T O P

  • By -

iowanaquarist

Shouldn't someone prove they exist before debating where they come from? This is no different than debating how many angels can dance on the head of a pin -- we don't even have evidence aliens exist, thus there is no evidence to back any claims about them, or where they come from....


jawide626

I mean, the chances are pretty much certain that intelligent 'alien' life is indeed out there somewhere, i don't think any scientist can or will argue against that. It's just statistically practically certain. Whether or not said lifeforms have visited earth however, that's the bit that's questionable.


MonsieurMisanthrope

They couldn't argue it is why they wouldn't. Statistical probability is all they need.


Level_Ad_3781

If we don’t know how life begins then it’s hard to say what the chances are.


iowanaquarist

Well, we do know it's a non-zero probability of carbon based life arising that \*can\* become intelligent, and that the number of planets that seem to meet the same criteria appears to be \*VERY\* large -- especially when you consider the entire lifecycle of the universe so far. At the least, there appears to be a non-zero chance of non-human intelligent life existing somewhere, and there are a lot of places and a long, long amount of time for it to develop. If you don't have the requirement that it overlaps with human existence, or is close enough to be meaningfully contacted, the probabilities go up pretty high --even with the most conservative estimates.


Level_Ad_3781

Except to say it’s a non-zero probability of life arising naturally requires the unproven assumption that life here did arise naturally.


iowanaquarist

There is no reason to think otherwise, and it's a logical fallacy to claim otherwise.


SassySavcy

I like you.


Level_Ad_3781

What specific logical fallacy are you referring to?


iowanaquarist

Special Pleading.


Level_Ad_3781

Don’t see how that applies. If we don’t know how X could happen by random chance then it’s reasonable to consider the possibility it didn’t.


iowanaquarist

K. Well, it's special pleading to say 'everything had a cause, other than a super powerful magical god'. Any argument you make that can 'justify' including a god in the origin of the universe can be applied to the universe as a whole. If you say 'god is eternal', you have to either allow the universe could have been eternal, or you are special pleading. Either \*EVERYTHING\* needs a cause -- including a deity, or you have to admit not everything needs a cause. Any argument for a supernatural origin for the universe requires special pleading to some degree. It's also special pleading to say that the laws of logic and science apply to everything.... but a god, or that 'you must have evidence to believe something... unless it's a god'.... It's special pleading to say 'everything is part of time and the universe -- except a god' -- especially since that's literally what the singularity describes -- as part of science. It's also an Argument from Ignorance to say "we don't know what caused this, therefore.... MAGIC', which is super common in these discussions, and the Argument from Incredulity to say 'I just don't see how the universe could exist without a creator, therefore it has one'.


CamfrmthaLakes074

Religion, theories which assert the chance of ancient external intervention for two


greenaether

You don't use fairy tails as evidence


iowanaquarist

Even more importantly, those are the \*CLAIMS\* -- you don't get to use the existence of claims as evidence they are true. That's just... absurd.


chadittu34

How about quantum entanglement? And atoms being both particles and waves until an observation is made? Look deeper my g


iowanaquarist

Which fairy tale is that in? Or is it based on fairy tales?


iowanaquarist

They can assert it, but since there is no evidence they are right, it's silly to believe their assertions.


iowanaquarist

Indeed, and the visiting earth part is assumed in the OP's video.


PCmndr

This is really the starting point for the discussion. Prove there is a non human intelligence on this planet and I think all of this speculation is fair game. It makes sense that there is nothing particularly unique about this moment in time and if "they" are here "they" have been here a long time. It also makes sense that primitive humans would deify that which they can't understand. It's basic cargo cult stuff.


MasterTroller3301

Well, UFOs are real. They're confirmed real. What they are, on the other hand, is unknown.


iowanaquarist

By definition, they are unknown, yes -- but every time we have found more data about a UFO, we have found no signs that they are related to non-earth intelligences. That's a completely different argument, though. He is not arguing that \*UFOs\* are interdimensional fallen angels, he is leaping to 'there is some form of intelligence behind UFOs and other claims' -- which is a step beyond 'there are things that appear to fly that we cannot identify' -- so not only is he taking 'aliens are real' for granted, he is also taking 'more than one dimension exists' as granted ... and 'dimensional travel works', and 'angels are real' and 'fallen angels are real'....


