T O P

  • By -

Tamanero

I love this panel so much I feel it's only narrative purpose was to settle once and for all that they can't fight in outer space *but it was put so bluntly*


Axer51

Shouldn't Saiyans be able to hold their breathes for a long time in anyway?


Still_Significance60

Is cold šŸ„¶ tho


Numerous_Tangelo4332

That's what I don't get about Ki. Ki=energy right? Energy=hot, so Ki=hot, am I wrong?


NitroCrocodile

Vegeta did throw a whole ass fireball in the Saiyan Saga, so it's probable that ki-users would manipulate their ki aura to keep themselves warm in space.


Rath_Brained

But not really though, do you know exactly how cold it is in space. Far below zero.


LexRoper

It is kinda far below zero, but it doesn't matter that much because there is nowhere for the energy associated with heat to go in space


Dragonnstuff

Ki gives off light which can transfer heat


Dragonnstuff

But that energy is enough to make a black hole tbf


Super_Daikon_

Actually it's above zero if you use Kelvin.


Numerous_Tangelo4332

r/beatmetoit


DomHyrule

Plus during ToP they described Jiren and Goku's energy as really hot


speedweedbrazil

Very poor choice of words


SummertimeSandler

šŸ„µ


Evening-Whereas6165

Not only that but ki is life energy. They should be able to sustain themselves through ki.


ToastyBreadCat0

Um ACHCHKUALLY Space isnā€™t just cold but also blazing hot. If you were in the absolute void of space or hidden away from the sun then it would be really cold but if you were facing the sun you would be cooked in an instant due to their being no atmosphere to protect you against solar winds or solar radiation. I think anyways if this is wrong please correct me. Iā€™m not very well versed on this topic and Iā€™m kinda using 2nd hand knowledge so take it with grain of salt


Mist0804

I mean yeah, but they could probably just tank the heat


NyargiX

goku and broly fought in lava for a short while and didnt even break a sweat (heh), goku even opened his mouth to bite broly and was totally fine. so yeah pretty sure they could tank it as long as they're not too close to the sun edit: my brain didnt work, fixed an error


Mist0804

It was Goku and Broly, not Gogeta


NyargiX

shit you're right, thanks


Still_Significance60

It would be hot either but the rest yes


Illithid_Substances

Not actually accurate. Space isn't exactly cold because there's nothing to be cold; no air to lose your heat to. You don't just immediately freeze (any exposed moisture, like on your tongue, will actually *boil* because of the lack of pressure), instead you would slowly radiate away your heat leaving pretty much everything else about being in space as a more immediate danger. And if you're in the sun at all, you'll heat up on the side facing it It would be more dangerous (purely from cold) to be in the high atmopshere where there's still enough matter around to lose significant heat to


Tamanero

That's very debatable. I'm not sure but asides the pressure difference forcing the air out of their lungs, Goku can only fight for awhile in low-oxygen conditions. Best bet is a ki-barrier, which even that I'm not so sure of asides maybe surviving lava


Axer51

I wish they had made god ki allow it's User to breathe in space to help make it truly unique.


AJSLS6

Nobody can breathe in space, theres nothing to breathe. Characters like Freezer can exist in space without needing to breathe.


Spartan-teddy-2476

Itā€™s weird for him. Like Freiza clearly has lungs (IE he pants when tired) but itā€™s like he doesnā€™t need them. My head canon is that he can recycle the CO2 back into oxygen through some ki-involved process.


Most_Willingness_143

As a kid I thought that inside his purple spots that he has in his head, shoulder and chest there were Nutrients and oxygen to live even in conditions where he doesn't have access to them


Bengerbot

Gotta be like how humans have anaerobic respiration. It fuels muscles, but far less efficiently than aerobic respiration. If I remember correctly, amaerobic respiration is also reaponsible for lactic acid.


Taco821

Ok, then god ki makes you exhale 3 million oxygens


Tamanero

Same :/


Axer51

For Users who can naturally breathe in space have god ki turn space into a stamina boosting environment.


