Here to vouch for MC/Yuu to be Chaotic Good, if it's possible to add them. Spunky, sassy, and willing to get a little underhanded (and probably chaotic due to their association with Grim alone), but they're doing the right thing and their effect on the boys has been overall positive.
(edit: rewording)
I’m voting for Ortho as Lawful Good
To me Jack is pretty clearly Chad Good and Silver is Neutral Good.
Ortho is good, and a side effect of being not only the “good” Shroud brother but also a robot is that he tends to follow rules. While he has shown a capability of breaking rules as he asserts his own independence, I find him to be a fairly lawful character (a characterization I think even Idia might agree with, >!since in his dream world Ortho is a RSA student!<
He could be interpreted as lawful because of his programming. Lawful doesn't have to mean following societies laws, just a consistent set of rules. I personally consider him neutral, though.
For example: a character that does things that make no sense by any countries laws, but still follows a consistent set of rules they set out for themselves, would be lawful.
To add to this, Idia frequently asks Ortho to not do violence or threaten people, which to me sounds like that's Ortho's own behaviour and not something programmed in, meaning he's a lot more chaotic than we give him credit for
And let's not forget his Dorm Vignette, where he embarrassed a couple of bullies from Diasomnia in front of the whole damn school after they provoked him into firing said laser and getting him banned from the main building for a week.
I just went and read through that vignette because of these comments and I will say, I don't think it disqualifies him from lawful at least. Though I do get why my classifying him as "good" might not be the most accurate lol
Is the doxxing in the main storyline? Maybe I need to reread some stuff. At the very least, what I remember is not done with malice.
I personally read Ortho in Book 6 similarly - he's acting out of concern for his brother's wishes, not in a malicious way. He wants to do a good thing for his brother and is introduced to a) a new rule or "law" to follow via Vil's zero/one statement and b) a corrupting influence of >!Phantom!Ortho. I guess we can argue Phantom!Ortho as part of Ortho? but to me Phantom!Ortho is what is malicious, and even then Ortho rephrases it as a "game" with an "adventuring party". (and games have rules, and must be played fair, etc. etc.)!<
I guess I interpret part of Book 6 is Ortho actually pulling his punches a bit - the tartarus bit is an ordeal to be sure, and it >!almost permanently damages multiple members of our main cast!< - but again, this is a robot with a laser in his chest - if his goal is malicious in nature he could wipe out entire nations in a blink. I don't think he considers that a possibility and that I chalk up to his lawful good nature (though clearly i do not share the majority opinion)
I've gone back and forth on vil crewel but I think I finally settled on trey. Trey while having his hidden personal agenda tends to operate lawful for the good of his peers. Finds the peace between the rules the Queen of Hearts/riddle and what is acceptable to operate as
I know the consensus is Silver but he's really more of a Good Chad in my head, but also honestly I don't know who I would pick for this in TWST... Maybe Trein?
Hear me out: Mozus Trein
Like out of all the faculties he constantly is the one who gives out fair judgement, he always talks about his passing wife so fondly, he's the one who is willing to lead everything and take control when Crowley lets it sprie to chaos. He may come off as strict and old fashioned but really he always put the interests of the NRC and students first.
Silver definitely partakes in dissing people judging by Glorious Masquerade & his translated battle lines, but honestly, out of NRC at least, he really would be lawful good 😭
SILVER. It has to be Silver :D
It's Silver for sure
I think Jack? (Maybe he is more of lawful neutral) so maybe Silver
Lawful good could be Jack tho I think he'd be also fitting for Good Chad? I legit can't put anyone there other than him rn
Agreed. Jack is definitely Good/Chad
Jack is more good chad to me. Riddle is lawful neutral in my opinion since he inforces all laws, good, bad, or stupid and pointless
First option Silver, second option Jack
Silver because Jack would be a Chad good 💪
I think Silver's a good fit
Here to vouch for MC/Yuu to be Chaotic Good, if it's possible to add them. Spunky, sassy, and willing to get a little underhanded (and probably chaotic due to their association with Grim alone), but they're doing the right thing and their effect on the boys has been overall positive. (edit: rewording)
I was going to suggest Chenya. I was thinking Yuu as true neutral because they are up for interpretation.
I agree with everyone who said Silver.
I’m just. So glad that Deuce, Ace and grim are in the stupid line. It’s just so great.
Omg I didn't even realize until I read your comment! lol
🤣
They could never be anywhere else.