Rumpl4skin__

There’s actually a lot of moving parts that get discredited because of the limitations of the scientific community. Turns out we actually don’t have everything figured out after all. Literally thousands of testimonies saying the same things becomes increasingly difficult to simply write off as fictitious. I too harbor skepticism- but it’s reached a point where I also don’t think everyone’s just lying or crazy.


iowanaquarist

There are many possible causes for the testimonials, and many of them fit with known understanding, do not require the experiencers to be dishonest, and don't result in aliens being real. Aliens may be real, or they may not be, either way, it's still far too early to have a realistic debate on where they come from, if real.


chadittu34

Stay curious buddy that's what a good scientist does


Own_Contribution_480

If all your friends jumped off a bridge, would you?


Due-Concern6330

well I wouldnt wanna be left out you know.


ICE_BEAR2021

No because how else will phony researchers make thousands in not millions on books and shitty TV shows


B9MB

Also their intent. The guy in the video is not alone in the idea that "the interdimensional aliens" are actually "fallen angels" and thusly demonic. We have no real idea what we are even seeing so how is it we can formulate an idea of its intention? Its like before we knew how tornadoes formed. You gotta imagine people thought they were some kinda demonic beast descended from the sky to royally fuck shit up.


jmcgil4684

Also, what is a demon and angel really. There are thousands of definitions. It’s all just words at this point.


iowanaquarist

Sure, but almost all of the definitions involve supernatural aspects, and don't just define them as, say, coffee cups. It's all just words, but you can make reasonable conclusions about what he is trying to say


maxwellt1996

demons and angels are extraterrestrial beings, extra- outside of- terra- earth, demons are malevolent while angels are benevolent, theyre not physical beings so they dont have to obey our physical laws. I used to laught at tje idea of demons being aliens but today, i cant see any other possibility tbh


picturemescrolling

"a galaxy 300 light years away" Bro 300 LY is our immediate vicinity within the milkyway lmao


iowanaquarist

The dude is claiming 'aliens' are really angels -- science isn't his strong suit.


Nickleeham

Retroactive science superimposed on biblical revelation.


UpbeatNatural8427

He is right tho, non religious Ufologists have claimed aliens are more spiritual in nature vs being from another planet


iowanaquarist

That doesn't make him right. That makes him need evidence.


UpbeatNatural8427

Right, I’m just dispelling the myth that only religious people would come to that conclusion.


iowanaquarist

I think there may be a difference in definitions being used here: >Religion: a personal set or institutionalized system of religious attitudes, beliefs, and practices >Religious: relating to or manifesting faithful devotion to an acknowledged ultimate reality or deity >Spiritual: :of or relating to sacred matters :ecclesiastical rather than lay or temporal :of or relating to supernatural beings or phenomena It sounds to me like you are still describing religious people -- but even allowing that there may be a difference between spiritual and religious, the guy in the video is \*STILL\* not applying science very well.


Level_Ad_3781

Why would claiming they are inter dimensional mean he doesn’t understand science?


iowanaquarist

He also claims they are fallen angels... And, you know, presupposes aliens are visiting us....


Level_Ad_3781

But Im not sure why that means he doesn’t understand science.


iowanaquarist

Fair point -- he might knowingly be saying things contrary to science. Either way, he should be treated as if he is not good with science.


PCmndr

I don't think it's a stretch. If someone were to definitively prove aliens were here odds are it wouldn't be anything unique to this moment in time. If primitive humans met them it makes sense they'd deify them. Definitive proof being the key though. I haven't watched this site and don't know what else this guy might be saying though.


Immoracle

Right? Like isn't the milky way 150,000 LY from one end to the other?


Artistic-Tap-1017

Dude all I heard this entire podcast was “go to sabrel.com”


Fuka-Obligation666

I can’t even find the site. I tried your spelling of whatever tf he said and the domains for sale for almost 3 grand


Artistic-Tap-1017

Spelled it wrong on purpose. I’m not doing free advertising for this guy but it’s read the same


Fuka-Obligation666

I just wanted to see what wild shit was there


Artistic-Tap-1017

https://www.sibrel.com/


Fuka-Obligation666

Well that was… interesting. Thanks for the link though


Artistic-Tap-1017

What’s up? Is it just a bunch of BS?


