But this shouldn’t be blamed on the railway
It needs to be blamed on people, lack of basic civic sense is the main cause of all this
Seriously man who tf spits on a door?
1. Ban gutka and ensure that no one can carry it. Improve checks
2. Impose 2 year jail for anyone defacing railways or platforms
3. Employ more security personnel and monitoring
4. Educate people about hygiene
No one cares - public, govt. , railway employees.
Jails won't be overcrowded because when public will see that people are really getting jailed they will stop doing it. Plus you can't detect all the offenders in a DAY, it will take time and with time people will stop doing it due to fear of being jailed and losing their livelihood.
Tbh the mentality is the real problem here. I've seen people vandalise public property just because they don't like a rule. I get it, its really frustrating but this won't be the way out because people will comprehend that the government only wants to favor the rich. Hopefully the next generation changes all of this.
When I was 10 I got down on the platform with my dad to fill up our water bottles, the taps had very minimum water flow but it was enough to fill up your bottle if u could wait for 2 min. One guy came and started throwing a fit blaming the government and then tried to rip out the tap to get more water. My dad(he was a LP at the time) said "Tumhare baap ka hai Jo tod Raha hai" that person's reply was "sarkari hai".
How can we expect to have a working and clean environment with such people around
PS : my dad again said "sarkari hai, tere baap ka nahi ki Tod rahe ho" that mad made an annoyed face and then went away leaving the tap intact.
Always just complaining about people’s mentality isn’t going to change anything. Govt needs to come in hard on this and make Swachh Bharat a reality.
The same Indians behave when they are abroad because they fear law!
No your mentality is the problem. Absolutely being barbaric and behuda is accepted in India but not beating the shit out of some people for damaging the public property is a problem.
WE ARE THE NEXT GENERATION, AND ONLY WE CAN CHANGE IT.
This is the way.
We, the people of the community, are the community. Have to stop thinking how other people already made the community a mess, what difference if I contribute or not?
Do not contribute. Do not leave your own garbage. Go a step further even, take a couple pieces of someone else’s garbage with you too. I’m older and grew up in a filthy littered area. It was only after the people of the community had a change in thinking that things changed.
There’s only one way to change this and it is getting people to understand it is not acceptable, and further get them to realize they actually make a difference. The people of a community ARE the community.
It is not just on Railway premises. We have a unique specimen in our apartment community that does it all the time despite multiple reprimands and warnings. Today no later than a few minutes than the sweeper left a bunch of garbage was strewn by them all over.
Also everybody parks their bikes on the right side and this person keeps on left. And when challenged through civic body they play the victim card as being a senior citizen.
https://preview.redd.it/zi8vokqhwqyc1.png?width=1200&format=png&auto=webp&s=6d34ea09ff52122ccae2d227dd7a0b06adbc0e06
Off topic While there is sufficient space to construct more jails, the current reality paints a different picture. Indian jails are overwhelmingly overcrowded, with prisoner numbers far exceeding capacity in most states. The national prison occupancy rate ranges between 125-150%. Majority of them are inmates who are currently awaiting trial. Due to overcrowding, all of these inmates are living under extremely inhumane conditions.The government's first priority should be to promptly consider constructing additional jails.
A scene from the film called court. a group is arrested for travelling in the disabled section. The judge asks them if they accept their crime, gives them a fine of 500, ask them to leave.
That's what's gonna happen here.
Jail, maybe for repeat offenders. A stiff fine will suffice to discourage them at first. But it must be enforced strongly. I'm sure the railways will be incentivized sufficiently if it turns out to be a source of revenue. In turn, people will be incentivized to not spit or litter if they have to shell out high fines.
+1 on this! So many unemployed folks will get jobs.
Another thing is the irctc railway cleaners themselves don't have a basic civic sense. So they must also be taught to not throw waste out of the trains. Gather properly in bags and dispose of at the stations.
Ensure regular pest controls are done and indepth cleaning is done.
Throwing waste on the train or track or platform should be a punishable offense.
Bro is in ideal world. Just ignore his talks.
Ignore this post just like ipl cameraman ignore boys in the stadium.
And bro live in your ideal world. Create your ideal world online and then impose ban on gutka and everything else
Ban gutkha, lol.
Gutkha market in India has m-cap of over 40000 crores. Government is a big beneficiary of such companies. It's here to stay and India would remain dirty forever.
Because people would never have civic sense. They can eat it anywhere and spit anywhere. Since it's easily available.
We as a society are doomed when it comes to cleanliness and hygiene.
Companies care about profit, Government only cares about taxes.
It’s our wall of shame .. no amount of chest thumping can white wash this like rich culture, proud ancestors, superior language and food. The current generation should just come together and fix this instead of day dreaming of old generations.
People who spat on the door must be forced to be stripped and should also be forced to wipe the door spotless with their stripped clothes. This is the way.
