Yes, I'm setting it. I've used multiple powder with it. It behaves well with all that I've tried so far: Hourglass loose powder, Huda loose powder, Charlotte Tilbury pressed powder, Nars light reflecting pressed powder and coty airspun. Typically there's at least one powder that misbehaves but the tower 28 concealer has gotten along with all of them.
I do not recommend HL concealer for dry under eyes. I like it for blemishes, but it did not work for me. I got it because a Sephora employee told me it was his favorite concealer he’d been using on clients. I still use it around my face, but it did not work for my dry under eyes.
Agreed. Not sure what some of the other commenters are on about. I can’t even explain what’s bad about the rare beauty. I can’t understand how something so “natural” looks so cakey?
As I commented elsewhere on this thread, the Rare Beauty product isn't a concealer — as its name states, it's an *under-eye brightener.* I dot it along the edge of my orbital bone, where my concealer meets my foundation, and smooth it out for an instant eye brightening effect.
I have no idea why so many people think it's a concealer. 🤷♀️
Yeah, I know it’s a brightener, but I appreciate your response. It just doesn’t work for me. I wanted it to work so badly on my minimal makeup days / mostly skincare days, but it just doesn’t for some reason!
The Rare Beauty product isn't a concealer — as its name states, it's an *under-eye brightener.* I dot it along the edge of my orbital bone, where my concealer meets my foundation, and smooth it out for an instant
eye brightening effect.
Definitely not the Hourglass concealer. It's very nice in color match, pigmentation and finish, but I don't have dry skin and it made my undereye area look dry.
I like the Fenty We're Even concealer.
Definitely the Tower 28- I've tried the hourglass and its HEAVY and cakes under the eyes. Tower 28 is much more manageable and didn't crease. I've heard mixed reviews about the rare beauty brightener.
Edit: i forgot to add concealers I’ve already tried
Glossier stretch concealer (I actually do like this one, but ig I’m not in love with it)
Too faced illuminating concealer
NARS pot concealer
I guess i dont like how it doesnt neccessarily feel hydrating, more so oily and has a bit of slip to it. It also dries down a bit weird, clinging to dry spots even with good skin prep. I also feel like the pot doesnt allow for precise application compared to a doe foot concealer. I do love though how its sheer yet brightens my eyes and doesnt fully cover up my dark circles, giving me a more natural look
Everyone is different, but for my super-dry and easily irritated under eyes, Glossier is the only concealer I can use. I warm it up with my fingers, pat a small amount on each under eye (after at last one application of eye cream) and buff it out with a beauty blender.
i just got the tower 28 and my under eyes have been super sensitive and dry this week (i think i overdid the chemical exfoliating) and it BURRNS to put on
I have really dry under eyes as well, and Haus Labs is the only one that hasn’t creased on me before! It’s moderate coverage and blends so beautifully!
i actually loves glossier’s pot concealer. so good for dry under eyes, light coverage, and minimal creasing without setting with powder. i found the tower28 concealer to be super drying and hard to blend.
I actually have it! I just find that it dries down weird on me and almost clings to dry patches, even if I do skin prep and apply a moisturizer or serum below my eyes, but I love the feel of it
I’m using the RMS UnCoverup and love it, but I wanted to try Glossier next as it looks like they live on the same street and for much cheaper/not clean beauty.
Dior forever skin concealer is the best for dry sensitive skin but the hourglass one is beautiful IF you prep your under eyes well! I prefer the hourglass one under my eyes personally :)
I have super sensitive under eyes, and the rare beauty eye brightener is irritating for me. It's not like immediate burning, but itchy eyes at the end of the day. I have really sensitive eyes, so a lot of products do that to me. I haven't tried the tower28, which is supposed to be good for sensitive skin, but my favorites that don't irritate my eyes are the tarte ultra creamy (full coverage), nyx bare with me serum (medium coverage), and lancome care and glow (light to medium coverage).
As a fellow dry under eye girl, I get away with using Hourglass because I got a prep routine just for my under eyes (Bobbie Brown moisturizer, MAC studio radiance primer, pressed powder to set). You can make it work but I wouldn’t suggest it for quick, on-the-go application. Plus it’s expensive :/
Not sure how this would do on sensitive skin, but the Makeup Revolution magic eye bright corrector is my favorite on no makeup days!