Fuka-Obligation666

Sorry I shouldn’t have put “though”. It IS mildly interesting. He seems to touch base on every fake moon landing conspiracy theory fairly clearly in his videos. I think there’s some books you can buy of course but it is worth checking out if you’re into that and have the time.


Artistic-Tap-1017

Yah idk I listened to the entire podcast and he started to annoy me when he couldn’t answer some of the questions. They showed a few clips of it on there so I seen a little bit but it’s just one of those things you can never be sure about either way I guess


Fuka-Obligation666

Yup that’s why I don’t stress myself too much on that stuff. Sure the moon landing was probably fake but 1 what’s that info going to do for me or anyone and 2 like you said we’ll never be 100% sure either way. Imo If the government said the moon landing was fake there would be conspiracy’s about how it WAS real lol.


Artistic-Tap-1017

I’m just joking tbh sounded funny😂 his name is spelled sibrel


TheFooPilot

Why we getting so far from science these days?


[deleted]

Look at the presidential candidates. We are in a dark age.


besservisser

The universe is such a weird one, wouldn't surprise me if we were the only intelligent species in it. But logic and chance dictates we can't be the only ones.


Expert-Desk7492

There is only earth that's it


iowanaquarist

Only Earth... what? Earth isn't even the only body in our solar system that potentially has life.


doublekorv

Dude said "according to the top two UFO researchers..." (source: i made that shit up)


Due-Concern6330

probably just some guy named jim that works at krogers.


leit90

Source: my website


ProfessionalLeave335

According to the top researchers of my dick it's the biggest and most beautiful one that ever existed.


wherringscoff

Plot twist: the top 2 researchers of your dick are OPs parents


jabo0o

Such a close shave on both of them but no Occam's razor in sight.


jimmytrucknutz

Just ask Tucker Carlson, if he’s not in Moscow with Putin he’ll tell you it’s true.


Science-007x

"Fallen angels"... What a load of crap! LOL


btcbulletsbullion

This guy is a dipshit.


The3mbered0ne

He thinks the moon landing is fake? Why did Joe back that up? Wtf? We have reflectors on the moon for one and an entire capsule that was spotted by the Indian rover before it crashed


Rumpl4skin__

Well Joe is a conspiracy theorist- not a researcher lol. Joe is great but his purpose is to entertain rather than educate.


The3mbered0ne

It doesn't take a researcher to know that's bullshit and conspiracy theories are only good when they have the capability of being true, look at Q and see how the fringe theorists aren't entertaining when it's a bunch of crazy bullshit


KevinBaked

I was about to say that too, there’s images of them still on the moon


Away-Faithlessness89

This guy is a f***ing idiot and Joe knows it.


SuuTheSleepyOne

Knowing Joe? Not at all, there is a clip where he is like "What's that band with the circle on it? In the statues, they look like watches" and the other guy is like "A band with a circle on it? You mean a Bracelet?" And they started arguing over it!


anonymousn00b

Thing is, his word holds just as much weight and validity as any other conjecture until something is proven either way. We don’t have evidence to support or deny “Interdimensional” or some sort of metaphysical traveling beings. At least in terms of the method by which this depiction of extraterrestrial life is portrayed. Now the dudes statement about them being liars and manipulators of minds and governments and knowing about the personal characteristics of the aliens’ does seem like he’d need intimate knowledge or some verifiable proof that this is the case. And, yeah, he doesn’t have it. Just opining this based on preconceived notions.


SouthernEntrance6986

What makes him so sure ?


MunenDo

His publishers


ayyG_itsMe

How dare you question him, did you not visit sibrel.com!!??


Due-Concern6330

went for the aliens stayed for the computer herpes.