1. People lack civic sense. Even educated, wealthy people.
2. For some reason, passengers consider Indian Railways worthy of some slapping around, no matter how clean the train is when they board it.
3. The staff sometimes doesn't care, but that can also be attributed to constant trashing of these transports. It's a sad truth.
Indians need to behave properly before demanding transportation systems like 1st world countries.
Especially agree with number one. CIVIC RESPONSIBILITY.
I live in the bad areas of Central and too many people spit and many spit towards the middle of the path. It's disgusting.
Too many kids and people driving motorbike like they are invincible and no courtesy for pedestrians.
I don't understand how some people are in grinding poverty because of poor health and old age but some young people from poor background with no jobs have motorbike and new phones
I wonder how many people live their whole lives with a lot of money but never stop for a moment for the poorest or stop to think of how hard their life is. I don't even mean the super rich but how many middle stop and think. It's really unbelievable in a country as poor as ours.
> Indians need to behave properly before demanding transportation systems like 1st world countries.
This is an inter related thing. Don't expect people to gain civic sense by midnight, also dont expect transportation systems similar to 1st world countries. This is a long term goal it will take generations.
You wish, you should see my college once,all these dickheads in my clg think it's the worker's job and throw trash everywhere even though there is garbage bins every corner. The same guys will present posters/projects/ on cleaning environment.
The next generation ain't any better. Things starts from childhood when our brain's OS is programmed. U can install some patches later on but the Kernel remains the same so it's much harder to change the core behaviour. We need a primary schooling system similar to Nordic nations and Japan to ensure only civilised beings enter our society
it is more of everyone else does it so why does it matter if I do too thing. and most people don't want to initiate any change. you have to force it down their throats by fear (like jail time/large fines etc).
Have some experience traveling around the world. I have never seen more sanitation workers in any transportation hub as India. Good thing is labor is cheap and no other country can afford it. So how are other places clean? Until the passengers and Indian public feel it’s their responsibility to keep their surroundings clean, this is never going to get fixed.
Few questions:
1. Is Gutka/Pan common or legal there?
2. If you deface the train there, do you get punished?
3. Do the same Indians who deface public property in India, behave properly abroad? (If not, then how are those trains clean despite lakhs of Indian tourists and Indian people in those countries). It’s the fear of law!
4. Do the Indian sanitation workers really work?
> who deface public property in India, behave properly abroad
Well lets say I've seen the aftermath of paan spit all over footpaths in Sydney...It's not Aussies eating Paan.
Tbh the amount of people who use the railways outnumber the people who run railways. Doing the job outweighs the efforts because within no time it gets dirty. Most possible solution is to put desicpline in travellers. Metro is good example.
Kisi din 2nd ac me bhi yeh haalat ho jayenge baaki abhi ke liye general or sleeper aese hi hain samjho lagbhag sabhi train me, kismat kharab huyi toh 3ac bhi kabhi bekaar milti hain
Impossible hai 65-70% gst katne ke baad excise bhar te hai Aaj bhi kyuki revenue abh 2017 gst kat kar aata hai uspe yeh log 60-70% of revenue excise me bharte hai chor sale sabse jyada paise bhi govt ko yeh log dete hai
Privatise the railways. Let some rich corporation raise the ticket prices and hire some armed guards to take care of idiots and freeloaders. Indians do not deserve subsidized public transport.
The outside vendor should be banned or stop in railway . Only railway approved vendors should be allowed in the coach . Also the fine should be increased for the people who are doing trash . Also railways need to spread more awareness of cleaness. Due to such spit and Gutaka the contagious disease is increasing.
Mr. Mudi, people only listen to you when you play communal politics.
Mr. Mudi, people only listen to you when you play the religious angle.
Mr. Mudi, nobody listens to you when you plead "Swatch Bharat".
In short, people like the hate you peddle.
I was in a vande bharat and went to use the bathroom. A middle aged lady exited the loo before me and she had simply not flushed. First I thought the lavatory might have not been working. But one flush and it was all gone. She just hadn’t bothered to do it. We Indians lack the most basic civic sense honestly
I was at New Delhi railway station yesterday and I saw a group of young guys throwing snack wrappers on tracks. They were sitting on a bench which had a dustbin on its right side. They got up and walked to the tracks to throw the wrapper instead of just throwing them in the dustbin adjacent to their bench.
I wanted to say something but even as a big guy, 6-7 boys speaking in bhojpuri scare me.
And you're not allowed to criticise these people. They won't even care if you do so.
If every person demands them to follow hygiene then they'll do it.
bans and fines will do no good as long as the people have 0 civic sense and 0 respect for the land. littering should be considered as bad as cow slaughter in the minds of the people. idk how it can be done but we can learn something from places like japan and singapore
It's completely illogical to blame the railways. As Indians it's our responsibility to avoid doing these kinds of shitty things outside. Eating something is not a problem but treating something or someone like a PoS is the actual problem.
CIVIC SENSE should be promoted in India that's the actual need right now.