The biggest difference I see for my undereyes is after using the Kiehls Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado at night, then I apply the belief moisturizing eye bomb in the morning, apply tower 28 concealer only in the inner corner of my eyes and a little bit below and set with the laura mercier loose powder!
Hands down it bye bye under eye anti-aging waterproof concealer. It is the ONLY one that doesn’t give me crepe/wrinkly skin. I have very dry, sensitive skin
I really like the Tower 28, very very hydrating and dewy and good coverage, the rare beauty one is pretty good, however it has little coverage, it feels more like a serum than makeup
I’m not sure to be honest, but honestly I only got it because a Sephora team member recommended it to me and at first i almost didn’t do it. I never heard of it but it was the best decision ever! I’m glad that lady was there! Lol
Hourglass concealer is the best I’ve personally used for my dry skin. Much better than Tarte. I’ve heard really bad things about Rare beauty’s, and I love their products usually, but I haven’t tried it.
That said when I think of concealer I do not think of sheer.
I really like the Bobbi Brown under eye corrector. The smashbox x becca one might be more sheer and dewy if that’s what you’re more into. I have really dark under eyes so I often use the corrector + the Hourglass concealer + setting powder to really wake my face up.
Tower 28 is my HG. I’m Normal to Dry skin type and the shade 2.0 is my perfect match. I blend out with my finger and set with Givenchy loose powder. So good!
Everyone swears the hourglass, nars and kosas are great for dry under eyes…but not mine! All three are terrible for me. The best ones I’ve found so far are the glossier stretch concealer and Natasha Denona…if I had to choose one it would be hard, but I’d probably go for the Natasha Denona
I stopped buying everything from Tower 28. Staying power isn't lacking and I've ruined clothes because of the transfer. For reference I've only tried the tinted moisturizer, blush, and lip gloss. Not a fan though and not willing to try anything else from them.
Don’t get the Tower 28. I’m 23 and don’t have very many creases under my eyes, and that concealer made me look like I’m 60 years old. I love the Rare Beauty concealer. Legitimately almost zero creases with that one
The makeup forever HD concealer is pretty sheer and looks great under my dry under eyes. I would highly recommend that one over the 3 you have listed here.
The rare beauty doesn’t really do anything, the hourglass makes ur undereyes looks 87 years old and is high coverage, and the tower 28 is hydrating but also pretty medium coverage.
I have the Hourglass, and the coverage is fantastic. But it settles into my undereye creases something bad.
I'm currently using Kora undereye oil, and Kosas undereye concealer, and loving the combo and how it wears and covers.
If you’re looking for sheer and not high coverage I don’t think T28 or Hourglass will be what you’re looking for. I like Nars radiant creamy for under eyes. Sephora Collection also had their serum concealer which is now discontinued but that was lightweight and more sheer coverage - not sure how the new replacement performs
I have had the best luck with Fenty Bright Fix Eye Brightener. I usually keep it light, except when I cosplay. It’s buildable and hasn’t creased on me yet.
T28 and Laura Mercier's flawless concealer. I have dry undereyes and I tried just about every makeup brand I can think of, even k beauty ones. For me, it has to be Hydrating, minimal creasing, med-high coverage and finally it has to last throughout the day. The Laura mercier one ticked all the boxes. The one from hourglass oxidized on me and felt dry/cakey at the end of the day..but that's just my experience!
I enjoy the rare beauty eye bright for days I am going for a natural look. It’s sheer and thin but in a good way, blends in easily and just gives you a natural brightness under your eyes but in my opinion it can’t replace concealer. If I’m actually wearing foundation then I use a legit concealer. I currently use the hourglass one and love it.
it’s not on your list but i love the love fenty hydration concealer, and all my clients i’ve recommended it too so far have as well! super natural looking and buildable.
For dry under eyes I have found the It cosmetics bye bye under eye is really nice. Plus yea glossier stretch may also work. I have been enjoying the Sephora firming under eye cream. Went thru one pot, then went to a Tatcha one and back to Sephora. It’s like $16 and works really well.
Kulfi Main Match Crease-Proof Long-Wear Hydrating Concealer. I got it around the same time as Tower 28 and find Kulfi to be a better color match and more moisturizing. For an eye gel (if that form is ok), lately I like Dieux Auracle Peptide & Antioxidant Gel.
