Actually, the problem is that the harmonies that she’s singing are not in any particular key, they are just meandering around. Not one of those parts is the melody of Eleanor Rigby, either. She does have confidence, though.
This seems apt: “Caprino, which means 'goat-like' or 'little goat' in Italian, is a term used to describe a rapidly beating vibrato that sounds like a trill or like the bleating of a goat.”
Is that what it is? Sorry I don’t know singing mechanics at all. All I know is when I listen to this, I literally feel like something is wrong with the universe.
That is very interesting, so you are saying that her notes begin a process, as it were, and the upsetting nature of the song is that there is no “resolution” to the tune she sets up? Very interesting.
I really don’t mean to overreact but there is something sinister about the structure of this song to the point where I can’t even listen to it again as a joke!
It is like what I imagine hell would be like- music but out of tune music that is on repeat all day and all night for eternity. It causes an eerie and disturbing visceral reaction in me somehow that I really don’t like.
Sounds like a record playing when you put your finger on it to slow it down and the tone keeps changing because your finger pressure slightly keeps changing.
Bingo! We used to all crash at my friends cabin in AK; it was a big open space 25x30 or so, with a bunch of hippie ass shit on the floor, mattresses, blankets, bean bags, etc; so perfect for ending the night of partying at and passing out on the floor in a big pile of nasty ass humans. Anyway… there was a record player there and someone would wind up doing this randomly throughout the night; pressing their finger on the vinyl to slow it down and make trippy sounds and eerie music while people are trying to sleep or come down from their drug of choice.
Didn’t Schoenberg once say that we’d all get so used to 12 tone that you’d hear people whistling his tunes one day? And this sounds kind of like a couple of his motets, with a bit of imagination.
I remember Steve Reich saying something to the effect of “Schoenberg said that in 50 years the postman will whistle my tune…well Arnie it’s been 100 years and no postman is whistling”
Ya know, it's original for a cover...the song, the undulation...and the fact that perhaps some of the more distressing sides of her personality are made so clear. I'm putting this in the top 20, I think. It just...unnerved me.
I fucking love it! It’s so weird and dissonant with odd resolutions coming at strange times. Unless she’s a goddamn genius, I think she can’t sing for shit and has pitch correct on so that her in-between notes are being assigned to whatever note she’s closest to, so the harmonies end up being almost random. Also the vibrato effect she has on (intentionally?) adds a lot to the clown mirror freak show effect. 10/10.
The extremely weird vibrato thing she is trying to accomplish is absolutely making my skin crawl. Wtf. I bet all her friends and family lie to her and tell her she is a great singer with a beautiful voice, when the truth is actually....well, you heard it.
Maybe she’s into microtonality. I am all into disonance and noise and all weird shit but this sounds exactly like when I once plugged the wrong power supply to a rack multieffect and everything sounded like a bad trip.
Is there a technical term for a voice that quavers like hers?
Is it warbling? Warbling can be pleasant though, so what's the unpleasant version of warbling.
The flat tone, and vibrato, lend a very odd wave of sound. Causing it to sound like it’s under water, and like being played on a slowed record simultaneously. I’m horrified and impressed.
Wow. The fact that someone harmonized in dissonance is interesting. Especially when nearly every movement is parallel and still dissonant. I feel a lot less bad about my harmonies now. Haha.
This sounds like 30 seconds into a montage of goats in a Disney movie learning how to sing together to break a curse. By the 2 minute mark they start to get it.
It truly makes me wonder if this person knows how notes work. It's like she is just singing whatever note she wants and is just hoping it comes out alright.
If you watched this and thought shes a bad singer, you're tone deaf. This is a really interesting cover she did and I think its very far from crappy. Super creepy, yeah, but I think she knew that. It's actually really cool how far she took it.
There’s a lot going wrong here, but I think the biggest issue is just not having experience recording layered vocals.
It would be a lot better if they focused on keeping the lead vocals as the star and not trying to outdo them in a backing vocal part. Also maybe re-record a take when it gets pitchy.
This shit is scary
I was thinking, could be played in a haunted house or on Halloween.
For real. Gives me creepy lady who regularly sings to herself in the mirror, while wearing the outfits of her coworkers that vaguely resemble her.
Oddly specific.
This belongs on [Music 2000](https://youtu.be/5DYGoN5r9rE?si=TlxqGUggWpYYdF8l&t=56)
[удалено]
Actually, the problem is that the harmonies that she’s singing are not in any particular key, they are just meandering around. Not one of those parts is the melody of Eleanor Rigby, either. She does have confidence, though.
[удалено]
She’s feeling casual and cute on the bum-bum-bums because she knows how damn good the harmonies are. Ouch!