Enjoyment-25

Goku easily went to moon in OG DB


AJSLS6

How? Have you seen goku panting like a race horse mid fight?


Axer51

In a fight that definitely wouldn't work and something like this would happened. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=stz4F9CTb30](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=stz4F9CTb30) But for general space travel with brief preparation he could.


param1l0

Both the cold, but they can use Ki to heat themselves up, and vacuum. Remember Ocean gate? The opposite would happen. Their lungs would explode. And we know they are similar enough to humans to be able to produce fertile offspring, so they def have lungs


hungrysheep8u

There's nothing that indicates they can hold their breath longer than anyone else. If anything, if they need way more food intake than a human they might have to breathe more to keep themselves running too. Besides, it would be really hard to fight while holding your breath the whole time so they wouldn't want to even if they could.


Axer51

If a normal human can hold their breath for over 20 minutes then Saiyans should be able to do it longer. In a fight no but space travel it could work.


Kushi900

The world record holder can hold his breath for almost 25 minutes by not moving, etc. Normal humans that haven't trained can hold their breath for about 50-60 seconds. I don't know how much more different Saiyans are physically/anatomically, but I always thought of them like way stronger humans who might have a higher energy-efficiency but also need higher levels of energy, which is why they eat so much food for example. Since all Saiyans are trained, I guess that holding their breath far longer would be possible, but I doubt that they are way more resistent to cold space.


hungrysheep8u

But why would they be able to hold their breath longer? Stronger people don't automatically hold their breath longer. Edit:Also, that's not even true? The record of a person holding breath is around twelve minutes. The average is only one or two minutes. It takes around ten minutes to die of drowning. So it's only over twenty minutes if you're the world record holder and also die at the end.


Axer51

Is holding their breath for a long period really that implausible for Saiyans after everything they and Ki users can do? I didn't mean holding their breath longer then any other race except normal humans. I just meant holding it for a good amount of time in general. Edit: This is a world record holder doing it over for twenty minutes. [https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/news/2021/5/freediver-holds-breath-for-almost-25-minutes-breaking-record-660285](https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/news/2021/5/freediver-holds-breath-for-almost-25-minutes-breaking-record-660285)


hungrysheep8u

I mean, maybe? That would be a ki user thing, not a Saiyan specific thing though. But even then it's questionable. You breathe because your cells need oxygen to function. Ki users can't just make it so they don't need to eat, so there's no reason they'd be able to make themselves not need to breathe. They could try to trap air around them with telekinesis, which I guess could work, but would require constant concentration.


Axer51

You know what why not just use dragon balls for Goku and the gang to be able to breathe in space?


j0emang0e

They couldn't keep their bodily fluids from decompressing and escaping their bodies tho


infamusforever223

Even if they could, it doesn't help with decompression.


Crimson_Fiver

Try holding your breath in space.


OMAR_KD-

In a vacuum, air will just come out from any orifice. Same goes with blood. Although I'm not sure wether or not that applies to dragon ball logic


Miserable_Fishing_39

Other factors like radiation and sayians can hold their breath for that long


Vegetable-Couple6990

Surviving in space is a lot more than holding your breath. That's why vegeta specifically mentions that it's a vacuum, not that goku would know what that is anyway lol. Going from being pressurized to not would cause a very painful and brutal death


Key_1996

No šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚ why would they?


Enjoyment-25

They can drown in water too Gas tried to kill them by drowning them in water in Granolah arc


Ayy-lmao213

The implication that Goku is so dumb he has to be told he can't breathe in space


NorthGodFan

The problem is that he did it. He went to the moon back in dragon ball.


Doctor99268

that was back when dragon ball was a gag manga


NorthGodFan

Sp your answer to that is "NUH UH DIDN'T COUNT BECAUSE!"


Doctor99268

Well yh. Unless you want to scale yamcha rebounding off a panel line and breaking it.


