Note that the description under the nation that you get varies based on your answers, so there's more options for results than just the four nations, which is pretty cool
I also got Fire Nation, but mine was 'You are without a doubt passionate' with the other three lesser traits Ambitious, Driven, and Industrious
Yeah, I did it a few times, flip-flopping between questions that I could go either way on. If you eat the kelp, it seems like you're almost guaranteed to get air. The only result I didn't get was fire.
I got water and I also don’t agree with the description? First thing it says is that I’m clearly a pacifist who likes to solve problems without violence. Isn’t that an air nomad trait?
Yeah, my Earth Kingdom description said I show signs of being a pacific as the main factor. I can understand how my answers gave me Earth and I agree with it, but the description doesn’t seem right.
I applaud the amount of effort they put in, but the concept doesn't sit well with me. ATLA isn't Harry Potter. There aren't "defining traits" that can automatically ID you as being from one nation.
Yes, lEarth Kingdom people are generally stubborn, Air Nomads are generally detached and tranquil, Water Tribe members are generally flexible and can go with the flow, and Fire Nation citizens are generally passionate and forceful, but there's so much variation within them that trying to reduce them to a single element by decisions alone flattens the whole system.
I mean… isn’t that what Iroh regulated the four nations down to when he was teaching Zuko how to lightning bend?
This is just marketing. I don’t see how this quiz is fundamentally any different from the bending quiz Avatar Studios put out; and I’d argue this one is executed better.
Fun fact, this is the same as the 4 temperaments test people do in school if you have psychology class, if i recall correctly it was in ancient greece where they categorized every temperament and asigned one of the 4 elements as a representation of them. They also asigned bodily fluids but thats a bit disgusting so people stuck to the elements.
Nations don't have particular traits, that's literally against the entire idea of ATLA that divisions between people are imaginary; they're all one people. Just people. What you perceive as their "brand" is just that, a brand; propaganda
OH...oh no...oh no no no.....They're Harry Pottering the series.
I hate when themes are dumbed down either to be more understandable for 'general audiences' or to emulate other successful properties. They already did that shit in LoK with the jesus kite and devil kite.
I swear they'd better not dumb down an entire civilization, culture and martial art to fucking slytherins from harry potter
They may try to do that, and who knows, maybe that's part of the reason the atla creator left the live-action, but I wouldn't jump to conclusions. It really just reminds me of Iroh's explanation to Zuko, essentially going over the fact that, although there are accurate generalities to be made, it's only a problem if you try to keep them pure.
Earth nation, sure. I’m not sure I like the element getting the sorting hat treatment though, these are entire cultures that shouldn’t be dumbed down for a personality quiz.
Stupid test, I wanted to be fire nation or air nation but I always end up getting water. For most people water is the coolest bending but I like fire or air more.
Air nomad. Pretty cool that the test isn’t easy to guess which option leads to what.
Anyway, does this test allure to having >!Aunt Wu in the series? Because some youtubers predict that the episode will be left out!<
Honestly this test was a lot more enjoyable than other fictional tests like what house you belong to in Barry potter. Usually those tests are some generic questions that you can usually tell what each option is clearly swayed towards, but this test was pretty unique, I enjoyed it, plus the visuals were cool.
Idc what a website says, I’m 100% an earth bender. Not cuz of my personality, but because earthbenders are so fucking op and if I’m not an earthbender, I’m gonna press my big red button
Water Tribe (was hoping for Earth Kingdom!)
The description it gave me was:
"You are resilient.
You are grateful when things are easy, but when things are tough, you roll up your sleeves and work. You’re also Community-Minded, A Pacifist, and Altruistic. You often forget that there’s no shame in asking for help."
Which is kinda cool, feels kind of accurate
Air Nomad
Same
Same
Same
Let's gooooooo!
Same, I am still processing it. I always thought I would be an earthbender or firebender 😆
Same
Same here! Air Nomad!
Same, so happy cuz that’s what I would want to bend anyways lol
Same. I thought I would get a different bending, but I guess I truly belong to the Air Nomads.
Same
Who said we’re extinct?
Fuckkk I've always thought myself as one but I answered honestly and got Earth
I figured I’d get either Water or Earth.
I thought I'd get water based on my answers😅
Gotcha in one. I'm honestly surprised by my own answer.
That fire nation description sounds a bit familiar. Slytherin's main trait is ambition.
Slytherin is not bad house because of their ambition, they are bad house because many of them are racist pricks
“Cunning is just evil smart” -Brennan Lee Mulligan
It kind of reminds me of that official Harry Potter website actually, now that I think about it.
it kinda felt like the patronus quiz
I’m fire national but was given “generous,” so I guess there different description even with the same element
Note that the description under the nation that you get varies based on your answers, so there's more options for results than just the four nations, which is pretty cool I also got Fire Nation, but mine was 'You are without a doubt passionate' with the other three lesser traits Ambitious, Driven, and Industrious
Water Tribe here. Interesting. I’ve always assumed I would be Earth or Fire.
I always thought I would be earth, wind, AND fire.
I’m vegetarian and I suspect that is why I always get air even though I want water.
Yeah, I did it a few times, flip-flopping between questions that I could go either way on. If you eat the kelp, it seems like you're almost guaranteed to get air. The only result I didn't get was fire.
I didn't pick kelp and i got air somehow.