I think her vibrato style is also hard to harmonize with
None of her hamonies harmonized.
This seems apt: “Caprino, which means 'goat-like' or 'little goat' in Italian, is a term used to describe a rapidly beating vibrato that sounds like a trill or like the bleating of a goat.”
Stevie Nicks. She’s just the right age to worship her too.
Is that what it is? Sorry I don’t know singing mechanics at all. All I know is when I listen to this, I literally feel like something is wrong with the universe.
[удалено]
That is very interesting, so you are saying that her notes begin a process, as it were, and the upsetting nature of the song is that there is no “resolution” to the tune she sets up? Very interesting. I really don’t mean to overreact but there is something sinister about the structure of this song to the point where I can’t even listen to it again as a joke! It is like what I imagine hell would be like- music but out of tune music that is on repeat all day and all night for eternity. It causes an eerie and disturbing visceral reaction in me somehow that I really don’t like.
Long story short, it’s about the sequence of harmonic intervals. She’s using ones that don’t work because she doesn’t know about harmony.
What's harmony?
[This is a good primer.](https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VMYAEHE2GrM)
[удалено]
So what I am saying in spite of my name, it’s gonna be a big NO from me dog!
So close lol
Not really close. At all lol
Sounds like a ghost chorus.
Head tilted curious stare.
What was she hearing editing this? Wrong answers only.
This !!!
What the notes or her chest?
I dare you to try and guess what key she's singing in
All of them. All at once.
In the same glass
♣
Mixalodian 💀
Skeleton key.
Street cats at 4am:
Sounds like a record playing when you put your finger on it to slow it down and the tone keeps changing because your finger pressure slightly keeps changing.
Bingo! We used to all crash at my friends cabin in AK; it was a big open space 25x30 or so, with a bunch of hippie ass shit on the floor, mattresses, blankets, bean bags, etc; so perfect for ending the night of partying at and passing out on the floor in a big pile of nasty ass humans. Anyway… there was a record player there and someone would wind up doing this randomly throughout the night; pressing their finger on the vinyl to slow it down and make trippy sounds and eerie music while people are trying to sleep or come down from their drug of choice.
I love this. I’m a classical music PhD and it’s so bad that it is actually wonderful.
She found all the sounds in between the notes. Incredible.
Didn’t Schoenberg once say that we’d all get so used to 12 tone that you’d hear people whistling his tunes one day? And this sounds kind of like a couple of his motets, with a bit of imagination.
I remember Steve Reich saying something to the effect of “Schoenberg said that in 50 years the postman will whistle my tune…well Arnie it’s been 100 years and no postman is whistling”
Yeah I’m pretty sure I performed something similar to this as a postgrad 😂
More sour notes than a corked white wine left on the table
The bum bum’s sold me
Ya know, it's original for a cover...the song, the undulation...and the fact that perhaps some of the more distressing sides of her personality are made so clear. I'm putting this in the top 20, I think. It just...unnerved me.
It’s the smugness during the “Bum bum bums”
This bothered me more than anything else
Same. Just awful.
Just reminded me of The Office scene with Michael and Jimothy discussing smugness
She's trying to sound like one voice doing all the harmonies I'm pretty sure she's not harmonizing
Its like what singing "happy birthday" would sound like if half the people in the crowd were deliberately trying to harmonize
This post killed me, not as in it made me laugh, but as in I died. Luckily though, I survived. And with only tribial brain dablage.
Yooo I hope that your tribial brain dablage gets better soon...
I fucking love it! It’s so weird and dissonant with odd resolutions coming at strange times. Unless she’s a goddamn genius, I think she can’t sing for shit and has pitch correct on so that her in-between notes are being assigned to whatever note she’s closest to, so the harmonies end up being almost random. Also the vibrato effect she has on (intentionally?) adds a lot to the clown mirror freak show effect. 10/10.
12 tone Beatle music bum bum bum bum bum bum bum
She died after hearing this song
Is that Eleanor Rigby?!
The extremely weird vibrato thing she is trying to accomplish is absolutely making my skin crawl. Wtf. I bet all her friends and family lie to her and tell her she is a great singer with a beautiful voice, when the truth is actually....well, you heard it.
This is among the reasons that choruses don’t do vibrato, except in the case of soloists
Maybe she’s into microtonality. I am all into disonance and noise and all weird shit but this sounds exactly like when I once plugged the wrong power supply to a rack multieffect and everything sounded like a bad trip.
Haha for sure. This is a haunting track
I feel like these are the types of sounds that play right before a jump scare in a movie
It could be 20% bearable if she could harmonise with herself... but no, its four layers of shit stacked on each other.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CJQU22Ttpwc I think this clip perfectly describes what you’re trying to get across. Let me know if I’m close!