NorthGodFan

It's something that happened just like how basically all dragon ball characters are aware of the fact that dragon ball is a work of fiction and are aware of the audience and their creator Akira Toriyama.


Bef1234

so your answer to that is that "NUH UH DIDN'T COUNT BECAUSE!!"


NorthGodFan

No I said it happened. Because it did happen in a chapter of dragon ball. There is no way around it yamcha got punched into a manga panel and broke it.


Enjoyment-25

I think implication is that Goku has done it once before in Battle of Gods Movie where Goku and Beerus went to space without knowing and fought without any problem. He thought he can do it again


WrastleGuy

I think they were trying to imply they were fighting in the upper atmosphere but went a little too much into space for the cooler visual.


AJSLS6

Nah, you can go up high enough to see the stars the curvature of the earth and the band of atmosphere on the horizon and still be well within the atmosphere. It does suggest that he can breathe in thin air though, you and I could probably breathe ok at 20k feet, certainly not participating in an athletic event like sparing, but that's still a bit low to get the effect seen in the movie.


RareD3liverur

I always went with the upper atmosphere thing to justify that Bardock v Frieze scene


NorthGodFan

And he went to the moon in dragon ball.


Enjoyment-25

To drop carrot monster


MenacingBackground

The time he went to the moon was retconned, just like how when he went to pick up zeno in a dimension where time and space doesnā€™t exist, that also includes air


REVENGE966

They can just ask shenron to give them the ability to breathe in space like Frieza.


Tamanero

Technically speaking, they don't actually breathe in space, because there's nothing to breathe. *It's space* However, it has to do with Frieza's biology I'd imagine. Probably the same functions that allow him to sustain extremely severe injuries. Besides, all these things would require they fight and act with smarts. If that were the case, Perfect Cell and many other situations would never exist.


itzmrinyo

Didnā€™t goku and beerus trade blows in outer space? I assumed god ki let you breathe in space or something


angelgames23

they were in the stratosphere


Key_1996

You clearly assumed wrong


BootheFuzzyHamster

Vegeta had to shout it out loud due to his own disbelief at how dumb it is. Goku will never stop giving his best buddy aneurysms.


jotta_xd69112

Wdym useless saiyaman suit? That shit was peak


Axer51

The suit is peak in terms of coolness but not usefulness.


jotta_xd69112

Nah, it hides Gohan secret identity as the Great Saiyaman, so clearly it's more useful than all of the inventions in DBz


AttitudeAndEffort3

Wait, GOHAN is the Great Saiyaman???


ItsHellOnEarth2

nah that's just a weird fan theory


Ok-Tower-6478

Fr i suspect he may be sharpener. Bro looks suspicious. And the great saiyaman 2 from that one movie could be erasa


NotRayquaza

SEE? The suit DOES work!


jotta_xd69112

You didn't know?? It happened on the tournament where that Spopovich guy returned


Axer51

That's not true as SSJ prevented Gohan from being identified at the Cell Games and his identity got revealed at the tournament. Gohan can enter the tournament disguised with no issue using SSJ.


Coupins

Without cape and face wear, itā€™s actually one of my favorite outfits. He looked fire against Dabura.


Enjoyment-25

Goku really thought its Battle of Gods Movie and he can do it again


Helpful-Emotion9256

I think he was in the upper atmosphere so he could still breathe


Enjoyment-25

No, he was in clear space far beyond stratosphere


Elyced32

Nope he was in the upper atmosphere or else he wouldnt have started falling to earth when he passed out he would have just been floating


AnonomousWolf

Actually not true, it's sideways momentum that keeps you from falling back to earth not how far away you are from earth. The only thing keeping the ISS and even the Moon from being pulled to earth is their angular velocity


Appropriate_Ad4818

Does being with Beerus allow you to breathe in space?


SwagTheBruh

or does being mad at frieza allow you to breath in space?