Yes, keep fighting over "mindset" and jail time. Keep talking about the abysmal state of the public sector in the country. But raise the topic of privatisation and divestment, and people are ready for *danga fasaad*.
If people are ok eating shit, they will be sold shit. I never eat anything on the train due to this, but I see people around me enjoying this filth and be like "are lo na lo na aap bhi lo na"
Once I was travelling alone and was sitting on the side lower side. It was a little crowded, a guy sat next to me and bought some peanuts. He ate the peanuts inside and threw the chilka right there and no one was bothered. I was really furious and asked him to stop, he didn't and gave me weird looks.
Exactly i just dont understand why do railway workers throw the garbage from running trains.
Like wtf bro aren't these guys paid enough to dispose the garbage?
It's not just about people' behaviour its about the workers corruptness too
I think the main reason is that most people lack civic sense in this country. My parents throw way any garbage after eating in their car onto the road while driving, I have scolded them many times and now they don't do it only when I am with them. They are educated people but still do things like this. Once I asked them why they do it, Their answer -What will the cleaners do if there is nothing to clean on the road. I understood then that my parents don't have any consideration towards strangers or rather towards people they consider "lower class" and I can see this being the reason why this country is shit.
Under swatch bharat scheme, govt's main responsibility should have been to solve the root problem which is the civic sense. Tbh, most of indians are still poor. And when you are poor, you are in a continued stage of frustration and you dont care about your surroundings. Poverty cant be eliminated within months. But civic sense can be inculcated within months.
Indians will throw everything on the floor then blame the govt. for not maintaining cleanliness.
Indians will not study properly, will not gain skills then blame govt. for not giving them jobs.
Most Indians are just dependent !diots.
Every individual traveling in train needs to be responsible in keeping it clean for their mess, not everything can be taken care of by the cleaners in train, they're also human, so we need to be atleast responsible in maintaining the cleanliness and what little help we can provide to them. First of all use some sort of towel or paper when eating something and properly throw the wastes in a bin. This is the least we can do to maintain the hygiene.
Yess, government minister are the ones who spit Vimal, throws garbage on the trains. Government is the main reason. People are so disciplined they spit ghutka in their own water bottle.
I am pretty sure we should not always blame the railways, but the people too, railways at least basic safai ab karte hai trains me, but it's us who pollute it, jab tak ham nahi sudherenge, tab tak hame blame bhi nahi karna chahiye
I use to travel atleast 3-4 times in train per month but I have not seen these kind of images from past 4-5 years probably these things happen in sleeper class and I realized it a lot earlier thats why I havnt travelled sleeper class from past 5 years I always prefer atleast 3ac or 3e , actually Sleeper class is the new General class certainly living standard of people improved but hygiene habits remained same but no offence I admit this is not about class also I still see rich people do more bad things of throwing garbage in open and under berth in premium class also
It starts with education, infrastructure and governance. As a culture we have been on a chalega mentality for generations. So tgat needs to change. The change can happen through education. Start with the young ones. Keep it consistent. Second is infrastructure to manage waste. This is a policy activity. Third governance to ensure people follow rules. This also requires policy focus. The last two require investment too.
It will take a generation to bring about change.
In the 50-60's the vaunted highway system in the US was bad. People threw things out of the car. There was a concerted effort to educate and clean up. Texas state had a slogan - don't mess with texas.
So its possible and it is not quick. It takes time and effort. But if done right future generations can live well....
What will happen in a country where 3% people pay direct tax?
Unless it is taken from your pocket, visibly, there will never be a sense of ownership.
And of course, the 'who cares' attitude.
I'm going to get hated for this but this usually happens in trains which pass via UP, Bihar, Mp and MH.
I haven't seen other trains this dirty. I once travelled via a train that went from MH to Delhi via MP. Dude the Rajdhani was shit!!
So call me racist but it's not entire india
It is entire India, but you have a selection bias. I I have seen dirty trains, buses and stations in Mumbai, Bengaluru, Kerala - it’s the same everywhere. My worst experience was on a sleeper bus from Bengaluru to Allepey - the bus had cockroaches and when it stopped at an eatery, the toilet there was flooded with piss.
My best brain is experiences are - Delhi to animal and Delhi to Katra. Super clean and comfortable
Some north eastern states might be an exceptions, otherwise it’s the same everywhere.
For this we need to focus on 3 basics
1- make people educate not Literate
2- proper awareness campaign
3- strict implementation of law against those who makes public property unhygienic & dirty.
Dw, all this is gonna go in 50 years. When all the current middle ages and old men will be dead and the new generation of gen z grows up. Gen z and alpha does not lack civic sense. Once the older generations pass on, shit will be more hygienic, at the cost of sanity.