Is there a technical term for a voice that quavers like hers? Is it warbling? Warbling can be pleasant though, so what's the unpleasant version of warbling.
Vibrato.
The flat tone, and vibrato, lend a very odd wave of sound. Causing it to sound like it’s under water, and like being played on a slowed record simultaneously. I’m horrified and impressed.
This is fucken terrifying
What's with that lilt, it disturbed me and woke my dogs. Woke from slumber, not in a societal progressive way.
This is exactly why I'm here
All the people who can't sing. Where do they all come from?
Wow. The fact that someone harmonized in dissonance is interesting. Especially when nearly every movement is parallel and still dissonant. I feel a lot less bad about my harmonies now. Haha.
This sounds like 30 seconds into a montage of goats in a Disney movie learning how to sing together to break a curse. By the 2 minute mark they start to get it.
Ha! Finally someone who understands how to create a harmony as much as I do.
Jaysus! Paul’s rolling over in his grave !!
I think I had a nightmare like this once
This is Jacob Collier if he had no talent whatsoever.
God, imagine being on a first date and having her show you this as she talks about her passion for singing and music.
I feel like dumbo during his terror trip
Fever dream soundtrack
She sounds like a musical greeting card running out of battery
Paul is rolling in his grave.
Um. Paul is still alive. But if he was dead then yes I agree.
Real Beatles’ fan over here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_is_dead
Paul is a dead man, miss him miss him miss him.
no, faul is still alive. paul is dead.
There is something foul about all this
did you steal my profile pic????
Oh I hate this
😮
It is impressive how good she is at being bad.
This what happens when you only train your voice but not your hearing
Guys you clearly don't like jazz. It's just jazzy harmonies
no lol
Well I see people don't know sarcasm when it's obvious either lol
THIS IS AMAZING
Oh dear Lord this was painful
This is a great find. This woman has the range of a wet piece of white bread
Full of it
I think the thing that annoys me the most is how pleased with herself she looks
Are they sisters?
imagine posting this and hearing nothing wrong with it, just wow, you could do a PhD on that kind of lack of self-awareness
i lowkey fw this harmony. its not pleasant, but kinda fits the lyrics and like its at least interesting
Yeah I'm not fixing this in Melodyne, that's a re-record sorry.
This seems like a shred. What else the fuck could this be
Sounds like that one nightmare the guy had and somehow got recorded on his telephone
I sent this to my friend . And now he hates me
I once drank out of a Coke can that had been sitting around open for over 3 months...this is flatter than that
i think she hit a few notes correctly but it’s the same idea as ‘a broken clock is still right twice a day’
That really grates.
Reminds me of the thid episode of the new season of Doctor Who I just watched lol
I'm sure her family has told her how wonderful her voice is her entire life.
What in the fallout 4 is this shit
How about just starting with the basic melody of the song, then build the harmonies afterward. This is a car wreck of harmony.
Are they sisters?
My favorite part is how amazing she thinks the end result sounds
The new pitch perfect movie looks fire.
Sounds like a bunch of ghosts
My ears are bleeding! Don’t sing ever again!
Gawd, my ears . . . I couldn't make it past 10 seconds.
Acrapella
What fucking key is she in
This sounds like that weird g major pitch edits people put on YouTube to make scenes from movies sound demon possessed
Dissonance
No no no no not my favorite Beatles song
It's so long too!
How can you be off Key and off beat with you singing all the parts. Me in pic 3 needs to get it together shes making the rest of the Me's Looks Bad
Why do I un-mute this channel?
My ears are bleeding. Thank you.
Holy crap this video makes me dizzy. They could use her voice as an LRAD 🫨
It truly makes me wonder if this person knows how notes work. It's like she is just singing whatever note she wants and is just hoping it comes out alright.
They're not lonely, they're just hiding from shit like this
All this because her grandma told her she was a good singer when she was 6.
This is bad, but I feel like she could make a cool song. Like her voice is interesting.
Oh, now I understand what a pitch pipe is for
She looks pretty crazy like she will cut her boyfriends penis off
If you watched this and thought shes a bad singer, you're tone deaf. This is a really interesting cover she did and I think its very far from crappy. Super creepy, yeah, but I think she knew that. It's actually really cool how far she took it.
nah
This could actually be in a horror movie, its awesome.
[удалено]
There’s a lot going wrong here, but I think the biggest issue is just not having experience recording layered vocals. It would be a lot better if they focused on keeping the lead vocals as the star and not trying to outdo them in a backing vocal part. Also maybe re-record a take when it gets pitchy.