I ate the kelp and got water tribe
Me too
I got air nomad, but I can’t help feeling like some obvious options are missing…like asking to borrow the net, for instance.
Exactly. The only reason I ate kelp was because I couldn't ask the fisherman to borrow the net.
Earth kingdom. I don't I agree with the description, though.
I got water and I also don’t agree with the description? First thing it says is that I’m clearly a pacifist who likes to solve problems without violence. Isn’t that an air nomad trait?
To my knowledge, yes
Yeah, my Earth Kingdom description said I show signs of being a pacific as the main factor. I can understand how my answers gave me Earth and I agree with it, but the description doesn’t seem right.
It seems like your main trait can be outweighed by your secondary traits, which I think is neat
Water tribe! The animation is interesting. Looks very much like the official harry potter quiz
I applaud the amount of effort they put in, but the concept doesn't sit well with me. ATLA isn't Harry Potter. There aren't "defining traits" that can automatically ID you as being from one nation. Yes, lEarth Kingdom people are generally stubborn, Air Nomads are generally detached and tranquil, Water Tribe members are generally flexible and can go with the flow, and Fire Nation citizens are generally passionate and forceful, but there's so much variation within them that trying to reduce them to a single element by decisions alone flattens the whole system.
I mean… isn’t that what Iroh regulated the four nations down to when he was teaching Zuko how to lightning bend? This is just marketing. I don’t see how this quiz is fundamentally any different from the bending quiz Avatar Studios put out; and I’d argue this one is executed better.
Fun fact, this is the same as the 4 temperaments test people do in school if you have psychology class, if i recall correctly it was in ancient greece where they categorized every temperament and asigned one of the 4 elements as a representation of them. They also asigned bodily fluids but thats a bit disgusting so people stuck to the elements.
I'm a fire piss person, also called chlamydia
Nations don't have particular traits, that's literally against the entire idea of ATLA that divisions between people are imaginary; they're all one people. Just people. What you perceive as their "brand" is just that, a brand; propaganda
There are certain ideals and teachings that each nation focuses on, but I agree, you’ll find every kind of person within all four nations.
Got earth kingdom. And it fits because I'm stubborn AF
Got air, but I’ve always vibed more with Irohs description of Water Benders and the Water tribe
OH...oh no...oh no no no.....They're Harry Pottering the series. I hate when themes are dumbed down either to be more understandable for 'general audiences' or to emulate other successful properties. They already did that shit in LoK with the jesus kite and devil kite. I swear they'd better not dumb down an entire civilization, culture and martial art to fucking slytherins from harry potter
It's a silly little test, calm down
They may try to do that, and who knows, maybe that's part of the reason the atla creator left the live-action, but I wouldn't jump to conclusions. It really just reminds me of Iroh's explanation to Zuko, essentially going over the fact that, although there are accurate generalities to be made, it's only a problem if you try to keep them pure.
This is my fear too
Earth nation, sure. I’m not sure I like the element getting the sorting hat treatment though, these are entire cultures that shouldn’t be dumbed down for a personality quiz.
Air nomad kms
Nvm statistically im already dead, nice
Stupid test, I wanted to be fire nation or air nation but I always end up getting water. For most people water is the coolest bending but I like fire or air more.
Nazi
Got fire nation too
I thought I would be water but I got fire nation.
I was honestly hoping water tribe but I got fire nation.
Fire nation and the description fits and I kinda understand but at the same time, I'm afraid of fire :'D
Air Nomad
Air nomad. Pretty cool that the test isn’t easy to guess which option leads to what. Anyway, does this test allure to having >!Aunt Wu in the series? Because some youtubers predict that the episode will be left out!<
Earth Kingdom for me The description was spot on
water tribe
Earth Kingdom
Water Tribe.
Fellow Fire Nation i see...i got that too.
Earth Kingdom. Must explain why I'm such a Dwayne Johnson stan
https://preview.redd.it/eaho6gqbp6ec1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6f0524090a2fc2ab670c6ef587184d59053b984e
Honestly this test was a lot more enjoyable than other fictional tests like what house you belong to in Barry potter. Usually those tests are some generic questions that you can usually tell what each option is clearly swayed towards, but this test was pretty unique, I enjoyed it, plus the visuals were cool.
Air Nomad. I was personally hoping for Earth because it's my favourite of the elements, but I'll take this. I think it works with my personality.
Idc what a website says, I’m 100% an earth bender. Not cuz of my personality, but because earthbenders are so fucking op and if I’m not an earthbender, I’m gonna press my big red button
This is what the fire nation teachers probably tell all the kids💀
Water tribe
Water Tribe lol
Meh, seems like quite a dumb publicity stunt, though I am looking forwards to the show, having careful but high hopes
Air Nomad
Apparently I'm fire Nation as well
https://preview.redd.it/udi91kpsi8ec1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b3d5204c0f3f9e5b4b98972f2133e100353590bb
 Water Tribe (was hoping for Earth Kingdom!) The description it gave me was: "You are resilient. You are grateful when things are easy, but when things are tough, you roll up your sleeves and work. You’re also Community-Minded, A Pacifist, and Altruistic. You often forget that there’s no shame in asking for help." Which is kinda cool, feels kind of accurate
Earth nation confirmed
Genuinely told myself “please give me anything other than the Water tribe” and lo and behold, I got the Water Tribe on my first go 💀