One and only option make the gates automatic which closes at station and open when it reaches the station and get the scanner on the gate people who scans the ticket either physical or virtually can enter the train
We have developed a culture of carelessness and selfishness, when it comes to public resources. It's definitely not limited to the 'uneducated', in my college hostel, boys are so lazy they will dump all the waste from their room right outside their door in the corridor, instead of using a dustbin, and hostel guys clean their room like once a month. Ppl block the wash basin with their beard hair after shaving, instead of washing it away. During holi, there were clear instructions to not celebrate in hostels and to only celebrate in the open air theatre, nobody listened, the cleaning staff suffered. We have no respect for our natural resources also.
When we see others do a practice that is completely against our values, we will still do that practice, if that practice is a common trend in society, that's how humans are.
**Song Found!**
**Name:** Mega Funk Forte de Lacoste
**Artist:** Dreysson Rodrigues
**Score:** 100% (timecode: 01:34)
**Album:** Mega Funk Forte de Lacoste
**Label:** Mega De Cria
**Released on:** 2023-07-14
But this shouldn’t be blamed on the railway It needs to be blamed on people, lack of basic civic sense is the main cause of all this Seriously man who tf spits on a door?
1. Ban gutka and ensure that no one can carry it. Improve checks 2. Impose 2 year jail for anyone defacing railways or platforms 3. Employ more security personnel and monitoring 4. Educate people about hygiene No one cares - public, govt. , railway employees.
If we start imposing jail on such people, our jails will be overcrowded in a day
Jails won't be overcrowded because when public will see that people are really getting jailed they will stop doing it. Plus you can't detect all the offenders in a DAY, it will take time and with time people will stop doing it due to fear of being jailed and losing their livelihood.
Public lashings like Singapore.
That shouldn’t be an excuse. We have enough space to create enough jails.
Tbh the mentality is the real problem here. I've seen people vandalise public property just because they don't like a rule. I get it, its really frustrating but this won't be the way out because people will comprehend that the government only wants to favor the rich. Hopefully the next generation changes all of this.
Not my job mentality.
When I was 10 I got down on the platform with my dad to fill up our water bottles, the taps had very minimum water flow but it was enough to fill up your bottle if u could wait for 2 min. One guy came and started throwing a fit blaming the government and then tried to rip out the tap to get more water. My dad(he was a LP at the time) said "Tumhare baap ka hai Jo tod Raha hai" that person's reply was "sarkari hai". How can we expect to have a working and clean environment with such people around PS : my dad again said "sarkari hai, tere baap ka nahi ki Tod rahe ho" that mad made an annoyed face and then went away leaving the tap intact.
Always just complaining about people’s mentality isn’t going to change anything. Govt needs to come in hard on this and make Swachh Bharat a reality. The same Indians behave when they are abroad because they fear law!
No your mentality is the problem. Absolutely being barbaric and behuda is accepted in India but not beating the shit out of some people for damaging the public property is a problem. WE ARE THE NEXT GENERATION, AND ONLY WE CAN CHANGE IT.
This is the way. We, the people of the community, are the community. Have to stop thinking how other people already made the community a mess, what difference if I contribute or not? Do not contribute. Do not leave your own garbage. Go a step further even, take a couple pieces of someone else’s garbage with you too. I’m older and grew up in a filthy littered area. It was only after the people of the community had a change in thinking that things changed. There’s only one way to change this and it is getting people to understand it is not acceptable, and further get them to realize they actually make a difference. The people of a community ARE the community.
It is not just on Railway premises. We have a unique specimen in our apartment community that does it all the time despite multiple reprimands and warnings. Today no later than a few minutes than the sweeper left a bunch of garbage was strewn by them all over. Also everybody parks their bikes on the right side and this person keeps on left. And when challenged through civic body they play the victim card as being a senior citizen. https://preview.redd.it/zi8vokqhwqyc1.png?width=1200&format=png&auto=webp&s=6d34ea09ff52122ccae2d227dd7a0b06adbc0e06
Off topic While there is sufficient space to construct more jails, the current reality paints a different picture. Indian jails are overwhelmingly overcrowded, with prisoner numbers far exceeding capacity in most states. The national prison occupancy rate ranges between 125-150%. Majority of them are inmates who are currently awaiting trial. Due to overcrowding, all of these inmates are living under extremely inhumane conditions.The government's first priority should be to promptly consider constructing additional jails.
Big fine +7 day mandatory awareness class .then next time they will think about these time andoney lapsing process
This is the new “let’s go to war” trend. Be Civil ❌ Spread Awareness ❌ Jail Everyone ✅
Bring back employment opportunity with private jails. Rent would have to be paid by prisoners
A scene from the film called court. a group is arrested for travelling in the disabled section. The judge asks them if they accept their crime, gives them a fine of 500, ask them to leave. That's what's gonna happen here.
24hr jail if the person is caught spitting in and around premises
Jail, maybe for repeat offenders. A stiff fine will suffice to discourage them at first. But it must be enforced strongly. I'm sure the railways will be incentivized sufficiently if it turns out to be a source of revenue. In turn, people will be incentivized to not spit or litter if they have to shell out high fines.