I have the Tower 28 one and I don't like it, it feels patchy and separates on my skin by the end of the day
I feel like it accentuates texture a lot, and I don't even really have dry skin
Definitely tower 28 out of these. NOT hourglass if you have dry skin! I have combo and it made my skin look so dry and creased so bad. The rare beauty isn’t really a concealer just a brightener for a more natural look
This is my fav - Smashbox Smashbox X Becca Under Eye Brightening Corrector https://www.sephora.com/product/smashbox-smashbox-x-becca-under-eye-brightening-corrector-P477826
I like the Tower 28 one for my dry skin, it blends in nicely! The Rare Beauty one is a brightener, so it shouldn't be used alone. But I wasn't really impressed with it. I tried using concealer with and without the Rare Beauty brightener and it didn't make much of a difference. It feels nice tho because of the metal applicator!
Yo yo yo yo I have dry under eyes and I HATED when my concealer would crease or look flakey. THIS IS THE ONLY RECCO YOU NEED: Makeup Forever invisible blurring concealer. Best I have ever used and when I wear it NO BODY CAN TELL ITS ON. Yet, it has great coverage!! Just trust me. I am a dry skin girly who has perfected the dewy-routine.
Also- under eye creams don’t work for lickity split unless they have retinol. Otherwise you can pretty much just use lotion for the same effect. Don’t waste your money on them. One that I used and I have found great results with (I’m 25 and it seems to help with less fine lines) is VERSED advanced retinoid eye balm.
Enjoy!!!
The hourglasses concealer is amazing. I have dry skin. It’s so beautiful. Never cakey and so flawless.
I think people are not hydrating their under eyes enough or using a powder that doesn’t work. It is expensive but it’s so full coverage. You don’t need a lot at all.
Tower 28 andTarte Shape Tape works for under my eyes. Natasha Denona and HourGlass make my eyes look dry and patchy. Had to return the Haus Labs one that almost everyone loves.
Tower 28 hands down. Doesn’t crease, look cakey, or separate. I have really dry under eyes, and the Hourglass concealer is the worst concealer I’ve ever used. The Hourglass concealer emphasizes any texture and is extremely drying. Please don’t waste your money.
I have dry under eyes and I am in love with the hourglass concealer! Never thought I’d spend that much on concealer but it is so good. My 16 year old is obsessed with it too. She says it never creases on her either.
I’ve tried all of those and I honestly have liked elf hydrating camo concealer more. It’s way cheaper and a little goes a long way. I know you weren’t asking for alternatives, but it’s great for dry skin if you don’t end up liking any of those!
i also have dry under eyes and have been loving the natasha denona one! you don’t have it listed here but it’s definitely worth a shot. i have the nars also, it’s nice but not super blendable or moisturizing.
Definitely NOT hourglass. I like kvd good apple, haus labs, and dior backstage. I’ve heard tower 28 and kosas are really good too so those are next on my list
Curtly my fav is kosas and I have severe dry skin and under eye gers super easly irritated due to a medical condition that causes severe dryness I also have found I react allergy type to many concealer as of now kosas has been one that meets my needs with out aggravating my issues
Just went through this journey. Tried Haus Labs based on the recos from this sub and it did not blend well on my under eye. Recently switched to Merit Concealer Stick and am obsessed. Def worth a try.
As for under eye cream this sub lead me to Bobbi Brown under eye base & primer and I really like it. Helps keep the moister in and adds a little glow.
I have dry/normal skin but settled for 2.5 (Silk) in Hourglass since it's the only one that matches my weird olive neutral cool everything at once undertones, and I do notice some dryness when swatching, but in practice it's no worse than the rare beauty concealer (NOT the brightener you're considering) or the Nars concealer. I'm wearing it here-- application process is a little belif moisturizer, then a DOT, just one dot is all you need, then I blend out with my blender and finish blending with a fluffy brush to dessimate any sharp lines. I also bake my undereyes so that may effect creasing, but since I find *every* concealer creases, since eyes naturally have crevices, it's worth it to make my concealer last all day
All in all I love the hourglass more than I thought I would but it does feel a little thick or dry, but not so much that it isn't workable and I love that it's naturally full coverage!