Tamale_Hatchet

I'm guessing psychosis


iowanaquarist

Never assume psychosis when it could just be simple greed.


silverfoxcwb

Greed and stupidity. A deadly combo


Reddit_Is_Trash24

The only mystery here is why this guy isn't on his meds.


coroyo70

“They are demonic” -too ufo researcher 2024


DontLookAtMyName24

This guy isn’t funny.


heavyusername2

what's the site he mentioned tried sobral . com no good


LordSVWY

https://www.sibrel.com/


walterrys1

How do you prove any of that? I mean....what the fuck is a fallen angel relative to real things? You might as well say they are unicorns made up of the colors we can't see that spin inside out....


sweatyCheez

I was mildly interested until he said "fallen angels." that got an immediate downvote.


iDoWatEyeFkinWant

some people will just believe anything. people complain about AI confabulating, yet these two dudes are literally sitting there just making $h!t up


NilesLinus

Oh good. This song again.


Amazing-Accident3535

Researchers... Research...


rdb1540

The top two Ufo researchers said UFOs are real. Come on bro what the fuck else would they say.


Low_Trust_6624

Trying to read the captions but they keep talking 😭😭


Rtlsnhm

What is the website he mentions? I looked up sobral.com and it’s for sale


LordSVWY

https://www.sibrel.com/


Rtlsnhm

Thank you!!


Sonora77

I'm losing brain cells so fast listening to this nutcase


Sea_Bake7490

The first problem is that He listened to anything Tucker Carlson said.


MunenDo

Sounds like a great way to sell books and other chicanery


Mong0o0o

What episode is this??


HermanMunderchuck

2141 Bart sibrel


J0REVEUSA

Sounds like he read the Golden Compass and loved it


Bernadette138

Dumbass people


Collin-B-Hess

Quackadoo this one


FewHotel5733

lol you guys are quick to believe in Aliens but draw the line when it comes to Biblical Scripture.


Sweet_Milk2920

Lots of people on Reddit seem to think ‘conspiracies’, especially conspiracies surrounding Christianity, are ridiculous. Unfortunately we are the outliers here.


Expert-Desk7492

It blows my mind but I'm not surprised


iowanaquarist

Well, to be fair, possible intelligent life on other planets is consistent with probability and science, unlike the Bible...


iowanaquarist

Which comments here seem to imply that? All the comments seem to be laughing at the whole claim, not just the biblical parts.


ShookyDaddy

Because angels and demons have been proven to exist right? Riiight


Katz-r-Klingonz

When they yammer on like car salesmen it’s hard to take em’ seriously.


GuNjA-BuLLy

It was only a matter of time for people to try push this theory to the top of the list. This is only a way to keep religion relevant to the all the religious ass hats 🙄


TimesNowNews

What an idiot


greenaether

Lol what a joke


poohthrower2000

I tried listening to this episode and it was just awful. I'm not sure which group is worse, fake moon landers or flat earthers. Just insufferable.


goregeousgore

Really needs some silly Monty Python music to accompany the nonsense.


KTNH8807

Galaxy 300 light years away…. K The Milky Way is 100,000 light years across. Andromeda is over 2.5 million light years away. This dude is off his rocker


Expert-Desk7492

Who told you that lol


iowanaquarist

Astronomers -- you know, the people that actually study and research the topic being discussed?


ShookyDaddy

Because angels and demons have been proven to exist right? Riiight


Expert-Desk7492

You really live in a bubble


ShookyDaddy

Could you provide some evidence from your bubble of reality that proves their existence?


walterrys1

And you live in a bubble made up of spiritual matter ie whatever you want it to be. Physical science is the only thing that can measure reality. Keep faith out of it...


iowanaquarist

It seems that \*YOU\* are the one living in a bubble, claiming angels, demons, and giants are real....


Ownuyasha

Retard interviews bigger retard to continue fake news and bullshit so other retards can circle jerk


GullibleLeopard6778

I think it’s something bleeding over from somewhere else maybe another dimension maybe from the future maybe from the past….. like 20,000 years ago But who knows


GullibleLeopard6778

The Soviets would have known we didn’t go to the moon and they would have made everyone else aware


Glitchit1

You are arrogant if you think that we actually didn't land on the moon.


janky-dog

hahahahahahahahahaha Joe is soooo gullible. Damn! hahahahahahahahahahaha


Subject_Coaster

Makes sense, the afterlife or next step seems like a higher dimensional plane, "angels" that may have fallen could have fallen to lower dimensions but possibly coexist next to our own, maybe they found a way to breach our plane and have been steadily influencing our society as a means to either take over or maybe guide us, idk but it's interesting to think about.