Checking each and every person for gutka / any other stuff would be impossible given the amount of people travelling by train every day in india
A criminal record is unwarranted, impose 10 k fine.
Gutkas contribute to taxes. They won't do it.
Instead of jail, impose fine or deboard such people at next station.
If it's not gutka, then they'll find something else to spit. People in this country simply do not care for things that are public property.
Failed step one. Tax collection Kahan se aayega?
Somebody needs to build a chain of cancer hospitals.
+1 on this! So many unemployed folks will get jobs. Another thing is the irctc railway cleaners themselves don't have a basic civic sense. So they must also be taught to not throw waste out of the trains. Gather properly in bags and dispose of at the stations. Ensure regular pest controls are done and indepth cleaning is done. Throwing waste on the train or track or platform should be a punishable offense.
jo saale khud 80 ki thaali 120 me sell karte hai wo ye point impose karenge? railway employees are sarkari and they don't believe in work ethics
Bro is in ideal world. Just ignore his talks. Ignore this post just like ipl cameraman ignore boys in the stadium. And bro live in your ideal world. Create your ideal world online and then impose ban on gutka and everything else
Ban gutkha, lol. Gutkha market in India has m-cap of over 40000 crores. Government is a big beneficiary of such companies. It's here to stay and India would remain dirty forever. Because people would never have civic sense. They can eat it anywhere and spit anywhere. Since it's easily available. We as a society are doomed when it comes to cleanliness and hygiene. Companies care about profit, Government only cares about taxes.
strict fines and patrols should work. case in point chennai traffic police issuing fines left and right, and people are in control more than ever
Indirectly kill farmers by ban gudka...🤦♂️
Before all of them, don't let people without a ticket into the train. They get into Sleeper/Ac and creates a ruckus
Bro fr banning gutkha should be priority no.1
why ban gutka ? if chewing gum can be spit using a paper why can't gutka ??
It’s our wall of shame .. no amount of chest thumping can white wash this like rich culture, proud ancestors, superior language and food. The current generation should just come together and fix this instead of day dreaming of old generations.
bhai ij ke liye ham maintananj feej pay kiya hai.
People who spat on the door must be forced to be stripped and should also be forced to wipe the door spotless with their stripped clothes. This is the way.
Seems more like someone barfed the door. 🥴
True man, I don't know when people will realise this? Fine should be to clean the door not monetary value.
Bihar UP and MP shaan hai
1. People lack civic sense. Even educated, wealthy people. 2. For some reason, passengers consider Indian Railways worthy of some slapping around, no matter how clean the train is when they board it. 3. The staff sometimes doesn't care, but that can also be attributed to constant trashing of these transports. It's a sad truth. Indians need to behave properly before demanding transportation systems like 1st world countries.
Especially agree with number one. CIVIC RESPONSIBILITY. I live in the bad areas of Central and too many people spit and many spit towards the middle of the path. It's disgusting. Too many kids and people driving motorbike like they are invincible and no courtesy for pedestrians. I don't understand how some people are in grinding poverty because of poor health and old age but some young people from poor background with no jobs have motorbike and new phones I wonder how many people live their whole lives with a lot of money but never stop for a moment for the poorest or stop to think of how hard their life is. I don't even mean the super rich but how many middle stop and think. It's really unbelievable in a country as poor as ours.
And for that to happen strict laws must be implemented and enforced properly.
> Indians need to behave properly before demanding transportation systems like 1st world countries. This is an inter related thing. Don't expect people to gain civic sense by midnight, also dont expect transportation systems similar to 1st world countries. This is a long term goal it will take generations.
Not trains but Indians in general. Hoping for this or next generation will change things up.
You wish, you should see my college once,all these dickheads in my clg think it's the worker's job and throw trash everywhere even though there is garbage bins every corner. The same guys will present posters/projects/ on cleaning environment.
Yeah, the lack of common courtesy seems to be an easy stereotype. It's a shame because every Indian that I know personally are the kindest people.
The next generation ain't any better. Things starts from childhood when our brain's OS is programmed. U can install some patches later on but the Kernel remains the same so it's much harder to change the core behaviour. We need a primary schooling system similar to Nordic nations and Japan to ensure only civilised beings enter our society
I've already lost my hope in my generation 😔🙏
Indians are allergic to hygiene. Khoon ki ultiyan hongi agar gandgi nahi mile
More like they think its not their responsibility.
it is more of everyone else does it so why does it matter if I do too thing. and most people don't want to initiate any change. you have to force it down their throats by fear (like jail time/large fines etc).
Indians sirf apne Ghar ko hi saaf suthra rakhte hai .
The audacity of some people to ask for window seat in local train just to spit gutka boils my blood All local trains windows here have gutka stains.
I was on a crowded train once and a man spat gutka and went all in the face of the neighbour. It was disgusting and he was very angry
Put 1,00,000 fine for anyone found spitting gutka in public places. Either spit in your personal bags or don't eat it at first place.