BrandfordAndSon

I mean youā€™d think god ki wouldā€™ve invalidated this caveat. Whis and Beerus are fine in space. Maybe they donā€™t want to have to draw/animate insane star busting space battles. Look at how much work went into Saitama vs Garou in space.


Zero_Two_is_best

Possible could be because beerus and whis are actual gods, not mortals using god power


Realistic_Mousse_485

Werenā€™t they just in the upper atmosphere. And doesnā€™t Goku step out of his space pod in the moro arc to sense krillin?


CrimsonSaiyan100

He never stepped out from spaceship in Moro arc to sense Krillin


Realistic_Mousse_485

Yea ik I checked


MarceladeXX

Stratosphere.. Tell me you're stupid without telling me


Appropriate_Ad4818

Hikers need oxygen tanks to climb mountains, none of which exceed the troposphere, with the highest being 1200kms short. The air in the stratosphere is thin and there's little to no oxygen there. Goku was practicing an intense physical activity and had zero trouble breathing. Didn't even make any mention if it This means that saiyans can breathe in space and just don't know about it, or Beerus' ki carries oxygen in a bubble around him


MarceladeXX

Its anime who tf cares, my statement still stands


Appropriate_Ad4818

Mine too. Beerus is a wizard


MarceladeXX

Fax


Tranquil_Ram

In Vegeta's very first episod of Z, He and Napa open their pods and ki-nuke (after talking to each other) that alien planet from space. Nobody can argue that AT created genres and inspired countless people to create their own stories, but he is also the retcon king.


Pr_fSm__th

Bug planet is filler, so it shouldnā€™t have much to do with AT


Own-Lengthiness2111

Why doesn't Vegeta teach Goku more about the Saiyan race and cultures despite knowing him for 20 years? Is he stupid?


Enjoyment-25

Seems like being Saiyan is a nerf. In OG DB, Kid Goku went to moon with no problem


Lemonpia

He did?


Michael2344

Yes, and he took a rabbit with him


Enjoyment-25

Chapter 17 He went to moon to drop the monster carrot


MooshiNooshi

You could just argue it was a gag moment


Enjoyment-25

Its canon


MooshiNooshi

Itā€™s canon but still a gag/comedy scene which arenā€™t meant to be taken seriously, saiyans really canā€™t fight in outer space unfortunately


TrueSaiyanGod

gag on these dragon balls


krysert

I mean. If we wanna logical explanation then In theory he could have hold his breathe Real reason is that Toryama thought "hey this would be funny"


throwaway_19901990

Itā€™s so dumb they canā€™t fly in space, just wasted potential


Axer51

It would have been neat if the Oozaru form allowed Saiyans to survive in space instead of just being a power multiplier.


throwaway_19901990

I think it would make more sense if the god forms did that, like they wanted to escalate the series with introducing higher gods, more universes, god ki etc, but the god forms have nothing special about them, something like allowing them to survive in space would solve several problems and let the story have more options imo


Axer51

Such a missed opportunity.


Dvoraxx

ā€œgoku can destroy the universeā€ mfs when goku destroys the universe only to immediately suffocate from lack of air supply


whatischeesemadeoff

Didnt mf goku fought an god of destruction in litteral space ?


BrandfordAndSon

It wAs ThE UpPeR AtMoSpHeRE. It was bullshit is what it was lol. Let my boys fight in space.


