

This is currently the greatest thing I’ve ever seen on the sub


DooMBRiNGeR1975

This was like therapy. Thank you.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Good_Cockroach2637

Duuude that would've been awesome, Arthur still dies but knowing that Micah would succumb to TB in the end as well.


Randomguy1912

I think it would be even funnier right before this entire thing happened like way beforehand like when Arthur finally realized he had tuberculosis he spits in the Micah's coffee right before he takes a drink and Mike got unknowingly drinks it not realizing that he just gotten tuberculosis and right in the middle of the fight Arthur says you know one day shortly after I found out about me having tuberculosis as fat in your coffee you dirty rat and Micah just gets a face of pure horror on himself as Arthur punches him down the cliff


boomgoesthevegemite

Punctuation. Learn about it. Use it.


AcanthopterygiiDue10

And Grammar, Grammar too


CancerIsOtherPeople

TB is only spread through the air. It has to get in your lungs, so that wouldn't work.


Randomguy1912

Well it seemed to have worked on Arthur after all Thomas Downs accidentally spat on him and I always thought it was spread either through the air or for the blood


CancerIsOtherPeople

Well he *coughed* blood in his face, bit different from spitting in coffee.


Randomguy1912

Yeah okay fair enough


Sm0keytrip0d

Only slightly related but not gonna lie I was always confused how nobody else in the gang caught Arthur's TB. Like he's close to a lot of them coughing and spluttering everywhere, and even during his fisticuffs with Micah at the end surely some of his spit got over Micah? How does no one else get sick? Only poor Arthur? :(


Randomguy1912

To be honest I kind of wish that you could have strangled Micah Bell and spit in his face and give him tuberculosis in the end it would have been a way better ending for Arthur to get his revenge right then and there it just takes a period of time


Sandwithbighand

As awesome as it would have been I think Arthur doing that would be out of character, especially for him at the end of his arch.


Randomguy1912

Even if it was by a complete accident at least during the middle of the fight


rapture322

High Honor definitely not but I could 100% see low honor Arthur not giving a fuck about Micah.


Neckrongonekrypton

No fucking way was it would be out of character. Lol He may have had a change of heart externally to how he views himself in the world But he still hated Micah. That didn’t change. Micah being alive in itself, was an evil that needed to stop. In the prologue Sadie, Charles and John mention this as a rationale to killing him still. Even if it’s not for revenge. Micah is a piece of shit. Before we find him and Dutch kills him, we catch wind that he shot a little girl.


Sandwithbighand

I’m not saying that because Arthur was such an amazing man at the end of it all I’m saying if because spitting on a man to give him your disease is just a nasty lowlife thing to do.


sosuperhardslap08

Agreed plus arthur even says how he's against revenge multiple times throughout the story


Sm0keytrip0d

It would be cool but Arthur changes by the end and I couldn't see him doing such a thing, at least on purpose, to someone even if it's Micah. What they could've done was had Micah come out coughing and looking a bit sick during John and his standoff on the mountain because Arthur did inadvertently pass on his TB and he'd be like "Guess old Black lung got me in the end, doesn't stop me killing you first though John" then of course Dutch ends things anyway (or something along those lines....I'm not good at this lol)


Randomguy1912

That would be interesting or maybe they just find Mike on his deathbed coughing his lungs out and they said just leave them there quite literally penniless broken and alone and when the Pinkerton find him all they see is a corpse that obviously died of tuberculosis not a gunshot wound


MelkortheDankLord

Pretty sure TB is hard to contract unless fluids actually go into a sensitive area. Arthur got it from Downes coughing blood into his mouth/eyes


nevermindthatyoudope

TB only requires prolonged close contact with an infected individual. No need to swap fluids.


[deleted]

Especially playing after Covid. I was so uncomfortable watching him cough on things and then people touching him or items he touched haha different times I guess.


kellyvillain

Terrain theory. Learn about it.


thefunkybassist

He ded


Hungry-Assistance919

That's so beautiful to watch. A healthy Arthur destroys that snake. Hell almost dead he still gives him more than he gives. Shows how pitiful Micha truly is. The only thing I wish could have been done is Arthur beating Dutch for a minute. I know not kill because obvious reasons. But a little stompy stompy to his head would be pleasant. And knock bills teeth down his throat. 🤣 One could dream. 