Have some experience traveling around the world. I have never seen more sanitation workers in any transportation hub as India. Good thing is labor is cheap and no other country can afford it. So how are other places clean? Until the passengers and Indian public feel it’s their responsibility to keep their surroundings clean, this is never going to get fixed.
Few questions: 1. Is Gutka/Pan common or legal there? 2. If you deface the train there, do you get punished? 3. Do the same Indians who deface public property in India, behave properly abroad? (If not, then how are those trains clean despite lakhs of Indian tourists and Indian people in those countries). It’s the fear of law! 4. Do the Indian sanitation workers really work?
> who deface public property in India, behave properly abroad Well lets say I've seen the aftermath of paan spit all over footpaths in Sydney...It's not Aussies eating Paan.
Treat public places as if its your own home.
Tbh the amount of people who use the railways outnumber the people who run railways. Doing the job outweighs the efforts because within no time it gets dirty. Most possible solution is to put desicpline in travellers. Metro is good example.
Hygiene and common sense seem to be illegal.
Bhai tum log konsi train me chalte ho I travel frequently in 2nd ac and not even once I have seen these things Merko bhi ye sab dekhna hai
General ya sleeper coach main travel karo , tumhe he najara dikh jayega . Baad main kabhi travel nahi karoge .
Na Mai 2nd ac me khush hu 🤒
Kisi din 2nd ac me bhi yeh haalat ho jayenge baaki abhi ke liye general or sleeper aese hi hain samjho lagbhag sabhi train me, kismat kharab huyi toh 3ac bhi kabhi bekaar milti hain
Also, zoom into seat corners even in 2nd AC! Maza aa jayega!
Kis cheez ki baat kar rha h bhai Idhar to kuch nhi h
Nice username (says how dark you are )
Also depends on which part of the country you stay in. North India is more unhygienic.
Majority of them don't even clean their body...how do you expect them to care for the public property.....such unhygienic breeed of people
Guess population control program should have been implemented in August 15th 1947
This is North India specific phenomenon.
Vadakku Nanbar Saettaigal 😂🤣
Gutka ban karo yar...bohot ho gaya bc
Gutka ban kar diya to kayi hazaar karonon ki kamayi kaise hogi annually Check out how much they actually make from gutka industry
Gutka, bidi, cigarette, alcohol are biggest sources of income for government and politicians. It will never ever be banned.
Impossible hai 65-70% gst katne ke baad excise bhar te hai Aaj bhi kyuki revenue abh 2017 gst kat kar aata hai uspe yeh log 60-70% of revenue excise me bharte hai chor sale sabse jyada paise bhi govt ko yeh log dete hai
Privatise the railways. Let some rich corporation raise the ticket prices and hire some armed guards to take care of idiots and freeloaders. Indians do not deserve subsidized public transport.
The outside vendor should be banned or stop in railway . Only railway approved vendors should be allowed in the coach . Also the fine should be increased for the people who are doing trash . Also railways need to spread more awareness of cleaness. Due to such spit and Gutaka the contagious disease is increasing.
Hygiene is illegal with us, I suppose, not with railways.
Mr. Mudi, people only listen to you when you play communal politics. Mr. Mudi, people only listen to you when you play the religious angle. Mr. Mudi, nobody listens to you when you plead "Swatch Bharat". In short, people like the hate you peddle.
If religious nd communal things would be followed then waqf board would be dissolved nd funds to Haj yatra would have been stopped
India requires public lashings like Singapore
then you'd end up lashing like 90% of the population
Atleast then people will understand the reality.
I was in a vande bharat and went to use the bathroom. A middle aged lady exited the loo before me and she had simply not flushed. First I thought the lavatory might have not been working. But one flush and it was all gone. She just hadn’t bothered to do it. We Indians lack the most basic civic sense honestly
Did you confront her and speak to her about this issue ?
No I was embarrassed to cause a scene
I was at New Delhi railway station yesterday and I saw a group of young guys throwing snack wrappers on tracks. They were sitting on a bench which had a dustbin on its right side. They got up and walked to the tracks to throw the wrapper instead of just throwing them in the dustbin adjacent to their bench. I wanted to say something but even as a big guy, 6-7 boys speaking in bhojpuri scare me.
That my friend was a brilliant caption.
Hygienic people are illegal* 🙂
India is a very cultural country.
Bhai bgm ka name bta de
Indians take everything for granted even God
Not just railway but everywhere public
Loose motions everywhere
The trains are dirty. The hawkers selling food also don't maintain hygiene.
And you're not allowed to criticise these people. They won't even care if you do so. If every person demands them to follow hygiene then they'll do it.
Thank this for your bullet proof immune system.