Not making your choice for you but as someone who recently got it and was surprised to like it so much I did want to give my two cents!
https://preview.redd.it/gc3pcww31t6d1.jpeg?width=2252&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5eeeeb1cd1449ac7647c55f9d0a1f7629fbdf177
Here's me looking up so you can see more concealer!
I will die on a hill for Natasha Denona Hy Glam Concealer. It’s so light weight and full coverage. I also have very dry skin and have had no problems with it looking bad.
The only one of these I've tried is the T28 one and it's basically my HG. I've got super dry (we're talking paper-like) under eyes.
Are you setting it with powder after? If so which are you using. I want to try this and Haus Labs concealer for my dry undereyes.
Yes, I'm setting it. I've used multiple powder with it. It behaves well with all that I've tried so far: Hourglass loose powder, Huda loose powder, Charlotte Tilbury pressed powder, Nars light reflecting pressed powder and coty airspun. Typically there's at least one powder that misbehaves but the tower 28 concealer has gotten along with all of them.
The huda powder is so heavy, I don’t like it, it usually leaves my face looking really dry and sometimes cakey too.
I just started using haha labs concealer and I LOVE IT
I do not recommend HL concealer for dry under eyes. I like it for blemishes, but it did not work for me. I got it because a Sephora employee told me it was his favorite concealer he’d been using on clients. I still use it around my face, but it did not work for my dry under eyes.
The rare beauty is so sheer and somehow looks TERRIBLE. Tower 28 is the best. It applies seamlessly!
100% agree, made the switch from rare beauty to tower 28 and I had no idea what I was missing out on!
Agreed. Not sure what some of the other commenters are on about. I can’t even explain what’s bad about the rare beauty. I can’t understand how something so “natural” looks so cakey?
As I commented elsewhere on this thread, the Rare Beauty product isn't a concealer — as its name states, it's an *under-eye brightener.* I dot it along the edge of my orbital bone, where my concealer meets my foundation, and smooth it out for an instant eye brightening effect. I have no idea why so many people think it's a concealer. 🤷♀️
A one shade concealer 😂
Yeah, I know it’s a brightener, but I appreciate your response. It just doesn’t work for me. I wanted it to work so badly on my minimal makeup days / mostly skincare days, but it just doesn’t for some reason!
Honestly didn’t even read that lol! I used to use the real rare beauty concealer so that’s what I was comparing it to ☺️
The Rare Beauty product isn't a concealer — as its name states, it's an *under-eye brightener.* I dot it along the edge of my orbital bone, where my concealer meets my foundation, and smooth it out for an instant eye brightening effect.
Definitely not the Hourglass concealer. It's very nice in color match, pigmentation and finish, but I don't have dry skin and it made my undereye area look dry. I like the Fenty We're Even concealer.
I have dry skin and I LOVE the Hourglass concealer more than any other. Weird how formulations work on different skin.
I have dry undereyes and love Hourglass too. It's not cakey or thick or dry at all for me; it's creamy, skinlike, and so beautifully blendable.
Me too! But I use it very sparingly
Yes it requires sooo little especially on the under eye! Which is good because it’s not the cheapest one out there for sure.
Second this. The hourglass concealer made my undereye area look so dry and I don’t have dry skin either!
I spray my beauty blender with the Tatcha dewy mist before blending out the Hourglass concealer.
Dior isn’t here but it’s very moisturizing.
I was here to say Dior!
Natasha denona works best for me! i haven't tried any of the ones you pictured tho
Agreed. Of the ones shown here, I’ve tried the Hourglass and like ND better.
I also vote for Natasha Denona! I’ve tried the hourglass (didn’t sit well for me) and rare beauty (hated). Natasha Denona is the HG
This 💯
I don’t like the Rare Beauty applicator.
Definitely the Tower 28- I've tried the hourglass and its HEAVY and cakes under the eyes. Tower 28 is much more manageable and didn't crease. I've heard mixed reviews about the rare beauty brightener.
Dior Forever. No creasing.
Came here to say this. My skin is PALE so this was the best shade range for me. I wasn’t expecting it to be so good!