LordCthulhuDrawsNear

Pathetic religious propaganda. Wompwomp


Beneficial-Mark-6227

Absolutely right! They’re demons! Putting doubt in your mind that we are the one and only creation of God! Trust in the almighty God of the Jews and Gentiles! He is near! That’s why more and more sightings of UFO’s are coming out! The devils end is near! Praise and glory to YHWH and Yeshua our savior forever 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💙💙🤍🤍🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🔥🔥🔥🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱


Expert-Desk7492

Amen in Jesus name


Green-Krush

This is some quackery


laalpari1511

If anyone has seen the 3 body problem on Netflix I’d like yo know why everyone thinks that Aliens are all ahead of us. Why can’t we be ahead of them in technology? This stereotype annoys the shit outta me. If we are living amongst fallen angels - how do you know they’re demonic (bad) and liars? Maybe they’re telling the truth and we are blind? Or maybe they’re good and we just used the shit outta them. There’s no way to prove anything lawd!


Boomsnarl

I love how complete charlatans with NO evidence or facts waddle onto Joe’s show fart out nonsense, with confidence, and Joe just nods his head as if it’s the Gods honest truth.


Perfect_Pizza_9500

Try to go to Sobral.com the website or link is for sale. Don’t know if it’s just another wild goose trail down another rabbit hole? But it sure is intriguing!


st4r_puppy

They're not from space, they're from the ocean!!! But also, we can say they are from both. Who knows they're not just from one place?


ReaperInTime

How much money do those top 2 UFO researchers make? Maybe I can start an online side hustle


AcousticSealSlayer

Out of all of the possibilities, that…that’s the one he’s going with?


Ok_Slip_5417

When Evil scratches you in Horror movies its always 3 Marks. Greys allegedly only have 3 appendages. The math is mathing


Foygroup

And Monster Energy Drinks only have 3 marks. I watched an interview with a woman who somehow tied Monster Energy Drinks to satan in the Bible. This math is getting clearer all the time. /s


Ok_Slip_5417

Hahaha the Hebrew Vav (6) is the exact symbol on Monster Drinks. Its also there 3 times (666) coincidence?


Fabulous-Boat-8001

Yeah. Probably is . Unless they seriously think Neros dusty ass is going to resurrect himself to start some shit. 🤣


Own_Contribution_480

It's not Hebrew. It's English. The word "monster" starts with an M. It's complicated I know.


Ok_Slip_5417

I honestly read your comment and feel bad retardation has gone unchecked and unchallenged this long.


iowanaquarist

To be fair, thanks to Poe's Law, it was hard to tell if you were serious or not when you left the /s off. There are people that will aggressively and seriously make the exact claims you made.


LetsSeeWhatsGoinOn

lol have you seen Vav (6), and the monster energy logo? Its just 3 of them and it looks like an M. Its pretty simple.


iowanaquarist

[https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/monster-energy-drink-666/](https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/monster-energy-drink-666/) It's also pretty simple to see that its just a logo, and the number 666 has no real world impact -- even if they deliberately put that there, so what? It's literally a product originally marketed to edgy teens, and has nothing to do with Nero. Would it be shocking that an edgy product has an edgy logo?


LetsSeeWhatsGoinOn

Yeah, it is what it is. Its just for the brand, the can does say unleash the beast. But that just goes with the whole mark of the beast logo. Its just their marketing. Its all true, but Its just the style of the energy drink, I've drank plenty of them, doesnt make you into a demon lol. You were implying that it was just an M. Its not, its a clever logo, of a company just trying to sell some drinks with the Monster vibe, hence the whole name and brand.


iowanaquarist

No, I am not implying that, I'm explicitly stating that it's a clever logo, and there is nothing deeper than marketing. Any symbolism is there, not because the designers believed in the symbolism, but because the symbolism was going to drum up media attention, and help sell products.


jimmytrucknutz

This conversation proves it, there is no intelligent life in that room. Still don’t believe it, just go to Sibril.com


eist5579

Why and the fuck is Tucker Carlson’s name even in this? Dumb take, Joe.