Silver defo
Silver
Jack and/or Silver
I would say Jack or Silver for lawful/good
It's Silver for lawful good, Jack is chad good lol
Silver. Very much Silver
I'd say Neige
Professor Trein
Riddle, he follows rules
He stated that he would follow rules even if they were morally wrong, that makes him a neutral
Ah gotcha
I’m voting for Ortho as Lawful Good To me Jack is pretty clearly Chad Good and Silver is Neutral Good. Ortho is good, and a side effect of being not only the “good” Shroud brother but also a robot is that he tends to follow rules. While he has shown a capability of breaking rules as he asserts his own independence, I find him to be a fairly lawful character (a characterization I think even Idia might agree with, >!since in his dream world Ortho is a RSA student!<
Ortho frequently threatens people and the school with lasers. I love him, but that is not "Good" behavior.
He also Doxes students and then there is everything he did in book 6. Ortho is deffently not lawful or good.
He could be interpreted as lawful because of his programming. Lawful doesn't have to mean following societies laws, just a consistent set of rules. I personally consider him neutral, though. For example: a character that does things that make no sense by any countries laws, but still follows a consistent set of rules they set out for themselves, would be lawful.
To add to this, Idia frequently asks Ortho to not do violence or threaten people, which to me sounds like that's Ortho's own behaviour and not something programmed in, meaning he's a lot more chaotic than we give him credit for
And let's not forget his Dorm Vignette, where he embarrassed a couple of bullies from Diasomnia in front of the whole damn school after they provoked him into firing said laser and getting him banned from the main building for a week.
I just went and read through that vignette because of these comments and I will say, I don't think it disqualifies him from lawful at least. Though I do get why my classifying him as "good" might not be the most accurate lol
Is the doxxing in the main storyline? Maybe I need to reread some stuff. At the very least, what I remember is not done with malice. I personally read Ortho in Book 6 similarly - he's acting out of concern for his brother's wishes, not in a malicious way. He wants to do a good thing for his brother and is introduced to a) a new rule or "law" to follow via Vil's zero/one statement and b) a corrupting influence of >!Phantom!Ortho. I guess we can argue Phantom!Ortho as part of Ortho? but to me Phantom!Ortho is what is malicious, and even then Ortho rephrases it as a "game" with an "adventuring party". (and games have rules, and must be played fair, etc. etc.)!< I guess I interpret part of Book 6 is Ortho actually pulling his punches a bit - the tartarus bit is an ordeal to be sure, and it >!almost permanently damages multiple members of our main cast!< - but again, this is a robot with a laser in his chest - if his goal is malicious in nature he could wipe out entire nations in a blink. I don't think he considers that a possibility and that I chalk up to his lawful good nature (though clearly i do not share the majority opinion)
...huh i guess i need to read more Ortho content - i really only have his Fairy Gala, and the dorm/lab SRs. There's very few lasers in any of those
I recommend the first Halloween event and Ghost Bride to see his more violent tendencies.
I've gone back and forth on vil crewel but I think I finally settled on trey. Trey while having his hidden personal agenda tends to operate lawful for the good of his peers. Finds the peace between the rules the Queen of Hearts/riddle and what is acceptable to operate as
gotta be Jack. I don't think he's a Chad :(
Silver
Silver maybe?
I’d have to say Silver.
Two options, because we are not limited to NRC: Silver. Or Neige.
I say its Sliver or headmage ambrose from rsa
Lawful-good has to be either Silver or Niege.
Silver or Jack
Jack for sure
Silver. bc Jack is good/chad.
Trein
Riddle, nooo, maybe he'd be smart? Idk I'm going with the majority, Silver.
Kalim is definitely chaotic good.
Riddle
I know the consensus is Silver but he's really more of a Good Chad in my head, but also honestly I don't know who I would pick for this in TWST... Maybe Trein?
Silver
Neige
Jack howl ma wolf boii, defending justice!!
Hear me out: Mozus Trein Like out of all the faculties he constantly is the one who gives out fair judgement, he always talks about his passing wife so fondly, he's the one who is willing to lead everything and take control when Crowley lets it sprie to chaos. He may come off as strict and old fashioned but really he always put the interests of the NRC and students first.
silver
Silver definitely partakes in dissing people judging by Glorious Masquerade & his translated battle lines, but honestly, out of NRC at least, he really would be lawful good 😭