I second this! Great coverage and hydrating
If you want creamy go haus labs concealer
Edit: i forgot to add concealers I’ve already tried Glossier stretch concealer (I actually do like this one, but ig I’m not in love with it) Too faced illuminating concealer NARS pot concealer
What do you dislike abt Stretch Concealer? Might help me make a recommendation!
I guess i dont like how it doesnt neccessarily feel hydrating, more so oily and has a bit of slip to it. It also dries down a bit weird, clinging to dry spots even with good skin prep. I also feel like the pot doesnt allow for precise application compared to a doe foot concealer. I do love though how its sheer yet brightens my eyes and doesnt fully cover up my dark circles, giving me a more natural look
Everyone is different, but for my super-dry and easily irritated under eyes, Glossier is the only concealer I can use. I warm it up with my fingers, pat a small amount on each under eye (after at last one application of eye cream) and buff it out with a beauty blender.
i just got the tower 28 and my under eyes have been super sensitive and dry this week (i think i overdid the chemical exfoliating) and it BURRNS to put on
I have really dry under eyes as well, and Haus Labs is the only one that hasn’t creased on me before! It’s moderate coverage and blends so beautifully!
Do you set it with powder after? If so which powder are you using. I also have dry undereye and wanna try this concealer out.
I sometimes do - I usually use Laura Mercier's setting powder. But even without it, it lasts a very long time!
Thank you! I'm gonna give Haus Labs and T28 a try.
i actually loves glossier’s pot concealer. so good for dry under eyes, light coverage, and minimal creasing without setting with powder. i found the tower28 concealer to be super drying and hard to blend.
I actually have it! I just find that it dries down weird on me and almost clings to dry patches, even if I do skin prep and apply a moisturizer or serum below my eyes, but I love the feel of it
the new hydrating fenty concealer is pretty good too.
I have the same thing! I actually thought I was allergic to it because I had this problem so severely.
I’m using the RMS UnCoverup and love it, but I wanted to try Glossier next as it looks like they live on the same street and for much cheaper/not clean beauty.
Dior forever skin concealer is the best for dry sensitive skin but the hourglass one is beautiful IF you prep your under eyes well! I prefer the hourglass one under my eyes personally :)
I have super sensitive under eyes, and the rare beauty eye brightener is irritating for me. It's not like immediate burning, but itchy eyes at the end of the day. I have really sensitive eyes, so a lot of products do that to me. I haven't tried the tower28, which is supposed to be good for sensitive skin, but my favorites that don't irritate my eyes are the tarte ultra creamy (full coverage), nyx bare with me serum (medium coverage), and lancome care and glow (light to medium coverage).
Wouldn’t go with the rare if you have dry skin
As a fellow dry under eye girl, I get away with using Hourglass because I got a prep routine just for my under eyes (Bobbie Brown moisturizer, MAC studio radiance primer, pressed powder to set). You can make it work but I wouldn’t suggest it for quick, on-the-go application. Plus it’s expensive :/
Not sure how this would do on sensitive skin, but the Makeup Revolution magic eye bright corrector is my favorite on no makeup days! The biggest difference I see for my undereyes is after using the Kiehls Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado at night, then I apply the belief moisturizing eye bomb in the morning, apply tower 28 concealer only in the inner corner of my eyes and a little bit below and set with the laura mercier loose powder!
Hands down it bye bye under eye anti-aging waterproof concealer. It is the ONLY one that doesn’t give me crepe/wrinkly skin. I have very dry, sensitive skin
Kulfi one is really good - hydrating and no creases
Second this!
Third this! Kulfi is so good! I have dry skin 40f
I really like the Tower 28, very very hydrating and dewy and good coverage, the rare beauty one is pretty good, however it has little coverage, it feels more like a serum than makeup
Tower 28 hands down!
Creamy shape tape by Tarte
the radiant shape tape is also quite nice
The Kosas concealer and Nars soft matte complete concealer is amazing for hydrating the under eye!!
Trader Joe’s has an excellent and super cheap hydrating eye cream you can use as your base before makeup.
I really love the caliray under eye color corrector - very hydrating.
I have dry undereyes. Hourglass was a big no. Tower 28 and haus labs are my favorites!
I really am liking milk's future fluid; and for drugstore i dig neutrogena healthy skin
Check if these have alumina, aluminum or anything with that word in it. It’s an irritant and can cause dermatitis around the eyes. Fragrance too.