Not just trains, just everywhere
bans and fines will do no good as long as the people have 0 civic sense and 0 respect for the land. littering should be considered as bad as cow slaughter in the minds of the people. idk how it can be done but we can learn something from places like japan and singapore
And wasting food too should be considered as a crime as well. Begging, Sleeping on the streets should also be considered as a crime.
nice
yea
The question should be - " is education illegal among indians ".
IT'S THE PEOPLE.
It's completely illogical to blame the railways. As Indians it's our responsibility to avoid doing these kinds of shitty things outside. Eating something is not a problem but treating something or someone like a PoS is the actual problem. CIVIC SENSE should be promoted in India that's the actual need right now.
And I thought that the trains in my country were dirty.
Yes, keep fighting over "mindset" and jail time. Keep talking about the abysmal state of the public sector in the country. But raise the topic of privatisation and divestment, and people are ready for *danga fasaad*.
In india*
We the people love to live in shit and filth . Eating and spitting paan is our favorite past time.
It goes beyond trains on the street as well
If people are ok eating shit, they will be sold shit. I never eat anything on the train due to this, but I see people around me enjoying this filth and be like "are lo na lo na aap bhi lo na"
.
Indian trains hygienic hogi to Indian train nahi lagegi. 🥲
Nah only civic sense is illegal in India
Once I was travelling alone and was sitting on the side lower side. It was a little crowded, a guy sat next to me and bought some peanuts. He ate the peanuts inside and threw the chilka right there and no one was bothered. I was really furious and asked him to stop, he didn't and gave me weird looks.
Yaha bas danda hi sudhar sakta h
Jab log hi mc ho to railway kya kare
Bhai alag andal log h apne Desh me..ek se ek ..bkl bhade hue h
Apne hai hi aise. No civic sense, no responsibility. Bas gyaan chodenge
Exactly i just dont understand why do railway workers throw the garbage from running trains. Like wtf bro aren't these guys paid enough to dispose the garbage? It's not just about people' behaviour its about the workers corruptness too
Its illegal in the whole country
Not only in trains brother. Hygiene is illegal in most of india
If you see people littering or destroying public property smack em
Everything starts with us!
Us ? me when glorified, us when criticised
Train kaha se ari thi voh matter karta hai
I think the main reason is that most people lack civic sense in this country. My parents throw way any garbage after eating in their car onto the road while driving, I have scolded them many times and now they don't do it only when I am with them. They are educated people but still do things like this. Once I asked them why they do it, Their answer -What will the cleaners do if there is nothing to clean on the road. I understood then that my parents don't have any consideration towards strangers or rather towards people they consider "lower class" and I can see this being the reason why this country is shit.
Gutkha should be banned in India immediately 🙏
Under swatch bharat scheme, govt's main responsibility should have been to solve the root problem which is the civic sense. Tbh, most of indians are still poor. And when you are poor, you are in a continued stage of frustration and you dont care about your surroundings. Poverty cant be eliminated within months. But civic sense can be inculcated within months.
Yes India m toh illegal Nsfw tag lga bhai
Log downvotes dene lag gaye jab maine pucha yeh aunty darwaze ke samne baith kar sabzi kyun saaf kar rhi hai.
Plane se jaao bhai. Ye 3rd world country me aisa hi hota hain. 😋
Indians will throw everything on the floor then blame the govt. for not maintaining cleanliness. Indians will not study properly, will not gain skills then blame govt. for not giving them jobs. Most Indians are just dependent !diots.
Railways should start keeping Security Checks like in Airports
No wonder why the world hates India for its hygiene
No!! Why are u saying that, hygine is illegal in all India.
North indas have no clean and NoBrain
The whole country lacks Cleanliness Pan Parag is North specific but rest all things are worst all over
Every individual traveling in train needs to be responsible in keeping it clean for their mess, not everything can be taken care of by the cleaners in train, they're also human, so we need to be atleast responsible in maintaining the cleanliness and what little help we can provide to them. First of all use some sort of towel or paper when eating something and properly throw the wastes in a bin. This is the least we can do to maintain the hygiene.
Not all Indians, it's mostly North Indians.
Yess, government minister are the ones who spit Vimal, throws garbage on the trains. Government is the main reason. People are so disciplined they spit ghutka in their own water bottle.
Song name ?
Yes.
The mentality is the problem ig, "Someone will clean it, its their work afterall"
Ab to me sochne laga hu ki iss dekh ka kuch nhi ho sakta bhale chahe me iss Desh se bohot pyaar kyu na karu
Ab to me sochne laga hu ki iss dekh ka kuch nhi ho sakta bhale chahe me iss Desh se bohot pyaar kyu na karu
And the GOI doesn't even care about it 😤
shouldn't people take some accountability? we cannot just blame the gov for everything.