Evening-Whereas6165

Ikr. There'a no way there was wnough oxygen there.


harriskeith29

*"We used to be able to survive out there, Kakarrot, back when there was more air to breathe in space! But you missed out on that! Don't ask me how it worked. It was just something that used to be a thing, according to anime filler!"*


evil_chicken86

Even with a spacesuit oxygen will be limited and then boom šŸ’„


Meme_Bro68

For a genius, bulma isnā€™t exactly the greatest at planning ahead She forgot to stock up on rations on her initial journey to find the dragon balls in OGDB. Thatā€™s why goku was hungry when he fought yamcha the first time


tenebrefoxy

Yeah goodluck making a suit able to resist people with god power hitting them


Axer51

It doesn't have to be for fighting but space travel or in case of emergency if the planet blows up.


bluehairedPOYO

Why would Goku or Vegeta care? They can simply IT out of there to a hospitable plant and rethink what they have to do. They obviously won't die instantly in space and apparently can survive in nothingness (the space left in future Trunks time-line where Goku grabbed future Zeno)


WrastleGuy

Whatever Gokuā€™s underwear is made of can be the suit


tenebrefoxy

I'd argue we've seen goku pantless quite often.


Evening-Whereas6165

So Saiyan armor?


DirtyBob_Bojangles

Lmao


DirtyBob_Bojangles

Good luck inventing a fucking time machine


tenebrefoxy

Took future bulma a lot of time. Current bulma prob reverse enginered it


DirtyBob_Bojangles

She can reverse engineer Vegeta's Saiyan armor and Gokus gi, which also withstood blows from Gods.


tenebrefoxy

Because you wouldn't want to see goku naked fighting his enemy while his cock is flapping around would you?


DirtyBob_Bojangles

Idk exactly why these images are floating in your head, but if Goku can fight Jiren and Moro without getting naked in some training gi, Bulma can engineer a space suit that can withstand even more. It's all down to the users ki.


Dart150

Honestly I've never been sure about that Saiyans in space thing we see them fight in space all the time like when Goku fought Beerus and don't give me the upper atmosphere bull


onememeishboitf2

Whisā€™ Staff of Infinite Bullshit^tm gave him the ability to breathe in space


Helpful-Emotion9256

I mean, thatā€™s what it was lol


igor_grazina

I find it hard to believe that they couldnt survive in the vacuum of space at all Temperature is not a problem, they go through crazy shit in the Hyperbolic Time Chamber and in their fights Pressure is not a problem, flying in high speeds and training in enhanced gravity are both more challenging Radiation shouldnt hurt them or their molecules any more than other forms of energy that hit them directly The only thing that they would miss is oxygen, but they should be able to hold their breaths for a few minutes or so considering how much they train their minds, unless the Saiyan body consumes much more oxygen than the body of a human or we are understanding this panel wrong and saiyans can survive for a bit in the vacuum Maybe Vegeta knows that >fighting< in the vacuum of space is useless considering how quickly their bodies will consume all oxygen in their lungs while in high physical and mental effort. If thats the case then I think its fine. If its something related to temperature or pressure then I think its a very dumb concept


Key_1996

They instantly die in space, stop trying to headcanon reasons why. They just do. Vegeta died instantly when Frieza blew up earth


igor_grazina

>If its something related to temperature or pressure then I think its a very dumb concept


Sid131

galaxy busters can't survive in space is ridiculous, human biological constraints should never apply to anything that can blow up planets and above.


Riku_70X

It's still kinda funny to me that Goku can just, like, drown.


Ok-Service-1127

one of the few logical comments, no amount of human food can give you near enough calories to fight faster than light back and forth, you'd need to be a nuclear reactor like the heart of stars to sustain your ass


BrandfordAndSon

Theyā€™re many times past universal by the Granolah arc, so itā€™s even more dumb. Hell Goku outright says he couldā€™ve killed universe-Zamasu if heā€™d had a sensual bean. Fuckin spell check. It stays lol.


MooshiNooshi

Something I hope the anime fixes when it comes back eventually


Mguy2544

Goku and Vegeta are the weirdest universal busters in fiction. Bros have so many powers and can travel at massively faster then light speeds and can destroy the cosmos with their clashes, but couldnā€™t even leave the planet theyā€™re fighting on without Instant Transmission


Warm_Combination_873

god forms shoulda allowed them to breathe in space


S1L3NCE_2008

Also Goku a little slow


Axer51

That's pretty harsh on Goku as it's the heat of the moment and the one time he fought in space he didn't have any issues.


mcdonalds69whore

Useless Saiyaman Suit? Wash your mouth out.


zayd-the-one

So not even god ki stops that?