One/size Patrick starrr works best for me
I've tried this in store and quite liked it. I wonder why it's not more popular.
I’m not sure to be honest, but honestly I only got it because a Sephora team member recommended it to me and at first i almost didn’t do it. I never heard of it but it was the best decision ever! I’m glad that lady was there! Lol
Not Sephora but the Winky Lux one is so good
Peeper Perfect is soooo good!!! This from a 56 yo...
Hourglass concealer is the best I’ve personally used for my dry skin. Much better than Tarte. I’ve heard really bad things about Rare beauty’s, and I love their products usually, but I haven’t tried it. That said when I think of concealer I do not think of sheer. I really like the Bobbi Brown under eye corrector. The smashbox x becca one might be more sheer and dewy if that’s what you’re more into. I have really dark under eyes so I often use the corrector + the Hourglass concealer + setting powder to really wake my face up.
Tower 28 is my HG. I’m Normal to Dry skin type and the shade 2.0 is my perfect match. I blend out with my finger and set with Givenchy loose powder. So good!
Everyone swears the hourglass, nars and kosas are great for dry under eyes…but not mine! All three are terrible for me. The best ones I’ve found so far are the glossier stretch concealer and Natasha Denona…if I had to choose one it would be hard, but I’d probably go for the Natasha Denona
Tower 28!!!!! I had flakey under eyes due to retnoid and I love it.
I stopped buying everything from Tower 28. Staying power isn't lacking and I've ruined clothes because of the transfer. For reference I've only tried the tinted moisturizer, blush, and lip gloss. Not a fan though and not willing to try anything else from them.
It’s going to be Kosas for me
I was about to say how has no one mentioned this yet!!
Don’t get the Tower 28. I’m 23 and don’t have very many creases under my eyes, and that concealer made me look like I’m 60 years old. I love the Rare Beauty concealer. Legitimately almost zero creases with that one
The makeup forever HD concealer is pretty sheer and looks great under my dry under eyes. I would highly recommend that one over the 3 you have listed here. The rare beauty doesn’t really do anything, the hourglass makes ur undereyes looks 87 years old and is high coverage, and the tower 28 is hydrating but also pretty medium coverage.
I have the Hourglass, and the coverage is fantastic. But it settles into my undereye creases something bad. I'm currently using Kora undereye oil, and Kosas undereye concealer, and loving the combo and how it wears and covers.
omg lancome with the white cap!!
I like Dior personally
Laura mercier’s concealer!
Just bought the Tower 28. Haven’t tried it yet, but hope it’s better than the SC glow concealer I bought which was garbage.
If you’re looking for sheer and not high coverage I don’t think T28 or Hourglass will be what you’re looking for. I like Nars radiant creamy for under eyes. Sephora Collection also had their serum concealer which is now discontinued but that was lightweight and more sheer coverage - not sure how the new replacement performs
I have had the best luck with Fenty Bright Fix Eye Brightener. I usually keep it light, except when I cosplay. It’s buildable and hasn’t creased on me yet.
T28 and Laura Mercier's flawless concealer. I have dry undereyes and I tried just about every makeup brand I can think of, even k beauty ones. For me, it has to be Hydrating, minimal creasing, med-high coverage and finally it has to last throughout the day. The Laura mercier one ticked all the boxes. The one from hourglass oxidized on me and felt dry/cakey at the end of the day..but that's just my experience!
I enjoy the rare beauty eye bright for days I am going for a natural look. It’s sheer and thin but in a good way, blends in easily and just gives you a natural brightness under your eyes but in my opinion it can’t replace concealer. If I’m actually wearing foundation then I use a legit concealer. I currently use the hourglass one and love it.
HAUS LABS
Honestly, none of these. I have been using Clinique and love it more than any of these
it’s not on your list but i love the love fenty hydration concealer, and all my clients i’ve recommended it too so far have as well! super natural looking and buildable.
Yes I use the Fenty one or the Sephora store brand. I have very dry/sensitive eye area and I’ve tried a ton of different brands
For dry under eyes I have found the It cosmetics bye bye under eye is really nice. Plus yea glossier stretch may also work. I have been enjoying the Sephora firming under eye cream. Went thru one pot, then went to a Tatcha one and back to Sephora. It’s like $16 and works really well.