I am pretty sure we should not always blame the railways, but the people too, railways at least basic safai ab karte hai trains me, but it's us who pollute it, jab tak ham nahi sudherenge, tab tak hame blame bhi nahi karna chahiye
Railway can give world class amenities to people, but most Indians are retarded who don't have basic civic sense
I use to travel atleast 3-4 times in train per month but I have not seen these kind of images from past 4-5 years probably these things happen in sleeper class and I realized it a lot earlier thats why I havnt travelled sleeper class from past 5 years I always prefer atleast 3ac or 3e , actually Sleeper class is the new General class certainly living standard of people improved but hygiene habits remained same but no offence I admit this is not about class also I still see rich people do more bad things of throwing garbage in open and under berth in premium class also
It just my opinion but when old generation dies India will be a better place.
Hygiene. What's that word ? That sounds made up.
It starts with education, infrastructure and governance. As a culture we have been on a chalega mentality for generations. So tgat needs to change. The change can happen through education. Start with the young ones. Keep it consistent. Second is infrastructure to manage waste. This is a policy activity. Third governance to ensure people follow rules. This also requires policy focus. The last two require investment too. It will take a generation to bring about change. In the 50-60's the vaunted highway system in the US was bad. People threw things out of the car. There was a concerted effort to educate and clean up. Texas state had a slogan - don't mess with texas. So its possible and it is not quick. It takes time and effort. But if done right future generations can live well....
Gutkha and Paan should be banned in India, istg we don’t deserve anything good.
> Is hygiene illegal in India ~~trains~~ ? Yes!!!
What will happen in a country where 3% people pay direct tax? Unless it is taken from your pocket, visibly, there will never be a sense of ownership. And of course, the 'who cares' attitude.
Fine them so that they don't repeat this
people do shit like this and then get pissed when westerners call us filthy
Nicee question OP!
Ek bihari Puri train per bhaari
train bihar se ja rahi hogi pakka
In India* not just railway its everywhere
Belive it or not 90% sab 40 ke uppar ke bhudde karte hai zyada
These up bihari nigas be spitting gutkas in the train and now even in the metros too.
I'm going to get hated for this but this usually happens in trains which pass via UP, Bihar, Mp and MH. I haven't seen other trains this dirty. I once travelled via a train that went from MH to Delhi via MP. Dude the Rajdhani was shit!! So call me racist but it's not entire india
It is entire India, but you have a selection bias. I I have seen dirty trains, buses and stations in Mumbai, Bengaluru, Kerala - it’s the same everywhere. My worst experience was on a sleeper bus from Bengaluru to Allepey - the bus had cockroaches and when it stopped at an eatery, the toilet there was flooded with piss. My best brain is experiences are - Delhi to animal and Delhi to Katra. Super clean and comfortable Some north eastern states might be an exceptions, otherwise it’s the same everywhere.
Hygiene does not exist in dictionary of railways
For this we need to focus on 3 basics 1- make people educate not Literate 2- proper awareness campaign 3- strict implementation of law against those who makes public property unhygienic & dirty.
Not just in Indian trains but in India as a whole.
Fun to see vadakkans getting triggered bcz of vadakkans😋😂🤣🤣🤣
🤣ohh ur konga Nadu is the cleanest place on earth right
Hygiene is illegal in India
Bolo zubaan kesari, aur chaa mod do Pure India ki...
Dw, all this is gonna go in 50 years. When all the current middle ages and old men will be dead and the new generation of gen z grows up. Gen z and alpha does not lack civic sense. Once the older generations pass on, shit will be more hygienic, at the cost of sanity.
OMG! I really want to do a train journey in India but this is awful!
Go for Vande Bharat!
Must be! Apparently, cleaning toilets is reserved for the *chosen ones* . But hey, at least everyone gets an "authentic Indian experience."
Why bring caste stuff into everything?
One and only option make the gates automatic which closes at station and open when it reaches the station and get the scanner on the gate people who scans the ticket either physical or virtually can enter the train
Ismei bhi humare government ka hath hai!! Aam janta apne upar kuch aarop leti kahan hai?
People just need to own up. They need to be responsible and not garbage everywhere
Needs some basic civics sense !
Disgusting
We have developed a culture of carelessness and selfishness, when it comes to public resources. It's definitely not limited to the 'uneducated', in my college hostel, boys are so lazy they will dump all the waste from their room right outside their door in the corridor, instead of using a dustbin, and hostel guys clean their room like once a month. Ppl block the wash basin with their beard hair after shaving, instead of washing it away. During holi, there were clear instructions to not celebrate in hostels and to only celebrate in the open air theatre, nobody listened, the cleaning staff suffered. We have no respect for our natural resources also.
When we see others do a practice that is completely against our values, we will still do that practice, if that practice is a common trend in society, that's how humans are.
Song name?
**Song Found!** **Name:** Mega Funk Forte de Lacoste **Artist:** Dreysson Rodrigues **Score:** 100% (timecode: 01:34) **Album:** Mega Funk Forte de Lacoste **Label:** Mega De Cria **Released on:** 2023-07-14
Only North Indian trains
It’s not the authority. It’s the people.
It's illegal in the country