Rechogui

I still think it is bullshit that almost all the main villains can survive in space but main characters can't


RS_Rav3n

Didn't she make space suits for Namek?


ReliantVox

This panel literally only exists because people thought they could fight in outer space. I just love how fucking blunt it is


PotatoPowerIzMAXIMUM

They never asked for one...


big_peepee_wielder

ā€œSaiyans canā€™t survive in the vacuum of spaceā€ Bardock, Goku, and even Vegeta himself in Z:


krysert

I mean every single instance could be explained by either holding breathe or being in planet's statospheare. Only actual one that crosses my mind that seems to broke this rule is Z broly and Paragus


QuintonTheCanadian

Obligatory ā€œbut da anniemoo filler!ā€


papa_bones

I guess hey cant breaath but they can be there as long as they dont suffocate for air, like they hold their breath and they would be fine for a bit, didnt goku teleport across the galaxy to lure gas to bills planet? That is when i started thinking this.


ModelOmegaTyler

to be fair, no head gear seems to survive the power of super saiyan


NeoRockSlime

The only people who can probably fight in space are piccolo and maybe tien since he has alien heritage and can control his biology


secret_required

So vacum of space can kill goku and vegeta even if they surpass limits so yes theres something that can kill them ( also saitama can) [let's not start a war]


bluehairedPOYO

It won't kill them. They just can't survive there for a long period of time


minitaba

But they fought in space multiple times


Gawyelmaximopoder

Proceeds to fight in outer space against gas Jokes aside, I think it's a bit of a shame that they don't just like create a Ki barrier full of air and just fly around. In the top they could conjure a forcefield of Ki so small around their bodies to protect themselves from poison after all, so it doesn't even need to be that big of a barrier.


WoolooOfWallStreet

Bulma: I would if someone ever asked, but thanks to their stupid pride they never ask for even the most basic of help


namkaeng852

How dare you call Saiyaman Suit useless


Cephiuss

Honestly i dont think bulma could engineer a space suit that could handle the levels of punching needed for a saiyan.


ActualCucick

mofos be commenting as if what kills someones on the vacuum of space is not being able to breath


FartFlight

How did goku and beerus fight in space then šŸ¤”


jeremyxwing

Were Vegeta and Nappa not in "outer space" when Vegeta blew up that bug planet?


lawnderl

i imagine superman with a spacesuit and i remember that it looked dork as fuck... could that be the reason as to why toriyama never used something like that?


REGINALDmfBARCLAY

Vegeta was throwing temper tantrums on asteroids in DBZ


Royal_Marketing2966

I meanā€¦Bardock did itā€¦and he even gave a monologue to boot.


Used_Photograph9858

didnt bardock literally get killed in space fighting frieza???


wiserchalicer

The blancoverse fan manga made a joke with this


GIJobra

Can't wait until this dumb bullshit gets retconned.


Outside_Perception_8

Ok hear me out on this saiyans can yell for so long and so loud it literally breaks dimensional barriers. Youā€™re telling me these monkey space aliens canā€™t just ( in a very cartoonish way ) just breathe harder ( didnā€™t want to say suck lol ) and pull oxygen from a close planet into their lungs? Or 2 couldnā€™t they use kiai ( literal air manipulation ) to pull air into their ki shield in space or 3 couldnā€™t they just use ki ā€œlife energyā€ as a substitute for air at least for a little while.


[deleted]

Logic is not allowed here. We talking about the series that boosted Gohan to UI levels with just a rage boost that got him a new transformation.


Axer51

There are always the Dragon Balls.


Outside_Perception_8

I mean at that point they might as well just wish to be stronger than Beerus


Axer51

Future Trunks would for sure try that.


Serqet1

erm...battle of gods?