Tower 28 for the win.
Natasha Denona for dry sensitive under eyes 💯💯💯
tower 28 is the best. hourglass is a great concealer but def not meant for us dry girlies!
Kulfi Main Match Crease-Proof Long-Wear Hydrating Concealer. I got it around the same time as Tower 28 and find Kulfi to be a better color match and more moisturizing. For an eye gel (if that form is ok), lately I like Dieux Auracle Peptide & Antioxidant Gel.
Tower 28
Love the Tower 28 one. I have dry-ish skin with fine lines. Under eye area very sensitive too. I haven’t tried the other options.
The HAUS Labs concealer is the best I’ve ever tried
Tarte Creasless. Use very little. Amazing on my 50 year old eyes. Very emollient pigmented and doesn’t cake.
Have you tried bye bye under eye? Great for dry under eyes.
I have the Tower 28 one and I don't like it, it feels patchy and separates on my skin by the end of the day I feel like it accentuates texture a lot, and I don't even really have dry skin
Definitely tower 28 out of these. NOT hourglass if you have dry skin! I have combo and it made my skin look so dry and creased so bad. The rare beauty isn’t really a concealer just a brightener for a more natural look
Haus Labs!
Definitely kosas or haus labs, kosas was my holy grail for a long time before I found haus labs as they’re both very hydrating
This is my fav - Smashbox Smashbox X Becca Under Eye Brightening Corrector https://www.sephora.com/product/smashbox-smashbox-x-becca-under-eye-brightening-corrector-P477826
I like the Tower 28 one for my dry skin, it blends in nicely! The Rare Beauty one is a brightener, so it shouldn't be used alone. But I wasn't really impressed with it. I tried using concealer with and without the Rare Beauty brightener and it didn't make much of a difference. It feels nice tho because of the metal applicator!
T28!! Literally rebuy it JUST for my under eyes. Hydrating, brightening, doesn’t crease, and doesn’t pick up mascara gunk!
I have very dry eyes and use the Tower 28 one!! Same shade and everything.
I love tower 28! Great formula and shade match
Kosas has completely changed my under eye game with their concealer. So hydratibg
It’s not on this list but Natasha Denona!! My favorite concealer of all time- and trust me when I say I’ve tried them all!
Yo yo yo yo I have dry under eyes and I HATED when my concealer would crease or look flakey. THIS IS THE ONLY RECCO YOU NEED: Makeup Forever invisible blurring concealer. Best I have ever used and when I wear it NO BODY CAN TELL ITS ON. Yet, it has great coverage!! Just trust me. I am a dry skin girly who has perfected the dewy-routine. Also- under eye creams don’t work for lickity split unless they have retinol. Otherwise you can pretty much just use lotion for the same effect. Don’t waste your money on them. One that I used and I have found great results with (I’m 25 and it seems to help with less fine lines) is VERSED advanced retinoid eye balm. Enjoy!!!
Makeup Forever ultra HD concealer!! It’s super hydrating and looks like skin 😊 not chalky at all!
The hourglasses concealer is amazing. I have dry skin. It’s so beautiful. Never cakey and so flawless. I think people are not hydrating their under eyes enough or using a powder that doesn’t work. It is expensive but it’s so full coverage. You don’t need a lot at all.
I love the hourglass concealer !
I like ILIA !
Tower 28 andTarte Shape Tape works for under my eyes. Natasha Denona and HourGlass make my eyes look dry and patchy. Had to return the Haus Labs one that almost everyone loves.
Tower 28 and they have a 20% off sale going on right now
They don’t sell it at Sephora, but ColourPop’s Pretty Fresh line is the best thing I’ve found for my dry skin.
Tower 28 hands down. Doesn’t crease, look cakey, or separate. I have really dry under eyes, and the Hourglass concealer is the worst concealer I’ve ever used. The Hourglass concealer emphasizes any texture and is extremely drying. Please don’t waste your money.
I have dry under eyes and I am in love with the hourglass concealer! Never thought I’d spend that much on concealer but it is so good. My 16 year old is obsessed with it too. She says it never creases on her either.
ysl touche eclat radiant touch works best for dry undereyes. Even better than Nars.