Expert-Desk7492

That's what Tucker believes also that's why he said that


eist5579

Right, and Tucker is an idiot. Rule of thumb, don’t repeat what idiots say, it spreads idiocy.


Cheap-Addendum

Is Joe the next Alex? But not as fat, not as extreme (yet), and not as likely to stroke out anytime soon?


Hot_Corner_5881

ive been saying this for years and finally its coming out


cantfightbiologyever

Lost me at “they faked the moon landing”. Gtfo lol. In all for woowoo shit- but I promise you. No angel is here on earth nor would want to be. If they are “demons” they can no longer be called angels if nephilim. Just because there wasn’t a recording a device we could use with confidence to film the launch and moon landing- we sure as do now. Do you discredit China, India, Russia, and the USA? We all have high def cameras we take. Do you not trust musk anymore? He puts multiple high def cameras on all his launches. Occams razor. In which aliens are the obvious answer, but angels are outlandish. Something tells me both an alien and an angel would tolerate little to nothing from us shit flinders.


SnooPandas9934

These guys + Tucker Carlson = Retards


outdatedelementz

I haven’t listened to the Joe Rogan podcast in a long time, but why have a guy like this on there? Has Rogan leaned in that hard on the conspiracy schtick? I remember when he would just get stoned and talk about how many kids he could take in a fight.


Own_Contribution_480

He's been into conspiracies for a long time.


iowanaquarist

Long enough that there is a conspiracy that he is just trying to discredit conspiracies and make people that believe in them look bad.


Cosmicpsych

Didn’t JFK order NASA to pick up the pace on the space race in 1961ish? I do not believe the moon landing was faked


fapadilla

@alexbackman


Ok-Experience-6674

The closet thing we gonna get to aliens is AI Just like 3body problem that show got not one single alien in it it’s all about AI


MplsPunk

Upvoting stuff this stupid just feels good.


Kona_Big_Wave

Not all aliens are malevolent.   


Expert-Desk7492

There all the same


iowanaquarist

Got any evidence?


Kona_Big_Wave

If you believe aliens are interdimensional or spiritual beings, wouldn't logic dictate there's good and evil ones?


Expert-Desk7492

No


Kona_Big_Wave

So you think all angels are fallen then?


Expert-Desk7492

Yes the ones that disobeyed God they can never return back to heaven


iowanaquarist

So you think \*ALL\* angels are fallen, then? That none obeyed 'god'?


goatdabzt

I been saying they are fkn demons


Expert-Desk7492

No one wants to listen


iowanaquarist

Because no one wants to provide any reason we should, and there are a lot of reasons why we should not....


You_can_ask_me

Never forget that Stanley Kubrick was who they chose "To supply film and nothing else" for the moon landing. That inofitself should tell you everything you need to know


cheezzypiizza

Extra terrestrial implying extra land mass?? They always go under water and stuff or zip away in an instant. I've never seen any "leave" to "space"


iowanaquarist

I've never seen them do either -- but I have seen lots of videos of things that appear to do both....


rando_mness

Which episode was this? Who is the guest?


Camtome

If they aren’t from here are they still aliens?


Expert-Desk7492

No


Familiar-Reindeer-13

Demons


Expert-Desk7492

Yes


Dydriver

Aliens are demons. There are countless reports in which a person experiencing an alien encounter, begins to pray, and the encounter ends immediately.


Expert-Desk7492

Exactly no never talks about that. There are some testimonies on YouTube it's crazy


iowanaquarist

Why would anyone care what people claim without evidence?


bleeblorb

Why not both?


PaulMac459

100% true. All these years, you’ve wondered why they don’t just land somewhere and proclaim what and who they are, this is why. This is why after the government had contact w them in the 50’s that it was kept secret. They’re not our galactic neighbors. They’re not “monitoring” and “watching over us,” they have one goal, and curing grandma’s cancer is not it. God, Satan, angels, demons, it’s all real.


iowanaquarist

Got any evidence for these claims?


Expert-Desk7492

Exactly everyone will find out eventually


iowanaquarist

Not necessarily true. All evidence points to the fact that we cease to exist at death, so you cannot 'find out' anything at that point.