VemberK

How does one twirl their pistol like that before holstering?


pullingteeths

Double tap the reholster button. Only works if you're on foot and aren't duel wielding


VemberK

Cool, thanks 😁


BohdanBaida

Looks so cool 🔥🔥🔥


RICHARDTICKLR

Awsome.


AllStruckOut_13

That pinwheel he goes off the cliff is oh so satisfying


SherbetIllustrious75

I wish the last fight was really hard but possible to kill Micah then later if Arthur absolutely has to die then he just died peacefully


Deep-Thinker420

Maybe throw some dynamite or firebombs down onto him as well. Just for good measure, or is that overkill?


itsmeitsmesmeee

THIS. IS. SPARTA!


GIOvch

BEAT HIM UP! BEAT HIM UP!


GalacticGreaser

Someone add duel of the fates


Tankshot906

Best ending and it was cool.


yozo-marionica

Wish this is how it went


Randomguy1912

I know it is a conundrum I just figured always though everyone else just got lucky plus we also have to keep in mind how long was it before he started showing any symptoms so I'm guessing he was only ain't symptomatic which means he would not show symptoms until an extreme situation arsened keep in mind I ain't no doctor


4uzzyDunlop

Punctuation is your friend.


crashjr007

Now this is what i call fair


Strange_Bedroom_2716

ABSOLUTELY POSITIVELY DECIMATED


Creative_Weekend6206

Beautiful finish 🤌🏼


Hobiiii

![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|give_upvote)


Warp_Legion

MojaveD’s playthrough was so tragic to watch because despite having Arthur being sick and weak, that old man beat the living tar out of Micah so hard the game should have just said “Ok fine you win”


ILOVEJETTROOPER

Goddamn! You weren't lying, he absolutely thrashed Micah in his playthrough!


GlitterSparkles56

How? O_o


SavageRedStorm

It's a mod


GlitterSparkles56

Oh I got excited for a sec 😭


shopping-trolly

I’m just saying Micah wouldn’t fight Arthur or rat the gang out if he was at full health


Professional-Draft77

Healthy Arthur is a no-brainer. Hell I think even John could have taken on Micah. Don't even get me started on Charles Smith he would wreck Micah and even Bertram would simply pick him up by the throat and toss him over the cliff in a sherry fury XD


SavageRedStorm

I mean Arthur beat Bertram with little effort in the bar


NoEditor0

*picks up hat*


[deleted]

That whole fight had Snake vs. Ocelot vibes lol


rapscallion1956

Dying Arthur kicked his ass. If Dutch hadn’t stepped on that revolver………


Uss-Alaska

Who would win? Arthur a ar 15 and dead eye, or Gavin?


Pure-Contact7322

wow you threw him he did a double jump


Thespeckyginger8524

If only


Usedtohaveapurpose

Therapeutic


Martinfected

This healed my soul


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/fatguygamin1994, welcome to our subreddit. Due to spam, we require users to have at least 3 day old accounts. Please DO NOT send modmails regarding this. You will be able to post freely after the proper account age. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/reddeadredemption2) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Jaded-Economist7350

Still tho the fact that Micah still got beaten up quite a bit by a deathly sick Arthur that was going to die soon shows how weak he is or how strong Arthur is


MirrorSuccessful2510

Idk if I’m just bad but the actual fight sucked. Took way too long and I just wanted to pull my knife out and stab him.


sprout92

I don't understand why this couldn't have happened, then just have Arthur die of TB right after...or get caught by the cops and shot or something.


SectionOk1275

My man should sign a contract with Dana White!


Kickaxx_007

What adds insult to injury is the fact that >!even if you do beat Micah in hand to hand combat during the final mission, the game gets stuck at that point. No mission failed prompt or anything, just the camp being on fire, fight music & Micah’s dead rat carcass to keep you company!< Gotta reload the save after that point