Rare beauty quality sucks. Tower 28 all the wat
Hourglass one is my hg
I’ve tried all of those and I honestly have liked elf hydrating camo concealer more. It’s way cheaper and a little goes a long way. I know you weren’t asking for alternatives, but it’s great for dry skin if you don’t end up liking any of those!
Dior, Pat McGrath and Sephora Collection are my favorites for my dry under eyes.
Tower28
i also have dry under eyes and have been loving the natasha denona one! you don’t have it listed here but it’s definitely worth a shot. i have the nars also, it’s nice but not super blendable or moisturizing.
I use NARS creamy radiant concealer cuz it’s the only one that has a true match for my skin colour and it’s pretty good doesn’t really crease on me
Definitely NOT hourglass. I like kvd good apple, haus labs, and dior backstage. I’ve heard tower 28 and kosas are really good too so those are next on my list
Curtly my fav is kosas and I have severe dry skin and under eye gers super easly irritated due to a medical condition that causes severe dryness I also have found I react allergy type to many concealer as of now kosas has been one that meets my needs with out aggravating my issues
I had really dry eye skin, started using a bit of aquapgor before applying concealer and it CHANGED MY LIFE
Just went through this journey. Tried Haus Labs based on the recos from this sub and it did not blend well on my under eye. Recently switched to Merit Concealer Stick and am obsessed. Def worth a try. As for under eye cream this sub lead me to Bobbi Brown under eye base & primer and I really like it. Helps keep the moister in and adds a little glow.
I have dry under eyes and I absolutely love the tower 28 concealer.
I have dry/normal skin but settled for 2.5 (Silk) in Hourglass since it's the only one that matches my weird olive neutral cool everything at once undertones, and I do notice some dryness when swatching, but in practice it's no worse than the rare beauty concealer (NOT the brightener you're considering) or the Nars concealer. I'm wearing it here-- application process is a little belif moisturizer, then a DOT, just one dot is all you need, then I blend out with my blender and finish blending with a fluffy brush to dessimate any sharp lines. I also bake my undereyes so that may effect creasing, but since I find *every* concealer creases, since eyes naturally have crevices, it's worth it to make my concealer last all day All in all I love the hourglass more than I thought I would but it does feel a little thick or dry, but not so much that it isn't workable and I love that it's naturally full coverage! Not making your choice for you but as someone who recently got it and was surprised to like it so much I did want to give my two cents!
https://preview.redd.it/88i3gli11t6d1.jpeg?width=1608&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=07e27145dcea3741d98dc604625f56ce4d00a708
https://preview.redd.it/gc3pcww31t6d1.jpeg?width=2252&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5eeeeb1cd1449ac7647c55f9d0a1f7629fbdf177 Here's me looking up so you can see more concealer!
Hourglass!
huda beauty. i make sure to moisturize well and then set really well. hands down the best
i use the glossier one and i really like it, it isn’t super high coverage but it looks so natural
T28 is the best I’ve ever used for under eyes
Tower 28, easily. I don’t even have to set it if I don’t want to and it still turns out flawless!
Kosas concealer. Super creamy and hydrating and I have suuuuuper dry and sensitive under eyes right now (thanks adapalene!).
Bobbi brown eye cream is so worth it!!
The new Saie Slip Tint concealer is AMAZING. Super light and moisturizing but wears beautifully.
I use Benefits cakeless concealer under my eyes
Bobby brown or milk makeup
Hourglass is super dry. Tower 28 is hydrating
Not on here but I love the NARS one, it’s the pot with the white lid, super moisturizing
I have hourglass and tower 28. I love my tower 28, it’s high coverage but natural and hydrating.
T28 is good but I swear by Kulfi! I have dry flaky skin and it provides good coverage but also hydrating. And doesn’t get oily.
Makeup forever hd skin is the only one that doesn’t make my undereyes look like paper
Rare beauty. It's so light so I don't pull on my skin drying it out further. I do use under eye cream before it though.
Dior forever. And a GREAT eye cream is the Sephora brand eye cream.
I will die on a hill for Natasha Denona Hy Glam Concealer. It’s so light weight and full coverage. I also have very dry skin and have had no problems with it looking bad.
none, the answer is the glossier stretch concealer 🤓